Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001-09-05 ACTIONS Board of Supervisors Meeting of September 5, 2001 1. Call to order. AGENDA ITEM/ACTION 4. Other Matters not Listed on the Agenda from the Public. Ms. Thomas recognized the presence of a group of individuals from the Esmont Senior Center. Mr. Walter Johnson provided Board members with information on traffic calming measures. · Ms. Meredith Richards, Chairman of the Lewis & Clark Festival Committee, updated the Board on the progress of the Committee and the events that will be taking place. She requested a $1,000 match from the County (the City is funding $1,000) to help fund upcoming events (action taken at the end of the meeting on this request). Mr. David Blount, Legislative Uaison, TJPDC, provided an update on the process for preparing and developing the Planning District's legislative program for 2002. He hopes to have a draft program completed by the end of this month and forwarded to the Board for information in October. Presentation: Certificate of Appreciation. The Chairman presented a Certificate of Appreciation to Rudolph Bevedy for his service on the Architectural Review Board. 6.1 SP-2001..0t7. Merrie Meadows (Sign #~9) (deferred from August 15, 2001) · Deferred until September 19, 2001. 6.2 Proclamation recognizing October, 2001 as Disability Awareness Month. · Chairman read proclamation and presented same to Billie Campbell. 6.3 Proclamation recognizing October 6, 2001 as Albemarle County Farm Tour Day. · Chain-nan read proclamation and presented same to Marcia 6.4 Burning Daylight Farm Road Name Change Request. · Approved new road name as requested and granted staff the authority to coordinate/implement the change. '6~5 Installation of "Child at Play" Signs on Wren Court (Route' 1595) in Brian~ocl Subdivision. · Adopted the attached resolution supporting Child at Play · sign(s) on Wren Court. 6.6 Resolution to accept roads in Redfieids Subdivision, Phase 3B, into the State Secondary System of Highways. · Adopted the ~tt~ched resolution. September S, 200,!. ,A?~IGNMEN? Meeting was called to order at 9:00 a.m., by the Chairman. Ail BOS members present. Also present was Robert Tucker, Larry Davis, Wayne Cilimberg and Ella Carey. Clerk: Acknowledge comments for Chairman' s signature. Clerk: Include on September 19 agenda. Attachment 1) Attachment 2) Tex.Weaver. Coordinate/implement change as approved. Clerk: Forward signed resolution to Juandiego Wade, (Attachment 3) Clerk: Forward signed resolution to Glenn Brooks. (Attachment 4) 6.7 Resolution to accept roads in Still Meadow Subdivision, Phase 2, into the State Secondary System of Highways. · Ad_~p__~! the attached resolution. 6.8 Response to Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) Report on Virginia's funding of transportation improvement projects. · Approved letter (with modifications made by Mr. Bowerman and correction made by Ms. Humphris) to be forwarded to JLARC under Mr. Tuckers signet[~e. 6.9 Esmont Senior Center - community's request to maintain two- day Senior Meals Program. · Approved staff's recommendation to provide an additional $4,213 to JABA to cover the additional meal costs for an estimated 25 seniors per day.. 7. Transportation Matters. · Mr. Bowerman asked if there are any areas with 35 mph where traffic calming measures (mentioned by Mr. Johnson) can be applied. Mr. Bryan said he did not know, but striping might have an affecL Mr. Tucker suggested checking speed warrants in Carrsbrook to see if the speed limit can be reduced from 35 mph to 25 mph. · Mr. Bryan reported the following information: · VDOT has finally solved the drainage problem on Route 791, Wyant Lane, They now need to install a guard rail. · VDOT will focus this month on vehicle maintenance. He included this information in his monthly.report to the Board. · The final deck for the Route 29 bridge was completed on Fdday, August 31, so the end is in sight. · They are still working on Morgantown Road issues. · Ms. Thomas commented that Mr. Bryan handled very well a difficult meeting with the residents of Morgantown Road. She appreciated his response. She also thanked him for his handling of VVyant Lane. · Mr. Perkins asked VDOT to look mad conditions on Route 682, Browns Turnpike. There are no shoulders and in a lot of places the fence and brush are on the edge of the pavement. · Mr. Dorrier asked VDOT to improve the entire segment of Route 20 into Charlottesville. The improvements between Keene and ~iile were great. Mr. Bryan said VDOT plans to improve Route 20 incrementally. The improvements will probably be a part of next year's paving contract. He will see where this is scheduled and let Mr. Dottier know. · Ms.. Humphris said on page 5 of VDOT's September report, Mr, Bryan reported that there had been a 1999 O&D study for Route 22/231. The Board previously asked for this study but received a letter indicating that it would be considered. Mr. Bryan said he received a copy of the study from the Richmond . off.me. The information has been shared with County staff. · Ms. Thomas said there was a drainage problem on Kimbrough Circle and it has been resurfaced in a way that the road is very rough. Mr. Bryan said he will check into this. · Ms. Thomas said she has received reports that the intersection Clerk: Fomrard signed resolution to Glenn Brooks. (Attachment 5) Cler. k: Forward modifications to County Executive. (Attachment 6) Melvin Breeden/Bud(3et Off'me: Include appropriation to JABA for $4,213 as part of public headng on budget amendment for October 3. Ci.erk.: Include in transportation letter to Mr. Bryan. of Owensville and Garth Roads is a dangerous intersection. She asked if spot improvements or something can be done, Mr. Bryan said he will take a look. Mr. Perkins said the recent hard thunderstorm caused extensive erosion on a lot of the gravel roads. There is a lot of ruffing on Route 689. Response to Audit Committee -- Carry-over policy/maintenance equipment fund. Approved the creation of a "Fleet Management Fund" for the next fiscal year that will provide funds for repair, servicing and replacement on a set cycle for County vehicles. V~ith regard to the second recommendation concerning a written carry-over policy, the Board supported staff's recommendation that 100% of unbudgeted revenues and 60% of departmental expenditure savings (savings after all encumbered amounts are re-appropriated) go into the Fund Balance to meet required cash flow needs. Any funds over and above what is necessary to meet minimum cash flow requirements to go to the CiP Reserve Fund for future capital needs, repair and maintenance items and/or debt service. The Board did not support allocating the remaining 40% of departmental expenditure savings, but requested staff to look at various options for use of that 40% and bring back some comparisons to the Board. 9. Public Hearing on an Ordinance to amend Chapter 11, Parks and Recreation, of the Albemarle County Code, to allow designated Off-leash areas. · Adopted the attached ordinance. 10. Public Hearing on proposed FY 2001 budget amendments. ~- Approved. 11. Public Hearing on proposed FY 2002 budget amendments. · . Approved,. 12. Board to Board Presentation, Sclxx)l Board Chairman. · Steve Koleszar made presentation. Received as information. 13. Presentation: Land Use Taxation Program. · Board expressed general support with staff selecting and auditing about 25 parcels that are in the Program. Staff to look at costs involved to audit these parcels. Before proceeding with the audit, staff to notify the landowners, provide them with information on their property and inform them that the County is planning to do this audit. i4. Work Session: Water Supply Issues. · Held. (Note: Joint with City Council, RWSA and AC, SA scheduled for September 27, 2001, 7:00 p.m., at Monticello . High School.) .. 15. Work Session: CPA-98-03. Post Office Land Trust (Hollymead Town Center). · Held. Scheduled public hearing for October 10. 16. Cancel November 21, 2001 Board of Supervisors' meeting. · Canceled November 21, 2001 Board meeting. . 18. From the Board: Matters Not Listed on the Agenda. Budget Office: Proceed as directed. Clerk: Forward adopted ordinance to County Attorney's office for inclusion in next update of County Code, and provide copy to Parks & Recreation. (Attachment 7) Clerk: Forward signed appropriation forms to Melvin Breeden and copy. appropd .~e persons. Clerk: Forward signed appropriation forms to Melvin Breeden and copy appropriate persons. Melvin Breeder. B~ W. oodzel!: Provide Board with rnore inforrnation on how staff p~ to proceed (this can come back on the consent agenda), , Clerk: Advertise for public hearing. · Mr. Tucker recommended, and the Board approved, the appropriation of $1,000 from its Contingency Fund for the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Exchange. Mr. Tucker mentioned a letter he received from the Mayor of Scoffsville asking for help from the County with regard to their stormwater management needs in the town. He suggested staff take a broader look at this and other issues requested by the town. He will put together a team of staff members to look at other towns (what they are providing and what the county is providing) and then he would appoint a committee of Board members to look at what staff has found, discuss that and bdng back a recommendation to the Board. The Board concurred with Mr. Tuckers recommendation. Ms. Thomas asked staff to look into the planning of the final closure plan of the Landfill since that was in limbo awaiting the recreation request. The closure has to happen 120 days from August 31. · Ms. Thomas said she had asked the County Attorney to look at the wording of the County's litter law- the lose items escaping from trucks. She found that the State Code is more clearly stated than our County ordinance. She asked staff to communicate to the police about the State Code provision and the way it might be more enforceable than the local ordinance. It does not require a change to our local ordinance. · Ms. Thomas said on Friday, September 7, there will be a public hearing by the Federal Highway Administration on the transportation planning process that we do in this region. She and Ms. Humphds plan to attend. Ms. Thomas said Saturday, October 13 is the Lewis & Clark Festival. There will be a number of things going on, including a one hour program in the Lane Auditorium involving students from Clark Elementary School and Medwether Lewis, Elementary School, · Ms, Thomas suggested doing the same type of thing for Brian Carlson as was done for Treva Cromwell. · Ms, Thomas asked if staff has heard anything from Greene County regarding the sewage treatment plant near Preddy Creek. Mr. Tucker said the County has not received anything formally, but Greene County did make a decision consistent with what the Board had requested, · Ms, Thomas said she has been receiving phone calls from the Conservation Leaders Network about the Roadless Area Conservation Rule. She assumed that the County is not getting involved in that. · Ms. Thomas said the Italians are coming in March 2002. She asked if anyone was interested besides her. They will be putting together a planning committee. Mr. Dorrier indicated that he is interested. · Ms. Thomas said the Board has been invited by City Council to participate in a meeting on September 20, from 7:00 p.m. until 8:00 p.m., regarding their transportation plan. She asked if any. Board members plan to attend. Clerk: Include appropriation on consent agenda for September 12. Mr. Tucker: Proceed as indicated. Mark Graham: Provide information. Larry. Davis; Communicate information to Police Department. ~MS~ Thomas mentioned that the January 2, 2002 meeting follows a holiday (January 1). She asked if the Board wants to continue with that being their first meeting January. Consensus of Board to take a look at the schedule in December. 19. Closed Session: Personnel Matters. · At 1:05 p.m., the Board ~.wen..t into Closed Session. 20. Certify Closed Session. · The Board reconvened into Open Session at 3:46 p.m.. 21. Appointments. REAPPOINTED Christopher Lee, Craig G. Van De Castle and Sherry Buttrick, to the Public Recreational Facilities Authority, with new terms to run from 12/14/2001 until 12/13/2004. · REAPPOINTED Cynthia Dupree to the Rivanna Solid Waste Author'rty Citizens Advisory Committee, with new terms to run from 01/01/2001 until 12/31/2003. · APPOINTED Sherry Buttrick to the Agdcultural/Forestal Distdct Advisory Committee, to officially replace P. Scott Morrill (no term limits). · REAPPOINTED Raymond E. Gaines to the Board of Building Code Appeals, with new term to run from 11/22/2001 until 11/21/2006, · REAPPOINTED Joseph T. Samuels, Jr. and Ross L, Stevens to the Acquisition of Conservation Easements Appraisal Review Committee, with new terms to run from 01/0t/2002 until 12/31/2002. REAPPOINTED Joy F. Matthews to the Housing Committee, with new term to run from 01/01/2002 until 12/31/2004. · REAPPOINTED Dr. Leo Mallek to the Joint Airport Commission, with new term to run from 12/02/2001 until 12/01/2004. · APPOINTED Lowry Abell to the Historic Preservation Committee (no term limit). . . . 22. Adjourn. · The meeting was adjourned at 4:00 p.m. /ewc Attachment I - Disability Awareness Month Proclamation Attachment 2 - Albemarle County Farm Tour Day Proclamation Attachment 3 - Resolution: Child at Play Sign on Wren Court Attachment 4 - Resolution: Redfieids Subdivision, Phase 3B AttaChment 5 - Resolution: Still Meadow Subdivision Attachment 6 - JLARC letter Attachment 7 - Ordinance: Designation of off-leash areas Disability Awareness Month Attachment WHEREAS, every year since 1945 the President of the United States has proclaimed a National Observance in October to promote the employment of individuals with disabilities; and WHEREAS, nearly one in five Americans have some type of disability, making people with disabilities the nation's largest minority; and WHEREAS, our community needs to harness the potential of all of its citizens so that our economy can continue to grow and our labor force can meet the challenges on the hodz~; and WHEREAS, we recognize that disability is a natural part of the human experience and affirm that disability in no way should limit a person's ablTity to make choices, pursue meaningful careers, or participate fully in all aspects of life; and WHEREAS, all of us have benefited from the achievements and contributions of people with disabilities; and WHEREAS, attitudinal barders can hinder people with disabilities from realizing their full potential; and WHEREAS, education and public awareness are the most powerful tools for increasing sensitiVity and achieving full integration and inclusion of people with disabilities into all aspects of life; NOW, THEREFORE, t, Sally H. Thomas, Chairman, on behalf of the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors, do hereby proclaim October 2001 as DISABILITY AWARENESS MONTH in the County of Albemarle and call this observance to the attention of all our citizens. Adopted this 5th day of September 2001. ....... Chairman ............ Attachment 2 ALBEMARLE COUNTY FARM TOUR DAY OCTOBER 6, 2001 WHEREAS, the Comprehensive Plan gives highest priority to agriculture and forestry as a land use in the Rural Area; and WHEREAS, the citizens of Albemarle County in the 1994 Albemarle County, Planning Needs,Survey, rated "preserving natural resources and open space" and "preserving farm/and and forested land" as the fourth and fifth most important goals out of a series of aalenty. Frve broad goals for the future; and WHEREA~ Albernade County is among the top 27 counties in Virginia for market value of agricultural products sold; and WHEREAS, it is the land resoume which provides the true value of agriculture and forestry to this communi~, with related benefits of open space for cleaner air, watershed protec#on, and wildlife habitat, scenic, rural and historic landscapes which encourage tourism; and quality of life for all residents; and WHEREAS, maintaining agriculture and forestry also enables the County to grow at a measured and deliberate pace, and to better plan for services; and WHEREAS, the loss of the agricultural and forestal resource base would permanently damage the County's economic base and natural environment; and WHEREAS, the Agricultural and Forestal Industries Support Committee recommended that educational programs be developed for the public, such as: · improving both the County officials' and the generalpublic's understanding of agriculture; · promoting appreciation of the nJml area by the community, and emphasizing the importance of agricultural and forestal lands to them; · supporting agricultural education in the classroom, and implementing a farm day for school children; and · implementing an educational tour of County fanws for the general public, County officials and decision, making staff; and WHEREAS, the future of agriculture and forestry in Albemarle County depends on the actions of the farm and forest owners, but also on the support of elected officials and ob~r citizens; NOW, THEREFORE, I, Sally H. Thomas, Chairman, on behalf of the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors, do hereby proclaim October 6, 2001 as: ALBEMARLE COUNTY FARM TOUR DAY and commend the Albemarle Farm Bureau and the Piedmont Errvironmental Council for helping to educate the cib'zens about the importance of farming to our community. Chairman RESOLUTION Attachment 3 WHEREAS, the residents of Wren Court are concerned about traffic on their street and the potential hazard it creates for the numerous children that play in the subdivision; and WHEREAS, the residents believe that a "Child At Play" sign would help alleviate some their concerns; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors hereby supports the community's requests for VDOT to install the "Child At Play" sign(s) on Wren Court (1595). t, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of the Resolution duly adopted by the Board of County Supervisors of Albemarle County by a vote of six to z.er~ on September 5, 2001. Clerk, Board of Supen/isors Att~hment 4 The Board of CountY Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, in regular meeting on the 5th day of September, 2001, adopted the following resolution: RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the streets in Redfieids Subdivision, Phase 3B, described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 6, 2001, fully incorporated herein by reference, are shown on plats recorded in the Clerk's Off'me of the Circuit Court of Albemarle County, Virginia; and WHEREAS, the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation has advised the Board that the streats meet the requirements established by the Subdivi.sion .Street Requireff~.n~ of the Virginia Department of Transportation. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors requests the Virginia Department of Transportation to add the roads in Redfields Subdivision, Phase 3B, as described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 6, 2001, to the secondary system of state highways, pumuant to §33.1-229, Code of Virginia, and the Department's Subdivision stree{ Requirements; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Board guarantees a clear and unrestricted right-of-way, as ~ibed, exclusive of any necessary easements for cuts, fills and drainage as described on the recorded plats; and FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation. R.eco[.ded vote: Moved by: Mr. Bowerman Seconded by: Ms. Humphris Yeas: Mr. Bowerman, Mr. Dorder, Ms. Humphris, Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins and Ms. Thomas Nays: None A Copy Teste: Ella W, Carey, Clerk, cMo Board of County Supewisors The roads described on Additions Form SR-5(A) are: 1) Redflelds Road from the intersection of Route 1281, Swan Ridge Road, and Route 1280, Devon Spring Court, and Route 1270, Redfields Road (existing podion). (Station 31+00) end of Phase 3A dedication to the intersection of Nettle Court and Pebble Hill Court (Station 39+83.25), as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81; and plat recorded 3/23/01 in Deed Book 2003, pages 627-630, in the Office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-Of-way width, for a length of 0.167 mile, 2) Courtyard D .~v~e from the intersection of Pebble Hill Court (Station 17+25) edge of right- of-way of Pebble Hill Court, to the cul-de-sac (Station 10+05) end of cut-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit .Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.136 mile. Cou~¥ard Cou~t from the intersection of Courtyard Drive (Station 10+14) edge of pavement of Courtyard Drive, to the cul-de-sac (Station 13+25.2) end of cul-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the off'me the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0,059 mile. Pebble Hill Cou~t from the intersection of Route 1270, Redfields Road (Station 10+12) edge of pavement of Redfields Road, to the cul-de-sac (Station 17+87.38) end of cul-de- sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26199 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in tl'e office the Clerk of Cimuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0,147 mile. Ne~tle.lCou.rt from the intersection of Route 1270, Redfields Road (Station 10+12) edge of pavement of Redfields Road, to the cul-de-sac (Station 13+9Z89) end of cul-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26199 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot fight-of-way width, for a length of 0.072 mile. Total Mileage - 0.58 mile. Attachment 5 The ~ of County Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, in regular meeting on the 5th day of September, 2001, adopted the following resolution: RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the streets in Still Meadow Subdivision, Phase 2, described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 20, 2001, fully incorporated herein by reference, are shown on plats recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circu'rt Court of Albemarle County, Virginia; and WHEREAS, the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation has advised the Board that the streets meet the requirements established by the Subdivision Street Requirements of the. Virginia Department of Transportation. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Albemarle Board of County Supewisors requests the Virginia Department of Transportation to add the roads in Still Meadow Subdivision, Phase 2, as described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 20, 2001, to the secondary system of state highways, pursuant to {}33.1-229, Code of Virginia, and the Department's Subdivision Street Requirements; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Board guarantees a clear and unrestricted right-of-way, as described, exclusive of any necessmy easements for cuts, fills and drainage as described on the recorded plats; and FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation. Recorded .v. ote: Moved by: Mr. Bowerman Seconded by: Ms. Humphris Yeas: Mr. Bowerman, Mr. Deifier, Ms. Humphris, Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins and Ms. Thomas Nays: None A Copy Teste: 'Elia W. Carey, Clerk, CMC Board of County Supervisors 1] The roads described on Additions Form SR-5(A) are: 1) Still Meadow Avenue from the intersection of Route 1351, Still Meadow Crossing (Station 6+66) to the intersection of Route 1427, Northfields Road, and Route 1436, Northfields Circle (Station 25+50) as shown on plat recorded 3/9~00 in Deed Book 1899, pages 731-736; plat recorded 10/6/00 in Deed Book 1961, page 407; and plat recorded 10/19/00 in Deed Book 1962, page 582, in the Office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50~foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.357 mile. 2) Br.o, wnstone Lane from the intersection of Route 1350, Still MeadOw Avenue (Station 0+10) to the intersection of Route 1350, Still MeadOw Avenue (Station 17+00) as shown on plat recorded 3/9/00 in Deed Book 1899, pages 731-736; and plat recorded 10/19/00 in Deed Book 1962, page 582, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.320 mile. Total Mileage - 0.68 mite. September 10, 2001 Attachment 6 Mr. Philip A. Leone, Director Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission Suite 1 t 00, General Assembly Building Capitol Square Richmond, VA 23219 Dear Mr. Leone: We are in receipt of your letter of August 6, 2001 regarding the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission's revieW of the existing system for funding highway construction and mass transit in Virginia and your request for input from local governments regarding this matter. Albemarle County would like to take this opportunity to provide the following comments. The County strongly believes that any transportation funding shortfalls at the state level should not be made up by counties, which already have limited revenue-producing sources. Transport~ion funding has traditionally been a primary responsibility of the state and enabling legislation already leaves counties with limited revenue alternatives to mee{ existing local obligations. Further obligation for transportation funding without significantly increased revenue producing allowances would pose an unreasonable burden on counties. Albemarle County supports the creation of a new funding classification and new street standards for the urbanized areas of counties such as Albemarle. The existing secondary system provides neither the funding nor the flexibility to meet the County's urban transportation needs. Such a new category should provide counties both a new funding source and more options for planning and designing transportation systems in support of urban land use planning priorities. Finally, Albemarle County would like more flexibility in utilizing VDOT's traffic calming program. VDOT's current guidelines do not allow their intelligent application and are too restrictive to be implemented in most cases in Albemarle. While funding has existed in the County's secondary road plan for traffic calming in recent years, the projects the County has proposed to VDOT, all of which involve neighborhood streets, have been determined not to meet VDOT's program guidelines. The County stands prepared to assist in further identifying solutions to these concerns. Please feel free to contact Wayne Cilimberg, Director of Planning and Community Development, at (434) 296-5823 to further discuss. Your consideration of these points is greatly appreciated. Sincerely, Robert W. Tucker, ,Jr. County Executive 13 Attachment 7 ORDINANCE NO. 01-11(1) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 11, PARKS AND RECREATION FACiUTIES, ARTICLE I, IN GENERAL, DIVISION 3, CONDUCT WITHIN AND USE OF PARKS, OF THE CODE OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervisors of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, that Chapter 11, Parks and Recreation Facilities, Article I, In General, Division 3, Conduct Within and Use of Parks, is hereby amended and reordained as follows: By Amending: Sec. 11-120 Pets. Chapter 11. Parks and Recreation Facilities Sec, 11.120 Pets. Division 3. Article I. In General Conduct Within and Use of Parks Ali pets shall be kept on a leash and under control while on park lands except in designated areas clearly identified by authorized signs allowing pets not to be leashed. (9-12-79; Code 1988, § 14-6.14; Ord. 98-A(1), 8-5-98; Ord. 01-11(1), 9-6-01) I, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of an Ordinance duly adopted by the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, by a vote of six to zero, as recorded below, at a regular meeting held on September 5, 2001. Aye Nay Mr. Bowerman Y. Mr. Dorrier Y Ms. Humphds ~ Mr. Martin Y.. . Mr. Perkins Y Ms. Thomas Y. Clerk, Board of County Supewisors ]4 I:rom-T;:; ?l~FF:l(: ~-lgure B-2. SPEED HUMP .! :PLA~ V]E'W -- '~00' Advar<~ Wam~g Marldngs <~ EDGE DETAIL TRAFFIC I · I T-SZ4 P. 0~3/0~4 F-141 ~ _ 3_50"+ 1 J SPEED HUMP PROFIL~ -'- MILL &"'REblOVE PAVEMENT 2=MTN; PRIOR TO INSTALLING 12~APER-- 0.283- 3.40 0.O -- 0.0 DIMENSION CHART SEE AP, pROAC, H ARC DETAIL VERTICAL DIMENSION CHART NOT TO ~ I I I I III I I I I I FLATTOP PROF/LE SPEED HUMP II I II II I I _ I I II ARLINGTON COUNTY, VIRGINIA - DEPARTMENT ~:',_,, PU:~,..,LI,,..''' W"'RK SECTION A'~ :='"'="~ .................... ~-" i' \ SECT/ON BBB ~ ~r~~ Memo To: From.. Date: Re: Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Meredith Richards, Charlottesville City Council 9/5/01 "Twin Communties" visit to our area The Lewis & Clark Bicentennial and the 'q'win Communities" Relationship The cities of Charlottesville and Long Beach, Washington and Counties of Albemarle and Pacific County, Washington, have entered into "Twin Community" relationships for the 2003- 2006 Lewis & Clark National Bicentennial. Our unique positions as the places that anchor the Easternmost beginning and the Westemmost end of this historic Amedcan adventure put us in an ideal situation for educating the nation about Thomas Jefferson's role as the author of the Lewis & Clark expedition, and about the Charlottesville area's role as the place where it began in concept, planning, preparation, and leadership. The Lewis & Clark Bicentennial is shaping up as a great opportunity for the Charlottesville area to gain national attention and to increase its attraction as a heritage tourism destination. The Bicentennial will begin at Monticello on January 18, 2003, the day two hundred years ago when Thomas Jefferson penned a letter to Congress requesting $2500 funding for the expedition. For Charlottesville-Albemarle and the Long Beach Peninsula, the "Twin Communities" concept captures the imagination, as two contemporary communities - one on the East Coast and one on the West Coast - discover their unique bond in the history of this momentous journey. First Exchange begins on September 14, 200t The first official exchange of this "Hands Across the Continent" relationship for the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial begins Friday, September 14 at Ashlawn Highland, where we will welcome a delegation of visitors from Pacific County and Long Beach, Washington. It will be marked by a ceremony at which East and West elected officials¢ tourism officials, school officials, Lewis & Clark historical groups, Native American tribal representatives, and Congressmen meet and greet one another as a symbol of our emerging relationship for the Bicentennial. James Monroe, who negotiated the Louisiana Purchase, which opened the West to exploration and commerce and made the Lewis & Clark expedition possible, will also be in attendance. Later in the evening, Long Beach resident and nationally-recognized Lewis & Clark historian Rex Ziak, will present an entertaining chronicle of Lewis & Clark's arrival at the Pacific Ocean and the 18 days the Corps of Discovery spent on the Long Beach Peninsula. Our visitors from Washington State will be treated to tours of Monticello, UVA, and Lewis & Clark sites throughout the area. A Virginia barbeque will be held at George Rogers Clark's home of Buena Vista. There will be a workshop at which future plans for school, historical botanical and cultural exchanges during the Bicentennial will be discussed. Request for matching funding of $1000 for East-West exchange The City of Charlottesville is contributing $1000 and the Charlottesville-Albemarle Convention and Visitors Bureau is contributing $1500 toward the expenses of hosting our Twin Communities delegation. I am asking the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors to contribute a matching sum of $1000. The total budget for these events is $3500, which includes the cost of a reception, buffet and public program at Ashlawn Highland on September 14, bus tours on September 15 and 16, barbeque at Buena Vista on September 16, and breakfast meeting expenses on September 17. I trust that you have already received your letters of invitation to these events. Please come and represent Albemarle County in this unique and stimulating East-West exchange for the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial. · Page 2 DISABILITY AWARENESS MONTH WHEREAS, every year since 1945 the President of the United States has proclaimed a National Observance in October to promote the employment of individuuls ~vith disabilities; and WHEREAS, nearly one in free Americans have some ~ype of disability, making people ~vith disabilities the nation's largest minority; and ]4rI-J~REAS, our communify needs to harness the potential of all of its citizens so that our economy can continue to gnnv and our labor force can mea the challenges on the horizon; and WIq~, ~ve recognize that disability is a natural part of the human experience and a~rm that disabili~ in no ~vay should limit a person's ability to make choices, pursue meaningful careers, or participate fully in all aspects of life; and Wt-~~, all of us have benefited from the achievements and contributions of people ~vith disabilities; and WHE~, attitudinal barriers can hinder people with disabilities from realizing their full potential; and ~, education and public a~areness are the most po~verful tools for increasing sensitivity and achieving full integration and inclusion of people ~ith disabilities into all aspects of life; NOW, Ti-1EREFORE, L Sally H. Thomas, Chairman, on behalf of the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors, do hereby proclaim October 2001 as DISABILITY AWARENESS MONTH in the County of_Albemarle and call this observance to the attention of all our citizens. Adopted this 5th day of September 2001. Chairman ALB~ COUNTY FARM TOUR DAY OCTOBER 6, 2001 WHF. REAS, the Comprehensive Plan gives highest priority to agriculture and forestry as a land use in the Rural Area; and WI4~. ~RFAS, the citizens of Albemarle County in the 1994 Albemarle Coun~ Planning Needs Sure_er rated "preserving natural resources and open space" and. "preserving farmland and forested land" as the fourth and fifth most important goals out of a series of twenfy-five broad goals for the future; and I4rHEREAS, Albemarle Coun~ is among the top 27 counties in Virginia for market value of agricultural products sold; and it is the land resource vehich provides the true value of agriculture and forestry to this community, n, ith related benefits of open space for cleaner air, ~vatershed protection, and ~ildl~ habitat, scenic, rural and historic landscapes ~vhich encourage tourism; and quali~y of life for all residents; and maintaining agriculture and forestry also enables the County to gro~v at a measured and deliberate pace, and to better plan for services; and WHF2ZEA~, the loss of the agricultural and forestal resource base nvuld pemmnently damage the County's economic base and natural environment; and the Agricultural and Forestal Industries Support Committee recommended that educational programs be developed for the public, such as: improving both the Counfy officials' and the general public's understanding of agriculture; promoting appreciation of the rural area by the communify, and emphasizing the importance of agricultural and forestal lands to them; supporting agricultural education in the classroom, and implementing a farm day for school children; and implementing an educational tour of Counfy farms for the general public, Courtly officials and decision-making staff, and WHEREAS, the furore of agricMture and forestry in Albemarle Counfy depends on the ~,ons of the farm and forest oveners, but also on the support of elected odTtcials and other citizens; NOW, TttEREFORE, L Sally H. Thomas, Chairman, on behalf of the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors, do hereby proclaim October 6, 2001 as: ALBEMARLE COUNTY FARbl TOUR DAY and commend the Albemarle Farm Bureau and the Piedmont Environmental Council for helping to educate the citizens about the importance of farming to our community. Chairman COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .AGENDA TITLE: Burning Daylight Farm Road Name Change SU BJ ECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Road Name Change Request STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Foley, Cilimberg, Weaver AGEN DA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: X ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: BACKGROUND: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Pursuant to Part I, Section 6 (e) of the Albemarle County Road Naming and Property Numbering Manual, road name change requests may be forwarded to the Board of Supervisors for approval upon validation of the following: Landowners of more than fifty (50) percent of the parcels served by the road in question have signed a petition in favor of a common road name, and that the proposed road name is otherwise consistent with other road name guidelines (not a duplicate name, etc.) outlined in the Man ual. DISCUSSION: Request to change the name of Burning Daylight Farm to C S Farm at the request of the landowner (see attached letter). A map indicating the location of this road is also attached. The property owner will be responsible for costs associated with new signage. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the new road name as requested and grant staff the authority to coordinate/implement the above referenced change. 01.157 08-29-01 P03:37 IN Mr. Patrick Powell County of Albemarle Planning and Community Development 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Va. 22902 June 15, 2001 Dear Mr. Powell In an effort to establish a new address for Chapel Springs Farm located on Wesley Chapel Road, I would like to propose changing the identifying road sign fi:om Burning Daylight Farm to C S Farnz If you require any further information please contact my manager Dale Holly at 975-9913. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, Halsey Minor COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Wren Court (Rt. 1595) Child At Play SUBJ ECT/PROPOSAL/REQU EST: Request to install Child At Play sign(s)on Wren Court (Rt. 1595) STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Foley,Cilimberg,Benish,Wade AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: Yes ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: BACKGROUND: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Yes The residents of Wren Court in the Briarwood Subdivision have petitioned the County to request Virginia Department of Transportation to install a Child At Play sign(s) on Wren Court (Route 1595). This request requires a resolution of support from the Board of Supervisors. The Briarwood subdivision is located in the Piney Mountain Development Area. DISCUSSION: 1. "Child At Play" signs shall only be considered on secondary roads. The residents have requested the sign to be located on Wren Court (Route 1595). Wren Court is a secondary road located in Briarwood subdivision, 2. The request must come from a Homeowner's Association where applicable. Staff has received a petition from the residents of Wren Court. (attached) There must be child activity attraction nearby for the sign to be considered. There are no sidewalks on Wren Court; hence the children have to walk in the street to reach other home and the playground. The playground is located at the intersection of Wren Court and Austin Drive (Route 1575). Staff considers Wren Court an appropriate location for a "Child At Play" sign. The installation of the sign shall not conflict with any existin,q traffic control device-~. The proposed location of the sign will not conflict with any existing traffic control devices. Staff will work with VDOT to determine the exact location for the sign. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the Board of Supervisors endorse a resolution supporting a Child At Play sign on Wren Court. 01.160 08-29-01 P03:3~ IN RESOLUTION WHEREAS, The residents of Wren Court are concerned about traffic on their street and the potential hazard it creates for the numerous children that play in the subdivision; and WHEREAS, The residents believe that a "Child At Play" sign would help alleviate some their concerns; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors hereby supports the community's requests for VDOT to install the "Child At Play" sign(s) on Wren Court (1595). I, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of the Resolution duly adopted by the Board of County Supervisors Of Albemarle County by a vote of on September 5, 2001. Clerk, Board of Supervisors July 17, 2001 RECeiVED ~, ue~q~e ,.~ountv n r~oard of Supervisors 401 Mc!ntire R.~..d,,- Charlottesville, Virginia 22901 Dear Supervisors: r L,~'4,,1, -, k~ ACd C COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT The residents of Wren Court are requesting that a street sign stating "Slow Down, t~nere are fourteen (i4) four story houses on Wren Court that do not have backyards or yard space to accommodate the children who live in these houses. I understand United Land is planning to build more of these houses on Wren Court and Route 606. That is too bad ,because we are already overcrowded with automobiles and have no place for our children to play. Instead of more houses, we would like to have another play~ound for our children...is this possible? Xx/~ thank ,~,,, we will be happy to meet with you. Sincerely, Kesiaents of Wren Court c/o Doris Fair 4745 Wren Court Charlottesville, Virginia 229 cc: Briarwood Neighborhood Group Mr. Juang Diego ........w aae, uept. of Plarming Enclosure: (Petition to Bd. of Supersivors) 07-26-01 A08:54 July 07, 2001 Dear Wren Court Neighbors: This is a petition requiring your signature and thereby supporting a request to Albemarle County Supervisors to install a "CItILDREN AT PLAY" sign on WREN COURT. We, the undersigned residents of Wren Court, request that you authorize the County of Albemarle to ,install signs on the street of Wren Court stating "Slow Down, Children-at-Play". We have a lot of children on Wren Court and they have no place to play except in the street. Therefore, we are asking that you look into this serious matter as soon as possible...Thank YOU! PLEASE READ THE ATTACHED LETTER THAT WAS SENT TO VDOT. -! The Board of County Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, in regular meeting on the 5th day of September, 2001, adopted the following resolution: RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the streets in Redfields Subdivision, Phase 3B, described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 6, 2001, fully incorporated herein by reference, are shown on plats recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of Albemarle County, Virginia; and WHEREAS, the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation has advised the Board that the streets meet the requirements established by the Subdivision Street Requirements of the Virginia Department of Transportation. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors requests the Virginia Department of Transportation to add the roads in Redfields Subdivision, Phase 3B, as described on the attachedAddifions Form SR-5(A) dated August 6, 200t, to the secondary system of state highways, pursuant to {}33.1-229, Code of Virginia, and the Department's Subdivision Street Requirements; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Board guarantees a clear and unrestricted right-of- way, as described, exclusive of any necessary easements for cuts, fills and drainage as described on the recorded plats; and FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation. Recorded vote: Moved by: Seconded by: Yeas: Nays: A Copy Teste: Ella W. Carey, Clerk, CMC Board of County Supervisors The roads described on Additions Form SR-5(A) are: 1) Redrtelds Road from the intersection of Route 1281, Swan Ridge Road, and Route 1280, Devon Spdng Court, and Route 1270, Redfieids Road (existing portion) (Station 31+00) end of Phase 3A dedication to the intersection of Nettle Court and Pebble Hill Court (Station 39+83.25), as shown on plat recorded 5~26~99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81; and plat recorded 3/23/01 in Deed Book 2003, pages 627-630, in the Office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.167 mile. 2) Courtyard Drive from the intersection of Pebble Hill Court (Station 17+25) edge of right-of-way of Pebble Hill Court, to the cul-de-sac (Station 10+05) end of cul-de- sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.136 mile. 3) Courtyard Court from the intersection of Courtyard Drive (Station 10+14) edge of pavement of Courtyard Drive, to the cul-de-sac (Station 13+25.2) end of cul-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of, way width, for a length of 0.059 mile. 4) pebble Hill Court from the intersection of Route 1270, Redfields Road (Station 10+ 12) edge of pavement of Redfields Road, to the cul-de-sac (Station 17+87.38) end of cul-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5~26~99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, fora length of 0.147 mile. 5) Nettle Court from the intersection of Route 1270, Redfields Road (Station 10+12) edge of Pavement of Redfields Road, to the cul-de-sac (Station 13+92.89) end of cul-de-sac, as shown on plat recorded 5/26/99 in Deed Book 1819, pages 73-81, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of- way width, for a length of 0.072 mile. Total Mileage - 0.58 mile. o la, la. 0 -I The Board of County Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, in regular meeting on the 5th day of September, 2001, adopted the following resolution: RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the streets in Still Meadow Subdivision, Phase 2, described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 20, 2001, fully incorporated herein by reference, are shown on plats recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of Albemarle County, Virginia; and WHEREAS, the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation has advised the Board that the streets meet the requirements established by the Subdivision Str. ee.t Requiremen~ of the Virginia Department of Transportation. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors requests the Virginia Department of Transportation to add the roads in Still Meadow Subdivision, Phase 2, as described on the attached Additions Form SR-5(A) dated August 20, 2001, to the secondary system of state highways, pursuant to §33.1-229, Code of Virginia, and the Department's .Subdivision Street Requirements; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Board guarantees a clear and unrestricted right-of- way, as described, exclusive of any necessary easements for cuts, fills and drainage as described on the recorded plats; and FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Resident Engineer for the Virginia Department of Transportation. Recorded ,vote: Moved by: Seconded by: Yeas: Nays: A Copy Teste: Ella W. Carey, Clerk, CMc Board of County Supervisors The roads described on Additions Form SR-5(A) are: 1) .Still Meadow Avenue from the intersection of Route 1351, Still Meadow Crossing (Station 6+66) to the intersection of Route 1427, Northfields Road, and Route 1436, Northfields Circle (Station 25+50) as shown on plat record.ed 3~9~00 in Deed Book 1899, pages 731-736; plat recorded 10/6/00 in Deed Book 1961, page 407; and plat recorded 10/19/00 in Deed Book 1962, page 582, in the Office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.357 mile. 2) Bro,wnstone Lane from the intersection of Route 1350, Still Meadow Avenue (Station 0+10) to the intersection of Route 1350, Still Meadow Avenue (Station 17+00) as shown on plat recorded 3/9/00 in Deed Book 1899, pages 731-736; and plat recorded 10/19/00 in Deed Book 1962, page 582, in the office the Clerk of Circuit Court of Albemarle County, with a 50-foot right-of-way width, for a length of 0.320 mile. Total Mileage - 0.68 mile. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Office of County Executive 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-$841 FAX (804) 296-5800 September 10, 2001 Mr. Philip A. Leone, Director. Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission Suite 1 I00, General Assembly Building Capitol Square Richmond, VA 23219 Dear Mr. Leone: We are in receipt of your letter of August 6, 2001 regarding the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission's review of the existing system for funding highway construction and mass transit in Virginia and your request for input from local governments regarding this matter. Albemarle County would like to take this opporttm/ty to provide the following comments. The County strongly believes that any transportation funding shortfalls at the state level should not be made up by counties, which akeady have limited revenue-producing sources. Transportation funding has traditionally been a pr/mary responsibility of the state and enabling legislation akeady leaves counties with limited revenue alternatives to meet existing local obligations. Further obligation for transportation funding without significantly increased revenue producing allowances would pose an unreasonable burden on counties. Albemarle County supports the creation of a new funding classification and new street standards for the urbanized areas of counties such as Albemarle. The existing secondary system provides neither the funding nor the flexibility to meet the County's urban transportation needs. Such a new category should provide counties both a new funding source and more options for planning and designing transportation systems in support of urban land use planning priorities. Finally, Albemarle County would like more flexibility in utilizing VDOT's traffic calming program. VDOT's current guidelines do not allow their intelligent, application and are too restrictive to be implemented in most cases in Albemarle. While funding has existed in the County's secondary road plan for traffic calming in recent years, the projects the County has proposed to VDOT, all of which involve neighborhood streets, have been determined not to meet VDOT's program guidelines. The County stands prepared to assist in further identifying solutions to these concerns. Please feel free to contact Wayne Cilimberg, Director of Planning and Community Development, at (434) 296-5823 to further discuss. Your consideration of these points is greatly appreciated. RWT,~ 01.052 /R_obert W. Tucker, Jr. otmty Executive COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMAR¥- o-o AGENDA TITLE: Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) Response Letter SUBJ ECT/PROPOSAUREQU EST: Board of Supervisor endorsement of comments to JLARC on equity and efficiency of Virginia's current approach toward financing transportation improvement projects STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs.,Tucker, Foley,Cilimberg,Benish,Wade AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENTAGENDA: ACTION: X ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Yes BACKGROUND: The Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) sent to all chief county administrative officers and board chairs a letter asking county officials to provide comments pertaining to a study they are now conducting on the equity and efficiency of Virginia's current approach toward financing transportation improvement projects. On August 15, 2001, the Board of Supervisors directed staff to draft comments in response to this letter. Issues to be included in the letter: ensuring that counties do not h ave to make up a growing VDOT transportation funding deficit; requesting that another funding category be added for urban roads in counties, such as the southern connector; and, easier utilization of traffic calming measures. DISCUSSION: Staff has prepared a draft letter which provides County comments for the Board of Supervisors' review and approval. JLARC is anticipated to release the findings from this study in November. RECOMMENDATIONS: Staff recommends that the Board of Supervisors review the attached letter for any additions and/or modifications and forward it to JLARC under Mr. Tucker's signature. 01.159 DRAFT August 24, 2001 rvlr. Philip A. Leone, Director .Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission Suite 1100, General Assembly Building Capitol Square Richmond, VA 23219 Dear Mr. Leone: We are in receipt of your letter of August 6, 2001 regarding the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission's review of the existing system for funding highway construction and mass transit in Virginia and your request for input from local ~overnments regarding this matter. Albemarle County would like to take this opportunity to provide the following comments. The county strongly believes that any transportation funding short-falls at the state level should not be made up by counties, which already have limited revenue producing sources. Transportation funding has traditionally been a primary responsibility of the state and enabling legislation already leaves counties with limited revenue alternatives to meet existing local obligations. Further obligation for transportation funding without significantly increased revenue producing allowances would pose an undue burden on counties. Albemarle County supports the creation of a new funding classification and new street standards for the urbanized areas of counties such as Albemarle's. The existing secondary system provides neither the fun ding nor the flexibility to meet the county's urban transportation needs. Such a new category should provide counties both a new funding source and more options for planning and designing transportation systems in support of urban land use planning priorities. Finally, Albemarle County would like more flexibility in utilizing VDOT's traffic calming program. VDOT's current guidelines, especially as regards limitations on the types of streets that can be traffic calmed, are too restrictive to be implemented in most cases in Albemarle. While funding has existed in the county's secondary road plan for traffic calming in recent years, the projects the county has proposed to VDOT, all of which involve neighborhood streets, have been determined not to meet VDOT's program guidelines. The County stands prepared to assist in further identifying solutions to these concerns. Please feel free to contact Wayne Cilimberg, Director of Planning and Community Development, at 434-296-5823 to further discuss. Your consideration of these points is greatly appreciated. Sincerely, RWT, Jr\ 01.052 Robert W. Tucker, .Ir. County Executive Philip A. Leone Director COMMONWEALTH of VIRGINIA Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission Suite 1100, General Assembly Building, Capitol Square Richmond, Virginia 23219 (804.) 786-1258 August 6, 2001 Mr. Robert W. Tucker County Executive Albemarle County 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Tucker: The Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) has directed JLARC staff to review the existing system for funding highway construction and mass transit. The current system for the allocation of highway construction funds is based on a study conducted by JLARC staff in cooperation with the Virginia Department of Transportation almost 20 years ago. Modifications based on the JLARC study were made to the allocation formulas in 1985, and the formulas have remained unchanged since that time. A study team was assembled in February and is currently conducting this funding study. November 13, 2001 has been set as the tentative date for completion of the study and the presentation of the study findings to the Commission. As part of this study, we are interested in receiving input from local governments regarding transportation funding in the State. In coordination with the Virginia Municipal League and the Virginia Association of Counties, we have already conducted two panel discussions with selected members of both organizations to discuss transportation funding in Virginia. As a further effort to receive local input, by this letter we are inviting counties, cities, and towns to submit written comments regarding transportation funding. You may submit comments on any issues pertaining to transportation funding. Some of the issues that you may want to comment on include: Use of a needs-based system for the allocation of highway construction funds Factors which could be used in funding formulas to reflect transportation n~e~s --:' US'e of th:e' p~i~a'r~' seconda'~'Y,:and urba~:~a~:cl~s'ifi~t~ syst'em f6'~ the'aiiocat'±0n~_0f'.~C0ns~ructi6n funds · . Allocat&0n.o~ f:uDding-among and-within road..:s~.tems · Needfo~ separate bridge and unpaved road funds Mr. Robert W. Tucker Augus5 6, 2001 Page Two · Virginia Transportation Act and funding for high cost, high priority projects · Transit funding You may send any comments to Hal Greet at either of the following addresses: Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission Suite 1100, General Assembly Huilding Capitol Square Hickanond, VA 23219 or H~reer91eg.state.va.us We would appreciate receiving your comments by September 7, 2001. In the meantime, if you have any questions about the study or this request for comments, you may contact Hal ~reer at (804) 819-4572 or at the above e-mail address. Sincerely, Philip A. Leone Director PAL:bct cc: The Honorable Sally H. Thomas, Chairman Board of Supervisors COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY -o ?o3:54 IN AGENDA TITLE: Esmont Senior Center SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Response to community's request to maintain two-day Senior Meals Program in Esmont STAFF CONTACT(S): Mr. Tucker, Ms. White AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: ACTION: × INFORMATION: ATTACHMENTS: Yes BACKGROUND: Several Esmont Comm unity members came to the August 1st Board meeting requesting the Board's assistance in continuing the two-day a week Senior Center Nutrition program in Esmont. The Jefferson Board of Aging had communicated to the Esmont seniors that the current congregate meals program would be reduced from two days a week to one day a week due to increased costs and Iow attendance. The following discussion and recommendation is based on several discussion s since that time between JABA and the community and JABA and County Executive staff. DISCUSSION: Attached is a letter from Debbie Foreman, JABA Senior Program Coordinator, which provides some background behind JABA's decision to reduce the Esmont program from two days per week to one. In that letter, JABA basically states that the Esmont'Senior Meals program has become increasingly expensive to run in light of the lower than average attendance. Although JABA felt that they had communicated the need for increased attendance to the community some time ago, the community seemed to be unaware that the derision had been made to cut back on the number of days if attendance did not increase. JABA's budget proposal to the County did not include funding for the second day, although JABA did not make that clear to the County in their budget request. Current average daily attendance is approximately 20 persons, while the average daily attendance for other centers is approximately 30 persons. Without increased attendance, JABA' states that the cost per person is too high and that resources must be directed to those centers with the greatest need. JABA states that it would need an additional $6,326 from the County to cover costs for a two day program with 30 participants. RECOMMENDATION: For several reasons, it does not seem to be the appropriate time to reduce the number of senior days at Esmont. First, the Esmont community did not seem to be aware that a major effort on their part was needed to increase attendance and ensure wider participation of other seniors living in and around the Esmont community. Second, the County was not made aware that funding for the second day at Esmont was not included in the FY02 budget request. Third, AHIP is preparing to rehabilitate the Esmont Ward Center with expanded kitchen facilities, so that it can be used as the new Senior Center location instead of the current site at New Green Mountain Baptist Church. The proposed rehabilitation has been a collaborative effort between the County, AHIP, JABA and the Ward Center using the County's CDBG admin funds, JABA funding and other community contributions. With this new expanded site coming on line this fiscal year, it does not seem to be the time to reduce the number of days AGENDA TITLE: Esmont Senior Center AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 for the Senior Center. Rather, it seems to be the time to encourage other seniors to come to the newly expanded site and bring attendance up to the needed average of 30 persons. Fourth, there may be some transportation issues that can be worked out with JAUNT that will help increase participation. Since JABA has indicated that it would need additional funding to maintain 2 days a week, staff recommends that the County provide an additional $4,213 to JABA to cover the additional meal costs for an estimated 25 seniors per day. Although this does not fully fund 30 seniors as JABA requested, it does anticipate that attendance will increase over the next year from the current 20 persons to 30, or an average of 25 for the year. Should the Board be willing to provide these interim funds to maintain the two-day per week program, it is expected that the Esmont Senior Center Advisory Council with assistance from both JABA and JAUNT staff will take the following actions during this current fiscal year: · Increase attendance to an average daily attendance of 30 persons by opening up the current Esmont Senior Center program to other seniors through an extensive outreach effort; · Use the newly expanded Ward Center to promote the senior meals program and attract new members to the Esmont program; · Revisit the idea of soliciting volunteer assistance to manage the program, a cost cutting solution that has worked for several other centers. If approved in concept by the Board, an appropriation to JABA for $4,213 will be brought before the Board at the October 3rd meeting for approval. 01.166 COUNTY OF ALBE~J~AR~ OFFICE Jefferson Area Board for Aging Services for Senior Ileallb and Independence MEMORANDUM TO: CC: FROM: SUBJECT: DATE: Esmont Senior Center Advisory Coul Lindsay Dorrier, Dr. Horace Rice, I Waltine Eubanks, Mark Reisler, Ed Jones, Sandy Wilcox, Will Harvey, Gene Smith, Nancy Luck, Lida Hurst and Gordon Walker Debbie Foreman Information for Discussion on Center Future August 2, 2001 This is in response to requests for information raised at our July 25 meeting and to issues covered in your July 29 memo to Gordon Walker. Hopefully, this will help prepare for our Tuesday, August 7 meeting with the Advisory Council of the Esmont Senior Center. As stated in Lida Hurst's e-mail the day after our July 25 meeting, JABA believes that our joint objectives should be to: 1) Improve communications; 2) Evaluate how well the Center is doing and make recommendations for improvements; 3) Examine the implications of the budget situation for the fiscal year beginning October 1; 4) Develop, as part of the process, a plan for recruitment and retention of more seniors at the Center; and 5) as attendance increases, advocate for additional funding when appropriate. We have no intention to phase out Esmont in favor of Scottsville. Back.qround - Our funding sources require us to emphasize "outcome measures" for evaluating performance. This means that we are asked to evaluate senior centers in terms of attendance, services to improve quality of life and other factors. In response to our funding sources, JABA initiated a process several years ago to develop an approach that would' enable staff to gather information and compare results for all our senior centers. This process involved senior center staff, aging services coOrdinators, JABA Board members and clients from different sites. What resulted is the monitoring tool sometimes referred to as the "re port card," a copy of which is attached. We began using this form in the fall of 1998. All senior centers collect monthly information relatedto this form and have a review every six months to evaluate progress. Every year each senior center staff reviews their results and goals are established for the next year. This information is intended to be reviewed with participants at each senior centeri Information from these reports is used to identify areas where improvements are needed, and during budget planning to help determine how we can most efficiently and effectively use JABA's limited resources. Comparative Information - When we look at quality issues on the monitoring form, Esmont compares favorably with our other ten senior centers. This is particularly true with respect to client satisfaction, where results for the last two years put Esmont's numbers at 98% and 96%. Certainly, this performance level is to be commended. It is in the area of census, however, that the problem arises. Basically, the number of clients served and the direct impact on cost per client, are very significant factors in budget decisions. Esmont's performance in this area has been significantly below average for some time. For the past several years, Esmont's attendance has been running at only about 60% of the average for similar centers. Over the same period, Esmont's daily costs per client served have been about 50% higher than the others. Simply put, Iow comparative attendance means high cost per senior. While a good argument can be made that there are few options for the elderly in the Esmont area other than senior center participation, this would seem to lead to the conclusion that many more would be attending the center, which at present is not happening. Most importantly, JABA staff continues to be committed to increasing attendance, but has realized for a long time that this cannot happen without extensive community involvement. It is hoped that the availability of new Ward Center will help in that regard. Implications - As part of JABA's look at attendance and costs during the recent budget process, decisions were made regarding several senior centers. You are likely aware that the Keswick site is now being operated by volunteers and administered by Union RUn Baptist Church. Two sites in Nelson County also will be volunteer managed. Given our understanding that the Esmont community is opposed to relying on volunteer management, the decision was to maintain paid staff, but to limit operations to one day a week. Costs for Second Day - JABA has invested more in the Esmont Senior Center in the past three fiscal years than in six other comparable centers. You asked about the cost for reinstating a second day at the Esmont. With respect to the upcoming fiscal year beginning October 1, JABA had planned to spend about $15,000 for one day of operation a week. This is in addition to the approximately $20,000 budgeted at Esmont for the Home Delivered Meals program, plus expenditures of another $3,000 for services related to disease prevention and health promotion. In order to goto two days, the most significant cost increases would be in the areas of senior center meals and staff. Itis estimated that it would cost approximately $6,[:)00 to add a second day at the present attendance level. To operate at an average daily attendance of 30 clients, comparable to other centers and the goal for the Esmont Senior Center, would cost approximately $11,000 more than presently budgeted. Conclusion - Significantly increasing average daily attendance at the Esmont Senior Center is considered to be the key goal. JABA believes that this can be accomplished by effectively working together to recruit and retain more clients. We are prepared to join the community, when appropriate, in advocating for additional resources to support a larger client base. It is our hope that the discussion on August 7 will represent a start to that important process. