Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutVA200100005 Review Comments 2001-05-01 STAFF PERSON: John Shepherd PUBLIC HEARING: May 1, 2001 STAFF REPORT VA-2001-005 OWNER/APPLICANT: Virginia Land Trust, owner/ Edin Kajan, applicant TAX MAP/PARCEL: 058A1-00-00-040D0 ZONING: RA, Rural Areas & VR, Village Residential, EC, Entrance Corridor Overlay District ACREAGE: 2.19 LOCATION: South side of State Route 250 West approximately '/ mile West of the intersection with State Route 678 in Ivy TECHNICAL REQUEST AND EXPLANATION: The applicant requests relief from Section 10.4, Area and Bulk Regulations, which requires a front yard of 75 feet. A variance of 9 feet is requested to allow construction of a dwelling 66 feet from the front property line. RELEVANT HISTORY: VA-87-45, a request to reduce the front setback in the SA- Highways Overlay District from 150 feet to 75 feet and to reduce the setback for a free standing sign from 150 feet to one foot from the right of way. This was in connection with a request to develop a veterinary clinic on this site. VA-87-45 was denied. VA-87-53, a request to reduce the front setback in the SA-Highways Overlay District from 150 feet to 100 feet and to reduce the setback for a free standing sign from 150 feet to 1 foot from the right of way. This was in connection with a request to develop a veterinary clinic on this site. VA-87-45 was approved with conditions. SP-87-79, a petition to locate a veterinary clinic on this site. This request was denied. Building Permit 2000-1856 SF was issued on November 8, 2000. A footing inspection performed on March 8, 2001 was rejected because the property line was not staked and the footings had already been poured. Virginia Land Trust and the County entered a consent agreement on April 9, 2001. This agreement addressed the issues arising from the disturbance of the stream buffer in January of 2001. The agreement calls for a mitigation plan and a fine. V-2001-117 cited the applicant for violation of front setback. I:IDEP71Building&ZoninglBZA\VA2001-005 VA Land.doc Variance Report, VA 2001-005 2 May 1, 2001 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND QUALIFYING CONDITIONS: This 2.19 acre parcel is approximately 402 feet wide and 230 feet deep. It is in the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir watershed. There is a perennial stream that meanders along the rear property line. The developable area of the lot is constrained by a 100 foot stream buffer and a 75 foot front setback from Route 250 West. The portion of the lot to the North of the stream is zoned RA and the portion to the South of the stream is zoned VR. The parcel has been graded, footers have been constructed and the block work for a full basement has been completed. Section 34.2 provides the following criteria for the finding of a hardship that qualifies for a variance from zoning regulations: "When a property owner can show that his property was acquired in good faith and where, by reason of the exceptional narrowness, shallowness, size or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of the effective date of this ordinance, or where, by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary situation or condition of such piece of property, or of the use or development of property immediately adjacent thereto, the strict application of the terms of this ordinance would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use of the property or where the board is satisfied, upon the evidence heard by it, that the granting of such variance will alleviate a clearly demonstrable hardship approaching confiscation, as distinguished from a special privilege or convenience sought by the applicant, provided that all variances shall be in harmony with the intended spirit and purpose of this ordinance." The applicant has submitted evidence (Exhibit "A") that it is possible to locate the proposed foundation with a 6 foot deep deck on the property within these constraints. If the structure were shifted to the East, a deeper deck would be permitted. The building plans show a 15 foot deep deck. Since this structure can be located on this lot within these constraints, the hardship is not the result of the shape, topography or other extraordinary condition of the property. The hardship in this instance is self-imposed and arises from the expense and lost time that will result if the applicant is required to relocate the structure. The granting of this request would be a convenience to the applicant. APPLICANT'S JUSTIFICATION AND STAFF COMMENT: A review of the variance criteria provided by the applicant and comments by staff follows: Hardship • "The applicant comments that the variance is necessary: C.IFilesIADOCSIVA2001-005 VA Land.doc Variance Report, VA 2001-005 3 May 1, 2001 The strict application of this ordinance would produce undue hardship for two reasons. Within a 2.19 acre lot, site selection is extremely difficult because only a small portion is available to actually build upon (see Exhibit "A"). In a narrow lot I am dealing with a 100' buffer setback from an already encroaching stream on one side and a 75' setback along State Route 250. Within this small area, I still have to work with a septic field area, well and driveway. To add to the hardship, I made an error in measuring the 75' setback from U.S. State Route 250. I measured off 75' down the slope from the right of way rather than using a horizontal measurement, with the result of having completed a foundation before discovering my error. Strict enforcement of the 75' setback will force me to move and relay (delay?) the foundation at great expense." Staff acknowledges that the setback and stream buffer constrain the building site on this parcel. However, there is adequate area on the property to construct a dwelling within these constraints. The hardship in this case arises from the expense of demolition and reconstruction of some or all of the footer and foundation in order to locate the structure in accord with the setbacks and stream buffer. The hardship does not arise from exceptional narrowness, shallowness, size or shape of the property at the time of the effective date of this ordinance, or from exceptional topographic conditions or any other extraordinary situation. 