Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1998-03-04 · Fl NAL · 9:00 .A.M. MlkRClt 4, 1998 ROOM 241, COUNTY OFFICE BUiLI)IN(; 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8~ 11. 12. 13. 13a. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. Call to Order. Pledge of Allegiance. Moment of Silence. Other Matters Not Listed on the Agenda from the PUBLIC. Presentation of Certificates of Appreciation. Consent Agenda (on next sheet). Approval of Minutes: April 10 and November 6, 1996. Transportation Matters: a) Discussion: Statement to be presented at the FY 1998 Preallocarion Hearing on the Interstate, Primary and Urban Systems Plan. b) Other Transportation Matters. Request to set a public hearing to amend the jurisdictional areas of the Albemarle County Service Authority to provide water and sewer service to the proposed Fontana Subdivision. 10:00 a.m. - PUBLIC HEARING on an Ordinance to amend and reordain Chapter 8, Finance and Taxation of the Albemarle County Code by amending §8-66, time Limits for appeals of Real Estate Assessments which shall establish time limits for appeals of real estate assessments: Adopt Resolution to designate Whitewood Park property as Open-Space Land under Open-Space Land Act. Discussion: Dance Hall Ordinance and Request for Permit to Operate Dance Hall. Discussion: Information Services Technology Planning Report. hrtroduction of Doug Morris, Superintendent, Shenandoah National Park. Board Briefing on FY 1999 Budget. Executive Session: Appointments to Boards and Commissions, and Legal Matters. Certify Executive Session. Appointments. Other Matters not Listed on the Agenda from the BOARD. 3:15 p.m. - ZMA-97-01. Still Meadows (Signs 63&64). PUBLIC HEARING on a request to rezone approx 142 acs from R-1 toPRD w/max of 150 lots. Loc at end of Northfields Rd. Access proposed to both Northfields Rd Sc Carrsbrook Dr. TM46,P21 Sc TM45B2,P2 (part of) Sc 4 (part of ). [The property is recommended for Neighborhood Density (3-6 du/ac) in Neighborhood 2 of the Comp Plan.] Rio Dist. (Applicant requests deferral to March 4, 1998.) 4:00 p.m. - Appeal: SDP-97-110. Ivy Landfill Final Site Plan. Adjourn. CON SENT A (~'E N D A FOR APPROVAL: 6.1 Set a public hearing for March 18, 1998, for approval of sanitary sewer easement across County- owned property (TM 91-2 ) near Monticello High School. 6.3 Resolution in support of Passenger Rail Service to Bristol, Virginia. FOR INFORMATION: 6.4 Comprehensive Services Act (CSA) Supplemental Ftmding Request. 6.5 December 1997 Financial Report. 6.6 Copy of Monthly Bond and Program Report for Arbor Crest Apartments (Hydraulic Road Apts) for the month of February, 1998. ACTIONS Board of Supervisors Meeting of March 4, 1998 March 6, 1998 6.1 6.2 6.3 g.a 8.b 9 10 11 12 17 AGENDA ITEM Set PH, Sewer easement near Monticello High School Procedure for BOS minutes (removed from agenda) Resolution, passenger rail service to Bristol. VA (adopted) FYI 998 Preallocation heating discussion Other trahsportation matters Set PH to amend jurisdictional areas of ACSA Fontana Subdivision PH on Ordinance to amend limits for appeals of Real Estate Assessments (adopted) Resolution, designate Whitewood Park as Open-space Land (adopted) Discussion, Dance Hall Ordinance Appoinmaents --Messrs. Larry L. Miller and Jeffi'ey Sobel, Ms. Meredith Strom-Gunter and ASSIGNMENT Clerk: Advertise PH for March 18, 1998 BOS:Discusswith~aff Clerk: Prepare f'mal resolution, forward copy to legislators Planning: Add list of northern area projects m statement, add statement about freight and rail passenger service, and correct t3pos noted. Ask VDoT to advise public of all task force meefmgs. Reserve car pool vehicle, if necessary, for Board members. Clerk: Ask BOS who will attend, then advise Planning if car pool vehicle is necessary. A. Tucker: Look into mud and gravel problems on Rt. 615 A. Tucker: Follow-up with County Attorney on local re~-mlations on air brakes Clerk: Advertise PH for April 1 Clerk: Prepare resolution, forward to appropriate persons Clerk: Prepare resolution, forward to appropriate persons County Exec Staff: Prepare draft showing proposed Ordinance after meeting with police officials, examining curfew and talking with other localities Clerk: Prepare appointment letters, update Boards & Commissions files 18 19 20 Ms. Maria Bell to the Commission on Children and Families --Mr. Albert Humbertsom, Jr. to the Equalization Board Other matters from the Board -Agreement between Town of Scottsville and the County pertaining to Deputy Sheriffs (approved) --Set PH for March 18, 1998 on Community Development Block Grant Program Community Improvement Grant to Support Microenterprise ZMA-97-01, Still Meadows (approved as proffered, dated