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE 1999 DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY REPORT COLINTY OF ALBEMARLE 1999 DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY REPORT STATISTICAL ABSTRACT Res/dent/al Building Permits Residential building permits issued in 1999 totaled 770 dwelling units. This number is somewhat lower than the level of building activity observed since 1990. The only other deviation from this trend occurred in 1995 when only 596 building permits were issued. · Of the 770 new housing starts in 1999, 434 dwelling units (56%) were located in Designated Development Areas and 336 dwelling units (44%) were located in the Rural Areas. · Residential building permits issued in 1999 were composed of the following types of dwelling units: - 78 % conventional single-family detached 11% single-family attached 8 % single-family townhouse 0 % multi-family units 3 % mobile homes located throughout the County · Of the 601 Single-family detached building permits issued, 49%, or 294, were in the Development Areas and 51%, or 307 in the Rural Areas. · Mobile homes accounted for 8% (27 totali of all building permits issued for dwelling units ih the Rural Areas - up from 6% in 1998. · Accessory apartments accounted for less than 1% (3 total) of building permits issued for dwelling units in .1999. Residential Subdivisions · 122 subdivision plats were signed in 1999 creating 301 new lots. · Of the 301 new lots created, 153 (51%) were located in the Designated Development Areas and 148 (49%) were located in the Rural Areas. · 85 (58%) of new Rural Area lots were development dght lots of less than 21 acres. The average lot size of the 301 new lots created in 1999 increased significantly to 23.18 acres from 6.24 acres in 1998. In 1999 the average new lot size in the Designated Development Areas (153 lots) increased to 3.21 acres, and the average new lot size in the Rural Areas (148 lots) increased t043.84 acres. This increase is due in part, to a few subdivisions in which the average acreage size exceeded 100 acres, thereby significantly increasing the overall figures. Site Development Plans · One major residential site development plan was signed in 1999 representing 96 mobile home units. 15 major non-residential site development plans were signed in 1999. These plans represented 346,944 square feet of commercial/retail services space, 22,510 square feet of industrial space, 0 square feet of office space, and 140,960 square feet of public/institutional space. Land Use Taxation and Agricultural/Forestal Districts Landowners have enrolled 20% of the Designated Development Areas, and 68% of the Rural Areas in the land use taxation program as of December 31, 1999. The total area in the land use taxation program comprises approximately 66% of Albemarle County. As of December 31st, 1999, the land area voluntarily enrolled by rural landowners in agricultural and forestal districts represented approximately 14% of Albemarle County's total land area. Zoning · A total of 130.71 acres were rezoned in 1998. One development, in Rural Area Two, Spdngridge, accounted for 75 acres of the total rezoned. TABLE OF CONTENTS I. iNTRODUCTiON ......................................................................................................................................... 1 II. RESIDENTIAL ACTIVITY ........................................................................................................................... 2 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. B. 2. 3. 4. 5. C. BUILDING PERMIT A CT1VITY ............... ? .............................................................................................. 2 OVERVIEW ................................................................................................................................................. 2 BUILDING PERMITS BY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DEVELOPMENT AREA .................................................... 2 BUILDING PERMITS BY DWELLING UNIT TYPE ......................................................................................... 5 BUILDING PERMITS BY MAGISTERIAL DISTRICT ................ : ..................................................................... 5 RESIDENTIAL BUILDING ACTIVITY COMPARISON ..................................................................................... 5 SUBDIVISION A CTIVITY ...................................................................................................................... 10 METHODOLOGY ....................................................................................................................................... i 0 ANALYSIS OF SIGNED PLATS ................................................................................................................... 10 HISTORIC COMPARISON OF SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY - SIGNED PLATS .................................................... 13 SIGNED PLATS - PUBLIC VS. PRIVATE ROADS ........................................ : ............................................... 13 RURAL PRESERVATION DEVELOPMENT ..................................................................................................17 SITE PLAN ACTMTY ............................................................................................................................ 18 III. INVENTORY OF LAND USE ................................................................................................................... 22 IV. ZONING AND COMPRFJ--IFNSIVE PLAN MODIFICATIONS ................................... ; ..................... 29 1999 REZONING ACTIVITY ................................................................................................................... 29 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MODIFICATIONS IN 1999 .......... ' ......................................................... 31 V. APPENDIX 32 111 LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1: Comprehensive Plan Area - Actual Dwellings Summary, 1995-1999 .................................................. 3 Table 2-2: Dwelling Units by Comprehensive Plan Area by Building Permits Issued in 1999 ............................. 4 Table 2-3: Number of Dwelling Units by Magisterial District by Building Permits Issued in 1999 ...................... 7 Table 2-4: Building Permit Activity Comparison,' 1992-1999 ............................................................................... 8 Table 2-5: Total Number of New Dwelling Units fxom Building Permits Issued, 1980-1999 ............................... 9 Table 2-6: Residential Subdivision. Activity in 1999 - Signed Plats ..................................................................... 11 Table 2-7: Distribution by Size (Acreage) Based on Signed Plats Located in the Rural Areas, 1997-1999 ........ 12 Table 2-8: Changes in Subdivision Activity, 1988-1999 - Signed Plats .............................................................. 14 Table 2-9: Rural Area Average Lot Size, 1996-1999 (development right lots) .................................................... 15 Table 2-10:1999 Signed Plats - New Public and Private Roads .......................................................................... 16 Table 2-11: Rural Preservation Developments, 1990-1999 .................................................................................. 19 Table 2-12: Major Residential Site Plans Approved in 1999 ............................................................................... 20 Table 2-13: Major Non-residential Site Plans Approved in 1999 ........................................................................ 21 Table 3-1: Residential Land Use Summary, 1999 ................................................................................................ 23 Table 3-2: CommerCial and Industrial Land Use Summary, 1999 ....................................................................... 24 Table 3-3: Acreage in Land Use Taxation by Year and Land Use Type, 1982-1999 ........................................... 25 Table 3-4: Estimate of Distribution of County Land Under Land Use, 1999 ....................................................... 26 Table 3-5[ Agricultural/Forestal Districts ............................................................................................................. 27 Table 4-1: Approved Zoning Map Amendments, 1999 ........................................................................................ 30 iv INTRODUCTION The Development Activity Report is an annual review of the residential, commercial, and industrial development applications approved by the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors, Planning Commission, Board of Zoning Appeals, Department of Planning and Community Development, and Building COdes and Zoning Services. This review in no way represents actual' development in.the County, it simply reflects serious development interests. Throughout the year, numerous actions are taken regarding building permits, subdivision plats, site development Plans, and changes to zoning regulations. This report tracks these actions and analyzes where trends of two or more years are occurring. The location of new residential and commercial interest is not only important to planners, but is also useful information for those involved in rural preservation, commercial development, or marketing activities. In June of 1996, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors adopted the 1996-2016 Land Use Plan. This Land Use Plan is similar in many ways to the previous Plan. However, the Villages of Earlysville and North Garden were eliminated in the Plan as Designated Development Areas. Development information for these eliminated areas has been incorporated in information about Rural Areas 1 and 3, respectively. It is important to point out that an amendment to the Plan, approved in December of 1989, created the Village of Rivanna Development Area. In this report, some of the data previously attributed to Rural Area 4 is nOw shown as belonging to the Village of Rivanna. Additions have also been made to the Development Areas of Piney Mountain and Hollymead. Piney Mountain was upgraded from a Village designation to a Community. It is also imPortant to note that the Community of Scottsville Development Area was eliminated with the adoption of the 1996-2016 Comprehensive Land Use Plan since a significant portion of the Area was incorporated into the Town of Scottsville by boundary adjustment on January 1, 1994. This report is divided into three major sections. The first section addresses residential development by analyZing where building permit, subdivision, and site plan activity has occurred. The next section describes inventories of residential, commercial, and industrial zoned land along with the distribution of County land in preferential land use taxation. The third section presents zoning map amendments and amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. As in past reports, one purpose of the Development Activity RePort is to evaluate the effectiveness of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance, adopted December 10, 1980. An objective of the Zoning Ordinance is to encourage development in the DeSignated Development Areas (these specific Development Areas aredescribed tin.detail.in the.Comprehensive Plan). While the Comprehensive Plan outlines goals and objectives for effectively managing Albemarle County's growth, the Zoning Ordinance provides the legal structure by which the goals and objectives are accomplished. For the purposes of this report, 1999 development activity comparisons will be made to the 1996-2016. Land Use Plan. II: RESIDENTIAL ACTIVITY BUILDING PERMIT ACTIVITY 1. Overview The annual number of new residential dwelling units is. an important indicator of growth in a locality. For this report, the number of building permits issued for new residential structures is: a measure of new dwelling units to be built in Albemarle County. Though the total level of activity from one year to the next is ascertained from building permit volumes, the distribution of new housing by location and by type can also be analyzed from information provided on a permit. The location and type of dwelling relative to existing utilities, public facilities, and infrastructure provides direction for,long-term planning efforts. 2. l~uilding Permits by Comprehensive Plan DeVelopment, Area In 1999, the number of new dwelling units from building permits totaled 770 (see Table 2-1). This total represents a decrease of 104 dwelling units from the 1998 total of 874. Overall, (with the exception of 1995 when only 596 permits were issued), the total number of building permits issued in 1999 is slightly less than the rate of building activity observed since 1990. Designated Development Areas (Urban Areas, Communities, and .Villages)accounted for 56% (434) of all new dwelling units in 1999. The Urban Area, consisting of Urban Ne!ghborhoods 1-7, accounted for 28% (218 units) of the total 770 new dwelling units in 1999, nearly one-third less than last year. Of the 218 new units located in the Urban Area, 86 were located in Urban Neighborhood 2 (see Table 2-2). The amount of activity in the Communities remained fairly consistent. The average number of new dwelling units since 1992 is 171 per year. In 1999, the Communities represented 167 units or 22% of the total number of new units in the County. The Community of Hollymead once again showed a .noteworthy amount of new dwelling unit building activity. In 1999, Hollymead accounted for 95 (12%) of the County's total new dwelling units. This made it the largest concen{ration of new building activity in the Designated Development Areas. The adoption of the revised Land Use Plan component Of the Comprehensive Plan in June 1996 eliminated two Village designations leaving only one Village in the Plan (Rivanna). The number of dwelling units from building permits in the Village of Rivanna, mainly due to the continued development of the Glenmore subdivision, accounted for 49 units or 6% of the total new dwelling units permitted. In the Rural Areas, the percentage of residential building permits issued accounted for 44% (336 units) of all permits issued within the County. This represents an increase from 33% percent in 1998, and the largest amount of activity experienced in the last five years. Although building activity was focused in the Designated Development Areas in 1995, the total number of building permits issued throughout the County in 1995 was Iow. This is the first year in the last 5 years in which the number of new dwelling units in the Rural Areas exceeded 300. 2 TABLE 2-1 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AREA - ACTUAL DWELLINGS SUMMARY 1995.1999 . ACTUAL DWELLINGS AND 'DIS~HIBUTION (from Building Reports) COMP PLAN AREAI 1995 I 1996 I 1997 I 1998 I 1999 Urban Areas 158 27% 401 48% 376 42% 367 42% 218 28% Communities 137 23% 140 17% 195 22% 158 18% 167 22% Villages 48 8% 63 , 8% 62 7% 63 7% 49 6% Rural Areas 253 42% 231 28% 272 30% 286 33% 336 44% TOTAL 596 100% 835 100% 905 100% 874 100% 770 100% TABLE 2-2 DWELLING UNITS BY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AREA BY BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED IN 1999 SFA % OF COMP PLAN AREA SF SF/TH DUP MF MH AA TOTAL UNITS TOTAL URBAN RURAL UNITS Urban Neighborhood 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.1% Urban Neighborhood 2 43 0 42 0 0 0 1 86 · 11.2% Urban Neighborhood 3 29 12 0 0 0 0 0 41 5.3% Urban Neighborhood 4 24 20 0 0 0 0 0 44 5.7% Urban Neighborhood 5 36 8 0 0 0 0 0 44 5.7% Urban Neighborhood 6 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.3% Urban Neighborhood 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0% Orozet Community 48 8 '0 0 0 0 0 56 7.3% Hollymead Community 63 16 16 0 0 0 0 95 12.3% Piney Mountain Community 0 16 0 0 0 0 0 16 2.1% Rivanna Village 49 0 0 0 0 0 0 49 6.4% DEVELOPMENT AREA SUBTOTAL 294 81 58 0 0 0 1 434 56.4% Rural Area 1 59 0 0 0 0 8 0 67 8.7% Rural Area 2 84 0 0 0 0 3 2 89 11.6% Rural Area 3 101 0 0 0 0 7 0 108 14.0% Rural Area 4 63 0 0 0 0 9 0 72 9.4% RU P, AL AREA SUBTOTAL 307 0 0 · 0 0 27 2 336 43.6% TOTAL 601 81 58 0 0 27 3 770 100.0% KEY TO TYPES OF HOUSING: SF- Single-Family (includes Modular) DUP- Duplex AA-Accessory' Apartment SFA- Single-Family Attached MF- Multi-Family SF/TH- Single-Family Townhouse MH- Mobile Home ,5. I~uilding ?ermite by Dwelling Unit Typei As in previous years, the highest percentage of 1999 residential building permit activity occurred in the category of single-family detached homes, including modular homes (see Table 2-2). In 1999, 78% (601 units) of all building permits issued for dwelling units were for single-family homes. Single- family detached homes as a percentage of total dwelling units increased by 14% from 1998. In the Rural Areas, 91% of all dwelling units were single-family detached homes. In the Designated Development Areas, 68% of all dwelling units were single-family detached homes.. The total number of single-family attached dwelling units increased from 63 units in 1998 to 81 units in 1999. Neighborhood 4 in the Urban Areas accounted for 25% of the 81 new single-family attached units. Of all building permits issued for dwelling units in Albemarle County, 11% were for single- family attached units. The total number of single-family townhouses increased to 58 units in 1999 from 42 units in 1998. Urban Neighborhood 2 accounted for the majority of new single-family townhouses (72%) in 1999, as it did in 1998. Of all building permits issued for dwelling units in Albemarle County, 8% were for sing le-family townhouses. There were no multi-family permits issued in 1999, contrary to a large amount of multi-family activity in recent years. Building permits were issued in 1998 for 184 multi-family dwelling units. In 1997, building permits were issued for 208 units; in 1996, building permits were issued for 226 units; this is not the first year in which no multi-family permits were issued, however, the same occurred in 1995. 4. Building Permite by Magisterial District The magisterial district boundaries used in this report are those which were revised on May 15, 1991, as a result of the release of the Census Bureau population figures for Albemarle County (see reference map in Appendix). Of the six magisterial districts, the Rivanna district recorded the highest level of residential building activity in 1999 with 333 permits issued for new dwelling units, accounting for 43% of all new .dwelling units (see Table 2-3). The Samuel Miller district recorded the second highest level of residential building activity in .1999 with 128 permits issued for new dwelling units, accounting for 17% of all new dwelling units. The White Hall district closely followed this with 125 permits issued for new dwelling units, representing 16% of the new dwellings units in the County. The Jack Jouett district had the lowest level of residential building permits with 2% (16 units) of the total number of new dwelling units in Albemarle County in 1999. 5. l~esidential Building Activity Comparison The average number of total dwelling units for which building permits were issued between 1992 and 1998 was 831 units (see Table 2-4). The 1999 total of 770 units represents a slightly below average year for building activity as compared to the seven-year average. In the Urban Area (Neighborhoods 1-7), Neighborhood 2 accounts for the largest amount of building activity. Among the Communities, the Community of Hollymead continues to account for the majority of the residential building activity. On average, over an eight-year period, the Community of Hollymead has accounted for 63% of all residential building activity in the Communities. In 1999, Neighborhood 2 and the Community of Hollymead accounted for 42% of all residential growth in the Desig hated Development Areas. 5 The total number of permits issued for new residential dwelling units located in the Rural Areas of the County increased from 286 in 1998 to 336 in 1999. This increase represents an erratic trend during which the number of new dwelling units .in the Rural Areas varies from year to year. Until this year, total dwelling units in the Rural Areas have totaled between 231 and 286 dwelling units annually, since 1992. Overall, the 770 building permits issued in 1999 for residential dwelling units represents an average year for housing permit activity within the last twenty years (see Table 2-5) as from 1980 to 1999, an average of 777 permits were issued annually. TABLE 2-3 NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS BY MAGISTERIAL DISTRICT BY BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED IN 1999 MAGISTERIAL SF SFA SF/TH DUP MF MH AA TOTAL % OFTOTAL DISTRICTS · UNITS UNITS Rio 45 ' 0 10 0 0 I I ,~7 · 7% Jack Jouett 16 0 0 0 0 ' 0 0 16 2% Rivanna 236 44 48 0 0 3 2 333 43% Samuel Miller 114 9 0 0 0 5 ! 0 128 .17% Scottsville 83 20. 0 0 0 8 0. 111 14% White Hall 107 8 0 0 0 10 0 125 16% TOTAL 601 81 58 0 0 27 3 770 100% (EY TO TYPES OF HOUSING: SF- Single-Family (includes Modular) DUP- Duplex AA- Accessory Apts. SFA- Single-Family Attached MF- Multi-Family SF/TH- Single-Family Townhouse MH- Mobile Home TABLE 2-4 ' BUILDING PERMIT ACTIVITY COMPARISON '!992-1999 COMP PLAN AREA 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 TOTAL % OF #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS#UNITS #UNITS TOTAL Urban Neighborhood I 1 60 0 0 0 48 23 1 133 2% Urban Neighborhood 2 74 85 210 97 99 234 69 86 954 16% Urban Neighborhood 3 144 1 4 0 20 5 177 41 392 7% Urban Neighborhood 4 79 85 219 48 264 48 48 44 835 14% Urban Neighborhood 5 24 20 14 11 15 36 36 44 200 3% Urban Neighborhood 6 0 2 2 I 2 .3 5 14 2 30 1% Urban Neighborhood 7 66 12 i 0 0 0 0 0 79 1% URBAN AREAS SUBTOTAL 388 265 450 158 401 376 367 218 2,623 45% Cmzet Community 51 72 40 I 35 37 59 48 56 398 7% Hollymead Community 103 122 123 94 91 134 96 95 858 15% Piney Mountain Community~ 46 1 10 8 12 2 14 16 109 2% COMMUNITIES SUBTOTAL 200 195 173 137 140 195 158 167 1,365 f 23% Rivanna Village 11 77 77 48 63 62 63 49 450 8% VILLAGE SUBTOTAL 11 77 77 - 48 63 62 63 49 401 7% DEVELOPMENT AREA TOTALI 599 I 537 I 700 I 343 i 604 I 633 I 588 t 434 14,438 I 76% I Rural Area 1 ' 57 63 65 68 57 77 79 67 533 9% Rural Area 2 54 52 51 39 45 46 53 89 429 7% Rural Area 3 85 80 68 69 75 66 81 108 632 11% Rural Area 4 71 73 55 77 54 83 73 72 558 10% RURAL AREA TOTAL t 267 I 268 I 239 I 253 I 231 I 272 I 286 I 336 I 2,152 I 37% 866 ' 805 939 596 835 905 87~ 770 5,820 100% TABLE 2-5 TOTAL NUMBER OF NEW DWELLING UNITS FROM BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED 1980-1999 YEAR NUMBER OF # CHANGE FROM DWELLING UNITS PREVIOUS YEAR 1980 583 1981 598 15 1982 482 -116~ 1983 · 1,063 581~ 1984 725 -338 · 1985 ·714 -11 1986 737 23 1987 654 -83 1988 . 673 19 1989 . 1,309 636 · 1990 804 -505 1991 614~ -190 · 1992 866 252 1993 805 -61. 1994 939 134 1995 596 -343 1996 835 239 1997 905 70 1998 ·874 -31 1999 770 -104 TOTAL 15,546 Average. 1980-1989: 753.8 Dwelling Units/Year Average 1990-1999: 800.8 Dwelling Units/Year Average 1980-1999: 777.3 Dwelling UnitS/Year B. SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY As the County of Albemarle continues to experience growth, there will be continued residential development in the area. The best mechanism for tracking developments is through the analysis of subdivision activity, given that a precursor to subdivision development is most commonly the subdividing of land into multipletots for individual dwelling unit construction. 1. Methodology For the purposes of this report, the definition of subdivision is limited to the division of a parcel of land, including re-divisions, which results in at least one (1) new residential building lot. The creation of condominium lots is separated from that of other residential lots in the analysis of this report, Condominium lots do not include acreage as part of the individual lot; therefore, it would be misleading to include them in calculations such as average lot size. This section of the 1999 Development Activity Report examines the characteristics of new residential building lots through subdivision activity during the year and includes data for plats signed for recordation. Not all subdivision plats approved by the Planning Department are subsequently recorded in the Courts,' therefore, adding together all current and historical new lots reported in this, and prior, Development Activity Reports, would result in an over-estimation or "double counting" of the actual number of lots in the County. Also, properties may be subject to repeated subdivision activity and therefore current and historical acreage subdivided cannot be added, since this would result in over-estimation of total acreage divided in the County. 2. Analysie of Signed Plate In 1999, 122 residential subdivision plats were signed and 301 new lots were created (see Table 2- 6). The Designated Development Areas accounted for 22% of the signed plats, 51% of the new residential building lots created, and 7% of the total acres subdivided in 1999. The major subdivisions in the Designated Development Areas that contributed a significant number of new lots were Dunlora and Foxcroft. The Rural Areas accounted for 78% of the total number of residential subdivision plats signed, 49% of the new lots created, and 93% percent of the total acreage subdivided in 1999 (see Table 2-6). The 95 new subdivisions in the Rural Areas in 1.999 are consistent with subdivision activity the County has experienced since 1986. The number of new lots in the Rural Areas is nearly consistent with the last two years, (100 lots in 1997 and 98 lots in 1998.) However, the total acreage subdivided in the Rural Areas increased exponentially from 2,421 acres in 1998 to 6,487, acres in 1999. This is mostly due to several rural divisions in the Rural Areas. In many of these divisions, several huhdreds of acres were divided into one or 'two acres. Therefore these numbers grossly inflated the total acreage, and consequently the average acreage size. The distribution of new Rural Area lots by size is shown in Table 2-7. Thirty-six percent of new lots created were between 2 and 9.99 acres in size. A total of 14 new lots were created in the 2 to 4.99- acre range, representing 10% of the total lots created in 1999. In the 5 to 9.99 acre range, 38 new lots were created, accounting for 26% of the tOtal. The percentage of new lots created in 1999 in excess of 21 acres (42%) showed a slight decrease from those Created in 1998 (46%). ]0 TABLE2,.6 RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY IN 1999 - SIGNED PLATS COMP PLAN AREA SUBDIVISIONS NEW LOTS TOTAL ACREAGE # % # % . Acres % Urban Neighborhood 1 1 0.8% 1 0.3% 76.55 1 · 10% Urban Neighborhood 2 1 0.8% 45 15.0% 28.62 0.41% Urban Neighborhood 3 2 1.6% 5 1.7% 56.63 0.81% Urban Neighborhood 4 2 1.6% . 23 7.6% 14.62 0.21% Urban Neighborhood 5 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00' 0.00% Urban Neighborhood 6 1 0.8% 1 0.3% 0.29 0.00% Urban Neighborhood 7 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00 0.00% SUBTOTAL 7 5.7% 75 24.9% 176.72 2.53% Crozet Community 4 3.3% 27 9.0% 74.94 1.07% Hollymead Community 14 11.5% 49 16.3% 120.27 1.72% Piney Mountain Community 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00 0.00% SUBTOTAL 18 14.8% 76 25.2% 195.21 2.80% Rivanna Village 2 1.6% 2 0.7% ~ t19.04 1.71% SUBTOTAL 2 1.6% 2 0.7% 119.04 1.71% DEVELOPMENT AREA SUBTOTAL 27 22.1% 153 50.8% 490.96 7.04% I Rural Area 1 18' 14.8% 25 .8,3% 912.40 13.07% RuralArea 2 20 16.4% 38 12.6% 789.87 11.32% RuralArea 3 23 18.9% 42 ~14.0% 1,606.02 23.01% RuralArea4 34 27.9% 43 14.3% 3,179.35 45.56% RURAL AREA SUBTOTAL 95 77.9% 148 49.2% 6,487.65 92.96% TOTAL 122 100.0% 301 100.0% 6,978.61 100.00% ]] TABLE 2-7 DISTRIBUTION BY SIZE (ACREAGE) BASED ON SIGNED PLATS LOCATED IN THE RURAL AREAS, AS DESIGNATED BY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 1997-1999 RANGE IN ACRES NEW LOTS CREATED Under 2.0 2.0 to 4.99 5.0 to 9.99 10.0 to 20.99 21.0 and Over 0 131 34 13 196 TOTAL 1997 %OF TOTAL RURAL LOTS 0% 67% 17% 7% 9% 100% 1 NEW LOTS CREATED 1 43 26 88 191 )98 % OF TOTAL RURAL LOTS 1% 23% 14% 17% 46% 100% NEW LOTS % OF TOTALiC CREATED RURAL LOTS 38 26°/ 20 14°/~ 62 42%~ 148 100°/~[ * Is due in large part to the Stonewood Deve opment, which )ossesses a Village Residential (VR) zoning classification that allows lot sizes under 2 acres. This VR zoning, in Rural Area II, is associated with land that was formerly designated as the Village of Stony Point in the 1992 Comprehensive Plan and subsequently removed. ]2 5. Hiel~oric ComFarieo~ of 5ubclivision~Ac~ivit, y ' 5ion~& Pla~,s The comparison of subdivision activity in 1999 to that of previous years is a useful tool for identifying growth patterns (see Table 2-8). In 1999, there was a slight decrease in the total number of new residential subdivision plats signed from 126 in 1998 to 122 in 1999 (see Table 2-8). But there was also a noticeable decrease in'the total number of new residential building lots created through subdivision activity from 435 new lots in 1998 to 301 lots in 1999. The Designated Development Areas accounted for 153 of the 301 new lots in 1999, which represents a decrease of 91 lots from 1998. These account for 51% of total lots, a slight decrease from 56% in 1998. The total acreage subdivided in the Development Areas actLially increased from 293 acres in 1998 to 491 acres in 1999. This increase in acreage subdivided and decrease in the number of new lots created has resulted in a higher average lot size for 1999 (3.21 acres vs. 1.20 acres in 1998). This new average is a great deal higher than in years past. Urban Neighborhoods 1-7 accounted for 75 new lots, the Communities accounted for 76 new lots, and Rivanna Village accounted for 2 new lots in 1998. In the Rural Areas, the 148 new lots created in 1999 represent a decrease of 43 lots from the 1998 · total of 191 new lots. The 148 new lots created by signed plat in 1999 are lower than the established trend observed in previous years in the Rural Areas. From 1987 to 1998, many of the Rural Area subdivisions created only one (1) or two (2) new lots each, and the average lot size tended to be larger, ranging from 7 to nearly 15 acres (see Table 2-8). In the years prior to 1987, the number of new lots created per subdivision was relatively high (3 to 5 lots per subdivision), and the resulting average lot size tended to be smaller. In 1995, the average lot size in the Rural Areas was 14.5 acres (the second largest since tracking this particular data set). The average lot size in the Rural Areas for 1999 was 43.84 acres. The new average lot sizes for Rural Area lots created with development rights (which exclude lots greater than or equal to 21 acres), from 1995 to 1999 appear in Table 2-9. Average lot sizes, of those lots-created with development rights in the Rural Areas, have increased in Rural AreaS 3 & 4. Meanwhile, lot sizes have decreased in Rural Areas 1 & 2. z~. 5i0ne¢i Plat, e - Public ye, Privat, e Roacle Effective January 1, 1984, the provisions in the Subdivision Ordinance regarding private roads were substantially amended to state that private roads would be the exception to public road constr,Jction in subdivision developments. Prior to this amendment, the number of subdivisions on private roads was higher than the number with public roads. After the amendment was enacted, the distribution of subdivisions on public roads versus private roads generally began to favor public road development. In 1999, public road access for new lots exceeded private road access with 27% of all new lots utiliZing public roads while. 7% involved private roads. Fifteen-.percent of new lots created in 1999 utilized both public and private roads (see Table 2-10). 13 · Table 2-8 CHANGES IN SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY 1988-1999 SIGNED PLATS COMP PLAN AREA 1988 1989 1990 ' 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 URBAN AREA Subdivisions 22 15 17 · 26 26 32 28 20 21 15 14 7i New Lots 167 200 162 190 234 191i 171 162 179 129 55 751 Acreage 183.00 144.00 348.00 48.00 160.00 130.00 100.76 218.00 91.95 297.24 222.24 176.72; · Average Lot Size 1.10 0.72 2.15 0.25 0.68 0.68 0.59 1.35 0.51 2.30 4.04 2.36 COMMUNITIES Subdivisions 6 7 3 12 12 18 12 14 11 15 13 18 New Lots l 207 42 14 125 127 272 135 208 40 143 138 76 Acreage 99.00 23.60 6.00 118.00 82.00 75.00 50.00 81,00 20.61 90.83 48.57 195.21 · Average Lot Size 0.48 0.56 0.43 0.94 0.65 0.28 0.37 0.39 0.52 0,64 0.35 2.57 VILLAGES Subdivisions 2 2 2 4 5 3 2! 8 3 3 1 2 New Lots 3 2 27 16 314 20 2 73 82 42 51; 2 Acreage 40.00 4.17 ;14.00 11.00 169,00 9.00 43,00 46.00 64.00 13.51 22,'13 119.04 · Average'Lot Size 13.33 2.09; 0.52 0.69 0.54 0.45 21.50 0.63 0.78 0.32 0.43 59.52 TOTAL DEVELOPMENT AREAS Subdivisions 30 24 22 42 43 53 42 42 35 33 28 27 New Lots 377 244 203 331 675 483 308 443 301 314 244 153 Acreage 322.00 171.77 368.00 177.00 411.00 214.00 193.76 345.00 176.56 401.58 292.94 490.96 · Average Lot Size 0.85 0.70 1.81 0.53 0.61 0.44 0.63 0.78 0.59 1.28 1.20 3.21 RURAL AREA 1 ' Subdivisions 36 29 31 18 20 33 30 26 18 22 ~6 18 New Lots 135 59 82 42 27 70 87 37 28 26 38 25 Acreage 993.00 993.35 584.00 316.00! 150.00 930.00 315.00 708.00 272.00 210.09 399.24 912.40 · Average Lot Size 7,36 16.84 7.12 7,52 5,56 13.29 3.62 19.14 9.7! 8.08 10.51 36.50 RURAL AREA 2 Subdivisions 23 26 27 25 25 21 21 13 ' 18 17 20 2C New Lots 60 51 48 30 38 36 36 20 33 75 27 Acreage 649.00 785.64 672.00 510,00 280.00 428.00 428.00 294.00 416.00 502.67 245.;48 789.87 · Average Lot Size 10.82 15.40 14.00 17..00 7.37 11.89 11.89 14.70 12.61 6.70 9.09 20.7~c' RURAL AREA 3 Subdivisions 33 ' 34 37 34 44 34 33 28 27 33i 29 New Lots ' 64 87 65 68 76 92 37 ' 69 42 52 100 1606.42'02 Acreage 5!5.00 862.12 733.00 550.00 873.00 460.00 794.00 732.00 313,00 461.89 1499.63 · Average Lot Size 8.05 9,91 11,28 8.09 11.49 .5.00 ' 21.46 10.61 7~45 8.88 15,00 38.24 RURAL AREA 4 Subdivisions 26 25 33 37 37 35 11 33 29 281 New Lots 28 72 50 48 50 75 19 56 45 43 26 4? Acreage 504.00 591.00 880.00 848.00 593.00 1387.00! 254.00 910.00 546.00 366.72 276.~4 3179.35 · Average Lot Size 18.00 8,21 17.60 17.67 11,86 18.49 13.37 16.25 12.13 8.53 10.63 73.94 TOTAL RURAL AREAS Subdivisions 118 114 128 114 126 123 95 100 92 100 98 9~ New Lots 287 269 245 188 191 273 179 182 148 196 191 148 Acreage 2661.00 3232.11 2869.00 2224.00 1896.00 3205,00 1791.00 2644.00 1547.00 1541.37 2420.7g 6487.65 · Average Lot Size 9.27 12.02 11.71 11.83 9.93 11.74 10.01 14.53 10.45 7.86 12.67 43.~' GRAND TOTAL Subdivisions 148 13~ 150 156 169 176 137 142 127 133 126 12:2 New Lots 664 513 448 519 866 756 487 625 449 510 435 301 Acreage 2983,00 3403.88 3237.00 2401,00 2307.00 3419.00 1985.00' 2989.00 1723.56 1942.95 2713.73 6978.61~: · Average Lot Size 4.49 6.64 7.23 4.63 2.66 4.52 4.08 4.78 3.84 3.81 6.24' 23.17 Average Lot Size is not an indication of density. For each subdivision approved by the Planning Department, "Average Lot Size" was determined by summing open space acres and acreage in lots and dividing by the total number of new lots thereby resulting in a higher density than may actually exist. 14 TABLE 2-9 . RURAL' AREA AVERAGE LOT SIZE, 1996-1999' (Development Right Lots) COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 1996 1997 1998 1999 CHANGE FROM 98-99 AREA P, uralArea 1 7.42 ac. 3.53 ac. 5.49 ac. 5.00 ac. -0.49 ac. RuralArea 2 9.11 ac. 4.91 ac. 5.27 ac. 3.43 ac. -1.84 ac. RuralArea 3 . 5.20 ac. 5.88 ac. 8.84 ac. 10.64 ac. +1.80 ac. Rural Area 4 4.84 ac. 4.34 ac. 4.29 ac. 6.58 ac. +2.29 ac. * Average Lot Size is not an indication of density. For each approved subdivision, "Average Lot Size" was determined by summing acreage of all new lots (including those dedicated to common open space, where applicable) and dividing by the total number of new lots thereby resulting in a higher density than may actually exist. TABLE 2-10 NEW PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ROADS 1999 NEW LOTS BASED ON SIGNED PLATS CLASSIFICATION OF ROADS # % # New Lots - Public Roads 80 26.58 # New Lots - Private Roads 21 6.98 # New Lots - Public / Private Roads 45 14.95 # New Lots - No Roads 155 51.50 TOTAL 301 100 §. · l~u~'al ?regerva'r, ion DeYelol~men~ The Rural Preservation Development was created as an alternative to the conventional development subdivision provisions set forth in Section 10 (Rural Areas District) of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance. The Rural Preservation Development option, added to the Zoning Ordinance in November 1989, is intended to encourage more effective land usage in terms of the goals and objectives for the Rural Areas as set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. Therefore, in addition to the standard subdivision provisions, which appear in the Zoning Ordinance, applications for Rural Preservation Developments are reviewed for the preservation of agricultural and forestal lands and activities; water supply protection; and/or cOnservation of natural, scenic, or historic resources. .Covesville was one the new rural preservation development approved in 1999 (see Table 2-11). ]7 C. SITE PLAN ACTIVITY The approval of site development plans is another measure of growth in Albemarle County. This section of the Development Activity Report examines the site development plans that were signed in 1999. In 1999, one residential site development plan, for Forest Springs Mobile Home Park, totaling 96 new dwelling units, was signed (see Table 2-12). The 96 units approved by site development plan in 1999 represent a decrease of 108 units over the 1998 total of 204. 'Major non-residential site development plans signed in 1999 appear in Table 2-13. Major site development plans included in the table, with the exception of public/institutional plans, exceed 15,000 sq. ft. A total of 14 major non-residential site development plans were signed creating 510,414 square feet of commercial/retail, industrial, or public/institutional construction. Of the total square footage approved, 199,284 square feet was for commercial/retail services (as compared to 201,219 square feet approved in 1998); 22,510 square feet for industrial (as compared to 24,000 square feet in 1998); 272,660 square feet for office services (as compared to 237,708 square feet approved in 1998); and t 5,960 square feet for public/institutional services (as compared to 179,757 square feet approved in 1998). Three (3) of the 15 site development plans approved in 1998 were located within Rural Areas, this is significant decrease from the eight (8) approved in the Rural Areas in 1998. TABLE: 2-11 ~ . RURAL PRESERVATION DEVELOPMENTS, 1990-'1999 COMP PLAN AREA 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 TOTAL RURAL AREA 1 Total.ACreage 172.53 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00i 0.00 0.00 .0.00 0.00 172.53 Number of Dev. Lots 37.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00' -1.11 0.00 0.00 0.00 35.89 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 2.58 0,00 0:00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 80.60 0.00 0.00 0.0C~ 0.00 0.00 1.11 0.00 0.00 0.00 81.71 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0,00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RURAL AREA 2 Total Acreage 0.00 0.00 132.90 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 132.90 Number of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 13.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 13.00 Ave, Acreage of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 5.79 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 0.00 0.00 57.70 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 57.70 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RURAL AREA 3 Total Acreage 332.05 0.00 84.13 521.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 198.45 1,136.54 Numberof Dev. Lots 30.00 0.00 7.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 16.00 93.00 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 5.05 0.00 5.26 2.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.30 RPTAcreage 166.52 0.00 47.331 385.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 113.92 713.20 Common Open Space Acreage 7.36 0.00 0.00 19.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26.56 RURAL AREA 4 Total Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00' 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Number of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 TOTAL Total Acreage 504.58 0.00 217.03 521.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 198.45 1,441.97 Number of Dev. Lots 67.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 -1.11 0.00 0.00 16.00 141.89 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 7.53 0.00 10.85 13.05 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 12.40 RPTAcreage 247.12 0.00 105.03 385.43 0.00 0.00 1.11 0.00 0.00 113.92 852.61 Common Open SpaceAcreage 7.36 0.00 0.00 19.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26.56 TABLE 2~12 MAJOR RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANS APPROVED IN 1999 I PROJECT NAME COMP PLAN AREA TYPE OF DWELLING NUMBER OF DWELLINGS Forest Springs MHP Hollymead Mobile Home 96 ' TOTAL 96 2O Table 2-13 MAJOR NON-RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANS APPROVED IN 1999 PROJECT NAME USE AREA MAGISTERIAL COMP PLAN AREA (SQ FT) DISTRICT COMMERCIAL/RETAIL SERVICES Store-It-Right Storage Units 46,700 Rivanna Hollymead Community Storage Center Storage Units 52,272 Rivanna Hollymead Community Westminster Canterbury Assisted Living !Assisted Living Facility 45,900 F;tivanna Neighborhood 3 Pegasus Motorcar Company Auto Dealership 18,800 Rivanna Neighborhood 3 Shadwell Antiquaries Antique/Retail Shop 16,112 Rivanna '1 Rural Area2 Blue Ridge Building Supply Storage Area 19,500 White Hall Rural Area 3 SUBTOTAL 199,284 INDUSTRIAL · Hampton Roads Publishing Co. Final Warehouse 22 510 Scottsville Neighborhood 4 SUBTOTAL 22,510 OFFICE Peter Jefferson Place II and III Office 125,000 Rivanna Neighborhood 3 North Fork Town Center Building #1 Office Building 69,900 Rivanna Hollymead Old Ivy Road Office Park Office Park ._ 53,760,Samuel Miller Neighborhood 6 Branchlands Professional Building Office Building 24,000! Rio Neighborhood 2 SUBTOTAL 272,660 PUBLIC/INSTITUTIONAL Montessori Community School Major Private School 4,320 Rivanna Neighborhood 3 Department of Motor Vehicles Final Public Office 9', 1'40 Rivanna Neighborhood 3 North Garden Volunteer Fire Dept. Final IFire Station 2,500 Samuel Miller Rural Area 2 SUBTOTAL .! 5,960 TOTAL 510,414 2] III. INVENTORY OF LAND USE An inventory of residential, commerCial, and industrial land was conducted to identify population and commerCial centers in Albemarle County (see Tables 3-1 and 3-2) in 1999. The analysis of the County's data was facilitated by the identification and grouping of developed and undeveloped properties in residential, commercial, and industrial categories. The purpose of this inventory is to examine the distribution of land uses in specific areas of the County. The inventory of residential, commercial, and industrial development was assembled with the assistance of the County's Comprehensive Information System (CIS); a database which stores parcel related data. The data represented in Tables 3-1 and 3-2 were revised for the 1999 Development Activity Report to reflect Zoning Map Amendments approved in 1999. The data in these tables does not incorporate changes due to development Of parcels previously listed in the 1998 Development Activity Report as undeveloped. Therefore, these totals may over-estimate undeveloped property. Also included in this section of the Development Activity Report is an inventory of land currently in the Land Use Assessment Program (see Table 3~3 and 3-4). This program was created in 1971 when the Virginia General Assembly enacted a law permitting localities to adopt special assessments for properties in agriculture, forest, horticulture, and/or open space. The County land use ordinance was adopted in 1975. Since rural area preservation has been an expressed concern in Albemarle County, the inventory of parcels in land use is an estimate of at least part of the acreage currently being maintained in agriculture, forest, horticulture, and open space. The perCentage of acreage in land use, in 1999, accounts for 66% (see Table 3-3) of the total acreage within Albemarle County. A total of 21% of the total acreage within the Designated Development Areas is in land use (see Table 3-4). This represents, no change from 1998. While 68% of the total acreage of the Rural Areas is in land use, the same perCentage as in 1998. In addition to enrollment in the Land Use Assessment Program, rural landowners also have the option of joining an Agricultural and Forestal District. Agricultural and Forestal Districts are created vol~ntarily by landowners. By joining an Agricultural and Forestal District, the landowner agrees not to subdivide or develop their property to a more intensive non-agricultural use during the period in which the property remains within a District. The Districts are approved for a period of 4 to 10 vears, after which time they are eligible for re-approval. Increased activity in the creation of new Agricultural and Forestal Districts, as well as additions made to existing districts, prompted the listing of these districts in the Development Activity Report for the -first time in 1987. The total acreage for all districts was 31,779 acres as of December 31, 1987. As of December 31st, 1999, a total of 65,426.91 acres were dedicated to Agricultural and Forestal Districts (see Table 3-5). This represents 14.07% of the total land area of Albemarle County, a 2% increase from 1998. 22 ~ 0000000 0 0~0 ~ 0 0 0000 0 ~Z ~ 0000000 0 0~0 ~ 0 0 0000 0 > 0000'000 0 ~ ~ 0 0 00~0 ~ ~ 000000~ ~ ~0 ~ 0 0 00~0 ~ ~ ) ~0-000 ~ 000 0 0 0 0000 0 ~ Oz ~ ~ ~0000 ~ 000 0 0 0 0000 0 O ~ ~0~0 0 ~0 ~ 0 0 00~0 0 O~ ~ ~o ooooooo 0 ~ ~ 0 0 ~~ 0 ooooooo D m~ D ~ D 0 ZZZZ.ZZZ 0~ ~ TABLE 3~3 ACREAGE IN LAND USE TAXATION BY YEAR AND LAND USE TYPE, 1982-1999 LAND USE TYPE PERCENTAGE YEAR OPEN TOTAL OF TOTAL AGRICULTURE HORTICULTURE FORESTRY SPACE COUNTY ACREAGE 1982 121,917 1,868 227,915 0 351,700 75.6% 1984' 108,519 · 1,919 207,243 9 317,690 68.3% 1985 109,051 1',931 209,312 9'320,303 68.9% 1986 107,832 1,921 208,259~ 8 318,020 68.4% 1987 110,036 1,952 210,653 8 322,649 69.4% 1988 109,283 1,985 211,489 8 322,765 69.4% 1989 110,236. 2,195 216,036 8 328,475 . 70.6% 1990 109,541~ 2,306 215,221 6 327,074 70.3% 1991 109,440 2,506, 216,389 6 328,341 70.6% 1992 109,932 2,521 218,936 6 331,395 71.3% 1993 110,736 2,447 219,593 6 332,782 71.6%! 1994 101,819 2,392 200,950 63 305,224 65.6% 1995 106,571 2,393 211,753 87 320,804 69.0% 1996 105 484 . 2,412 213,165 13Z '321,195 69.1% 1997 103 803 2,'416 207,138 ' 134 313,491 67.4% 1998 101,925 2,296 202,370 108 306,699 66.0% 1999 107,090 2,026 195,824 126 305,066 65.6% Note: Totals for 1983 are not available. Estimated total acreage of Albemarle County is 465,040. This is a new estimate calculated digitally in March 1998. Previous years were re-calculated to reflect this change.. TABLE 3-4 ESTIMATE OF DISTRIBUTION OF COUNTY LAND " UNDER LAND USE, 1999 ACP,EAGE ACREAGE IN NOT IN TOTAL LAND USE LAND USE Development Areas 4,440 17,856 22,296 P,u ral Areas 300,626 142,118 442,744 TOTAL 305,066 159,974 465,040 Notes: .1. Total County land area is based on a total area of 726.625 square 'miles x 640 acres per square mile= 465,040 acres. The Federal government as .a national park owns approximately 14,000 acres ol rural area, not in land use. 2. These estimates were calculated digitally. 26 TABLE 3-5 ALBEMARLE COUNTY AGRICULTURAL/FORESTAL DISTRICTS (As of December 31, 1999) NAME DATE ACTION/ACREAGE CURRENT ACREAGE PARCELS REVIEW PERIOD REVIEW DATE 1. Totier Creek 06-29-83 District Created/6,070.77 acres I 10 years 06-29-91 District Reviewed/7,246.52 acres 10 years 09-16-92 Addition/1,392.22 acres 10 years 07-10-95 Withdrawal/764.08 7,874.66 10 years 06-29-2001 2. Hatton , 06-29-83 District Created/2,913.69 acres 10 years 12-19-84 Withdrawal!40 acres '10 years 06-29-91 District Reviewed/2,824.22 acres 10 years 07-10-95 Withdrawal/2,035.68 788.54 10 years 06-29-2001 3. Eastham 10-02-85 District Created/764.75 acres 10 years 10-13-93 District Reviewed/587.30ac 10 years 12-08-93 Addition/135.19ac 10 years 05-11-94 District Reviewed(Cont.)/178.09 ac 900.58 10 years 10-13-2003 4. Blue Run .06-18-86 District Created/1,136.08 acres 8 years 01-04-.89 Addition/2,998.67 acres 8 years 07-13-94 District Reviewed/3,634.89 acres 8 years 04-12-95 Addition/60.21 acres 31695.10. 8 years 06-18-2002 5. Keswick 09-03-86 District Created/5,223.11 acres 10 years ~9-07-88 Addition/699.01 acres 10 years 01-16-91 Addition/263.00 acres 10 years 10-12-94 District Reviewed/6,063.81 acres 10 years 10-12-94 Addition/320.52 acres 10 years 04-12-95 Addition/17.38 acres 10 years 08-13-97 Addition/190.872 6,592.58 10 years 09-03-2004 6. Kinloch 09-03-86 District Created/1,586.60 acres 10 years 05-02-90 ~dditipn/63.40 acres 10 years 04-14-93 ~ddition/34.17 acres 10 years 11-17-93 Add t on/3.81 acres 10 years 10-12-94 District Reviewed/1,683.96 acres 10 year.~ 10-12-94 Additon/393.16 acres 2,077.12 10 years 09-03-2004 7. Moorman's River 12-17-86 District Created/8,035.98 acres 10 years 09-07-88 Add t on/2,269.03 acres 10 years 01-04-89 Addition/173.69 acres 10 years 05-02-90 Addition/443.44 acres 10 years 04-14-93 Addition/170.45 acres 10 years 12-21-94 District Reviewed/9,989.36 10 years 04-12-95 Addition/330.00 acres 10 years' 08-09-95 Addition/59.92 acres 10 years 08-13-97 Additi0n/242.38 10 years 05-12-99 Addition/Il0.44 acres 10,732.10 215 10 years 12-17-2004 8. Hardware 11-04-87 District Created/6,023.94 acres 10 years 05-03~89 Addition/206.88 acres 10 years 11-12-97 Review/3856.031 acres i0 years 05-13-98 Addition/11.97 acres 3,868.00 10 years 11-12-2007 9. Jacob's Run 01-06-88 District Created/727.28 acres . · 6 yea~s 05-03-89 Addition/500.43 acres 6 years 03-02-94 District Reviewed/I,124.99 acres 6 years 09-10-96 Withdrawal/107.73 acres 1,017.26 6 years 01-06-2000 27 TABLE 3-5 (CONT.) ALBEMARLE COUNTY AGRICULTURAL/FORESTAL DISTRICTS NAME DATE ACTION/ACREAGE , CURRENT ACREAGE PARCELS REVIEW PERIOD RE. VIEW DATE 10. Car~er's Bridge 04-20-88 District Created/7,969.72 acres 10 years 10-31-90 Addition/3,692.36 acres 10 years 05-21-97 Addition/262.75 acres 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/9,004,16 acres 10 years 02-10-99 Addition/ 42.00 acres 10years 05-12-99 Addition/117.69 acres 9,163.85 10 years 04-20-2008 11. Lanark 04-20-88 District Created/996.05 acres 10 years 09-16-92 Addition/4,625.89 acres I 10 yea. rs 09-09-98 District Reviewed/5,633.52 acres I 10 years 02-10-99 Addition/39.71 acres ~ 10 years 94-20-2008 10-06-99 Addition/154.638 acres 5 827.87 · 10 years 12. Panorama 04-20-88 District Created/1,066.1 ! acres 10 years 06-14-95 Addition142.40 acres 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/265.40 acres 10 years 03-17-99 Addition/7.12 acres ~ 272.52 10 years 04-20-2008 13. Free Union 09-21-88 District Created/1,394.60 acres 10 years 01-04-89 Addition/30.01 acres . 10 years 05-15-91 Addition/716.37 acres . 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/I,379.27 1,379.27 10 years 09-21-2008 14. Ivy Creek 11-02-88 District Created/578.03 acres 7 years 04-14-93 WithdraWal/55.17 acres~ 7 years 02-14-96 Review/494.860 acres 494.86 7 years 02-14-2003 15. Buck Mountain 01-04-89 District Created/633.35 acres 10 years 04-12-95 Addition/26.89 acres 10 years 01-13-99 Review/488.92 acres 10 years 01-04-2009 10-06-99 Addition/13.55 acres 502.47 10 years 16. Yellow Mountain 03-08-89 D st-ict CreatedJ975.52 acres 10 years r06--24--96~Vithdrawal/275.55 acres 10 years 01-13-99 Review/681.29 acres 10 years 05-12-99 Addition/43.77 acres 10 years 05-12-99 Withdrawal/84.00 acres 641.06 10 years 03-08-2009 17. Chalk Mountain 09-06-89 D str ct Created/1,272.47 acres 10 years 10-06-9fl Revi,w/1,272.47 acres 1,272.47 10 y,ars 09-06-2009 18. Sugar Hollow 09-06-89 District Created!2,581.97 acres ~ 10 years 06-01-90 Addition/697.72 acres . 10 years 04-14-93 Addition/I,524.32 acres 10 years 11-17-93 Addition/55.79 acres 10 years 10-06-99 Review/4,729.14 acres 4,729.14 10 years 09-06-2009 19. Batesville 05-02-90 District Created/906.51 acres 906.51 10 years 05-~02-2000 20. High Mowing 01-16-91 [:)istrict Created/622.44 acres 622.44 10 years 01-16-2001 21. Pasture Fence Mtn. 11-17-93 District Created/870.42 acres I10 years 07-13-94 Addition/453.50 acres 1,323.92 10 years 11-17-2003 22. N. Fork Moorman's River 11-17-93 District Crea{ed/270.48 acres 270.48 10 years 11-17-2003 '23. Nortonsville Local 10-06-99 District Created/92.575 acres 92.58 8 years 10-06-2007 24. South Garden '10-06-99 District Created/2,033.33 acres 2,033.33 7 years 10-06-2006 TOTAL 65,426.91 Acres 14.07% of 465,040 acres in Albemarle County Updated 05-04-2000 IV.ZONING AND CO REHENSIVE PLAN MODIFICATIONS A. 1999 REZONING ACTIVITY This section of the Development Activity Report is a review of zoning changes that were approved bY the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors in 1999. The ability to modify the Zoning Ordinance provides flexibility in land use regulations. The purpose of these actions is to mitigate unreasonable hardships imposed by the ordinance, to recognize compatibility with neighboring uses, and to acknowledge changes in growth patterns that affect the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. A total of 130.71 acres were rezoned in 1999 as a result of 14 Zoning Map Amendment applications, which resulted in 6 Zoning Map modifications (see Table 4-1). The most significant rezoning, in terms of acreage, occurred in Rural Area 2 with 75 acres rezoned from RA and R-1 to PRD. The amount of acreage rezoned by zoning map amendment throughout the County significantly decreased in 1999 from. a total of 250.65 acres rezoned in 1998. 29 TABLE 4-1 APPROVED ZONING I~AP AMENDMENTS, 1999 (changes to zoning classifications) COMP PLAN AREA PREVIOUS NEW ACRES ZONING ZONING Hollymead RA R-4 23.62 Neighborhood 1 R-6 C-1 4.55 Neighborhood 3 R-6 HC 1.50 Neighborhood 3 RA PRD 19.94 Neighborhood 4 PUD R-1 6.06, Rural Area 2 R-l, RA PRD 75.05 ~ TOTAL ACREAGE REZONED 130.71 3O B. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MODIFICATIONS IN 1',999 There were two Comprehensive Plan Amendments adopted in 1999. The first, the Natural Environment amendment, was part of a state mandated 5-year review, and the second is associated with the development of the Ashcroft subdivision. The Albemarle County Board of Supervisors adopted a revised Land Use Plan in June 1996. This revised plan incorporated several changes from the previous plan. The new Land Use Plan places an increased emphasis on promoting infill development of a more urban scale within the Development Areas. To achieve this goal the Plan recommends: · :. Achieving higher gross densities of development in the Development Areas Encouraging mixed use developments Encouraging neighborhood style development and design Encouraging road development and design to be of a scale more in keeping with surrounding neighborhoods which also accommodates multiple modes of transportation such as bicycle, pedestrian and mass transit · ,*o Encouraging interconnection of neighborhoods with provision of walkways, bikeways, open space -- areas, and neighborhood scale street systems Emphasizing the provision of necessary public facilities and services to support such scale of development including water, sewer, and recreation facilities. In January 1997, in an attempt to implement these recommendations, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors instituted the Development Areas Initiative Project. Through participation in Project activities, residents and citizens will determine the physical qualities a new development should have and how that new development should relate to existing neighborhoods and commercial centers in the urban areas. At the end of the project, the County will have a "master plan" for the neighborhoods, communities, and villages to guide future developments in those areas. This "master plan" will also assist the County to know what zoning and subdivision ordinance changes will be needed in order to implement the infill goal outlined in the new Land Use Plan. V. APPENDIX RA RA 3 1 NORTH ~ RA 4 OF SCOTTSVILLE .AO RA 2 ALBEMARLE . C~3~JNTY, VIRGINIA/~' Comprehensive Plan. Eand Use Plan currmT DeveLoPmeNt ^~eas B NFtGHBORHOODS 1 - 7 ~'  VILLAGES R A ~u~ , PRIVARY ROADS ~ IHT~R~AT~ HICH~Y ........... STRatUS ~ U.S. HIGhWaY ....... COUNTY BOUNDARY ~ VA. PRIMARY HIGH~AY INCORPORATED TOWN ....... OR City BOUNDARY ~ VA. SECONDARY EPARED BY' varLment of Plannin! and Community Development · Office of Mapping, Graphics and Information Resources {OOMGAIRI Coun[y Urban Area of Albemarle Neighborhoods 1-7 \ IVY RE) [TY / / ? / ,/ ? PREPARED BY: ' Department of Plannin/~ and Community Development * Office of Mapping, Graphics and Information Resources ¢OOMGAIR) C~ZET HALL DISTRICT FRE, I!~ PRECINCT RIO FR. EE BRIDGE PRECINCT .~RECrNCT % % % % \ \ \ tNORTH OF % ALBEMARLE . ViI:tGiNiA~_-,~ - COUNTY, MAGISTERIAL DISTRICTS I,~dopt. ed May 15th, 1991 lmended June 2nd. 1993 ~, ~lay 7, JACK JOUETT RIO RIVANNA SAMUEL SCOTTSVILLP. WHITE HALL PR~KCT 90UIIDLR2~S EPARED BY: oartment of Plannin~ and Community Devetoomen[ · Office of MaDoini. GraDhics and Information Resources TYPE OF RESIDENCE Single-family residenee 1 building, 1 lot, 1 dwellin~ unit bldg. 1 lo: Examples: Single-family attached 1 building, 2 lots, 2 dwelling units I lot 2 lot North Pines Earlysville Forest Wynridge Oak Forest Camelia Garden Georgetown Court Commonwealth Drive Briarwood e Single-family townhouse 1 building, 3 or more lots, 3 or more dwelling units ! lot 2 lot .3 lot Townwood Birnam Wood Minor Hill Duplex 1 building, 1 lot, 2 dwelling units 1 bldg. I Exam pies: Whitewood Multi-residence 1 building, 1 lot, 3 or more dwelling units 4 '$' bldg. [ lot Exam pies: Old Oak Court Huntington Village COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE 2000 DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY REPORT STATISTICAL ABSTRACT Res/dent/a/Bu//ding Permits Residential building permits issued in 2000 totaled 650 dwelling units. This number is somewhat lower than the level of building activity observed since 1990. The lowest level of activity occurred in 1995 wl~en only 596 building permits were issued. · Of the 650 new housing starts in 2000, 369 dwelling units (57%) were Iocatedin Designated Development Areas and 231 dwelling units (43%)were located in the Rural Areas. · Residential building permits issued in 2000 were composed of the following types of dwelling units: 83 % conventional single-family detached - 10 % single-family attached 1% single-family townhouse 0 % multi-family units 4 % mobile homes located throughout the County - 2 % accessory apartments · Of the 540 single-family detached units created from new building permits issued, 287 (53%) were located in the Development Areas and 253 (47%) were located in the Rural Areas. · Mobile homes accounted for 6% (17 total) of all building permits issued for dwelling units in the Rural Areas - down from 8% in 1999. · Accessory apartments accounted for less than 2% (13 total) of building permits issued for dwelling units in 2000. Res/dent/a/Subdiv/s/ons · 98 subdivision 'plats-were signed'in 2000 creating 567 new lots. · Of the 567 new lots created, 320 (56%) were located in the Development Areas and 247 (43%) were located in the Rural Areas. · 196 (79%) of new Rural Area lots were development right lots of less than 21 acres. The average lot size of the 567 new lots created in 2000 decreased significantly to 13.0~ acres from 23.18 acres in 1999. In 2000, the average new lot size in the Designated Development Areas (302 lots) decreased to 1.12 acres, and the average new lot size in the Rural Areas (247 lots) decreased to.23.49 acres. This is due to a significant decrease in the number of lots created in new subdivisions. $/te Development Plans · One major residential site development plan, Woods Edge, was signed in. 2000, representing 90 units. 40 major non-residential site development plans were signed in 2000. These plans represented 146,945 square feet of commercial/retail services space, 19;288 square feet of industrial space, 267,005 square feet of office space, and 109,810 square feet of public/institutional space. Land Use Taxat/°n and Agricu/tura//Foresta/ D/stricts Landowners have enrolled 21% of the Designated Development Areas, and 68% of the Rural Areas in the land use taxation program as of December 31, 2000. The total area in the land use taxation program comprises approximately 66% of Albemarle County. As of December 31st, 2000, the land area voluntarily enrolled by rural landowners in agricultural and forestal districts represented approximately 15% of the acreage in Albemarle County's Rural Areas. Zon/ng · A total of 84.18 acres were rezoned in 2000. Glenmore, in Rivanna Village, accounted for 38 acres of the total rezoned acreage. TABLE OF CONTENTS I. 'INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................... 1 II. RESIDENTIAL ACTIVITY .................................................................................................................... 2 2. 3. 4. 5. B. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. C. BUILDING PERMIT ACTIVITY .............................................................................................................. 2 OVERVIEW .............................................................................................................................................. 2 BUILDING PERMITS BY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DEVELOPMENT AREA ................................................. 2 BUILDING PERMITS BY DWELLING UNIT TYPE ...................................................................................... 5 BUILDING PERMITS BY MAGISTERIAL DISTRICT .................................................................................... 5 RESIDENTIAL BUILDING ACTIVITY COMPARISON .................................................................................. 5 S UBD1VISION .4 CTIVITY ...................................................................................................................... 10 OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................................................ l 0 ANALYSIS OF SIGNED PLATS ................................................................................................................ 10 HISTORIC COMPARISON OF SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY - SIGNED PLATS ................................................. 13 SIGNED PLATS - PUBLIC VS. PRIVATE ROADS ............. : ........................................................................ 13 RURAL PRESERVATION DEVELOPMENT ............................ ' ................................................................... 17 SITE PL,4N ,4 CTIVITY ............................................................................................................................ 18 III. INVENTORY OF LAND USE ................................................................................................................ 2.22 IVe 2000 REZONING ACTIVITY ................................................................................................................... 29 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MODIFIC'4 TIONS IN 2000 ...................................................................... 31 111 LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1: Comprehensive Plan Area - Actual Dwellings Summary, 1996-2000 .................................................. 3 Table 2-2: Dwelling Units by Comprehensive Plan Area by Building Permits Issued in 2000 ............................. 4 Table 2-3: Number of Dwelling Units by Magisterial District by Building Permits Issued in 2000 ...................... 7 Table 2-4: Building Permit Activity Comparison, ] 993-2000 ............................................................................... 8 Table 2-5: Total Number of New Dwelling Units from Building Permits Issued, 1981-2000 ............................... 9 Table 2-6: Residential Subdivision Activity in 2000 - Signed Plats ..................................................................... 11 Table 2-7: Distribution by Size (Acreage) Based on Signed Plats Located in the Rural Areas, 1998-2000 ........ 