1. The applicant has not provided evidence that the strict application of the ordinance would produce undue hardship. Uniqueness of Hardship The applicant notes: • "This hardship is not shared generally by other properties in this zoning district and vicinity because the property and boundaries of my lot differ from the majority of surrounding lots. The possible changing of the streambed and consequent changing of the buffer areas has required a great deal of effort on my part. That, combined with the 75" setback from U.S. State Route 250, and working with the Health Department to establish a septic field and well site have left very little area on which to build." Since no qualifying hardship has been identified, staff is unable to find that a hardship exists that is not shared generally by other properties in the same zoning district. 2. The applicant has not provided evidence that such hardship is not shared generally by other properties in the same zoning district and the same vicinity. C:IFilesIADOCSIVA2001-005 VA Land.doc Variance Report, VA 2001-005 4 May 1, 2001 Impact on Character of the Area The applicant offers: • "If granted this variance, no other properties would be affected. Once I have planted all the trees along U.S. State Route 250 for privacy and noise control, it will be very difficult for anyone to see the property, much less determine there is a 8.4' encroachment on the setback. It is my understanding that the 75' setback was established to set high standards for the visual appearance of neighborhoods and roadways in this area. As I hope to make obvious in my presentation on May 1st, the improvements as shown on my landscape plan will greatly enhance the appearance along U.S. State Route 250." Staff acknowledges that the construction of a dwelling on this property will have a certain impact on the area. However, the construction of the dwelling on this property can be done by right. It is staff opinion that the reduction of the front setback from 75 feet to 66.6 will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property and will not change the character of the district. 3. The applicant has provided evidence that the authorization of such variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property and that the character of the district will not be changed by the granting of the variance. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Since only one of the three criteria for approval has been met, staff cannot recommend approval. Should the Board find cause to approve this request, staff recommends the following condition: This variance is for the construction of the dwelling as described in Building Permit 2000-1856-SF. Any future additions or replacements will be subject to the setback and yard regulations at the time of application. C IFilesIADOCSIVA2001-005 VA Land doc . , • , •_, „ '. „, , _i! :, , -, , . , 1 .. ...' ,. -.. -.. . ,1,,i00, . ., •" / ..L,I•0• ,• ...44 A ,.0 .-.• • . ., ,•I'1:..1‘,i I,4 'pfrill r. rfl•,,,•4.,. y.44.. 4 ' \ .,' .7. '''. .I.,..r ''',\ , '• ..,..:4r. ,II' 's% r. .•.. .' ,0 !., . p ,..,,i ; 7., ,,,_,..,.• \,L,•.:,-.i,',-/•,.' . ' •,: .: ' -•' •7' .,),(440„e_ . , _,.: . , ,q •• ., , \ ,: „, . _,..,•1 lo• • 7., ,: j• „Jo, ,', -v,... •.,,L.;, 440,1 'A, • 1 ' ': ' ' . ' - 5.540.• -...• -•--,, 1 , . ... -- -:, Fi.. , w,t. ....:...„.___.... .:77.__. ., . : 1. . 1 —,1 -\ . • ,. _if- r 1,4: .,41.„„........„,......-..„......;=,— _4 !. '•• 'i !s• 1 ,.1.1,:: - •;.•.sr."A' r, •• . 1 •,,. . 1 ,• . ."10, fid4.• - ••• • ,. .. .- • • " " . - ' • ,1 ; 1 -• r '- -. ' • ,..-. • . . , ,,, - • - • • — - _ • '.. ---" •••••• 1 -.. r-• . . . - • _ .,_ 'bey - ••=7,` -.. ' . 410••••--- A:. . '- ` .'-filimp..-...,„:. • ., , -‘'• --' , r." 411"6"--, :-;+o•-. --- „7- 11"---21.. - —— . „„...t--_-",• -,,,... 1.1%!!!....°L!iirt*lopm,,, -- .... '7-• ' ' '` 1, .1. *j.,- L'.- , - , -4 ana**,;,/:•(-•, ,„..„-Alyto4.- . A:- -..,-- AI• ... ..1 , *A , . eV.:.4.1.,,,,,,,..xs:_.:,....,,......„ .2. ..15,.: . I. . •-'. ,' ; r,.....i '... '. 1. 4T- .,.' .- f. ,. ... 7:- I:;'..:.r:''' ..."' '''. '..7,0. ; ''''';'--9,:. "-.•-• .,.- ..-• --'•• 1 .';:,'" '-'6*-11/61 .1-'; :', MIMI • •._ ----. ' n't-•,--,•'''1,••_' • ... . •,- : •.'. -. • ..-.,.*-74--z-'4-,4...a.'-•..-1.4::... ;:-...:;: t.-;,:isi,.7:...:.1.(1..• ' ':-,- .. - ' ---4,..,....,.... • . - ...,•,....,r"- LOOKING NORTH FROM NEAR STREAM \'' \' i ,1 I , ..4•4-.. . 1 / ,.• --„..,...,_ . , ,.., / . / . ) il . .,•--.7 , ----7-----•••,--_r—,„ ,.4,. • ... ." 4 ' , • i,., 'i\ I i . ' I 'dr-pir•I'''" • •f•-•-•*•-•••. if".,: '•'''• r 4111h lb'. 4 • ' ' ' "- ~:t.s.." - .,i..,. .?, -•'1.k' ' ', • 4r ., .7,.., ;'7„,rs, ' '':7:!,J', /..' , ' -.-1-.,-',, . ,.,. .' .t,It• , ..., . , -. i ,-,,1„,e- •-• . ., .....4,...r.-.7' 1 PH SA ";_•':;':.' ' . s 44.1.r, ,,.. ..k.,.,I•LI'. '.„ .„'iii,.,, ;6;1 I ),,,.., ,,1 . 11, • ' A 4 "i:!I'''/ v Ne,:..I frAr 4' ' 71 ,S.'''' :" • I \Ili e•,,-;:•b;4..''.4s:*,"1•i-1.' r .I1 LI4.1-!,.,,'.:11'.6,-,.i.1.,1-t, 18h4—i—l''I':'41'r,.:At )10 l\,'.•• v7,1,..'.i.A!r',';r1N.•1.1.I r 1',t 1,. ,'-'''t,‘,•t-I I'',.4°z,,:'.,4,.1,1,41..AI.•[I„-L4?c''' A,frtr,S.,ri9,rr,,"fr:'•',e,,.'.,',.,.4/ 0; , f .-7,c-.,,-•.;.r.A•f,-4,`,',--,.•.:!‘.,*,.,,,y,..Y..:.',r,#*_‘•p•'• i, .it- .,- - , • k•v,,i,.-,-,-; ,, .4-.-, r%. -,-;''i- ' • 1.1.iiiit4-.--' ' ...• •.,..,,, ,i•,,,t,k., • ....„...-. ,.,,..... . ... _ • .. •111101..„..,. ,, ..,.. • . ----,.-„,...,,.4...,...t .t..• ,,,,,..d.„,,,,,,i'i':'1,‘.44'.' ' ' '-- -, ....,,,_ ...,14,•..s.414.•t 1-2,..! 41,-t%7TZIP,' ..f:!!":- : •. . 's''''',N, . .., -4.) . ....24 - , ‘., -, -4,_ ;re:!"-."1"1,?":"•*.'i klii- :7',v4i' ' ''. • ' --'''' '. '•„;•:' ie - ,.'. ,/, . - 4:"! i ' •'.'• .. ' '''--.4 '''' '• . - • • '• . . r' 'ii,`•.'':'....4„-‘'.44,--0•kr;'' s- ' "' s - ..1•:---,. - ..,,,,,1"' i,.}.4.1 4.,.'i ,,,',.,•••••,'",v .,,,'.',...,•--1,'::;,f,1 s, ",; • ' '9:* - • .- 1* •'• . " ,- 4,',114-1, :, .•;.,"1,..r.„F.4.‘4•*.iik••-.4,'''.',.k. .