Febraary 27,1998, attachment A) Appeal: SDP-97-110, Ivy landfill Final Site Plan (see motion, attachment B) Clerk: Obtain County Attorney's signature, send originals to Town of Scottsville, Sheriff Hawkins, and Board file, cc to R. Huff Clerk:AdvertisePH Planning: Investigate making the detailed Master End Use Plan a part of the Comprehensive Plan /lbh Distribution list: Bob Tucker Rick Huff Roxanne White Kevin Castner Wayne Cilimberg Larry Davis Bill Mawyer Amelia McCulley Bruce Woodzell Attachments: 2 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Office of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, V~rginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins Wh~ Hal Sally H. Thomas March 6, 1998 Mrs. Angela G. Tucker Resident Engineer 701 VDoT Way Charlottesville, VA 22911 Dear Mrs. Tucker: At its meeting on March 4, 1998, the Board of Supervisors made the following comments regarding transportation matters: Agenda Item No. 8.a. FY 1998 Preallocation Hearing on the Interstate, Primary and Urban Systems Plan Mrs. Humphris asked that VDoT begin publicizing all Task Force meetings on the Rt. 29 South Corridor Study so that the public can attend. Agenda Item No. 8.b Other Transportation Matters You said you would look the problem with mud and gravel on Route 615. You said you would follow up with the County Attorney on local regulations on air brakes. /lbh cc: Robert W. Tucker, Jr. Sincerely, a ~. Carey, C~C~ / Printed on recycled paper COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Request to advertise fora public hearing for approval of sanitary sewer easement to Hill~est Land Trust SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Request to advertise for a public hearing for approval of sanitary sewer easement across County-owned property (TMP 91-2) near Monticello High School. STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Huff, Kelsey, Davis, Trank .AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: X ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Yes BACKGROUND: TMP 77-47, owned by Hillcrest Land Trust, was rezoned to Planned Development Shopping Center (PD-SC) and the developer is preparing design plans for the proposed shopping center to be constructed at that site. The proposed shopping center would be served by public water and sewer. The only available connection to anexisfing sanitary sewer manhole is located on the Lakeside Apartments property. This requ!res that the proposed sanitary sewer extension cross either parcel TMP 77-43, owned by Calvary Baptist Church, or the County-owned property. The Purchase Agreement for the Monticello High School property contains a provision that states that the County agrees to grant "utility" easements necessary to provide utility service to certain other parcels owned by the sellers (including TMP 77-47), but a separate provision dealing with sanitary sewer easements does not specifically obligate the County to grant such easements. The '20' wide sanitary sewer easement, as shown on the attached plat and sketch, runs along the property line and, according to the Engineering and Public Works Department. will not have a negative impact upon future development of the County parcel. Va. Code § 15.2-1800(B) requires the Board of Supervisors to hold a public hearing prior to conveying any interest in County-owned property, including easements. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that a public hearing be advertised and set for March 18, 1998 to consider granting the proposed sanitary sewer easement. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS 98.02g ~EXIST-tNG MM TAX NAP 77. PARCEL 44 LAKESIDE APARTNENTS EXISTING TO 38.98 N84°52 26"E CALVARY BAPTIST CHURCH TAX NAP 77, PARCEL 43 TAX NAP ga. PARCEL i: :'J ~PROPOSED IRON S33°39'24'W %, r ,/~ TAX NAP 77, PARCEL 47 HILLCREST L.L.C. SANITARY SEWER EASEMENT -2. PLAT SHOWING PROPOSED 20' ~tIDE SANITARY SE~IER EASEI~EN% ACROSS PARCEL ~, SHEET g! AND PARCEL 44. SHEET ??. TAX MAPS SCALE: ~" -- §0.00 ALBEMARLE COUNTY. VIRGINIA FEBRUARY ~6. ~ggB B. AUBREY HUFFMAN ~9 AS$OCZATE$. LTD. CIVIL ENGINEERING - LANO SURVEYING - L~NI? PLANNING CHAR/0 T TES VIL L E, ' . VIRGINIA COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Members of the Board of Supervisors Ella W. Carey, CMC. Clerk~ February 26, 1998 Minutes of Board of Supervisor meetings Currently the Clerk's office prepares detailed minutes of the Board of Supervisors meetings. While this has been effective in providing an almost verbatim account of each meeting, it is extremely time consuming and does not allow adequate time for the Board office to operate efficiently or attend to other required tasks. Staff, therefore, proposes that the Clerk be allowed