12 Table 2-8: Changes in Subdivision Activity, 1989-2000 - Signed Plats .............................................................. 14 Table 2-9: Rural Area Average Lot Size, 1997-2000 (Development Right Lots) ................................................ 15 Table 2-10:2000 Signed Plats - New Public and Private Roads .......................................................................... 16 Table 2-11: Rural Preservation Developments, 1990-2000 .................................................................................. 19 Table 2-12: Major Residential Site Plans Approved in 2000 ............................................................................... 20 'Fable 2-13: Major Non-residential Site Plans Approved in 2000 ........................................................................ 21 Table 3-1: Residential Land Use Summary, 2000 ................................................................................................ 23 Table 3-2: Commercial and Industrial Land Use Summary, 2000 .........................................................- .............. 24 Table 3-3: Acreage in Land Use Taxation by Year and Land Use Type, 1982-2000 ........................................... 25 Table 3-4: Estimate of Distribution of County Land Under Land Use, 2000 ....................................................... 26 Table 3-5: Agricultural/Forestal Districts ............................................................................................................. 27 Table 4-1: Approved. Zoning Map Amendments, 2000 ........................................................................................ 30 iv INTRODUCTION The Development Activity Report is an annual review of the residential, commercial, and industrial development applications approved by the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors, Planning Commission, Board of Zoning Appeals, Department of Planning and Community Development, and Building Codes and Zoning Services. This review in no way represents actual development in the County, it simply reflects serious development interests. Throughout the year, numerous actions are taken regarding building permits, subdivision plats, site development plans, and changes to zoning regulations. This report tracks these actions and analyzes where trends of two or more years are occurring. The location of new residential and commercial interest is not only important to planners, but is also useful information for those involved in rural preservation, commercial development, or marketing activities. In June of 1996, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors adopted the 1996-2016 Land Use Plan. This Land Use Plan is similar in many ways to the previous Plan. However, the Villages of Earlysville and North Garden were eliminated in the Plan as Designated Development Areas. Development information for these eliminated areas has been incorporated in information about Rural Areas 1 and 3, respectively. It is important'to point out that an amendment to the Plan, approved in December of 1989, created the Village of Rivanna Development Area. In this report, some of the data previously attr, buted to Rural Area 4 is now shown as belonging to the Rivanna Village. Additions have also been made to the Development Areas of Piney Mountain and Hollymead. Piney Mountain was upgraded from a Village designation to a Community. It is also important to note that the Community of Scottsville Development Area was eliminated with the adoption of the 1996-2016 Comprehensive La,c.,d Use Plan since a significant portion of the Area was incorporated into the Town of Scottsville by boundary adjustment on January 1, 1994. This report is divided into three major sections. The first section addresses residential development by analyzing where building permit, subdivision, and site plan activity has occurred. The next section describes inventories of residential, commercial, and industrial zoned land along with the distribution of County land in preferential land use taxation. The third section presents zoning map amenctments and amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. As ~n past reports, one purpose of the Development Activity Report is to evaluate the effectiveness of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance, adopted December 10, 1980. An objective of the Zoning Ordinance is to encourage development in the Designated Development Areas (these specific Development Areas.-are .described in .detail in-the Comprehensive Plan). While the Comprehensive Plan outlines goals and objectives for effectively managing Albemarle County's growth, the Zoning Ordinance provides the legal structure by which the goals and objectives are accomplished. For the purooses of this report, 2000 development activity comparisons will be made to the 1996-2016 Land Use Plan. II. RESIDENTIAL ACTIVITY BUILDING PERMIT ACTIVITY 1.. Overview The annual number of new residential dwelling units is an important indicator of growth in a locality. For this report,' the number of building permits' issued for new residential structures is a measure of new dwelling units to be built in Albemarle County. Though the total level of activity from one year to the next is ascertained from building permit volumes, the distribution of new housing by location and by type can also be analyzed from information provided on a permit. The location and type of dwelling relative to existing utilities, public facilities, and infrastructure provides direction for long-term planning efforts. 2. Building Permite by Comlareheneive Plan Development Area in 2000, the number of new dwelling units from building permits totaled 650 (see Table 2-1). This total represents a decrease of 120 dwelling units from the 1999 total of 770. Overall the total number of building permits issued has decreased steadily since 1997. Designated Development Areas (Urban Areas, Communities, and Villages) accounted for 57% (369) of all new 'dwelling units in 2000. The Urban Area, consisting of Urban Neighborhoods 1-7, accounted for 29% (189 units) of the total 650 new dwelling units in 2000, nearly thirty less than last year. Of the 189 new units located in the Urban Area, 74 were located in Urban Neighborhood 2 (see Table 2-2). The amount of activity in the Communities decreased slightly. The average number of new dwelling units since 1990 is 162 per year. In 2000, the Communities represented 180 units or 20% of the total number of new units in the County. The Community of Hollymead once again showed a noteworthy amount of new dwelling unit building activity. In 2000, Hollymead accounted for 75 (12%) of the 'County's total new dwelling units. This made it the largest concentration of new building activity in the Designated Develcpment Areas. The adoption of the revised Land Use Plan component of the Comprehensive Plan in June 1996 elir;~inated two Village designations leaving only one Village in the Plan (Rivanna). The number of dwelling units from building permits in the Village of Rivanna, mainly due to the continued development of the Glenmore subdivision, accounted for 50 units or 8% of the total new dwelling units permitted. In the Rural Areas, the percentage of dwelling units created from new building permits issued accounted for 43% (281 units) of all permits issued within the County. This is about average for the last seven years. Although building activity was focused in the Designated Development Areas in 2000, the total number of building permits issued throughout the County in 2000 was Iow. TABLE 2-1 COMPREHEN,~IVE PLAN AREA - ACTUAL DWELLINGS SUMMARY 1996-2000 ACTUAL DWELLINGS AND DISTRIBUTION (from Building Reports) COMP PLAN AREAI 1996 I 1997 '1 1998 I 1999 2000 I ! Urban Areas 401 48% 376 42% 367 42% 218 28% 189 29% Communities 140 17% 195 22% 158 18% 167 22% 130 20% Villages 63 8% 62- 7% 63 7% 49 6% 50 8% Rural Areas 231 28% 272 30% 286 33% 336 44% 281 43% TOTAL 835 100% 905 100%' 874 100%. 770 100% 650 100% · TABLE 2-2 DWELLING UNITS BY cOMpREHENSIVE PLAN AREA BY BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED IN 2000 % OF COMP PLAN AREA SF SFA SF/TH DUP MF MH AA TOTAL UNITS TOTAL ~ I URBAN RURAL UNITS Urban Neighborhood I 0 0 0 0 0 0 ' 0 0 0.0% Urban Neighborhood 2 '58 10 6 0 0 0 0 74 11.4% Urban Neighborhood 3 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 3.4% Urban Neighborhood 4 22 20 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 42 6.5% Urban Neighborhood 5 38 8 0 0 0 0 0 46 7.1% Urban Neighborhood 6 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.6% Urban Neighborhood 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0.2% Crozet Community I 51 2 0 0 0 0 0 53 8.2% Hollymead Community 44 21 0 0 0 9 1 75 11.5% Piney Mountain Community 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.3% Rivanna Village ' 50 0 0 0 0 0 0 50 7.7% DEVELOPMENT AREA SUBTOTALI 287 65 6 0 0 9 2 369 56.8% Rural Ai'ea 1 61 0 0 0 0 5 1 67 10.3% Rural Area 2 54 0 0 0 0 0 3 57 8.8% Rural Area 3 79 0 0 0 0 5 3 87 13.4% Rural Area 4 59 0 0 0 0 7 4 70 10.8% RURALAREA SUBTOTAL I 253 0 0 0 0 17 11 281 43.2% TOTAL 540 65 6 0 0 26 13 650 100.0% KEY TO TYPES OF HOUSING: SF- Single-Family (includes Modular) ~DUP- Duplex AA-Accessory Apartment SFA- Single-Family Attached :MF- Multi-Family SF/TH- Single-Family Townhouse MH- Mobile Home I~uilain0 ?straits by Pwellin0 Unit Typ~ ~ As in previous years, the highest percentage of 2000 residential building permit activity occurred in the category of single-family detached homes, including modular homes (see Table 2-2). In 2000, 83% (540 units)of all building permits issued for dwelling units were for single-family homes. Single- family detached homes as a percentage of total dwelling units increased by 6% from 1999. In the Rural Areas, 90% of all dwelling units were single-family detached homes. In the Designated Development Areas, 77% of all dwelling units were single-family detached homes. The total number of single-famiiy attached dwelling units decreased from 81 units in 1999 to 65 units in 2000. Neighborhood 4 in the Urban Areas accounted for 20% of the 65 new single-family attached units. Of all building permits issued for new dwelling units in Albemarle County, 10% were for single-' family attached units. The total number of single-family townhouses decreased to 6 units in 2000 from 58 units in 1999. Of all building permits issued for dwelling units in Albemarle County, only 1% were for single-family townhouses. As in 1999, there were no multi-family permits issued in 2000. Building permits were issued in !998 for 184 multi-family dwelling units. In 1997, building permits were issued for 208 units; in 1996, building permits were issued for 226 units; no multi-family permits were issued in 1995. 4. i~uilding Permits by Magisterial District The magisterial district boundaries used in this report are those which were revised on May 15, 1991, as a result of the release of the Census Bureau population figures for Albemarle County (see reference map in Appendix). Of the six magisterial districts, the Rivanna district recorded the highest level of residential building activity in 2000 with 244 permits issued for new dwelling units, accounting for 38% of all new dwelling units (see Table 2-3). The White Hall district recorded the second highest level of residential building activity in 2000 with 129 permits issued for new dwelling units, accounting for 20% of all new dwelling units. The Samuel Miller district closely followed this with 119 permits issued for new dwelling units, representing 18% of the new dwellings units in the County. The Jack Jouett district had the lowest level of residential building permits with less than 2% (12 units) of the total number of new dwelling units in Albemarle County in 2000. 5. Residential Building Activity Comparison The average number of total dwelling units for which building permits were issued between 1993 and 2000 was 797 units (see Table 2-4). The 2000 total of 650 units represents a below average year for building activity as compared to the eight-year average. In the Urban Area (Neighborhoods 1-7), Neighborhood 2 accounts for the largest amount of building activity. Among the Communities, the Community of Hollymead continues to account for the majority of the residential building activity. On average, over an eight-year period, the Community of Hollymead has accounted for 64% of all residential building activity in the Communities. In 1999, Neighborhood 2 and the Community of Hollymead accounted for 40% of all residential growth in the Designated Development Areas. Thetotal number of permits issued for new residential dwelling units located in the Rural Areas of the Cot~nty decreased from 336 in 1999 to 201 in 2000. This decrease represents an erratic trend, 5 during the last decade, in which the number of new dwelling units in the Rural Areas has varied from year to year. Total dwelling units in the Rural Areas have totaled between 231 and 286 dwelling units annually, since 1993, with the exception of 1999. Overall, the 650 building permits issued in 2000'for residential dwelling units represents a below average year for housing permit activity over the last twenty years (see Table 2-5) as from 1981 to 2000 an average of 781 permits were issued annually. TABLE 2-3 NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS BY MAGISTERIAL DISTRICT BY BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED IN 2000 MAGISTERIAL SF SFA SF/TH DUP MF MH AA TOTAL % OF TOTAL' DISTRICTS UNITS UNITS Rio ' 42 0 0 0 0 0 1 43 7% Jack Jouett 10 0 0 0 0 0 2 12 2%' Rivanna 192 33 ,~ 6 0 0 10 3 244 38% Samuel Miller 101 10 0 0 0 3 5 119 18% Scottsville 76 20 0 0 0 6 I 103 16% White Hall 119 2 0 0 0 7 1 129 20% TOTAL 540 65 6 0 0 26 13 650 100% KEY TO TYPES OF HOUSING: SF- Single-Family (includes Modular) DUP-Duplex AA- Accessory Apts SFA-Single-Familty Attached MF-Multi-Family SF/TH-Single-Family Townhouse MH-Mobile Home · . TABLE 2-4 BUILDING PERMIT ACTIVITY COMPARISON 1993-2000 r COMPPLAN AREA 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 TOTAL % OF #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS #UNITS TOTAL Urban Neighborhood 1 60 0 0 0 48 23 1 0 132. 2% Urban Neighborhood 2 85 210 97 99 234 69 86 74 .954 15% Urban Neighborhood 3 1 4 0 20 5 177 41 22 270 4% Urban Neighborhood 4 85 219 48 264 48 48 44 42 798 ' 13% Urban Neighborhood 5 20 14 11 15 36 36 44 46 222 3% Urban Neighborhood 6 2 2 2 3 5 14 2 4 34 1% Urban Neighborhood 7 12 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 · 14 0% URBAN AREAS SUBTOTAL 265 450 158 401 376 367 218 189 2,424 38% Crozet Community 72 40 35 37 59 48 56 53 400 6% Hollymead Community 122 123 94 91 134 96 95 75 830 13% Piney Mountain Community 1 10 8 12 2 14 16 2 65 1% COMMUNITIES SUBTOTAL 195 173 137 140 195 158 167 130 1,295 20% I Rivanna Village 77 77 48 63 62 63 49 50 489 8% V LLAGE .SUBTOTAL 77 77 48 63 62 63 49 50 · 489 8% DEVELOPMENT AREA TOTALI 537 I 700 I 343 I 604 I 633 I 588 I 434 I 369 I 4,208 I 66% Rural Area 1 63 65 68 57 77 79 67 67 543 9% Rural Area 2 52 51 39 45 46 53 89 57 432 7% Rural Area 3 80 68 69 75 66 81 108 87 634 10% Rural Area 4 73 55 77 54 83 73 72 70 557 9% RURAL AREATOTAL I 268 I 239 I 253 I 231 I272 I 2861336128112'166134%1 TABL~i~;$ ! TOTAL NUMBER OF NEW DWELLING UNITS FROM BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED 1981-2000 YEAR NUMBER OF # CHANGE FROM DWELLING UNITS PREVIOUS YEAR 1981 598 , 1982 482 ~ -116; 1983 1,063 581 1984 725 -338 1985 714 -11 1986 737 23 1987 654 -83 1988 673 19 1989 1,309' 636 1990 804 -505 1991 614 -190 1992 866 252 1993 805 -61 1994 939 134 1995 596 ~343 1996 835 239 1997 905 70 1998 .874 ·-31 · 1999 770· -104 · 2000 650 -120 TOTAL 15,613 AVerage 1981-1990: ·775.9 Dwelling Units/Year Average 1991-2000: 785.4 Dwelling Units/Year · Average 1981-2000': 780.7 Dwelling Units/Year B. SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY 1. Overview As the County of Albemarle continues to experience growth, there will be continued residential development in the area. The best mechanism for tracking developments is through the analysis of subdivision activity, given that a precursor to a residential development is most commonly the subdividing of land into multiple lots for individual dwelling unit construction. For the purposes of this report, the definition of a subdivision is limited to the division of a parcel of land, including re-divisions, which results in at least one (1) new residential building lot. The creation of condominium lots is separated from that of other residential lots in the analysis of this report. Condominium lots do not include acreage as part of the individual lot; therefore, it would be misleading to include them in calculations such as average lot size. This section of the 2000 Development Activity Report examines the characteristics of new residential building lots through subdivision activity during the year and includes data for plats signed for recordation. Not all subdivision plats approved by the Planning Department are subsequently recorded in the Courts, therefore, adding together all current and historical new lots reported in this, and prior, Development Activity Reports, would result in an over-estimation or "double counting" of the actual number of lots in the County. Also, properties may be subject to repeated subdivision activity and therefore current and historical acreage subdivided cannot be added, since this would result in over-estimation of total acreage divided in the County. 2. Analysis of Signed Flats In 2000, 98 residential subdivision plats were signed and 567 new lots were created (see Table 2-6). The Designated Development Areas accounted for 19% of the signed plats, 56% of the new residential building lots created, and 5% of the total acres subdivided in 2000. The major subdivisions in the Designated Development Areas that contributed a significant number of new lots were Glenmore (72 lots) and Waylands Grant (49 lots). The Rural Areas accounted for 81% of the total number of residential subdivision plats signed, 44% of the new lots created, and 95% percent of the total acreage subdivided in 2000 (see Table 2-6). The 79 new subdivisions in the Rural Areas in 2000 is among the lower levels of subdivision activity that the County has experienced since 1986. The number of new lots .in the Rural Areas was lower than has been observed in the last two years, (98 lots in 1998 and 95 lots in 1999.) HOwever, the total acreage subdivided in the Rural Areas increased from 6,487 acres in 1999 to 7,038 acres in 2000. This is mostly due to several rural divisionS in the Rural Areas. In many of these divisions, several hundreds of acres were divided into one or two parcels. Therefore these numbers grossly inflated the total acreage, and consequently increaSe the average acreage size. The distributiOn of new Rural Area lots by size is shown in Table 2-7. Thirty percent of new lots created were between 2 and 9.99 acres in size. A total of 44 new lots were created in the 2 to 4.99- acre range, representing 18% of the total lots created in 2000. In the 5 to 9.99 acre range, 28 new lots were created, accounting for 11% of the total. The percentage of new lots created in 2000 in excess of 21 acres (21%) showed a marked decrease from those created in 1999 (42%). TABLE 2-6 RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY IN 2000 - SIGNED PLATS COMP PLAN AREA SUBDIVISIONS NEW LOTS TOTAL ACREAGE # % # % Acres % Urban Neighborhood 1 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00 0.00% Urban Neighborhood 2 2 2.0% 32 5.6% 16.95 0.23% .Urban Neighborhood 3 5 5.1% 34 ' 6.0% 111.00 1.50% Urban Neighborhood 4 1 1.0% 3 0.5% 4.91 0.07% Urban Neighborhood 5 0 0.0% 0. 0.0% 0.00 0.00% Urban Neighborhood 6 1 1.0% 1 0.2% 0.33 0.00% Urban Neighborhood 7 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00 0.00% 'SUBTOTAL 9 - 9.2% 70 12.3% 133.19 1.80% Crozet Community 4 4.1% 98 17.3% 78.38 1~06% Hollymead Community 5 5.1% 80 14.1% 79.23 1.07% Piney Mountain Community 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 0.00 ,0.00% SUBTOTAL 9 9.2% 178 31.4% 157.62 2.13% Rivanna Village 1 1.0% 72 12.7% 66.47 0.90% SUBTOTAL 1 1.0% 72 12.7% 66.47 0.90% DEVELOPMENT AREA SUBTOTAL 19 19.4% 320 56.4% 357.27 4.83% RuralArea 1 25 25.5% 71 12.5% 1,702.95 23.03% F~uralArea 2 17 17.3% 70 12.3% 2,008.38 27.16% Rural Area 3 14 14.3% 26 4.6% 607.16 8.21% RuralArea4 23 23.5% 80 14.1% 2,719.70' 36.78% RURAL AREA SUBTOTAL 79 80.6% 247 43.6% 7,038.20 95.17% TOTAL 98 100.0% 567 100.0% 7,395.47 100.00%. TABLE 2-7 DISTRIBUTION BY SIZE (ACREAGE) BASED ON SIGNED PLATS AS DESIGNATED IN THE 1996 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN LOCATED IN THE RURAL AREAS, ~1998-2000 · 1998 1999 2000 RANGE IN ACRES NEW LOTS % OF TOTAL NEW LOTS % OF TOTAL NEW LOTS 1% OF TOTAL CREATED RURAL LOTS CREATED RURAL LOTS CREATED RURAL LOTS Under 2.0 1 1% 13' 9% 0 0% 2.0 to 4.99 43 23% 15 10% 44 18% 5.0 to 9.99 26 14% 38 26% ,28 11% 10.0 to 20.99 33 17% 20 14% 124 50% 21.0 and Over 88 ,46% 62 42% 51 21% TOTAL 191 100% 148 100% 247 100% 12 Historic Comparison 'of Subdivision Activity - Signed Plats The comparison of subdivision activity in 2000 to that of previous years is a useful tool for identifying growth patterns (see Table 2-8). In 2000, there was a decrease in the'total number of new residential subdivision plats signed from 122 in 1999 to 97 (see Table 2-8). But there was also a noticeable 'increase in the total number of new residential building lots created through subdivision activity from 301 new lots in 1999 to 567 lots in 2000. The Designated Development Areas accounted for 320 of the 567 new lots in 2000, which represents an increase of 109% since 1999. These account for 56% of total lots, a slight increase from 51% in 1999. The total acreage subdivided in the Development Areas decreased from 491 acres in 1999 to357 acres in 2000. This decrease in acreage subdivided and increase in the number of new lots created has resulted in a lower average lot size for 2000 (1.12 acres vs. 3.21 acres in 1999). This new average is consistent with 1997-1998. Urban Neighborhoods 1-7 accounted for 70 new lots, the Communities accounted for 178 new lots, and Rivanna Village accounted for 72 new lots in 2000. In the Rural Areas, the 247 new lots created in 2000 represent an increase of 67% from the 1999 total of 148 new lots. The 247 new lots created by signed plat in 2000 are higher than the established trend observed in previous years in the Rural Areas. From 1987 to 1998, many of the Rural Area subdivisions created only one (1) or two .(2) new lots each, and the average lot size tended to be larger, ranging from 7 to nearly 15 acres (see Table 2-8). In the years prior to 1987, the number of new lots created per subdivision was relatively high (3 to 5 lots per subdivision), and the resulting average lot size tended to be smaller: In 1995, the average lot size in the Rural Areas was 14.5 acres (the third largest after 1999 and 2000). The average lot size in the Rural Areas for 2000 Was 28.49 acres. The new average lot sizes for new Rural A~ea lots created with development rights (which exclude lots greater than or equal to 21 acres), from 1997 to 2000 appear in Table 2-9. Average lot sizes of those lots created with development rights in the Rural Areas have increased in Rural Areas 1,2 & 4. Meanwhile, lot sizes have decreased in Rural Area 3. 4. Signed Plats - Public vs. Private F, oads Effective January 1, 1984, the provisions in the Subdivision Ordinance regarding private roads were substantially amended to state that private roads would be the exception .to public road construction in subdivision developments. Prior to this amendment, the number of subdivisions on private roads was higher than the number with public roads. After the amendment was enacted, the distribution of subdivisions on public roads versus private roads generally began to favor public road development. In 2000, public road access for new lots exceeded private road access with 45% of all new lots utilizing public roads .while-28% involvedprivate roads. Twelve percent of new lots created in 2000 utilized both public and private roads (see Table 2-10). TABLE 2-8 CHANGES IN SUBDIVISION ACTIVITY 1989-2000 SIGNED PLATS COMP PLAN AREA 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 LIRBAN AREA Subdivisions 15 17 26 26 32 28 20 21 15 14 7 10 New Lots 200 162 190 234 191 171 162 179 129 55 75 70 Acreage 144.00 348.00 48.00 160.00 130.00 100.76 218.00 91.95 297.24 '222.24 176.72 133.19 * Average Lot Sizel 0.72. 2.15 0.25 0.68 0.68 0.59 1.3,~ 0.51 2.30 4.04 2.36 1.90 3OMMUNITIES Subdivisions 7 3 12 12 18 12 14 11 15 13 18 7 New Lots! 42 14 125 '127 272 135 208 40 143 138 76 178 Acreage 23.60 6.00 118.00 82.00 75.00 50.00 81.00 20.61 90.83 48.57 195.21 157.62 * Average Lot Size 0.56 0.43 0.94 0.65 0.28 0.37 0.39 0.52 0.64 0.35 2.57 0.89 VILLAGES Subdivisionsl 2 2 4 5 3 2 8 3 3 I 2 1 New Lots 2 27 16 314 20 2 73 82 42 51 2 72 Acreage 4.17 14,00 11.00 169.00 9.00 43.00 46.00 64,00 1351 22.13 119.04 66.47 * Average Lot Size' 2.09 0.52 ' 0.69 0.54 0.45 21.50 0.63 0.78 0.32 0.43 59.52 0.92 TOTAL DEVELOPMENT AREAE Subdiws~ons' 24 22 42 43 53 42 42 35 33 28 27 18 New Lotsl 244 203 331 675 483 308 443 301 314 244 153 320 Acreage 1.71.77 368.00 177.00 411.00 214.00 193.76 345.00 176.56 401.58 292.94 490.96 357.27 * Average Lot SizeI 0.70 1.81 0.53 0.61 0.44 0.63 0.78 0.59 1.28 1.20 3.21 1.12 RURAL AREA 1 Subdivisionsl 29 31 18 20 33 30 26 18 22 26 18 25 New Lots 59 82 42 27 70 87 ' 37 28 26 38 25 71 Acreage 993.35 584.00 316.0( 150.00 930.00 315.00 708.00 272.00 210.09 ' 399.24 912.40 1702.67 * Average Lot Sizel 16.84 7.12 7.52 5.56 13.29 3.62 19.14 9.71 8.08 10.51 36.50 23.9~ RURAL AREA 2 I Subdivisions 26 27 '25 25 21 21 13 18 17 20 20 17 New LotsI 51 48 30 38 36 36 20 33 75 27 38 70 Acreage 785.64 672.00 510.00 280.00 428.00 428.00 294.00 416.00 502.67 245.48 789.87 2008.38 * Average Lot Size 15.40 14.00 17.00 7.37 11.89 11.89 14.70 12.61 6.70 9.09 20.79 28.69 RURAL AREA 3 Subdivisions 34 · 37 34 44 34 33 28 27 33 29 23 14 New Lots 87 65 68 76 92 37 69 42 52 100 42 26 Acreage 862.12 733.00 550.00 873.00 460.00 794.00 732.00 313.00 461.89 1499.63 1606.02 607.16 * Average Lot Size 9.91 11.28 8.09 11.49 5.00 , 21.46 10.61 7.45 8.88 . 15.00 38.24 23.35 RURAL AREA 4 Subdivisions 25 33 37 37 35 11 33 29 28 23 34 23 New Lots 72 50 48 50 75 19 56 45 43 26 43 80 Acreage 591,00 880.00 '848.00 593.00 1387.00 254.00 910.00 546.00 366.72 276.44 3179.35 2719.70 * Average Lot Siz~ 8.21 17.60 17.67 11.86 18.49 13.37 16.25 12.13 8.53 10.63 73.94 34.00 ]'OTAL RURAL AREAS Subdivisiom 114 128 114 126 123 95 100 92 100 98 95 79 New Lots 269 245 188 191 273 179 182 148 196 191 148 247 Acreage 3232.11 2869.00 2224.00 1896.00 3205.00 1791.00 2644.00 1547.00 1541.37 2420.79 6487.65 7037.92 * Average Lot Size 12.02 11.71 11.83 9.93 11.74 10.01 14.53 10.45 7.86 12.67 43.84 28.49 3RAND TOTAL Subdivisions 138 150 156 169 176 t37 142 127 133 126 1;.'2 97 New Lots 513 448 519 866 756 487 625 449 510 435 301 567 Acreage 3403.88 3237.00 2401.00 2307.00 3419.00 1985.00 2989.00 1723.56 1942.95 2713.73 6978.61 7395.20 * Average Lot Size 6.64 7.23 4.63 2.66 4.52 4.08 4.78 3.84 3.81 6.24 23.18 13.04 Average Lot Size is not an indication of density. For each subdivision approved by the Planning Department, "Average Lot Size" was determined by summing open space acres and acreage in lots and dividing by the total number of new lots thereby resulting in a higher density than may actually exist. --~ 14 ~ TABLE 2-9 RURAL AREA AVERAGE LOT SIZE, 1997-2000' (Development Right Lots) COMPREHENSIVE 1997 1998 1999 2000 CHANGE AREA FROM 99-00 Rural Area 1 3.53 ac. 5.49 ac, 5.00 ac. 7.29 ac. 2.29 ac. RuralArea2 4.91 ac. 5.27 ac. 3.43 ac. 5.88 ac. 2.45 ac. RuralA. rea 3 5.88 ac. 8.84 ac. 10.64 ac. 10.12 ac. -0.51 ac. Rural Area4 4.34 ac. 4.29 ac. 6.58 ac. 7.80 ac. 1.22 ac. * Average Lot Size is not an indication of density. For each subdivision approved by the Planning Department, "Average Lot Size" was determined by summing open space acres and acreage in lots and dividing by the total number of new lots thereby resulting in a higher density than may actually exist. ]5 TABLE 2-10 NEW PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ROADS 1999 NEW LOTS BASED ON SIGNED PLATS #OF CLASSIFICATION OF ROADS i NEW % LOTS Public Roads 255 44.97 Private Roads I 157 27.69 Public / Private Roads 70 12.35 No Roads 85 14.99 TOTAL 567 100.00 5. l~ural ?reoervat, ion Development, The Rural Preservation Development was created as an alternative to the conventional development subdivision provisions set forth in Section 10 (Rural Areas District) of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance. The Rural Preservation Development option, added to the Zoning Ordinance in November 1989, is intended to encourage more effective land usage in terms of the goals and objectives for the Rural Areas as set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. Therefore, in addition to the 'standard subdivision provisions, which appear in the Zoning Ordinance, applications for Rural Preservation Developments are reviewed for the preservation of agricultural and forestal lands and activities; water supply protection; and/or conservation of natural, scenic, or historic resources. There were no rural preservation developments approved in 2000. (see Table 2-11). C' SITE PLAN ACTIVITY The approval of site development plans is another measure of growth in Albemarle County. This section of the Development Activity Report examines the site development plans that were signed in 2000. In 2000, one major residential site develOpment plan, for Woods Edge Apartments, totaling 90 new multi-family dwelling units, was signed (see Table 2-12). The 90 units approved by site development plan in 2000, was consistent with the 96 new units approved in 1999. Major non-residential site develoPment plans signed in 2000 appear in Table 2-13. Major site development plans included in the table, with the exception of pUblic/institutional plans, exceed 15,000 sq. ft. A total of 17 major non-residential site development plans were signed creating 548,094 square feet of commercial/retail, industrial, or public/institutional construction. Of the total square footage approved, 116,823 square feet was for commercial/retail services (as compared to 346,944 square feet approved in 1999); 0 squar.e feet for industrial (as compared to 22,510 square feet in 1999); 259,900 square feet for office services (as compared to 272,660 square feet approved in 1999); and 171,371 square feet for public/institutional services (as compared to 140,960 square feet approved in 1999). Four of the seventeen development plans approved in 2000 were located within Rural Areas,.this is an increase from the three approved in the Rural Areas in 1999. TABLE:2,!I : RURAL PRESERVATION DEVELOPMENTS, 1990-2000. COMP PLAN AREA 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 TOTAL RURAL AREA 1 Total Acreage 172.53 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00. 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00= 0.00 172.53 Number of Dev. Lots 37.00 0.00 0.00 ~ 0.00 0.00 0.00 -1.11 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 35.89 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 2.'58'0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 80.60 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.11 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 81.71 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RURAL AREA 2 TotalAcreage 0.00 0.00 132.90 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 :).00 O.00 0.00 132.90 Numberof Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 13.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 13.00 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 5.79 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 0.00 0.00 57.70' 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 '0.00 57.70 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RURAL AREA 3 Total Acreage 332.05 0.00 84.13 521.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 198.45 0.00 1,136.54 , Number of Dev. Lots 30.00. 0.00 7.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 16.00 0.00 93.00 Ave. Acreage of Dev: Lots 5.05 0.00 5.26 2.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.30 0.00 RPTAcreage 166.52 0.00 47.33 385.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 113.92 0.00 .713.20 Common Open Space Acreage 7.36 0.00 0.00 19.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26.56 RURAL AREA 4 TotalACreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0,00 0.00 Number of Dev. Lots 0.00 '0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 RPTAcreage 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Common Open Space Acreage 0.00 0,00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TotalAcreage 504.58 0.00 217.03 521.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 198.45 0.00 1,441.97 Number of Dev. Lots 67.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 -1.11 0.00 0.00 16.00 0.00 141.89 Ave. Acreage of Dev. Lots 7.53 0.00 10.85 13.05 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 12.40 0.00 RPTAcreage 247.12_: 0.00 105.03 385.43 0.00 0.00 1.11 0.00 0.00 113.92 0.00 852.61 Common Open Space Acreage 7.36 0.00 0.00 19.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26.56 TABLE 2-12 MAJOR RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANS APPROVED IN 2000 PROJECT NAME COMP PLAN AREA TYPE OF DWELLINGS NUMBER OF DWELLINGS WOods Edge Hollymead Multi-Family 90 TOTAL 90 TABLE 2-14 MAJOR NON-RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANS APPROVED IN 2000 ' AREA MAG ! COMP PLAN AREA PROJECT NAME USE (SQ FT) DISTRICT ! COMMERCIAL/RETAIL SERVICES RoseWood Village Assisted living facility 44,711 =,lo Neighborhood 2 International Auto Sport Warehouse and office space 40,000' ~ivanna Neighborhood 2 Brown Auto Group Minor Car wash 16,000 Rivanna · Rural Area 2 Shadwelt Antiquares Antique sales and restaurant 16,112 Rivanna Rural Area 2 SUBTOTAL 116,823 INDUSTRIAL SUBTOTAL 0,000 OFFICEwhitewood Office Park Office park -' 30,000 Rio . Neighborhood 1 . North Fork Town Center Office Building 69,900 Rivanna Piney Mtn Community Value America Office bu Iding 160,000! Rivanna Piney Mtn Community SUBTOTAL 259,900 PUBLIC/INSTITUTIONAL Northwoods at Four Seasons Pool 384 Jack Jouett Neighborhood 1 Charlottesville Catholic School Private School 42000 Rivanna Neighborhood 2 Still Meadow Swim & Tennis Club Swim and Tennis Facility 990 Rio Neighborhood 2 Blue Ridge Juvenile Detention Fac. Juvenile correctional facility 28726 Scottsville Neighborhood 3 Peabody School Add. & Alt. School 11295 Scottsville Neighborhood 4 Covenant School - Upper Campus Private school 57251 Scottsville Neighborhood 5 Trinity Presbyterian Church Church youth fellowship facility 17500 Samuel Miller Neighborhood 5 Boars Head' Inn Spa Addition Spa 4225 Samuel Miller, Ne ghborhood 6 Olivet Presbyterian Church Church expansion 2400 Samuel Miller Rural Area 1 Kenwood Library Library 6600 Scottsville Rural Area 4 SUBTOTAL 171,371 TOTAL 548,094 '2] III. INVENTORY OF LAND USE An inventory of residential, commercial, and industrial land was conducted to identify populaiion and commercial centers in Albemarle County (see Tables 3-1 and 3-2) in 2000. The analysis of the County's data was facilitated by the identification and grouping of developed and undeveloped properties in residential, commercial, and industrial categories. The purpose of this inventory is to examine the distribution of land uses in specific areas of the County. The inventory of residential, commercial, and industrial development was assembled with the aSsistance of the County's Comprehensive Information System (CIS); a database which stores parcel related data. The data represented in Tables 3-1 and 3-2 were revised for the 2000 Development Activity Report to reflect Zoning Map Amendments approved in 2000. The data in these tables does not incorporate changes due to development of parcels previously listed in the 1999 Development Activity Report as undeveloped. Therefore, these totals may over-estimate undeveloped property. Also included in this section of the Development Activity Report is an inventory of land currently in the Land Use Assessment Program (see Table 3-3 and 3-4). This program was created in 1971 when the Virginia General Assembly enacted a law permitting localities to adopt special assessments for properties in agriculture, forest, horticulture, and/or open space. The County land use ordinance was adopted in 1975. Since rural area preservation has been an expressed concern in Albemarle County, the inventory of parcels in land use is an estimate of at least part of the acreage currently being maintained in agriculture, forest, horticulture, and open space. The percentage of acreage in land use in 2000 accounts for 66% (see Table 3-3) of the total acreage within Albemarle County. Twenty-one percent of the total acreage within the Designated Development Areas is in land use (see Table 3-4). This represents no change from 1999. Sixty-eight percent of the total acreage of the Rural Areas is in land use, the same percentage as in 1999. In addition to enrollment in the Land Use Assessment Program, rural landowners also have the option of joining an Agricultural and Forestal District. Agricultural and Forestal Districts are created voluntarily by landowners. By joining an Agricultural and Forestal District, the landowner agrees not to subdivide or develop their property to a more intensive non-agricultural use during the period in which the property remains within a District. The Districts are approved for a period of 4 to 10 years, after which time they are eligible for re-approval. Increased activity in the creation of new Agricultural and Forestal Districts, as well as additions made to existing districts, prompted the listing of these districts in the Development Activity Report for the first time in 1987. The total acreage for all districts was 31,779 acres as of December 31, 1987. As of December 31st, 2000, a total of 64,470.53 acres were dedicated to Agricultural and Forestal Districts (see Table 3-5). This represents 14.56% of the area in the Rural Areas of Albemarle County, as designated by the 1996 Comprehensive Plan, a level consistent with 1999. 22 ~Z ~ 00~0~ ~ ~00 ~ 0 ~ i ~0~00~ ~ 0~0 ~ 0 ~ OZ ~ ~o~ooo~~ ~ o~ o~o~ ~ o ~ > ~0000 ~ 0 ~0 ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ 0~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~  ~ ~0 ~ 0 ~ ~00000 ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~0~~ ~ '~ 0 0 0 ~ z -- ~, 00~~ ~ ~ 0 0 ~ ~ N z Z ~ ~000~ ~ ~0 ~ 0 ~ ' ~ 0 0 ~ m ~ og~== ~ o~o ~> o~o~oo ~ ~o ~ o ~ > 0000000 0 000 0 0 0 > 0000000- 0 000 0 0 0 z gg§oooo o ~ o o ~ ~ 0o00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ooooooo ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~z ~ ~ 0 ~0~ ~ O~ ~ ~ 0 0 0~ ~ ~ ~ 0000000 0 0~0 ~ 0 0 0000 0 ~ ~Z ~ 0000000 0 0~0 ~ 0 0 0000 0 ~ 0000000 0 ~ 0 0 00~0 ~ ~ Z! 000000~ ~0~ 0 0 00~0 ~ ~ > o o ~ Z. ~ ~  ~ ~ 00~ O0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 ~ ~ O~ ~ ~ ~ ~~0000 ~ 000 0 0 0 0000 0 ~ ~ Z~z ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~oooo ~ ooo o o o oooo o'~ Z Z~ ~ ~ ~ > ~m~oo ~ ~o ~ o o oooo o ~ ~ ~0000 ~ ~0 ~ 0 0 000~ ~ ~ Z ~ ~~0 ~ ' ~00 0 0 0 0~ ~ ~ Z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~0 0 ~ '0 ~ 0 0 0~0~ ~ 0 0 ~ ~0~0 0 ~0 ~. 0 0 0000 0 ~ Z ~ ~ O~ ~ ~ ~0~ 0 0~0 ~ 0 0 ~0~0 ~ ~ ~ ~00 ~ ~ ~ Z ~ ~ ~' ooooooo ~ ~ ~ ~ ~mm~ ~ ~ o o ooo o o ~ e~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o.~ .~ ~ = = = I0 zzzzzzz 0~ ~ ~~ TABLE 3-3 ACREAGE IN LAND USE TAXATION BY YEAR AND LAND USE TYPE, 1982-2000 LAND USE TYPE PERCENTAGE YEAR OPEN TOTAL OF TOTAL AGRICULTURE HORTICULTURE FORESTRY SPACE COUNTY ACREAGE 1982 121,917 1,868 227,915 0 351,700 75.6% 1984 108,519 1,919 207,243 9 317,690 68.3% 1985 109,051 1,931 209,312 9 320,303 68.9% 1986 107,832 1,921 208,259 8 318,020 68.4% 1987 110,036 1,952 210,653 8 322,649 69.4% 1988 109,283 1,985 211,489 8 322,765 69.4% 1989 110,236 2,195 216,036 8 328,475 70.6% 1990 109,541 2,306 215,221 6 327,074 70.3% 1991 '109,440 ' 2,506 216,389 6 328,341 70.6% 1992 109,932 2,521 218,936 6 331,395 71.3% 1993 110,736 2,447 219,593 6 332,782 71.6% ~ 1994 101,819 2,392 200,950 63 305,224 65.6% ~ 1995 106,571 2,393 211,753 87 320,804 69.0% 1996 105,484 2,412 213,165 134 321,195 69.1% 1997 103,803 2,416 207,138 134 '313,491 67.4% 1998 101,925 2,296 202,370 108 ~ 306,699 66.0% 1999 107,090 2,026 t95,824 ~ 126 305,066 65.6% 2000 107,058 2,026 195,683 126 304,893 65.6% Note: Totals for 1983 are not available. Estimated total acreage of Albemarle County is 465,040. This estimate was calculated digitally in March 1998. Previous years were re-calculated, tO reflect this estimate. TABLE 3-4 ESTIMATE OF DISTRIBUTION OF COUNTY LAND UNDER LAND USE, 2000 ACREAGE ACREAGE IN NOT IN TOTAL LAND USE LAND USE DeVelopment Areas 4,752 17,544 22,296 Rural Areas 300,141 142,603 442,744 TOTAL 304,893 160,147 465,040 Notes: 1. Total County land area is based on a total area of 726.625 square miles x 640 acres per square mile = 465,040 acres. Approximately 14,000 acres of Rural Areas land, not in land use, is owned by the Federal government (Shenandoah National Park). 2. These estimates were calculated digitally. TABLE 3'-5. ALBEMARLE COUNTY AGRICULTURAL/FORESTAL DISTRICTS (As of December 31st, 2000) ' , CURRENT PARCELS REVIEW REVIEW DATE NAME DATE ACTION/ACREAGE ACREAGE PERIOD 1.Totier Creek 06-29-83 District Created/6,070.77 acres 10 years 06-29-91 District Reviewed/7,246.52 acres 10 years 09-16-92 Addition/I,392.22 acres 10 years 07-10-95 W'~hdrawal/764.08 10 years 09-11-00 Addition/174.084 10 years 06-20-01 Review/- 781.837 acres 7,007.79 10 years 06-29-2011 2. Hatton 06-29-83 District Created/2,913.69 acres 10 years 12-19-84 Withdrawal/40 acres 10 years - 06-29-91' District Reviewed/2,824.22 acres 10 years 07-10-95 Withdrawal/2,035.68 10 years ! 06-20-01 Review/- 3.741acres 641.42 10 years )6-29~2011 3. Eastham 10-02-85 District Created/764.75 acres 10 years 10-13-93 Distdct Reviewed/587.30ac 10 years 12-08-93 Addition/t 35.19ac 10 years 05-11-94 Distr ct Reviewed(Cont.)II 78.09 ac 900.58 10 years 10-13-2003 4. Blue Run 06-18-86 District Created/1,136.08 acres 8 years " 01-04'89 Addition/2 998.67 acres 8 years 07-13-94 District Reviewed/3,634.89 acres 8 years 04-12-95 Addition/60.21 acres 3,695.10 8 years 36-18-2002 5. Keswick 09-03-86 District Created/5,223.11 acres 10 years 09-07-88 Addition/699.01 acres 10 years 01-16-91 Addition/263.00 acres 10 years 10-12-94 District Reviewed/6,063.81 acres .- 10 years 10-12-94 Addition/320.52 acres 10 years 04-12-95 Addition/17.38 acres 10 years 08-13-97 Addition/190.872 6,592.58 10 years 09-03-2004 6. Kinloch 09-03-86 District Created/1 586.60 acres 10 years 05-02-90 Addition/63.40 acres 10 years 04-'14-93 Addition/34.17 acres 10 years 11-17-93 Addition/3.81 acres 10 years 10-12-94 3istrict Reviewed/I,683.96 acres I 10years 10-12-94 Additon/393.16 acres 10 years I 09-13-00 Additon/8.85 acres 2,085.97 10 years 09-03-2004 7. Moorman's River 12-17-86 ~)istrict Created/8,035.98 acres 10 years 09-07-88 Addition/2,269.03 acres 10 years 01-04-89 Addition/173.69 acres I 10 years 05-02-90 Addition/443.44 acres 10 years 04-14-93 Add i{ion/170.45 acres 10 years 12-21-94 District Reviewed/9,989.36 10 years 04-12-95 Addit on/330 00 acres 10 years 08-09-95 Addition/59.92 acres 10 years 08-13-97 Addition/242.38 10 years 05-12-99 Addition/110.44 acres 10 years 04-19-00 Addition/81.45 acres ' 10,813.55 10 years 12-17-2004 EL Hardware · 11-04-87 District Created/6,023.94 acres 10 years 05-03-89 Addition/206.88 acres 10 years 11-12-97 Review/3856.031 acres 10 years 05-13-98 Addition/11.97 acres 10 years 07-12-00 Addition/153.48 acres 4,021.48 10 years 11-12-2007 9. Jacob's Run 01-06-88 District Created/727.28 acres 6 years 05-03~89 Addition/500.43 acres 6 years ?-7 03-02-94 District Reviewed/l,124.99 acres 6 years 09-10-96 Withdrawal/107.73 acres 6 years 04-19-00 Review/1017.26 acres 1,017.26 10 years 01-06-2010 10. Carter's Bridge 04-20-88 District Created/7,969.72 acres I 10 years . 10-31-90 Addition/3,692.36 acres ' I 10 years 05-21-97 Addition/262.75 acres 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/9,004.16 acres 10 years 02-10-99 Addition/ 42.00 acres 10 years 05-12-99 Addition/117.69 acres 9,163.85 - 10 years 04-20-2008 11. Lanark 04-20~88 District Created/996.05 acres . 10 years 09-16-92 Addition/4,625.89 acres 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/5,633.52 acres ! 0 years 02-10-99 Addition/39.71 acres 10 years ' 04-20-2008 10-06-99 Addition/154.638 acres 5,827.87 10 years 12. Panorama 04-20-88 Distdct Created/I,066.11 acres 10 years 06-14-95 Addition/42.40 acres 10 years 09-09-98 District Reviewed/265.40 acres 10 years 03-17-99 Addition/7.12 acres 272.52 10 years 04-20-2008 13. Free Union 09-21-88 District Created/I,394.60 acres 10 years 01-04-89 Addition/30.01 acres 10 years 05-15-91 Addition/716.37 acres 10 yea?s 09-09-98 District Reviewed/1,379.27 1,379.27 10 years 09-21-2008 14. Ivy Creek 11-02-88 District Created/578.03 acres 7 years 04-14-93 Withdrawal/55.17 acres 7 years 02-14-96 Review/494.860 acres 494.86 7 years 92-14-2003 15. Buck ~ountain 01-04-89 District Created/633.35 acres 10 years 04-12-95 Addition/26.89 acres 10 years 01-13-99 Review/488.92 acres 10 years 10-06-99 Addition/13.55 acres 502.47 10 years D1-04-2009 16. Yellow Mountain 03-08-89 District Created/975.52 acres 10 years 06-24-96 Withdrawal/275.55 acres 10 years 01-13-99 Review/681.29 acres 10 years 05-12-99 Addition/43.77 acres 10 years 05-12-99 Withdrawal/84.00 acres 641.06 10 years D3-08-2009 17. Chalk Mountain 09-06-89 District Created/1 272.47 acres 10 years 10-06-99 Review/1,272.47 acres 10 years 04-19-00 Addition/48.06 acres 1,320.53 10 years 99-06-2009 18. Sugar Hollow 09-06-89 District Created/2,581.97 acres 10 years 08-01-90 Addition/697.72 acres 10 years 04-14-93 Addition/1,524.32 acres 10 years 11-17-93 Addition/55.79 acres 10 years 10-06-99 Review/4,729.14 acres 4,729.14 10 years 09-06-2009 19. Batesville 05-02-90 District Created/906.51 acres 10 years 04-19-00 Review/633.78 acres 10 years 09-13-00 Addition/38.499 acres 672.28 10 years 95-02-2010 20. High MoWing 01-16-91 District Created/622.44 acres 10 years 06-20-01 Review 622.44 10 years 91-16-2011 21. Pasture Fence Mtn 11-17-93 District Created/870.42 acres 10 years 07-13~94 Addition/453.50 acres 1,323.92 10 years 11-17-2003 22. N.Fork Moorman's River 11-17-93 District Created/270.48 acres 270.48 ' 10 years 11-17-2003 23. Nortonsville Local 10-06-99 District Created/92.575 acres 92.58 8 years 10-06-2007 District Created/2,033.33 ~ 24. South Garden 10-06-99 acres 2,033.331 7 years 10-06-2006 TOTAL 64,470.53' acres 13.86% of 465,040 acres in Albemarle County IV. ZONING AND COMPREHENSIVE PL LN MODIFICATIONS Am 2000 REZONING ACTIVITY This section of the' DeVelopment Activity Report is a review of zoning changes that were approved by the Albemarle County Board .of Supervisors in 2000. The ability to modify the Zoning Ordinance provides flexibility in land use regulations. The purpose of these actions is to mitigate unreasonable hardships imposed by the ordinance, to recognize compatibility with neighboring uses, and to acknowledge changes in growth patterns that affect the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. A total of 85.68 acres were rezoned in 2000 as a result of 11 Zoning Map Amendment applications which resulted in 6 Zoning Map modifications (see Table 4-1). The most significant rezoning, in terms of acreage, occurred in Rivanna Village with 38 acres rezoned from RA to PP, D. The amount of acreage rezoned by zoning map amendment throughout the County significantly decreased in 2000 from a total of 130.71 acres rezoned in 1999. 29 TABLE 4-1 APPROVED ZONING MAP AMENDMENTS, 2000 (changes to zoning claSsifications) COMP PLAN AREA PREVIOUS NEW ' ZONING ZONING ACRES Crozet Community - PRD PRD *0 Neighborhood 1 CO CO 0.885 Neighborhood 1 I ~R-6 C-1 9.104 Neighborhood 1 R-4 R-10 1.23 Neighborhood 2 PUD PUD 0.25 Neighborhood 2 R-4 CO 0.35 Neighborhood. 2 CO R4 1.5 Neighborhood 3 R-10 and R-1 PRD 12.3 Neighborhood 4 R-1 PRD 22.1 Neighborhood 6 CO with proffer CO with proffer *'13 Rivanna Village RA PRD 37.96 TOTAL ACREAGE REZONED 85.68 * Denotes change in proffers to alter setbacks. ** Denotes change in proffers to permit additional building area. 30 Bf COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MODIFICATIONS IN 2000 The Albemarle County Board of Supervisors adopted the current, revised Land Use Plan in June 1996. This revised plan incorporated several changes from the previous plan. The new Land Use Plan places an. increased emphasis on promoting infill development of a more urban scale within the Development Areas. To achieve this goal the Plan recommends: · :- Achieving higher gross densities of development in the Development Areas Encouraging mixed use developments Encouraging neighborhood style development and design Encouraging road development and design to be of a scale more in keeping with surrounding neighborhoods which also accommodates multiple modes of transportation such as bicycle, pedestrian and mass transit o.'o Encouraging interconnection of neighborhoods with provision of walkways, bikeways, open space areas, and neighborhood scale street systems *:* Emphasizing the provision of necessary Public facilities and services to support such scale of development including water, sewer, and recreation facilities. In 2000, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors approved (3) Comprehensive Plan Amendments, as follows: 1. A plan to update the current Version of the Comprehensive Plan with an updated and expanded version of the Historic Preservation Plan. 2. The adoption of the Personal Wireless Service Policy. 3. An amendment to the Communities Facilities Plan standards to allow for larger public facilities in the Rural Areas. In addition, in January 1997, the Board of Supervisors began the Development Area Initiatives Project to provide guidance on how to obtain a higher quality of development in the Development Areas and -- provide guidance on master planning the urban neighborhoods, communities, and villages. A Board appointed committee, the Development Areas Initiative Steering Committee, began work in February 1997 and completed their work in March 2000. In April 2000, they recommended a three volume report, -- The Neighborhood MOdel, to the Board of Supervisors. The first volume provided 12 guiding principles for new development and a template for developing master plans. The second volume provided _ implementation strategies. The third volume contained the supporting documents for the recommendations. In May of 2000, the Board of Supervisors forwarded the report to the Planning Commission and asked the Commission to consider the volume 1 as a Comprehensive Plan amendment to the 1996 Land Use Plan. 'From June to December 2000, the Commission held worksessions to consider significant planning and development changes proposed in the report and to edit the document. The CommissiOn worksessions were carried over to 2001. 3] V. APPENDIX RA RA 1 [EENE RA ! 4 OF .I SCO'I'TSV1LLE AO RA ALBEMARLE ~ COUNTY, VIRGINIA,'-'/' ~'~ Comprehensive Plan, [;and Use. Plan CURRENT DEVELOPMENT AREAS NEIGHBORHOODS 1 - 7 x~ V1LLAGES R A ~u~ A~AS PRIgARY ROADS~.~INT£RS?A?EHIGHWAyHIGHWAY ................... SECONDARY ROADS ~'=~U.S. ........... STREAMS PREPARED BY: Department of Planning and Community Development * Office of Mapping. Graphics and Information Resources (OOMGAIR) Coun[v Urban Area of Albemarle Neighborhoods 1-7 c% IVY TY CH PREPARED BY: Department of Planning and Community Development * Office of Mapping, Graphics and Information Resources ¢OOMGAIR) -/ CROZET PRECINCT i,,'J GREENWOOD HALL DISTRICT FREE [] ~REPARBD BY: Deoartment of Plannin~ and Communitv DeveloomenL FREE BRIDGE PRECINCT STONY PR~C1NCT f ~UaT'f ~COTT~VILLE ALBEMARLE COUNTY. VIRGINIA MAGISTERIAL DISTRICTS (A~opLed ][ay 15th. 1991 Amended ,tune 2nd. 1993 & Uay ?, 1997} JACK JOUETT RI0 RIVANNA SAMUEL SCOTTSVILLE WHITE HALL Y~,~ ~ PI~CINCTS PIISClNCT 90UflDAPJSS i DISTRICT BOUNDARI~ ] ~WNG * Office of Maooin~.Graohics and Information Resources TYPE OF RESIDENCE Single-family r esidenee 1 building, 1 lot, 1 dwelling unit bldg. Exam pies: North Pines Earlysville Forest Wynridge Oak Forest Single-family attached 1 building, 2 lots, 2 dwelling units 1 !c: 2 Examples: Cam ella Garden Georgetown Court Commonwealth Drive Briarwood Single-family townhouse I building, 3 or more lots, 3 or more dwelling units Exam pies: Townwood Birnam Wood Minor Hill Duplex 1 buKding, 1 lot, 2 dwelling units Exam pies: Whitewood Multi-r esidenee I building, 1 lot, 3 or more dwelling units 1 bldg. 1 Old Oak Court Huntington Village FAX I804) 972-4t26 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Department of Building Code and Zoning Services 401 Mclntire Road, Room 227 Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596 TELEPHONE (804) 296-5832 TTD (804) 972-4012 August 10, 2001 Steven W, Blaine LeClair Ryan 123 East Main Street, 8th Floor Charlottesville, VA 22902 Re: Official Determination of Number of Development Rights - Verulam Farm (Tax Map 74, Parcel 17) Dear Mr. Blaine, This is to confirm for the record, that this tax map parcel (74-17) has a total of nine (9) theoretical development rights. In addition, the residue can be divided into a maximum of approximately 25 parcels of at least 21 acres in size. I will explain the basis for this determination in the proceeding. The decision that these development rights exist is based on the most recent recorded plat and deed for this property and on case law relating to public roads subdividing properties. The relevant plat by Roudabush, Green & Gale, Inc is dated June 13, 1984, last revised August 25, 1986 and is signed for approval by the County on August 28, 1986. It is recorded with the deed (deed book 896, page 208) which conveys the property from Verulam Farm Limited Partnership to Peter D. Nielsen. This plat notes a total of four (4) development rights for the 550.73 acres now known as tax map 74, parcel 17. In addition, there are 5 further development rights associated with parcel 18 based on case law, for a total of nine (9) for the property. The plat notes "all 5 rights allocated to parcel 18 are to remain with the residue of that parcel." This note would indicate that parcel 18 was conveyed without any development rights. However, this plat was approved by the County in 1986 prior to 1990 case law relating to public roads subdividing parcels (and establishing associated development rights) and it is not correct. The 1990 case Ann H. Sanford v. Board of Zoning Appeals of Albemarle County, Virginia Case 3984-L stood for the finding that the presence of property owned by others or dedicated to public :use which physically separates the ownership and use of property, such as a public road traversing a parcel, serves to 08-i4-01 A08:48 N Letter to Steven W. Blaine Official Determination of Number of Development Rights August 10, 2001 Page 2 subdivide it in fact. The Sanford case relies on the finding in City of Winston Salem v. Tickle, 281 SE 2d 667 of the North Carolina Court of Appeals (1981). Prior to December 10, 1980, Parcel 18 existed in two physically separate pieces which were divided by Interstate 64. Therefore, the southern piece of parcel 18 with the majority of the acreage (noted as the residue) and the northern piece of 13.94 acres (noted as portion of parcel 18) are two separate parcels, each with five (5) development rights. The development rights for 74-17 are compiled as follows: · 536.37 acre residue of parcel 17 has 3 development rights {122.13 acre parcel A residue has remaining 2 development rights}; · 13.94 acre portion of parcel 18 has 5 development rights based on case law (see preceding) · 0.42 acre parcel 16 has 1 development right* 9 development rights total *For the 0.42 acre parcel 16 to have an actual development dght, it must in fact be buildable, If anyone is aggrieved by this determination, they have a right to appeal it within thirty (30) days of the date notice of this determination is given, in accordance with Section 15.2-2311 of the Code of Virginia. If they do not file a timely appeal, this determination shall be final and unappealable. An appeal shall be taken only by filing with the Zoning Administrator and the Board of Zoning Appeals a notice of appeal which specifies the grounds for the appeal. An appeal application must be completed and filed along with the fee of $95. The date notice of this determination was given is specified above. If you have any questions, please contact me. Sincerely, Zoning Administrator Cc: Nielsen, Peter D. Ms. Carey, Please advise the Board that VDOT has informed the citizens who submitted comments or spoke at the heating of the Commonwealth Transportation Board's decision. Thanks, Gerald Utz August g~', 2OUl Location Public Hearing Project R000-002-259, C501 Free State Connector Fr: Route 631 (Rio Road) To: Route 651 (Free State Road) Albemarle COUnty This letter was sent to those on the attached list. '~h~'c°mm°nwealth :~ri-ansp0rtation Board at its meeting' On August 16, 2001, approved Alternative "B" as presented by the Department's Engineers at the Location Public Hearing held on January 25, 2001. This approval is made with the provision that Belvedere Station Land Trust donates the necessary right of way and easements through their property as they have proposed. Alternative "B" is the westernmost alignment that runs in the proximity of the Norfolk-Southern Railroad right of way. Sincerely, Gerald G. Utz Contract Administrator /ggu cc: Mr. D. R. Askew Mr. R. H. Connock, Jr. Ms. Karen Kilby Ms_ Ella Carey 08-29-01 A09:07 IN Mr. John Smith 1528 Cherry Bark Lane Charlottesville, VA 22911 Mr. John Thompson 1504 Grove Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Charles Trachta 203 Westbrook Place Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Robert M. Hauser Robert Hauser Homes, Inc. P.O. Box 5487 Charlottesville, VA 22905-5487 F. R. Haney 2522 James River road Howardsville, VA 24562 Forrest G. and Becky Hyre 2500 Huntington Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Roland N. Smith 4277 Woods Edge Road Boyd Tavern, VA 22947 Mr. David L Phillips 2622 Hunt'mgton Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 J. C. & Charlotte Levenson 1581 Belvedere Drive Charlottesville, VA 22901 Ms. Patricia R. Crook 1348 Dunlora Drive Charlottesville, VA 22901 Stephen E. Bach 1208 Meriwether St Charlottesville, VA 22902-5421 Ms. Joanne Sedleniek 1147 River Oaks Lane Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Gunnar Sedleniek 1147 River Oaks Lane Charlottesville, VA 22901 Dr. Harold L. Bare Sr. 1025 E. Rio Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901 Jillian Galle 702A Graves St. Charlottesville, VA 22902 Mr. Robert Yancey 2601 Huntington Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901 Ms. Elizabeth M. Yancey 2601 Huntington Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901-1225 Mr. Leo J. Casey 1386 Allister Greene Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Kenneth W. Derby 1082 Blackburn Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. John P. Springiest 895 Charter Oaks Drive Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. John Boyle 607B Altavista Avenue Charlottesville, VA 22902 Mr. James M. Hubbard 935 Charter Oaks Drive Charlottesville, VA 22901 Mr. Kent Schlussel 1171 River Chase Ridge Charlottesville, VA 22901 Noelle M Klein 2702 Huntington Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22901 Ms. Cathy Horton 1305 Barclay Hill Charlottesville, VA 22901 Ms. Tricia Branch 504 Eastbrook Drive Charlottesville, VA 22901 Board of Directors, Fairview Swim & Tennis Club 1316 Belvedere Drive Charlottesville, VA 22906 Stephen C. Horton 1305 Barclay Hill Charlottesville, VA 22901 Albemar!e County Serv ce Serving · Conserving August 30, 2001 Mr. Robert W. Tucker, Jr. Albemarle County Office Building 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Re: Water Supply Alternatives Hand Delivered Dear Bob: Recently Supervisor Lindsay Dorrier asked me to provide a historical background of Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority's (RWSA) funding of capital improvements and the allocation of costs between the City of Charlottesville and Albemarle County Service Authority (ACSA) customers. I will limit this history to urban area projects since Scottsville and Crozet project costs are allocated solely to ACSA customers. I am attaching a copy of the Four Party Agreement for the benefit of the readers. This agreement, which created RWSA, established certain projects to be undertaken by RWSA and the cost allocation for those projects. To date, RWSA has sold revenue bonds to finance all of these projects. Article IV of the agreement addressed future water and sewer needs of the City and/or ACSA. In several instances, the City and ACSA have asked RWSA to undertake new projects jointly needed by both utilities and the allocation of costs between the two utilities has been negotiated. A brief description of those projects follows: 168 Spotnap Road Buck Mountain Reservoir Land Acquisition In a 1983 joint resolution, the City and ACSA asked RWSA to acquire land for this future reservoir and established terms for payment of this debt, including a surcharge on all new customers in the City and urban areas of Albemarle County. Southern Loop Water Line In 1987, the City and ACSA agreed to the installation of a new water transmission main around the southern perimeter of the City, but within Albemarle County, and the construction of a water storage tank on Avon Street Extended. Costs were allocated between the two entities based upon relative benefits to each. P.O. Box 2738 · Charlottesville, VA 22902 · Tel [804) 977-4511 · Fax (804) 979-0698 www. acsanet.com Page two Robert W. Tucker, Jr. August 30, 2001 Moores Creek Relief Sewer A new sewer line parallel to the Moores Creek Interceptor was required in 1990 to meet the demands of growth in the southern urban area. RWSA undertook this project for the City and ACSA. Costs were allocated based upon estimated sewer flow into this pipeline from each jurisdiction. Urban Area Water Connector Main In 1995, the City and ACSA agreed to fund a new water main connecting the Observatory Water Treatment Plant and the South Rivanna Treatment Plant. Through negotiations, the City and ACSA agreed to a fixed percentage cost split for the term of the debt. South Rivanna Water Treatment Plant Expansion RWSA has just recently completed expansion of this treatment facility from a daily capacity of 8 million gallons to 12 million gallons. Cost of this expansion is being shared on the basis of the percentage of urban area consumption by each jurisdiction. Other projects have been undertaken by RWSA which were for repair or improvement to existing facilities and provided no additional capacity. In those cases annual debt costs are shared on a prorata basis relative to consumption by each the City and ACSA. Once the decision is made on which options to pursue for future water supply ACSA and the City must negotiate the sharing of those costs. A formula must be devised to equitably allocate expansion costs to future users and the cost of capacity restoration in the existing reservoir to existing users. I hope this is the information Mr. Dorrier sought. Very t~ly yours, J.W. Brent Executive Director JWB/slrb Enclosure cc: Board of Directors Judy Mueller THIS AGREEMEi~T, made as of the day 1973~..~,~,.