•*.ii.4e4;•,-,*'.. 1 - ''' • '''''"'•;,'"4.`•" ' '.2,11f.:,:., •,. •' •,,:i•ei,...-.• "'.41.,,,,ro.t . *-. _ •',. 11:•'`" .- •• '...'4,'•'42:-,41t. ' •• . ., -1,,:'. ' • r" •;.,-I."-4.• yo:,..!-4'.4 ''1,.•r,''',i ‘.I .' ••••• • '' ,---c- 1:•-- • ... •-- • , .y. ..., 't.k.,•-•,...4... ,fw, r•.;„ .,..„..,„,,J..t..., „ ,,,,4 • , --7,-.; _ ,.. - .-- -,. • - .‘ --4.1,,,, . -*or., ..,,:„; ,-,......•:•-.,,,,',••••• - - '..7‘4-itt-Lic K., •."- • .._ '•.%'• .. ., -4. - -. .,1•:-.._,-'. *• ,..,p,,.. -- • , :?..';0-4,- - •S'.4.1.,-' •,,,,,,,„:'g (,- 1,J,,- .., 'kltr,, ',- -' . -,,,,&,,-4.-r,,,' ,i-'446-1; - 1..2'•'.''': %,' -'.....;,,i,..4.- .-::::„‘.6..:..1. .:,..s.'-'::• - :,fs::.-•..,i.,„-'- • ... ,,•...c.,:_ . -,,,,,,: . • - - ,..,•..- - . .:.4. • , -., . . •,•••,.., •,,,.,..v,i...4,,,,,,:, • ...,.„ .,:„..,-.6; ..-s.,'.:12gt,,,,,. ,4 ; fa,I-1",,,, • 5,.. .• gia,,:04 .,, ; 4,,i,..„..._.",V .* ,..,,,,,11, ',..,,-...k.A.-„.-4,,,„ .„,- NA:i.‘l', •••••'•I'.•:A• .0...6, •• ' • ..., - i ij r '.,f Allf,7. : 'i. ':.,A1. ''..-.''t q 1 .'r.)tlire ...,?P' t• _A.` • ,'.i, j°11.,a.:41:4,4,1i10:2%, • • .ort. - ../6"••,::::• -., . ,,!". ." '.- , 04.7:',,,. ' :..-'. -, ' ‘-''t,...,;',X'.. ...,',.,..... ..' .1., ...!,t•c-k.,'%L.P.V.:.. .. ', LOOKING EAST ALONG RI 250 , i N, ..., `�. _ • s-' .1 i ‘,1',' ,-• \\ \i, *te, • Y t it r .. -_� * . ` 1- sue y ,' '.' • y' " .ivy tyn..�c - T ` r t 'mot,�'V►. �_ 1 �( i. • r` z • r4 ., : ,li ,..la 3 s •a• „ `mac • - r ENTRANCE OFF RT 250 LOOKING EAST TOWARD IVY • • . •• .i t'• • f • am �, •..`1* a��a r 3' r.• � ;�w�,+r • v • � ... • we �• � •N •�'•a?.; .`� S� v �"', Ap:•F "t' 'testa-- --••-- - rtr' cP_-••kliii '.+►�."a n .. ti-•fwi1 "'!.a►tt�` -st- •"ti-`.-n,a�. +� SLOPE OFF RT 250 LOOKING EAST -1 ii -4 1 IMPIRM-- , \ I .s S i 1.'.- • ., . '. ?,, ,, 1 1 _ ,•`''.''' ;) 1-k' (`-$:..;, ,i,, '!• • •, ''; , ! •, - r V•,.';,:' li , ..,. ,, • ,,,, :......,..., ' .2 11.1i1 t f • A 'V ', 11 t. ,, i• ''' ei • - ,1, , i 1 '• 1.•'`-- '4. i 111 A 1 •• i ,4,T .1 1,11%; ,•I ‘,1' . s 1 " Iliti. 7,• ,' :';1,,I ., . 4' 1, 14 i E, 1, t!"?.1;0, ; ,r, , N , ... / ;-• — alai- ,-i..•1,4 ' -4di,,, 1-; ,,Lit,.,1 ' • _ .,-....._ ,,, • ,. ...•.;,41• - ,...oft,-—s--.,.. _ , ',..\,..; .'•,::- , .•‘ : ;_... WPM .4.x ,.,.. .', . ......... . _., ,,_ , r. IN , ... ,,,..‘4,4e,,,,4e ,..."4",'''ftci., AI".,'.W,".• ,-4, . •21.7,04,-;, 'L - ,f,;...., - :.1,Vf01 ::,, •.,, , • -P'_ .,,r-1 - -' . , .1, ' -' r . .pitko , • ‘.. ,: - ).:•,.;,,01.1--' . • „i, ,___ ,,. ,,, ,, - ,,..,--- . . A•-•vi si.fr,z-;'..• i,_ ,,A,aw ; : ,o• • , ,f,,Itz! '•,,,_,1) , -r'.•-•',51,. , .'' ..'... `i.i.174,,,„ : f•-<',,,,, • '2..;.* , ,, ..., '1.......,. /,‘ 4 - '• .., \‘'‘.i •:,,._••A, • „• ,, ...,A I.S>„1.,-- f -' , , - -,. .0.-I • ,..".0:,-1.4"-• ' . .j -'4`,..:. . ..4..;:t' , - .•-• ' r.. • • 4...4-4' ;4 it) '.."/... ! ' , • ,?.".Ar.1/2., ,_ , -4„,-1".., 1•41.-4,. ,, , . ,,--. .. .., ,,,,,,, .. ,„„, .--1,: ,..i ..,,• .,..,.. 1 • r-:-.,:.-- . -- • - ,.,.. .1 .. .., .. fs.,-441,-, . .. .•7- .,.••74.,'-‘' ..„ .-..k :. Iltk-t•!tme:t47;* . . . 1 ,,, .. .,,. ...• , -a. . *-.,„.. 4'It`...• '" ''•'c • ''.'-,,A' -. ol' .'•' '• ''.. ''.1''•'‘... 1 ''' . • 141V,e' -'4 * . 4.4.444•-• ,:,C• ' %:s' .. • • .. '-- .•- ' • ' **" ''''' .61 ' . I 4 - ;.`.-4.4.-.: 144',.0:4-1 A,. ' . ,1- ' •_‘..4 4.'44 • ---.CZ. ar'-: . ;,'itl • 44'4' ) ' -.N 4 4 • - 4. N,s,# N.,.,, . • .4.,\ ,4. , . 4,1, ,t,.. 1.47''.- , ' V-t-‘'- _ 3,74.4:i -....„.r. .... .: ke ,..- • - ,.. . - '-eilf).-' • : ' . '--- -4 .s y • 1.t. . I. , w ' 1 ' ' ' •#-.1- ',' \ ' • LOOKING WEST AT SLOPE ALONG RT 2sn I liN I . I 1 I n ' \ I d 1. 1 . \ ° ' ' \I . f • . .. • ,..-- • ,, ....•-•-•• ,$ . ' ' \ '1' •i• / - 1 i If .., ,... 4 ‘iti "110 --ii .1' .2-'1.---- - _,Ar........:s.,,F-.4...-._- ,,..,_:„.. _- ...--'It-, , ... • .. v . o J.-.1 _ r.'• . „, r,....... . ...,.4. .-, '. .4.44c.......1-:-.....; ,,',. ,_.:,,r- .-...,,ori- . . .-..-,t •,,1,74_,., B....0F., , • , 3-,,:: "X ''1/4. ' - - ."" •• ' '' ), ,, •. ...,,..• - N .., • ,.. • ..-...e1SV' r..-, ,._ .,. '( i , .4.,,,,„• ..... . . ,. ,- •- ' . . '• itli..,i•.... -, t:•'-1,, .>.- -7•P+, ' , ' ; •'!: 1- ' ' -,,* * *it 4. I,: !I.*"•••ii. ' . * n 6,_ ...6.,,,,,_. ^ ' ''' '•'• •4 .1 . .., •:, 11"1—Qn.oriSAItt,„,,,,,, ''''''''''--"ele..•04007,14t.- ' ..:— —- .,• .1i.. . .""" --.'---"------.----7., _7r•E'r'r ---..--.—..i...._ --1"-l'imIx,iir ' 4tt.a.4, • ....aimam...,,....L.„,,,,,,„„......._.,_,..,„„,„...., •,.,,. • - -,,-,,. _ r air ,igailadiam....... ..,.....,ps,*_.0.•• .01114,.... , ' ---, -7; i r• t_ '.. i...- _ . -q1.111114156H.F45111111,611171ris 110 g'AM..r• • r:'..Iti..4+ . .14141111111.00011.001.'",.501001.: t 0.,,. ..1.7.1: ilk 4, . 11*--'a. 4 .--- ----• b. 'ea INCji.11". • . b, 4•:,e. .44- • 4 -...,144.: .. ii 44.4' /JO' -,',.-i4N ' ',--•L•'',`-'004 '-`,.t.'-, - ,w1 t4, •...,„ ••104—: - . ' : ., ....4.340.--„,, k '',. . ------, o - ---—14... : .' ,••;;:ta,,,t,- •,...- • ‘-•• • • •ic's -- 444k, t .1,4 ... • • k-,4,....• I i . . ... . , •,,,, ‘'. .4 T le, ' 'A • ., • •- ...., 1^',.gt'''..\7: '. - • ,, ,411‘ ... • . b. . 06 ,it,:-, 4 .se,•., ''. ir,,, ' 4' .,, ••• • •• ' t . . '...-,' -,,e. '•• • .,L •!... • '', t ' ' * ..' '`'` . 4 t • •••3#,, its•-'‘.. -• .1-- ,, . ,‘ .• 4 • ,- •-. --,.. .0. '• • , , *.0 LOOKING NORTH FROM FOUNDATION TO RT 250 --t Residential Property 4505 Ivy Road EXHIBITS PRESENTED TO 6 0 n *01 )ci \LA- COUNTY CF AL L ARLE Z71411 ± . p r +it t �. i. Jrrri 1 } h''i' •il tI3Y-i{ � tli 7 „, • ., it ., ` t �� fit} I "1 1 • j`'!l. 4 f`t k. t I IItt 1 , . � k, .1 { ', - , ! 1 �I. 1I. I. j 'f'c 11 6 irtt,- :,„ • t,e z`/ rIFFPr j + r I I'Yl % 1 Iltir Si i'•1 6� 4.. , f r • �h N1 1� 11#444 S I. 1 �4K4�* ..NN c` ''' r it r � } '. , V..� -k a: A t t - - t ` r per:.•• �+ s`. • s :i . . ., . .:If R ., .. 40* LOOKING WEST FROM FRONT LEFT CORNER OF FOUNDATION p ' ` r.� , .,v h inn .l V ,,+ `• �1'' ji I 1 i' ��h Fi,•1 .. 1 io-- • ' , Avo:,:wok• 5iiii ' ..:-..,..„-;-• , . -, - . . .",.,-1. . ts L. 4 ll' ' .( 4 t • 441%k .HA • • fiL' Kft.I.-,,,,' ••••,s-• *i K (,:•,• yL,; l,„'i'. .,. • .4U ,e *,�.. t1-,, ,i• 1 v' if, , t <: i 1 ti ,err \ .. '. , r M t 4 `f � '.. •'.. 