Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutVA198500046 Application 1985-11-12 $ 50 .3Permit Fee (i Application No. % j Tic Si 7 Staff: � ,.,, . i f APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE OCT 24 1985 Zoning Department 401 McIntire Road ALBEMARLE COUNTY Charlottesville, VA 22901-4596 ZONING DEPARTMENT County of Albemarle 296-5875 Date of Application October 21 , 1985 OWNER OF PROPERTY OCCUPANT (If other than owner) Name: Ernest H. and Edna F. Bruce Name: "len< -(JUJU C i oe :)- ; Q t � Address: Address: / Ivy, Virginia 22945 '-�c) C11 3:.'-*; Telephone: 296-8288 Telephone: 9 .- - --4cp co Location of Property: Route 676, East side of Turner ' s Mountain Road, . 2± mile North intersection with Route 250 Tax Map 58 Parcel 55 Acreage 5 . 3 Existing Zoning R-A District -- - Existing Use: Single Family [ 1zjf, l iA ,, q Variance sought (describe briefly relief sought) : Relief from Section 10 . 4 of Zoning Ordinance, to allow existing base- ment apartment to be rented, thus having three dwelling units on 5 . 3 acres , a variance of . 7 acre. Applicants are elderly and in poor health, Mrs. Bruce is almost blind from glaucoma. They need someone in the same house and need to provide separate living quarters in order to get someone. I hereby certify that the foregoing information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief and that I am the owner name .above. 7 v ictyl a__ /V- 4-6 :n-,u,--C''k-^ C '2 ii/g...5 Applicant Date FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Zoning Administrator has/has not rendered a decision. If so, state substance of decision: Date of Hearing: `1C-\i , ‘ \CA g C Final Decision Made: The variance sought was denied/approved-with the following conditions: /VW iti. r ykrd - vo ,, 4 7,---, '7 ,97/-,,,, 6#4. /re /1./.'" ,i0. - - ,- ' i--1/ '"' s•/ 1 _ I.).-1c41, _OK is:IA/4444r, 4,, , -- *, ,..- , - - , - Special Use Permit�� d ' °�' BOARD OF. ING APPEALS._ Sign Permit# BY:i'/ �E / `2� i� Viz-/e,5- .7� � �( D Building Permit11 / Variance# VA-84-61 N"" OF A L BE v AR<Go �4OF�L8\ dry' ��kGIN�P" MICHAEL E. TOMPKINS DEPARTMENT OF ZONING KENNY THACKER ZONING ADMINISTRATOR ZONING INSPECTOR 401 MCINTIRE ROAD ANDREW D. EVANS CHARLOTTESVILLE. VA. 22901-4596 JOHN GRADY DEPUTY ZONING ADMINISTRATOR ZONING INSPECTOR (804) 296-5875 KATHY BRITTAIN AGENCY COORDINATOR MEMORANDUM TO: Honorable Chairman and Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Michael E. Tompkins, Zoning Administrator . ,/C�G�.�zc.