~ ~by and between the CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, a municipal corpo- ration (the City), ALBEMARLE COUNTY SERVICE AUTHORITY, a public body politic and corporate duly created pursuant to the Virginia Water and Sewer Authorities ACt (the Service Authority), the !I BOARD OF COUNTY SUPERVISORS OF ALBEMARLE COUNTY, acting for and · on behalf of Albemarle County (the County), and RIVANNA WATER AND SEWER AUTHORITY, a public body politic and corporate duly created "pursuant to the Virginia Water and Sewer Authorities Act (Rivanna) provides that: WHEREAS, the City owns and operates water supply and wastewater treatment facilities which furnish water and provide wastewater treatment for all of the City and certain outlying areas in the County, and the County, acting through the Service Authority, owns and operates water supply and wastewater treat- ii ment facilities which furnish water and provide wastewater treatment for certain areas in the County; and WHEREAS, in the interest of efficient water quality management for the upper Rivanna River Basin, the City and the County caused Rivanna to be formed on June 7, 1972, for the purpose of acquiring, financing, constructing and maintaining facilities for developing a supply of potable 'water for the City and the County and for the abatement of pollution resulting from sewage in the upper Rivanna River Basin; and WHEREAS, the parties desire to enter into this Agree- merit to provide for the acquisition of certain existing faciliti~, the construction o£ new facilities and the financing, operation and maintenance of all such facilities and recognize that this Agreement will be used to facilitate the obtaining of interim financing and the issuance of revenue bonds by Rivanna to finance a portion of the cost of such acquisition and construction; NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and the mutual covenants and agreements hereinafter contained, the parties hereto agree as follows: ARTICLE I Definitions and Warranties Section 1.1. Definitions. The following words as used in this Agreement shall have the following meanings: "Act" shall mean the Virginia Water and Sewer Author- ities Act (Chapter 28, Title 15.1, Code of Virginia of'1950, as amended). "Bonds" shall mean the revenue bonds issued by Rivanna to obtain funds, together with other available funds, to pay the cost of the Project and shall include any notes or other obliga- tions issued for such purpose. "City" shall mean the City of Charlottesville, a munic- ipal corporation of the Commonwealth of Virginia. "Cost", when used with respect to the Project, shall have the meaning specified in~ Sections 15.1-1240(m) and (n) of the Act. "County" shall mean Albemarle County, a county of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and shall include the Board of County Supervisors as its governing body. - 2 - "Points of Delivery" shall mean such points as Rivanna may establish from time to time for delivery of treated water to or.receipt of wastewater from the City and. the Service Author- ity. "Political Subdivisions" shall mean the City, the Service Authority and the County. "Project" shall mean the facilities to be acquired by Rivanna pursuant to Article III, whether by purchase, lease or otherwise, and the facilities to be provided by Rivanna pursuant to Article IV, as the same may from time to time exist. "Rivanna" shall mean Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority, a public body politic and corporate duly created pursuant to the Act. "Service Authority" shall mean Albemarle County Public Service Authority, a public body politic and corporate duly created pursuant to the Act. "Trustee" shall mean the trustee under the resolution or indenture authorizing or securing the Bonds. Section 1.2. Representations and Warranties. Each of the parties represents and warrants that it has full power and authority to enter into and perform this Agreement. ARTICLE II Term of Agreement Section 2.1.. Initial Term. This Agreement shall be in full force and effect from the date of its execution until June 30, 2012; provided, however, that if on such date the Bonds have not been paid or provision made for their payment the term - 3 - of this Agreement shall continue until the Bonds shall have been paid or provision made for their payment. Section 2.2. Continuation of Agreement. This Agree- ment shall continue in effect beyond June 30, 2012 (or such later date as provided above), until terminated by the City, the Service Authority, the County or Rivanna. No such termination shall be- come effective until two years after written notice thereof shall have been given to each of the other parties hereto. ARTICLE III ~c~uisition of Existing Facilities Section 3.1. Agreement to Acquire. Rivanna agrees to acquire and the Political Subdivisions agree to sell, lease or otherwise make available to Rivanna the water impoundment, pro- duction, transmission and storage facilities and the wastewater interception and treatment facilities set forth herein upon the terms and conditions set forth herein. Section 3.2. City Facilities - Water. (a) The City will sell and Rivanna will purchase the water prodUction, trans- mission and storage facilities described on Exhibit 1 attached hereto. Pending the consummation of such sale and purchase, the City will lease such facilities to Rivanna. (b) The City will assign and Rivanna will accept the City's rights under a ground lease between the City and the University of Virginia dated April 18, 1922, whereby the Univer- sity of Virginia leases to the City the site on which is located the City's Observatory Mountain Filtration Plant; provided, how- ever, that the City will continue to furnish water to the - 4 - University of Virginia pursuant to such ground lease as may be in effect from time to time. The City will sell and Rivanna will purchase the facilities other than land. constituting the Obser- vatory Mountain Filtration Plant located on such site. Pending the consummation of such sale and purchase, the City will lease such facilities to Rivanna. (c) The City will lease to Rivanna for the term of this Agreement all water rights in and to the Sugar Hollow Reservoir, the two Ragged Mountain Reservoirs and the South Rivanna Reservoir, which rights shall be the right to maintain and operate all impoundment and pumping facilities, and the right to withdraw all water that may be available. Rivanna will undertake to maintain all dams and other facilities at such reservoirs.for the production of water but will not be required to maintain areas at such reservoirs used for' municipal purposes. Section 3.3. City Facilities - Wastewater. (a) The City will sell and Rivanna will purchase the wastewater inter- ception and treatment facilities described on Exhibit 2 attached hereto. Pending the consummation of such sale and purchase, the City will lease such facilities to Rivanna. (b) The City will lease to Rivanna the Riverside Pump Station and the Meadow Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant.until Rivanna has placed its proposed advanced wastewater treatment plant into operation. the water Section 3.4. Service Authority Facilities - Water. The ServiceAuthority will sell and Rivanna will purchase production, transmission and storage facilities - 5 - described on Exhibit 3 attached hereto. of such sale and purchase, the Service Authorfty will lease such facilities to Rivanna. (b) The Service Authority will assign and Rivanna will accept the Service Authority's rights under agreement with the County to use the wells, pumps and other facilities at Mint Springs. Pending the consummation (c) The Service Authority will lease to Rivanna the wells, pumps and other facilities at Flordon, Jefferson Village, Colthurst and West Leigh for so lOng as any of them may be needed by Rivanna. (d) The Service Authority will assign and Rivanna will accept the Service Authority's rights under leases between the County and the Service Authority or such other rights as the Service Authority may have to the Beaver Creek Reservoir and the Totier Creek Reservoir. (e) The County will join in each such sale or lease to the extent of its interest, if any, in any of such facilities. Section 3.5. Service Authority Facilities - Wastewater. (a) The Service Authority will sell and Rivanna will purchase the wastewater interception and treatment facilities described on Exhibit 4 attached hereto. Pending the consummation of such sale and purchase, the Service Authority will lease such facili- ties to Rivanna. (b) The Service Authority will lease to Rivanna the Brownsville School, Berkeleyand Woodbrook wastewater treatment facilities for so long as any of~them may be needed by Rivanna. - 6 - Section 3.6. Consummation of Sales and Purchases. The sale and purchase of each of the facilities enumerated in Sections 3.2 through 3.5, inclusive, shall be consummated ten years from the date of this Agreement or at such later time as the debts, if any, of the City or the Service Authority, as the case may be, attributable to any of such facilities shall have be~n paid or provision made for their payment. It is intended that the pur- chase and sale of. each facility shall be closed promptly upon the satisfaction of.the conditions hereinabove stated. At each closing Rivanna shall pay the purchase price as determined, pur- suant to Section 3.7 and the City, the Service Authority or the County, as the case may be, shall deliver: (a) a good and sufficient deed or deeds in form reasonably satisfactory to Rivanna conveying to Rivanna, with special warranty, fee simple title to all real estate consti- tuting a part of such facilities; (b)' an assignment or assignments in form reasonably satisfactory to Rivanna assigning to Rivanna ali other interests in real estate constituting a part of such facilities; (c) a bill or bills of sale in form reasonably satis- factory to Rivanna conveying to Rivanna all tangible personal property constituting a part of such facilities; (d) all engineering data and other records, relating to such facilities; and (e) such other documents transferring title of .any .... part'of such facilities from the City, the Service Authority or the COunty, as the case may be, to Rivanna which Rivanna may reasonably determine to be necessary or desirable. - 7 - Section 3.7. Purchase Price. The sale and purchase ~price of the facilities shall be their fair value as of the date of this Agreement as determined by Paul B. Krebs and Associates and McNair and Associates, consulting engineers, less such amounts as may be paid to the City or the Service Authority, as the case may be, pursuant to Section 3.8 on account of debt retirement. If such consulting engineers are unable to agree on the fair value of any of such facilities within one year from the date of this Agreement, the two consulting engineers shall select a-third consulting engineer,_ and the decision of two of the three con- sulting engineers shall be binding. All expenses of determining such fair values shall be divided equally between the City, the Service Authority and Rivanna. The parties recognize that pay- ment of such purchase price by Rivanna will be made either from excess operating revenues or from borrowed funds and that the use of funds from either source may be limited by the resolution or indenture authorizing and securing the Bonds. If payment for sny facilities is not made when the same is due and payable, the un- paid purchase price shall bear interest from such due date at the f o rate o 6% per year until paid. Section 3.8. Lease of Facilities. As consideration for the lease of the facilities enumerated in Sections 3.2 through 3.5, inclusive, Rivanna shall pay to the City or the Service Authority, as the case may be, an annual rental of $1.00 plus an amount sufficient to pay the debt service if any, attrib~ab%e ~to such facilities and coming due within the next succeeding twelve months. Each suchlease~sha!l~equire RiVanna to maintain - 8 - such facilities in good working order. In the event the City or the Service Authority determines that it is prohibited from entering into leases of any such facilities, it shall make every reasonable effort to eliminate such prohibition and, if it is unable to do so, it shall enter into use agreements or make similar arrangements under which Rivanna may operate such facil- ities as a part of its regional facilities for water impoundment, production, transmission and storage and wastewater interception and treatment. The County shall join in any such lease, use agreement or similar arrangement to the extent of its interest, if any, in any such facilities. ARTICLE IV Construction of New .Facilities Section 4.1. New Facilities. Rivanna will provide (a) the additional water facilities described on Exhibit 5 at- tached hereto and (b) the additional wastewater facilities described on Exhibit 6 attached hereto, as the same may be modi- fied to meet requirements of appropriate regulatory bodies~ Rivanna shall also undertake the provision of such additiOnal facilities as may be agreed upon from time to time by the City, the Service Authority and Rivanna. Section 4.2, Payment for New Facilities. The obli- gation of Rivanna to provide the facilities described in SectiOn 4.1 is limited to the funds available to it from time to time for such purpose. Rivanna shall be under no obligation to pro- v.ide funds for such purpose except in accordance with Section 5olo - 9 - Section 4.3. Additional Facilities. In the event that the City or the Service Authority determines the need for addi- tional water impoundment, production, transmission and distribu- tion facilities or wastewater interception and treatment facil- ities, Rivanna shall provide the requested facilities at the sole Cost of the City or the Service Authority, as the case may be. ARTICLE V Obligations of Authority Section 5.1. Sale of Bonds. Rivanna shall, as soon as may be practicable and with all reasonable dispatch, issue and sell the Bonds pursuant to the Act in an amount, together with other available funds, which will be sufficient to pay the cost of constructing and placing the Project in operation; pro- vided, however, that nothing contained in this Agreement shall require Rivanna reasonable by it. Rivanna to issue the Bonds except upon terms deemed Section 5.2. Acquisition and Construction of Project. shall, as soon as may be practicable and with all reasonable dispatch after the necessary funds are made aVailable to it, acquire, construct and place the Project in operation. Section 5.3. Production and Delivery of Water. Rivanna shall produce and deliver potable water to the City and the Ser- vice Authority at Points of Delivery in accordance with their needs and within the limitations of available supply. Rivanna shall provide water to the City and the Service Authority in . quantities and at pressures at least equal to the quantities and pressures available on the dare-hereof. - 10 - Section 5.4. Acceptance and Treatment of Wastewater. Rivanna shall~accept and treat all sewage delivered by the City and the Service Authority at Points of Delivery up to their respective allocated plant capacities in accordance with rules and regulations adopted by Rivanna from time to time. Rivanna shall be under no obligation to treat wastewater delivered by the City or the Service Authority in excess of their allocated ~daily plant capacities. Section 5.5. Operation of Project. Rivanna ~hall operate and maintain the Project in an efficient and economical manner, making all necessary and proper repairs, replacements and renewals, consistent with good business and'operating practices for comparable facilities and in accordance with applicable stan- dards of regulatory bodies. Production of water and treatment of wastewater shall meet or exceed all applicable standards of regu- latory bodies. Section 5.6. Adoption and Enforcement of Rules and Regulations. Rivanna shall adopt and enforce such reasonable rules and regulations as may be necessary or desirable to insure the efficient operation and maintenance of its facilities and the compliance with applicable regulations and orders of regulatory bodies. ARTICLE VI Obligations of the Political Subdivisions Section 6.1. Rivanna to Produce All Water. The Polit- ical Subdivisions will not produce or sell potable water from any source other than Rivanna. - 11 - Section 6.2, Rivanna to Treat Ail Wastewater. Ail publicly owned wastewater treatment facilities in the Political Subdivisions, except (a) facilities of the Albemarle County School Board and the Commonwealth of Virginia and (b) septic tank tile field systems, shall be operated by Rivanna under this Agreement. The City and the Service Authority shall deliver to Rivanna at Points of Delivery all wastewater collected by them and shall not permit or provide for the treatment of wastewater collected by them in any other manner. Section 6.3. Limitation on Plant Capacity. The Polit- ical Subdivisions recognize that the capacity of Rivanna's pro- posed advanced wastewater treatment plant will be regulated by the State Water Control Board and that allocations of plant capac- ity may have to be made in order to avoid overloading. The City and the Service Authority each covenants and agrees not to exceed its plant capacity as allocated from time to time. The City and the Service Authority have the primary responsibility for the necessary actions to insure that their wastewater flows remain within their allocations. At such time as the City or the County and the Service Authority are advised by Rivanna that the average fl0TM Of the City or the Service Authority, as the case may be, for any three consecutive months has reached 95% of its allocated daily plant capacity, the City or the County, as the case may be, shall suspend the issuance of permits which allow start of con- struction on projects in the affected area until capacity is in- creased by reason of reallocation or it is advised by Rivanna that additional wastewater may.bed~iivered to Rivanna. - 12 - Section 6.4. Payment of Charqes. The City and the Service Authority each covenants and agrees to pay promptly ~when due the charges of Rivanna as determined pursuant to Article VII and billed to it from time to time; provided, however, that the City and the Service Authority shall not be obligated to pay such charges except from revenues received by the City and the Service Authority, respectively, from the charges to be paid by the users of its water and sewerage systems and available to them for such purposes, including availability, connection, consumption and service charges or fees and any other revenues of such systems. The City and the Service Authority each covenants and agrees to fix and collect from the users of its water and sewerage systems charges sufficient to make the payments required of it under this Agreement. Rivanna shall provide the City and the Service Author- ity with information as to the minimum charges necessary for their respective required payments. Section 6.5. Observance of Regulations. The Political Subdivisions each covenant and agree to observe all reasonable rules and regulations respecting the use of and services furnished by the Project in accordance with Section 5.6 or legally required by any other authorized regulatory body. ARTICLE VII Rates and Charges Section 7.l. Rates in General. Rivanna shall fix and determine from time to time rates for water furnished t? and wastewater delivered by the City and %he Service Authority. Such rates shall be established by Rivanna at such levels as may be - 13 - necessary to provide funds, together with other funds that may be available, sufficient at all times to pay (a) the cost of operation and maintenance of the Project, including debt service attribut- able to facilities to be acquired by Rivanna, and reserves for such purposes and for replacements and improvements and (b) the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Bonds, as the same become due, and reserves.therefor. Section 7.2. Rates for Urban Are~. Rivanna shall es- tablish an urban area which shall include all of the City and designated portions of the County. The boundaries of this area may be changed from time to time. Rivanna shall establish rates for furnishing water to and treating wastewater from the urban area as follows: (a) Water rates shall be uniform throughout the urban area, except as provided in subsection (c) below. Rivanna shall compute the cost per 1000 gallons for the operation and mainte- nance of facilities fOr the impoundment, production, treatment and transmission of water. Rivanna shall compute the cost per 1000 gallons for debt service on ~e existing facilities to be acquired pursuant to Sections 3.2 and 3.4 and the cost of new facilities to be constructed pursuant to Section 4.1. The water rate per 1000 gallons shall be determined on the basis of the-sum of the opera- tional costs and debt service figures. (b) Wastewater treatment rates for the urban area shall not be uniform. Rivanna shall compute the cost per 1000 gallons for the operation and maintenance of facilities for the intercep- tion and treatment of wastewater, which rate shall be the same for the City.and~the Service Autholrit~,_ _Rivanna shall comD~te the cost per 1000 gallons for debt service on the existing facilities to be acquired pursuant to Sections 3~3 and 3.5 and the cost of new facilities to be constructed pursuant to Section 4.1 on a basis - 14 - whereby the City pays one-half as much per 1000 gallons as the Service Authority. The wastewater treatment rate per 1000 gallons shall be determined on the basis Of the sum of the operational costs and debt service figures. (c) In the case of (1) the Powell's Creek Interceptor and (2) additional water impoundment, production, transmission or distribution facilities or wastewater interception or treatment facilities provided by Rivanna at the request of the City or the Service Authority pursuant to Section 4.3, the full amount of debt service thereon shall be added to the water or wastewater treatment rates determined in accordance with .subsections (a) or Section 7.3. Rates in Other Areas. Rivanna shall es- tablish separate rates for water now being furnished and waste- water now being treated at Brownsville, Crozet, Scottsville and at such other areas in the County outside of the urban area to which Rivanna may in the future provide water or from Which it may treat wastewater. Section 7.4. Uniformity in Debt Service Charqes. The parties recognize that there will be substantial variations from year to year in the cost per 1000 gallons for both water and wastewater treatment for debt service on both existing facilities to be acquired and new facilities to be constructed. In an effort to maintain reasonable uniformity of rates from year to year, the parties agree that Rivanna will, to the best of its ability, com-. pute such debt service charges at a uniform rate throughout ten year periods from the date of this Agreement. The parties under- stand and agree that this procedure will result in excess - 15 - collections for debt service in certain periods but in. other periods the amount collected for debt service will be less than actually required. Rivanna agrees to apply the excess collections to make up deficiencies during periods where debt service costs exceed debt service revenues. Section 7.5. Determination of Charges. Water and wastewater treatment charges shall be determined by applying the rates determined pursuant to Sections 7.2 and 7.3 to the total amount of water delivered to the City and the Service Authority as obtained by their respective customer meter readings. Section 7.6. Rayment of Charqes. Rivanna may present charges based on budget estimates, subject to adjustment on the basis of an independent audit at the end of each fiscal year. All charges of Rivanna shall be payable upon presentation. In the event the City or the Service Authority shall fail to make payment in full within 30 days after presentation, interest on such unpaid amounts shall accrue at the highest rate of interest payable by RiVanna on any of the Bonds then outstanding. Rivanna shall bill the~City and the Service Authority, and no one else, for water furnished and wastewater treated. ARTICLE VIII Miscellaneous Section 8.1. .Amendments. It is recognized by the parties hereto~that this Agreement will constitute an essential part of the Rivanna's financing plan and that, after the.. Bonds have been.sold, this Agreement Cannot be amended, modified,_.~or otherwise altered in any manner that will impair or adversely - 16 - affect the security afforded hereby for the payment of the prin- cipal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Bonds, but that this Agreement can be modified or amended only with the consent of the Political Subdivisions, Rivanna and the Trustee given in accordancewith the resolution or indenture under which it has been designated. Section 8.2. Books and Records. Rivanna shall keep proper books and records in accordance with accepted accounting practices which shall be available for inspection at all reason- able times by the Political Subdivisions through their duly authorized agents. Rivanna shall cause an annual audit of its books and records to be made by an independent certified public accountant at the end of each fiscal year and a certified copy thereof to he filed promptly with the governing bodies of the Political Subdivisions. Section 8.3. Transfer of Customers. To the extent permitted by existing bond resolutions and other contractual obli- gations, the City will offer to the Service Authority all existing customers of the City located in the County and, upon any enlarge- ment of the City's boundaries, the Service Authority will offer to the City all existing customers of the Service Authority lo- cated in the City. As a part of any such offer the City or the Service Authority will offer to sell to the other party all of its facilities which provide service with respect to any customers to be transferred. The purchase price of any such facilities shall be their fair market value as part of a going business which shall be determined by appraisal in the manner prescribed in Section 3.7. - 17 - The City or the Service Authority, as the case may be, will have six months after the'date of any such offer, which shall state the purchase price, to accept and pay for or reject. Rejection of any such offer shall be final. In the event the Service Authority rejects the offer of the City, the City shall be entitled to serve exclusively those areas so delineated on a map entitled "Service Areas," and on a map entitled "Service Area Boundary Line," attached hereto as Exhibits 7 and 7b respectively, and as further described in Exhibit 7c attached hereto. Section 8.4. Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding upon, inure to the benefit of and be enforceable by the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. Section 8.5. Severability. If any provision of this Agreement shall be held invalid or unenforceable by any court of competent jurisdiction, such holding shall not affect any other provision hereof. Section 8.6. Counterparts. This Agreement shall be executed in several counterparts, any of which shall be regarded for original. all purposes as one IN WITNESS WHEREOF,.the parties.hereto have daUS-~d 'thlS--AgfeA~h~h-t-~6- be exeCnt-~ and '-their Revised 6/6/73 - 18 - seals to be affixed and attested by their duly authorized officers, all as of the date first above written. CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE Mayor ATTEST: City Cl~r-~ ALBEMARLE COUNTY p.~Bt~I~- SERVICE AUTHORITY Chai~an ATTEST: ~,~ Secre%ary BOA~ OF COUNTY SUPERVISORS OF ALB~E COU~Y Cha frm~n ATTSST: Clerk (S L) ATTEST: RIVANNA WA.T.~K AND SA~ER AUTHORITY / Chairman -' ' Secretary - 19 - WATER PRODUCTION~ STORAGE AND TRANSMISSION FACILITIES TO BE ACQUIRED BY RIVANNA FROM CITY 1 Mechum's River Raw Water Pump Station 2 One 18-inch transmission line from Sugar Hollow and Mechum's River to the Ragged Mountain Reservoirs 3 - One 18-inch raw water transmission line from Ragged Mountain to the Observatory Mountain Filtration Plant 4 - One 18-inch raw water transmission line from Ragged Mountain to Observatory Avenue and Southern Railroad and the 16-inch line from that point to the Observatory Mountain Filtration Plant 5 ~The Royal and Stadium Pump Stations 6 - South Rivanna Water Filtration Plant and Storage Tanks 7 - One 16-inch finished water transmission line from Observatory Mountain Filtration Plant to Lambeth Field Pump Station, but not including the Lambeth Field Pump Station 8 - One 24-inch finished water transmission line from the South Rivanna Plant generally paralleling U.S. 29 to Rio Road 9 - One 18-inch finished water transmission line from Rio Road and U.S. 29 to Melbourne Road 10 - One 18-inch finished water transmission line from Rio Road and U.So 29 to Hydraulic Road Exhibit 1 EXISTING WASTEWATER TREATMENT AND INTERCEPTION FACILITIES T~O BE ACQUIRED BY RIVANNA FROM CITY 1 - Moores Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant and its necessary appurtenances 2 - One 30-inch interceptor sewer (Moores Creek) extending from the existing Moores Creek Treatment Plant to the site of the old Moores Creek Treatment Plant 3 - One interceptor sewer (Meadow Creek) varying in size from 21 inches to 36 inches extending from Emmet Street to the Meadow Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant 4 - One intercepting sewer (Schenks Branch) varying in size from 18 inches to 21 inches, and extending from McIntire Road and Preston Avenue to the Meadow Creek Interceptor Exhibit 2 WATER PRODUCTION, STORAGE AND TRANSMISSION FACILITIES TO BE ACQUIRED BY RIVANNA FROM ALBEMARLE COUNTY SERVICE AUTHORITY 1 - North Rivanna Water Production facilities including the diversion dam, Filtration Plant and the storage tank at the Filtration Plant 2 - One 12-inch finished water transmission line running from the North Rivanna Plant to U.S. 29 3 - One 12-inch finished water transmission line running from U.S. 29 North to Piney Mountain 4 - The 700,000 gallon storage tank on Piney Mountain 5 - One 12-inch transmission line running South along U.S. 29 and West to Stillhouse Mountain and the 700,000 gallon storage tank on Stillhouse Mountain 6 - Beaver Creek Pumping Station 7 - One 12-inch raw water transmission line from the Beaver Creek Pumping Station to the Crozet Filtration Plant 8 - Crozet Filtration Plant including the 500,000 gallon storage facility including the right to use the wells at Mint Springs 9 - One 12-inch finished water line from the Crozet Filtration Plant to its terminal point 10 - One 10-inch raw water line from the Scottsville Reservoir to the Scottsville Filtration Plant 11 - The Scottsville raw water pump station 12 - Scottsville Water Filtration Plant and its necessary appurtenances 13 - One 10-inch finished water transmission line from the Scottsville Filtration Plant to the 250~000 gallon standpipe 14 The 250,000 gallon Scottsville Standpipe Exhibit 3 EXISTING WASTEWAT~.R TREATMENT AND TRANSMISSION FACILITIES TO BE ACQUIRED BY RIVANNA FROM SERVICE AUTHORITY 1 - Central Scottsville Pump Station (located in vicinity of Lagoon) with its respective force main 2 - Scottsville Lagoon and its appurtenances 3 - Wastewater Treatment Plant at Camelot Exhibit 4 Future Water Impoundment~ Production and Transmission Facilities to be Constructed by Rivanna 1. Construction of a finished water transmission main connecting the existing South Fork System in the vicinity of Hydraulic Road and Route 29 North to the existing Observatory System in the vicinity of Lambeth Field. 2. Comstruction of a finished water transmissio~ main from an existing transmission main in the vicinity of Penn Park Road alomg Rivanna River terminating on pantops Mountain and including a finished water storage tank on Pantops Mountain~ 3. Construction of a 12-inch finished water line from the existing Stillhouse Mountain finished water storage tank to serve the West Leigh-Flordon area; line terminating in t.he vicinity of the crossing of West Leigh Drive and Little Ivy Creek. 4. Construction of an additional finished water storage tank at Crozet in the vicinity of Buck Mountain Road and Railroad Avenue as well as the construction of approximately 8,500 feet of finished water transmission main from'the existing 12-inch main in State Route 240 to the proposed water storage tank° Exhibit 5 Proposed Wastewater Treatment and Interception Facilities to be Constructed by Rivanna. 1. Interim modifications to the M~ores Creek and Meadow Creek Wastewater Treatment Facilities to provide for increased capacity as an interim solution until the Regional Plant is available in 1977. 2. Construction of a pumping station at the confluence of PoweI1 Creek and the Rivanna River with its respective force main and receivimg gravity interceptor sewer to receive wastewater from the Powell Creek area and transmit to the Meadow Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant. This pumping station will be phased out upon completion of the Rivamna Interceptor and the Regional AWT Plant° 3. Construction of the Moores Creek Interceptor from terminal point of the existing 30-inch line near Rougemont Avenue and Quarr~ Road to Sunset Avenue to eliminate three pumping stations presently on the line and to otherwise relieve the presently overloaded Moores Creek Intercepting Sewer. 4. Construction of an interceptor sewer from the Berkeley Wastewater Treatment Plant to the existing Meadow Creek Interceptor Sewer to relieve the overloaded Berkeley facility with diversion to the Meadow Creek Wastewater'Treatment Plant until the Rivanna Interceptor and the Regional AWT Plant are available. 5. Construction of a pumping station with its respective force main and gravity intercepting sewer from Albemarle High School to the intercepting sewer in NOo 4 above to allow the abandonment Exhibit 6 of the existing septic tank-sand filter system presently serving the Albemarle High School and Jack Jouett Jr. High School. 6. Construction of an intercepting sewer from the existing Woodbrook Lagoon to the confluence of Powell Creek and Rivanna River to enable the eventual abandonment of Woodbrook Lagoon upon completion of the Rivanna Interceptor and the Regional AWT Plant. 7. Construction of a 20 MGD AWT Plant (first stage 15 MGD) at or near the confluence of Moores Creek and the Rivanna River to --~-- provide the Region with a single treatment facility to treat wastewater from the upper Rivanna River Basim. The design of this plamt may incorporate the present Moores Creek Plamt. 8. Comstruction of the Rivanna Interceptor from the proposed Regional AWT Plant parallel to the Rivanna River and extending along the South Fork Rivanna River to U.S. Route 29 eliminating the need for the existing Meadow Creek and Berkeley Wastewater Treatment Plants and the proposed Powell Creek pumping station. 9. Construction of an interceptor on Morey Creek connectimg the Moores Creek Interceptor at Sunset Avenue and extending to U.S. 250 West to carry the discharges from the area south and west of the City including the Ednam Forest area, and will carry the discharges from the Crozet area to the Regional AWT Plant via Moores Creek Imterceptor. 10. Construction of an 'interceptor, pumping stations and force mains from the Morey Creek Interceptor to the Crozet-Brownsville community to carry the discharges from the Crozet area to the Regional AWT Plant via the Morey and Moores Creek Interceptors. Il. Construction of an interceptor along Powell Creek from its confluence with the Rivanna River to the Northside School to carry the discharges from the school to the proposed Powell Creek pumping station until such time as the Rivanma Interceptor and the Regional AWT Plant are operational, at which time, this interceptor will carry the discharges from the Northside School to the Regional AWT Plant via the Rivanna Interceptor. DESCRIPTION OF BOUNDARY LINE OF SERVICE AREAS AS SHOWN ON EXHIBIT ?B Beginning at a point, the intersection of the Northern boundary line of lot #1, section 61 Albemarle County Tax Map, of the Chapel Hill Sub-Division, with the centerline-of State Route 631; thence along center line of State Route 631 in a Southerly direction to its intersection with the Western boundary of parcel 144, section 61; thence with the Western boundary of parcel 144, section 61, in a Northeasterly direction to a corner, and continuing with the Eastern boundary of said parcel in a Southerly direction to its corner with parcel 146D, section 61; thence with said parcel 146D, section 61, in a Northeasterly direction along its Northern boundary to a corner in the Western margin of the RoO.W. of the Southern R.R; thence with the said margin of the Southern RoR. in a Southerly direction ~to a corner common to parcels 150 and 15lA, section 61; thence crossing the said Southern R.R. in an Easterly direction to a'corner common to parcels 154 and 155, section 61, in the Eastern margin of the RoOoWo of the Southern RoR.; thence with the Northern b~undary of parcels 155, and I54D, 154B, 154A, and 164, section 61 to a corner common to parcel 164 and 164A, section 61, in the line of parcel 16, section 62; thence crossing parcel 16, section 62, in a Southerly direction to a corner common to. parcel 16, section 62, and parcel 165, section 61; .thence with the Easterly margin of parcels 165 and 166, section 61 to a corner common to parcel 166, section 61, and parcel 16, section 62; thence crossing parcels 16 and 17, section 62 in a Southeasterly direction to a corner common to parcels 17 and 17C, section 62; thence with the boundary of parcel 17, section 62, in a EXHIBIT 7C Page 1 of 6 Southeasterly direction to a corner common to parcels 17 and 17C, section 62; thence in a Northeasterly direction along the Southeastern boundary of parcel 17, Section 62, to the West bank of Rivanna River; thence Southernly along the West bank of Rivanna River to the Western boundary of parcel 29, section 78; thence in a Southwesterly direction along the Western boundary line of parcel 29, section 78 to a corner common to parcels 29 and 22, section 78; thence, crossing parcel 22, section 78, in a Southwesterly direction to a corner common to parcels 22 and 23, section 78, in the margin of State Route 53 and continuing the same course to the center of State Route 53; thence in Westerly direction along center line of State Route 53 to its intersection with the Charlottesville-Scottsville district line at or near the entrace to Monticello; thence in a Southerly direction along Charlottesville-Scottsville District line (crest of mountain) to a point where South boundary line of parcel 25, section 77 and parcel 30, section 91, extended Eastward intersects the~Charlottesville-Scottsville District line; thence in a Westerly direction to the South East Corner of parcel 30, section 91, and continuing along the Southern boundary of said parcels 30 and 25 to a point 700 feet East of State Route 20; thence in a Southerly direction crossing parcels 29 and 7, section 91, to the North East corner of lot 36, section 91; thence Southerly along the East property line to the Southeast corner of lot 36, section 91; thence in a Southwesterly direction, crossing parcel 7, section 91, and State Route 20 to the Southeast corner of parcels 2 and 8, section 91; thence in a North Westerly direction along South boundary line of parcel 2, section 91; to ~ corner with parcel iA in the line of parcel 2, section 91; Page 2 of 6 thence Southwesterly along the Southeastern.boundary of parcels iA, 1E, IF, and lB to a corner common to parcels lB and 1, section 91; thence continuing Westerly crossing parcels 1, ID, and 13, section 91 to a corner common to parcel 13, section 91, and parcel 35I, section 90; thence with the Northeast boundary of parcel 35I, section 90 in a Northwesterly direction to the center of State Route 742 and with same to a point opposite the entrace to Lake Renovia; thence with the entrace road to Lake Renovia, parcel 36, section 90, in a W~sterly direction, crossing a saddle to a ridge and along the crest of the ridge in a Northerly direction, crossing parcel 36, section 90 and parcel 57, section 76 to the Southern RoOoW. of Highway 1-64; thence Westerly along Southern RoO.W. of Highway 1-64 to a corner common to parcels 54 and 55D, section 76; thence along the Southern boundary of parcel 54, section 76, to the corner of parcels 54, 46A, and 46H, section 76; thence in a Westerly direction along the Northern boundary and in a Southerly direction along the Western boundary of parcel 46H, section 76, to the center line of State Route 631; thence in a Westerly direction along center line of State Route 631, to the intersection of State Route 781; thence Westerly from the intersection of State Routes 631 and 781 crossing parcel 49B to the South East corner of parcel 23, section 76; thence Westerly along the Southern boundary of parcel 237 section 76, to a corner common to parcels 23 and 49, section 76, and Sherwood Farms, as shown on section 76N; thence with the said Sherwood Farms in a clockwise direction along the Southern and Western boundary of Sherwood Farms, section 76N, to its corner common to parcel 44, section 75, thence with parcel 44, section 75 Westerly along its Southern boundary to a corner common to parcels 43 and 44, section 75; thence Northerly with the Western boundary of parcel 44, section 75 and Page 3 of 6 continuing the same course, crossing the Southern Railroad and Hy. 29 to a point 300' north of the center line of Hy. 29 in parcel 45, section 75; thence in a Northeasterly direction by a line paralleled to and 300' from the center line of Hyo 29, crossing parcels 45 and 48, section 75, to a point in the boundary line common to parcels 48 and 53, section 75; thence in a Northwesterly direction along the Western boundary line of parcel 53, section 75, to its intersection with the South R.OoW. of Hy. 1-64; thence Westerly along South RoOoW. of 1-64 to its intersection with Eastern boundary of parcel I (City Reservoir) section 75; thence along Eastern boundary parcel I, section 75, to its intersection with the Western corner of parcel 81, section 59D; thence along Western boundary of parcel 81, section 59D to a point approximately 300' South of the Southern R. OoWo of U.So 250; thence parallel to and 300' from the Southern R.OoWo of UoS. 250 in a Western direction to a point opposite the Eastern boundary of parcel 23E, section 59; thence Northerly 300' to UoS. 250 R.O.Wo, and continuing along same line to the Southeast corner of parcel 23E, section 59; thence along Eastern boundary of parcel 23E, section 59, to its intersection with the C & O, R~O.Wo and the same course continued crossing the C & O R.R. to its boundary with Farmington; thence along the Western boundary of Farmington in a clockwise direction to the intersection of State Routes 601 and 654 at the bridge over Ivy Creek; thence Southeasterly approximately 200' along center line of State Route 654 to the Western boundary of parcel 3, section 60; thence in a Southerly 'direction along the Western boundary of parcel 3, section 60, to a corner common to parcel 3, sectiom 60, and "Colthurst Farm" section 60C; thence with "Colthurst Farm," section 60G, along its Western and Southern boundary to a corner common to "Colthurst Farm" Page 4 of 6 and parcel 66, section 60; thence in a cotmter clockwise direction along the Western, Southern and Eastern boundari~'~ of parcel 66, section 60, to the center of State Route 654; thence in a Northerly direction along the Western boundaries of parcels 27 and 27A, to the Northwestern corner of parcel 27A, sectio~ 60A and continuing with the said parcel 27A Eastward along its Northern boundary and Northward along its Western boundary to a corner common to parcel 27E, section 60A; thence in a Northerly direction with the Westerly boundary of parcel 27E to a corner common to parcels 27E, and 10A, ('hessian Hills") section 60A; thence im a counter clock- wise direction along.the boundary of "Hessian Hills" to a corner in the West side of State Route 656; thence in an Easterly direction to the center line of State Route 656; thence in a Northeasterly direction along center line of State Route 656 to the South corner of Georgetown Greem; thence in a clockwise direction around the boundary line of Georgetown Green Sub-Divisiom to the center line of State Route 743; thence in a Northerly direction along State Route 743, to the Northwestern corner of parcel 27A, section 61; thence Easterly along the Northern boundary of parcel 27A, section 61 and continuing along Southern boundary of parcel 29, section 61, to a corner common with parcel~ 29, section 61, "Westfield," section 61W, and the Berkeley Gommunity, section 61M; thence with the Southwestern boundary of Berkeley, section 61M and parcel 119, section 61 to the center line UoS. 29; thence Northward along the center line of Hy. 29 to a point, the intersection of the center line of.Hyo 29 with the Southern boundar~ extended, of parcel 135A, section 61; thence with the Southern boundaries of parcels 135A and 135B, and 135 in a Southeasterly direction to a corner common to 135B and 136, section 61; thence along South boundary of 135B, section 61, in an Easterly direction to a corner common to lot 135B and Page 5 of 6 lot 14 of Chapel Hill Sub-Division; thence in a clock-wise direction around Chapel Hill Sub-Division to the center line of State Route 631 (Rio Road), the point of beginning° Page 6 of 6 Zo ,J 0 ~ ~ 0 wO~O ONO ~OO~N O~O ~qqhq ~qq~q h~qhh hq~qq ~8~r8 ~88~8 ~Sr~ ~8~~°° ~oo movm~o o© ROBERT S. TUCKER DIRECTOR TEL: f804) 371-9172 akatz@ scc.state.va.us oNWEALTI+ OF VI'" STATE CORPORATION COMMISSION PUBLIC SERVICE TAXATION DIVISION August 2001 P. O. BOX 1197 RICHMOND, VIRGINIA 23218 FAX 1804 371-9797 Dear Sir or Madam: In an effort to certify the annual assessments at an earlier date, we are hereby providing you with certified statements of assessed value for the electric, gas, water, and telecommunications companies that pertain to your locality. In prior years we have provided you with complete assessment books for all the localities within the Commonwealth by company type. That required sending the books to the printers for duplication and binding which resulted in an additional month delay before the assessments could be sent to you. We hope that you will find this change helpful in getting your tax bills out at an earlier date. Should you have any questions regarding this format or the assessments, please contact this office. Very truly yours, Robert S. Tucker Director TYLER BUILDING, 1300 EAST MAIN STREET, RICHMOND, VA 23219-3630 TELECOMMUNICATIONS DEVICE FOR THE DEAF-TDD/VOICE: (804) 371-9206 ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER CORPORATIONS - ALBEMARLE COUNTY A STATEMENT Showing the Value of Real and Tangible Personal Property of Electric Light and Power Corporations in the Commonwealth of Virginia, assessed as of the beginning of the first day of January 2001, pursuant to Title 58.1, Chapter 26, Article 2, of the Code of Virginia. NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION 1. Value of 2. Value of 3. Value of 4,5. Value of 6. Value of' 7. Value 8. Value of 9. Value of 10. Value of 11. Value 12. Value of Total Value OF PRINCIPALIN VIRGINIA.OFFICE OR AGENCY land and generating station overhead underground of meters and street automobiles of general material and value of of (Name and address shown in improvements, equipment, equipment, lines, conduit, line installations lighting and and tracks, plant supplies. / all merchants' parentheses is the officer of the company transmission transmission conductors, transformers and signal systems, equipment. Plant under property, capital. in charge of the settlement of taxes.) and and and and property construction. LOCATION OF PROPERTY distribution, distribution, devices, services, un customers' CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT premises. Appalachian Power Company Roanoke (R. K. Totten, Supw. State Tax ] Compliance, P. O. Box 2021, ] Roanoke, VA 24022-2121) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 382,416 0 1,800,912 3,983,002 628,389 1,355,900 248,067 20,635 0 2,299 52,787 8,474,407 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 0 24,438 8,874 74,847 28,988 10,078 0 - 0 6,573 153,798 0 tOTAL ALBEMARLE COUNTY .......... 382,416 0 1,800,912 4,007,440 637,263 1,430,747 277,055 30,713 0 2,299 59,360 8,628,205 0 2entral Virginia Electric Coop. Lovingston (Howard L. Scarboro, President & CEO, P. O. Box 247, Lovingston, VA 22949-0247) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 3 t 8,499 0 956,303 2,854,526 909,962 1,856,555 215,116 0 0 0 54,772 7,165,733 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 0 3,638 0 3,478 552 0 0 0 0 7,668 0 'OTAL ALBEMARLE COUNTY .......... 318,499 0 956,303 2,858,164 909,962 1,860,033 215,668 0 0 0 54,772 7,173,401 0 ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER CORPORATIONS ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED 2 NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION 1. Value of 2. Value of 3. Value of 4,5. Value of 6. Value of 7. Value 8. Value of 9. Value of 10. Value of 11. Value 12. Value of Total Value OF PRINCIPAL OFFICE OR AGENCY land and generating station overhead underground of meters and street automobiles of general material and value of . IN VIRGINIA of (Name and address shown in improvements, equipment, equipment, lines, conduit, line installations lighting and and tracks, plant supplies. / all merchants' parentheses is the officer of the company transmission transmission conductors, transformers and signal systems, equipment. Plant under property, capital. in charge of the settlement of taxes.) and and and and property construction. LOCATION OF PROPERTY distribution, distribution, d~vices. ' services, on customers' CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT premises. Potomac Edison Company, (The) Winchester (Wayne E. Wilson, Mgn. Taxes, Other/Tax Acct., Greensburg C.C., 800 Cabin Hill Drive, Greensburg, PA 15601) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 324,132 46,579 68,225 8,973 4,145 0 0 3,110 455,164 0 Rappahannock Electric Cooperative Fredericksburg (Cecil E. Viverette, Jr., President, P. O. Box 7388, Fredericksburg, VA 22404) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 143,500 0 3,316,326 1,467,096 1,020,131 954,139 194,484 0 0 0 217,087 7,312,763 0 ?irginia Electric & Power Company Richmond (Connie Stanley - Senior Tax Accountant, Tax Dept. 17tlffOJRP, P. O. BOX 26666, Richmond, VA 23261) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 959,791 0 10,380,605 24,182,800 29,082,252 22,558,842 2,954,536 989,535 88,969 1,905;467 122,446 93,225,243 0 }RAND TOTAL ALBEMARLE ........ 1,804,206 0 16,454,146 32,839,632 31,696,187 26,871,986 3,650,716 1,024,393 88,969 t,907,766 i 456,775 116,794,776 0 I GAS CORPORATIONS AND PIPELINE DISTRIBUTION CORPORATIONS - ALBEMARLE COUNTY A STATEMENT Showing the Value of Real and Tangible Personal Property of Gas Corporations and Pipeline Distribution Corporations in the Commonwealth of Virginia, assessed as o£ the beginning o£ the first day of January 2001, pursuant to Title 58.1, Chapter 26, Article 2, of the Code of Virginia. NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL 1. Value of 2. Value of 3A. Value of 3B. Value of 4. Value of 5. Value of 6. Value of 7. Value of Total 8. Value OFFICE OR AGENCY IN VIRGRqlA land and machinery, automobiles furniture, mains, services, meters and material and value of of (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer improvements, and fixtures and regulators, supplies. / all merchants' of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) tracks, miscellaneous Plant under property, capital. LOCATION OF PROPERTY equipment, construction. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT Columbia Gas of Virginia, Inc. Columbus (John O'Brien, VP of Tax, 200 Civic Center Dr., Columbus, OH 43215) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 11,900 23,027 0 0 158,184 5,037 2,929 0 201,077 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 8,041 0 0 42,134 29,824 2,535 0 82,534 0 Company Total ............... 11,900 31,068 0 0 200,318 34,861 5,464 0 283,611 0 GRAND TOTAL ALBEMARLE COUNTY .......... 11,900 31,068 0 0 200,318 34,861 5,464 0 283,611 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY A STATEMENT Showing the Value of Real and Tangible Personal Property of Telecommunications Companies in the Commonwealth of Virginia, assessed as of the beginning of the first day of January 2001, pursuant to Title 58.1, Chapter 26, Article 2, of the Code of Virginia. NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of .Value of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station automobiles general material and all merchants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY right of way) office equipment and trucks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, construction. 360° Communications Co. of Charlottesville clfo/a Alltel (c/o Robert D. Rash & Associates, Inc. ATTN: Toby Reese P.O. Box 1600 Rowlett, TX 75030-1600) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 2,494,297 578,661 4,226,445 0 121,872 552,878' 854,408 8,828,561 669,000 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 0 99,264 18,665 212,623 0 0 0 0 330,552 0 Company Total ............ 0 0 0 2,593,561 597,326 4,439,068 0 121,872 552,878 854,408 9,159,113 669,000 ;60° Communications Co. of Lynchburg clPo/a Alltel (c/o Robert D. Rash & Associates, Inc. ATTN: Toby Reese P.O. Box 1600 Rowlett, TX 75030-1600) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 9,193 0 0 0 0 31,097 0 40,290 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station automobiles general material and all memhants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY right of way) office equipment and tracks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, construction. 360° Communications Co. of Virginia, Inc. d/b/a Alltel (c/o Robert D. Rash & Associates, Inc. ATTN: Toby Reese P.O. Box 1600 Rowlett, TX 75030-1600) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS. 0 0 0 20,725 1,332 11,396 0 0 23,556 0 57,009 0 kT&T Communications of Virginia,/nc. (Jim DiFerdinando, Tax Director P. O. Box 1329 412 Mt. Kemble Ave Morristown, NJ 07962-1995) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 615,258 452,667 0 1,352,943 0 0 6,184 0 2,427,052 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 8,174 0 0 79,104 0 0 0 0 87,278 0 Company Total ............ 0 0 623,432 452,667 0 1,432,047 0 0 6,184 0 2,514,330 0 tmeriean Telephone And Telegraph Co. of Va. (Jim DiFerdinando, Tax Director P. O. Box 1329 412 Mt. Kemble Ave. Morristown, NJ 07962-1995) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 1,277,926 7,385,915 0 2,591,024 24,022 0 75,254 981,201 12,335,342 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 16,738 34,945 0 213,123 0 0 0 0 264,806 0 Company Total ............ 0 0 1,294,664 7,420,860 0 2,804,147 24,022 0 75,254 981,201 12,600,148 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PPdNCIPAL ,, CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station automobiles general material and all merchants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY fight of way) office equipment and trucks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, construction. Broadslate Networks of Virginia, Inc. (Dean Ferrell, Controller 630 Peter Jefferson Pkwy Suite 300 Charlottesville, VA 22911 ) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,683,326 0 1,683,326 0 Clew Network, Inc. (Steven Craig Highland, Director Tax Policy P.O. Box 1990 Waynesboro, VA 22980-7590) ALBEMARLE COUN'I~: ALL DISTRICTS 266,873 0 578,739 0 0 23,652 4,974 12,843 0 326,819 1,213,900 0 CFW Telephone, Inc. NTELOS Telephone, Inc. (Steven Craig Highland, Director Tax Policy 401 Spring Lane Waynesboro, VA 22980) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 35,515 0 0 0 0 0 0 35,515 0 Cellco Partnership . dfo/a Verizon Wireless (Charles Meadows, Associate Director 180 Washington Valley Road Bedminster, NJ 07921) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 9,176 0 134,221 0 0 4,972 0 148,369 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED 4 NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of ~)alue of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station~ automobiles general material and all memhants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY right of way) office equipment and tracks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, constmction. Central Telephone Company of Virginia (Jack Denny, Property Tax Specialist Property Tax Department P.O. Box 12913 Shawnee Mission, KS 66282) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 1,255,719 792,051 31,668,911 3,692,399 0 13,007,067 60,817 1,404,979 2,654 114,259 51,998,856 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 31,602 0 209,023 146,916 0 1,306,067 50,287 3,361 4,901 0 1,752,157 0 Company Total ............ 1,287,321 792,051 31,877,934 3,839,315 0 14,313,134 111,104 1,408,340 7,555 114,259 53,751,013 0 Uharlottesville Cellular Partnership T/A United States Cellular-Charlottesville (Mouv-Lang Lov, Senior Accounting P.O. Box 31369 Chicago, IL 60631) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 1,661,897 785,726 3,064,229 0 0 5,824 2,217 5,519,893 0 VICI WORLDCOM Network Services, Inc. (Jody Pace, Property Tax Manager 500 Clinton Center Drive Clinton, MS 39056) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 0 0 835 0 0 970 . , 0 1,805 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE CLAS~ CLASS 2 CLASS~ 3 Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. ' conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station automobiles general material and all merchants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY fight of way) office equipment and tracks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, construction. Nextel Communications of the Mid-Atlantic, Inc (Adele Jaffin, Preparer c/o Deloitte & Touche 1111 Broadway, Ste. 2100 Oakland, CA 94607-4036) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 0 0 35,736 0 0 0 0 35,736 0 Nextel WIP License Corp. d/b/a Nextcl Partners, Inc. or NPCR, Inc. (Jeanctte VanBelle, Finance Manager 4500 Carillon Point Kirkland, WA 98033) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 180,920 180,920 0 ~outhernNet Systems, Inc. (Jody Pace, Property Tax Manager 500 Clinton Center Drive Clinton, MS 39056) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 472,228 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 472,228 0 ;print Communications Company, L/P (Jack Denny, Property Tax Specialist P.O. Box 12913 Shawnee Mission, KS 66282-2913) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 1,573,113 0 0 30,872 0 0 0 0 1,603,985 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED 6 NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of land Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of · Value of value of of of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than antennas, central station automobiles general material and all merchants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY right of way) office equipment and trucks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, and apparatus. Plant under towers, construction. Triton PCS License Company, LLC d/b/a SunCom (Mike Morrell 1100 Cassatt Road Berwyn, PA 19312) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 15,632 20,830 2,062,237 0 0 109,613 1,019,862 3,228,174 51,920 Verizon South Inc. (Robert Garringer, Manager P.O. Box 152206 Irving, TX 75015-2206) ALBEMARLE COUN'I~: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 4,203 0 0 0 4,203 0 Verizon Virginia Inc. (Charles Burkhardt P.O. Box 52206 Irving, TX 75015-2206) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 64,557 320,625 1,488,093 170,1 I0 0 1,075,356 28,847 0 0 0 3,147,588 0 SCOTTSVILLE, TOWN OF 0 0 1,717 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,717 0 Company Total ............. 64,557 320,625 t,489,810 170,110 0 1,075,356 28,847 0 0 0 3,149,305 0 TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES - ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED 7 NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL CLASS 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 OFFICE OR AGENCY IN THIS STATE Total Value (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer Value of Value of Value of Value of lend Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of Value of value of of of the compeny in charge of the settleraent of taxes.) pole line. conduit, wire lines. (other than material and right of way) entennas, central station automobiles general · all merchants' LOCATION OF PROPERTY office equipment and trucks, equipment, supplies. / property, capital. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT buildings and equipment, end apparatus. Plant under towers, comhuctiun. Virginia Cellular, LLC (Brandy Lilly, Accounting Manager P.O. Box 1002 Staunton, VA 24402) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 31,027 2,934 57,732 0 0 0 0 91,693 0 Virginia PCS Alliance, L.C. (Steven Craig Highland, Tax Manager P.O. Box 1990 Waynesboro, VA 22980-7590) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 0 0 0 307,965 338,451 5~235,257 212,525 0 1,861 425,661 6,521,720 0 GRAND TOTAL ALBEMARLE COUNTY .......... 1,618,751 1,112,676 37,909,920 16,567,643 1,746,599 34,719,919 385,675 1,543,055 2,503,090 3,905,347 102,012,675 720,920 WATER CORPORATIONS - ALBEMARLE COUNTY A STATEMENT Showing the Value of Real and Tangible Personal Property o£ Water Corporations in the Commonwealth of Virginia, assessed as of the beginning o£ the first day of January 2001, ~ursuant to litle 58.1, Chapter 26, Article 2 of the Code of Virginia NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL 1. Value of 2. Value of 3A. Value of 3B. Value of 4. Value of 5. Value of 6. Value of 7. Value of Total 8. Value OFFICE OR AGENCY IN VIRGINIA land and machinery, automobiles furniture, mains, services meters and material and value of of (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer improvements, and fixtures and and fire other plant supplies. / all merchants' of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) trucks, miscellaneous hydrants, equipment. Plant under property, capital. LOCATION OF PROPERTY equipment, construction. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT Broad Run Service Corporation Fairfax (Eric Lamb, Pres., P O Box 986, Stanardsville, VA 22973) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 327 374 0 0 327 0 0 0 1,028 0 Earlysville Forest Water Company Charlottesville (Bryan Hiles, Asst. Controller, C/O AquaSource Inc., 200 Corporate Center Dr., Suite 300, Coraopolis, PA 15108) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 54,784 8,326 0 0 122,906 6,443 16,933 0 209,392 0 Keswick Utilities, Inc. Keswick, Va (Dean P. Andrews, Pres., 701 Club Drive, Keswick, VA 22947) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 926,152 0 0 0 900,454 0 0 0 1,826,606 0 WATER CORPORATIONS ALBEMARLE COUNTY - CONTINUED NAME OF COMPANY AND LOCATION OF PRINCIPAL 1. Value of 2. Value of 3A. Value of 3B. Value of 4. Value of 5. Value of 6. Value of 7. Value of Total 8. Value OFFICE OR AGITNCY IN VIRGINIA land and machinery, automobiles furniture, mains, services meters and material and value of of (Name and address shown in parentheses is the officer improvements, and fixtures and and fire other plant supplies. / all merchants' of the company in charge of the settlement of taxes.) trucks, miscellaneous hydrants, equipment. Plant under property, capital. LOCATION OF PROPERTY equipment, construction. CITY, COUNTY, TOWN AND DISTRICT Oakhill Water Company, Inc. Charlottesville (Sue B. Minor, Pres., 1017 Forest Lodge Lane, Charlottesville, VA 22903) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 38,379 1,133 0 0 8,744 0 16,243 0 64,499 0 Peacock Itill Service Company (Carole Horwitz, Treas., P.O. Box 284, IW, VA 22945) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 74,207 38,952 0 1,407 996 0 43,668 34,098 193,328 0 ?ublic Service Company of Virginia, Inc. Charlottesville (Joseph M. Casero, Pres., P.O. Box 304, Greenwood, VA 22943) ALBEMARLE COUNTY: ALL DISTRICTS 16,403 5,763 0 1,085 1,450 163 0 0 24,864 0 GRAND TOTAL ALBEMARLE COUNTY ........ 1,110,252 54,548 0 2,492 1,034,877 6,606 76,844 34,098 2,319,717 0 COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF THE STATE CORPORATION COMMISSION Richmond, Va. This is to certify that the foregoing is a true copy of the assessment made for the year 2001 by the State Corporation Commission of Virginia of the real and personal property of electric light and power corporations, gas and pipeline distribution corporations, telecommunications companies, and water corporations as of the beginning of the first day of January 2001. Teste: Clerk of the Commission To the Comptroller; President or proper officer of each company; Governing bodies of each County, City, and Town; Commissioners of the Revenue The foregoing certified copy of the assessments made by the State Corporation Commission of Virginia for the tax year 2001, is sent to you ~n accordance with the provisions of Title 58.1, Chapter 26, Article 6, of the Code of Virginia. Respectfully, Clerk of the Commission COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Response to Audit Committee - Carryover Policy/Maintenance and Equipment Fund SUBJECT/PRO POSAL/REQUEST: Request Board approval of recommendations for a Vehicle Maintenance Fund and a new carry-over policy. STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, White, Bullard AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: X CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: IN FORMATION: Yes BACKGROUND: On December 6, 2000, Albemarle County's Audit Committee submitted a report to the Board of Supervisors that contained nine recommendations. Staff prepared responses to seven of these on April 4, 2001. The attached report specifically addresses the two that have not been previously addressed - Recommendations #3 and flA. Recommendation 3: Develop Equipment, Replacement, and Maintenance Category or Budget: "We recommend a new category in our operating budget or a separate budget altogether for Equipment, Replacement, and Maintenance." Recommendation 4: Develop a formal process for dealing with annual surpluses: "The BOS should review capital and operating needs to determine priorities for surpluses. Also staff should recommend whether the funds should be held in reserve and invested or spent on current needs." DISCUSSION: See Attached Report. SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS: Develop Equipment, Replacement, and Maintenance Category or Bud.qet Staff has found that there is an efficient tracking system in place for most equipment, replacement, and maintenance items. In the General Fund, each department has control over its own budget for their small capital replacement needs, while major maintenance and replacement projects are funded in the CIP. Computer maintenance needs are budgeted' and tracked within each department and expenditures are transferred to Information Services to be expended. The School Division has a self-sustaining fund for bus repair and replacement and a separate line item in the ClP for both major and minor maintenance and repair needs. However, staff has found that the one area in which the County lacks a reliable tracking system is in vehicle maintenance and replacement. With the continued growth of the county fleet, it has become apparent that in order to alleviate the ups and downs in vehicle budgeting; a fleet management fund would be useful. 08-29-0t PO1:01 IN Develop a formal process for dealinq with annual surpluses Albemarle County dOes not have a written policy for allocating end-of year monies. These monies can come from either revenues collected over and above the budgeted amOunt and/or expenditure savings within departments. Currently, through the re-appropriation process, de partments can request re-appropriation for the continuation of projects already approved or encumbered amounts such as contracted studies. However, recently, departments have also begun to request their own expenditure savings for new requests that have not been previously approved. From the research, staff found that other counties are grappling with the same issues as Albemarle County, although there is no set mechanism that is consistently used. The research has also shown that those jurisdictions with guidelines clearly outlining priorities for the distribution of funds provide a more efficient process for the Board and staff's review of end-of-the-year review. