HomeMy WebLinkAboutVA200300010 Application 2003-09-25 •
MEMORANDUM
TO: Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals
7{e-----`
FROM: John Shepherd, Manager of Zoning Administration
DATE: September 25, 2003
RE: VA-2003-10 Motion for Rehearing
Background: On September 2, 2003 the BZA approved this variance with
conditions. The variance permitted the demolition of the former Advance Mills
Store and the construction of a dwelling in its place. The application included,
but the BZA denied, a request to cantilever the northern portion of the proposed
building three feet beyond the existing foundation. The applicant has requested
the granting of a motion to rehear the request for this three-foot extension. The
request and justification is contained in the attached letter from Palmer Burch.
The Rules of Procedure adopted on November 15, 2002 by the BZA establish
the following criteria for the approval such a request:
Motion for Rehearing. Any decision made by the BZA may be reheard upon the
granting of a motion for rehearing approved by at least three affirmative votes.
40 A 'j oVGD The motion may be made only after consideration of a written application by the
661
u r ,f.,p pGpGRperson requesting rehearing, which shall be filed within thirty (30) days after the
_ date of the BZA's original final decision. The BZA may grant the motion if it
11+0 7b "r finds that the decision has not already been appealed to the Circuit Court and: (1)
ab_ 21 2,en>3 new evidence can be presented that, in the opinion of the BZA, is relevant and
pecGm
material to the decision but could not have been presented at the original hearing;
ti evil144G, 4'0 or(2) in the opinion of the BZA, one or more relevant and material conditions or
// e1 gyt�j/ situations have changed so as to bear on the BZA's original decision. If the BZA
' i ehi Kie-14"- grants the motion, it shall set the date for rehearing. Notice of the rehearing shall
t iNO3 be provided as otherwise required for the matter being reheard.
Staff Comment: It is staff opinion that this request should be denied because
neither criterion has been met. No new evidence has been presented that could
not have been presented at the original hearing. No conditions or situations have
changed so as to bear on the original decision.
If the BZA grants this motion, the matter will be placed on the agenda of the
meeting scheduled on November 11, 2003.
15 ZA Afi'RoUED ‘1
Attachments: Palmer Burch Letter
QQ r
VA-2003-10 Action Letter TO I - 17115 4 Ta TN r:
QZA APPRdveb v e-1Q.-tt laggl T 't o N nV cM -R i l e 2003 146-entu&
wivo 1401n o RA R M6- 4:0 e 5 : o . ,4, .0
1.\DEPTBCZS\2003 staff re orts\VA-2003-10Request P Rehearing 9 /47l7(03
17e,L4- 1/14 ? t-0P(-1 S„c9,1
CL,.` ( UL c., t'c,Le''' : %v`, N4•4cw4•^4- QCbt'OS SI00 �' �•htsc
M=ALs RD. 4,„7t Gzeft. et.:‘,Nr-e-se4L-4
Ia.3Q —gZA ‘`'`te7S. . UtA, L 4-ttoke- Tcrs s W,�L �1�u �2st'es
n ,�y , I
tlr��-CT-L osl „� w•�S u 1n. a.trt, v 411 • 1a,s itAte7hti.l.
R-,., de b‘i v Sc� LAw to-v41r Li 1 CV 4
D I � Q(�'r°'P so".1
411'4breN/S c..e�
b v4-C .-►�' h9. $ )vs 4 O ff o S►-le . -11.1%.5 G�ti r�,r ,,,,..s OV I kJ
11pp .1 1 "�
l,•�l'+� � C ou„1i��v� �o..� Ka-� �`a t,.� f vvb C a 4- -�4'0. rLit L
*I- Stv.Ik% (4wv �� wovie9 CGS'‘4-�\A \.$4' 1‹;-1-e . Jity
So€4 weV gap L4;. ert,b+- C-006A- Z," 1.4Sc c.-Le:Ar e?0-sSNot-
Atcts.T— 1/,y y,,yv; %. iae uo4(
sLJ t ti- n�..,.. s .,e l9 �D �s � d�:srLe..s
a.v,S ve.,rx., to Jg re f,re- rc'4-„.60,..ce..? w, ,40„I k a` ,cruse y,,
c._ CAv wA4t V k1O 3 . 't'�w �� `� ;4- is w�( '�.✓�
t .r caw .