to condense the information contained in Board minutes. The Clerk's office has been downsized from a three frill-time employee office to a two fnll-time employee office in an effort to streamline costs and operate more efficiently. With part of the savings, the Board office contracts for part-time derical support to help with minute preparation. Since 1985 the Board minutes have been current only when the office has been staffed by three full-time employees. The minutes currently prepared contain all votes, resolutions, etc., and a complete discussion of all conversations, While detailed minutes provide all the conversational material, they are time intensive, expensive and take valuable time away from other administrative duties. For each set of detailed minutes, staff prepares an outline which includes motions, conditions and executive sttmmaries, and then transcribes the conversations into the outline. Minutes are then edited and forwarded to the County Attorney for review for legal compliance. Any revisions are incorporated into the minutes and then forwarded to the Board for approval. During 1997. the Board held 42 meetings which consisted of 157 hours of open session. Attachment (E) is asa example of detailed minutes. It requires four hours for each hour of meeting time to transcribe detailed minutes. With 157 hours in meetings, approximately 988.50 total hours are required to complete the minutes at a cost of $19,638.08. The chart on Attachment (A) is a break down of the cost for this type of minutes. Staff proposes srreanflining the process of preparing minutes to reduce staff time and allow for needed indexing, to respond more timely to citizen and staff requests, and to perform other administrative duties. Two other formats are currently used in localities throughout the Commonwealth: action minutes and sununary format. Action Minutes: Action minutes provide an outline of actions taken at a meeting which would include the votes, resolutions and ordinances. Action minutes would not include the ex~ecutive summaries or any conversations. It would take staff approximately 45 minutes for Peach hour of meeting time to prepare a set of action minutes. Since action minutes contain tuffy meeting actions, they would require less proofreading and fewer revisions. It would talce approximately 118 hours, at a cost of $2,379.62, to complete 157 hours of meeting time. The Memo To: Board of Supervisors Date: February 26, 1998 Page 2. County Attorney's review would also require less time. Attachment (C) provides an example of a set of action minutes. Action minutes could be available for Board approval at the next Board meeting. Please remember that tapes of all meetings are always available for future detailed references when needed. SummaW Minutes: Summary minutes include the votes, resolutions, ordinances and a brief summarization of the meeting discussion. Building on the action minutes, it takes an additional hour, or a total of one mad three-fourth hours for each hour of meeting time, depending on the content of the meeting. With 157 hours of meeting time. it would require 552.75 hours of staff time to prepare these minutes, a savings of 435.75 hours from the detailed minutes (see Attachment A). The cost savings is approximately $10,334.71. Staff would still be required to edit and then forward the minutes to the County Attorney. Summary minutes could be available for Board review within two weelcs of the meeting. Attachment {D) shows an example of stunmary minutes. The portions that are different from detailed lninutes are highlighted. Other costs that must be factored in are minute books and copying charges. Historically it tai~es four minute books for each year of detailed minutes. Each minute book contains 500 pages and costs $400 (see Attachment A). Condensing the minutes would reduce the number of required minute books, as well as the space needed to house the minute boo/cs. Since tape recordings of all the meetings are permanently maintained, the Board. citizens and staff would always have access to full conversations of the meetings, if necessary. The Clerk's ofllce receives, at the most, one request from a staff person or citizen during any ~given week for a full set of minutes. Should any Board member request a verbatim transcript of a particular ~ubject. one could be prepared. Attached (B) is a summary, of i~fformation from ten localities throughout Virginia on their minute preparation. Six of the localities prepare action minutes: three summarize the discussions and one prepare a detailed discussion. A survey of the Clerlcs at a recent meeting Of the Virginia Municipal Clerks Association indicated that action minutes are the most prevalent throughout