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS 1. Staff recommends the creation of a "Fleet Management Fund" for the next fiscal year that will provide funds for repair, servicing, and replacement on a set cycle for County vehicles. 2. Staff recommends the following guidelines for a formal written carry-over policy: 100% of unbudgeted revenues and 60% of departmental expenditure savings (savings after all encumbered amounts are re-appropriated) will go into the Fund Balance to meet required cash flow needs. Any funds over and above what is necessary to meet minimum cash flow requirements will go to the CIP Reserve Fund for future capital needs, repair and maintenance items and/or debt service. The remaining 40% of departmental expenditure savings will be allocated as follows: 30% to a countywide gain sharing fund. Depending on the recommendation of the Leadership Council, this money will be used for either countywide initiatives or individual department requests. 10% to a countywide Innovation Pool that will be used to implement innovations such as technology improvements, productivity improvements, or countywide systems at the recommendation of the Leadership Council. These policies would be guidelines that are subject to the end-of-the-year revenues, fund balance needs, and other County or Board priorities that may arise. 01.161 2 STAFF RESPONSE TO AUDIT COMMITTEE: RECOMMENDATIONS #3 AND #4 CONCERNING A MAINTENANCE/REPLACEMENT/EQUIPMENT FUND AND FORMAL POLICY FOR ALLOCATION OF END-OF-YEAR MONIES SEPTEMBER 5, 2001 INTRODUCTION On December 6, 2000, Albemarle County's Audit Committee submitted a report to the Board of Supervisors that contained nine recommendations. Staff prepared responses to seven of these on Apdl 4, 2001. This report specifically addresses the two that have not been previously addressed - Recommendations #3 and fl4. These recommendations are quoted below: Recommendation 3: Develop Equipment, Replacement, and Maintenance Category or BUdget: 'l/Ve recommend a new category in our operating budget or a separate budget altogether for Equipment, Replacement, and Maintenance." Recommendation 4: Develop a formal process for dealing with annual surpluses: "The BOS should review capital and operating needs to determine priorities for surpluses. Also staff should recommend whether the funds should be held in reserve and invested or spent on current needs." Per the Board's request, County Executive staff has prepared a response to these recommendations. Staff examined current policies and procedures undertaken in Albemarle County and surveyed several Virginia localities to determine how they are handling these issues. Based on this analysis, staff is recommending courses of action. The report is divided up into 2 parts. The first section addresses Recommendation #3 and the second section addresses Recommendation fl4. PART A: RECOMMENDATION CONCERNING THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN EQUIPMENT, REPLACEMENT, AND MAINTENANCE CATEGORY CURRENT PRACTICE IN ALBEMARLE COUNTY Individual departments are responsible for budgeting vehicles, vehicle maintenance, and other small capital replacement items, such as furniture and small office equipment within their baseline budgets. These one-time items have historically been funded with fund balance, although in the current year most of the one-time maintenance and replacement items were budgeted in departmental budgets with anticipated year-end revenues, thus including carry-over replacement decisions in the annual budget review process. During the budget process, approximately $1.5 million dollars of anticipated carry-over funds were allocated to the School Division for their one-time needs, which could include one-time replacement and small maintenance items. County-wide major maintenance, repair, and replacement projects over $10,000, such as computer replacement and maintenance and repair for both general government, i.e. county office building, court square, parks and recreation and libraries, and schools, are budgeted as separate line items in the CIP and are, therefore, easily identified and tracked. The school capital maintenance/replacement line-item within the School Capital Fund funds 2 building repair, roof replacement, and HVAC replacement systems, as well as more minor items, such as carpet and tile replacement. Approximately $400,000 is budgeted in each year of the School CIP for small maintenance and repair items. School bus replacement is budgeted by the School Board in a separate self-sustaining fund. CURRENT PRACTICES IN OTHER LOCALITIES Staff conducted telephone interviews with officials from several Virginia localities to discern how other jurisdictions deal with maintenance, replacement, and equipment items in both the General Fund and the CIP. These jurisdictions included the counties of Hanover, Stafford, Prince William, and Chesterfield, and the cities of Roanoke and Charlottesville. As a result of such interviews, staff found that Hanover and Stafford counties include these items in individual line-item operating budgets, much the same as Albemarle County, while Prince William allocated CIP maintenance funds to the Department of Public Works as Albemarle does with separate line-items for Parks and Recreation, Schools, and Court Facilities. However, the survey also highlighted some unique practices of these jurisdictions that are outlined below. The City of Roanoke has a Capital Maintenance and Equipment Replacement Program ("CMERP"). CMERP is funded from the unexpended end-of-year balance in the City's General Fund, if any exists. In addition, the City has several "enterprise" and "internal service" funds which charge back usage costs to departments, creating earnings which are retained by these funds and applied to selected needs of the enterprises and internal services as part of the CMERP process. The process is a part of the Code of the City of Roanoke. The CMERP funding cycle is separate from the regular budget cycle. Requests are reviewed by a staff committee and funding recommendations are approved by City Council in August or September through an appropriations report. There are no specific criteria other than need and no dollar limits placed on requests. The selection of requests relies on the committee's knowledge and experience. The County of Prince William has several different funds to provide for maintenance and replacement items. The Seat Management Fund is an internal service fund in which the County has contracted with one vendor to handle all basic hardware and software replacement, help desk functions, and network connection needs. Departments pay a certain amount each year into this fund. Specialized software such as GIS is not covered and must be requested in the regular budget cycle or with carry-over monies. The County also has a Fleet Management Fund, which is an internal service fund that provides for the replacement and maintenance of vehicles. New vehicles must be requested in the general line item budget, and only thereafter, are moved into the Fleet Management Fund. · The City of Charlottesville has a separate Facilities Repair Fund and an Equipment Replacement Fund. Funds are set aside from the City/County Revenue Sharing Agreement to fund the Facilities Repair Fund. Funds for the Equipment Replacement Fund are budgeted within each department (both General Fund and non-General Fund) that operates vehicles. Funding for both of these funds is not guaranteed and can be adjusted during the budget process. The County of Chesterfield also has several separate internal service funds that address these needs. The Fleet Management Fund provides repair, servicing, and maintenance for both County and School Board vehicles. The County Maintenance Projects Fund, developed in conjunction with the CIP, provides a lump sum of money for maintenance and repair on large public facilities. The Technology Improvement Program Fund is also developed in conjunction with the CIP and prOvides for the funding of projects that cost more than $10,000, do not recur annually, and/or require more than 3 months of staff time to complete. ANALYSIS Four of the six surveyed jurisdictions have one or more specialized funds that have been set up to fund maintenance, repair, or replacement items. These are summarized below: Roanoke Prince William Charlottesville "CMERP" Seat Management Fund Facilities Repair Fund Fleet Management Fund Equip. Replacement Fund Chesterfield Fleet Management Fund County Maintenance Fund(CIP) Technology Improvement Fund (CIP) Sometimes, a jurisdiction that has a specialized fund for one area, such as vehicles, chooses to have a single line item for larger maintenance needs. For example, in addition to their Seat Management Fund and Fleet Management Fund, Prince William County has a line item in its CIP for maintenance projects that can be used at the discretion of the Public Works Department. This line item serves the same purpose as Chesterfield County's County Maintenance Projects Fund. But, although line items can serve similar purposes as separate funds, there is a difference between them. An internal service fund is a business management tool that charges departments' fees for a service or product. Either one is a way of financially tracking the spending of money, but internal service funds allow items to be budgeted without competing against Other line items and they save for their own capital. Internal service funds can be used to separate out specific items, like vehicles, and help departments track the maintenance needs of such items. However, the proliferation of internal service funds can complicate the budgetary process by 1 ) creating many off-budget and non-reported funds, and 2) producing administrative inefficiencies. Staff has found that Albemarle County has an efficient tracking system in place for most equipment, replacement, and maintenance items. In the General Fund, each department has control over its own budget for their small capital replacement needs, while major maintenance and replacement projects are funded in the CIP. Computer maintenance needs are budgeted and tracked within each department, and expenditures are transferred to the CIP for use by the Information Services Department. The School Division has a self-sustaining fund for bus repair and replacement and a separate line item in the ClP for both major and minor maintenance and repair needs. However, based on our research of other jurisdictions and conversations with local department heads, staff has found that the one area in which the County lacks a reliable tracking system is in vehicle maintenance and replacement. There are currently 256 vehicles in the county fleet, and this number grows each year. It has become apparent that in order to alleviate the ups and downs in vehicle budgeting, a fleet management fund could be useful for Albemarle County right now - without complicating the budget substantially. RECOMMENDATION · Staff recommends the retention of current methods of tracking small capital replacement items, computer maintenance needs, large capital maintenance projects, school bus replacement, and school maintenance projects. Staff recommends the creation of a "Fleet Management Fund" for the next fiscal year that will provide funds for repair, servicing, and replacement on a set cycle for County vehicles. This will involve an annual charge levied to each department depending on the number of vehicles, although the specific financing details must still be worked out and a plan presented to the Board of Supervisors during the next budget process. PART B: RECOMMENDATION CONCERNING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A FORMAL PROCESS FOR DEALING WITH END-OF-YEAR SURPLUSES CURRENT PRACTICE IN ALBEMARLE COUNTY Currently, Albemarle County does not have a written policy for allocating end-of-year funds. These monies can come from either revenue collected over and above the budgeted amount and/or expenditure savings within departments. Currently, through the re- appropriation process, departments can request re-appropriation for the continuation of already approved projects or prior year encumbered amounts, such as contracted studies and purchase orders. However, departments have recently begun to request their own expenditure savings for new one-time requests that have not been previously approved by the Board. Departments submit requests to the County Executive's Office and the Finance Department in August, with review by the Assistant County Executives and requested approval from the Board in September or early October. At the end of FY98, FY99, and FY00, county departments saved a total of $699,866, $533,760, and $635,104, respectively, after re-appropriations for continued projects or purchase orders. Approximately 50% of those savings were due to staff turnover, vacancies, and other salary lapses. CURRENT PRACTICES IN OTHER LOCALITIES Each year, revenue projections and actual expenditures can be over or under budgeted amounts due to circumstances beyond the control of individual localities, such as state revenue shortfalls or cutbacks and economic upturns or downturns. Because of this, all of the contacted jurisdictions have had annual end-of-the-year funds left over that required them to develop formal or informal financial policies that guide the use of such funds. In both Stafford County and Hanover County, excess revenues and expenditure savings are allocated to the fund balance, while encumbered amounts are re-appropriated by departments. However, Hanover is considering a "County Savings Plan" where departmental savings will go for emergency projects that come up or projects that cost more than budgeted, rather than going into the fund balance. In the City of Roanoke, the year end balance is allocated for specific purposes, including fund balance, the CIP, and Capital Maintenance and Equipment Replacement Program (CMERP). See explanation in Part A. Prince William County has a process whereby departments and agencies can request the use of their savings from the previous fiscal year for a special one-time project or item, including maintenance and repair items. Excess revenues are directed to the Fund Balance. The Budget Office submits a funding recommendation to the Board, contingent on the larger countywide financial condition. The Budget Office and the Board give preference to agencies or departments whose savings have resulted from a process improvement or efficiency rather than simple under spending. This gives people the opportunity to be rewarded for their contribution. There is also some flexibility for allocating these funds, if a department has a critical need that must be funded, but has no savings. However, the Budget Director in Prince William pointed out that this process involves a great deal of time and effort during the summer months when many staff members are out, and often times, departments include requests that do not fit the criteria. He suggested that they may return to a traditional carry-over process where all savings are returned to fund balance. The City of Charlottesville has a written policy by which any expenditure savings departments have at the end of the fiscal year is split 55% to the fund balance, 30% to their gain-sharing account, and 15% to the Innovation Pool. The gain sharing monies can be uSed by departments for any purpose, at the discretion of the department head. Typical expenditures include extra training, travel for education, and bonuses. The Innovation Pool is a program administered by the City's leadership organization that rewards innovative employee recommendations that result in increased customer service, increased safety, or other benefits to the department. These policies are subject to the City ending the year in an overall positive financial position. City Council also developed a policy that any funds in the General Fund Balance (excess revenues) above and beyond the 12% required reserve get automatically transferred to the Capital Fund. The County of Chesterfield has a year-end process very similar to Albemarle County's. A memo must be submitted to Budget and Management to request appropriation of unspent appropriations or excess revenues for use in the following fiscal year. This memo must detail the projected revenue surplus or expenditure savings and reason for such, the requested amount of appropriated expenditure savings, and description of the proposed use. Funding of these projects is approved bythe Board and depends on the availability of funds and the County's financial condition. ANALYSIS The Audit Committee directed staff to look at setting priorities for funds available at the end of each fiscal year. From the research, staff found that other counties are grappling with similar issues as Albemarle County, although there is no set mechanism for allocating year-end fund consistently used by localities. Most do, however, limit the use of money for one-time projects to expenditure savings, not unbudgeted revenues, and all find that their guidelines are contingent upon the jurisdiction's financial standing and immediate needs. 7 The research has also shown that those jurisdictions with guidelines cleady outlining priorities for the distribution of funds, such as the City of Charlottesville, have a more efficient process for the Board and staff's review of end-of-the-year review, RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends the following guidelines for a formal written carry-over policy: · 100% of unbudgeted revenues and 60% of departmental expenditure savings(savings after all encumbered amounts are re-appropriated) will go into the Fund Balance to meet required cash flow needs. Any funds over and above what is necessary to meet minimum cash flow requirements will go to the CIP Reserve Fund for future capital needs, capital repair and maintenance items and/or debt service. These reserve funds could also be used for unexpected emergency situations that may arise. · The remaining 40% of departmental expenditure savings will be allocated as follows: 30% to a county-wide gain-sharing fund. Based on the departmental savings for the last 3 consecutive fiscal years outlined eadier, this would average approximately $187,000 a year. Depending on the recommendation of the Leadership Council and the County Executive's Office each year, these funds money would be used for either county-wide initiatives or individual department requests. Departmental requests can be submitted throughout the year and approval would be based, not only upon the justification of the projected use, but also the nature of the savings. Preference will be given to those savings that were due to process improvements or innovation, rather than salary lapses or simple under-spending. 10% to a county-wide Innovation Pool that would be used to implement innovations such as technology or productivity improvements and/or county-wide training or system improvements at the recommendation of the Leadership Council. Details on this process will be worked out by the Leadership Council and the County Executive's Office. · These policies would be guidelines that are subject to the end-of-the-year revenues, fund balance needs, and other County or Board priorities that may arise. 8 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Public Hearing for Ordinance to amend Chapter 11, Parks and Recreation, of the Albemarle County Code SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Adoption of proposed ordinance to amend the leash law in County parks to allow designated off leash areas. STAFF CONTACT(S): Mr. Tucker, Ms. White, Mr. Davis, and Mr. Mullaney AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: X ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: I N FORMATION: ATTACHM .EN~,~ ~r-~Ordinance REVIEWED B'~:~ BACKGROUND: Historically the City of Charlottesville has not had a leash law in City parks. An increase in conflicts between unleashed dogs and park users has caused the City to reevaluate this position. The City has created a fenced off-leash area referred to as a dog park at Azalea Park. The dog park has been very heavily used. The City would like to expand the number of dog parks in the area but available space in the City is limited. Some of the dog owners using City parks are County residents. The City has requested that a dog park be located at Towe Park. The Towe Park Committee has approved this request. Towe Park is managed by the Albemarle County Parks and Recreation Department for the City and County and is governed by the Albemarle County Code. Section 11-120 of the. Albema tie County Code requires all pets to be on a leash and under control while on parklands. This section of the code needs to be amended to allow dogs off-leash in such areas that are designated for that purpose. The County Attorney has prepared the attached ordinance to permit off leash areas to be designated in County parks. RECOMMENDATION: After the public hearing, staff recommends that the Board adopt the attached ordinance. 01.165 Draft: 07/11/01 ORDINANCE NO. 01-11( ) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 11, PARKS AND RECREATION FACILITIES, ARTICLE I, IN GENERAL, DIVISION 3, CONDUCT WITHIN AND USE OF PARKS, OF THE CODE OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA BE IT ORDAINED Bythe Board of SupervSsors of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, that Chapter 11, Parks and Recreation Facilities, Article I, In General, Division 3, Conduct Within and Use of Parks, is hereby amended and reordained as follows: By Amending: Sec. 11-120 Pets. Chapter 11. Parks and Recreation Facilities Article I. In General Conduct Within and Use of Parks Division 3. Sec. 11-120 Pets. All pets shall be kept on a leash and under control while on park lands except in designated areas clearly identified by authorized signs allowing pets not to be leashed. (9-12-79; Code 1988, § 14-6.14; Ord. 98-A(1), 8-5-98; Ord. 01-11(1), 8-1-01) I, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of an Ordinance duly adopted by the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, by a vote of __ to __, as recorded below, at a regular meeting held on Mr. Bowerman Mr. Dorrier Ms. Humphris Mr. Martin Mr. Perkins Ms. Thomas Aye Nay Clerk, Board of County Supervisors COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE 08-2~-01 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A08:50 IN AGENDA TITLE: FY 01 Budget Amendment Public Hearing SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST'. Public Hearing on Proposed FY01 Budget Amendments in the amount of $233,830.72 and approval of Appropriation #20081 and 20082 for various school and local government programs. STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Breeden; Ms. White AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: .ACTION: X ATrACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: BACKGROUND: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Yes ~ The Code of Virginia §15.2-2507 stipulates that the County must hold a public hearing to amend its current budget if the additional appropriated amounts exceed 1% of the original budget or $500,000, whichever is the lesser. The Code section applies to all funds, i.e., Capital, E-911, School Self-Sustaining, etc., not just the General Fund or the County's adOpted operating budget. To meet this requirement and to provide timely appropriation of funds, a regular public hearing is scheduled on the first day meeting of each month to have all appropriations heard and approved. DISCUSSION: This proposed FY01 Budget Amendment totals $233,830.72. The chart below breaks out the estimated revenues and expenditures for the amendment in the General and Piedmont Regional Education Program (PREP) Funds. ESTIMATED REVENUE General Fund/Other Funds State Grant Revenues Fund Balance - Other Funds General Fund/Other Funds Est. Revenue PREP Fund Fund Balance PREP Fund Estimated Revenue TOTAL ESTIMATED REVENUE ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES General Operating Fund Public Safety Total General Fund Expenditures 1,848.64 2,686.41 $ 4,535.05 $ 229,295.67 $ 229,295.67 $ 233,830.72 $ 4,535.05 $ 4,535.05 PREP Fund $ 229,295.67 TOTAL ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES $ 233,830.72 This budget amendment consists of two appropriations that will need approval subsequent to the public hearing. A detailed description of these appropriations is provided on Attachment A. RECOMMENDATION: Subsequent to the public hearing, staff recommends the Board of Supervisors amend the FY02 Budget in the amount of $233,830.72, and approve Appropriation #20081 and 20082 as detailed on the appropriation forms. 01.155 Attachment A APPROPRIATION #20081 ApproPriations $229,295.67 Funding for FY 2001 PREP Activities The County served as fiscal agent for activities relating to the construction of the new Piedmont Regional Education Program building. During FY 2001, construction expenses totaled $229,295.67. Funds from the PREP Fund Balance will be used to fund these expenses. APPROPRIATION #20082 4,535.05 Funding for FY 2001 EMS Grant Activities The Virginia EMS for Children Program administered by Virginia Commonwealth University has approved 2 mini- grants providing funds to assist with childcare and babysitter safety and car seat training efforts. The County of Albemarle Board of Supervisors approved the grants for the 1999/00 fiscal year. This appropriation request reappropriation for the completion of the program in the 2000/01 fiscal year. There is no local match. Revenues are provided by the EMS fund balance and EMS grant funds. APPROPRIATION REQUEST FISCAL YEAR: 00/01 NUMBER 20081 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: ADDITIONAL TRANSFER NEW X ADVERTISEMENT REQUIRED ? YES NO X FUND: P.R.E.P. PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: FUNDING FOR FY01 ACTIVITIES. EXPENDITURE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1 9810 61194 800200FURNITURE/FIXTURES $ 16,094.90 800605 CONSTRUCTION 213,200.77 TOTAL $ 229,295.67 REVENUE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 2 9810 51000 510100 FUND BALANCE $ 229.295.67 TOTAL $ 229,295.67 TRANSFERS REQUESTING COST CENTER: EDUCATION APPROVALS: DIRECTOR OF FINANCE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIGNATURE DATE JULY 23, 2001 APPROPRIATION REQUEST FISCAL YEAR: 00/01 NUMBER 20082 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: ADDITIONAL TRANSFER NEW X ADVERTISEMENT REQUIRED ? YES NO FUND: E.M.S. GRANTS PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: FUNDING FOR FY01 ACTIVITIES. EXPENDITURE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1 1558 32012 312500 INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPLIES $ 2,000.00 1 1559 31012 930200 TRANSFER TO GRANT PROJECTS 2,535.05 TOTAL $ 4,535.05 REVENUE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 2 1558 24000 240415 EMS FUNDS $ 1,848.64 2 1558 51000 510100 FUND BALANCE 151.36 2 1559 51000 510100 FU ND BALANCE 2,535.05 TOTAL $ 4,535.05 TRANSFERS REQUESTING COST CENTER: FIRE RESCUE APPROVALS: DIRECTOR OF FINANCE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIGNATURE DATE AUGUST 13, 2001 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AG EN DA TITLE: FY 02 Budget Amendment Public Hearing SU BJ ECTIPROPOSAL/REQUEST: Public Hearing on Proposed FY02 Budget Amendments in the amount of $2,386,938.59 and approval of Appropriation #2001007, 2001008, and 2001009 for various school and local government programs. STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Breeden; Ms. White AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: X ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: BACKGROUND: The Code of Virginia [}15.2-2507 stipulates that the County must hold a public hearing to amend its current budget if the additional appropriated amounts exceed 1% of the original budget or $500,000, whichever is the lesser. The Code section applies to all funds, i.e., Capital, E-911, School Self-Sustaining, etc., not just the General Fund or the County's adopted operating budget. To meet this requirement and to provide timely appropriation of funds, a regular public hearing is scheduled on the first day meeting of each month to have all appropriations heard and approved. DISCUSSION: This proposed FY02 Budget Amendment totals $2,386,938.59. The chart below breaks out the estimated revenues and expenditures for the amendment in the Tourism, Capital Improvement, and School Funds. ESTIMATED REVENUE Tourism Fund Local Revenues State Grant Revenues Fund Balance Tourism Fund Estimated Revenue Education Funds Local Revenues Education Funds Estimated Revenue Capital Improvement Fund - General Transfer from Tourism Fund C.I.P.- General Estimated Revenue TOTAL ESTIMATED REVENUE $ 847,240.00 25,000.00 913,945.50 $1,786,185.50 $ 1,807.59 $ 1,807.59 $ 598,945.50 $ 598,945.50 $2,386,938.59 08-29-01 P12:37 IN ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES Tourism Fund Contingency Transfer to CIP Tourism Fund Expenditures Capital Improvement Fund - General Education Operating Fund TOTAL ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES 179,240.00 1,606,945.50 1,786,185.50 598,945.50 1,807.59 2,386,938.59 This budget amendment consists of three appropriations that will need approval subsequent to the public hearing. A detailed description of these appropriations is provided on Attachment A. RECOMMENDATION: Subsequent to the public hearing, staff recommends the Board of Supervisors amend the FY02 Budget in the amount of $2,386,938.59, and approve Appropriation #2001007, 2001008, and 2001009 as detailed on the appropriation fOrms. 01.156 APPROPRIATION #2001007 Appropriations Attachment A $837,240.00 Original Appropriation for FY02 Tourism Fund To establish the original budget for the FY02 Tourism Fund, this action recognizes that 60% ($837,240) of the FY 02 hotel/motel room tax estimate of $1,395,400 is reserved by code for tourism related projects. The following tourism-related projects were approved in the Ca pital Improvement Budget: 1. Court Square Enhancements $ 250,000.00 2. Rivanna Greenway 25,000.00 3. Paramount Theater 33,000.00 4. Acquisition of Conservation Easements 350,000.00 $ 658,000.00 This action will authorize the transfer of this amount to the CIP Fund, leaving a contingency of $179,240 from FY02 revenues in the Tourism Fund. After year end balances are finalized, Tourism Fund balances will be allocated to the General Fund for already committed projects. APPROPRIATION #2001008 $1,547,891.00 Reappropriation of Tourism Projects From FY01 Based on a decision made in the capital improvement process to budget tourism related capital projects in the CIP using Tourism revenues rather than budgeting them in a separate tourism fund, this request is to reappropriate uncompleted FY01 tourism projects into the FY02 CIP Fund. This request includes seven projects totaling $598,945.50 plus the $350,000 allocated for the A.C.E. Program in FY01 that has not yet been expended. APPROPRIATION #2001009 $1,807.59 Sutherland Middle School received a donation in the amount of $609.59 from Ahold Financial Services. This donation will be used to purchase instructional materials for the school. Murray Elementary School received an anonymous donation in the amount of $500.00. This donation will be used to support the miscellaneous needs of the school. Crozet Elementary School received a donation in the amount of $298.00 from Andrew Sche iner and Mary Gallo. This donation will be used to purchase instructional supplies for the school. Greer Elementary School received a donation in the amount of $400.00 from William Tucker III. Mr. Tucker stipulated that $200.00 be used to purchase instructional supplies for Lisa Molinaro's 1't grade class and $200.00 be used to purchase instructional supplies as needed. APPROPRIATION REQUEST FISCAL YEAR: 01/02 NUMBER 2001007 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: ADDITIONAL TRANSFER NEW X ADVERTISEMENT REQUIRED ? YES NO X FUND: TOURISM PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: ORIGINAL APPROPRIATION FOR FY02 TOURISM FUND. EXPENDITURE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1 1810 72030 999999 TOURISM CONTINGENCY $ 179,240.00 1 1810 93010 930010 TRANSFER TOC.I.P. 658,000.00 CODE 2 1810 12000 TOTAL $ 837,240.00 REVENUE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT **~**~*** ******************************************* ************************** **~**~*~****~*~** 121000 HOTEL/MOTEL ROOM TAX $ 837,240.00 TOTAL $ 837,240.00 TRANSFERS REQUESTING COST CENTER: FINANCE APPROVALS: DIRECTOR OF FINANCE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIGNATURE DATE JULY 19, 2001 APPROPRIATION REQUEST FISCAL YEAR: 01/02 NUMBER 2001008 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: ADDITIONAL TRANSFER NEW X ADVERTISEMENT REQUIRED ? YES NO X FUND: TOURISM/C.I.P. PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: REAPPROPRIATION OF TOURISM PROJECTS FROM FY01. CODE 1 9010 72030 568901 1 9010 72030 950026 1 9010 72030 950055 1 9010 72030 950056 1 9010 72030 950107 1 9010 72030 950111 1 9010 72030 950112 EXPENDITURE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT ******************************************* ************************** ~c*~c******~****$c***~* VISITOR'S BUREAU-MAINT. RIVANNA GREENWAY RT 250/616 TURN LANE IVY ROAD BIKE LANES RIVER ACCESS IMPROVEMENTS GREENBELT-BOAT ACCESS GREENBELT-FREE BRIDGE $ 8 700.00 60 000.00 110 000.00 5 500.00 30 000.00 369 745.50 15 000;00 1 1810 93010 930010 TRANSFER TOC.I.P. 598,945.50 I 1810 93010 930010 TRANSFER TOC.I.P. 350,000.00 TOTAL $ 1,547,891.00 REVENUE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 2 9010 51000 512034 TRANSFER FROM TOURISM $ 598.945.50 2 1810 18000 181108CONTRIBUTION-DEVELOPER $ 10,000.00 2 1810 24000 240500 STATE GRANT 25,000.00 2 1810 51000 510100 TOURISM FUND BALANCE 913,945.50 TOTAL $ 1,547,891.00 TRANSFERS REQUESTING COST CENTER: FINANCE APPROVALS: DIRECTOR OF FINANCE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIGNATURE DATE JULY 19, 2001 APPROPRIATION REQUEST FISCAL YEAR: 01/02 NUMBER 2001009 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: ADDITIONAL TRANSFER NEW X ADVERTISEMENT REQUIRED ? YES NO X FUND: SCHOOL PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: AUTHORIZATION TO EXPEND DONATED FUNDS. EXPENDITURE CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1 2255 61101 601300 ED/RECSUPPLIES $ 609.59 1 2215 61101 580000 MlSCSUPPLIES 500.00 1 2203 61101 601300 ED/RECSUPPLIES 298.00 1 2204 61101 601300 ED/RECSUPPLIES 400.00 CODE 2 2000 18100 TOTAL $ 1,807.59 REVENUE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 181109 DONATIONS $ 1,807.59 TOTAL $ 1,807.59 TRANSFERS REQUESTING COST CENTER: EDUCATION APPROVALS: DIRECTOR OF FINANCE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIGNATURE DATE AUGUST 16, 2001 BOARD -TO -BOARD September 5, 2001 - 10:30 a.m. A Monthly Communications Report of activities from the Albemarle County School Board to the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors. Highlights: School Board Briefs for August 9 and 23, 2001 were, provided through e-mail. RECENT 2000-2002 BOARD/SUPERINTENDENT PRIORITIES: At its June 16 Retreat, the Board began to review the 2000-2002 Board/Superintendent Priorities and the progress that is being made towards meeting the priorities. The Board discussed revisions to the Priorities at its June 28 and August 9 meetings. The Priorities were approved at the August 23 meeting. In developing the priorities, the School Board is placing major emphasis on measurable outcomes. For the coming year, the Board is also going to place special emphasis on increasing parental involvement. The Priorities are important because they drive the School Division in terms of time, energy and resources. (Attachment 1 is a copy of the Adopted Priorities). PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: At its August 9 meeting, the Board established that the Pledge of Allegiance will be recited in all Albemarle County Schools during the first hour of each school day. This is in response to a new state law. The American Legion has generously donated new flags for a number of our classrooms and will be recognized at the September 13 meeting BACKPACK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS: At a previous meeting, a parent brought to the attention of the Board issues involving the weight of backpacks. At that time, there was Board consensus for this issue to be reviewed and recommendations presented to the Board. The School Board Health Advisory Board Backpack Committee presented recommendations at the August 9 meeting. Staff recommended implementing some of the recommendations while others needed more review. Some of the recommendations included an introductory educational program, weekly backpack cleanup, and · putting a weight limit on textbook selection. STANDARDS OF LEARNING: At the August 9 meeting, the Board received a preliminary report on the Standards of Learning test results. Based on this preliminary information, eleven Albemarle County schools met full accreditation requirements. Those schools are Broadus Wood, Cale, Greer, Hollymead, Meriwether Lewis, Red Hill, Stone- Robinson, Stony Point, Woodbrook, V.L. Murray Elementary Schools and Westem Albemarle High School. A number of other schools are very close to meeting the requirements for full accreditation. It is a School Board Priority that all schools be accredited by next year. STRATEGIC PLAN: The Board received the 2001 and Beyond Strategic Plan on August 9th for information and discussion. The Board held further discussion at the meeting on August 23. The Strategic Plan highlights the school division initiatives planned to meet specific School Board Goals and School Board/Superintendent Priorities. The initiatives drive the daily work of the school division. The Board will consider the Strategic Plan, you are receiving today, for adoption at the September 13 meeting. (Attachment 2) FUTURE ITEMS OF INTEREST HONORARY HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA: The 2001 General Assembly adopted Senate Bill 1210 establishing an honorary diploma .and designating the first week in September as Virginia World War II Veterans Appreciation Week. Senate Bill 1210 recognizes the educational, personal and financial sacrifices made by World War II veterans who served in the armed forces. Some veterans left school before completing the requirements for their high school diploma, and many were not able to finish their high school education upon returning home. Bill 1210 provides for the issue of an honorary high school diploma to qualified veterans according to guidelines developed by the Board. (Attachment 3 is a copy of Superintendents Memo No. 109 from the Department of Education) GUIDELINES FOR THE DISTRIBUTION OF CAMPAIGN MATERIALS: At the August 23 meeting, the Board adopted a set of guidelines for the distribution of materials by Political Candidates on school grounds. Attachment 4 is a copy of the memo to principals that sets forth the guidelines. We hope that the guidelines will help the schools deal with candidates in an equitable manner. MIDDLE SCHOOL REVIEW: The Board received a preliminary report from the Thomas Jefferson Center for Educational Design on the Middle Schools Review Project, Part I and Executive Summary. The report included a snap shot of our middle schools. Although the report includes recommendations, it also states that the middle schools provide a sound education for the vast majority of students. Principals and School Improvement Teams are analyzing the division and individual school data for inclusion of objectives in School Improvement Plans. The Middle School Steering Committee is also reviewing the recommendations and will present updates and action plans to the Board. After further review and research of the recommendations, the Middle School Steering Committee may come forward with one or more budget initiatives during this year's budget cycle to further improve our middle schools. Attachment 1 2000-2002 School Board/Superintendent Priorities (Updated August 23, 2001) The School Board/Superintendent Priorities are designed to support the Division's Mission and the five System Goals, which have been formally adopted in Albemarle County School Board Policy AE. The Priorities are organized based on the five System Goals. Much of the evidence of progress on System Goals and Board Priorities is documented in the Division's Annual Progress Report. Mission The primary mission of the Albemarle County Schools is to provide and promote a dynamic environment for learning through which students acquire the knowledge, skills, and values necessary to live as informed and productive members of society. Goal I - Student Performance Standards Priority 1.1 - Standards of Accreditation · By 2002, all schools will be accredited. · All students will graduate through one of the following: - acquisition of sufficient course work and verified credit to graduate with a Standard, Modified Standard, or Advanced Studies diploma; or, - satisfactory completion of an Individualized Education Program (IEP). Priority 1.2 - Academic Progress of High Achieving Students By 2002, the percentage of students scoring at the advanced level on each SOL test will meet targeted increases, as approved by the School Board. (See attached table.) By 2003, the percentage of students earning an Advanced Studies Diploma will increase from 59% to 65%; the percentage of students in grades 9-12 taking one or more Advanced Placement courses will increase from12.6% to 15%; and, the percentage of students in grades 9-12 taking at least one Advanced Placement test will increase from 8.8% to 10%. Goal 2 - School Climate and Board Adopted Values Priority 2.1 - School Climate and Board Adopted Values · By 2002, a minimum of 70% of students served by the Enterprise Center (excluding students who leave the Division)will be successfully transitioned back into a Division school or earn a GED, IEP, Standard, Modified Standard, or Advanced Studies diploma. Priority 2.2 - Equity and Diversity · By June 30, 2002, Board members, the Superintendent, and Assistant Superintendents will participate in at least two (2) additional Multicultural Competency Workshops. Goal 3 - Feeder Pattern Support Priority Priority 3.1 - K-12 Achievement Gap Intervention Programs The achievement gap between black and white students and between students eligible for free/reduced lunch and those who are not, as evidenced by English and Math SOL test results, will decrease by 25% per year until closed in 2004. 3.2 - Student Passing SOL and Scoring at Grade Level I in Reading, Writing, and Math By the spring of 2002, 85% of students in grades 3, 5 and 8 will pass the SOL tests in language arts and math. The 2001 Progress Report will include data concerning the Division's progress in meeting the goal to have at least 85% of students in grade 2 scoring at or above grade level on a local reading assessment. Attachment 1 Goal 4 - Curriculum and Staff Development Priority 4.1 - Grade Level Performance Benchmarks/Workplace Standards · By 2004, local assessments will be developed and implemented in all core content areas to measure students' ability to apply knowledge in performance situations using portfolios and performance assessments that are representative of grade level performance benchmarks. Priority 4.2 - Middle School Program Review · As a result of data gained from the Middle School Program Review, specific improvement strategies will be implemented and the Board will receive fall and spring reports of middle school activities and action plans. Priority 4.3 - Staff Development · Through the "Leading the Learning" initiative in 2001-2002, administrative, teacher, and site-based professional development will be jointly focused on the Division's major instructional initiatives. · Building level professional development focus areas will be established by December, 2001. Goal 5 - Extended School Community Priority 5.1 - Communications 80% of parents will agree or strongly agree that the school their child attends is satisfactory based upon each of the Effective Schools correlates in the 2001 Parent Survey and/or through possible future use of a structured telephone poll. During the 2001-2002 school year, the School Division will implement a structured =Families Count" initiative designed to proactively promote family involvement in the educational process. Priority 5.2 - Budget Process The School Division will work directly with the Local Government Finance Department to identify and purchase an updated financial management software package. Division Goals Support Priority The recruitment and retention of high-quality and diverse teaching, administrative, and classified staff will continue to be vigorously pursued, with particular emphasis on increasing the percentage of minority teachers to reflect the diversity of the system. Recruitment and Retention · The current gap between system diversity (15%) and the percentage of minodty teachers (8%) will be reduced by 25% each year beginning in the fall of 2001. PRIORITY 1.2 - IMPROVEMENT TARGETS - ADVANCED LEVEL ON SOL TESTS Grade 3 Test 2000 performance 2002 Target English 15.2 20.0 Mathematics 42.2 50.0 Grade 5 Test 2000 Performance 2002 Target Reading 25.5 30.0 Writing 34.5 40.0 Mathematics 16.7 25.0 Grade 8 Test 2000 Performance 2002 Target Reading 33.2 40.0 Writing 9.8 30.0 Mathematics 12.8 25.0 End-of,Course Tests (The Superintendent reserves the right to revise targets upward based on peer group information.) Test 2000 2002 Target Performance Reading/Literature 20.4 30.0 Writing 20.3 30.0 Algebra I 8.4 20.0 Geometry 12.8 25.0 Algebra II 8.1 20.0 World History I 19.1 30.0 World History II 10.8 25.0 U.S. History 6.6 15.0 Earth Science 9.9 25.0 Biology 16.7 25.0 Chemistry 7.3 20.0 Commonwealth of Virginia' World War II Veteran Hdn0rary High School Diploma Copy to: Jean Murray COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA .......................... DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION P.O~ BOX 2120 RICHMOND, VIRGINIA 23218-2120 Page 1 of 2 SUPTS. MEMO NO-. '109 AUgust 3, 2001 I N FORMAT I ONAL TO: Division Superintendents FROM: Jo Lynne DeMary S.uperin~endent of Public ~nstructiOn SUBJECT: Commonwealth of Virginia World:War,II Veteran Honorary High School Diploma This memorandum provides information about the establishment Of the Commonwealth of Virginia World War II Veteran Honorary High School ~iploma to be issued by the Board of Education. T~e 2001 Genera~- Assembly adopted. Senate Bill 1210, sPonsored by then SenatoF, now Congressman, Randy Forbes, to establish thm.hgn°rary diploma a_n~ designate the first week in September as Virginia World War:-II ~eter~ns Appleton Week. At its July me:e'ting, ith~_.Board-~ Education adopted guidelines for the application process and the award of the diplomas. These guidelines, a copy of SB 1210, and a sample diploma are attached. Senate Bill 1210 recognizes the. educational, personal,..and financial sacrifices made by World War II veterans who sebved in the United States armed forces. The General Assembly found that some of these veterans left school before completing the requirements for their high school diploma. Many of them were unable to complete their high school education, for various reasons upon returning home. Because the General Assembly found that these veterans have made "significant contr~but~o to this country "while gaining substantial knowledge and skills through work," Senate Bill 1210 provides for the issue of the honorary high school diploma by the Board of Education'~o qualified veterans accordi~ -to guidelines developed by the b~ar~. "" Any eligible World War II veteran may apply for the Commonwealth of Virginia World War II Veteran Honorary High School Diploma by filing with the board a writteh statement including the following: 1. The veteran's full name; 2. Branch of service; 3. Dates of service; 4. Location of last school attended; and htto ://www.ven.k 12.va.us/VDOE/suptsmemos/2001/inf109.html 8/3/01 Attachment A to Info Memo No. 109 · S Guidel,ne for Commonwealth of V IB · · ~rg~n~a World War !! Veterans Honora~ High School Diploma State Board of Education July 26, 2001 Attachment A to Info Memo No. Guidelines for Honorary Diplomas for World War II Veterans Introduction In recognition of the efforts and sacrifices of veterans who served in World War il, the 2001 General Assembly designated the first full week in September as Virginia World War II Veterans Appreciation Week, beginning in September 2001. The General Assembly found that between 1939 and 1945, many young persons from Virginia and other states left school to serve in the armed forces as the United States fought World War I1. These individuals made great sacrifices and suffered economic and personal loss in order to protect their country and its people and to defend humanity. ~ Many of these young people were not able to continue their education upon retuming home because of financial hardship and other personal reasons. Despite educational constraints, these veterans2 "reentered society and made significant contributions to our country through hard work as civilians, while gaining substantial knowledge and skills through work."3 They "have earned and do deserve our esteem and gratitude and our acknowledgement that without their sacrifices, our lives would not be the same as they are today.''4 Requirements of the Code of Virginia Pursuant to § 2.1-27.2:01 and § 22.1-17.4 of the Code of Virginia, World War II veterans who were unable to complete their high school education may apply for a Commonwealth of Virginia Wodd War il Veteran Honorary High School Diploma if they meet the criteria specified by the Board of Education. Any World War I! veteran may apply for an honorary high school diploma by filing with the board a written statement declaring that: The veteran served in a branch of the United States Armed Forces during the years between 1939 and 1945; 2. The veteran was drafted or enlisted in the United States Armed Forces; and 3. The veteran was unable to resume his education upon returning to civilian life. Virginia Board of Education Requirements ~ SB 1210, General Assembly 2001. 2 The term veteran means a person who served in the active military, naval, or air service, and who was discharged or released under conditions other than dishonorable. 38 USC § 101. 3 SB 1210, supra. 4 Id. Attachment B to Info Memo No. 109 Request Form for Honorary Diploma for World War Ii Veterans~ I. Veteran's full name: II. Branch of service: III. Dates of service: IV. Location of last school attended prior to military service: V= I, the undersigned, was drafted or enlisted in the United States Armed Forces2; and I was unable to complete my high school education upon returning to civilian life. Signature: Date: ~ These diplomas will be issued pursuant to §§ 2.1-27.2:01 and 22.1-17.4 of the Code of Virginia. z The veteran may have been enrolled as a student in any school in any state or territory, or located on or associated with any military base or embassy. VIRGINIA ACTS OF ASSEMBLY -- 2001 SESSION CHAPTER 263 An Act to amend the Code of Virginia by adding sections numbered 2.1-27.2:01 and 22.1-1Z4, relating to the Virginia World War II Veterans Appreciation Week and certain 'honorary high school diplomas. IS 12101 Approved March 15, 2001 Whereas, between 1939 and 1945, World War II the most devastating war to occur on earth -- raged across Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Pacific islands; and Whereas, more than 16 million young Americans, many of whom left high school as mere teenagers to take up this cause, served in the United States Armed Forces during this period, defending their country and humanity; and Whereas, the economic and personal loss suffered by these young Americans can only be imagined, with lives interrupted and inexorably altered; and Whereas, upon returning, many of these young Americans were unable to resume their schooling becaus~ of economic and other personal reasons; and Whereas, these young Americans reentered society and made significant contributions to our country through their hard work as civilians, while gaining substantial knowledge and skills through wor~; and Whereas, in the golden'years of their lives, the veterans of World War II have earned and do deserve our esteem and gratitude and our acknowledgement that without their sacrifices, our lives would not be the same as they are today; now, therefore, Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia: 1. That the Code of Virginia is amended by adding sections numbered 2.1-27.2:01 and 22.1-17.4 as follows: 37 2.1-27.2:01. Virginia World War II Veterans Appreciation Week; honorary diplomas to be awarded under certain circumstances during such week. A. In recognition of the sacrifice of the members of the United States Armed Forces who served in World War II, the first full week in September, i.e., the week that was the first full official week of peace in 1945, shall hereby be designated the Virginia World War H Veterans Appreciation Week, beginning in September 2001. In accordance with the Board of Education's guidelines as authorized by 37 22.1-17.4, any veteran of World War H may apply for a Commonwealth of Virginia World War II Veteran Honorary High School Diploma by filing with the Virginia Board of Education a statement declaring that: 1. During the years between 1939 and 1945, he served in any branch of the United States Armed Forces; 2. He was drafted or did enlist in the United States Armed Forces while still enrolled as a secondary school student in any school in any state or territory of the United States or any school located on or associated with a United States military base or embassy; and 3. He was unable to resume his secondary education upon returning to civilian life. B. Upon receiving a statement in compliance with this section and 3722.1-17.4 that has been filed in accordance with its guidelines, the Board of Education shall award the veteran a Commonwealth of Virginia World War H Veteran Honorary High School Diploma. Such diploma shall be delivered during Virginia World War II Veterans Appreciation Week. 3722.1-17.4. Certain honorary diplomas to be issued under specific circumstances. A. Any veteran of World War II may apply to the Board of Education for a Commonwealth of Virginia World War II Veteran Honorary High School Diploma by filing, in compliance with Board guidelines, a statement declaring that: 1. During the years between 1939 and 1945, he served in any branch of the United States Armed Forces; 2. He was drafted or did enlist in the United States Armed Forces while still enrolled as a secondary school student in any school in any state or territory of the United States or any school located on or associated with a United States military base or embassy; and 3. He was unable to resume his secondary education upon returning to civilian life. B. The Board of Education shah establish guidelines setting forth the timeHnes and procedures for applyittg-:~for such diplomas. Upon the filing of the required statement in accordance with its guidelines, the Board of Education shall award the veteran a Commonwealth of Virginia World War II Veteran Honorary High School Diploma. Such diplomas shall be delivered to eligible veterans during the first full week in September that has been designated, in accordance with 3~ 2.1-27.2:01, as the Virginia Worm War II Veterans Appreciation Week. ALBEMAI~LF~ COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Memorandum TO Principals FROM Frank Morgan RE Distribution of Materials by Political Candidates DATE August 24, 2001 We have received requests from various political candidates to hand out literature at high school athletic events, orientations, PTO meetings, back-to-school nights, and other school events. Based on consultation with legal counsel and discussion with the School Board on August 23, we are responding to these requests as follows: We have permitted Candidates to pass out literature at high school athletic events in the past, and will continue to do so. However, this activity will be subject to the following time, place and manner, restrictions: Candidates will be required to confine their activity to a specific area outside the stadium area or building designated by the Principal. Candidates will not be permitted to distribute materials inside the stadium area or building, nor will they be permitted to set up tables or booths outside the stadium area or building, or place literature on vehicle windshields. Candidates will also be asked to make every effort to leave the area in which they were distributing materials free of discarded materials. Literature may be distributed from one hour before the game until 30 minutes after the end of the game. We have not previously permitted candidates to pass out literature on school property at orientations, PTO meetings, back-to-school nights, and other school events. Legal counsel has advised that there is no legal or policy requirement for us to do so, and one group cannot be favored over another. Therefore, this prohibition will continue. A candidate may stand on non-school property at such events, on a public thoroughfare, to distribute literature. · Literature may be distributed in conjunction with a bona fide candidate forum. In addition, Athletic Directors and club sponsors should not accept gifts from candidates that are advertisements, such as footballs to throw into the stands, water bottles?,dentifying the candidate, and the like. Candidates may purchase advertising in game~programs. Please check with me if there is any question in this area. A copy of this memo will be disseminated to candidates. Please feel free to contactme if you have any questions or need any guidance. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY P04:78 iN AGENDA TITLE: Land Use Taxation Program SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Update on Albemarle County's Land Use Value Taxation Program/Options for Changing Land Use Policy and Implementation STAFF CONTACT(S): Mr. Tucker, Ms. White & Mr. Breeden AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ITEM NUMBER: ACTION: X INFORMATION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTAC H M ENT~S~Y~,~ REVIEWED BY: ~k~"-' INFORMATION: BACKGROUND: The attached report on the Land Use Value Taxation Program is brought to the Board in response to several questions on program implementation, as well as a request for more information on the Sliding Scale Roll-Back legislation. This report includes a bdef summary of the enabling legislation, the general policies and procedures and updated figures on the size and deferred value of the program. A separate section discusses some of the same alternatives to the current land-use taxation program that were presented to the Board in a 1994 report, as well as a discussion of an annual revalidation process and the Sliding Scale Rollback legislation. DISCUSSION: Under the current land-use value taxation policy, the County has approximately 310,319 acres under land use, approximately 65% of the County's total acreage. The annual tax deferral to the County is approximately $7.2 million dollars, a deferral that has been exacerbated over the past 10 years by rapidly declining SLEAC values in horticulture and agriculture. Following the program overview, the second part of the report is divided into three sections to address several policy or implementation options: The first section updates the three options for changing land use eligibility that were discussed in the 1994 Board re port. Those three options were: · Eliminate all categories of use value taxation (only eligible land within agricultural forestal districts would qualify for land use). · Use value taxation for open space classification only. · Eliminate use value on forest land only. The second section offers two options for tightening land use value taxation eligibility requirements: · Require periodic revalidation of land use properties. · Expanded review of parcels in the land use program by County staff. The third section provides an analysis of the new Sliding Scale Roll-Back provision: · Allows a longer roll-back period in exchange for a higher tax deferment. RECOMMENDATION: This report is brought to the Board for information purposes only and does not require any action at this time. Should the Board be interested in pursuing any of these options, staff would be prepared to come back to the Board with a more in-depth analysis of the cost, impact, timeframe, etc. of that specific option. 01.162 Land Use Value Taxation Statutory Provisions for Land Use Under the provisions of Title 58.1-3230 of the Code of Virginia, a county, city, or town may adopt an ordinance that provides for use-value assessment under four categories: real estate devoted to agricultural use, horticultural use, forest use and open space use. Land used in agricultural and forestal production in an agricultural district, a forestal district, or an agricultural/forestal district is eligible for use value assessment in the absence of a local ordinance. The State Land Use Advisory Council ISLEACI was created in 1973 to estimate the use value of eligible land for each locality participating in a use-value taxation program. Once a local land use ordinance is adopted for a land use classification, any parcel that meets the state criteria for that category must be granted use value taxation. The County does not have the authority to impose additional eligibility requirements based on zoning restrictions or on the owner's future intentions for the use of the land. The enabling legislation further states that before use-value assessment is granted, the local assessing officer must determine that the land meets the uniform standards for agricultural and horticultural use as defined by the Commissioner of Agriculture and Consumer Services, for forest use as defined by the State Forester, or for open-space use by the Department of Conservation and Recreation. The County adopted ali four categories of land use in 1975. Each category of land use must meet prescribed standards and minimum acreage requirements: A,qriculture Use: Land used for agricultural use must consist of a minimum of five acres and must meet prescribed standards for a bona fide production for sale of crops and/or livestock or be in an approved soil conservation program. Horticulture Use: Land used for horticulture use must consist of a minimum of five acres and must meet prescribed standards for bona fide production for sale of fruits, vegetables, ornamental plants and/or ornamental products. Forest Use: Land used for forestal use must be a minimum of twenty acres and must include standing timber and trees devoted to tree growth in such quantity and so spaced and maintained as to constitute a forest area. Open Space: Land in open space must be at least five acres or such greater minimum acreage, set by local ordinance, and be used to provide or preserve the [and for park or recreational purposes, conservation of land or other natural resources, floodways, historic or scenic purposes or to assist in the shaping of the character, direction, or timing of community development, or for the public interest and consistent with the local land use plan. in 1990, the Board set the minimum acreage for open space at 20 acres. Land Use Report 1 08/29/01 Application Process A property owner must submit an application for taxation on the basis of use assessment at least sixty days prior to the tax year for which the reduced taxation is sought. Anyone receiving use value taxation must submit a reapplication whenever a change 'n acreage or a change 'n land use occurs. Albemarle County charges a fee of $15 per parcel plus 15 cents for each acre over one hundred acres for initial applications and reapplications. In order to qualify a property owner must certify on the application that the property meets the standards of classification prescribed by the Commissioner of Agriculture, the Director of Conservation and Recreation, or the State Forester. Land use guidelines provide that the following items may be helpful in determining eligibility for land use: The assigned USDA/ASCS farm number. Federal tax forms (1040F) Farm Expenses and Income, (4835) Farm Rental Income and Expenses, or (1040E) Cash rent for Agricultural land. A conservation Farm Management and/or Forest Management plan prepared by a professional or a letter of intent stating that the land will be forested. Evidence that gross sales averaged more than $1,000 annually over the previous three years. Although a number of localities require these items, the County requests these documents only if a physical review of the property is insufficient to determine eligibility, it should be kept in mind that most of the property in the land use program originally qualified in the mid 1970s and no revalidation has been done since that time. During the biennial reassessment, the County's real estate division does its best to ensure that land use properties continue to meet the classification standards set by the State. If continued eligibility of the property is suspect, the Assessor will require the landowner to submit proof that the land is either being farmed or forested. If the County Assessor determines that the property no longer meets the classification standards, the property is removed from land use and roll-back tax is assessed. Any property owner denied use value assessment may appeal the County Assessor's decision to the local Land Use Advisory Board. Roll-back When land changes to a non-qualifying use, the property is then subject to roll-back taxes for the year of the change and for five years preceding the change, including 10% simple interest. In the years 1991-2000, Albemarle County collected $1,250,627 in roll-back taxes on 7,787 acres Isee Exhibit A). Legislative attempts to increase the roll- back period from 5 years to 10 years have repeatedly failed in the General Assembly. Land Use Report 2 08/29/01 State-Wide Utilization of the Land Use Pro.qram There are 95 counties in the Commonwealth of Virginia, 69 of them allowed land use value taxation in 2001. Of this number, 42 counties allow for agriculture, horticulture, forestry, and open space use. Twenty counties allow for only three uses with the major excluded category being open space. Six counties allow only agriculture and horticulture as qualifying uses: Amelia, Floyd, Lancaster, Orange, Prince Edward and Wythe. Only Amelia County has changed the status of its land use program (eliminating all categories except agriculture/horticulture) since the program's inception in 1973. Current Status of Land Use in Albemarle County Based on current real estate assessment data, Albemarle County has 310,319 acres under land use, approximately 65% of the County's 473,600 acres. Agriculture accounts for 103,087 of the County's land use acres (33%), 204,719 acres (66%) are in forestry and the remaining 2,513 acres (1%) is in horticulture and open space. Of the total amount of acres under land use, 21% (66,100 acres) are currently enrolled in agricuitural/forestal districts. Since 1994, the acreage enrolled in the land use program has declined 7%. Tax Implications of Land Use in Albemarle County Exhibit A. below shows the deferred assessment, the deferred tax and the roll-back taxes collected since 1991. Assuming 2001 deferred tax revenues of $7.2 million, the FY2000/2001 real estate tax revenue at $686,700 per penny, and a tax rate of $0.76, the additional cost to ineligible properties is approximately 10.5 cents on the tax rate. Exhibit A. 1991 4,388 329,843 0.72 583,345,000 4,192,884 111,407 1,931 1992 4,417 * 0.72 581,014,040 4,183,301 119,111 665 1993 4,550 331,147 0.72 751,753,780 5,412,627 139,016 783 1994 4,611 * 0.72 741,335,980 5,337,619 200,901 814 1995 4,613 332,472 0.72 764,241,670 5,502,540 105,755 797 1996 4,680 * 0.72 763,538,570 5,497,478 99,822 547 1997 4,784 321,195 0.72 759,462,599 5,468,131 99,097 648 1998 4,841 * 0.72 761,253,899 5,481,028 108,493 509 1999 4,743 315,309 0.72 761,784,400 5,484,848 176,061 656 2000 4,953 * 0.76 781,041,450 5,935,915 90,964 437 2001 4,983 310,319 0.72 / 950,530,600 7,222,437 ** 146,091 ** 750 0.76 · Acreage report is done in reassessment years only. · * Information is year-to-date. Land Use Report 3 08/29/0 t Exacerbating the burden on ineligible properties in the past few years, particularly 1999 and 2001, has been the increasing disparity between the rising fair market values on rural land and the decreasing SLEAC land use values. Attachment A shows SLEAC values for land use properties in Albemarle County over the last ten years. The suggested 2002 SLEAC values when compared to 2001 values indicate an average decrease of 13% in the agricultural rates, a 31% decrease in horticulture rates, and a 10% increase in forestry rates. The 2002 suggested SLEAC rates are being furnished for comparison purposes only, as new SLEAC rates in Albemarle County will not take effect until 2003, the next general reassessment. Factors driving the decline include continued Iow negative returns, a 7% decline in government payments from TY 2001 to TY 2002, an increase in long-term interest rates {SLEAC rates are determined using data that is at least two years old} and increased machinery costs in some counties where producers are switching tillage types in an effort to increase yields. Orchard values are experiencing extreme declines- on average nearly 50%, due to continued losses resulting in net zero returns. A large number of orchards are going out of business in Virginia as market preferences change. The varieties of apples grown in Virginia are no longer in demand and most apples in Virginia are being processed or used for juice. Orchards that are staying in business are dedving their income from real estate transactions or retail "niche" stores. Exhibit B. below summarizes SLEAC value trends in the preceding decade. Exhibit B. Average SLEAC Values in Albemarle County 700 .m 600 · ~ 500 ~ 400 .