1, l oD k L -c ,M LA;AL `-/e v 1 v. f-tfp.v—•
�.� S�.l►
1°4
Cn•
SEP 2 5 2003 I :)
BUILUC'S G:"E "tG
Or ALA,
tt;'7
ktRciykr
COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE
Department of Building Code and Zoning Services
401 McIntire Road, Room 227
Charlottesville,Virginia 22902-4596
FAX(434) 972-4126 TELEPHONE(434) 296-5832 TTD (434) 972-4012
September 4, 2003
Palmer Burch
4049 Broadway #222
New York City, NY 10032
RE: Board of Zoning Appeals Action
VA-2003-010 - Tax Map 20, Parcel 15B
Dear Mr. Burch:
At their meeting on September 2, 2003, the Board of Zoning Appeals voted (5:0) to
approve the variance requested with modifications from the applicant's request and
staff's recommendations. This approval is subject to the following conditions:
1 . Applicant shall provide a measured drawing showing the existing foundation
including the wall between the garage bay and the feed room and the limits of the
front porch prior to the demolition of the building.
2. This approval is for a new dwelling, comparable to that described in the application,
with the following conditions:
a) The new dwelling may be constructed on the existing foundation or within the
same location as the existing foundation of the store, restroom, garage and feed
room.
b) A new deck and walkway may be constructed at the northwest corner of the
building. The deck shall project no more than three feet beyond the northern
foundation wall and no more than five feet beyond the western foundation wall.
VA-2003-010 - Tax Map 20, Parcel 15B
September 4, 2003
Page 2
3. This approval amends the approval of VA-2002-27.
To clarify the modifications made at the meeting, you would be permitted to construct a
second floor above the existing garage and feed room on the existing foundation.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact our office.
Sincerely,
---L-fat-e/1-41/1
John Shepherd
Manager of Zoning Administration
cc: Judy & Dana Burch
N N=NEXT M=MAIN MENU P=PREVIOUS 08/04/03 15:28:56
INQUIRE COMPREHENSIVE INFORMATION SYSTEM T571 CIS002
CISINQ02
PARCEL # : 02000-00-00-015B0
PARENT PARCEL #: - - -
OWNER(LAST,FIRST,MI,TITLE) : BURCH , JUDITH V ,
PARCEL LOCATION: (HOUSE #) 5600 (STREET NAME) ADVANCE MILLS RD
(CITY) RUCKERSVILLE (ZIP) 22968
MAILING ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION
BURCH, JUDITH V & DANA BURCH 1. 2//
2. ACREAGE
3. WB 77/279
5600 ADVANCE MILLS RD 4. ADVANCE MILLS STORE
RUCKERSVILLE VA
ZIP CODE: 22968 - 01/01/2003 OWNER: BURCH JUDITH
DEED BOOK REFERENCE: 2248 / 580
HELP = "F1" OR PUT CURSOR AT BOTTOM
N N=NEXT (P=PREV-PLANNING) X=SELECTN MENU M=MAIN 08/04/03 15:29:00
INQUIRE COMPREHENSIVE INFORMATION SYSTEM T571 CIS002
CISINQ20
PARCEL #: 02000-00-00-015B0 OWNER NAME: J V BURCH
PARCEL ORIGINATION DATE: / / TAX EXEMPT DATE: / /
CURRENT ASSESSMENT CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT
LAND $ 30,000 LAND
BLDG $ 88,900 BLDG
$ 118,900
TAX DISTRICT: 6 WHITEHALL DISTRICT ZONING (TAX PURPOSES) : RA
PARCEL ACREAGE: 0.000 AGRI/FOREST DIST.: 99
CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY: 4A COMMERCIAL CLASS
UNDER LAND USE?: N LAND USE ASSESSMENT: 0
RECORD DATE: 08 / 12 / 2002
TAX BILL INFORMATION
MKT VALUE TAX AMOUNT: $ 903.64
BILL 1: 2003104115 $ 451.82 DEF VALUE TAX AMOUNT: $ 0.00
BILL 2: 2003204115 $ 451.82 TAX DUE: $ 903.64
HELP = "Fl" OR PUT CURSOR AT BOTTOM
q 1 ID / 19
1-1
t.
C' X kC‘ g
\!`R o
? 1
l=q—ITO ---4-k
■_ ---— i •—I— —el t —I— I� -- — t
•
"r)1 o I I -
i , II -k - —A
•
'1, I [ I
...r. r4 . r thi• A,
(.ill 1.......... -4.% ,MEIN . lt,' Eigli ..
p I
,1, 1..,, , _ 'tZT
dilIl I r
7 r------T. ' -.3-..., ,....1 _
IN » �_.1��� � - T �t
K G
C. I— p.m 1
�� .� ; 4 _.