1 '', . ...-• ' . ' i.,‘ 4,..‹.•' ---- r ''' - .-•.,:,3.•c:'.:' ;i.--3'4'• 'e44,1 i• viiit\‘,31,..,0...:,.., ,...,k..! .:._,..?\,,, , •s.�l r .^, :..?�r ''I,.11.a"�.:+- 1 `j.l f /- • .� .1/ ,c- �`` f� 71 ht r -:---.;:—;—::"I- ' '-:•":".t-',4/"/,;;-.-:'‘i,./....‘-:`,..,'\...\'-':-;:1-11:-`;-::1-\..: f r* ''��aa ..A, e,r:- er• . .�' . ,. - _ ... " - •z' . . .. . \IAK. t• .YC- add. .Z. Ill. LOOKING EAST FROM MIDDLE OF PROPERTY AT STREAM y� ..' '�'�. t ./ L"•erg ,. Fla , t � ia.A sF, . ,!Pr \ . µ ,, 61 S rc,, .�., t, Wig;• i c 9.� t, �.. - '. •'."-' . ..41.....„4:-, -- - 11—''.. . - '.!1":.."'..'.':' :t4•- .14C.-'. tom t - N.1 4 _ { y'F ' �f�}yk� - ^-`4.15 1.L+s !i i! • '5''..� '„ , .y„ . , < < a s 1r, :2 r 1 ss ,F IP • --t i,• r t • Z - t ; Y '^�-a .1 is. .4 - i4 ; •fix x' ! . :Mei. . -44'. F .. -. . -,-4,�.gyy +�n LOOKING TO SOUTH AT STREAM AND ADJACENT PROPERTY :;,,.:,$.:-;..,.„..,„ i i,f,i.,f , ,, , i yil ,,,, • : ii . ,..,,, .t. ,,• - 1 -,, ‘,.. ' .. ill 's !, 1 ,of . .‘,.f ifr.;0' kl -...... [� V'"• ! +: i t,T'r4 •' 1 Z•.1 i 1 •( �ia�f 1,\ • • , 1 F T `tTw ,.••. • r ' jr . ,.,1' t s� T {x�? �". 'V .It, � 1I .i; N • ��T`„v' 1.fc` 4,f • 13 r•, 1 /A� j 11�,.� . ,.,.� 1 • `.'�1 •'.�' .f 1 {r' I r t.�ti` i ''�• .1 �,<r ft>• 4+ vF I. A Ai.: 4',, til I.',::'''..-k*4.:4- ,• .,._ ,_ le 0, ,,1+ !.Y�.i-•f S., e�r�,a 71 t '.1 i r' •.•-s.,1 at --c ` s a / '. 4 I 0 w.L tail.►i -' - •?i.: 1 '�.�- -..;I11\ ;,y - _•��r �4 •ii'> if:1s. •L w , ti .rf�s a. • ,�,.�,� P. • 17 y 11't • r . t ••,•07 V. .. s. r\ Y"! tw �.l�tr"'..._pFr- t' ,� ' "j v ` t• C_•:- its';- ., !� /p7 !,;. m `sue'\•, 1 ` !. z- . ! .ii/t• - • .0.';''bra 1'- ! v d� 4', 1 / y , ';^'f. r Y-, 4� ',t_..,�`.-4'.1 •.••y:N '•n �,' a ' a j� • 1 LOOKING TO EAST FROM NEAR STREAM a"fir ' �' •�' �� 1 � •- .; Y �'t ti , �� :a ��jw{+[�7(�� y •*fi !. .'�'' *." dt ,, 1,r P ,i?Iall ` c , il !i 'l' .'• 7"'to""- f ,wp m• : i.) . rs-, „,,,;.,04 , ,4 ..,. / �. V<1014r+ , , 1 • [ t 7.t,,, `K• gam ,,.2 y ei Y •d .' .�;t`,.1..1=,R`�. .w i fr ''-�'' e A:Ill a,. ,,,{ ,„ .• .. `, ' ,A+•tiffs.+..`; r.� . '✓. l ?. E r t om 'cF 1-, :- : I +y �•\te r`?r is `�w '! 2`' , . , r•. AP *IPPt iR �' •c._, aY.+,..pl -�,`I' ii ` 5'Y t1 i ik .f .�'a. t +!�. , 1 a .,lr°4 44 .1,, Y s`• >.*"f !i 2y ! i s .•M �c d - t - • • ' ,.' �, {$1 �'' 'ram' ot, fit' pp . '€ . �:.. A EASTERN PROPERTY LINE FACING ADJACENT PROPERTY TO EAST Ir •,'� -' , 5} ",'. „.., , , N ! ,t !`.•-• !..k .'\ ....4....., :... ' +.0: , ' , r , \ 'm '''''.',4'' CA' ',./ 4„.''' `-'fr, '1/2.44tfr/+-1 ‘4'' .---....vt....-...—.., $1.-.4.-i.,, .41,-,,-, 1 ,t r \ I Y , �..:r. .1:.•'_c - J,t'N. 4 fir'' ' .$ r p", 1 iF. .... ,1 & i'.� fly), v' ...or.• •t _Z°. tok ri p ±;1 sT. ``H �..' } fj�2�.R�A �' �r 'Q"-/" -fit •.' i z� at .ct ..�7 IL- "ze h r t• a\ 'Yl< ,n, r .s�• .� •.iµ. ' `cam }.S :. • ,t'�'. ^N.. '�"'`:C; . T '_ i v f,`it- ,'4 { -1 4-`'l - ,a..^ Ik'/k�L' ,'-4'te+'.`�,j t "l':' i 4',�r,mod" t . i y `� a rr�' C bi±�.r ✓� , au V{ �"„�. EASTERN PROPERTY LINE NEAR STREAM FACING ADJACENT PROPERTY TO EAST 9 4,°eV), N\NNN ..),,,.. . . • :. , . . „ _ - , , . . , , , • , , , ., ,, •,-..,‘,,,,, ,..', , .• , , .+ , ....,,,...•,/,,,,,,,,. --- '• . _, . , --.1 ,,N , ,,.,,, .4 -,,...- ,, . i -,- • . •.,••• . _ - . - .e„,,..,N,,,,,, .,; ;',4I,11 4' •,,,'• ' ... . .. .'''''' ' .'-1'. IA•.1'",111 • . " \r‘/ . ‘ ' , .,, • -.- ' ' -‘) ' - t,...,,....s...„.„ , .. , - -- -- lit 'i .......- I.-..;..:-ii;;•, • .1 ,,,1V,•/ ,„ ' ' ' ''Vk""•ti'''. _ • • •- '.;,••••„\; '' ' ''"•-•It,. ., • i . -' :'•,''' -..-— • - -i', ,,•'; ',L41'• •`1,--7 a-„,:•• '•:.'''"", ' ',,,-' .:'• . '11 . "• -:-,1. :-.- ...-••... ,-, ,.-. ,•-.• " . , ,- . '.1„,.„ '"-, - :. - '', t'i.:,..,"•:'"' 1 .f_4•'•-••.., 4-..,•••;."``'''.. -...: -....:Y:i4:\ ,,' ' • --".".",';'-' •-•;rt..:-Ah-Ae.3,J. ...,,,,,,,..... ..:,,,,.,- s,-;,..).-,,,. .,-... ,, -.... . .4,,-;-. _ .• . •.,-;..._.., - -,, ...0........ ,.1,- ,- .•-.,-. W 4,.. -,.--.---- "--..--'" -k- -1).„. -- .....,. -.,.. • - ----s-cr :.„,, .......,,.,„. ,.:...... :.:._..., „.,,„,, ,. ,.. ... _._ .,.., , ,..,.,, ,,,, ..,.,..;.:„.....„.....,.,..„. e.,,_,,,,,F,,,..,,,-„... . . y.. 4.01,..)..,..„, . ....,,,r,......,:,.,„ .7_, ..,,. . .„.... ...,„ . ..„, ..... ... .7 •-<•''';`,'• -01" el ' -'-'• to .r. ' .7. '.,'af 6,,,,r-Ar."3."t.t.".7...irli.'.-;1 :-'--4.r---'... i*/ '--.67-''''''''-;•;il-'4inS4V-9". iN' *.:3-113_::-‘. '-- .--'7.3' • • - --'-' •%--..•" '--t,'‘ ''11.7 F.;... .... '-'7,,,,Iii , T., .2-.*;.--- -..7s,Z3---at:.,L.,',i j,-,j------t.'1":3,4,- .411%.#"7- ---i I .. ....7Str".:•:,. ...-..,_- .4,3"-'...'1,"- , '''.-t,:',. •---.,•-2,7, - -'• ..: 7''.4177)1-iiii1714 •'.- -4.-- ' :-',..;, 7114--'.,#_"--- ;,^r -,--.-_,1 , Al''. '''1'- ..**‘.."4-7-4.4S4.3 3'**41%*:".44-"* 4. ': slit .,;•3*,;',....',..••.40'4 3..4-,3-*f ,...--4- -''---/ . , '-./ , .3 "•• ti 24,_„,....•tklito:C.4 ri. ,,,,,.' ''....,.3.'";:v.3',.; * -';:-- ' .' 'te7;/7- . * ''',-:!e3*.-<"'•1.-'7- ''..-lir' ii--:,,,V,,t1 „Wil....r.-' ' $-• ..'IN. '- .... .''-?111010=ft.i- '' '-`1-•3. ' ,- -.,;...-,,,;?:.-•-4 Vi.,,, ,:-.., 4,•'Nv. -Ai.4 3, _ 0' •," • r., • - • - ui-- '....ktt, ,,,,,,, ,, ,--?-"..'re'.."•.. --..\\---„ii: -.3'144- ,.` IP..._ ...:io.i... , , _ (4 ..,01,,,,. , ,. ' -":..., - ,,,d,,,,,,,„ io.„_- ...-z4 -1, :-.!,‘,- - , ,...., , q-„. -•Ai? 14..t.Zilt .-X":"t *T. ,..ltiel, ''.•3/ 3 ......k..i.;' VIEW OF STREAM LOOKING . EAST • , . , t• .1), ; ,---4'. i ) V , A., f, ,,A 0 , 1 ,! A , , •' , , , , " , 4,,, ,i-.„. V.,‘ ! .:. • 4 , „ •,*414#.4-Wit'l.: : '1 4• ',I-. 141 ! ' ' ,,,!' ' 'i• ''. • .--`----- -\. ' r flip,!• ',i ,, ,.. , „dr. . • Lf• •,,,. • ,... ,.-. 4), t to ., ,„...: .,..; i. . ... •....:, ., 1 .., .. - ,0 .•,. - ,,7 • • fit .sle' ..1•1'. .-IP,.03$ , FY f ' t. r,,‘ r . - 1 '::: i,IV .‘f:'0''' ,'' .... ''' •X 1' 1 .-'t '. - '''.. ."'Prf$-, ., , .-- ,,/ --,__,_. \I- ' ''i'l -, c '--? .4.1,AlP 4,•,.„,.'tlkle7rAdf i A, ,,-, -';., • ',Sidi P,.,, c;:r I a.V7-:it??;T'F•I',' -.'7'1 1,. r,, ,:i!'ft,. ' • 4 4*a,i ;', , , \ ‘:.,,e.-,->,.v.,,,o4.7:1.--.:•!...;....14.7 4 4; ‘',..;' ;. , ,,`.. - .74.\•,'.1-1*--1::".•4 -II' '''. ' . \ , .:" l'i ' I i -- '.'