HomeMy WebLinkAboutZMA202200006 Narrative 2022-08-15Application Narrative
999 Rio Road East Rezoning
PROJECT PROPOSAL
Basic Overview
August 15, 2022
Tax Map Parcel
Owner
Acreage
Zoning
Comprehensive Plan
Land Use Designation
06100-00-00-154BO
Windmill
1.947
NMD
Urban Density
Ventures LLC
Residential
On behalf of 999 Rio, LLC, the contract purchaser of property designated on the County of
Albemarle, Virginia (the "County") tax maps as parcel 06100-00-00-154BO and having an
address of 999 Rio Road East (the "Property"), we propose to modify the existing Neighborhood
Model District (NMD) to allow additional residential units, eliminate the commercial portion of
the project, and revise the layout (the "Project").
On March 4, 2020, the Property was rezoned from R-4 to NMD (the "2020 Rezoning"). The
2020 Rezoning envisioned a mixed -use development, consisting of up to 6,000 square feet of
commercial space, a 14-unit multifamily building, and an 11-unit cottage courtyard in the back
acre of the Property.
The commercial market drastically changed during the latter half of the month of March 2020
with the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. Due to the deceleration of the commercial
market and rising construction costs, the Applicant requests to revise the 2020 Rezoning to
eliminate the commercial portion of the Project and add up to 10 additional residential units. The
Project will still provide ample greenspace, meet the County's affordable housing requirements,
and will be designed to meet the demands of middle -income residents.
Public Need or Benefit:
The intent of the small "cottage" units within the 2020 Rezoning was to provide less expensive,
single-family detached homes. The Charlottesville -Albemarle market had, and still has, a very
limited number of newly constructed single-family detached homes that are affordable to the
"middle market" buyer. To maintain the original vision and intent of the 2020 Rezoning, the
Applicant proposes two-family attached units that will still serve the middle -income of the
market.
A two-family attached unit consists of two "stacked" units, where the first floor is one unit, and
the second floor is a second unit. Each unit is a single story. These units will line the frontage of
Belvedere Boulevard (28 units). 28 units was the maximum residential density allowed in the
2020 Rezoning. The Applicant proposes 10 additional 3-bedroom units fronting the internal
roadway, to replace the 6,000 square foot commercial building. These units would provide
larger, for -rent housing, designed for small families. This unit type is smaller when compared
with other similar for -rent townhomes, which typically consist of 20 to 22-feet in width
(compared to 16 to 18-feet), internal garages, and four -bedrooms (compared to three). The
smaller size and more basic amenities package keep these units discounted when compared with
other units available for this family type. While these units are currently intended as rental units,
they will be designed to be easily converted to for -sale condominium units. If sold as for -sale
units, they would likely meet the lower- to middle -market homebuyer, which would satisfy the
original intent of the 2020 Rezoning of meeting the needs of middle -income homebuyers.
Beyond meeting the public need for more middle -income housing, the Project will also benefit
the public by connecting the missing portion of the existing multi -use path that currently ends at
opposite comers of the Property.
Intent of Neighborhood Model District:
According to Section 20A.1 of the County Code, the purpose of the Neighborhood Model
District is "to encourage a development form and character that is different from conventional
suburban development by providing the following characteristics:
• Pedestrian orientation;
• Neighborhood friendly streets and paths;
• Interconnected streets and transportation networks;
• Parks and open space as amenities;
• Neighborhood centers;
• Buildings and spaces of human scale;
• Relegated parking;
• Mixture of uses and use types;
• Mixture of housing types and affordability;
• Redevelopment;
• Site planning that respects terrain; and
• Clear boundaries with the rural areas."
In addition, "the NMD is intended to provide for compact, mixed -use developments with an
urban scale, massing, density, and an infrastructure configuration that integrates diversified uses
within close proximity to each other... " Importantly, according to Section 20A.2(b), "an
application is not necessarily required to possess every characteristic of the Neighborhood
Model ... in order to be approved as an NMD." The County Code continues, "the size of the
proposed district, its relationship to a larger neighborhood, or other similar factors may prevent
the application from possessing every characteristic." While not all of the components of NMD
are met in the proposed plan, the Project satisfies a majority of the goals and components of
NMD, and therefore it is appropriate to maintain the NMD zoning designation. In addition, as
noted by the County Code, the small size of the Property and its proximity to nearby residences
may prevent the proposed development from containing certain NMD characteristics (for
2
instance, a mixture of uses). However, NMD is still warranted in order to achieve the desired
layout, density, and unique housing types.