I
* — tom) = "' 1 1 'G I ,..1
A i ,
— i ' ...4-,,•
ill 1 -: —10
No
021 99 ? -
i _• ...‹,, ot el I r;,,. .
-a
--e....._•-•:"5- 1:CSL 7\. :
1-4 -.. -,_..$ 1..1
E A
el _ AIM- I
4 '- A t
..�-
1
ts f 3g 17
r
III
fticv 1.-11.14 8.1.012
BURCH RESIDENCE LOWER PLAN PROPOSAL a PENNELL DESIGN,LLC
5600 Advance Mills Road SCALE 1/8"=1'-0" 133 Eighth Avenue,4C
0 Ruckersville,VA 22968 DATE 10 21 02 Brooklyn,NY 11215
DRAWN BY-MBP Tel 718 399 3882
c 1 VA2Ic
IOW fitt1455AL
-
1 . ...__.,:,..... "
/�.I MI � q�
"w 10C1
i
a� , ;!, milill ZS - .i•
:. S . GC. M E4 m H
nAturJ(I `hi * \tiU � )0 fa r r6�6-
7-)(1
_- 4 .
- Niiiiire ..''' 1 1 0 "Th
• 1.�' � p11Ho�akT1t i I �� 1 l 1 I I I _ a
- 1 1 0
Li d' o _ z o
NM II/ , .•,,_ , \ , \
. .1 2 2 80 .
i „
fili111111MICE -Milk. -. , 6. . c =
Wm...Oil i -_ , __,. ;64 -< E.-. -tt
30 II PM S. F . -,44,.
t 1 _ _...........
_. Ea- ..,
9., i'.
,1 , ilipprr, .__„ ______
•
y N
N.
, VNI+� pvw� Si��[ Po�roSPL. a d
O U
/7 - s W I \ UPPER FLOOR PLAN
_- PROPOSAL B O D D
SCALE 1/8"=1'-0"
VA2ac'3 - • - , ivAr0 3oi
r-r---, .
` Mb FIR, 3o I v
- . ►�Es�,n 1 31
L•r ' � ' � 17640 1' •�el
TOTAL �$011 /W� , r.11ib,_
I �! A 7 N CV
\ �i I ' ��, gal ¢'\�IiI r � '' Wr� z $
\ MI
„11i ► 1 m %cc;
Z 'w cCZ
W
X -14Q- �-� 6oxsa= ziso a !;t INIIU
Pea-( -1-IttAl ' ' f
,I ti1e� ! r R t iwt'
SIC. kiI
• ! 25 _0 a
—
0.; 9_0:11 27- at,
ezi,1117)-/ -- - cl I -)
�m •
r v
O
��- ITGN�IU LA? tiia11t ? ✓f'( ,4. '�
.T.. — W
iiiiiw
uf
as
1 it NN is ,l l SIN E'poh�1 -� � U >
h �
•
LOWER FLOOR PLAN
r-- _ -- PROPOSAL B D D
SCALE 1/8"=1'_ O
S to- i-3 3 GI E.S
Q Q ED g 'IliS0a01Ia c�1
NOLLVAa'Ia.LSva (.a+YN)04 OS d►
7' 8 1 •1
voM al-
tJvsle A
iy
Z1
oo O y
\...
w
.141_- VIIIIIII )or'V—
11 } ;, o
" ' aidd ob �. � 'wry
_ :\:14,,,gt.� 'O ue`\``
0 _ s '
It nt t___1 llj
10
til
67;.' z
Li Z a r a rIItA41 44 al *IA It)/ O cid
N 00 r C CI
.N. fi
N A
z
r ,
r
COUNTY OF ALBEMARL WIT:
I, Aar_ . A.Wright, a Notary +'ublic in and for County
aforesaid, in the State of Virginia, hereby certify that C.T.OtNeill, E.C.
Brown, and J.Curtis Fray, whose names are signed to the foregoing writing,
bearing date the 1st day of uctober 1948, have acknowledged the same before
me in my County aforesaid. I I
My commission expires the 27th day of Jan. 1951.
Given under my hand this 26th day of October, 1948.
Margaret A.Wright, Notary Public.
I
STATE OF VIRGINIA ( 1
COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE TO WIT:
I, Margaret .Wright,A a Notary rublic in and for the County
aforesaid, in the State of virginia, hereby certify that A.Oaines Fray and
Lucy Lee Fray, his rife, whose names are signed to the foregoing writing,
bearing date the 1st day of October, 1948, have acknowledged the same before
me in my County aforesaid.