( (:%'' f j..x1;���tt DATE: November 8, 1985 I RE: VA-85-46 (Reference VA-84-61) Ernest and Edna Bruce This case was reviewed and denied by the Board on October 9, 1984. The applicant is resubmitting a request for a variance. The facts presented in the previous staff report have not changed. Conse- quently , staff respectfully resubmits that staff report for your review of this case. MET/mv STAFF REPORT - VA-84-61 APPLICANT: Ernest & Edna Bruce TAX MAP/PARCEL: 58/55 ACREAGE: 5.3 acres ZONING: RA (Rural Areas) LOCATION: Located on east side of Turner' s Mountain Road off Route 676, approximately .2 mile north of its intersection with Route 250 VARIANCE REQUEST The applicant requests a variance from Section 10. 4, Area and Bulk Regulations (Gross Density Requirements) of the Zoning Ordinance to allow three dwelling units on 5.3 acres, a vari- ance of . 7 acres. AREA CHARACTERISTICS Currently, a single-family dwelling and a rental cottage exist on the applicant ' s property. The applicant ' s property is located in a moderately developed area of the County. The property is located a little more than a mile from Ivy and immediately adjacent to Glennaire and Whispering Pines subdivisions. ZONING HISTORY A building permit (83-1475AC) was issued in November 1983 for renovation of the Bruce 's basement . The renovation created a kitchen, living room, bathroom, and a bedroom. The building per- mit clearly notes that this portion of the dwelling unit is not to be rented. A copy of this building permit is attached to the staff report . STAFF COMMENT The Zoning Administrator has worked with the Bruce ' s since this case has become an issue. Attached to this staff report is a letter from the Zoning Administrator to the Bruces dated August 7, 1984. This letter explains the situation to the Bruce ' s and offers an alternative. It is staff ' s opinion that the Bruces were not aware that this "unit" could not be rented and, therefore, proceeded as if it could. Unfortunately, this case is directly related to the Montgomery case, reviewed by the Board at it ' s June 1984 meeting. The Montgomery case (as well as this case) was concerned with when a variance is construed to be a rezoning. In such cases, to grant a variance altering permitted densities would be tantamount to a rezoning which is an action exclusively reserved for the Board of Supervisors. STAFF REPORT - VA-84-61 Page 2 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above, staff recommends denial of the requested variance. • . k, I, a* ,, .! 1 , ' . • ( ) • i C) . A 4. .. .'II,',.‘01' 44 .--,., ,.".i."' ' , ''' " ''4. ' ,' 1.',,,1•4.4: t'llP:."4.1.). 4.4:,•'':-,.4 4'••*:: \,, .;,.. , '. ,, I 1 ...........m...... . ,. .. ,,• ., . . • 44 .. '• • -!.. ''",: ' , '','''' "' 7 4 l','J.,:"11'`....I''' :••.•' . -. i:... 4.:'.•‘`ii ,:'',..' r..' , : ' 4 ..."• ., . . ' 2 .".' .- ''''' '"-'..- .''1 --•', .. -,r,, ..• •14,.,‘ . -•.. '-‘,"......;'.4 '•'''' ' ''' ' ..: '• ''''' '' ' • 1 . . , ' .: -. .,' ,: . ''' ' ... ' • i,''''' I. •' :„' ' • . ' ,' ,,!..!