Also, the immediate proximity contains a mixture of uses: the Property is within 0.2 of a mile
from the Center at Belvedere. The Center at Belvedere offers a variety of events aimed at
"creating opportunities for healthy aging through social engagement, physical well-being, civic
involvement, creativity, and lifelong learning." The Center at Belvedere also has a Greenberry's
Coffee shop inside that offers a variety of food and beverages. Located further along Belvedere
Boulevard but still within a mile is the Fairview Swim & Tennis Club, Fraites Dental, and the
Soccer Organization of the Charlottesville Area (SOCA) Field House. Rio Road East also
contains several nearby commercial uses, such as, the Circle K Convenience store, and several
gas stations. The existing commercial zoning districts of C-1 and Commercial Office allows for
further redevelopment of more intense commercial uses in the future. The amount of existing
surrounding commercial uses, as well as the number and size of surrounding properties with
commercial zoning districts satisfies the intent of the mixed -use component of NMD without the
need for commercial uses on this specific parcel.
As stated earlier, the Project also provides ample greenspace, and orients homes along Belvedere
Boulevard, where the missing connection in the multi -use path will be complete, and therefore
such space would be much more inviting for pedestrians and bicycles to travel from the Property
to the Center, SOCA, or the trails and parks down John Warner Parkway. Parking is relegated
behind such homes along Belvedere Boulevard, and fully screened from view from Rio Road
East. The County's affordable housing policy is met, and the homes are designed for middle -
income residents. Such characteristics meet the desired components of Neighborhood Model
districts. Each component of NMD is discussed in more detail in the next Section of this
Narrative titled, "Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan and Neighborhood Model."
CONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND NEIGHBORHOOD MODEL
The Property is designated on the County Comprehensive Plan as Urban Density Residential,
which calls for a high density (6.01 to 34 dwelling units per acre), complementing the proposed
multifamily and request for additional residential density. The project proposes 20 dwelling
units per acre, which is well within the density range recommended by the Comprehensive Plan.
In addition, the Urban Density Residential land use designation calls for a maximum building
height of 4 stories or 45 feet, with two or more housing types preferred in each development.
We are proposing a maximum of 3 stories, or 35 feet, and two housing types, as detailed above.
The applicable Parks and Green Systems Map shows a multi -use path extending along the front
of Rio Road East and Belvedere Boulevard, linking the Property to the Rivanna Trail. Our
application plan shows such extension, consistent with the Parks and Green Systems Map of the
Comprehensive Plan.
3
The proposal also achieves other goals of the Comprehensive Plan, such as, Objective 4 of the
Housing Section of the Comprehensive Plan, which states, "Provide for a variety of housing
types of all income levels and help provide for increased density in the Development Areas." As
stated earlier, the project meets the County affordable housing requirements, and the market rate
units are targeted towards meeting the needs of middle -income residents.
Characteristics of Neighborhood Model Districts:
• Pedestrian orientation;
As noted above, the proposal consists of extending the existing multi -use path,
linking the Property to the extensive Rivanna Trail network. This will allow
residents of the development easy access to this extensive trail network as
well as the parks and green spaces located along such trails.
• Neighborhood friendly streets and paths;
The extension of the multi -use path, noted above, will also contribute to the
eventual connection of the Rivanna Trail to the Belvedere subdivision,
allowing such residents to enjoy walkable access as well. The buildings along
Belvedere Boulevard will also consist of two-story, two-family attached units.
The small height of these buildings, as well as patios facing the multi -use
path, will be inviting for users of the multi -use path.
There is very little internal street network due to the small size of the
Property.
• Interconnected streets and transportation networks;
There is a small 20-foot strip of property located between the Property and the
subdivision on Fowler Ridge Court. Therefore, the Project cannot connect to
such residences. While there is no vehicular connection to adjacent parcels,
the pedestrian connection via the multi -use path does allow for future
residents to enjoy the benefits of walkable access to the commercial uses
mentioned earlier, as well as the parks and greenspace along the Rivanna
Trail.
• Parks and open space as amenities;
The proposal consists of a shared common open space. Such common space
will include landscaping to shelter quiet spaces to read or gather, as well as
4
natural playscapes. There will be an area that will be usable for a small dog
park. While the Project's residential density has increased, removing the one-
story commercial portion of the 2020 Rezoning allows for the Project to
consist of more amenities and greenspace than the prior proposal.