the state. The County Attorney has indicated that the legal requirements for minutes only mandate that there be a record of the votes made by each member of the Board for appropriations and the adoption of ordinances mad resolutions. Records of actual discussions ~/nd comments are not required, only the actual motion. Therefore, at least legally, the detail in recording minutes is discretionary (see Attachment F). Staff recommends that the Board permit staff to begin preparing summary minutes of all Board meetings rather than the more lengthy detailed minutes currently being done. This change would be more cost-effective, would free up needed staff time for other responsibilities and would enable the Board to receive minutes in a more timely manner. Should the Board n~embers prefer the action minutes, staff would also be prepared to complete minutes in that format. Thank you for your consideration, /ewc Attachments (6) COST ANALYS~ PROCESS DETAILED MINUTES' SUMMARY MINUTES ACTION MINUTES HOURS COST HOURS COST HOURS COST Outline 118 tzrs $ 2,528.74 118 hrs $ 2,528.74 Not required Tape Transcription 628 hfs $ 9,790.52 274.75 hfs $ 2,283.35 118 Ins $1,839.62 Proofread and edit 236 hrs $ 5,057.48 157 hfs $ 3,364.51 Minimal, if needed County Attorney review See note below Revisions 6.5 hfs $ 101.34 3hrs $ 46.77 Not requfred Board approval Minute Books $1,600.00 $ 800.00 $ 400.00 Copycosts $ 560.00 $ 280.00 $ 140.00 TOTALS 988.50 brs $19,638.08 552.75 hfs $9,303,37 llShrs $2,379.62 FACTORS USED INTHECHART 1) 2) 3) ]'he analysis is based on an entire year o£minutes-- 42 meetings and 157 hours ofmeeting time dm:rog 1997. Ike HOURS column is the average number of hours it takes to complete that task. l'he COST colunur is the cost of salary and benefits of the Clerk or Deputy Clerk to complete that task at $21.43 per hour and ~15.59 per hour. respectively. In preparing this analysis, the salary for the Deputy Clerk was used for transcription and revisIng the minutes. The Clerk also prepares minutes, but her salary was not used for this analysis. FACTORS USED TO DETERMINE FIGURES FOR DETAILED MINUTES 1) Outline- It takes approximately 45 minutes for each hour of meeting to prepare an outline of the minutes. 2) Transcription - It takes four hours for each hour of meeting time to compose a detailed set of minutes and one and three-fourths hour of meeting t/me to prepare summary minutes. 3) Proofread and edit - It takes approximatel) one and one-half hours to proofread and edit detailed minutes and approximately one hour to proofread and edit summary mmares. 4) the County Attorney reviews all minutes for data relevant to legal issues. Based on the length of the meeting, he spends from 15 to 30 minutes reviewing the information. 6) Revisions - At the most it takes 15 minutes to make corrections from the County Attorney. 7) Minute Books - Each minute book costs $400. It takes four minute books for one year of minutes. 8) Copy costs - Each minute book contains 500 sheets of paper. Seven sets of all minutes are made for distribution. Each page costs four cents. ATTACHMENT A SURVEY OF VIRGINIA LOCALITIES LOCALITY MINUTE DATA Chesterfield County' Detailed d/scussions of all topics City of V£rginia Beach No discussion; include staffreports, ordinances, resolutions and motions. They also prepare a transcript for the file of any couU'oversial issue. County of Fauqmer No discussion; brief statement of the item being discussed; motions and conditions. County of Henrico No discussion; motion and conditions; separate book to contain resolutions & ordinances. City of Portsmouth No discussion; motions and conditions City of Rictzmund No discussion: List people who spoke and one sentence stating thek position; include motions. ordinances/resolutions City of Fairfax Summary of discussion County of Spotsylvarl.ia Brief discussion of issue; include motions County of Fairfax County ofLoudon No discussion; only statement included is if someone made it "for the record": include motions No discussion; motions action NOTE: The localities that do not include discussions of the meetings, file the/r audio tapes permanently. ]'hey also prepare transcripts when necessary. ATTACHMENT B March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 13 A regular meeting of the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, was held on March 12, 1997, ac 7:00 p.mo, Room 241, County Office Building, McIntire Road, Charlottesville, Virginia. PRESENT: Mr. David P. Bowerman, Mrs. Charlotte Y. Hnmphris, Mr. Forrest R. Marshall, Jr., Mr. Charles S. Martin, Mr. Walter F. Perkins and Mrs. Sally H. Thomas. ABSENT: None. OFFICERS PRESENT: County Executive, Robert W. Tucker, Jr., County Attorney, Larry W. Davis, and