__ .,~ 300 -, 200 o E 100 '~ 0 Year Avg. Agriculture Avg. Horticulture Avg. Forestry As stated above, properties ineligible for use value taxation bear a greater share of the property tax as a result of the land use program. It is implicit in the concept of land use taxation that the tax burden is shifted to other taxpayers, as well as implicit in the program intent that the redistribution of the tax burden is '~n the public interest both to the direct beneficiaries of land use and to the other taxpayers who derive indirect benefits from land preservation. Whether one can demonstrate that land will ultimately be preserved or protected for the long run benefit of the community is a separate question. Land Use Value Taxation Policy and Implementation Options This part of the report is divided into three sections: the first section presents three options for changing categories of land eligible for land use. The second section offers options for tightening eligibility requirements - one through an annual revalidation and Land Use Repo~ 4 08/29/01 the other through a dedicated staff person to monitor land use. The third section provides an analysis of new legislation that allows a longer roll-back period 'n exchange for a higher deferment. Land Use Eligibilify Option 1: Eliminate all categories of use value taxation Result: Only eligible land that meets the agricultural/forestal districts would quality for land use. SLEAC criteria within Advantages: Eliminating all categories of land use would have a large impact on County revenues. With only 66,100 acres currently enrolled in agricultura/forestal districts with $1.3 million in deferred taxes, the immediate benefit to the County could be approximately $5.9 million annually. Roll-back taxes would continue to be collected on parcels that were previously in land use, but not in the agricultural/forestal districts, for up to five years, if the use changed to a non- qualitying use. Realized revenues may be substantially lower, since some rural properties would likely join an agricultural/forestal district. (Since this would have such an immediate and negative impact on the farming community, it is assumed that the effective date of such a policy change would be deferred to allow rural parcels to either join an existing agricultural/forestai district or create a new one.) Since agricultural/forestal districts are permitted only in the rural areas, land use in the growth areas would be eliminated. Currently there are 4,371 acres in growth areas with deferred tax revenues of $334,1 60 (see Exhibit C.). Of land use acreage in growth areas, 2117 acres are in the urban ring, 797 acres are near airport road, 1269 acres are in Crozet and 188 acres are east of town, near Boyd's tavern. Exhibit C. Ra 1,500 R 1 1,923 R2 273 R4 361 R6 190 R15 97 prd 27 These properties are still in the program because they were rezoned by governmental action where the property owner had no decision in the rezoning. The vast majority were zoned during the original zoning process, which went into effect in the late 1960s. Although this option would eliminate land use in the growth areas, targeted properties over 25 acres with environmental, recreational, scenic or historical benefit to the County could receive land use by being designated a mini- agricultural/forestal district within the growth area. Land Use Report 5 08/29/01, Requires a 4 to 10 year commitment from bona fide agricultural/forestal parcels and ultimately gives local government more control over the location and extent of land use taxation. Disadvantages: Eliminating all categories of land use may have a destabilizing and devastating effect on the bona fide agricultural community, because uncertainty will be created around long-term investment return. The impact on the small farmer may be devastating, s'nce tax increases may rise to levels exceeding a farmer's annual income. · Potential loss of important natural resources. Property owners no longer qualifying for land use may pose the threat of opening up their land to immediate development. Although some support this view, others argue that development is linked to demand and that the rate of growth would not change significantly. · Administrative problem to- rapidly agricultura/forestal districts. organize and implement new Option 2: Use Value Taxation for Open Space Classification Only I~esult: This option would eliminate use value taxation for agricultural, forestal and horticultural classifications and allow only the open space designation. Based on a 1989 amendment to the use-value taxation law, a locality may authorize use-value for open space only. This option could achieve a similar effect as Option 1, which would eliminate use value except for etigibie parcels within the agricultural/forestal districts. It may also encourage property owners to grant an easement to a public body in return for the benefit of use value taxation and the assurance that the property will be preserved as open space. If this option is chosen, the property must meet one of the fol owing three requirements: be within an agricultural, a forestal, or an agricultural/forestal district; be subject to a recorded perpetual easement that is held by a public body, and promotes the open space use classification; be subject to a recorded commitment entered into by the landowners with the local governing body not to change the use to a non-qualifying use for a time period stated in the commitment of not less than four years nor more than ten years. The withdrawal procedures for this commitment are similar to those of the ag/forestal districts. Advantages: · May be best alternative from a planning perspective, because it increases local government"s capability of directing land use taxation toward the goals of the Land Use Report 6 08]29/01 comprehensive plan. Involves governing body 'n decisions about land to be included in agricultural/forestal districts or subject to a contractual agreement. Allows more Board control over the range and extent of use value taxation through the contract option. · Requires a commitment from the property owner to preserve the land for a specific period of time in exchange for the tax benefits of land use. Disadvantages: Would require current recipients of land use to make a commitment not to develop their land for a specified period of time. However, length of commitment could be based on proximity to the path of development with a minimum agreement period of 4 years. · Administrative problems to either enroll current eligible properties into agricultural/forestal districts or develop individual contracts for Board approval. Option 3: Eliminate Use Value on Forest Land Only Result: In Albemarle County, this would eliminate more than 64% of the land currently enrolled in land use (199,436 acres). Advantages: Would have initial large increase in revenues. Although it is not possible to break out the deferred taxes on forest land only, assuming the value of forest land at half that of agricultural land, the realized revenues could be as much as $3.3 million. However, since much of the forestland might eventually be incorporated into an agricultural/forestal district, recovered revenues could be significantly less. · Parcels in agricultural/forestal districts could still qualify for land use taxation, if eligible under the forest classification. Disadvantages: Forestland provides non-market benefits to the community, i.e. temperature moderation, reductions in non-point source pollution, critical slopes, natural beauty and animal habitat. · The comprehensive plan purposefully established the 21-acre rural lot size in order to qualify for all types of use value taxation, including forestal. Land Use Report 7 08/29/01 Land Use Eligibility Standards Opfion 4: Require periodic revalidation of land use properties Once the property has qualified, the governing body may require any property owner to revalidate annually on any land previously approved for taxation on the basis of land use. The code also allows a locality to impose a revalidation fee every six years. The revalidation fee cannot exceed the original application fee. Currently in Albemarle County there is no revalidafion requirement or revalidation fee. The four types of documentation listed in the application section could be required 'n a periodic revalidation process. Currently appraisal staff visits all properties on a biennial basis, and the parcels are field checked at the time of the appraisal review for compliance to State standards. Thus, receipt of these documents has never been strictly enforced, and the need to revalidate land use parcels on an annual basis has never been required. It has been the policy of the County Assessor's office to monitor all parcels in the land use program to ensure they meet and maintain al State and local land use standards. However, it is becoming more difficult for appraisal staff to provide the ongoing supervision required by the program. Advantages of requiring revalidation: · May ensure that necessary qualifying information concerning land use parcels is accurate on an annual basis. Revalidation fee would be a source of revenue. (The current fee would produce approximately $72,000 every sixth year.) Process would notify ail property owners (especially new owners) on an annual basis that they are enrolled in a tax deferral program. · Proof could be required from the land use participants of a farming/forestry/horticulture operation (i.e., Schedule F, income receipts, farm numbers, etc.) · Acts as an annual reminder of the standards of qualifying uses. Disadvantages of requiring revalidation: · Revalidation fee can only be charged every sixth year. · Additional cost to administer the program (i.e., increased staff, office space, storage space]. At a minimum this expense is estimated to be $55,000 per year, compared to $72,000 in revenue every sixth year. · Appraisal staff currently visits land use parcels on a biennial basis, which makes revalidation seem redundant. · Possible confusion resulting from filing land use application and revalidation form in the same year, if property is subdivided after revalidation. · Failure to meet deadline(s) would result in parcel being removed from the program, resulting in taxpayer complaints. Land Use Report 8 08/29/01 Option 5: Ongoing review of parcels in the land use program by a County staff person devoted solely to assuring program compliance Currently, County real estate assessors do their best to make sure properties enrolled in the land use program continue to meet classification standards. County personnel devoted solely to the land use program were phased out approximately twenty years ago as the number of new land use program applications declined. Advantages of specialized land use compliance inspections: · Increased expertise of inspectors and increased effectiveness of inspections (e.g. scheduling inspections of agricultural tracts during growing season} could be more effective in identifying non-complying parcels. · More cost effective than annual revalidation. · Places a lesser burden on landowners than revalidation. Disadvantages: · Additional cost to administer the program (i.e., hiring an assessor dedicated to land use compliance). · Possible redundancy with assessor staff visits. Additional costs that would be incurred by implementing Option 4 or 5 could be partially offset by raising the County's land use program application and/or reapplication fee. Albemarle County currently charges an initial application and reapplication fee of $15 per parcel plus 15 cents for each acre over one hundred acres, This fee has not been changed since the County adopted the land use program in 1975. The table below compares the application fee in Albemarle with those of surrounding iurisdictions. Exhibit D. Albemarle County $15 plus $0.15 per acre over 100 acres Augusta County $12 plus $0.15 per acre over 100 acres Fluvanna County $10 plus $0.10 per acre over 100 acres Greene County $15 Louisa County $10 Nelson County $50 plus $0.25 per acre over 100 acres Orange County $15 or $0.15 per acre Rockingham County $50 plus $25.00 for adjoining parcels Exhibit E. below indicates the amount of fees received by Albemarle County for land use applications and reapplications for the past five years. Relatively few new parcels come into the land use program because most eligible parcels are already enrolled in the program. Land Use Report 9 08/29/01 Exhibit E. 1996 27 . 252 $ 405 $ 3,783 279 $4,188 1997 89 174 1,335 2,608 263 3,943 1998 30 25 ] 585 3,772 281 4,357 1999 41 162 685 2,435 203 3,120 2000 32 254 480 3,809 286 4,289 Total 219 1,093 $3,490 $16,407 1,312 $19,897 Legislative Option Option 6: Sliding Scale Rolhbacl< Legislation In recent years the majority of urban localities have experienced rapid growth and have looked at additional methods of containing sprawl. In 2000 a bill was introduced in the General Assembly and ultimately signed into law that allows localities, upon adoption of a local ordinance, to provide for a Sliding Scale Roll- back. The Sliding Scale Roll-back extends the roll-back from 5 years up to 20 years. In conjunction with this extension, the deferment is also increased up to 99% of the current use value. To participate, a property owner must enter into an agreement with the locality and by doing so, gives up their right to change the use of the property for up to 20 years. There are several options available for setting the contractual time frame. The deferment can be increased at a rate of 5% each year up to the 20th year where it would be increased 4% and the deferment held at 99% thereafter. The scale could be set up to give a 50% reduction for the first 10 years of a 20-year contract and increased to 99% for the last 10 years or the scale could be set up to give 99% reduction every year during the 20-year contract. It could also be set at a fractional part of the 20-year period, for example 10 or 15 years, with a prorated reduction in the deferment. To date, only Loudoun County has adopted the Sliding Scale Ordinance. They chose to set their scale at 50% reduction for 10 years and 99% reduction for the next 10 years. A copy of Loudoun County's ordinance is attached accompanied by some of their statistical information regarding program participation (Attachment B). At this time only 9 % of the eligible applicants have signed up for the program. This equates to about 11% of the land available for the program. On average, each applicant saves an additional $246 annually. Albemarle County would need to conduct its own analysis to determine the costs of implementing the Sliding Scale Roll-back. Advantages of the Sliding Scale Roll-back: · Properties under this agreement might not be developed for up to 20 years. · The additional tax deferment could be insignificant to the locality. · The roll-back could be up to 20 years versus the current 5 years, thus a source of additional revenue. Land Use Report 10 08/29/01 Disadvantages of the scale: Data will have to be maintained for up to 20 years, as opposed to the current five years. The current sliding scale roll-back legislation does not require a participant to continue in the land use program for the entire 20-year period. The sliding scale agreement is revocable on the part of the landowner at anytime during, the entire agreement period. For example, if the owner chose to change the use of the property to a non-qualifying use, the parcel would have to be removed from the program and a roll-back bill issued. Land Use Report 11 08/29/01 Category: 2001 County Acreage Agriculture: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Use Value 239 35,879 27,923 18,993 255 12,319 7.460 19 '103,087 1991/92 SLEAC Value County of Albemarle Use Value Taxation 1993/94 1995/96 1997/98 SLEAC SLEAC SLEAC Value Value Value Attachment A 650 410 56O 520 590 370 510 470 430 280 380 350 350 220 300 280 260 170 230 210 220 140 190 170 130 80 110 100 40 30 40. 30 43,725,442 27,735,502 37,961,392 34.972,852 1999/2000 SLEAC Value 46O 410 310 24O 180 150 9O 3O 30,600,502 2001 SLEAC Value 150 140 100 8O 6O 5O 3O 10 10,225,891 Ho~iculturel: 1 0 1,060 810 880 1,240 910 32¢ 2 519 1,100 860 890 1,120 970 350 3 514 940 760 760 830 860 310 4 375 850 700 680 660 800 290 5 0 630 520 510 500 590 210 6 351 520 420 420 -410 480 170 7 175 330 280 270 250 310 110 8 ~ 50 30 40- 80 30_ 10 Use Value 1,934 1,613,080 1,295,900 1,302,220 1,443,060 1,468,2'00 528,660 Ho~iculture h 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Use Value 760 840 1,130 850 300 800 840 1.020 900 330 700 710 750 790 290 640 630 600 730 270 480 470 450 540 190 390 390 370 440 160 250 2'40 220 280 100 30 40. 70 30_ 10 244,690 248,190 264,930 276,130 101,040 0 109 75 66 0 100 95 0 445 1,010 1,030 87O 78O 58O 48O 310 5O 306,450 Forestry: 1 71 617 260 230 230 320 270 240 2 29,578 180 160 160 225 185 165 3 103 393 120 105 105 145 120 105 4 131 100 100 100 100 100 75 UseValue 204,719 36,364,720 32,073,755 32.073,755 44,577,575 37.228,780 32,934,540 Open Space: 1 0 650 410 560 520 460 150 2 44 590 370 510 470 410 140 3 45 430 280 380 350 310 100 4 38 350 220 300 280 240 80 5 0 260 170 230 210 180 60 6 3 220 140 190 170 150 50 7 3 130 80 110 100 90 30 8 0 40 30 40_ 30 30 10 Use Value 134 59,908 38,060 52,058 48,079 42,008 13,999 1991 - 2001 Reduction -76.925 -76.27% -76.74% -77.14% -76.92% -77.27% -76.92% -75.00% -76.61% -69.81% -68.18% -67.02% -65.88% -66.67% -:67.31% -66.67% -80.00% -67.23% -70.30% -67.96% -66.67% -65.38% -67.24% -66.67% -67.74% -80.00% -67.03% -7.69% -8.33% -12.50% -25.00% -9.43% -76.92% -76.27% -76.74% -77.14% -76.92% -77.27% -76.92% -75.00% -76.63% Total 310.319 $82069,600 $61,387.,906 $71,637,615 $81,308,496 $69,615,620 $43,804,129! -46.63% Attachment B COUNTY OF LOUDOUN DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SER VICES OFFICE OF THE ASSESSOR ~ H~RR~SON StREEt, S.E. LEESBURG, VA 20177-7000 (703) 777-0290 finance~co.loudoun.va.us SLIDING SCALE DEFERRAI~ FOR PROPERTY HELD FOR LONGER PERIODS IN QUAIJFYING USE .Loudoun County Land Use Assessment Statistics Total Parcels: 76,000 Total Acres: 331,520 Land Use Parcels: 4,772 Land Use Acres: 189,345 Sliding Scale Statistics Sliding Scale Parcels: 417 Sliding Scale Acres: 20,965 Est. Additional Deferral: (Assessed Value) $9,500,000 Est. Additional Deferral: (Tax Dollars) $ 102,600 Use Value A/V: $219,005,280 (Land Only) Land Use Tax $$: $ 2,365,257 ORDINANCE OF LOUDOUN COUNTY CHAPTER 848.036 SLIDING SCALE DEFERRAL OF TAXES 848.036 SLIDING SCALE DEFERRAL FOR PROPERTY HELD FOR LONGER PERIODS IN QUALIFYING USE. (a) Any pJoper~y otherwise qualifying for use value taxation under Art/cie 4, Chapter 32, Title 58.t of the Code of Virginia, as an~ended, and this section, may qualify for additional deferral of taxes upon a recorded corrm~itment to keep the property in its quali~Sng use for a rer~n of years. The portion of additional taxes defen-ed shall be in accordance with the following scale: (1) In the event of a commitment ro hold the property in its qualifying use for more than ten years, but not exceeding twenV years, ninety-nine percent of the use value taxes othenv/se assessed may be deferred for the term of the connrzitment. (2) In the event of a commitment ~o hold property in its qualifying use for more than five years, but not exceeding ten years, fifty percent of the use value taxes otherwise assessed may be deferred for the ~erm of the cormnitment. (b) To qualify for the additional deferral, the property owner must execute a '~n-itten agreement which sets forth the property subject to the restriction, the nature of the restriction and the period of time that the prope~- shall remain restricted to its qualifying use. The written agreement shall be in a form approved by the County Attorney, executed by the Co~o_nty and recorded in the land records. The County Administrator, or his or her designee, is delegated all necessary authority to prepm~e mad execute agreements on behalf of the County. (c) For any properts~' entering into a written agreement mad receiving deferral under the remus of this section, any roll back taxes shall be calculated in accordance with Section 58.t- _~_~7(C) of the Code of Virginia, as amended. Ali other provisions of Article 4, Cb_aprer ~2, Title 58.1, of the Code of Virginia, as amended, and this chapter, not inconsistent xMth this section, shall apply. (d) This section is in addition to the use value tax deferral pro,am established under the other provisions of tl~is chapter. Subiect to the calculation o~ roll back taxes pursuamr to Section 58.1-3237(b) of the Code of Virginia, as amended, landowners may participate in the use value tax deferral program subject to the other provisions of tlxis chapter without the requirement of entering in~o a written agreement. (e) The provisions of ttxis section shall be imvlemented beginning with the tax year 200I for property owners applying on or before November 1, 2000. (Ord. 99-19. Passed 12-15-99.) Any property otherwise qualifying for USe Value taxation under The Code of Virginia and Loudoun County Ordinances may qualify for additional deferral of taxes upon a recorded commitment to keep the property in its qualifying use for a number of years. The portion of additional taxes deferred must be in accordance with the following scale: (1) A commitment to hold the property in its qualifying use for more than ten (10) but not exceeding twenty (20) years, ninety-nine percent (99%) of the use value tax otherwise assessed may be deferred for the term of the commitment. (2) A commitment to hold the property in its qualifying use for more than five (5) but not exceeding ten (10) years, fifty percent (50) of the use value tax otherwise assessed may be deferred for the term of the commitment. To qualif~ for the additional deferral the property owner must: a. Execute a written agreement, which sets forth the property subject to the restriction. b. The time period that the property shall remain restricted to its qualifying use. c. The written agreement shall be in a form approved by the County Attorney. d. Be executed by the County and recorded in the land records (County Clerk's Office). Roll Back Taxes: Normal roll back taxes extend for the preceding five years in which a property qualified for use value assessment. Under the Sliding Scale Deferral, roll back taxes will extend for the time the additional deferral is received by the property. Roll back taxes under this condition will include the additional deferred taxes as well as the normal deferred tax under regular use value assessment. If the property owner fulfills the commitment, roll back taxes will return to the normal five-year period. CALCULATION FOR USE VALUE ASSESSMENT: Assumptions: 10 acre parcel 1 acre non-qualifying land (House site, driveWay, etc.) Qualifying in the Open Space Category Fair Market Value: Land $125,000 Buildings $ 250,000 Total $ 375.000 Fair Market Value Taxes at Current Tax Rate: $4,050.00 Calculation of Use Value Assessment: 1 acre Non Qualifying Housesite: 9 Qualifying acres of Open Space: Use Value Land Assessment Fair Market Building Assessment Taxable Value in Use Value $ 60,000 $ 10,800($1,200peracre) $ 70,800 $250,000 $320,800 Taxes Under Use Value at Current Tax Rate: $3,464.64 Calculation of Use Value Assessment Sliding Scale Agreement 11 Years: 1 acre Non Qualifying Housesite 9 Qualifying Acres of Open Space Use Value Sliding Scale Land Assessment Fair Market Building Assessment Taxable Value in Use Value Sliding Scale $ 6O,OOO $ 110 (99% deferral) $ 60,110 $25O,OOO $310,110 Taxes Under Sliding Scale at Current Rate: $3,349.19 CALCULATION FOR USE VALUE ASSESSMENT: Assumptions: 100 acre parcel with no building 0 acres non-qualifying land (House site, driveway, etc.) Qualifying in the Open Space Category Fair Market Value: Land $1,000,000 Fair Market Value Taxes at Current Tax Rate: Calculation of Use Value Assessment: 100 Qualifying acres of Open Space: Taxable Value in Use Value $10,800 $120,000 $120,000 Taxes Under Use Value at Current Tax Rate: $1,296.00 Calculation of Use Value Assessment Sliding Scale A~reement 11 Years: 100 Qualifying Acres of Open Space Taxable Value in Use Value Sliding Scale $ 1,200 (99% deferral) $ 1,200 Taxes Under Sliding Scale at Current Rate: $ 12.96 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGEN DA TITLE: Worksession on Water Issues SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Discussion of water supply issues STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Foley, Hirschman, Bowler AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: × CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: INFORMATION: ATTACHMENTS: Yes Please bring your copy of the Water Supply Project Study for discussion at the Board meeting next week. Staff will be prepared to review various issues related to the study and answer questions the Board may have at that time. Attached is a copy of an e-mail provided by John Martin to Charlotte Humphds as referred to at the August Board of Supervisors Meeting. Staff's understanding is that the Board meeting will provide an opportunity to discuss issues related to the Water Supply Project Study, such as those contained in the information from Mr. Martin. 08-51-0t Al1:18 IN 01.167 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE DEPARTMENT OF ENGINEERING & PUBLIC WORKS MEMORANDUM TO: The Albemarle County Board of Supervisors FROM: Water Resources Staff, Deparhnent of Engineering & Public Works DATE: 31 August 2001 SUBJECT: Issues arising from the Water Supply Study Introduction This memo is intended to support the 5 September work session on water supply requested by the Board of Supervisors, It includes analysis of recurrent issues brought forward by citizens to RWSA, the County, and the City throughout the Water Supply Project. Some of these issues are also raised in an email from John C. Martin to Charlotte Humphris as referred to at the 1 August Board of Supervisors Meeting (attached). In addition, the memo discUsses Integrated Resource Planning (1RP). IRP is a toolkit for integrating water supply needs with other community values, such as environmental resources, economics, and land use planning. The memo outlines how the current process does and does not incorporate these principals. We anticipate that the Board and City Council will be faced with a balancing act in responding to the feedback received during the upcoming water supply discussions. On the one hand, the spotlight on water resources provides an opportunity to deal with some longstanding issues and act proactively to prepare for future challenges. On the other hand, we are close to, if not already in a situation where the water supply is vulnerable to severe drought. There will be a strong instinct to avoid deh'berations that can stow progress on the new water supply. These approaches, however, are not mutually exclusive. The water supply planning process should not be lengthened unnecessarily, nor is it the proper venue to resolve every outstanding water resource issue in the community. However, this process can and should be used to set an agenda, schedule, and commitments to address several issues beyond simply providing additional water supply capacity. Of course, these measures must be made in concert with the City, RWSA, and ACSA We feel that RWSA and VII have deftly addressed the task that was put to them of assembling a package of recommendations that will meet the community's water quantity needs and have a high probability of being permitted by federal and state agencies. Openness to a range of options has led to a creative set of recommendations that seem environmentally and fiscally sound. The Pa~e l recommended staged approach allows the community to achieve reliable water supply in the near term while allowing for flexibility in the long term Integrated Resource Planning: What is it and are we doing it? IRP is a comprehensive planning approach that brings water supply, environmental resource protection, water conservation, and other issues into one discussion. As water becomes a more contentious issue in years to come, IRP could be a major part of the solution. It is currently being promoted by the American Water Resources Association- the major professional associ~ion for those working with water supply (see attached AWWA excerpt). Without IRP, all of the players may be doing their individual jobs quite well but overall important issues fall through the cracks (see attached RWSA-CAC "Charlottesville and Albemarle Water and Wastewater Matrix"). Albemarle has put its water supply infrastructure in the hands of two public utilities- RWSA (along with the City) and ACSA. Through providing expertise, a rate structure for funding maintenance and improvements, and coordination with the City, these utilities do their jobs well. But their mandates are limited to the water supply and waste removal functions. Within these lim2*ts, these utilities are not mandated to practice IRP. Below are some of the resulting issues. Issues Resulting from Lack of IRP- 1. Difficult to link water supply management to development area planning The County has spent considerable time with planning for the Development Areas, as demonstrated with the DISC model. However, since the County is responsible for land use planning, and RWSA is responsible for the Water Supply Project, it is not always evident that the two are quite interrelated. This is not the say that water supply should be u~%xl to either encourage or limit development, but only that coordination is necessary. For instance, the Water Supply Project envisions a phased approach to increasing water supply capacity - certain improvements (e.g., a bladder to raise the level of the reservoir) will be constructed as they are needed based, in part, on increases in demand. Increases in demand have a lot to do with how and at what rate development takes place in the County's Development Areas. This is a prime example of two issues that can be tied together through an IRP process. The DISC effort envisions master plans for each Development Area. It seems appropriate for these master plans to take into account the phasing of-arater supply improvements, as these improvements will dictate when, where, and how much additional capacity will be provided. Alternately, the master plans will provide critical feedback on how to phase the water supply improvements. In this regard, we can create an intelligent Development Areas planning process that is synchronized with water supply infrastructure. Implicit in this is also a challenge to the community with regard to water conservation- infill and fulfillment of the DISC concepts will have a better chance of success if water conservation can delay the need for the most costly water system improvements. It would be optimal to have the largest customer base possible before implementing future structural improvements. 2. Difficult to develop integrated demand side policy Water supply and water demand are inexorably linked, but while work on the supply side is traditionally an engineering response to meeting demand, work on the demand side always Pace 2 involves fundamental aspects of community policy, law, and community behavior. In Albemarle, both the demand side and the supply side responsibilities fall with the ACSAi As an authority for the County, ACSA has helped the County develop a drought ordinance and initiated a water conservation program. However, ACSA is not responsible for setting community policy. As a result, ACSA's mandate may not be as broad as the some of the issues it confronts. For example, in an IRP setting, leaders might consider a community-wide policy of promoting landscaping with low watering requirements. Similarly, a linkage might be made between drought water restrictions (such as limitations on outdoor water use) and cutbacks on stream flow (in the Moormans or Rivanna River). Matching our approach to demand management to the complexity of the challenge may require applying a broad range of technical expertise and the mandate of elected governmem. Such an approach may be possible only through IRP. 3. Difficult to attend to environmental and cultural uses of water Of course, the best example of this issue is the flow in the Moorman's River below Sugar Hollow Dam. RWSA has a mandate to supply drinking water, but does not have an official mandate to address environmental uses of water. Other agencies have the responsibility of considering the health of the Moormans, but do not work directly with drinking water supply. Admirably, RWSA has established a voluntary release of water to provide some relief; but a truly comprehensive discussion of the problem has never occurred. IRP would not make everyone happy, but it would allow full discussion of the issue in relation to water supply needs, the County's Comprehensive Plan, and other local and state water resources issues. 4. Difficult to link surface water and groundwater issues Surface water and groundwater are linked both physically and politically. Yet because county staff have a limited role in surface water quantity matters and RWSA and ACSA have no assigned responsibilities in groundwater matters, there is little institutional link between surface and groundwater. 5. LinMng water quantity and quality This area is one in which our community has done fairly well without IRP. The unique scenario of having a Watershed Manager linked to both County government and RWSA helps to connect water quality management (the County staff function) to quantity (the utility function). However, with IRP we could do a better job of linking County residents in the water supply watershed and customers of the public water system. 6. Establishing a sense of responsibility for comprehensive water managrnent We hear from some citizens that it is frustrating trying to have water policy issues addressed in our community because they don't whether to go to the County, RWSA, or ACSA. Indeed, responsibility for water management is divided among the agencies based on the particular topic or area of authority. While coordination takes place on an ad hoc basis, there is no institutionalized way to coordinate the functions and responsibilities of the various agencies. IRP could provide a framework for addressing this. Options/Recommendations for..IRP- 1. Seek advice on how to establish IRP P~e3 The sense that IRP (by whatever name) might be valuable for our community has been a matter of discussion for some time but we've never come across a clear vision of how it should be implemented. Responsible agencies could form a committee to develop the options for IRP while proceeding with the Water Supply Project. Possible contributors to the discussion include the Thomas Jefferson Water Resource Advisory Committee (a technical support group sponsored jointly by the TJSWCD and the TJPDC) and the RWSA-CAC. 2. Create a regional policy guiding body Proceed with the Water Supply Project while committing to establishment of a new regional body to carry out IRP for the County, City, RWSA, and ACSA as an implementation tool. Such a body could be designed to have a diverse range of expertise and a clear integrated resource planning mission. Individual proposals would require implementation by the local governments and/or the utilities. 3. Expand RWSA mandate and resources The RWSA is an existing regional body with signdi' cant water related responsibilities. The County and City could revise RWSA's foundational documents to imbue it with responsib'flities for planning for environmental and cultural water uses, groundwater, and demand side issues. Many policies would require legal action by the local govenm~nts, but the water planning effort could be coordinated by RWSA. The utility probably would require additional funds, staff resources, and training to take on such responsilfilities. It might be necessary to expand the Board of Directors as well. (ACSA's mission could be broadened as well, or it could take policy guidance from the expanded RWSA.) This approach would be the fastest, but would still require that it proceed in parallel with or as an implementation strategy of the Water Supply Project. Stream Flow Stream Flow Issues 1. The Moorrnans River below Sugar Hollow Dam After years of discussion about flow in the Moormans, a 400,000 gallon/day voluntary release was approved last year by the RWSA Board of Directors, County Board of Supervisors, and Charlottesville City Council for an indefinite period. DGIF and County staffhave reported that the voluntary release has provided some benefit though how much is unknown. The County independently asked the Department of Game and Inland Fisheries whether it could provide information on the benefits of the chosen release amount and whether modifications might improve it. These discussions have been separate from the Water Supply Project. It should be noted that the resource goals, other than water supply, need to be identified and prioritized (e.g. fishery, recreational, aesthetic, property values, etc.). Without knowing what values to protect, it is difficult to seek resolution of this issue. 2. The South Fork Rivanna River below the SFRR dam The volume of the minimum release from the SFRR dam has traditionally been 8 million gallons per day (mgd). One of VHB's recommendations is to alter the release to be 8mgd or the estirnated flow into the reservoir during periods of drought. Once additional water supply is in place, the release would be restored to 8mgd. After much scrutiny, the amount of the release appears to be a matter of policy rather than law at this point. Until we have enough water to meet Paee 4 current demand during a significant drought (be that through demand management or increased supply), it seems there is little choice but to adopt this policy in the short run. Stream. Flow Options/Recommendations i. Near term adjustments for the Moormans IfDGIF identifies improvements that could be made to the voluntary release, the County could ask RWSA to consider the modifications in the context of water supply needs. 2. Long term planning for the Moormans and Rivanna We believe Moormans and Rivanna long term release goals and strategies should be determined through locally based Integrated Resource Planning in cooperation with state and federal agencies. 3. Released water quality as well as quantity We recommend addressing water quality as well as quantity in this process. Releasing a lower volume of better quality water may be preferable to releasing a greater volume of poor quality water. (It is possl'ble that if a bladder is added to the SFRR dam, adjustments for water quality improvement could be implemented at the same time.) The Problem of Sedimentation The Sediment Issu.e As Gene Potter of RWSA pointed out on I August, roughly half of the projected difference between water demand and safe yield is the result of sedimentation, The Water Supply Project regulators have suggested that sediment load reduction be included as a "supporting altemative"- a necessary and important strategy the benefits of which cannot be quantified. Sediment reduction is a longstanding effort that started with the 1979 South Rivanna Reservoir Watershed Management Plan. It has been carded out mainly through agricultural best management practices and Albemarle County regulation of new development. The regulators and some members of the community are asking for a commitment to take the sediment reduction effort further. At our request, the Thomas Jefferson Water Resources Advisory Committee is helping Albemarle County identify ways the sediment issue could be studied and addressed. Such a study would require a significant, long term, local commitment and outside gram funding. Implementation will have to be guided by research~ Presently we are not confident that we are addressing sediment sources in the most effective manner. In general, sediment reduction strategies will range from those of moderate cost with moderate to immeasurable returns to those of higher costs with higher returns. It is tmlikely that there are options of low cost and high return. Other interim strategies could be identified through an update of the 1979 South Rivanna Watershed Management Plan. In a few months we will have a report on the lessons of past watershed management efforts tentatively titled, The South Fork Rivanna Reservoir at 35. With the information from this report and the Water Supply Project, it seems the time has come to update the t979 plan (whether we do so in an IRP context or otherwise). Sediment Policy Options/Recommendations 1. A substantial commitment to researching the problem Pa~e 5 As part of the Water Supply Project, general policy objectives and specific financial and staff commitments could he established for research and implementation. Cost estimates would have to be developed. The order of magnitude is hundreds of thousands of dollars spread over five to ten years. In addition to possible environmental benefits, the return would he savings in reduced or delayed water supply replacement costs, prevention of misapplication of funds to ineffective sediment reduction strategies, or both. 2. Immediate emphasis on stream buffer enhancement Our only immediately available approach to sedimentation is the expansion of stream buffers. In addition to the possibility of modest sediment reduction at a relatively low cost, this option provides ancillary ecological benefits and builds upon to ongoing federal regional, state, and local efforts. Conclusion Of course, there are other important issues surrounding the Water Supply Project and the region's water policy. We have tried to highlight the recurrent issues based on Mr. Martin's email and other citizen input we have seen and heard. (Some detailed comments could best be addressed by RWSA and its consultants.) We have also tried to identify a policy solution, IRP, that would help the community address a wide range of issues. We hope this discussion will help the community proceed with both the Water Supply Project and development of institutional mechanisms for dealing with cross-disciplinary and interagency water resource issues now and in the future. Attachments Copy: Mark Graham, Director of Engineering and Public Works Pace 6 From: Tim SanJule Fax: +t(804)589-7576 To: Ali Carey F~(: (804)296-5800 Page 2 of 5 Wednesday, August 29, 2001 11:40 August 28, 2001 Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Albemarle County Office Building 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Re: Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority Dear Sirs and Madam, The Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority's (RWSA)proposal for a four-foot crest increase at the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir (SFRR) as the best alternative to provide additional water supply. However, before the Authority proceeds with the permitting process four the 4 foot crest increase, several important environmental issues related to county water resources must be addressed. Moonnans River. The highest priority should be given to restoring the natural flow to the Moormans River. The diversion of water from Sugar Hollow Dam (roughly 2 to 4 million gallons a day [MGD]) to Ragged Mountain Reservoir continues to compromise the ec ~logy of the Moormans. The 'Scenic River' status of the Moormans River is one of the County's important environmental assets and must be pro':ected by restoring the historic natural flow of the River. Water Conservation and Drought Manageme~ current water conservation efforts of the Counl additional measures must to be taken. Technologi~ more sophisticated early warning systems for drou help insure adequate water supplies during ch allowing 'run of the fiver' water releases from th necessary to maintain the health of our rivers. Give: 'safe yield' water deficit, improved conservation at measures should be set up as soon as possible. Dredging the SFRR. Eventually the SFRR will ret uire dredging to prevent creation of a serious safety hazard. Analysis of vari6us dredging options for the' SFRR needs to be given a higher priority. The future cost of dredging the reservoir should be treat6d as a cost of maintaining the reservoir and included in the' present water rate structure. m We appreciate the y and City; however, ~s now exist to establish ~s. Such systems will ,ught conditions while Authority's reservoirs a the Authority's present .d drought management Minimum Water Release from the SFRR. Rather than the historic standard of a constant 8 MGD release from the SFRR, we suggest that a ~variable flow release' be established by the Department of Game and Inland Fisheries. This variable release should be equal to the actual inflow into the From: Tim SanJuie Fax: +1(804)589-7576 To: ,~Ji Carey Fax: (804)296-5800 Page 3 of 5 Wednesday, ~gu~ 29, 2001 11:40 AM SFRR plus any diversions from the Sugar Hollow dam to the Ragged Mountain Reservoir. Future Water Supplies. During the 1999 summer drought, water levels in the Rivanna River were dangerously low. Droughts of similar size have occurred in each decade since the 1930s. (See Attachment A) Several factors are presently increasing water withdrawals from the Rivanna River watershed. These factors include increases in population and commerce inside the RWSA and Aquasource service areas, greater ground water uses in both counties outside the service areas, and increases in impervious surfaces such as new construction and paved parking lots. The cumulative effect of increased uses of both surface and ground water throughout the Rivanna watershed are significant and need to be carefully monitored. There are already some indications that ground water levels in some areas of the County are declining. The negative effect of excessive ground water withdrawals on surface water availabilities is well established. We support the Count3~s decision to drill observation wells for monitoring ground water levels. While the RWSA is formed to produce and wholesale water, no county agency is presently designated to monitor important environmental issues. We suggest that the Board consider creation of a new agency focused on these environmental watershed issues. Sincerely, Jackie Brown President From: Tim SanJule Fax: +1 [804)589-7576 To: Ali Carey Fax: (804)296-5800 Pr~ge 4 of 5 Wednesday, .~Jgust 29, 2001 11:40 AM Attachment A: Rivanna River Drought Periods The following table shows the lowest instream flo~vs for the Rivanna River for each of the last six decades. Instream flows are measured in cubic feet per second (cfs) [MGD = cfs x 0.645]. Droughts are not necessarily short in length: the average length for those listed was 2 months and twenty days. Besides the drought periods listed, there was at least one additional drought period (cfs less than 100) in each of the six decades. 1 This low instream flow information indicates the importance of maintaining water flows from upstream sources such as the SFRR. Low instream flows can damage the river's natural habitats and ecosystems. Studies from other Virginia rivers show a clear relationship between instream flows and a deterioration of water quality and river ecology. The variable weather patterns predicted to accompany global warming could increase the number of droughts. Instream Flows for the Rivanna River at Palmyra Virginia Monthly Mean Streamflow Measured in Cubic Feet/Second Date Monthly Mean Average Low Month During Normal drought period MonthlyFlow* September-November, 1941 July-September, 1954 July-August, 1966 July-October, 1977 August, 1987 June-August, 1999 65.7 46.4 539 49.8 30.5 442 29.6 20.2 426 51.7 37.0 472 49.9 49.9 460 70.5 56.2 481 *65 Year Average monthly streamflow for each drought period. Date: July 31, 2001 To: Albemarle County Board of Supervisors From: Friends of the Moormans River Memo: RWSA Recommended Alternatives Report At your August l~t morning meeting, Gene Potter, Assistant Executive Director RWSA, will provide the RWSA perspective on the latest Water Supply Consultants Report, titled Recommended Alternatives. These alternatives represent the final phase of the Water Supply Planning Project, started more than five years ago. Over the course of this project, interested individuals and citizen groups (such as Friends of the Moormans River, the League of Women Voters, the ad hoc Water Conservation Committee, the Rivanna Roundtable, and the Rivanna Conservation Society) have expressed a number of concerns that unfortunately have not been incorporated into the recommendations to be presented to you. The following concerns specifically require your attention: I. Comprehensive Planning for preservation of all water resources is the County's responsibility. Albemarle County should develop a modem drought management/water conservation plan that is proactive for prevention of deficiencies and not simply reactive to :the appearance of a water supply deficit, as is presently the policy. A modern drought management/water conservation plan would help maintain surface water supplies, protect the ecological health of streams and forests and preserve ground water supplies. The development of an integrated resource management plan, such as this, is beyond the scope and charge of the RWSA. 2. Dredging the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir requires special attention by Albemarle County. This reservoir has both recreational and water supply values; and, if allowed to silt-in, will pose a future threat. Total loss of SFRR capacity to siltation is a keystone of the argument behind the Recommended Alternatives report. Albemarle County cannot allow the reservoir to silt-in for at least two reasons. First, the integrity of the dam will ultimately be compromised, and the dam will have to be breached. The EPA will require that the silt load be removed anyway, to prevent contamination of the Rivanna River downstream. Second, upstream flooding and siltation onto private properties will require mitigation by the County. Both of these consequences will be very expensive; thus, modem reservoir recovery dredging (not old-fashioned bulk marine dredging) can be viewed as an inexpensive prophylactic measure. 3.: Albemarle County should insist that proper water release into, the Moormans River be formally incorporated into the Water Supply Planning Process. Albemarle County is the legally-appointedAdministrator of the State Scenic Moormans River and is responsible for safeguarding the ecological health of the river. By VA Code, the Virginia Department of Game and Inland Fisheries is the proper agency (not RWSA) to determine what release amount would bring about the highest benefit to stream habitat. VGIF has already stated that the current release "experiment" is inadequate and is prepared to provide guidance. Albemarle County should consult VGIF and require that their recommended release rates be incorporated into the Water Supply Planning Project. This can be accomplished at no additional cost to the public. Subj: Date: From: To: BCC: File: Water Supply Project-RWSA Presentation 7/31/2001 6:13:43 PM Eastern Daylight Time JCMartinl chumphd@albemarle, org moormansr@cstone.net MIF ._Rivanna_W. doc (23280 bytes) DL Time (44000 bps): < 1 minute Dear Mrs. Humphris: Since speaking with you be telephone late last week, I have tried several times to sit down and draft some "bullets," per your suggestion, to identify questions and issues that the Board might wish to address in its review and consideration of RWSA's recommended water supply alternative. This has proven to be very difficult for me, since this entire matter is so technically and politically complicated, and with brief"bullets" I don't want to trivialize the importance and complexity of these issues. I've finally decided to just be informal, and do the best I can. Set forth below are some, but certainly not all, ofthe questions and issues I think the Board may wish to consider. Page I of 4 -The Moormans_Ki.v~. The RWSA recommended alternatives make no provision for minimum ir~trear~flOw in the Moormans River. The experimental release of 400,000 gallons per day approved last year was not intended to be a long term solution for the Moormans. Envirohmental scientists need to determine what MIF in the Moormans should be under modem standards, and then the water supply alternatives need to be examined to determine how to accommodate this additional demand factor. Unless and until the RWSA and local government recognizes that the environmental "demand" for water is a legitimate demand factor, to be weighed and considered along with human consumptive demand, the chances of satisfactory local solution to this problem, in the short term, are bleak. -T~ In the summer of 1999, the RWSA unilaterally decided to reduce flow into the Rivanna River from the Rivanna Dam to a level below the historic release of 8 MGD. The RWSA decided at.that time that notwithstanding the historic practice, a release of this magnitude was not required by law or regulation. Without notice to the public and our local governing bodies, therefore, the RWSA decided to simply make new local policy for the Rivanna River on its own. For purposes of the present water supply project, the RWSA suggests that henceforth, MIF into the Rivanna River should be 8 MGD or "natural inflow" whichever is less. This alternative is seriously flawed, however, because there is no "natural inflow!' into the Rivanna Reservoir, since up to 4 MGD is withdrawn daily from the Moormans River at the Sugar Hollow Dam, RWSA's consultants simply ignore this factor in their analysis. MIF for the Rivanna River should be determined with the assistance of environmental scientists. Attached to this e-mail message is a copy ofmy letter to Rich Collins, dated May 29, 2001, by which I relayed the results of some inquiries I made concerning the history of the 8 MGD Rivanna River release commitment. --MIF for the Moormans and Rivanna. It has been suggested by the RWSA and its consultants, that 1~ determinations for the Moormans and the Rivanna may be made during the course of the permit approval process for our new water supply. The concept seems to be that MIF will be something for "negotiation" with the "regulators." In other words, the Moormans and the Rivanna may be "bargaining chips" in the negotiations to obtain approval of other water supply alternatives. Many of us believe, however, that the better more ethical approach would be to determine MIF locally, and include it as a legitimate demand factor in the overall design ofour new water supply. Additionally, Bill Ellis stated at a RWSA work session on June 4, 2001, that it was his view that placing a "bladder" Wednesday, August 01, 2001 America Online: JCMartinl Page 2 of 4 on the Rivanna Dam may not need regulatory approval by the Corps of Engineers. It also appears, that should the RWSA abandon its small hydroelectric generator, FERC approval would not be required. It is poss~le, therefore, that if permitting approval is determined not to be necessary, there will be no future "negotiations" for MIF in the Moormans and the Rivanna. For this adcht' ional reason, I think it would be better to address the matter of MIF locally, and in conjunction with local approval of our final water supply alternatives. --Dredging. By everyone's estimation, dredging the Rivanna Reservoir would be costly, although I am riot p~/sonally satisfied as a citizen that VHB and RWSA have thoroughly explored all available dredging technology to make truly informed decisions regarding cost. Whatever that cost might be, however, attention should perhaps be given now as to what the financial implications might be if a decision is made not to dredge. In other words, if the Reservoir is not dredged now, it will continue to receive sediment for the next 20 to 30 years, and it will fill up to the point that'the additional capacity obtained by the "bladder" will be lost. What financial burden will we then be passing along to the next generation? What ever the cost now, it may be less expensive over the long run to dredge now, rather than to wait 30 or 40 years. Consideration perhaps should also be given to the ethical question of whether the community wants to pass a huge financial burden and'a huge environmental problem on to the next generation. This is an extremely difficult question. --,__C~hfis~ Green Lake. "Chris Green Lake" is a reservoir constructed many years ago for water supply purposes. It has never been used as a reservoir, however, and instead has been used as a valuable recreational resource. Although RWSA is presently not considering its short term use for water supply, it represents a rather significant increase in safe yield if it could be connected now to a water treatment plant. This would not mean that water from Chris Green Lake would have to be used immediately, and the "lake/reservoir" could continue to be used for recreation~ If a severe drought is experienced in the next 5 to 10 years, however, it could provide valuable additional capacity for the entire system This option would be worth of additional consideration. -~B_e_av. er Creek Reservoir. Beaver Creek Reservoir has a safe yield of 2 MGD, and its water treatment plant is currently producing only about .4 MGD for Crozet consumption following the departure of Con Agra. Keeping in mind that "safe yield" means what the reservoir could produce during a severe t930's type of drought, this reservoir represents substantial additional capacity. Raw water could be transferred by pipe to the Ragged Mountain reservoirs thus relieving reliance of the Ragged Mountain Reservoirs on the Sugar Hollow Reservoir and the Moormans River. Alternatively, the Beaver Creek treatment plant could be connected with the urban service area system thus providing additional capacity. Crozet, of course is a designated development area, and eventually, it might be needed to serve solely the Croz~t community. At present, however, the Beaver Creek reservoir has sufficient excess safe yield capacity to serve 6000 additional homes in Crozet, and it would seem highly unlikely that Crozet will grow to this level any time in the foreseeable future. The Beaver Creek Reservoir has never been studied in any of the water supply Planning to date, and the BOard and the RWSA may wish to give this some more thought. --Money~. To my knowledge, the matter of who is going to pay for the new water supply has,never ~ussed publicly. It has been my continuing impression, however, that the underlying 'iron clad" assumption is that it must all be funded by the RWSA, and that not one penny will come from general tax revenues of the City and the County. I would suggest, however, that this is a matter that should receive additional consideration, and that failure to do so might be "penny wise and pound foolistz" By this I mean, that if it is assumed that RWSA must shoulder the entire financial burden, its projections of its future revenues for the next 20 to 30 years might, understandably, effect what water supply alternatives are implemented for our future. Personally, I think it would be better to focus first Wednesday, August 01, 2001 America Online: JCMartinl Page 3 of 4 on what additional elements of our water supply are needed to meet future needs, and focus secondly on financing, to make sure that the best decisions are made. If some contn~bution is needed from general revenues to insure an adequate and safe water supply for the next generation, so be it. Things never seem to get cheaper, and difficult investments now might actually save millions long term. Additionally, and importantly, it has been my feeling, and the feeling of scores of other County residents that the environment represents a legitimate demand for water that must be accommodated, and this obviotisly will involve some degree of cost. City and County water customers should not be' required to bear all of these environmental costs. Residents, such as myself with wells, should share, somehow, in these additional costs. One way to do this would be to draw some funding from general revenues. Again, however, political limitations on funding, and a history of disputes between the City and the County over money should not dictate the adequacy of our future water supply. Lets do what's right, not what's cheapest. --Ragged Mountain/Sugar Hollow Mode .rni?atio, n: At the RWSA Board of Directors meeting yesterday, th~ safe~y ~fthe ~g~-d Mountain dams was discussed. The RWSA must issue a request for proposals to study the dams in order to insure continued certification by State Dam safety staff, and it seems clear that dam safety improvements are going to be necessary unless a decision is made to abandon the Ragged Mountain Reservoirs. This event serves to highlight the antiquity of the Ragged Mountain/Sugar Hollow element of the overall water system which dates back to the 1880's. I have commented previously before the Board concerning the "weir box" located at the Ragged Mountain reservoirs which results in the waste of Moormans River water. How frequently, is unknown, because there are no gages or controls, and the "weir box" is so remote in cannot be routinely monitored. A study and over haul of the entire Ragged Mountain/Sugar Hollow element of the system is long overdue, and it should be done now, in conjunction with the water supply project. --~Drought Management and Water ~Co~e~atio_m Presently, I can only describe the drought ~meht and water conservation water supply alternatives presently recommended as "window dressing." These plans do not exist, and it is unclear as to who will drm°c then~ It is clear, however, that the City Department of Public Works and the Albemarle County Service Authority must not be placed in sole charge of these tasks. These entities serve only water customers, and in a real and direct sense, the more effective drought management and water conservation programs might be, the lower will be the revenues of these service providers. I mean no insult or disrespect to these agencies, but the task force that will be needed to draft these plans must have a broad community base. --Risk Assessment of Four Foot Crest Controls. Should a bladder installed on the top of the Rivanna River Dam fail catastrophically, there could be extensive property damage and eveff loss of life down stream from the darn. I am not aware of any studies reflecting the degree of risk of catastrophic failure or its consequences. The bladder is a relatively new technology, and as far as I am concerned, the City and the County have a duty to insure that appropriate risk analyses are conducted. _(-3~oncln.qion. I apologize for the informality and the length of this e-mail message, but I hope that it will provide some service. At the very least, I would like to convince you that there is much work that needs to be done with respect to this water supply project, and there are a lot of things to be thinking about, many more than the few matters outlined in this message. Also, the 45 minutes allocated for the RWSA presentation is clearly inadequate, and as a lowly citizen, I would suggest that several, perhaps of series, of work sessions will be needed. I also hope that the imagination and talents of Rich Collins will be fully utilized. As a final plea, please also keep in mind that for several years there has been a vocal, noisy, but very well intentioned cadre of community residents and organizations deeply Wednesday, August 01,2001 America Online: JCMartinl Page 4 of 4 concerned about this community. made!!!! Invite us in from the cold and just watch the progress that can be John C. Martin 5115 Catterton Road Free Union, Virginia 22940 Phone: (804) 978-2872 FAX: (804) 978-4107 E-Mail: JCMartinl ~aol. com Wednesday, August 01, 2001 America Online: JCMartinl JOHN COLLIER MARTIN 5115 CATTERTON ROAD FREE UNION, VIRGINIA 22940 (804) 978-2872 FAX: (804) 978-4107 May 29, 2001 Mr. Richard C. Collins Chairman, Rivarma Water & Sewer Authority 108 Wilson Court Charlottesville, Virginia 22901 Re: Historical Background of Rivanna River Minimum Instream Flow Commitmems Dear Rich: This is to relay to you the results of some inquiries I have made concerning this Community's historical commitment to a minimum discharge of 8 million gallons per day (MGD) from the South Fork Rivanna River Dam into the Rivanna River. As I have previously mentioned to you, I began this task earlier this year, to follow up upon inquiries initiated last year by Ms. Treva Cromwell. Ms. Cromwell's inquiries stemmed from a somewhat surprising announcement by Vanasse Hangen Bmstlin, Inc. (VHB) in its February 2000 "Water Supply Project Analysis of Alternatives, "that there was no regulatory requirement for a minimum discharge of 8 MGD into the Rivanna River, contrary, to then generally accepted belief. Upon this determination, made in 1999, but not publically announced, the Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority (RWSA) reduced discharges into the Rivanna River below 8 MGDduring an extremely dry period during the Summer of that year. Based upon my inquiries, I have concluded, that while VHB may be technically correct in its finding of no explicit State or Federal regtilatory requirements for an 8 MGD minimum discharge, it cannot be denied that this level of discharge has been part of Community practice and policy for decades. For this reason, and as result of express representations the Community has made to State and Federal regulatory agencies over the years, I feel that the Community should have considered itself bound by its South Fork Rivanna River Dam discharge practices and policies, and that a better course in 1999 would have been not to change these historic practices and policies arbitrarily, especially without public notice and an opportunity for public comment. Nevertheless, the issue now is with respect to the level of protection this Community is going to afford to the Rivanna River for the future. I am offering these thoughts, as a citizen, to assist in the development of policies and plans, in conjunction with the on-going Water Supply Project, to help insure future protection for both the Rivanna River, and the Moormans River, a State designated Scenic River, and a significant tributary of the Rivanna River. I believe that an understanding of this Community's past commitments is vitally important to this process. Background. For a period of 35 years, that is, from the time the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir Dam was constructed in 1965, it seems to have been accepted that a minimum of 8 MGD would be released from the Rivanna Dam into the Rivanna River. VHB recognized this commitment in its 1997 "Supply Analysis" by stating: In determining available withdrawals for the South Fork Rivanna WTP, this value has been adjusted to incorporate the minimum flowby currently used for purposes of maintaining water quality on Moore's Creek (downstream of the Moore's Creek WasteWater Treatment Plant). This flowby is not mandated by a Minimum Instream Flow requirement. Discussions with Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (VDEQ) personnel indicate that the 8.00 mgd currently used is based on an old modelling [sic] effort (from the 1970's) and suggest that additional modelling [sic] could be performed as part of a study to establish a more accurate estimate. Until such a study is complete, 8 mgd has been used as the best existing estimate of the minimum flowby required to maintain water quality. Therefore, the current safe yield for the Rivanna Reservoir is 8 mgd less (7.2 mgd) than the unadjusted 15.2 mgd estimate based on the 1930 drought. (Supply Analysis, at p. 12). The view expressed by VHB in the Supply Analysis seems to be confirmed in the text of a letter from the RWSA to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, dated June 3, 1982, at the time the RWSA was applying for a Federal Power Act exemption for the construction of a small hydroelectric generator at the dam. On behaffofthe RWSA, Mr. William Sessoms wrote: The South Rivanna Dam was completed in 1965, at which time the 12 CFS discharge limit was suggested by the Virginia State Water Control board as an operating parameter. It has never been necessary to enforce this release. "Run-of-the-river" means that the reservoir will never be drawn down to produce power. Therefore, I concur with Mr. Kinsor's definition, except that there is a time lag between inflow and outflow peaks and valleys,y (Attachment 1). g It is noted that "12 cubic feet per second (cfs)" equates to 7.755 MGD, or when rounded up, to 8 MGD. An exchange of correspondence between the RWSA and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) also at the time of RWSA's application to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) for a Federal Power Act exemption for its hydroelectric project further confirms the generalized understanding that operation of the Rivanna dam was subject to an 8 MGD release. In a letter fi:om the EPA to the RWSA, dated March 29, 1982, the EPA expressed concerns about the amount of flow that it understood (incorrectly) would be released from the dam. (Attachment 2). By letter dated May 12, 1982, the RWSA responded to the EPA letter to correct EPA's misunderstanding that apparently was caused by the fact that an incomplete copy.of RWSA's application for a Federal Power Act exemption had been forwarded to EPA. In order to "clear up" some of the concerns and questions raised by the EPA, Mr. Sessoms explained, categorically: Second, regarding minimum discharges, the present water supply system operates under a discharge minimum of 12 CFS, which will be maintained after installation of the powerhouse. The hydro project will be operated run-of-the-river with no change in the quantity of water passed downstream fi:om present practices. (Attachment 3). Accordingly, the RWSA made an explic, it representation to the EPA in 1982, that a 12 CFS (8 MGD) minimum discharge policy or practice existed in the past, and that it would continue on into the future should the FERC exemption for the hydroelectric project be granted. It seems reasonable to conclude that the EPA relied upon the RWSA representation. It should be further noted, that in its letter dated March 29, 1982, the EPA advised: To determine the appropriate flow requirement for this project, you should consuk with the State agency responsible for issuing water quality certifications under Section 401 o f the Clean Water Act, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. A site specific instream study may be determined to be necessary. (Attachment 2). Either upon its own initiative, or at the suggestion of the EPA, the RWSA did contact the Virginia State Water Control Board, the State Agency responsible for water quality certifications under Section 401 of the Clean Water Act. In reply to the RWSA, Mr. John P. Godfi:ey, on behalf of the Virginia State Water Control Board, advised: A Water Quality Certification pursuant to Section 401 of the Clean Water Act will be required for this activity. The following issues are critical to water quality and should be addressed in applying for the Section 401 Certification: 2. Confirmation that the minimum instantaneous release will be 12 cfs under all conditions. 