• Neighborhood centers;
Not applicable. The Property is not located at a "Center."
• Buildings and spaces of human scale;
The buildings will be two- to three -stories. Per Table B of the Code of
Development, buildings on the Property are restricted to a maximum of three -
stories and 35 feet, consistent with a human scale development.
• Relegated parking;
The parking is relegated to behind the buildings fronting Belvedere Boulevard
and will be fully screened from Rio Road East. The streetscape along
Belvedere Boulevard will consist entirely of building frontage and/or
greenspace.
• Mixture of uses and use types;
The proposed redevelopment consists of a mixture of housing types:
townhomes and two-family attached homes. However, the Project does not
include a mixture of uses. Due to the variety of existing commercial uses
located within a mile of the Property, as well as the number of nearby
properties much larger in size that are already zoned for commercial, it is not
necessary to require commercial within this specific parcel.
• Mixture of housing types and affordability;
The proposed redevelopment consists of townhomes and two-family units.
These units are intended to be less expensive than the average home on the
market in the area — see the "Project Proposal — Public Need or Benefit"
Section of the Narrative above. The Project also meets the requirements of
affordability in the Comprehensive Plan, please see Section IV —
Supplementary Regulations of the Code of Development.
5
• Redevelopment;
The Property currently consists of an abandoned single-family dwelling and
shed. We propose to redevelop the Property into a more urban residential
development with various housing types and ample greenspace.
• Site planning that respects terrain; and
The Property is mostly flat and therefore redevelopment will involve very
little land disturbance.
• Clear boundaries with the rural areas
Not Applicable. The Property is not nearby the boundary between the rural
and development areas.
As stated earlier, the Project provides ample greenspace, orients homes along Belvedere
Boulevard, completes a missing connection of the existing multi -use path, relegates parking,
meets the County's affordable housing policy, and the proposed market -rate homes are designed
for middle -income residents. Such characteristics meet the desired components of Neighborhood
Model districts.
IMPACTS ON ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES
None. There are no streams or critical slopes located on the Property.
Currently, the Property consists of a vacant single-family home and shed. The front of the
Property is cleared, with minimal landscaping, while the back of the Property consists of a
wooded area. The Property also slopes slightly in the back portion; however, such slopes are
minimal and therefore redevelopment of the Property would consist of very little land
disturbance.
IMPACTS ON PUBLIC FACILITIES & PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE
Transportation Impacts
The Rio Corridor Plan was approved by the Board of Supervisors on August 3, 2022. The Rio
Corridor Plan recommends a continuous green-T intersection for the Belvedere Boulevard and
Rio Road East intersection. The Rio Corridor Plan also recommends signalization of the
intersection as warranted pursuant to VDOT standards. The continuous green-T intersection can
offset some of the delays in left-hand turns by allowing left-hand turn movements to occur in a
two-step process where vehicles exiting Belvedere Boulevard only need to navigate one direction
of crossing travel at a time, instead of two. The Applicant will work with the County, VDOT
H
and other impacted landowners to ensure the improvements recommended by VDOT come to
fruition, thereby enabling the improved safety and functionality of this important intersection.
The estimated vehicular trips from the proposed development are as follows:
AM
PM
Use Description
ITE
Qty
in
out
Total
in
out
Total
Multifamily220
38 units
4
15
19
16
9
1 25
The 2020 Rezoning estimated vehicular trips were as follows:
AM
PM
Use Description
ITE
Qty
in
out
Total
in
out
Total
Single Family
Detached, TH,
Multifamily
220
28 units
6
16
22
18
10
28
General Office
710
6000 SF
12
2
14
2
7
9
Total
18
18
36
20
17
37
As shown above, the estimated traffic impacts will decrease when compared with the 2020
Rezoning. This decrease in traffic is important for an intersection in need of improvement, and
further justifies not requiring a mixture of uses on this specific parcel, despite it being a desired
component ofNMD.
Parking and Loading Needs Study
The below is based on the minimum parking requirements outlined in Section 4.12.6 of the
County Code:
• 1.50 parking spaces per one -bedroom multifamily unit
• 2.00 parking spaces per two -bedroom+ multifamily unit
• 2.00 parking spaces per single family detached unit
• 2.00 parking spaces per townhome (or single family attached unit) with 2 or more
bedrooms
Assuming the maximum allowable density, the minimum required parking for 38 residential
units will be 62 required parking spaces.