County Planner, V. Wayne Cilimberg. Agenda Item No. i. The meeting was called ~o order at , by the Chair- man, Mrs. Humphris. Agenda Item No. 2 Pledge of Allegiance. Agenda Item No. 3 Moment of Silence. Agenda Item NO. Public. Other Matters Not Listed on the Agenda from the Agenda Item No. 5. Consent Agenda. Motion was offered by Mr. Marshall, seconded bs- Mr. Martin, To approve Item 5.1 and to accept the remaining zcems on the consent agenda as information Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded roue: AYES: Mr Marshall, Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Mr. Martin, Mr Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Item No. 5.1. Appropriation: Education, S7,893 (Form #96054). By the above shown voted, the Board adopted the following resolution of appropriation: FISCAL YEAR: 1996/97 NI/MBER: 96054 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: NEW FUA!D: SCHOOL PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: USE OF CARRYOVER FUNDS RESULTING FROM BUILDING RENTAL FEES. EXPENDITURE COST CTR/CATEGORY DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1220161101800101 1220361101800101 1220561101830101 1220961101800101 1221261101800101 1221461101800101 1221561101800101 1221661101800101 1225161101800101 1225261101800101 1225361101800101 1225461101830101 1230161101800101 1230261101800101 MACB/EQUIP-REPL BROADUS WOOD MACH/EQUIP-REPL CROZET MACH/EQUIP-REPL HOLLYMEAD MACH/EQUIP-REPL SCOTTSVILLE MACH/EQUIP-REPL WOODBROOK MACH/EQUIP-REPL CALE MAC~ EQUIP-REPL MURRAY MACH/EQUIP-REPL ADNOR-HURT MACH/EQUIP-REPL BURLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL HENLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL JOUETT MACH/EQUIP-REPL WALTON MACH/EQUIP-REPL ABS MACH/EQUIP-REPL WARS TOTAL S28.00 4.00 30.00 60.00 146.00 96.00 10.00 697.80 158.40 187.20 1,788.00 21.00 4,642.60 24.00 s7,893.00 REVENUE DESCRIPTION AROUNT 2200051000510100 FLrND B~I2L~CE S7.893.00 TOTAL $7,893.00 March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 2) Item NO. 5.2. Copy of Supss. Memo. No. 1, dated February 24, 1997, from Richard T. La Pointe, Superintendent of Public Instruction, Eo Division Superintendents, re: Aid 5o Localities Appropriations, 1996-98 Biennium, was received for information. Item No. 5.3. Copy of Planning Commission minuEes for February 25, 1997, was received for information. Item No. 5.4. Notice from the Department of Transportation that the Location and Design Public Hearing scheduled for March 25, 1997, on the proposed construction of Greenbrier Drive (Route 866) from 0.026 mile south of the intersection of Nydraulic Road (Route 743) to 0.172 mile north of the intersection of Route 29, in Albemarle County, has been canceled, was received for information. Agenda Item No. 6. Public Hearing on an Ordinance to Amend and Reenact the County Code in Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl, Article II, Dogs, Division 2, Running a5 Large, 5o add Subsection 4-19[a)(36), LexingEon Subdivision in Earlysville as one of those areas where dogs are prohibited from running at large. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Motion was offered by Mr Perkins, seconded by Mr. Bowerman, ~o adopt an Ordinance to amend and reordain Chapser 4, Animals and Fowl, Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running a5 Large, of the Code of the County of Albemarle, Vir- ginia, to add Subsection 4-19(a)(36), Lexingson Subdivision in Earlysville as one of those areas where dogs are prohibited from running at large. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vase: AYES: Nays: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs. Numphris. perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. ,The adopted Ordinance is set out below:/ ORDINANCE NO. 97-4(1) AiN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REORDAIN CPIAPTER 4, ARTICLE 2, DOGS, DIVISION 2, RUNNING AT LARGE, COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA. ANIMALS ~ FOWL, OF THE CODE OF THE BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervisors of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, that Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl, Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running at Large, is hereby amended and reordained by amending section 4-19, In certain areas, as follows: Sec. 4-19. (36) ARTICLE II. Division 2 In certain areas Lexington Subdivision as platted and recorded in the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of the County mn Deed Book 564, page 088. DO~S. Running au Large. Agenda Item No. 7. Public Hearing to receive commenus on the County Executive's Recommended Operating Budgem for FY 1997-98. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on March 9 and March 11, 1997.. No action required at this time. Agenda Item No. 8. ZM3~-96-17. Mechum River Land Trust (Sign $33) . ~- II ...... ~ on ~ rc~c~t ~ ~ .... ~ ~prax~,~" ac from P~ ~ ~ ~ *~ ~ ~ & ~,'~ March 12, 1997 (Regttlar Night Meeting) (Page 3) Basin d2ainagc a::c~.,; W.~itc Ifa!! ~is;. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Motion wes offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Marshall, to defer ZMA-96-17 until April 16, 1997. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Agenda Item No. 9. ZMA-96-22. R/~H Developmenn Corp (Sign $72). Public ....... ~ .................... = .......... 1.~ Rio Dist. (Advertised in the Da Progress on February 24 and March 3, Motion was offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Marshall, to defer ZMA-96-22 until April 16, 1997. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded rome: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs. ~umphris. NAYS: None. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Agenda Item No. 10. Discussion: Regional Competitiveness Program in the Thomas Jefferson Planning District (deferred from March 5, 1997). The Board deferred this ztem until March 19, 1997. Non Agenda. At 9:15 p.m., monion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr Martin, to go into Executive Session pursuant to Section 2~1-344(A) of the Code of Virgmn~a under Subsection (1) to consider personnel matters relating 5o appointments to Boards, Commissions and Committees; and under Subsection (7) to consult with legal counsel and staff regarding specific legal matters relating to reversion. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: NAYS: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Mrs. Humphris. None. At 9:45 p.m., the Board reconvened into open session. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall, ~o certify the executive session Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Agenda Item No. 11~ Discussion: Process to appoint additional members 5o the Development Areas Initiatives Committee. This item was non discussed. Agenda Item No. 12. Other Matters non Listed on the Agenda from the BOARD. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall no set a public hearing to increase the Board's salary 3.5 percenn for FY 1997-98. Roll was called and the mormon carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Mrs. Humphris. March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 4) NAYS: None. Agenda Item No. 13. Adjourn to March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mrs. Thomas to adjourn to March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Martzn, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Chairman Approved by Board Initials March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 1) A regular meenln9 of the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County, VirgInia, was held on March 12, 1997, aE 7:00 p.m., Room 241, County Office Building, McIntire Road, Charlottesville, Virginia. PRESENT: Mr. David P. Mr. Forrest R. Marshall, Jr., Mrs. Sally H. Thomas. Bowerman, Mrs. Charlotte Y Humphris. Mr. Charles S Martin, Mr Walter Perkins and ABSENT: None. OFFICERS PRESENT: County Executive, Robert W. Tucker, Jr.; County Attorney, Larry W. Davis; and County Planner, V. Wayne Cilimberg~ Agenda Item No. 1. The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m., by the Chairman, Mrs. Humphris. kgenda Item No. 2. Pledge of Allegiance. Agenda Item No. 3. Moment of Silence. Agenda Item No. 4. Public. Other Matters Not Listed on the Agenda from the Agenda Item Wo. 5. Consent Agenda. Motion was offered by Mr. Marshall, seconded by Mr. Martin, no approve Item 5.1 and to accepn the remamning items on the consen5 agenda as information. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vone: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mrs. Humphris. WAYS: None. Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Item No. 5.1. Appropriation: Educanzom, $7,893 (Form ~96054) . By the above shown roue, the Board adopted the following resolutLon of appropriation: FISCAL YEAR: 1996/97 NI/MBER: 96054 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: NEW FD-ND: SCHOOL PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: USE OF CARRYOVER FUA/DS RESULTING FROM BUILDING RENTAL FEES. EXPENDITORE COST CTR CATEGORY DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1220161101800101 1220361101800101 1220561101800101 1220961101800101 1221261101800101 1221461101800101 1221561101800101 1221661101800101 1225161101800101 1225261101800101 1225361101800101 12R5461101800101 1230161101800101 1230261101800101 MACH/EQUIP-REPL BROADUS WOOD MACH/EQUIP-REPL CROZET MACH/EQUIP-REPL