•'S..'s :__-L,''''" -' 't '''! ;','. : , •.'''0,'4. s'3,,y,,,,,' - . ../. 3 "---. ,-• ,.;.•• ' /..1\-"-‘,,'-'...,:: •••'..):\:1,%4:: . s.'-' '_-s•:-'_..3-'7:-.,' ;4.-... ii-.1.,-•4.1.-: ''''' ,..C::'''''':';' )''''.. '.--''' IN' 414"'41.11114111'..- :"3-rn,141..4;16: 1.' st. . '\'471, '`...V11,:s..•;.1.-!-. '7;2...'''''.... ..;1"-_,I..„4-,....•'":).r:..,.`.1.-.;.,:sf.,„ ''''i.,:v7".- c.,,,,,,/...?,...',"'It.,x'..4""?. .,1/4.,;,..--,•.....'',...„4„;::::-.......-:---:.z.Z.,:::::_z.,2"---i_.„...1.,..:i-?:'--i..,, 7_-,.........,,-„, '-. 1 '- - '' '.,,, ,,`. : ._ ,, ,.‘ ...,- _2,_..... •-_s___,..--'',...5..L.,7-,...(4-"Dt_i , ., „0.- 4...,„.„.-,,,,,, f.-4 : -.,tv-.- . •..•,-•••••F1.. .-,.„-._ - I-..., •f. ( -1. - "' c 4.--:''.,••:It': - '. . .' „.,; . it.,,: . . •• ' A '. -‘-','''•--i--- ' '‘• ' '- A •leilos . •--7.:7‘`'.: .,•,` `4., ' - •"" "," - —4. .* '1- * V ' -.',..*'-'''-' -it•-•-' ' ^ 7' '', . ' r3 tok-4'.'. ' .• _ ..- .....: "...—•1,7-..'.'.. ilarN -.....- ..;:?-* , .• l'• ,,3 3 3 _ 7, -. _ - ....' ../L, ,' , - , •---% .i`,0 _., . -- --- , _-,, _. __ ,.. ..-- . :>• • ' . ,. t''.4'• 01.,,s, ', ,.. -- , - „:, .. ik A 5:. •-••_,‘, ,t,,3 , . - ' ... '•-----.-:;-.33. ''' - ' - ... "....!ii **'- 4'.'.7,,t 3.4--',;',1,,t•K-137,K*N -••-'-'• - '- :- -„•-.:.,'"••.333'.1„ ..1131/43,,„„3:-Vgil T • , ,'-• ,A' "..13t12,.&:`,MV 1 r 04;••' .,' ', -'4';•'"- • ' ;'''''`,. ..4- *, 46.—Vielt ' -,...0.r...f-V -0,-;:,•7:14,4'sii—..st.v... ,- ..... ...,-,.% -- . -. - ‘• - . VIEW OF STREAM LOOKING WEST Ots, �., ��.� �� F® 4 . lo .1 ;,,4� ' '''..''.' ' .. -a, 1,,,, ...f, ' F �1 E!. Ohlkik v d'` , A :: , ._,.,,j13,N.E.41 ,?'',,,,.1 ,„. ti fi • � �.' ` }�jj1R l .y:. .4 l`,r� "h};-t "`y '3. �.�f �(aI yr . • `'!� 7-,.. �.,.:, , ,,ram, e ' s.,..• Y t .'¢ I. '" + A , *')r "k s_- ems` r wH.l . ,fir ..-• L ,'- [ r FL I, y i. i• C SY. a•. ,yip '�- ti 'L. . ";lam• 'f ; L e,� {• Z- a+i+� r , f. arpv .. w �A n ,r ei. ..'+• R 1 _.,,. fY `Sy ,.d tl Y '4 s.a. . •:, .G. r _ • LOOKING EAST ALONG RT 250 ACROSS FROM BB &T BANK 41110,, • T.Frik,4-, „ 4 , ��• :fir ��6't' i+l' d-. "; VA."'';:i'l L '.\V: j a _a•s'�",. 1 I. " � i,"" 'u: •,.;i- . ', 4k. 'S` i "i r•1 ,, kJ1ç • �, p4 - , i #j- w • 'i�1 � R• 1�,. rt'�yi,�'� _ =,d i` �" I< y+f�y r Cj�u� Tg�rV� AA�•. '�. JM4�x X:" n. -.,.7. F rti ."i/ ...j~t' -, v ,� p 11 y„. 1 'fi x ff!: :-�,1 ., v� - 'EGR{•-`..' .. ' `c '- t a� 2- < '.t "—•- . �__._..s�....__..y�has v y�• T �.'i n 1. �l - 'l� T?.. .:eft' ". i�'Yi �.,y «� <� iPrr • ;, y-Y.04 " • ,, C a. SAME AS ABOVE—ACROSS FROM DUNERS RESTAURANT 1/4' 'ft*/ 4.: 0 .1( •41 \ / . .., ,,,, ., ..., r• . ,,..,.... , , , f' .air -..., \ . . , 6. • \\\ A . . I A Ath . N I . . .... V __ _ :_-,_•,, -.- . , -- 0 / •111 ..........)'.16 •••• 4 s . I . . . , OF- . . • , . ... , . - -\-Ti / ....41 111L --...1•A_ ' - a gS0r1023c1 ED v ill...,--: , ... .. ,, • . ,, ..... .......A,,,, , (. , ‘ _ A , • 1t 1 . lir .-.. ..;;,'... ! ...Ili...-. -. N ......— ,... 1 A. . ,.._..- A . — . = 41k- ,—...:,:..— . li.I 'i"kk'I , , • .If it *0. t - _4...'....‘ \ 41 4111. ir •,i - -'1"-_ .„,..,„‘,,/ `itie I Vollinc - .---- . . N. .. A I,. ;.„...• ......,„., .„,..,.. „,..... il ) -\ - ------- , r ( ,, •-am. Ao. , W' ,.-sr 4\ ii' ."-k .... _ . . ./..., ' • , . .' - !, 4,. - \ N. /CI: s. % 0 liCC G...) 11 1 --, . . 0 r it : : ‘', •Nt ) ,.... ....„ gm og --- is . • l, C0'9.4(. cz ki10,.)N sg,\'-.4-t4,,.. 4- '.''' '314' '- Z 414 4 6. "q , . 0%7') 4,) (OA, „,<1‘, 't(k• , , 411, dO Scenic 250 Scott Peyton, President PO Box 5 Greenwood,VA 22943 804/456-6400 (tel) 804/456-8600 (fax) E X I B I T S s 0( Albemarle County Board of Zoning Appeals PRESENTED TO 1�2Aor\ 1 County Office Building, Room 227 401 McIntire Road j( (r) Charlottesville,VA 22902 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Re: Edin Kajan/Charles Hurt -- Request for setback variance Dear Board Members: Scenic 250 submits these comments in opposition to the request for a setback variance by the applicant for the property located immediately west of the Ivy community on Route 250 West,parcel 40-D, tax map 58-Al. Scenic 250 is a local organization in Charlottesville and Albemarle County that represents a cross-section of neighborhoods,businesses, and people who live along or use the 250 West corridor and who seek to maintain the rural and scenic character of the corridor which helps make living in Albemarle County so unique and wonderful. Organized in 1997, Scenic 250 currently has approximately 500 members and supporters, and is working constructively on a variety of issues central to the future of the 250 West corridor. Route 250 West is a state scenic highway and entrance corridor and enforcement of setbacks is central to maintaining the long-term scenic character of the corridor. The zone of 250 West running from the community of Ivy to Mechums River is of special concern. This is a particularly scenic and rural zone relatively close to Charlottesville. Scenic 250 is working to preserve this area through the promotion of conservation easements and other land preservation techniques, and we place an extremely high priority on proper and appropriate development in this zone. There is no justification for granting a variance in this case. Granting the variance and reducing the setback from Route 250 will create a negative impact to the character of the area. In addition to the general importance of enforcing setback requirements, in this particular case the applicant and owner removed the significant natural buffer between Route 250 and the lot in question that existed prior to the onset of construction. Had the proper setback been followed, there would have been less need to remove this natural buffer. Denying the variance will not cause an undue hardship on the applicant or owner. This is simply a case of poor and sloppy planning and execution without regard to the interest of the public. Indeed, in addition to removal of the natural buffer,the applicant/owner violated County 0 dO . requirements by illegally clearing land along the creek that runs through the property. Any hardship suffered now was of the applicant/owner's own making. They should not be given special treatment by the Board of Zoning Appeals now. Thank you for your consideration of these comments. Sincerely, s// Scott B. Peyton Scott B. Peyton President, Scenic 250 cc: Mr. John Shepherd 2 A--\rs , • '_ • \ f 1 :474; .