The total above assumes all one -bedrooms for the two-family attached units (1.5
required parking spaces x 28 units = 42 required parking spaces)
The total above also assumes the remaining 10 townhomes will be 3 bedrooms (2
required parking spaces x 10 units = 20 required parking spaces).
As shown on the Application Plan, the Property has sufficient parking spaces for the intended
design.
7
Stormwater Management Facilities
Stormwater will be addressed by an above ground stormwater pond as shown on the enclosed
conceptual grading plan.
Public Safety Facilities
The Project is fairly small and will have a minimal impact on County public safety facilities.
There is an easement in place between the Property and Fowler Ridge Court that will allow for
fire truck access as needed. The internal roadways will be designed pursuant to approval by the
County fire safety officials and applicable regulations.
Public School Facilities
The Project will result in a limited number of additional school children. In addition, the
Brookhill redevelopment has proffered a new school building site, which will accommodate any
additional pressure on the school district in this particular area. Since the Property has been
designated as high density in the Comprehensive Plan for some time, the School district has been
able to account for the redevelopment of the Property, and possible additional school children
during such time. In addition, the Project only proposes redevelopment to a density of up to 38
total units, versus the maximum of 66 total units recommended by the Comprehensive Plan.
Public Parks
The addition of the completed connection of the existing multi -use path will enable future
residents access to the newly proposed park trail head at the Rio Pointe development, as well as
the parks and greenspace along the Rivanna Trail and John Warner Parkway.
The newly designed layout also allows more greenspace on the Property
CONCLUSION
The Project is consistent with the County's Comprehensive Plan and meets the desired
components of Neighborhood Model districts. It provides ample greenspace, and orients homes
along Belvedere Boulevard, where the missing connection in the multi -use path will be
complete, and therefore such space would be much more inviting for pedestrians and bicycles to
travel from the Property to the Center, SOCA, or the trails and parks down John Warner
Parkway. Parking is relegated behind such homes along Belvedere Boulevard, and fully
screened from view from Rio Road East. The County's affordable housing policy is met, and the
homes are designed for middle -income residents.
The Project will complement the County's continued development, and satisfy the need for more
housing in the area, especially for middle -income families. We request the County approve the
proposed modification to the 2020 Rezoning.
H
Instrument Control Number ,
005866
Commonwealth of Virginia
IIIIIIIININNNIBNNVININNVIIIIIflIIIIVINNUVIIININIIIII
Land Record Instruments
Doc 10: 032920950004 Type: DEE
Cover Sheet - Form A
Recorded: 06/23/2024 at 03:30:36 Ph
1 of 4
Fee Amtl $
o209.66vpage
Albemauntv,Debra M. Shipp Ciruit Clerk
File# 2014-00005866
pLSVLRCover Sheet Agent 1.0.88]
aK4505 Pa218-221
T C
Date of Instrument: 16110/2014 ]
A 0
Instrument Type: [DBS ]
X R
P
E
Number of Parcels [ 11
Number of Pages [ 31 l_..._.........................
...._..._....._...............
E
City ❑ County ❑x [Albemarle County ]
(Box for Deed Stamp Only)
M
hat and Second go
tors
P
Last Name First Name
Middle Name or Initial SufTx
[PUGH ] (BARBARA ] [H 1 [ 1
❑ ❑
[ ][ 11
][ ]
First and S eond Grantees
Last Name First Name
Middle Name or Initial Suffix
❑❑ Q
VENTURES I
[WINDMILL
Grantee Address (Name) [WINDMILL VENTURES
LLC 1
(Address 1) (535 FOXDALE LANE 1
(Address 2) [
1
(City, State, Zip) [CHARLOTTESVILLE ] [VA 1 122903 ]
Consideration [500,000.00 ] Existing Debt [0.00
] Assumption Balance (0.00 1
Prior Instr. Recorded at: City ❑ County ❑ [ ] Percent in this Juris. [ 1001
Book ( ] Page [ ] Instr. No [ ]
Parcel Identification No (PIN) [06100-00-00-154B0 1
Tax Map Num. (If different than PIN) [SAME 1
Short Property Description 12 ACRES MORE OR LESS OFF OF STATE ROUTE 631 (RIO ]
[ ]
Current Property Address (Address 1) [999 RIO ROAD EAST ]
(Address 2) [ ]
(City, State, Zip) [CHARLOTTESVILE ] IVA ] [22901 ]
Instrument Prepared by
Recording Paid for by
Return Recording to (Name)
(Address 1)
(Address 2)
(city, State, Zip)
Customer Case ID
Cover Sheet Page # 1 of 1
[LEWIS A MARTIN III
[MCCALLUM & KUDRAVETZ PC
[MCCALLUM & KUDRAVETZ PC
[250 EAST HIGH STREET
[CHARLOTTESVILLE
[13217.18658 ] [
.....__....------
PREPARED BY: Lewis A. Martin, 111 VSB*19005
MARTINWREN, P.C.