6. Adequately detailed drawings should be provided when you apply for the 401 Certification. Plan and cross-sectional views which describe the proposed activities should be included. (Attachment 4). It appears, however, that the RWSA never applied for a Section 401 certification, and no such certification was ever issued. RWSA's written commitment, therefore, that "...the present water supply system operates under a discharge minimum of 12 CFS, which will be maintained after installation of the powerhouse..." never became a formal regulatory requirement. I could not determine fi:om my review of RWSA records and fi:om my conversations with former Executive Director Arthur Petrini and VDEQ official Joseph Hassell as to why the RWSA did not apply for the Section 401 certification, and as to why the various regulatory agencies involved seem not to have followed up with respect to this matter. Due perhaps to the fact that historically there was abundant flow into the Rivanna River which routinely exceeded 8 MGD, there may have been no event prior to 1999, that raised minimum discharges into the Rivanna River as an issue. In the summer of 1999, however, the RWSA reduced flows fro m the Rivanna Reservok dam into the Rivanna River to a level below 8 MGD. This was revealed to the Community, apparently for the first time, in the VHB February 2000 "Water Supply Project, Analysis of Alternatives." This was done in a discussion of what VHB deemed a water supply alternative which involved a recalculation of the safe yield of the Rivanna Reservoir upon a revised release regimen based upon 8 MGD, or the rate of"natural inflow" into the reservoir, which ever is less. In its discussion, VHB first acknowledged RWSA's historical commitment to provide a minimum discharge from the Rivanna Reservoir dam of 8 MGD, but then takes the position that the RWSA is not required to provide this magnitude of release. 4 Historically, the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir has released a minimum of 8 mgd to the Rivanna River downstream, even when natural stream flows into the reservoir are substantially less. There appears, however, to be no regulatory requirement for a release of this magnitude. The 8 mgd release actually augments natural flows in the South Fork Rivanna River during severe drought conditions, and this augmentation of natural stream flows sharply curtails the safe yield of the South Fork Rivanna River Reservoir. During droughts, outflows from the reservoir substantially exceed natural inflows at the very time water is most needed for water supply purposes. (February 2000, "Water Supply Analysis of Alternatives," at p. 25). VHB then proceeds to explain: For purposes of determining the safe yield of the South Fork Rivanna River Reservoir at the beginning of this study, it was assumed that the past practice of releasing a minimum of 8 mgd during droughts would continue. However, during the course of this evaluation two events occurred that together suggest that this "alternative" might better be viewed as existing practice and that the current safe yield of the South Fork Rivanna River Reservoir should be regarded as including the additional yield attributable to this alternative. First, the RWSA determined that there is no regulatory requirement that 8 mgd be released during droughts from the South Fork Rivanna Reservoir, as had previously been assumed. Second, as a consequence of that determination, during a severe drought in summer 1999, the release from Sourth Fork Rivanna Reservoir was reduced below 8 mgd beginning approximately July 4, 1999, and lasting until August 30, 1999. Due to the lack of gages, the actual releases from and inflows into the reservoir during that period are not known. (Id.). In its most recent draf~ of suggested water supply alternatives, V~ further states: When this study was begun, the study team was informed and understood that SFRR was required as a regulatory matter to release at least 8 mgd at all times. The safe yield of the reservoir was accordingly calculated on that basis. Subsequent investigation has failed to idemify any such regulatory requirement, however. Accordingly, the current yield of the reservoir is actually greater than that assumed in the supply study. If the reservoir is assumed to release at a rate of 8 mgd or at the rate of natural inflow, 5 whichever is less, then the yield of the reservoir would increase by 1.6 mgd. (May 2001, "Summary of Recommended Alternatives," at p.3). Upon this record, therefore, with no attention having been given to a long term solution for minimum instream flow in the Moormans River below the Sugar Hollow dam, historic minimum flow into the Rivanna River below the South Fork Rivanna River Dam now also is threatened. This threat, which began with no notice to the Community and its governing bodies in the summer of 1999, continues. Discussion. First, I wish to temper the remarks which follow by the statement that I believe that the RWSA is entering a new era of greater environmental sensitivity and public responsiveness as an instrumentality of government. Institutionally, however, k seems to this writer, that the RWSA continues to be dominated by "corporate water supply strategists," rather than "Community water supply planners," and that water is viewed primarily as a commodity to be used and exploited, without regard for legitimate environmental needs. I believe also, that in pursuit of its institutional purpose to provide potable water to serve the needs of Community residents, the RWSA, institutionally, fails fundamentally to recognize that the vast majority of these "water consumers" do not want to witness the rape of our watershed, a process that certainly will occur without greater sensitivity and planning. Upon information and belief, the action taken by the RWSA in the summer of 1999, upon the advice of its consultants, to abandon a 35 year commitment to the Rivanna River, was unilateral, and wkhout adequate public notice and involvement by the governing bodies of this Community. To say that the 1999 summer dry spell was short lived, and that no substantial harm may have been done to the Rivanna River, to its ecosystems and to other Communities downstream, is not an adequate response to public concern. In my view, the RWSA action was tantamount to a breech of trust. This was an exceptionally bitter pill for many to swallow in light of all the work done by citizens to seek protection for the Moormans River, thinking that the Rivanna River was safe from the onslaught of water deprivation which has effected the Moormans for far too many years. Moreover, the justification for the RWSA action to change the historic release regimen for the Rivanna River is seriously flawed. It is presently argued, that a change in the historic release regimen is warranted because RWSA's belief, that a minimum 8 MGD discharge was required by regulation, was a mistake of fact, and that no such requirement had ever been imposed upon the operation of the Rivanna dam. RWSA's "mistake," however, was in not filing an application for a Section 401 certification in the I980's as it had been instructed to do by the State Water Control Board. Had this "mistake" not been made then, the RWSA would be under a regulatory obligation to meet an 8 MGD release requirement. By claiming "mistake" now, the RWSA 6 unfairly seeks to capitalize upon the mistake it made two decades ago. Rather than to claim that it has never been under a regulatory obligation regarding a release from the Rivanna Dam, it would be fairer to admit, that but for its mistake in the 1980's, such a requirement would be in place, and that for this reason, it should honor the 8 MGD release requirement as if it was explicitly required by regulation. The "alternate release scenario" water supply alternative is also seriously flawed in concept. It is proposed that a new release scenario, which would increase the safe yield ofthe reservoir, would be 8 MGD, or "natural inflow," whichever is less. It is suggested that a set 8 MGD release is unreasonable, because in times of severe drought, such a release would actually augment natural flows during such periods. (See, February 2000, "Water Supply Project, Analysis of Alternatives at p. 25). The more reasonable approach, or so it is argued, would be to place the bottom limit for discharges at the amount of natural inflow to mimic what nature would provide for downstream flow if the dam did not exist. The problem with this concept is that there is no "natural inflow" into the Rivanna Reservoir. Since the 1920's, long before the Rivanna dam was constructed, up to 4 MGD has been withdrawn from the Moormans River at Sugar Hollow and transported to the City by pipeline. The amount of actual inflow in the Rivanna Reservoir is not dictated, therefore, by nature. The inflow available to the Reservoir, and ultimately to the Rivanna River, is a direct function of the amount of water withdrawn from the head waters of the Moormans River. Accordingly, the alternate release scenario as outlined by VHB, would actually result in artificially lower discharges into the Rivanna River than would otherwise be produced by nature. In order to replicate what inflow would be provided by nature, one would need to add the amount of water withdrawn from the Moormans River to actual inflow into the Rivanna Reservoir. It is also of deep and abiding concern to many members of this community that this debate over the RWSA "alternate release scenario," as outlined in the VHB reports, is even taking place in a discussion confined to the Rivanna River. The Moormans River and the Rivanna River are part of one river system, with two dams and two reservoirs. That which is needed, quite desperately, is a comprehensive revised release scenario that accommodates the needs of both rivers in a sensible way. Instead of quibbling over now ancient regulatory history, a study should be commenced to determine appropriate levels of minimum instream flows for both rivers, to. accommodate both water volume and water quality for downstream benefit. Although there may be the intention to "negotiate" minimum instream flow levels for both rivers with Federal and State regulators during the permitting process for a new water supply, the better course I believe, would be to conduct our own study with the considerable resources available in this community. The residents of this Community have a right, in my view, to participate in planning for the future health of these two important rivers. This should be done with full participation and the direct involvement by our local governing bodies. This should not be something that is left for negotiation behind closed doors, notwithstanding the faith developed by many of us in our Federal and State regulatory agencies. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. ~K] John C. Martin CC: Mr. Andy Wilson Rivanna Conservation Society RIVANNA WATER 84 SEWER AUTHORITY P. O. BOX 18 CHARLOTTESVILLE. VIRGINIA 22902 (804~, 977-2970 June 1982 Rob Kelsey U.S.D.I., Fish and W£1dli£e Service Di¥ision o£ Ecological Services 1825B Virginia Street Annopolis, Maryland 21401 Dear Mr. Kelsey: I have received Mr. Kinsor's letter of Hay 14 1982 and can reply to the concerns rai~ed. ' The area at the base o£ the dam will not be dewatered, even when no £1ows are passing over the spillway. Also as a result of the sizing of the generators in relation to stream flow, ~,'ater is expected to pass over the spillwa), even at max~mu~n po~,'er generation 25% of the year. The other words, maximum diversion of flows will still allow water to go over the dam approximately 25'% of the year. 'Th~ South Rivanr, a I)am was completed in 1965, at ~,'hich ti~ne the 12 CFS discharge limit was suggested b), the Virginia State IVater Control Board as an operating parameter. It has never been neces- sary to enforce this release. "Run-of-the-river" mean:; that the reservoir will never be drmvn do~,'n to produce power. Therefore, I concur with Mr. K~nsor's definition, except that there is a time lag between inflow and out flo~v peaks and valleys. With regard to anadromous fish populations, I enclose a letter from the Virginia Fish and Game Commission. The estal;ti:;hment of runs in the Rivanna River is only infinitesimally probable. The issue was of course dealt with before the dam was bui''+ · .. In any event, this project would not affect the difficulty ef establishing an anadromous population. ' Low dissolved oxygen levels ~ indeed be a problem. No party consulted, however, can commit to an absolute opinion. It is a concensus, though, that reservoir quality will improve bec~-ffse of the new circulation patterns induced by a bottom dra~,', in an)' event, mechanical rdIaedics for the possible low D.O.: levels in the discharge are easily included if found to be necessary in the final design phase of the project, i believe that any low D.O. levels will be a temporary condition that will disappear as new circulation patterns ~n the reservoir stabilize. June 1982 Page 2 I expect'a further comment/report letter within 30 days, for it to be in'time to be useful in our license exemption application. Sincerely, ~VKS/rc Enclosure lVilliam Sessoms Administrative Supervisor UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY RE. GION III 6TH AND WALNUT STREETS PHILADELPHIA. PENNSYLVANIA 19106 MAR 29 1982 Mr. William Sessoms Administrative Supervisor Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority P.O. Box 18 Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Mr. Sessoms: We have reviewed your application for exemption of a small hydroelectric power project at the South Rivanna Reservoir on the South Fork of the Rivanna River, Albemarle County, Virginia. Your application refers to at least six figures and possibly more. The information that we received did not have any of these referenced drawings. We do not oppose the development of a hydropower project, however, we are unable to determine from the information provided if the project will affect the water quality and hydrologic regime of the South Fork of the Rivanna River. Therefore, we beleieve it is appropriate at this time to list the main areas of EPA's concern so that they may be addressed in the environ- mental report to be developed under the permit. A permit issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, under 404 may be required for the project, depending on whether placement of material in the river or adjacent wetlands is involved. We recommend that you use EPA's Guidelines issued under Section 404(b)(1) of the Clean Water Act to deter- mine the information needed to assess the project's impacts on wetlands, water quality, fisheries, wildlife, and other aquatic resources. The Guide- lines were published in the December 24, 1980 Federal Register, and copies are available by contacting this office. This project should be operated in a manner which provides for an instan- taneous minimum flow release sufficient to protect water quality downstream of the project. Because flows less than 7Q10 may not provide adequate assimilative capacity to prevent violations of water quality standards down- stream, the project should at no time, except as limited by inflow, release flows less than 7Q10. A _long-term flow of 7Qt0, however, will result in a significant detriment to the physical and biological quality of the stream, and therefore a higher flow should be provided. To determine the appropri- ate flow requirement for this project, you should consult with the State agency responsible for issuing water quality certifications under Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. A site specific instream study may be determined to be necessary. Adequate depth and velocity must be maintained in the channel downstream of the facility during extended low flow periods when the project is operating. Discharges, such as bearing cooling water, trash rack debris, sanitary wastes, oil or chemical wastes, or any other pollutants would require National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (N?DES) permits under Section 402 of the Clean Water Act. Any discharges should be identified. Should you have any questions, please contact Frank Thoumsin of my staff at 215-597-0961. Sincerely yours, ,:.,'/ -. ../,:,~_ /.,.~ ? .~:..~.1'..,~,..~ J0~hn R. Pomponio, Chief EIS & Wetlands Review Section RiVANNA WATER & SEWER AUTHORITY P. O. BOX 18 CHARLOTTESVILLE. VIRGINIA 21~902 {804) 977-2970 12 May 1982 Frank Thoumsin ElS & Wetlands Review Section EPA Region 1 i I 6th and Walnut Streets Philadelphia, Pa. 19106 Dear Mr. Thoumsin: My request for a comment letter on a small-scale hydropower project was recently reviewed by John R. Pomponio. Unfortunately, an incomplete copy of our draft application was enclosed. Therefore I enclose an updated version of the draft application for your review and co~nment. I believe that at this point I can clear up some of the concerns and questions raised by Mr. Pomponio. First, [ have contacted state and federal fish and wildlife agencies for their comments. At present, the only modifica- tion to the stream bank will be the retaining wall and modi- fied discharge structure below the powerhouse. Their responses are to be incorporated in the next draft of the environmental report. Second, regarding minimum discharges, the present water supply system operates under a discharge lnin~mmn of 12 CFS, which will be maintained after installation of the power- house. The hydro project will be operated run-of-the-river with no .change ~n the quantity of water passed downstream from present practices. I am expecting a comment letter from the State Water Control Board this week relating to this sub- ject. I look forward to receivinga further comment letter. WKS/rc Enclosure Sincerely, William Sessoms Administrative Supervisor R. V. Davis, P. E. Executive Director Post Office Box 11143 Richmond, Virginia 23230 {804} 257-0056 COMMONWEALTH o[ VIRGINIA STATE IFATER CONTROL BOARD £I 11 Hamilton Street July 6, 1982 Mr. William Sessoms Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority P. O. Box 18 Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Dear Mr. Sessoms: Your application for Federal Power Act Licensing Exemption his been reviewed by the staff. The project is very commendable in concept and can be per~ formed in a manner to minimize the impacts on water quality. A Water Quality Certification pursuant to Section 401 of the Clean Water Act will be required for this activity. The following issues are critical to water quality and should be addressed in applying for the Section 401 Certification: The impacts associated with discharging from the bottom level of the reservoir and methods of mitigating these effects should be itemized. The release from the reservoir must com- ply with the Water Quality Standards (emphasis on dissolved oxygen and temperature) and must minimize the impact on the river downstream of the dam. Confirmation that the-minimum instantaneous release will be 12 cfs under all conditions. 3. The proposed scheduling of construction activities. 4. Description of the proposed operational procedures, including a schedule of power generation. Erosion and sedimentation control measures proposed for the construction activities should be delineated. Also, any possible erosional effects at the toe of the tailrace or downstream in the river should be considered. An Affirmative Action/~_quaI~~E~plover July 6, 1982 -2- Mr. William Sessoms Adequately detailed drawings should be provided when you apply .for the 401 Certification. Plan and cross-sectional views which describe the proposed activities should be included. These item§ outline the major water quali~y considerations inherent in your project. I apologize for being so slow in responding. If you have any further. questions, please contact me at any time at (804/2S7-0581). Sincerely, J~n P. Godfrey I ~ Pollution Control Engineer Bureau of Surveillance & Field Studies :SCC cc: SWCB-Valley Regional Office, Attention: Dwight Sours COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Work session: CPA 98-03, Post Office Land Trust (Hollymead Town Center) SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Proposal to amend the Comprehensive Plan land use designation for approximately 180 acres of land west of route 29, south of Airport Road and east of the Deerwood Subdivision. This work session is to discuss the property owners' proposed Master Plan and design guidelines for the proposed Town Center. STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Foley, Cilimberg, Benish AGENDA DATE: September 5, 2001 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ITEM NUMBERS: INFORMATION: X ACTION: IN FORMATION: ATTACHMENTS: Yes REVIEWED B Y-~ ~ 'C~ BACKG ROU N D: During the Board's review of the Planning Commission's recommended Comprehensive Plan amendment language for the Hollymead Town Center, property owners within the proposed Town Center area expressed concern over some of the recommendations in the proposed amendment language. On February 7, 2001, the Board deferred action on the Comprehensive Plan Amendment in order to allow the property owners to develop their proposal for a master plan for the Town Center consisting of development and design guidelines. A Master Plan was submitted on July 20th to the Planning Department for review. Staff has reviewed the proposed Master Plan and compared it to the Planning Commission's recommended amendment language. A full copy of the Master Plan document is inciuded with this report. DISCUSSION: AttachmentA is the Planning Commission's recommended amendment language for the Town Center, which provides the recommendations, standards and guidelines for the development of this area. In bold and italic print are staff's summary comments regarding the. consistency of the Town Center Master Plan developed by the property owners to each section, as necessary. A summary of the major issues and differences are provided below: The initial areas of most concem to the property owners were 1 ) the proposed requirement of a floor area ratio (FAR) of .75, 2) the limit on compatible low FAR regional service uses of no more than 65,000 square feet on a single floor, and 3) a recommendation for a one hundred foot undisturbed vegetative buffer along the Town Center frontage of Route 29. The proposed Master Plan does not provide for a minimum desirable FAR for the Town Center and places no limit on the size single-story regional service uses in the Mixed Use/Regional Service designation. The Master Plan calls for a landscape frontage of Route 29 dependent in part on the ultimate design of ,the Route 29 improvements (rural or urban design). Staff provides the following comments. Regarding FAR, the intent of the Commission's recommendation for a high FAR ~s to encourage to greatest extent possible an urban type design that maximizes site utilization (and minimizing "on-site" sprawl). By doing so, it would be hoped that the County ultimately delays the need to further expand the Development Areas. Within the context of a 20-year Comprehensive Plan, densities of this range may be able to be reached as the economic conditions ("market" conditions) in the region change.. The Albemarle Square Town Center CPA proposal at the Sperry site is proposing a development with a .61 FAR. The Sperry site is a more central "in town" location and is a much smaller site (62 acres), and is more of an "infill site" within the context of a larger, more densely developed area. But it does indicate that higher densities (FAR) of non-residential development are possible in the County. Tepography and other physical/site constraints also play a part in the accommodating density. The Hollymead Town Center site has a 08-30-01 AOg:06 IN AGENDA TITLE: Work session: CPA 98-03, Post Office Land Trust (Hollymead Town Center) September 5, 2001 Page 2 rolling topography, with a substantial ridgeline running through the middle of the Town Center area. These site characteristics can limit the intensity of development unless extensive grading is undertaken. Table 1 (Town Center Estimated Land Use/Development Density) of the Master Plan estimates a maximum .42 gross FAR and .57 net FAR. Staff had recommended to the Commission a gross FAR goal of .5. Staff recognizes that a .75 FAR is very aggressive development goal, particularly for a short-term time frame (next 5 years) for this location. One method to address the intent of encouraging a higher FAR build-out is to demonstrate how lower FAR areas of the Town Center, primarily in the Regional Service area, can be developed/retrofitted in the future to increase FAR (buildings designed to add additional stories, parking garage locations, identifying infill sites, etc.). The Master Plan does state that "current design should consider how future redevelopment, or additional development of existing sites would provide for increased overall density [and] may be accomplished (p. 13)." While the Master Plan has provided a schematic example and this brief statement, this effort may need to be further expanded on and emphasized either within this Master Plan an/or Comprehensive Plan text amendment. Regarding the "65,000 square foot building size" the staff and Commission believe that a large, one-story commercial use with a large parking lot is a development style that uses land less efficiently and is difficult to integrate into the development pattern envisioned in the Neighborhood Model. Indications from the development community are that the cost of multi-story commercial developments is beyond what the County's "market" can sustain at this time. Multi-story, large-scale retail stores do exist, but most are found in more densely developed areas and communities larger than Charlottesville/Albemarle. Staff believes that large scale, single story, single use commercial development should be discouraged and design concepts more in keeping with the intent of the neighborhood model be encouraged. The issue to consider is how strongly does the County hold to this recommendation given the County's current market conditions. The Commission recommended maintenance of a 100-foot vegetative buffer along the Town Center's frontage of Route 29. This site was recently logged and the existing vegetation along the frontage of this site has been removed. The Master Plan provides a reasonable alternative approach utilizing landscaping along Route 29. The applicant is proposing an az-grade crossing (intersection) at the mid-pint of the Town Center site between the Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive intersections on Route 29 (P. 14). The Transportation recommendations for the Hollymead Community, adopted by the Board on February 7, 2001, does not recommend any new crossovers of Route 29. The need for this improvement is heightened by the unsure timing of the full development of the proposed local/parallel road network, including the upgrading of the Hollymead Drive and Timberwood Boulevard intersections along Route 29 to grade separated crossings. The property owners feel that this improvement is essential in the short term to adequately accommodate traffic to the Town Center without overtaxing the Timberwood Boulevard intersection and requiring excessive road design. Staff opinion is that the need for an additional at-grade crossing may be best determined at the time of rezoning when a traffic analysis can be undertaken for the a development proposal. Staff would be reluctant to assume the need for such a crossover at this time and would recommend that the Comprehensive Plan recognize the intent to minimize at-grade crossings in this area. However, it would be appropriate to the note that additional (possibly interim) improvements to Route 29 may be warranted in the short term, given the status/timing for overall road network development. One other major issue identified by staff is that the proposed Mixed Use/Regional Service Area (Figure 14) appears to generally reflect a more conventional strip development design in terms of building s~ze and site configuration. The Master Plan Design Guidelines as proposed would serve to address some of the negative aspects of conventional strip shopping developments. However, additional design guidelines specific to this area may be necessary to more concisely identify developmenfJdesign expectations for this area. For example, the expected road design standards for the streets internal to the commercial area are not provided; therefore, it is unclear whether sidewalks and landscaping are to be provided. Also, the identification of the way in which this area will be integrated and blended with the rest of the Town Center area is weak in the Master Plan. Pedestrian connections and/or greenspace connections, public spaces, consistency of building orientation/design/materials and internal street design are Master Plan components which should be further developed to address this issue. AGENDA TITLE: Work session: CPA 98-03, Post Office Land Trust (Hollymead Town Center) September 5, 2001 Page 3 RECOMMENDATION: This work session is to present and discuss the property owners' Master Plan as it relates to the Commission's proposed amendment. Staff opinion is that much of the Master Plan is consistent with the Commission's proposed amendment. Staff has noted the more significant differences in this Executive Summary and commented on their appropriateness for the Board's consideration and direction. The more minor deviations identified in Attachment A can be addressed through revisions to Comprehensive Plan language or modifications to the proposed Master Plan, or both. Once direction is provided by the Board, staff will work to amend the proposed Comprehensive Plan language and work with the property owner on Master Plan Changes that may be necessary for further review and action by the Board. 01.163 ATTACHMENT A Proposed Language to be added to the Hollymead Community Profile, Recommendations (page 78, Land Use Plan) [NOTE--The bold and italic print are staff's comments regarding the consistency of the Town Center Master Plan developed by the by the property owners to these recommendations.] The area designated as Town Center west of Route 29 and south Airport Road is intended as a mixed use, high- intensity area containing a mixture of businesses, services, public facilities, residential areas and one that attracts activities of all kind. Nearby residential development will be of high enough densities to support many of these uses. · This designation replaces the previous patchwork of regional service, office service and industrial service areas in an effort to establish a more unified planning and development process. The Town Center should adhere to the following twelve design principles as further defined in the General Development/Design Guidelines: 1) pedestrian orientation, 2) neighborhood friendly streets and paths, 3) interconnected streets and transportation networks, 4) parks and open spaces, 5) neighborhood centers, 6) buildings and spaces of human scale, 7) relegated parking, 8) mixture of uses, 9) mixture of housing types, 10) redevelopment rather than abandonment, 11) site planning that respects terrain, and 12) clear edges. The Design Standards proposed in the Master Plan are based on the twelve principles of the Neighborhood Model. General Development/Design Guidelines The following are general guidelines for the entire area designated as a Town Center in the Hollymead Community. LAND USE and DENSITY · A mix if residential and non-residential land uses shall be provided within the Town Center, including Urban Density Residential (6 to 34 du/ac.), Office Service Community Service, Public/Institutional uses including parks and greenways, and compatible Regional Service and Industrial Service. Over the whole Town Center area, a mix of residential and non-residential uses is provided. Table I in the Master Plan provides an estimated breakdown of uses and range of densities. Residential is permitted in the Regional Service area as proposed in the Master Plan. However, no residential is shown in the Mixed Use/Regional Service area in Table 1. Uses not considered desirable for this area include heavy industrial and manufacturing uses, and other traditionally large land consuming uses, such as warehousing (including self storage facilities), auto dealershi ps and larger scale highway-oriented regional commercial uses located in a free standing, big box concept with large expanses of parking. The Master Plan states that for the Mixed Use/Community Service area warehousing, self storage facilities, auto dealerships and auto service and stations and repair shops would be permitted at the discretion of the Commission and Board (p. 4). The Mixed Use/Regional Service area "may include large department stores, discount department stores, home improvement stores, and other anchor-type retailers (p.4)." Commercial development densities should consist of a minimum floor area ratio (FAR) of .75, with higher FAR encouraged (1.0 or greater) (31/2 to 4 floors and shared or reduced parking) (Attachment A, 3--DISC Volume 1, p. 97). Discussed in the attached Executive Summary. Low FAR uses of more than 65,000 square feet are generally not appropriate. However, compatible uses larger than 65,000 square feet shall be multi-story structures and otherwise meet recommended development criteria (up to 65,000-sq. ff./floor). 4 There is a building footprint limit of 65,000 square feet for the Mixed Use/Community Service area in the Master Plan. No building footprint limit is established for the Mixed Use/Regional Service' area. See further comments in the attached Executive Summary. · A significant residential component is anticipated within the designated Town Center area, both mixed with other commercial/office uses and within walking distance (approx. ¼ mile from core commercial center. The Master Plan states that "urban density residential would be permitted in all areas, and in fact, is expected to be the predominate use in much of the Mixed Use/Community Service area." Table 1 show between 360 and 1280 dwellings in this area. The Urban density area adjacent to the Greenway would provide 160 to 400 dwellings. Development of this area shall be pursuant to approval of an overall development plan for the Town Center area. Ap proval of Development Plans for a portion of the Town Center Area may be necessary and appropriate in certain situations, but is less desirable. SITE DESIGN · All building facades visible from a public road shall continue design elements present on the front of the building. · Orient buildings to street (parking behind buildings or within parking structures). The Master Plan provides guidelines for relegating parking. These includes guidelines for the location and screening of parking areas, use of on-street parking to meet needs, as well as the reduction in amount of parking must provided through shared parking methods. · Building should not appear monolithic. Massing, architectural features and component structures (pods or multi-story) should be used to reduce the size, footprint and presentation of large buildings. Uninterrupted facades should be avoided. · Site development should incorporate multi-story structures to conserve land and allow development of a 'critical mass? of uses; residential is an appropriate secondary use and is encouraged above commercial/retail. Stand-alone residential also appropriate in an urban form. In the Mixed Use/Community Service area, multi-story structures are anticipated and will be necessary to meet proposed development densities. In the Regional Service area, more "single use, singe story, larger footprint buildings are expected (p.9).' · Site development should respect the terrain and use appropriate design techniques to minimize clearing and grading activities. · Roof design shall mitigate the visual impact of larger scale structures and associated buildings, especially considering the general location of this area along a ridgeline. · Special attention should also be given to the visibility of development from Route 29. The Visibility of the Mixed Use/Regional Service Area will be significant issue. The development of this area is the most visible part of the Town Center as it is the "front door" to the area. Additional design/development guidelines may be necessary to better address this issue either in amendment language or the Master Plan, or both. · Loading docks, trash collection facilities, outdoor storage and related facilities shall be incorporated into building design so they are not visible. · Metal buildings not permitted in Core Area. · A system of walkways and bikeways shall be included in site design. Provided for in the Master Plan. Parking: -All parking areas shall be limited to that required by the Zoning Ordinance. -Parking should be centralized where appropriate. Cooperative parking arrangements are encouraged where feasible. -On-street parking shall be incorporated into road design. -Large parking areas should be divided into smaller components and distributed around or behind buildings, with trees and other landscaping material used to minimize visual impacts and heat generated by large areas of pavement. 5 -Avoid locating parking areas between streets and buildings. These general concepts are identified in the design guidelines of the Master Plan. · The General Development/Design Guidelines applies to this area. In addition: -Development at a higher FAR (Floor Area Ratio) shall be encouraged to conserve land and increase available open space for public use. A more compact urban design approach, incorporating public space and is strongly encouraged. Discussed earlier. Compact design and a higher FAR are components of the development expectations for the Mixed Use/Regional Service area. -Building shall be "inward" oriented to internal road system serving the Town Center (north-south street and/or east- west street) and not oriented to Route 29. Buildings within a portion of the Regional Service area are oriented to internal private roads and appear to be intended to function like streets which also forms a street and block system within the area. However, as proposed, there remains an impression of building orientation to Route 29. Additional design measures and building location modifications may be needed to be more fully articulated to address this issue. -A minimum one hundred (100) feet undisturbed vegetative buffer shall be maintained along Route 29 North, from just south of the Timberwood Boulevard extended to Hollymead Drive intersection. Augmentation of this buffer may be necessary with development of this area. The purpose of the buffer is to provide separation of the Town Center development from Route 29 and encourage an inward orientation of development as opposed to a highway orientation. The buffer also is intended to maintain to some extent the wooded character of this segment of the Route 29 corridor. Other means of meeting this intent may be considered under an ultimate development proposal. A portion of the Town Center property was subject to timbering activity recently. The existing vegetation up to the Route 29 right-of-way has been cleared. Little vegetation remains along the frontage of Route 29. TRANSPORTATION, TOWN CENTER AREA (See also the TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT section for specific recommendations for improvements along the Route 29 Corridor) Transit service should be provided as soon as operation is feasible and site design shall accommodate future transit service. Provided for in the Master Plan. "Bus stops are provided for in the Town Center and their use encouraged by an extensive pedestrian and bike system. Provision of bus service is beyond the control of the Owners Group (p. 12)." · All roads should be designed with the intent of providing pedestrian friendly neighborhood oriented streets. All roads in this area, including the north/south parallel read, should be constructed as an urban cress-section, with sidewalks, bike lanes and street landscaping. Lower design speeds and minimizing road width (number of through lanes) should be encouraged. However, on-street parking should be encouraged where appropriate. The Master Plan is generally consistent with this recommendation. The road network for the Town Center should consist of a system of interconnected streets forming a network of blocks. The network should consist a minimum of two (2) north-south roads with crossing streets creating a block pattem. Shorter block lengths consistent with the intent of creating a walkable community should be provided. The desirable block lengths would be between 200 and 300 feet. The Master Plan calls for multiple road network with the average block length approximately 500 feet. Some blocks are created by pedestrian crossings or private roads/access ways to buildings and parking areas instead of crossing public streets. However, the intent is to provide a small block pattern of development. The Town center road network shall include connections to Route 29 at Timberwood Boulevard, Hollymead Drive and minimum of one mid-point access (without a cross over) between the Hollymead and Timberwood connections. Access shall be provided to Airport Road at two (2) locations: 1 ) the future North Fork Research park access on Airport Road; and, 2) a future cross over located just west of the U. S. Post Office Building. The proposed Master Plan calls for a midpoint access with a crossover in addition to the existing crossovers at Hollymead Drive and Timberwood Boulevard. The north/south parallel road should be designed as a "Boulevard"or "Main Street"(as defined in the Neighborhood Model), recognizing that while carrying a higher volume of traffic, it also serves as important Neighborhood Street within the town center concept. As such, the road needs to accommodate pedestrians, cyclists, transit service and contribute positively to the character of the area. Other streets in the Town Center Area may be designed as a "Main Street," "Avenue," "Neighborhood Street," or "Way" depending on the character and intensity of development in the area (Attachment C, 1-5). Road recommendations are very similar. The Master Plan proposes a "modified Boulevard" design not included in the Planning Commission recommendations. The Master Plan does not include Neighborhood Model "Avenue or Residential Boulevard" design option. Overall though, the typical road design options and the proposed design for the roads in' the Town Center are generally consistent with the Commission recommendations. · Pedestrian and bicycle systems and transit access shall be provided throughout the town center, with a continuous walkway and travel way provided from Airport Road and Route 29 North. Provided for in the Master Plan. · Pedestrian activity is encouraged. Sidewalks on both sides of streets built 10 feet wide or greater shall be provided in high-density areas; six feet minimum width elsewhere. Master Plan is generally consistent. However, some guidelines would permit sidewalks to be one side of street (if no development on one side) and as narrow as 4 feet. In higher density areas, sidewalks would be 14 to 18 feet. · A park and ride lot shall be established near the town center area. Park and ride facilities are not discussed in Master Plan. · A network of subsidiary cress streets linking all major roads in a street block system shall be established throughout the larger site. Linkages shall be made to existing developed areas where possible (Deerwood, Forest Springs). Linkages are shown to Deerwood, the Forest Springs area, Airport Road in two locations and also to the area to the immediate south of the Town Center. Access points to Route 29 North shall be limited to Timberwood Boulevard Extended, the intersection at Hollymead Drive, and a minimum of one midpoint access (with no cross over) in between. Exact location to be determined. Grade separated vehicular crossings of Route 29 are recommended at Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive. Bicycle/pedestrian facilities shall be provided as part of grade separated crossings to provide pedestrian connectivity between the east and west sides of Route 29. These should be located at or near Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive. Sidewalks and bike facilities shall also be provided to link to planned facilities along Airport Road. PUBLIC SPACE AND PUBLIC FACITIES/SERVICES · Open space, recreation areas and public spaces shall be provided to serve patrons, employees, and community residents. Development of public open space/features such as a public square, traffic circles, and "pocket park(s)" are throughout the town Center area. Four public spaces are shown in the Master Plan (2 "squares" at either end of Main Street, a "pocket park" and a "linear park connecting the Mixed Use/Regional Service area to the Greenway). No public spaces are shown in the Mixed Use/Regional Service area. A greenway shall be established along the stream forming the western and southern boundary of the Town Center designation and should include walking and bike trails and other features/amenities. This greenway and associated trails should extend across Route 29 to link to the residential areas east of Route 29 and ultimately to the proposed greenway along Powell Creek. This has been provided for in the Master Plan. · The Community Facilities Plan indicates a need for a public library and police substation in the Hollymead Community. These facilities should be provided in the Town Center area. Parking for the Library could be used as a public parking lot. · Space shall be made available for a recycling center (not counted against square footage limits). No specific provision has been made in Master Plan for these public facilities. In the Neighborhood Centers section (p. 7) of the Master Plan it states that "any civic or public uses should be located in the Main Street area." ENVIRONMENT · Regional stormwater facilities shall be established to serve this portion of the Hollymead Community. Three stormwater detention facilities are shown on the Master Plan in locations where they could provide regional detention serving the Town Center, and the surrounding areas. · Exemplary specimen or old growth trees that may exist in this area shall be preserved to the extent practicable. · Area landscaping shall minimize water requirements · Principles of sustainable design shall be incorporated to a significant extent in site development, including use of natural lighting within buildings, green roof technology, energy efficiency. The above three recommendations are not covered in the Master Plan. Road Improvements, Route 29 Corridor and Proffit Road Amendment to Hollymead Community Profile Recommendations (pp. 78-81) Adopted, 2/7/01 (CPA 2000-05) · Transportation improvements include...(p.80) Recommended improvements along the Route 29 Corridor: 1. Road design and alignment improvements to Route 29 should be in keeping with the emerging community consisting of a mix of residential neighborhoods, and commercial and employment centers. Improvements related to upgrading Route 29 shall be consistent with an overall network of interconnecting roads that balance the need to serve both the local and regional transportation demands. 2. Parallel or adjunct roads east and west of Route 29 should be designed and located in a manner consistent with other land use and transportation recommendations of the Corn prehensive Plan. 3. Any system of parallel roads to augment Route 29 should be constructed as an urban cross-section design (curb/gutter) with sidewalks and bike lanes. This creates a system of reads more in keeping with a neighborhood street system and more consistent with th e character of the adjacent neighborhoods. 4. Recommendations for road design/classification for the parallel roads are taken from the Albemarle County Neighborhood Model as recommended by the Development Area Initiatives Study Committee (DISC) Report. Road design should be an "Avenue/Residential Boulevard" or "Neighborhood Street" design on the eastern parallel road from Polo Grounds Road to Hollymead Drive; a "Main Street" design on the eastern parallel road from the cemetery to Proffit Road; a "Boulevard" or "Main Street" design on the western parallel road system transitioning to "Avenue/Residential Boulevard" or "Main Street" south to Hollymead Drive extended. 5. The eastern parallel road system should extend to Polo Grounds Road (Route 643). 6. The southern end of any western parallel road system should terminate at a connection with Hollymead Drive Extended. 7. Hollymead Drive and Timberwood Parkway should be designed with grade-separated crossings of Route 29, without ramps, to connect with the road system on the western side of Route 29 and accommodate east-west vehicular, pedestrian and bicycle movements with the appropriate facilities. Provide a grade-separated crossing without ramps at Airport Road to accommodate east-west vehicular, pedestrian and bicycle movements with the appropriate facilities. Based on development patterns east of Route 29, provide grade separated bicycle/pedestrian overpasses/underpasses to accommodate east-west movement. 10. East-west connecting roads should be curb/gutter design with sidewalks/ bike lanes and the design should be "Avenue/Residential Boulevard" or "Main Street" design. 11. In the long term, consider establishing an east-west connection from Route 29 to Earlysville Road (Route 743) as recommended in the Charlottesville Area Transportation Study (CATS) by extending Hollymead Drive to Earlysville Road. This road location and design should be coordinated with the relocation of Dickerson Road (Route 606). 12. Intermediate accesses, without crossovers, to Route 29 should be provided on the east side between Ashwood Boulevard and Timberwood Boulevard and west side between Hollymead Drive and Timberwood Boulevard. 13. Stop the northern end of the eastern parallel road at Hollymead Drive and access undeveloped land north of Hollymead directly from Route 29, without a crossover. This will avoid significant impact to existing homes in Hollymead. 