•',.••• ,"; ' • , , . ..,..• • 1 , '•••••• - , ti ..= '.- .., • -..,' .:...-•'-•' ‘.....','' ,,• . --- .''.'. 3 . -... ."- /A i. '-.,-'".A!.-,--•"--..-- ' ,2. '`'-. ''' ' '' ' `'.• '•`','.'':; , . ' ' ''".' .1':.'• ' ''. ' ', • ..' • " ', ''' .1.'" . , r , , ' . , , • "'' g. :... . ,_ .., , . :., . A,7• ,. ,. ,. 7, .1,, ,, .. ,.e ,„ A .. I.4. •. . I '.' • .' .4 ' •.4 4. t - .44- ...444 :... ' • .A. . '.- aKoof ,W,V,TX ,, , ..?4 il 11•*OP 4 44 ...' ... . 4.. " 1 Off ' 1 1.04' , 4 ••• o', .0 / . 0 '•• i- . • ,.• , ,, , ''''.' ..‘' • ' • ' 10/ ' 0 40/."'1914 r- • '. " 7 -1 '2: , - • *iv:, •i , •,. ssc .0s r p 0 if- •.1";''.-4. _`3,-•;- ! 7 e 0 .>' ' ,'' '-'" -3, '`-'• '''' ''';;,s'; '- 1,e' .- s • %- ' 1''`• i '' ,',.''..''''I- .`fw,...?., ' • -: -• . i `. ' '` ''' V • 4 :\ I • s• , '' '''?..? --.,7, ' , . '' • t,"11, f .... 1 1 .'' •0. 4 ' SO- 4 ,.,• t. ' C 'I ;' ' , • of 0 f' ,.. . . - 9 ' 1 1 ''•X '7...... .4 ..,. . '' 4 .4' d`• . li -.`- .0, .0 ,..": : \ -.:.. . - . ..... ,_- 1 it%T..1..- '4 ,-... '''''''. " Ar;i ..$1,',..,•,' ik " "p-101 '•;t -'' - , "' ,', 1 ' - ' .- • ""' "' • •.,,,, , ,., . .. .,,,;_tt ..• . , . , „...t. , 0...„...,, 4 ` ' • Yr •4 ir''.''''''''' ' .1 ' . '.6..-It '‘.1‘ ' A..' I .;4.4 r'..' p'' II 1,n1 61' • --,* 4.3-3 $ ., 1 , • -17'' . •••1 ,. ,.._,.. •.,,, A,..1 A ji , 6 ' ' , it.16:40.:::,;.:4_,,...,-t hcr.:,••40_10: ,., .,,1 ,. „:;,: ..,,,',..7-° -1".. i.....,..•-L--..- ,-....,0 •-‘9-Iii,..,.- ---`1.1:: "--,f4!..'ei..."."--'-'..: l'...:..41:...1.-74,:;::.' ...,.... -0'1 I '4.! s•4'.re if,: , _ , . .4, . ... ,• .et.4 4 -n vs"-°I- - - ••' -•-•-::::.- " :-...--...4......, ,.. . . -,.. ,., , • ,.. ' t 4 .;,..ii:6,-,..:c•APP•#.".:1"," ------ --,,,I.A- •,* , ci,-.---• '• ' ',$._ 1 :. . _4,067--...kk.... _ ,,,,.., „ . ........._ . AI id .......,....,........ . '''.4. 7.6,74t4:e4.1, ...."4................ . ,. Iekl:.‘4'. ' ......'"'".i '''.*6 .-'4. 4 .. ' . '' ' ' .,' ''4'/L:.. .14' 1'-'-'4.' '• - ^P ;7".""e • . /4 t..,..•' . '.. 'qt- l'"' ••r•'Ir.:74;4o),, '-•,' - , ' X''-'r,:,-`* , .,' , ' ..- • , ,.' , '.. , t .'.. ..••.:),.:,-'''.-e•.,' 13/7/44.3.* , ." -•' • . 1'' '-' ' ... ' • , It •,•;• •',•• • i - , ', : •• ', •1' ,. .1 -••1' 7•''' • ' ' .- •SMIA.5°'1 ' 1 - ' 4; ta.s - , I . ''' •1 - fpfX flAr°.51- ' ' • ; ''' , ''' '';'c` ,, , . I , . ;4.,:',/,',',. ,, ' ^ •" " '' ,'''' t' . 7 ft.. ,•'1- ..1,t• ,'-' *. , 1 • , 0 .' . • c, ,, . - ,.., ,,,.'-•.' ' : • a$5..5944./....*;,.V. ' . I ' -' ., ' ,',,,'•• 1 ,..t'i.'i'•1,..4..'.- Oa10', ,-..- -7 a .1 . • .•1 ' ' " ''' - ' ' ' ' ''...' '"1,.-'-'';10. 'pf0°. '' . . , ., -,:r, ,- -- _ , .i.,Ar-,.., 1,k-,-t'.,, ',- •. ,-r• . .-,t-,.;.b ? - r- 4 eit r 1 . ,,,is. , , ,' ' , - ' ' 1 . ... -.) . , , , ,••;'.t 44-- . k 3-9- ' • ... ;• .