•41--, ".3k- • ", 1 Ati 4_1 • '• , .t - . Y4•f`� Y`F.rt tY i _ 1•46 yyj t`' a 'ESL .I47s00.' ,r...+• , .y- .. •-e.. r +.:,I3Ss 'WV ,r,4 , ^reX.. r . .. 2 okUJ ••1"`-.••.Y•. a z. •r7,i � x 3R !..' ,-:e�. .E, -�'r- _'- .s14r R ...1 :.c .1, �-•. ..'.`.),4•t,...,9, i,•,;_ .157,14-` ta�e d ,t•�,�.2 d�-ac�' .t V: •v►v!as. - _ 0 ENTRANCE OFF RT 250 LOOKING EAST TOWARD, IV`( " � �_ O ,���� I-- O '� U w• .l - `,j\Zir c.,.b: I1 1 ,5u.: - "s .,t- ly i .^" ex t �In . ._a.s- � t , . 14' '11.. .At..:•VI! ,',:,* ".-,'''';...:4-XZ'Zi:•••.'-4#4,7 ';'' •" i ..' .-AS•- NMI ..y •ti1;,'. "nW1ti Y ..1•. • , 1 'YA \\[;I 1 1' .1t,!" `.4 11 • �lfLW•�t.� r'w f. _A..- ti''Y! ;`• 4.M�• a..:..� 1 l..�•.�_�w�iT tt • "ie _ ♦_ •a.�, _ y1:.•)`T• 1 • - j _ .•L`.may -- R K�4 • �: .• ? T Y 1 � `'�r � • 7 r T%s ! ' T�K � i � 1f \ •Seti T } -._ .�.....LwtC4,..:..'yo,i. ;�y +a.i:,,,a6 ••••••'•6..11l ,-t...�....-' _.a_- . �_l...Y.;-. ..:... -L�►:: s�a.4:"4 SLOPE OFF RT 250 LOOKING EAST - ' •-'. : •.."'•• -• ,..1 I. --•-ci-. • ------.;"‘ *.••••••;: -.L. ...W.5'......"•°' ...:-.1'; .:- / /.._.''''.2 .' :-•ILL vA''' ''''''' ."iir.1-71f4TI'' -,7.-:7:7_"..,7';..77:•:': Nrompt ,. • A,: •v..v ,;,:., ,•iii:*.;7s 4 . *, ,•• ''•• ,/ '' •-,"...--•;II. . .1%,i'.. ' •if,q,; 'A.1 .! .1,7' ,,_ , • • q . 1 1:;,...11,.'• ,..•A ,i j • '-.1 , -- • ..- -,. :.........----.-•- - .,, -'.,, :'......,.ikii,01...% • ... '..4,- - ----.."'-•‘-.7.._..-_:--.'-'''• I • / •- • - I ,,,„ ..',...ketlil..",-,%. •- .;...,4.... ...;'-‘-'f.; .,,,, t - air. . i.' • . ,i,, - t: - ,A,e'--. , - '„rfe••:,...#•-- --- , , It'? ' -.14 '-e-06.- ' - '- ---- ' '..- '-.-'-1.',14- . 1.1 %. ''''';,;" Iiit:..,;,;.•,-..,_-..:,:',-.•,•''N'••:..•-•-•,e-::/-iff.,,•/-;:,--.,";.---• 4 -Ali'''. • /-• , ' 9. -A) ',..'s,, ,,,ZrP,!.•.•AL.,, ,,,31 .-rs ' ' - ' ' k-"•''. '11-. P • It 1,-....-'• -__.--..--=::175,7-7----;..,,,..,. . •• . ., • 1 rj"---...----7-6.-:`.--..'.....'-- _ --e" .:.•=i.,--':.:, , , !...., :. _.___.. __....... ,.. .•C•fv.. ,I,..1,:tew .', ..- '-::::- '..•. '.. l‘ite„I ' : .I '.rt:' ......=.--....s-----..-,:.;- "".':..,.f.2,'„,.,...,:.., _ , . .. ' • --•-•.-,-..... . -.I... , i .• -•--.•••••-T •:-.05c- --lUoll t....411b,• .. -ei‹.:-''..T.. .: '. ....7- 1SIN• •• • •.... •••,.... ...,' ' • „........• • • , ... . ., . • 4.7vo, , 4.311 '...., : - 4,,, •-..,s1..... •, '•,-..,--,....&D.j.,-' --., ' '''..44'. --...t.t! , . • -.:\ t ' "•'•,,•';•/..,•f•. • -- %Ili,.' •',-• ••:.- -:-___ . .:?'•'-'<- -- ••••••1.C`'71-t-* .- - •• ,.. •iw),- ,....-iiktin,"_:.'- ...• 1. - '. --.41 -"stl:',-'.' ii•-•':".-;; ;':;•:- ,;t:'..e. ,.. '" 1--- / ...---•••••••_ ..- -,,,,r,..tice,:.•' f ii........•:----r,- - .---/„....a.,: '.,.... CD .k:).(.• • . • . •••7...,.:-..A. ,f,... ...t..•-••,..--4 ..1N,21.7..,•r--:, • --c•,,,,3,,,,z,‘„...1, • .f... CD CD ''.•': , .„ .. , -„. . '.__.. ' ' . _ ' . .}.• • ' - :.-I ' ''''"- ,---.. 7-1-..21::Q00:44:,..i5;;; . .- • J .k _I 1 ''- Cit• 41 .''''.,-A--, ^ -..;/..' f• 2S ' ,.I • ' . • t• ' ;"'IA ' /P.1,,-,--.0t7:"..to,.; r••• ' •--------.MAL* ;"...,t--,, '... • i .' , .'__.......1. r4.7'7.1.t.4''et'-'4)%;.-"' '' - - --...%,.•'. ''. 14'` '-'4.4 ••••(: '1.p.ivii- ":"If '114't O. ,•A'''.-:•-•.- --:.•:-- -- •'•••• .., .. .. .:- - i• 1 •• :-Atctri.". • t"•.:. .-"tis i'''-'''..."ki7..'''''''.-" ;,---- ---.,..7,--::.:.'- '44. Or,' ILL\--Li- ' 1' 1 i , ' ' " --1 c• , ,Ii ' , ,-, 1., Al......, G) .s.,., .',..;,.1.' . . .• - ., ;7.•(:•...'',....,:t.'•,,,,•;.,. ,.:,.,irz:.- . .:-.*--. .;:••i..?...7•1•••••••-..... .1''' ... -.*:-. '• -.',i.',I1::',:I,k••1...----... •.-• •----•'-'4...:4 ,73?.. _: - ,(1, ..- . . :-i,,..-x•I? it1,1„:,• .•L.-• . ••.•.• •• • . ; -;.1.. -•t-,,.,• ::::, -7-=.---_e----,:,::,:irr'..lic‘s.. .-.!,. c:-.) •4..... 1,qt. 7• / t'I'l ,. .... . l'..--r'--------. .:•,*.i*'. 4i-• f'°4•PIL.- rri I., it....+ ii .1 • • ' • ,'- / t, ' '- -;-_ ..,,p-.fitk.: c_/.1 ..;_sii_,...-!7 -.-..._ .-- •, "-?..:-....,- ‘, . r...,--,,-...,........_:_-_,-.-.:-..„......1....,..,,......tt-Ata...'„,,-.-4, ,,,... "•1!....:f r.'•. , ,-.. y.,.•k . • ' •,_..-_---;_,-,7-;:.7....":;.:::.;-37.11:1-..iff•-• ." . -T1 • .`•'.. - '. . '.-,to • - - ' •'.-44-.A.''',.•,r, A ' 04,.• .. . ,...-e . .... - -••24/14•19*,`- 1, i.'..- - . • , .-••..,.. ..;..:.•,..4,....... ....-- 1 •.......• . • .. .1, .,i IV '.- 0,. , :-.: •41.. 1'.'.1.1ti -q:•:-.A cn --4 ri i ••• C3 •,• _ ..... • ihk• •-„,i. ) gm. , lirmezt__::. .:A.*••4t.; c) "-• .e•-..."••- -.• ' '',.•ri i.1. . .., r ‘%.j 0,..;:,•..1......r.......1,_,. ....4 7 t..:.,•.. .r., :e tt.;i;,...;f::;717;K . •. .. . •,Ti. .1 • .4111 •., . 2 - . . - ;; .......,...--,.. •,..,--„....,,,„. . -- ..s......5'l.,'S* -t) 7 Ak 41.. r. .%.7: '' .14:',1. s 6.z Y:..-, A‘, zt.-- -;;-..-.---•-•-•: .. lftL..,..0, ; ......., . . . _ . . ' •,•,.... •. . ".1!,,,,,,ii.;,'A.-';::. rri •-..; • •.,,tiro,,,,•• .. • X ,,,, :::--.,••1-f..:•• .,,.,.. .;:c. „--„,,,,,,..,.; -T1 n - ••''..: I *; 5- ' • - 111 - . ..11.../.00.4„A•4.•, -,•' , 1 • il'Itl.. '..% .' .1'. .'1*. • 1 ›r• • . •• .1 C n..:,:''''!.':-.:':.k•' 12 • 1 1!.. ! 'allifT4,1::. :Fii,,,..:„,,:,:z7.„ r- •irt:i 7 V.1. . •••,,;r:, •, 1..:••••••.11':-'7.-'•.;-;;,,r..-7'. ' 1_. -:' L.--.---iz,•:".•7. -'-'',...,.. „0,.. ''. 1 1 - ''' • ' '111.. .• -.05, ...Vt;I C3 . ,, ,f ',.,;. •,.•, .;;,..• t`h A,...- ',.40'.,..r..f.'4..:•,.73-41,.‘..-1-•....yvr• PL.', • .:•`...•' : •'..'1, .• r i . bill I .1, t ' .• 1 .i - &At, I "•. • C:) •.•.• ... '''' ...':.i.::,, i.5 90.!-•. i-4-111 • '1. - II; •• • -4••••••.71... ..,,,,!.. , 4..1:141 ,, se:: '..,Ki :::.4,..y , 1,r'S ... .,•••...4•••,,i• •..., -.P.... ., 2.:•• 1,;.•.. , '•'' •,.'• r.'t r 1. .1-r , v .-:, • .. III) ..-::. G..) ,Iv4,:t.••., . .c.,• 7.a.,,..,7,,••;.-1.,.:4 .4,4,-..,-•41..4.- -...,.: -..._...,*-.Z.,''''"7-,,,,,,... • . .f.Z..;. ....:.: .. ,,' , .• Y.' -- I .• . 4. -• ,.. 441 .1.1; • ,,r !:-.--.•-- •;4„.,•)- ,........-4,...„,-,„-,•,. ' •.•,=.• .;,•-. . .-_-....,2:-,,.••••••ye.--,.., ••••cili -- , ..