My commission expires the 27th day of January 1951.
Given under my hand this 26th day of October 1948.
Margaret K.Wright, Notary Public.
a
2° I
��.3pw is a t+ ; f
1' 31., V'`"� V'
r7 �y� \ i o
:i w ya a
cl
ol
CO \,.. yC i�
F A ° Sa So' •°L'\
�O ov
' 'iI,,s{'pro. v ° \ < 4? OmU"I �s IaMI j
,4_1/4 •t4y,7'4 ,g- -
i°b '� 2, 4 t ; J� o 1
__ '\ 'p
Iii, YO_�- �� .ltk •e\ R 3
tifr
F.
0or \ o c e �rnc� 8f"
0 /
ft-- 3 V:\1
m;u -,...
A~ •4y i. ,e
ttQ
47 .
►
/to \.4 �I 3°0
-�y,\ ,Rhh
., - _ I u
e2
FF r 1 : a FH : r. 19 2003 01:01PM P1
Att_ John Shepherd
Mgr. Zoning Administration
Palmer Varney Burch, our son, is authorized to handle all
of the official matters, applications and negotiate on our behalf
regarding our property: Advance Mills general store and I Fri old
mill site across the road.
We are extremely excited about being responsible members
of your community. As soon as possible, we look forward to
moving into our new space. We hope to enhance the spot and to
make you feel good about all of the work you have done on our
behalf.
Thnnk yni
411.3
Judith Varney Burch Dana DeWitt Burch Jr.
August 5, 2003
I\L V I V V "'L
in
ENGINEERED SEPTIC SYSTEM oo 0
42.25'x 64' in CN
N
-1—' x —
� O •—
PLAN NORTH m •�
- #
O
I4938 > O L
r
•
� Ia
6.5'
a
I1'-4.38" 5 �
CO 7
At
32'8" Li
-D U -
n`
s.
aap W O
4•11-
rV
t ' N 20'e , .
1 p (I
O� i
kg
LINE OF EXISTING BUILDING i,'e✓
(p.- R, .1;'
G Q ° C
NEW RESIDENCE aty 0
lO O
<
Q'
y3,
Q
?V
25' Z5\ /0 '‘tl(\44N7
`of
n .
SCALE 1" = 20'
DATE. 4-6-
PROPOSED RES�ENCE SCALE'
2600 ADVANCE MILLS ROAD DRAWN. TWN
CKERSVILLE,VA CHECKED•
TRUMP 20-15B-LOT 2 JOB NO
ALBEMARLE COUNTY
.928 ACRES
L11\D O
U
BURGH-PLAT-0104 DV
I I
I i
I i
I I I
I j
I I j
I I
I I
I I
i I
O II I
CI' I I
\ I 1000
I !ODD
g
I❑ ❑ ❑ I I
\\
C
O
I i
c
Y t v
] I
�7t _ "�.._ i I
v.
• I
C'F.
I i
o z c) z D ELEVATIONS Residence iv On t� v ' Z
o m •• FOR: DANA Sc JUDY BURCH P.O. Box 458 0
I, 13 I I I I>ItI c-'ni I-rl I c-Ir-r I Cann AA.,,,.,,.,, AAt11. D,.,.A I _ _ I 1 i I I
34'-8 9/16' ,
O
v \�
'
O
O
o
Z
O
m
r p
N
\ \\
- )>' \
\ \\
.f
h:.J \ \\
C
, 100-- i.
r
/ • plIl
e
N
A
/ J
-- ')
o
n
--1,--1-`'S-- _(\ c`r ,
Flo cr..), --..._
II 1 '.1
d
ill f
.. l (__, t.)
Mi
\ \\ n
4
C
`_ -
O /
oo --
z
m e O
>
r. r
o� co rn n D Residence IV on tl vy
Z R 1 m ELEVATIONS FOR: DANA & JUDY BURCH
P.O. Box 458
D w ---- - - - - - —
rcnnn A J ��•n_ n__�
s �,
\\\, 1l1IHlIiiil n �-S
. _ t, ..-1 7--
1/4-P,..4_, `" L ...
) 47- ,
za
\ \\ .j � —
\ \\ \\ -. -4_
C - �
›- '.
---N, . * i i ,
sc3 . . I . . . . . . . .
4_
7-r-
/
z n V T Residence M on tl vy
o o z NOLTION FOR: DANA & JUDY BURCH P.O. Box 458
IF,I r-r1 I 1414 1 I I 5600 Advance Mills Road I 1vv. Virainia 22945 I I I I ICI