-4, , ys.... 3 , 1 . r..,.. -,;,,.- i.,,,l,,,,,"•f.'..,,,,,,,e.-::.,, .i e ' P LAT Y3F A 4.70 ACRE TRACT-AND PARCEL ".y: A -- :,: . . 0 so ACRE TRACT. LOCATED 4OFF. ST. RT 676.NEAR ,:„.,,,,,,,,,;i• _ . .: • ,.....-.: • •... •••,ie,-,---0.4., -,-,••• 72 • ,. I-4 A., ' • '',:, -...- ,,- -- ivy IN ALBEMARLE COUNTY*:-ARpINI .. ... _,.., ....,- ..,-. : ,• .. , i . 4• ' . . •-• . A- -,' -,• : • : ...- ;--.* - - '''':,•;- `' ;',- .•••• ""' -4"4 -i, '4;r""f•-'`i '-$:'" - z' .. I I- ". ---"'•••••".-,‘, •'- -'--• ' ' „ •••• .4 ,. . •. "te, DATE17/12/65',54r ‘‘,...1 •i - : '• - • 1 I 3 1041 t"-t .''';, ' '4 .4 `• ' r 1 r • •• ,.•j.:•ur"-;.'.'Z.'•'•'4,....=' ; -'.-.k•, -. ', ..•.., • ..,...';e ra,••.,.-,'',r'•.‘;'..1,,.,.'.,.x,.." '' _.•. C„-,;fr . , 7 . .i .., .4•„1„ r•••..4. .„.. 44t:' i.''''.'•-^ , „ 34 T'.H , .„.. ., . -,, ., . ., , , . , ,, .. •"! :''. •'''' , .4 J. ,.,• •, • , .. , ‘'.,, ;, • ., -' 4,• .4 .V., ,,.$. , ' ,•. # , THOMAS D. Diftl,,,, .., _ . . ,,,..-,., ,,...y. , .+1 .,••4)':'• ' •;, k' • 't..A.;.''4' - • . ''' '' '' . 1 44 CIVIL ENGINEER 6 LAND suRvEyoa .-.._,. ..:....,,,,.,,. •,---,..I • r • • . . .,,,, A 'tI '-'''•.• -.... ''* ' ''s' . ' • CHARLOT i ESV IL EIrrll....P'4i,•'.'1.-i ..•. .'1. ....,,.,.t•s',.•,..+0.,..,".....t.•,.".. 'PO LW tI'r . ' 4' ' .j.. . - . 4 '•. .360 4 . „.. '.4111.V.Z.1:-'''P'3:pit--.1'.. - .. • ' " , A LBEMARLE COUNTY 42 IA IC� IE y 1' J9,„. 69E •� \ � fines• "' . rON �`q� � 1 .!O 109 748 L4511 ) 1 / 4'1o � ' \lit[ TIC I • for la 1 it/ R� `�1 1658 esx a 70 M .e, .. f0!t /61 ��J...JI``6 �� i 70 • 31' 6?et A i • Ioe 1 . SIt .a i !. 1 a,t w cap 1.J r3 _ N. • 'vC , situ st !ram ! =11,�' ' 1 „! �� • 6SA n4 .AI I` ..., 3.101 x / 4 • � __ ..N.,.. ,14 \,_ J 1.42ALi / 6$ 4114,e _I,1. 6. . 3c %)....;.13 36 / rs /4./ 111V IFF s —..,1 ` / 642121 'e'.4 / �, till zee " • • NY • 7T8 � © l© VA-85-46. Ernest H. & Edna Bruc:. �'�`��©. Tax Map 58, Parcel 55 �,j� "'�®�"�Q�®�:04 111 ' \k\ 6 I. • '/ / 64J • y9A �re �® v _��� � 1• .. Ise, \ r� ----. .2 2�! I:1,••• % �` �1„ M, 798 63 tar ,ac Weer w � �tl, ^ es 84 / st...„ _. 45ti:,- `` \ .4 _ 39 �, T-. , 9 441, A 41 illir \\ Q.N. • i . '"," .L + , „ • A ...;.._ __,k1/4. AN rr.L----.. sr (sr' 7am �Y 1je.,,AO'/re � pI' �3 �Gsr/i�� �et,stcra� / . to6 •. fr: / ' . o, / S8 A r; M ' L33 ;xl 9s8 I�� �� nYJ� • `f � 3S ass —�\�-�f 93 _ ► v�99/ 92A I 94 � l2.� �904 !Ia =A•.r~~I 25 I / r L j row. / '►. Tat,. 91 ( . 11 2. i Ki.4 j /, I24 / 1tC \' f1 15 /�� �J / 95 / �.�1 / Is. *"..*...."....\%% r. / 16 r zn ,•. ys /,/yam �/�'�'-�''f� y \ 19\ 142 4a0 '!Y / �' 'i/ If 100 101 \ / N.,u / • • / ...., ,%' . , • •............, oi • )(2 V ( \ ,l-, \:. — ,-\\ /._ \ N N_ -- _i 74 __ i j _. .._ scaLt IN►ur IN - ,••• SAMUEL MILLFR nisTRlcT ccr_-rInnM =o