• ..,-. ,•;'...,.1..:•4....4 i'.,'...._Vs• ' .,•": • 1$,.....-`'.._,.....•..,..;.'-7. in Ai: '',••if itakirtilet„_ .,:i....j. ',...:::''!'•f.'..4:.i .''' i • ' I Ill '. . '.• ' ' . le P 4 . 16,.... ' --I • e?'• .41. ',A,"%•,{1.1*.•rint -A,A• •' -,..".I,"4--:;-'4"!..'..*V-ZtP, • .....4....'...... ttiol'' ' • . '' .14 -':`.. .i, :.;', \_) -A ! ./.,• ....Vt. ' k ,...;:'-',' t Ali 0 • •'. •.. ' fa ,',.•.....N0,,,_, I - '. , • '. ' i ••• •,,‘,..., ' '''S.t., :•-,-, ,....s., . ....,„ .s ,....se. .. .s.„.•,,,•v......„.- ,. 4, ... , s. _ .•........, < ., -: . , : -...,,i,,, .., . •,.. ,IP t - , • t ,'„.•,., ..,... ..........taie .- --.-', -.4 ..1:-,i•.;',..1.7i7i.e-'Olt..''',••=:?:. " -•?..r.-4.'•• V,. *X.; %lis'''' ' . A...A I:! 1:-.7.,••••,.'‘...1W 44•.‘1`7.•••:i %',1e','••'.41;')..'$VOM.. - •:' .4... ?ki1.0 ...,:t.,•• ‘,'••\,••• :.:...11-..Esi. Al A.ii d.......,...1,,itt;..;.; ,,..7..••.,.**.:7•1,e.lie.`7.4:4.1.6.7e.;•f,;,-, .'.-,''.(,•^:••:' .‘•;k`;`,itY/I. ---1 - *....•:.:;1'..-%11; 11.;'e•'''• :, . • , ' $'. , 6 h.1 *.'....: •:;,..005••ill . 4.•.':,,--- -..,„.. .. ...'.•-. ..:z.,,,-....; :..-..,... ' ';:ii-.'. ' c_ri 7. ..... ' ...1 r-,-;retir$ ,*0-17-;',..A.:', -.'„,,.:1,,A,:,!*: .-.--.':.;=••:,_-4'#..,!,:...-i.,_• *: •-•:' •.,' C3 ' •rf.° -. - $11 ' '`. : . . ,.' .II. ', _ ' .--A-...,-'';‘: t, .1.-, .--ii.?1,:!..;--..:_.''''..,-••1,.;'"...:,•.::.:'.-4-:.4',ALIIi",7.144-. ,rN ".i.•!. , .....,''. .f • , '.....i; ..-,...-1 pi. 1- . , •• I ,46•,...'-., , , , . ?,,l'I:.1;-. WA .liA-1',:--..."‘'•:.1)'-';'•,'%-:'''''...-1'•'..r.,,Nii-IF,-,•;,...:._ i:).1.,.4.,i • ,-,00...•-•,. r.....,-4.0.,-.--.'••-:0”..,.. :tx-4., ,,,i'. , ' 4- - •' ......... . ..., .. , '. ..:,:.-.,.11..1 ,. 1 --;•,: %. • 2 . ''-----. . ..-4'' -.*If..4i7::::.!.V.,,W..3.•• ...,,..'.....-,....... .., ._ -'.• ... . .... • d. 1 1.- • '•:. ' . 7-- ---71..,,j‘, ' ''...4. : ''... '. 1.'".t...,,:i..r.X.;itf-f': . • 2 f;rlit.." , '..' r- . .. . ., .,,. ,, . , ., ! : ....,. . ...., ....• . •,...„vt r ., „... . • • .,-...,...-,:• .,, .•:„. . „ , ....: ,,. •, .••• . • • . . ,., . . , i _.-.......10 kw ' t , 1,- :;‘....,..4,-,,,, • • , '. ••••`31g,c4.,•.-'•f,,..\,V k ;;,, -14:P.:,V• ,:•• • - --,, :•.,'2,4'•!"0,141:---p- • ; . ,., -:- i.;6,-i ,t.,;„•••.,..,e. •:•,,,..., •.i•I . V,..0;:i4.•:'---.',..,-t- •',,,.:4,•;17,:_ity4, ...47,,E. '\I iv? k..71".." • . -, • . , , • ,. ," •••...; *. •,.....'4•a, ....,..:; 711***:. ..zity71%l:.4",.'1.. "`•• . .*,j ' f 1 f ' • i 7:.f. . ' .• "\-.*- :. , r.',.. .• :I...'....::,-....7; ,.' •t .....!' ' •;„..4 / , i t', ;41 •'y ' ; '="3 -"I A • . ' '•..• . i . -...,:.,.. ' . '''...,,'( .!' ' ,-. 11' ''..,,,-•!,,. .'• ; ' ".''.. '''''; . ". ''';A ,"' .fr' sr 1;.!..% r's•4 • ; s". '',A.. . •Z' e„. ..:.• - -.,.,'•. : / :-• .r, •• -.... . ,, . . . . -•,.a, -- ,44.4, -..,,-.-. .,. .„ a • • •11 1 no ..›.',..$11.4.--‘, '' 4::...,...-_ ,_-; t, ..,•3.1 ,I.,.,.. PRESENTED TO _ 6zig- c5-.)-1 $1,10_, ( 60 ----/ 6(.661 COUNTY OF #:.:1Ei,:tifiLE . \ \ " 1-:"i\T• / 7 •'''. ,r 4fl,-ei•".•"•'y'•,•(,I\,•./'...'',ti,.".v4i..r..i..,,..'.'.,-:,,.\f\1 'I,i•,4,J,-,i-.1',...i2.1r,,- I'i.),'' -J.Ir,-'.,'fe...;,,t,,,f'A'.1:,'',.•,ir.7•,,,4-,,.a,:T,"e:r,.rx.)‘,•.".7,_4.c,';,:.,'4.r4:,,.7-_:(-'‘.e.,..-.,V,...,.,-.c..t.-..;,r7.---4,,-,-..y,r'.......$'"„....."..'..-,1„.-_..•t...A.*....:-1—i ri-r,..'.','.,,'N,„,.,•4,-.'.,te"t1.',/'ik,A).0„),f 1, • lhI,( 4,I , p „r , L • k : ,• Yi . / : ( \ i f.j 4.. ' - • ‘" -- .I .. s'•••-•;',',-2'..1 • 1 ' .i 'r , :-.-:-.1: -74.7., _..:%i-.3,.,. .,....._.,- ft- . - :. .,,,. . r - ,, ...'',••• • '' •/ I • / • • • ; 1 0 1,1 / .1 • • " I 7 :. .,, II •* ' Pth 44.. • --......_---„:••••_._ .. .„--...fTr, i 1 ,- 4 • , I' 5 .4 a `•' ----:-.7.=-- :-= .- -yr - .4 t 1',, . ! r• i. ry. I. : ._ •• s, .... , , i i41 Nrm i 4.1, -' • ' - , -• i, v.. . 4-4,- ••:. ..,- ,----,„..... • - • ' , • '" • ,,. . -- .--,e11`•.•,---.7 ..., : . •'7, • ,,,,, - '-..•••t-,e • SP .V.', - • • '....f.,;•,......1., , - -.•.-- • ......8141...t...A .A.t,41--, ..,.),s'r, ..54-•••••.1.' •••••-"....,ii - • * ••-.. ''' .•...:. .`..,....,:r . -0-0 ••..6. •'.-,•,--,_ • -,.. ........ - • r.- .-' -, ..:L-Jr-,.?, .7-......w. 44'64* aka ., ,.....""0,11,41611.1 ow—.....4.0 '''' 4'....4"..:1-." • . `•itt.t".7.....:-,.... :;;4.',.......,- •‘•'• 'V 1. ';41.:?1,.......4. 1" ' s" Iiir.•••• f,,'!'' - • '. • - " - '-.-••';."if,'2,44TN."- -` ti4,-A,:,..,-.„ _ .14,04....04...,..,,. _ •P•401.77 '.1•'1'4 v ,: ''';-:•- - •.,,,'1..'' 4' .., .h •0-.'" • .%•-12:4J.. 4--3tiogc "..'<`:.),,-.1.: rtiZ • ___A-f-t'ig,-,:";.... --. • I 4.4.s.....:-.:,_:1,1,.:',"... •"' ' I V) #?-:idar • "- '''-. ..iP,..--,,,_......:- . -„-.. :::„., ,., ..- ..;,„, ' -,,- --; :-,z4.7,--;.r.- ,--,-,- --•14-,.. .. .--,,......., : E 4 CC. • •4 .. . • -..... .-~ •.-" : " "*•.- • --•.. : •• •:::._... ..: ;.. 7,--• . N ,11 w LOOKING NORTH FROM NEAR STREAM 0..ii ..... IA. = 0 0. , 0....1 , • , ..1, .,.; ,s,. . ,,,,,,„, ;VP t? - .• z - • ,14 'il 4 r • ; i e..1 I le« ' f ' 7./. f• • -..-. LU ', e tt it;I%..,, ,•;2,1 .-: ,.:71 ititV p4 f'..k, . . • 4 .411,:,Ili' ,^ i .../ ' • ' u) tr) N . , 1, ,1 4 • 1 r. 1 .f ,.:, 4,131 .• ,,,A, t • , ,-,- ••A_,,u, „ • .,,..! wftew, jtoOite4.: t `Nr• 4''#z- .---0 t''' ,, ' ..7 • • Lli .24 iitgr4,./....Viblki. ;%171/.41, .t„,,,,:i •SV,1•41411, - '‘,,flit't.. :;:- . • cr .. :1- -,. -. „, .7.$ f I••'' 0..... 1:44 ;..• f. , •, \- , i . . • a --:* • •• ri-q• , .,..„..4... k.‘,... •AN.9.. • frifotplb,.. ,,-;• • ‘,..1,, ' :-. , .• .•,. ittio., ,,g...1-7,."- ,,- . tAiov,- ! ,:r.'4,4 ct` . ...,,• . , ,. • - -. *•:::IN1 ,;.i, ,•g., . ; ,4•11,.e , .•el, „,r I , ,, •-&:* •••• • , , , • - .. . . • — • '. \ - -. II* 0. !rt. . , 4,0 . I ...,14"F • '- .--* ='• ‘ ., . . . i.t 1 t . .1 . 11,,14 . .-.) ?;ir, 1 J., . ( , I$1,eilift . . , •-,,.:,,,,%,,,;i '4,.7; ,*.:", Vstoll !••:•.'''i IV I! : iti*1 slii' . 1 '1, ': .iVi:•4:Vr..,,i! : r''. ;1*,i; ilif ,ot.e:-.,..,,, • ; ::;•:-4. .. ir fkilt .-,•••„,, , _ -, . i; ,,•,. i , •..., i. ., i J I..:' . ... . pi.. ' • A: : t.', 1 ' •;. ' el j li I 1..e4til tIV li 1' fil i j 1 14. ',. .44.- .....;i4 tt ' '....i .13• 'II04 1 . 31 :. 1 . , Itti .. . i ... . -J, 1 1 .di. - -r - I: t,'-, ' 114 N•t\ 1 I 14 ' 0.4,-.... 