14. Proffit Road (Route 649) should be constructed with a "Neighborhood Street" design from Worth Crossing to Lanford Hills Drive, including sidewalks and bike lanes. The section from Route 29 to Worth Crossing should be designed in a manner necessary to accommodate transition to the ultimate improvements to Route 29 and Airport Road. A major upgrade of Proffit Road east of Lanford Hills to Route 20 is not recommended; however, minimal spot safety improvements may be appropriate in certain locations. The Master Plan does not address road improvements outside of the Town Center area other than the proposal for an at-grade crossover at the intermediate access recommended in #12, above. HOLLYMEAD TOWN CENTER CPA-98-03 OWNERS' RESPONSE TO EXECUTIVE SUMMARY On July 20, 2001, the principal owners of approximately 180 acres in the Hollymead Growth Area submitted a Conceptual Master Plan & .Design Guidelines for the Hollymead Town Center ("Master Plan"). After nearly two years of efforts by the Planning Commission and others failed to produce a consensus among all the owners to change the l_ztnd Use Plan .initiated by CPA-98-03, the owners agreed with tike Board of Supervisors in February to attempt to arrive at a coordinated plan for area. The Master Plan represents the owners' response to design principles articulated by the Planning Commission and by the-Board of Supervisors during the process. The Master Plan was assembled after months of meetings, among the owners, architects, engineers, land planners, and market and industry experts. On August 31, the staff released its Executive Suminary of the MaSter Plan for the Board's consideration on September 5. The owners appreciate the thorough review provided by the staff but wish to respond below to several observations and recommendations contained in 'the Executive Summary. I. FAR. The MaSter Plan represents an overall FAR of 0.57 for the Town Center (net of open space and roads). Staff recognizes that a 0.75 FAR, as recommended by the Planning Commission, "is a very aggressive development goal, particularly for a short-term time frame (next 5 years) for this location." The owners also wish to emphasize that the Master Plan is not intended to be static. While the uses and types of build out conceptualized in the Master Plan may take 5, 10 or even 20 years to develop, the owners'fully expect that as market conditions warrant, further infill and redevelopment assuredly will take place. Staff suggests demonstrating how lower FAR area~' Of the Town Center, primarily in the Regional Service area, can be developed/retrofitted in' the future to increase FAR. Staff concedes that the Master Plan does: state that "current design should consider how future redevelopment, or additional' development of existing sites would provide for increased overall density [and] .may be accomplished (p. 13)." That statement should be more than sufficient for any conceptual land use plan. It should, be easy for all of us to imagine that buildings may be retrofitted or razed to create, more density, or to' add additional stories; that parking garages can be constructed on current surface lot locations, etc., all as market conditions dictate. Beyond that, it would be impossible to predict or 'master land use plan' for future changes in market conditions. ' H. Building Size Limitation. It appears from the Executive Summary that the staff continues to question the efficacy of large scale (in excess of 65,000 square feet), single story, single-use commercial buildings, which the Planning Commission previously tried to prohibit. The effect of this would be to preclude or limit certain types of supermarkets, department stores, home improvement stores, or many national retail stores from' the Town Center. The Executive Summary tells us that the' Planning Commission:believes that 'large., single story buildings should be discouraged because they are not in keeping with the Neighborhood Model. The Neighborhood Model addresses principles for more effective land use. Surely, it was not the Board's intent by adopting the Neighborhood Model to banish an entire category Of retail tenants of the type that are so clearly valued and recognized by consumers and community lead,rs in cities and towns around the country. The Executive Summary recognizes that "the cost 6f multi-story commercial developments is beyond what the County's "market" can sustain at this time." The Executive SUmmary correctly observes that "multi- story, large-scale retail stores do exist, but most are found in more densely developed areas and communities larger than Charlottesville/Albemarle." It also states that "the issue to consider is how strongly does the County hold to the [Planning Commission] recommendation given the County's current market conditions." But the choice need not be market forces versus the Neighborhood Model. The choice should be to implement the principles of the Neighborhood Model within the market realities, as the Master Plan contemplates. The Master Plan represents the first time in the history of Albemarle County that multiple ownership interests have proposed an integrated mix of a variety of uses, including Commercial and Regional Service, yet all within a five-minute walk of residential uses. This is a remarkable opportunity for the County and for the Neighborhood MOdel. It should also be pointed out that the area designated for Mixed Use/Regional Service 'in the Master. Plan is ~ currently designated for Regional Service in the County's Land Use Plan. The Regional Service designation was adopted by the Board, without any building size limitation or similar restriction, as an ~inducement. to the' Owner, Wendell Wood'to undertake certain obligations that he has fully met. ~-- ' "' HI. 100-1Coot Buffer. The Executive Summary indicates that-the Master Plan provides a reasonable alternative approach to the Planning Commission's recommended 100-foot buffer, utilizing landscaping along Route 29. The owners agree with the Executive Summary on this. IV. At-Grade Crossover. The'Owners propose an at-grade crossing (inter~ecfi0n) at the mid2pint of the-' Town Center site between the Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive interSeCtions on.Route .29 (P. ' 14). The Transportation recommendation for the Hollymead Community, adopted by the Board on February 7, 2001, does not recommend any new crossovers of Route 29. As the staff indicates,' now "the need for this [at-grade crossing] is heightened by the unsure timing of the full development of the proposed local/parallel road network..." Indeed, as the .Executive summary also points out, this improvement is'essential in the short term to adequately accommodate, traffic to the 'Town Center without overtaxing..the TimberWood Boulevard intersection and requiring excessive road design. Staff opinion is that the need for an additional at-grade crossing may be best determined at' the time of rezoning when a traffic analysis can be undertaken for the a development proposal. The owners feel the need for an additional at-grade crossing should be apparent from the Master Plan. Therefore, the Board need not wait for this to be determined at the time of rezoning. The Master Plan contemplates at least two entrances to the Town Center that will be inviting as well as safe and efficient for traffic management. Without a crossover, northbound traffic on Route 29 would be forced to either make a u-turn movement t0 enter the Town Center off Route 29 at the Town Center's main; centrally located entrance, or enter via Timberwood Boulevard. These predictable traffic movements should be apparent without requiring a traffic study. That precluding the crossover will create unsafe conditions by tempting the u-turn movement~and/or overtax the Timberwood Boulevard should be clear noTM. It should be noted that any crossover of course would need to be approx;ed by VDOT, based upon.a thorough traffic study. The owners do not wish to embark on the costly prospect of a rezoning, with attendant traffic studies, etc., without the County's support on the crossover. In addition, including a crossover enhances the succes~ °fthe Town Center. The main, boUlevard entrance lo the Town Center from Route 29 becomes superfluous without the crossover. Precluding a crossover effectively limits the new Town Center ~to a single entrance from Route 29 for northbound residents and patrons. IV. Desien Issues. Staff characterizes the Mixed Use/Regional Service Area of the master Plan as "reflecting a more conventional strip development design in terms of building size and site configuration." The owners respectfully disagree, but believe that this merely an expression of personal aesthetic preferences and not appropriate'for conceptual land use planning. The owners' particular response regarding building size is addressed above. As for the site configuration, it is important to recognize that'-factors relevant to the practidal development of this site, as with any site, such as topography and'needs of the ultimate tenants of the buildings must be considered. It is also important to emphasize that the sketch, for the Mixed Use/Regional Service Area is intended only to be conceptual. Staff points out correctly that specific architectural features - down to building design and even materials--are not fully addressed in the Master Plan. Such features would be beyond the scope of a conceptual master plan of this undertaking. The Master Plan provides a set of design guidelines, the illustrations of which in all instances were beyond the scope of a conceptual plan. ,The owners are prepared and willing to Consider these design guidelines as we proceed with the ultimate proje~ct pJan through the rezoning and site plan process. Design elements such as sidewalks and landscaping will indeed be provided, as will.other pedestrian connectionS and/or green space connections. Such features are~:clearly beyond the scope of the ComprehenSive Plan's purpose, which under the 'statutes of Virginia is to be general in nature. INTRODUCTION For more than two years a Comprehensive Plan Amendment (CPA-98-03) has been under consideration for establishment of a Town Center in the Hollymead Development Area. The proposed Town Center, approximately 180 acres in size, is intended as a mixed use, high-intensity area containing a mixture of businesses, services, public facilities, and residential areas that attract activities of all kinds. It is intended that the Town Center not Only serve the need of residential uses within the Town Center, but also of residential development throughout the Hollymead Development Area and surrounding areas. The Town Center designation is to integrate the existing patchwork of regional service, office service, and industrial service designations in an effort to establish a more unified planning and development process consistent with The Neighborhood Model as adopted by the Board of Supervisors on May 16, 2001. - The Town Center designation will implement the twelve design principles set forth in The Neighborhood Model as listed below: 1. Pedestrian orientation 2. Neighborhood friendly streets and paths 3. Interconnected streets and transportation networks 4. Parks and open spaces 5. Neighborhood centers 6. Buildings and spaces of haman scale 7. Relegated parking 8. Mixture of uses 9. Mixture of housing types 10. Redevelo~t rather than abandonment 11. Site planning that respects terrain 12. Clear edge In addition to the twelve principles set forth above, general development and design guidelines for the Town Center have been set forth herein, in the Master Plan, and Figures attached. During consideration of the Town Center by the Plann/ng Commission and Board of Supervisors concerns were expressed by several landowners (hereafter referred to as "Owners Group") relative to some of the specific requirements set forth in the General Development/Design Guidelines. Of most concern were proposed requirements of a floor area ratio (FAR) of .75, a maximum building footprint of 65,000 square feet, and a minimum one hundred (100) feet undisturbed vegetative buffer along Route 29. As a result of these concerns it was proposed by the Owners Group, and agreed to by the Board of Supervisors during their February 7, 2001 meeting, that the Owners Group produce a master plan for the Town Center inclusive of design guidelines acceptable to thenx The Board of Supervisors would then consider the proposed master plan before taking any final action on the Town Center. At their February 7, 2001 the Board of Supervisors adopted a related document to the Town Center, "Road Improvements, Route 29 Corridor and Proffit Road- Amendment to the Hollymead Community Profile - Pages 78 - 81". Some of the facts surrounding assumptions about future VDOT improvements, (particularly those having to do with a parallel road to Route 29) have changed since the adoption of this Amendment to the Hollymead Community Profile. Therefore, the Road Improvements Amendment is amended and further supplemented by the Transportation section contained at the end of this submission. Tiffs document provides a proposed Master Plan and Design Guidelines for the Hollymead Town Center. The Design Guidelines are organized in accordance with the twelve design principles of The Neighborhood Model with comments and illustrations indicating how those design principles are to be met. MASTER PLAN The Master Plan shows land use for designated areas of the ;town Center, street layout and classification, open space and parks, potential storm detention locations, five rainute walk radiuses (1,500 feet) from focal points in the Town Center, and pedestrian and bike systems. The Town Center is organized around a Main Street running north/south with parks tcnzahating the street at both ends. A linear park runs east/west intersecting Main Street at the center of the Town Center, and connects the greenway along Power Creek that borders the Town Center to the center of Main Street. The Town Center streets are arranged in a grid pattern with east/west connections limited because of grade conditions. However, through the use of entrances into parking areas, pedestrian connections including the linear park, and the cross streets, a distinct urban grid pattern w~]l be established with a minimum of thirty distinct blocks. Multiple connections to surrounding areas provide external access and disperse traffic within the Town Center. Almost all areas of the Town Center, and some of the surrounding area, are within a five-minute walk of the intersection of Main Street and the linear park. From the parks terrrdnating Main Street essentially all areas of the Town Center are within .a five-minute walk. An extensive pedestrian and bike network will provide for and encourage pedestrian and bike activity. Approximately eighteen acres of open space and parks are shown on the Master Plan, and additional open space will be designated as individual sites within the Town Center are developed. Three storm detention locations are shown, and are envisioned as an important part of the open space. It is hoped that each of these can become a permanent water feature with the two on the east of the Town Center providing a northern and southern temfinus for a landscaped edge along Route 29. The device at the northwest comer of the TOwn Center is envisioned as the entry to the greenway along Powell Creek that ultimately could connect through Forest Lakes and Hollymead to the Rivanna greenbelt. While the exact location and sizes of storm detention devices may vary from the Master Plan, the intent is to integrate them as attractive features of the Town Center A greenway along Powell Creek (approximately eight acres and 4,000 linear feet) wffi bound the west .and south sides of the Town Center. A bllre/walking path within this greenway will ~ovide connections to areas outside the Town Center as well as provide connection between the northwestern and southeastern portions of the Town Center. The linear park (approximately one and one half acres and 1,200 linear feet), also with a b~e/walking path, connects the greenway to the Main Street area of the Town Center. Parks (each approximately 10,000 square feet) terminate each end of Main Street. These parks are envisioned as public spaces framed by buildings with commercial or residential uses on the ground floor. Bus stops at both parks provide attractive and convenient stops for a public transportation system In addition to the parks at each end of Main Street, a small pocket park will be created around an existing family graveyard. A landscaped edge is planned along the east side of the Town Center consistent with the design of Route 29. If Route 29 remains a rural design, a bermed, landscaped buffer inclusive of trees with a paved bflce/wa.lldng path is envisioned. If Route 29 becomes an urban design with curb, gutter, and sidewalk, a grass strip behind the sidewalk with more formal landscaping and street trees is envisioned. The Master Plan and any renderings or figures referenced herein are for illustrative purposes only. Building sizes, orientation, and other design features are for illusla~ve purposes only, and may be changed so long as not inconsistent with the provisions of this Comprehensive Plan Amendment. Land Uses Three land use classifications are shown; Urban Density Residential, Mixed Use/Community Service, and Mixed Use/Regional Service. Urban Density Residential would be permitted in all areas, and, in fact, is expected to be the predominate use in much of the mixed Use/Community Service area. Mixed Use/Community service would be allowed in Mixed Use/Regional Service areas. Urban Density Residential Used as an exclusive designation in areas adjacent to streams and single farrfily development. · Developed at densities of 6 .to 34 units per acre with a target average density of 20 units per acre. Product types envisioned are attached townhouse, multi story rental apartments, and multi story for sale condominiums. · Building heights required for six story buildings wall be permitted, and greater heights permitted where thek design provides for the appropriate spatial enclosure. Mixed Use/Community service · Uses allowed in this designation include conm~mity-scale cona~ercial, professional, .and office uses providing retail, wholesale, business, medical offices, general office, and public service to the Hollymead Development Area and larger geographic sections of the County. No single commercial use to exceed a building footprint of 65,000 square feet, but no limitation on gross building square feet in total. · Warehousing (including self storage), auto dealerships, and Service station and auto repair facih'ties would be permitted only where deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors. · Urban density residential would be permitted within this land use designation both as stand alone buildings and as a mixed use within a single building. Multi level residential buildings, either rental apartments 'or for. sale condominiums, are envisioned as stand alone buildings. Also envisioned are mixed use, multi-level buildings with residential units above retinal service and/or office. · Live/work units would be permitted in this land use designation. · Urban' density exceeding 34 units per acre would be penrtitted where deemed appropriate by the Planning Comn~sion and Board of Supervi~sors. · Building heights required for six story buildings would be permitted, and greater heights permitted where their design provides for the appropriate spatial' enclosure. · Industrial Service uses would be permitted where deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors, and would be favored when supportive of a remWsmwSce component. Mixed Use/Regional serVice Uses allowed .in this designation include, all uses allowed in Mixed Use/Community Service as well as regional scale commercial centers and medical centers, and mixed-use areas providing retail, wholesale, residential, business, and/or employment.services to Albemarle County and the region. The Regional Service designation ma~y include large department stores, discount department stores, home improvement stores, supermarkets, and other anchor-type retails. No limitation on building sizes shall be imposed within this Service Area designation. Large buildings in excess of 65,000 square feet generally shall be oriented away from Route 29, either perpendicular to Route 29 or facing inward. Stores facing Route 29 shall generally be located toward the exterior of the site as grades permit, with reasonable screening from Route 29 by means of buffers, landscap/ng and/or small out parcel buildings. No FAR minknum requ/rements shall be imposed. Summary of. Land Uses Multiple issues'make it impossble to .precisely quantify land use in terms of gross building square feet and/or numbers of residential units at this time. Certainly, the most significant issues are an uncertainty regarding the most appropriate mix of uses over an extended period of time, and Uncertainty regarding regulatory changes that are required to implement the Master Plan. Changes in the mix of uses, particularly in the mix of residential versus non-residential use, could dramatically change gross btdlding square feet. Without knowing the changes in regulations that may be agreed to, it is not possl~ole to know the impacts such changes may have on the ab~ty to mix uses and/or increase density. Nevertheless, an estimate of land use and density is provided in Table 1. DESIGN GUIDELINES The Design Guidelines are based on the twelve principles of The Neighborhood Model, tailored to the land uses and product mix envisioned for the Town Center. Pedestrian Orientation As indicated in discussion of the Master Plan, all of the Town Center, and some - surrounding area, is within a five minute walk of the Main Street area, or the center of the Town Center. Pedestrian and bike activity will be provided for and encouraged in the following ways: Sidewalks will be provided on streets within the Town Center in accordance with the design guidelines set forth in Figure 1. Also shown in Figure 1 are design guidelines for pedestrian and multi-use paths. On street bike lanes vall be provided as designated on the Master Plan, and additional on street bike lanes will be provided as development occurs if deemed required. However, the goal will be to compliment the on street lanes with off street b~e paths, and on street bike routes so that street widths are not unnecessarily wide. In particular, an on street b~e lane is not planned for Main Street. Figure 2 provides the requirement for on street bike lanes, and illustrates a bike lane, bike route, and bike path. · A paved pedestrian/b~e path within the Powell Creek greenway, the linear . park, and potentially the landscaped buffer along Route 29 will~ provide 5 additional pedestrian/b~e access. A minimum of 5,000 linear feet of paved paths, and poss~ly up to 8,000 linear feet will be prodded. The emphasis of mixed use, the placement of parks and their relationship and connection to other features such as the greenway and Main Street, and the interconnected nature of the street system and pedestrian/b~e system should enhance pedestrian and bike use. Additionally, the provision of bus stops at key locations will further enhance pedestrian activity. Neighborhood Friendly Streets and Paths Street designs will be based on The Neighborhood Model as illustrated in Figures 3 through 8. Boulevard (Figure 3) -- What is envisioned for the Town Center would exclude the side medians and related parking areas and/or frontage roads, and more closely resemble Figure 4. This design~ would be used at primary entrances from Route 29, and poss~ly at the western edge of the Mixed Use/Regional Service areas. Main Street (Figure 5) - This design would be usedforMain Street and other p15mary streets in the M/xed Use/Comnamity Service areas. Sidewalk width may be reduced in predominately residential areas. Neighborhood Street (Figure 6) - Used for the primary streets in predominately, or exclusively, residential areas. In some cases it may be advisable to reduce street widths to less than thirty feet. Way (Figure 7) - Ways are not shown on the Master Plan, but are envisioned as potential secondary streets in predominately residential areas. Alley (Figure 8) - Alleys also are not shown on the Master Plan, but are envisioned, especially in residential areas. As illustrated in Figures 3 through 8, the street designs envisioned allow for streetscape elements such as grass strips between the street and sidewalk, street trees,, and on street parking. A street hierarchy will establish which streets are most important relative to esthetics, relegated parking and other considerations. Interconnected Streets and Transportation Networks The Master Plan illustrates the interconnected nature of the street, pedestrian and bike networks. In. fact, as already mentioned, by interconnectious of street, pedestrian and bike paths, and entrances into parking areas, approximately thirty distinct blocks will be creater[ Along Main Street block length will not exceed 300 feet, and, in general, block lengths will not exceed 500 feet. .Because of terrain, the proposed street system is not a strict rectilinear grid pattern. It more closely resembles the Cundlinear Grid Pattern as described in the Neighborhood Model with the characteristics as shown in Figure 9: Site design should accommodate future transit service within the street system for the Town Center. The Town Center road netWork shall include connections to Route 29 at TimberWood Boulevard, Hollymead Drive and three points of access between the Hollymead and Timberwood connections. Access shall be provided to Airport Road at two (2) locations: 1) the future North Fork Research park access on A/rport Road; and, 2) a future cross over located west of the U. S. Post Office Bm~lding. The area along Route 29 North, from just south of the Timberwood Boulevard extended to Hollymead Drive intersection should accommodate future connections to the east side of Route 29. Parks and Open Spaces The Powell Creek greenway will be consistent with the design guidelines set forth in Figure 10, and the Main Street parks will be based on design characteristics of '°the Square" (Figure 11). The Powell Creek greenway will incorporate walking and bike trails. The Powell Creek greenway and associated trails system will take int6 account poss~le extensions across Route 29 to link to the residential areas east of Route 29~ The linear park will vary in design depending on location. In the vicinity of the greenway it will be less form~ with design characteristics skmlar to the greenway (Figure 10). In the vicinity of Main Street its design will become more formal s'nnilar to "The Square" (Figure 11) and/or "The Plaza" (Figure 12). The design of the pocket park shown on the Master Plan, as well additional pocket parks expected but not shown on the Master Plan, will be consistent with "The Pocket Park" (Figure 13). Neighborhood Centers The Neighborhood Center is Main Street with the parks at each end. This area is within a five-minute walk of all areas within the Town Center, and is the area where the greatest mix of uses is expected. Main Street should be the most important street from a design perspective, with parking relegated, buildings pulled close to and ~ming the street, wide sidewalks with street trees in planters, and street furniture provide an attractive and comfortable area for people to congregate. Any civic or public uses should be located in the Main Street area. Pedestrian and b~e systems wl~ll provide access from all' areas within the Town Center to Main Street, and public transportation stops at the parks will be particularly convenient to Main Street. Buildings and Spaces of Human Scale Emphasis will be placed on the design and placement of buildings and their relationship to streets and other outdoor spaces so that enclosed, comfortable outdoor spaces are created. This emphasis is considered to' be of particular importance in the Maid Street area and other areas designated Mixed Use/Conanunity Service, as well as in areas designated Urban Density Residential. While deemed a desirable goal, it will be less achievable in areas designated Mixed Use/Regional Service. Building placement for the Mixed Use/Regional area along Route 29 may include using out-parcel buildings to buffer parking areas, as well as generous use of trees, and landscaping. Setbacks from Route 29 may be within 30 feet. Since no single fan~y residential homes are envisioned in the Town Center, building types that are appropriate for townhouses, multi-level stacked condos and/or apartments, or multi-level mixed use buildings will be the norm in Urban Density Residential and Mixed Use/Conanunity Service areas. Thus, the following as taken directly from The Neighborhood Model provides appropriate design guidance. "In general, heights of buildings should be greatest at the Centers and Cores, and diminish gradually away from those areas. Where a Center or General Area abuts a rural area boundary, buildings may be fairly high up to the boundary~ The important feature is that the heights of bmrldings should relate to the rest of the neighborhood and building proportions should relate to the s/ze of the human body. This means that combined height and width (mass) of buildings should not be overwhelming. Larger buildings can use techniques that reduce their perceived mass. For example, a change in material or texture above the first or second floor can help to reinforce the base (scaled to a human) while .diminishing the portion above. This technique is used at the old Monticello Hotel in Court Square in Downtown Charlottesville. Other techniques include the use of cornice lines above the second or third floor or setbacks at the same location. Most important is the level and quality of detail at the first and second floor, the areas most within the view of the pedestrian." As descn~oed in The Neighborhood Model, build-to lines in lieu of front yard minimum setbacks should be used: '°The front faqade build-to line is the line in which the primary mass of the front facade should be set. It is measured from the edge of the right-of-way to the building. The larger the primary mass of the front faqade, the greater the front yard should be. This line should be consistent within a ~block, unless .it is intentionally varied to achieve a more picturesque effect and/or avoid unusual site conditions." One or more members of the Owners Group have submitted contemporaneously with this Master Plan an illustrative plan of development for portions of the Town Center. An ~ustrative plan for the Mixed Use/Regional Service Area contained in Figure 14 for example, depicts btdlding sizes, building mass, building orientation and parking for potential retail development within this area, but is for illustrative proposes only. It is intended to depict one poss~le plan of development that would be permitted within the Mixed Use/Regionxl Service Area, and may not represent the final development plan or' scheme. Figure 15 illustrates architectural treatments as taken from the Neighborhood Model, with appropriate build-to lines, consistent with the'mix of uses and product types expected in the Town Center, and in particular in the Urban Density Residential and Mixed Use/Community Service areas. In the mixed Use/Regional Service areas more single use, single story, larger footprint buildings are expected. Nevertheless, the goal of human scale, comfortable, enclosed outdoor space should remain the same, and the architectural design of those buildings, their placement, landscaping, and other external features should keep that primary goal in mind. Side yard setbacks should be based on Building Code with consideration to privacy requirements of product types, particularly residential product. Side yard design guidelines at street comers should be as follows: · Side yards should allow for buildings to be set close to the street without interfering with sight distance for vehicles. · Building design should consider the view from both streets. · At the comer of two major streets, the building should provide a front facade to both streets (Figure 16). · At the comer of a major and minor street, the building should typically front the major street, but design elements that enhance the view from the minor street should be considere& Examples of such design elements are as follows: · Wrap the front porch around the side and extend the length of the building along the minor street (Figure 17). · Add an ancillary structure that frOnts the minor street (Figure 18). · Side yard setbacks on corner lots should be consistent with the front yard setbacks of braidings fronting the street the corner side yard abuts (Figure 19). · Where poss~le, building facades vis~ble from a public road should continue design elements present on the front of the building. Loading docks, trash collection facilities, outdoor storage and related facilities should be incorporated into building design so they are not readily vim~ole. As indicated in The Neighborhood Model, spatial enclosure, or the relationship of the heights of buildings to the distances between them, is the appropriate design guideline for creating human scale outdoor space. Figure 20 illustrates the concept of spatial enclosure as well as the utulization of building recesses at upper levels to minimize building height and mass and thereby maintaining appropriate spatial enclosure. Trees can be used to help create spatial enclosure where distances between buildings are excessive relative to tbe/r heights. The utilization of trees to create spatial enclosure will be of particular importance ha the Mixed Use/Regional Service areas where building footprint size, the distances between buildings, and parking areas will tend to be the largest. Relegated Parking Perhaps the most challenging issue ha designing pleasing urban environments is how to accommodate parking. The Neighborhood Model identified eleven potential ways to relegate parking. The appropriateness of each for the Town Center is discussed herein. 1. Relegate parking areas behind and to the sides of large slractures. What must be realized is that what is "behind" and/or "to the side" from one perspective is not from others. Thus, street hierarchy becomes extremely important in determining the placement of parking. Certainly, parking should be to the side and rear of buildings fronting Main Street. A~s illustrated in Figure 21 this most likely would result in parking areas abutting the streets parallel to Main Street. In general, in Urban Density Residential and Mixed Use/Community Service areas, it is felt parking can be placed to the side and/or rear of buildings facing the most hrq3ortant streets. In the M/xed Use/Regional Service designation, the intent is to minimize large parking fields oriented to Route 29. Parking areas in front of stores that are perpendicular, or parallel to Route 29 are appropriate so longas the fields of parking are broken up by using means such as landscaping islands, drive aisles, grade breaks and other appropriate means. See Figure 14. 2. Locate residential parking behind the front fagade or along an alley. It is felt that most parking ha most residential areas will be to the side or rear of buildings as discussed above, including townhouses. Single-family residences are not envisioned in the Town Center, but, if used, this parking guideline will be utilized. 3. Encourage the use and provision of parking garages. While some use of parking garages could ultim~ately occur in the Town Center, their use ha the early stages of development is not envisioned. As correctly pointed out in The Neighborhood Model, parking garages would cost four to five tfl,aes per space more than' surface parking. This cost differential raises significant issues relative to housing affordab~ty, and the ability to compete for non-residential uses relative to areas where parking garages are not required. The provision of incentives to provide parking I0 garages as discussed in The Neighborhood Model would certainly encourage their use. Some use of tuck-under parking as illustrated in Figure 22 is expected, particularly in multi-fan~y residential buildings. While use of parking garages in the early stages of development may not be economically feasl'ole, construction of posm'ole future parking garages may be facilitated in the initial design of the Town Center. 4. Allow stand-alone parking lots or garages. It is agreed that stand-alone parking lots and/or garages would result in better overall design and should be permitted. In fact, to require that all parking be on site severely limits the ability to create a pleasing urban environment. Increase the distance from which a use can be separated from its associated use. Again, it is agreed this is desirable. Without this change, the ability to uUlize stand-alone parking or shared parking is significantly reduced. Count on-street parking-toward parking requ/rements. It is agreed this is desirable. Thought must be given as to how such credit is applied, i.e., if on public roads does it apply to specific sites or in general? Reduce minimum parking'requirements to coincide with common usage rather than peak usage and consider maximum parking allowances; provided that no limit on parking ratios will be imposed in the Mixed. Use/Regional Service Reduced parking requirements certainly may be desirable, and in particular as requirements are. applied to individual sites/uses. For retail commercial uses the current requirement is, in general, ten spaces per 1,000 gross square feet of building up to the first 5,000 square feet, and five spaces per 1,000 gross square feet thereafter. Thus, for a mix of small sites/uses the required parking would be significantly greater if applied individually by site/use rather than for groups of sites/uses as a whole. For example, the Main Street area of the Town Center is approximately twenty acres. Assume there are twenty individual sites/uses of a retail commercial nature of one acre each, and further assume that each site is developed at a conventional suburban development density of 0.20 FAR or about 8,700 gross building square feet. Applying the current parking. requirement would mean sixty nine spaces per site, or 1,380 in total for the twenty sites. If the parking requirement applied to the twenty acres as a whole the total spaces would be 895, or 485 fewer spaces. Assuming 400 square feet 11 per space, the savings in land required for parking would be 194,000 square feet, or about 4.45 acres. The 485 spaces saved would provide parking for an additional 97,000 square feet o~7 office or retail space, or 242 residential units (338,800 square feet assuming 1,400 square feet per unit) provided the additional building space was upper floor space, i.e., above ground floor. Thus, one level suburban conm~ercial development could become two to three level urban mixed use development-with the FAR increased from 0.20 to betWeen 0.30 and 0.40 depending on the mix of commercial and residential uses. For example, in the M/xed Use~egional Service designation, the intent is to minflmz' e large parking fields oriented to Route 29. Parking areas in front of stores that are perpendicular, or parallel to Route 29 are appropriate so long as the fields of parking are broken up by using mean.q such as landscaping islands, drive aisles, grade breaks and other appropriate means. While the above examples are hypothetical and may vary significantly for different site conditions, they do indicate how changes in requirements can .change the pattern of development. 8. Increase the oppommifies for shared parking. 10. tl. It is agreed that shared parking should be encouraged, particularly between residential and certain non-residential uses. Recent surveys at various Albemarle County townhonse and office sites indicate that up to 60% of the residential parking could be utilized for office parking during normal weekday office hours. Figure 23 illustrates how shared parking could work between sites. By sharing the parking on the adjacent residential site, an additional 26,400 gross square feet of building space would be poss~'ole on the office site. Shared parking will not be required in the Mixed Use/Regional Service Area. Provide reduced parking requirements where employers use Transportation Demand Management (TDM). While this may be a reasonable way to reduce parking requirements, it is beyond the control of the OWners Group at this time. However, the proposed design of the ToWn Center will facilitate implementation of such a measure. Develop Centers around bus transit corridors. Bus stops are provided for in the Town Center and their use encouraged by an extensive pedestrian and bike system Provision of the bus service is beyond the control of the Owners Group. Allow for use of non-asphalt surfaces for a.portion of the required parking. While this may be advantageous it is not felt it would be particularly useful 12 with our local soft conditions. Additionally, it would not reduce the required parking, or the amount of land required for such parking. In summary, it-is felt many potential options exist to both reduce the parking requ/rement and the impact of parking that is require& Items 1, and 4 through 8 offer great potential given the proposed Master Plan and mix of uses. Item 3, or parking structures, would provide for increased density, but at a cost that currently would make that increased density uneconomic. It is felt that changes in current requirements, particularly related to Items 4 through 8, should be agreed on, and the impact of those changes measured, before any requirement for parking garages is hnposed. Certainly, economic incentives for providing parking structures would be beneficial in promoting their use. Mixture of Uses Clearly, a broad mix of uses is envisioned for the Town Center. This mix not only will exist in close proximity from building to building, but also within buildings as illustrated in Figure 24. Mixed Housing Types and Affordability As already indicated, single family detached homes are not expected, or certainly not expected to be a significant component, in the Town Center. However, a wide range of housing types is envisioned. Those types will potentially include attached single farm~ly, townhouses, multi-level rental apartments, multi-level for sale condominiums, and live-work units. This mix will provide a wide range in price and affordatnlity. It should be noted that the Town Center abuts Deerwood, a single family detached neighborhood, and Forest Springs, a mobile home neighborhood providing a high degree of affordabflgy. An example of how the various housing types may relate to one another is provided in Figure 25. Redevelopment Since the Town Center is currently undeveloped, redevelopment may seem to be irrelevant. However, current design should consider how future redevelopment, or additional development of existing sites that would provide for increased overall density, may be accomplished. Figure 26 illustrates how this may be accomplished. Site Planning That Respects Terrain As is typical of almost all areas of Albemarle County, the Town Center does have terrain issues that influences design. Thus, the number of east/west streets, or those mnniag perpendicular to the terrain, were minimized to reduce the amount of grading required. Other features such as the linear park were utilized to help the desired block pattern. The land use designations provide for the lowest density of development along 13 Powell Creek. Roof design shall mitigate the visual impact of larger scale structures and associated buildings, especially considering the general location of this area along a ridgeline. Additionally, designs that work with the terrain such as illustrated in Figure 22 will be used as site development occurs. Clear Boundaries with the Rural Areas Since the Town Center does not abut any Rural Area this principle is not applicable. However, the Powell Creek greenway will provide a buffer and clear edge between the Town Center and adjacent residential areas. The Town Center will nevertheless incorporate special environmental considerations. Regional storm water facilities are contemplated to serve multiple parcels within this portion Of the Hollymead Community. Exemplary specimen or old growth trees that may exist in this area will be preserved to the extent practicable. Area landscaping shall mini~rfize water requirements. TRANSPORTATION The future prospects and timing of the north/south parallel road originally proposed by VDOT are now uncertain. In the original proposal considered by the Board, grade separated vehicular crossings of Route 29 were recommended at Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive. The timing of grade separated and related improvements will not likely coincide with the commencement of development of the Town Center. Future planning and design should not preclude such desired improvements. Therefore, a Route 29 cross-over (median cut) and full movement traffic signal shall be supported for the main entrance to the Town Center (Mixed Use/Regional Service area). See Figure 14. For example, a cross-over at Route 29, between Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive shall be incorporated into the Town Center design, as shown on Figure 14. Until grade separated vehicular crossings of Route 29 at Timberwood Boulevard and Hollymead Drive are built, pedestrian and vehicular connectivity between the east and the west sides of Route 29 should be-accommodated by holding areas in the median, or by similar means. Alternative locations for crossings of Route 29 should be explored as part of VDOT's Route 29 improvement project(s), including linking a green way to the east side of Route 29. 14 LAN ~RKS & OPEN SPACE SYSTEM ~GIONAL SERVICE )MMUNITY SERVICE TY RESIDENTIAL u $ ROUTE 29 ~ ( PREUMINARY SITE PLAN IAN & ;TEMS ;T BIKE LANES [RPOSE PATH · INCLUDE SIDEWALKS STER PLAN STREETS 5 MTN~ WALKING RADIUS EROM NORTtt PUBLIC SPACE -'~5 MIN, WALKING RADIUS FROM INTERSECTION OF MAIN ST. & LINEAR PARK PUBLIC SPACE PRELIM[NARY SITE PLAN Table I - Town Center E~;~;mted Lam] ~velopment Density Land Use Residential Units Resk~entiat Units SqFt NomR~ SqFt Parks~Open 8pece Acrea Minimm Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total SqFt Tolat SqFt 0 0 Roads (Per Master Plan) 30 0 0 Urban Dens~y Re~(~mt~ 16 160 400 Mixed Use/C~ Service 58 36O 1,280 MEed Use/Regional Ser~ce 58 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 336,000 560,000 0 0 336,000 560,000 420,(300 1,792,030 174,~00 540,0D0 O O E~,296 757,944 505,296 757,944 Totals 180 520 1,680 756,(300 2,352,000 679,296 1,297,944 1,801,296 3,283,944 FAR (Total Land Area) FAR ( Total Net of Open Space/Roads) O.23 0.42 O.31 0.57 (1) The minimm tolal square feet is the~combination of minimum residential square feet and max~mm non-residential square f~et. The maximum total square feet is the combination of maximum residential square feet and minimum non-residential square feet. (2) The minimum resident~at'un~ in the Mixed Use/Communi{y Service assumes 18 acres developed ~lly, and 40 acres devetoped non-resk~ntially with perking requirements based on the area as a whole as opposed to individual sites. (3) The maximum residential unk's in the Mixed Use/Community Service assumes 18 acres developed residenlf~y, 50% of the grotmd floor space in the remaining 40 acres developed residentially, and 100% of the upper floor space in the remaining 40 acres developed residentially. Parking requira3qents are based on the 40 acre area as a whole as opp<~sed to indivuat sites. F Figure 1 -DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR SIDEWALKS, PEDESTRIAN PATHS & MULTI-USE PATHS Sidewalks Def'mifion: A sidewalk is a paved footpath, usually of concrete, parallel to a vehicular thoroughfare. Suggested application of Sidewalks · Sidewalks should be provided along all vehicular thoroughfares except high-speed, limited access highways. · Sidewalks should typically be separated from the roadway by a planting strip, except in commercial areas. · Sidewalks should typically be provided on both sides of a street, except where there is no development along one side of the street or where topography or vegetation precludes provision. · Sidewalk widths vary, depending on their use; the range generally extends from 4' to 18'. · In lower density residential areas, sidewalks should be wide enough to accommodate two people walking side by side (at least 4'). · In commercial areas, sidewalks should include the space commonly required for the planting strip and be at least 9 feet in widtk In higher density areas, sidewalks should be 15 to 18 feet in width. · Pedestrian crossings of roads should be provided a t grade, wherever possible, in marked pedestrian crossings to continue the paths across the street. Residential Area Sidewalks ? Commercial Area Sidewalks ? ? Figure I (Continued) Pedestrian Path Defmifion: A pedestrian path is an off-road path that connects places of activity. It is nsu- ally constructed of a material dilferent than con- crete, such as asphalt, stone dust, compacted gravel, mulch or bark When an impermanent surface is used, consideration should be given to the need for and appropriateness of accessibil- ity. ff wheelchair access is important to a desti~ nation, a permanent surface meeting ADA re- quirements should be provided. Suggested application of pedestrian paths · A pedestrian path may be used to connect neighborhoods together where a vehicular thoroughfare is either im- practical or unwarranted such as in a very low density area and where steep tcazain makes a sidewalk difficult to construct. · Pedestrian paths may be used as nature trails such as along a greenway · With an urban scale of development, pedestrian paths may be used to augment a sidewalk systcan when access to or through natural features is important. When augmenting a sidewalk system, pedestrian paths should con- neet directly with the sidewalk in places that support access through the development · Pedestrian paths through we'dands or on very steep slopes may have to be raised as a boardwalk. Appropriate at: Large open spaces, Multi-use Path Definition: An off-road accc~sway for pedes- trians, bicyclists and persons in wheelchairs, Such paths are generally paved and fairly wide to accommodate the different users of the paths at the same time. Suggested application of Multi-nse paths · Multi-use path should be used where high volume non-vehicular traffic is expected · Multi-use paths may be used to provide off-road connections between high activity areas such as a shopping center and a university center. · ' Multi-use paths may also be used ffdifferent medes of transport are anticipated in a neighborhood. · It may be necessary to separate groups or provide directional information on a multi-use path through the use of smping. Appropriate at: High activity areas, recreational areas, school yards and large parks Figure 2 - DESIGN GUIDEL~S FOR BIKE LANES, ROUTES & PATHS B~keways Detrmition: A bike way is pm-t of a safe, con- venient, well marked and easily understood network that may include both on and off- mad mutes. Features: · A bike lane is a marked lane of a mad- way for the exclusive use of cyclists. · A bike path is an off-road asphalt path used for both recreation and travel · A bike route is a signed or unsigned area of any low-volume thoroughfare where cyclists feel comfortable sharing the roadway with automobiles. · The local thoroughfare network should supply the vast majority of low-vohime, low-speed routes for cyclists directly on thc pavement, allowing cycling to daily activities. · In the rare instances where abutting cul-de-sacs are developed they should have a cycle-path connectio~ A continuous local street system parallel to arterial streets is a preferred option for cyclists rather than providing cycle lanes or separate paths on arterial roads. · On thoroughfares with projected traffic volumes of more than 3,000 vehicle trips per day (serving over 300 residences) and near schools where long-distance commuter and recreational cycling are undertaken, lanes should be marked specifically for bicycles. Bicycle Route Figure 3 - BOULEVARD AS TAKEN FROM THE NEIGHBORHOOD MODEL Boulevard Definition: A boulevard is a multi-lane thorouglffare separated by several medians. A boulevard could transform a highway on the Fringe of a Development Area into an urban street in a General Area or Center. Features of Boulevards: Suggested speed limit is 35 mph. Side median.q can separate slower traffic and parking activity from thc through-traffic in the ccatcr lanes. This arrangement creates an alternative to the "strip highway," by allowing building frontages, sidewalks and pe- destrian activity up to the right of way. Suggested locations: Centers, Cores and where neighborhoods adjoin. Figure 4 - MODIFIED BOULEVARD Modified Boulevard Definition: The Modified Boulevard is a multi.lane thoroughfare separated by medians. This application illus- trates the omission of side median.q and parking separating thc boulevard from building frontages. Features of Modified Boulevards: · Suggested speed limit is 35 mpk · No parking is permitted at the curb of either side of the modified boulevard Suggested locations: Centers, Cores and where neighborhoods adjoim Figure 5 - MAIN STREET (Commercial Street) Definition: A main street or commercial street accommodates two-way traffic and parallel parking Features of Main Streets: · Main Streets have raised curbs and closed storm drainage. · Sidewalks are adjacent to curbs at a typical width of 10 - 18 feet which may be reduced in predominantly resi- dential areas. · Trees can block views to storcfronts and are therefore not always desirable. When used, they should be in planters and have clear minks and high cano- pies. A single species generally should be used and a series should be planted in ali~tmmenL · Street furniture is desirable · Suggested speed limit is 15 - 25 mph. Suggested locations: Centers and Cores 7' Figure 6 - NEIGI~BORltOOD STREET OR ROAD Definition: A neighborhood street or road is a local slow-movement thoroughfare. A neighborhood street is urban in character and a road is rural in character. Features of Main Streets: · Streets have an "urban" cross section which includes curb, gutter, street trees, and sidewalks. Streets are used to establish an "urban form" which supports urban densities. · Parallel parking is allowed. · Building fronts are aligned with small setbacks. · Drainage system is close& · Suggested speed limit is 20 mph. Figure 7- WAY Definition: A way is narrower tan a street or mad; it is designed for 'hfield "movements. Features of Main Ways: · Suggested speed limit is 15 mph. · The may be one- or two-way. · They axe never striped · One car must pull over to allow for oncoming traffic to pass. · Ways are appropriate for minor neighborhood streets; however, they should extend for no more than two to three continuous blocks before ending at a T-intersecfiom Suggested locations: Fringes and General Areas; at Centers on a limited basis. Figure 8 - Alley Definition: 'An alley is a narrow access at the rear of lots providing for service areas and access to parking and utility easements. Alleys accommodate yield 'movement. Features of Commercial Alleys: Commercial alleys have no sidewalks and little landscaping. · They should be paved to accommodate tracks and dumpsters. · Inverted crowns provide for center drainage in alleys. Appropriate locations: Centers and Cores Features of Residential Afleys: · Residential alleys have no sidewalks. · They should accommodate low-lying landscaping. · The surface may be paved or, tn low density areas, gravel. · The surface should be 10 - 14 feet tn width with a right-of-way of 20 - 24 feet tn order to accommodate utility eflF~melll[S. Garages and fences may be built a thc right-of-way line. Suggested locations: Fringes and General Areas Figure 9- THE CURVILINEAR GRID PATTERN Definition: Thc curvilincar grid pattern is a modified grid that more easily adapts to the terrain.. It can be used with new and existing development pat- terns. Thoroughfares are cm~ed and nm ,~11, el to the to- pography to accommodate moderately sloped terrain_ A variety of lots can be accommodated and designed. A hierarchy of thoroughfares can pr yeidc for architec- tural treatments on comers for highe Alleys are loaded on both sides, pr in infrastructure. Curving streets can provide another ual interest Paths (with stairways and ramps) mid-block where grades prevent vel~ Cm~ilinear blocks can be challengi of lots for townhouses and are more It may reduce the character of sloPi alleling it It can result in asymmetrical stree! downhill houses with retaining walb Figure 10- THE GREENWAY Deirmition: A greenway is a corridor follows a natural feature such as a stre plain, or swale. It may also follow the doned road or railroad bcd. It usually pedestrians and/or bicycles. r design speeds. ~viding efficiency way to create vis- may be included calar access. ag to the creation difficult to plmL ag terrain by par- with uphill and open space that aa valley, flood- path of an aban- }ntains a path for · It can extend between villages and neighborhoods as well as through them, connecting the countryside to urban parks and squares. It is desirable that greenways lead to destinations. · At narrower areas, buildings should front the green- way which may be framed by thoroughfares. At wider areas, buildings may back onto it. Where pti- vacy is desired, screening should be provided at the rear yards. · Landscaping for greenways should be appropriate to the locafion~ More formal landscaping would be ex- pected within neighborhoods; more natural lamtscap- lng would be expected between neighborhoods.. · Greenways generally follow natural features but can begin and end a Centers in the urban area. Figure 11 - THE SQUARE Definition: The Square is a public space usually no larger than a block at the intersection of significant thoroughfares used primar- ily for civic purposes. Buildings can front it on all sides. Features: · Its landscape consists of lawns, paved walks, trees and civic buildings. All of these features are formally disposed and requffe regular maintenance.. · Generally, squares are relatively flat with slopes no greater than 6°/~ · On occasion, a square may abut Greens or a Greenway. It may provide a civic terminus to a natural feature. · Squares may be surrounded by buildings with commercial or residential uses on the ground floor. Figure 12- THE PLAZA Little Del'tuition: A Plaza is a public space that is generally less than half the size of a block located at the intersection of important thoroughfares, It is devoted to civic uses and commercial activity and is surrounded by buildings on all sides. ~ Features: · Its landscape is composed primarily of durable pavement and trees formally planted within the paving in grates. maintenance is requirec[ ~, · Plazas are flat, except in rare circmustances. ] · On occasion, Pla~an may be open on one end towards a view. · Plazas are dominated by commercial and civic activity on the "---ll ground floor. Figure 13- THE POCKET PARK Del'tuition: a pocket park is a small park that often is a piece of leftover space that a conventional suburban development would have privatized or placed into someone's backyard. Features: · A Packet Park's ~hape varies, but it is always less than 1/2 block in length. · Landscape features of a Pocket Park will vary. · Pocket Parks can contain tot lots or be passive park area~ · Maintenance is performed privately ff owned by a Homeown- ers Association, If the space fronts on a major thomu~mhfare, it is maintained publicly. \X Figure 14- MIXED USE/REGIONAL SERVICE CENTER Figure 15 - ARCHITECT~ TREATMENTS OF BUILDINGS Definition: An architectural treatment primarily ~. · . designed to promote retail activity, the shop front downtown buildings, this architectural treatment allows pedestrians to walk right to the edge of a building ffthey choose in order to window shop. Location of front fagade build-to-line: The front faqade build-to-line is at or near the edge of the fight-of-way. The entrance to the building is · It can be used for retail buildings with residences or offices on upper floors · It can accommodate an awning or cantilevered signage. · It is not appropriate for single-family detached usage because ils benefit is to invite large amounts of pedes- trian traffic. Suggested locations: Centez% general and retail areas Colonnade Front-Commercial Front Definition: An arehitecttwal treatment promoting retail activity, second stories of buildings over- hang the sidewalk and are supported by cohmms, The colnmn.~ enclose the space of the sidewalk within a colonnade. Location of front fagade build-to-line: The front faqade build-to-line is within the fight-of- - way. The building is recessed on the first floor to allow for a sidewalk. The second story is lo- cated over the sidewalk. The sidewalk should be completely absorbed within the colonnade to pre- vent pedestrians from bypassing iL The entrance to the building is at the property line. Features: · It is appropriate for retail use an~ for civic buildings. · It requires special permission for placing structures in thc right-of-way. · It is not appropriate for single-family detached residential use because its benefit is to invite large amounts of pedestrian tmffic. Suggested locations: Centers, mixed uses and retail areas 7 Figure 15 - ARCltITECTURAL TREATMENTS OF BUILDINGS (Continued) Dooryard Front-Residential or Commercial From - Uphill & Downhill Detrmifion: An architectural treatment providing for a paved or landscaped surface between the right-<fi-way and front faqade. Location of front fagade build-to-line: The front fa- qade build-to-line is-10-15 feet from the edge of the fight-of-way. Within this yard is a landscaped are& The main entrance to the building is either several feet higher than the street or several feet lower, depending on the terrain. Features: It is appropriate for residential or commercial uses in an 'hnban" setting. · It can provide an elevated lawn, garden, or terrace in the area between the street and the door on the uphill side. · It can be effectively used for retail bn~qinesses. · It can also be used for ground floor residences in single family houses, townhonses, or apartment buildings. · In areas of steeply sloping terrain, it may be set as high as 4 feet above or below the sidewalk to absorb some of the grade. · When used on the downhill side, the area can provide for a mnken "light court" between the sidewalk and the building. · When used on the downhill side, the lower levels can provide for residential uses, retail uses, or office spaces. · Use of the-dooryard front may occur as uphill and downhill sides on opposite sides of the street. Suggested locations: Centers, mixed use and general areas Stoop Front-Residential Front . Definition: An architectural treatment that provides an urban front yard acceptable for ground floor resi- dential use. The "stoop" is a small staircase that pro- vides a "walk-ap" to the first floor of the residence. Privacy from pedestrians walking by the house is as- sured by raising the first floor, while the stoop pro- vides an "outdoor seat" for the residea~ts. Location of front fagade build-to-line: The front facade build-to-line is 0-I0 feet from the right-of-way. The entrance to the building is at least 3 feet higher than the grade of the sidewalk to assure visual privacy for windows. Features: · It accommodates ground-floor residential uses including single family attached and detached homes, town- houses and apartment buildings. · Buildings using Stoop Front may be intermingled with buildings using the Shop Front · Houses designed with Stoop Fronts' generally do not provide off-street parking and are and are accessed from a sidewalk · A stoop front can be used with a "side yard" or "Charleston ho~e", which is entel~l off of a side garde~ When used in this way, the front yards are generally diminished as 0-$ feet. Suggested locations: Centem, mixed uses and retail arms Figure 16- BUILDING FRONTING TWO MAJOR STREETS MAJOR STREET Figure 17 - BUILDING AT MAJOR/MINOR STREETS MINOR STREET Figure' 18 - ANCILLARY STRUCTM ON MINOR STREET MINOR STREET Figure 19 - SIDE YARD SETBACK OF CORNER STRUCTURE CONSISTENT WITH FRONT YARD SETBACK ON SECONDARY STREET MINOR STREET Figure 20- SPATIAL ENCLOSURE Spatial Enclosure of 2:1 increasing to 3:1 as building height increases Spatial Enclosure of 3:l with trees to maintain the street edge Shopping Center Parking with trees to provide spatial definition Figure 21- RELEGATED PARK/NG I i ri I l I I 1 I I I, ~, PARK1N~ P~KIN~i PARKINd Figure 22- TUCK UNER PARKING Figure 23 - ILLUSTRATION OF SHARED PARKING BETWEEN SITES 220 Residential Spaces ~ 60% yields 132 spaces for office use during weekday office hours or an additional 26,400 gross square feet of office space. Figure 24 - MIXED USE WITHIN BUILDINGS Figure 25- HOW VARYING HOUSING TYPES MAY RELATE For Sale Condominiums Townhouses Rental Apartments Figure 26 - ALLOWING FOR EXPANSION Phase 1--AH surface parking 7 Phase 2--Adding 50,000 to 75,000 square feet by adding a parking garage. SEPTEMBER 5, ~EO01 CLOSED SESSION -MOTION I MOVE THAT THE BOARD O0 INTO CLOSED SESSION PURSUANT TO SECTION ;2, I -344(A) OF THE CODE OF VIRGINIA · UNDER SUBSECTION (I ) TO CONSIDER APPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS; · UNDER SUBSECTION (7) TO CONSULT WITH LEGAL COUNSEL AND STAFF REGARDING PROBABLE LITIGATION AND OTHER SPECIFIC LEGAL MATTERS RELATING TO THE IVY LANDFILL ; AND · UNDER SUBSECTION (7) TO CONSULT WITH LEGAL COUNSEL AND STAFF REGARDING PROBABLE LITIGATION RELATING TO A PUBLIC SAFETY INCIDENT. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE MEMORANDUM TO: Members of the Board of Supervisors FROM: Laurie Bentley, C.M.C. ~.// "~ Senior Deputy Clerk ~~ DATE: August 30, 2001 RE: Applications for Boards and Commissions I have attached applications received for current vacancies on the Architectural RevieW Board. I have also attached the application you will need as you interview one person for the vacancy on the Historic Preservation Committee on September 5. Thank you. Attachments cc: Bob Tucker Larry Davis County of Albemarle Office of Board of County Supervisors 401 Mcinti~e Road Charlottesv~le, VA 229024596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD/COMMISSION/COMMII"rEE (Please type or print.) Board/Commission/Committee Architectural Review Board Applicant's Name Richard R. Abidin Full Home Address 5192 Coventry Lane, Barboursville, VA 22923-1618 Home Phone 804-978-4955 Magisterial District in which your home residence is located Rivanna Employer Management Services Cor~ration Business Address Post Office Box 5306, Charlottesville, VA 22905 Phone 804-9774181 Occupation/Tide Construction Manager Years Resident in Albemarle County 36 Previous Residence 860 Buckhorn Trail. Earlysville, VA 22936 Date of Employment Spouse's Name Christine Number of Children 12/03/1996 One Education (D%~ree~ and Graduation Dates.) James Madison University 1983 B. S. Psychology Memberships in Fraternal, Business Church and/or Social Groups Church of the Incarnation, The Red-Land club Public. Civic and Charitable Office and/or Other Activities or Interests Paramount Restoration Committee, Coventry HOA President & Chair Architectural Review, Earlysville Forest HOA President, Senate Page Virginia General Assembly, Fund raising Heart Association Reason(s) for Wishing to Serve on this Board/Commission/Committee Concerned with maintaining the quality of onr community. Feel that my experiences working for a state wide developer hiring architects & engineers and Waveling the state where I have seen examples of both good and bad develonments will benefit mv oosifion on this board. Th~rmation provided on this application will be released to the public upon request Signature Date 0g-05-2001 Return m: Clerk, Board of County Supervisors Albemarle County 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902- 4596 FAX: (804) 296-5800 08-06-01 Pt2:14 ~N County of Albemarle Office of Board of County SupetwLsors 401 MclntLre Road Charlottesville, VA 22902~4596 ¢04) 206-$S43 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD/COMMISSlON/COMMITT~ (Please ripe or print.) Architectural Review Board Board/Commi.qsion/Commi~e. Applicanfs Name Charles T. Lebo HomePhone Fu~HomeAd&ess 370 Mallard Lane; Earlysville, Va. 22936 975-391 5 Magisterial District ha which your home residence is located R i o En~loyer Lebo Commercial Properties, Inc. Phone 973-1977 Bus~essAddress 684 Berkmar Circle; Charlottesville, Va. 22901 Ocmpaton/Tide Commercial Real Estate Broker/Owner DateofEmployment 1987 Years Resident in Albemarle Counry 1 4 Spouse's Name Robin G. Lebo Previous Residence 2133 Timber Pointe Rd. Chville, VA .Number of Children 2 Educafion .(Degrees and Graduafion Dates) Major: Political Science - 2 years at Edinboro State Univ. and 2 years at Univ. of Pittsburgh 1969-1973 Memberships ha Fraternal, BushaesmChurchand/orSochtGroups Past board member Skyline Council of Va. Girl Scouts; Member National Wildlife Fed.; (Cont_inued on .addendum_) Public. Civic and. Charitable Office and/or OtherAcfivifies or Interests Chairman North Charlottesville .. Business Council'; Past Pres. Blue Ridge Home Builders Assoc.; (Cont.) Reason(s) for VdshMg to Seine on this Board/Com~fission/Comn~ee See attached addendum The k~fo~ation provide_d~ application w~l be released to the public upon request. SitTmure Dare Return to: Clerk, Board of County Supervisors Albom~rl~ County 401Mclutire Road C]lado~ VA 229O24596 FAX: (804) 296-5800 Charles T. Lebo 370 Mallard Lane Earlysville, va. 22936 July 16, 2001 Addendum to application Architectural Review Board Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Memberships in Fraternal, Business, Church and/or Social Group.s.: Past Religion Education Director Church of the Incarnation, member World Wildlife Fund, member of National Wildlife Federation, member Charlottesville area Chamber of Commerce, member US Chamber of Commerce, member of International Council of Shopping Centers. Public, Civic and Charitable Office and/or Other activities or Interests: Past Virginia National Representative to National Association of Home Builders, past chairman Parade of Homes Blue Ridge Home Builders Assoc., past Board member Charlottesville- Albemarle Chamber of Commerce, Chairman Trees for Rt 29, Co-founded Charlottesville-Albemarle Clean Community Commission (C-AC3), Co-directed Gulf War appreciation parade. Also assisted fund drives for the following orgamzations: Toylift, Focus, SPCA, Albemarle County Police, Girl Scouts, Boy Scouts, United Way, American Heart Assoc. and the Senior Center. Reasons for Wishing to Serve on this Board: I have been an active member of this community since moving here over 25 years ago. Having also lived on Hilton Head Island for ~tbout 3 years I have come to appreciate the advantages and rewards of living in locales where development with aesthetics can be a balanced aspect of a communit3~. I have managed the Rio Hill Shopping Center since it wasbuilt 13 years ago and take pride in its appearance. I also manage the Berkmar Crossing business park for its owners and consider it to be one of the best maintained complexes in the County. My wife and I own several properties in Albemarle County, hence, [ have a vested interest in preserving the charming ambience offered here. I am a firm believer in giving back to the community and am confident that I can make a solid contribution to the ARB given my experience and background. Thank you for your consideration. County of Albemarle Office o£Board of County Supervisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 229024596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD/COMMISSION/COMMITTEE (please type or ptitm) Board/Commission/Committee ~! f ~,L [ ./-"~' ~ -~2~ Full Home Address ~ { ~7 ~ ~p~'~'~ &~ ~t ~ Magisterial Distdct in which your home residence is located Employer 5-~ l 0-- ~hone Home Phone Business Address Occupation/Tide ~ ~ ~ ~ ~' Years Resident in Albemarle County Previous Residence Education (Degrees and Graduation Dates) Date of Employment Spouse's Name .) ~' ~ Number of Children Memberships in Fraternal. Business, Church and/or Social Groups ~-'-~-- ~ t~ i Public, Civic and Charitable Office and/or Other Activities or Interests Reason(s) f0r Wishing to Serve ,on this Board/Commission/Committee bo~.~_~_ i, ~ A.:s%~-.'~/ o ~---_ Thegn provided on this application will be released to the public upon request. Signature / Return to: Clerk, Board of County Supe~isom Albemarle County 401 bic~ntite Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 FAX~ (804) 2%4800 Z NEW TERM EXPIRE DATE APPLICANT INTERVIEW, IF SCHEDULED Richard P~ Abidin T. Lowry Abell 1:00 p.m. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Members of the Board of Supervisors Laurie Bentley, C.M.C./~/// Senior Deputy Clerk ~ August 31,200I Vacancies or~ Boards and Commissions I have updated the list of vacancies on boards and commissions through December 31, 2001. In addition, it was the consensus at the Board's August 15 meeting that I provide information regarding staggered terms. I have.attached a chart (on yellow paper) which lists each Board, Committee, and Commission for which I am responsible, including length of.term and the number of terms an appointee can serve. Thank you. Cc: Bob Tucker Larry Davis Chamber of Commerce From: EJla Washington Carey, CMC_~J~ Subje~ Reading fist For September 5, 2~i Date: August 31,2001 March 2 t (A), 200 I April 25, 2001 May 9, 2001 July II, 2001 Ms. Thomas Ms. Thomas Pages 28 - end - Mr. Martin Pages t- 17 (end at Item # I I) - Mr. Dorrier /ewc