400 Locust Avenue, Suite I
Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
PH: (434) 817-3100 Far: (434) 817-3110
Assessed Value: $487,300.00
Tax Map: 06100-00-00-154B0
Name of Title Insurance
Underwriter for Instrument: Old Republic National Title Insurance Company
THIS DEED made this 10"' day of June, 2014, by and between BARBARA H. PUGH,
Grantor, and WINDMILL VENTURES LLC, a Virginia limited liability company, Grantee,
whose address is ; 535- foXD t.- L-A.Q r , C1442LCFI�' , VPr 2-29 03
WITNESSETH:
That for and in consideration of the sum of FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND AND
NO1100 DOLLARS ($500,000.00) cash in hand paid to the Grantor by the Grantee, the receipt of
which is hereby acknowledged, the Grantor does hereby GRANT, BARGAIN, SELL, and
CONVEY with SPECIAL WARRANTY OF TITLE unto Windmill Ventures LLC, all that
certain lot or parcel of land described in Schedule A attached hereto.
The property hereby conveyed is subject to any and all easements, restrictions,
reservations and conditions contained in duly recorded deeds, plats and other instruments
constituting constructive notice in the chain of title to the above described property, which have
not expired by a time limitation contained therein or have not otherwise become ineffective, and
to any lien inchoate or otherwise, for real estate taxes, and assessments, not yet due and payable.
WITNESS the following signature and seal.
,�ctthAXA1 Yl - jb� 1 -4 P, (SEAL)
Barbara H. Pugh
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLt
The foregoing deed was acknowledged before me this 2 day of June, 2014,
by Barbara H. Pugh.
N y Public
My commission expires: ( 3D I
SI W FRFi
`o`�.•
� Y G�y �:
p0
N0
=0i• roa&FRoNy_
Schedule A
All that certain tract or parcel of land lying and situate on State Route 631 (Rio Road) about one-
fourth mile southeast of Rio Station in Albemarle County, Virginia, containing two (2) acres,
more or less, and being more particularly described by plat of O. R. Randolph, Engineer, dated
March 29, 1955, included with a deed recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of the
County of Albemarle, Virginia, in Deed Book 317, page 28 with plat at page 29; LESS AND
EXCEPT the parcel set out in the Certificate of Take by the Commonwealth of Virginia, dated
December 6, 2007, recorded in said Clerk's Office in Deed Book 3527, page 469.
BEING the residue of the property conveyed to Floyd S. I Laney and Fannie L. Haney, husband
and wife, as tenants by the entirety, by deed from W. Curtis Thacker and Mary E. Thacker.
husband and wife, dated May 26, 1958, recorded in said Clerk's Office in Deed Book 340, page
143. Floyd S. Haney died intestate September 4, 1984, and by operation of law title to the
subject property vested in Fannie L. Haney. Fannie L. Haney died intestate March 3, 1999, as
evidenced by her List of Heirs recorded in Will Book 94, page 237, and by operation of law title
to the subject property vested in her children, Patsy H. Carrott, Barbara H. Pugh, Betty H.
Blincoe and Floyd R. Haney. By deed dated April 11, 2002, recorded in said Clerk's Office in
Deed Book 2184, page 235, Patsy H. Carrott, Betty H. Blincoe and Floyd R. Haney conveyed all
of their right title and interest in the subject property to Barbara H. Pugh.
RECORDED IN CLERKS OFFICE OF
ALBEMARLE ON
JUNE 23 14 at 3:30:35 PM
AS REOU BY VA CODE 0.1-502
.. V20 flmIIyX14)0kmt Ndl) Pwk AxhmWkmy Ax-mwm, l91J1&v STATE ISA LI LOCAL:E250.00
OR
COUNTY, VA
M. SHIPP CIRUIT CLERK
C