1. - ,fi. .- ).,ik ' .""••••,,-,7---- -...t:4...-1 i•..; 4,;...111.;, ;,111,.,,. ,id,1 1 .E. I • et.1 .15.,, ''',.1.,,..,... 11_,. 1...,.-A....0.A 4-1-", _ "`Vg=....- .,1.4 , .1 • r.Jo .. 't ,,, .; ...) :i,,... ..,:,...,..4;••• , .s,„1.,..4 „4, „„„,...: „...4 ,...:.. ,k,,.,4, ........:,...... . ,4.., , griretel,4.4,..4,44 .fP'''. •-,•ti,E4-'Z'A"7-“, ---,•• ,.„. i'i.„ ' 1...•higli... ' '' „....-bell ,:41.4,4...4.4.1 4,-,,•:.:1,t....71•444,... -I, ''• .. .'1,•71••,,,:•.; ,ig,Wqr".•,':.•-i-- .' ., •••';. ,.z-, .1•••-•tr-.:. --,...,- -• .."-, • ..--:-..,:.:711i1-,,,_ - _,•„„...1 a..All...-4,11,ksiart.j,;;,..: •. •f-•-- . ••,-.!:/40.1.;._,,,•• •-1.„,,._,__ ,e. .,_ — -,-,,r.-..... - .., - -.,--.,... iciii,g.01-Itt 4'.7'-'•'t'' ' .. ". ,-,--.''.c'''''411.:•v b• :.-,-,..,•,.f•-ar", a' =* , n '. --_.*! •: 1.",..,.."1:i" • •...._ • " • •• • f•••! 4..• 71(1*Vr.1...rs- 111 "-W.Z.'•' -, ' ''. 4.--../........t.••••••-i.4„. • •• -'''' •• ;• ‘"ri,.....2:.::•'- '..!.....,..:4.^. '''.'S.1).g as. ...'... ..• A- .,.;-, ,,....r.,..:.•,N;7 7 4-'1-7=::•!r. ...,,-. ,- ?;,.. • :01, ,,..,„...,..,.;if:._c,„...,-,,,l...........t.,,,l, , . _e . • . .\.t•... .-.:••;;44. 1:44,1,""? . '?.., 1 1... '.: .;.. .'.../..fir . '....i,....• ..•....1"te• ..'..,,,....... •t: ••••4Z..-, ......,...t .e1.......%..,::41.1,...1.,-•. \‘‘C',------,.,,e,•:r...i.‘, ,....e.-- k --- .v....., ,...-, - ...‹ .. ..,. ... .,....• .. .. ...si, .- ,%•.... ....,..- -, 1•2-tlig g ' ' ..;,111.,•.. • •..,"g',IP••••• • .1.,,.. , '• '1, ‘ • 't ••Ik'. ''It....7.-g • •r I 4.• ••. \de...S.. . . . .• •..e.• ,. _.0...i.4'..0.1 .,:r..AN‘orei. .,..44A° . .1.1%. ;.+V.refe,..-;...• . ... .. ..... • .. :'..' 0 - .•^-..1T .14:ki., . 4."3::,;\att..,' -6••., , s S., ' :.., •'4...,04 5.'th_,,,, - . . •••• ••. 1,-,/..' ••;;!.....64.1::` '•'''..;,..tr•-• •.'•ef. • - -s‘s.t. . .- v• Cr4vIrrlirtAer-..0,tiell. t •••.•;-fja. - • .,‘4,.%,,,,. f•••- • ,. ..--1.1.- .1 : '"?.;-.,.. " 1, • - .•.. -S ii••••-:XL.If; ' „1,...i• 4.1•9•4.4'sft.- -41'11‘. •• ' • • ' ., • ......,•-'.: ' S'- " .v".4 ..• .i.'ewe- • ,ft:l'iiin'e.-4,..titel.....4 # er.r........"*7.'• ',:,..s..:t • ''' • ,,,,,.21. . .ft.c 4.1.n....47 •.114.P.r.44, c .-.t•tAr,144.. ,,y. NO. . ...••• ' ' .. ‘••••• .• ...'"I rs*.••• ;-11'44••••‘14!1/...."! :•:•.-)",kir...7.1.-'1, :.:....k•. ••.• ‘'••••1/41,,' ••. : •,....1'. -4 -- • 44V- . . ....f: -.• ...., '. . -,'N'f••‘.'........ • ...._ 4,-:If ,...-.-.A.4„,..t.. • ... .,,r• kr. ._ _ .. .„ ,.., • • LOOKING EAST ALONG RT 250 —Original Message— From: Crowder,William R[SMTP:WRC2KR@hscmail.mcc.virginia.edu] Sent: Monday,April 30,2001 9:00 PM To: 'Charlotte Humphris' Subject: RE:Variance-Dr.Hurt in Ivy Ms. Humphris: Thank you for your time and effort on this matter. I have several questions that may or may not be relevant to this process. First, has anyone addressed how traffic will be managed in and out of this property. 250 is a very busy road and the driveway in and out of this property is steep. Traffic traveling East on 250 crests a hill near the property and will have little time to respond to a car coming in or out of this driveway. Will this be a safe situation? Traffic traveling West on 250 will face delays and possible hazards by cars turning left into this drive. Second, the applicant excuses an error in measurement by stating, "I made an error in measuring the 75' setback from U.S. State Road 250. I measured off 75' feet down the slope from the right of way rather than using a horizontal measurement, " This seems to me to be a rather shallow excuse and I am concerned that the proverbial wool is being pulled over the eyes of the Board. I suspect that this person has been in development longer enough to know how to measure correctly. Ignorance of the law is no excuselllll In addition, I was informed (I am not sure correctly) that the setback for a designated scenic road, such as 250 is greater than normal setbacks. Are you familiar with such restrictions? Third, as noted there is a stream buffer which has been violated. Protection of our water resources is one of my greatest concerns especially with my children. After acknowledging the "encroaching stream" in the preceding sentence, the applicant in stating the case for hardship commented, "Within in this small area, I still have to work with a septic field area, well, and driveway." Well that is exactly the reason why we have these regulations so that septic fields are not put to close to water resources. I am concerned that a fine in this instance is just a slap on the hand. In addition, I am only vaguely familiar with Federal and State laws concerning wetlands protection. What if anything should be done to consider violations in this regard? My wife plans to attend the hearing tomorrow. I will not be able to attend as I have child rearing responsibilities. Please feel free to pass my comments and questions on to the appropriate people. Again, thank you for your help in this matter. Will Crowder EX I T S PRESENTED TO 6 UT On 5/1/Di Vm-2061-S COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE 250 WEST ___ d 1 000 (m00000000 0 000 0000 000 MAIL AI 000C 0000000000 ek ___ w 0 SEPTIC 0 ---- ---- 0 ---- --- - n ------ 0 ,...---- .---- I 40' i ---'.-- I ------- ------- ------- ........ ..--'---- ,-'- 0 40' r.---- , ,-- ------ 230' 0 / ,,,------ ,--' PROPOSED 15' / ' ------ DECK ------ 40:- - ----__ / ------- ------ ------ ---- _ _ EXISTING TREf...---- _ ------ 7"------ „------ / / / (EXIST(NG TRE i 100' IP e , - : -' 7 - PROPOSED WELL EXISTING TREE EXISTING --- /,z. XISTING R iEE 1 ---- n ______-__ ( ,.... XISTING TREE ) - ___ ---- ING\EXIST TREE , I \ r ,--- _ \ EXISTING TREE -____ !EXISTING TREE \ ------ --7 i '•--/----//.1 / _.- -/ ,----- EXHIBITS PRESENTED TO 624 DY1 /1/0 p VA- 2vvf-5" Siayl0 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE 9 -0131, SP Exhibit "A" \IA- 20C$ft005 U S, E�0UTE_ 250 --- em—en t PARCEL 40 (A) R�-2815 76; J m ITS P^,ESENTEDTO COuN'� l OF AL9c!`iAAF^.LE ALBEMARLE COUNTY 3-A(2) SCALE IN FEET SAMUEL MILLER DISTRICT ` -200 o foa 400 sDO Soo IVY INSERT SECTION 58•A(I) 1 j, } _'