HOLLYMEAD MACH/EQUIP-REPL SCOTTSVILLE MACH/EQUIP-REPL WOODBROOK MACH/EQUIP-REPL CALE MACH/EQUIP-REPL MI/RRAY MACH/EQUIP-REPL AGNOR-HURT MACH/EQUIP-REPL BURLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL HENLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL JOUETT MACH/EQUIP-REPL WALTON MACH/EQUIP-REPL ABS MACK/EQUIP-REPL WAHS TOTAL S28.00 4.00 30.00 60.00 146.00 96.00 10.00 697.80 158.40 187.20 1,788.00 21.00 4,642.60 24.00 $7,893.00 REVENUE DESCRIPTION AMOL~NT 2200051000510100 FUND B~LANCE S7,893.00 TOTAL $7,893.00 March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 2) Item No. 5.2~ Copy of Supts. Memo. No 1, dated February 24, 1997, from Mr. Richard T. La Pointe, Superlnmendent of Public Instruction, mo Division Superintendents, re: Aid mo Localities Appropriations, 1996-98 Biennium. was received for information. Item No. 5.3. Copy of Planning Commzssion minutes for February 25, 1997, was received for information. Item No. 5.4. Notice from the Department of Transpornanmon that the Location and Design Public Hearing scheduled for March 25, 1997, on the proposed construction of Greenbrier Drive (Route 866) from 0.026 mile south of the intersection of Hydraulic Road (Route 743) mo 0.172 mile north of the intersection of Route 29, in Albemarle County, has been canceled, was received for information. Agenda Item No. 6. Public Hearing on an Ordinance to Amend and Reenact the County Code mn Chapmer 4, Animals and Fowl, Article II, Dogs, Division 2, Runnmng am Large, to add Subsection 4-19(a) (36), Lexingmon Subdivision mn Earlysville as one of mhose areas where dogs are prohibited from running at large. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on February 24 and March 3, t997. Mr. Tucker said that Lexington Subdivision mn Earlysvitle has requested the Board include the subdivision mn the County's Dog Leash Ordinance area. Of the emght occupied lots, six are mn favor of instituting a dog leash law. Following the County's policy of supporting any subdivision that has am least 51 percent of the residents in favor of the dog leash law, staff recommended setting the public hearing. The Chairman opened the public hearing. Mr Joseph Becker, a resident of 5830 Lexlngnon Lane, said he was the person who requested the ordinance after many problems with dogs in the nelgiiborhood. There being no other comments, Mrs. Kumphris closed the public hearing. The motion was offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Bowerman, to adopm an Ordmnance to amend and reordain Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl. Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running at Large, of the Code of the County of Albemarle, Virginma, to add Subsection 4-19~a) (36), Lexington Subdivision in Earlysville as one of those areas where dogsLare prohibited from running at large. Roll was called and the momion carried by the following recorded rome: AYES: Nays: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. None. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. The adopted Ordinance is set oum below: OP~DIN/kNCE NO. 97-4 (1) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REORDAIN CHAPTER 4, ANIFLALS AND FOWL, ARTICLEcouNTY OF2'ALBEMARLE,DOGS' DIVISIONviRGi!fiA~UNNING AT LARGE, OF THE CODE OF THE BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervisors of the County of Albemarle, Virgmnma, that Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl, Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running at Large, is hereby amended and reordained by amending section 4-19, En certain areas, as follows: ~_RTICLE II. Dogs. Division 2. Runninq an Larqe. (36) Lexingmon Subdivision as platted and recorded mn the March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 3) Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of the County in Deed Book 564, page 088. Agenda Item NO. 7. Public Hearing Lo receive commenus on the County Executive's Recommended Operating Budget for FY 1997-98. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on March 9 and March 11, 1997.) Mrs. Humphris reminded all presenn no speak a5 the public hearing no limit their commenns no no more than three minutes per individual or five minutes if representing a group, uo stick to the facts and to eliminate applause. Mr. Tucker stated that this was the first public hearing on the proposed FY97-98 budgen, and that work sessions would follow during March. A final public hearing would be held before the Board on April 9, 1997. Mr. Tucker presented the County Executive's recommended operating budget for FY 1997-98. The total budget is S126.5 million, an increase of 6~5 percent over FY1997. The school budget represents an increase of 61 percenn, which does non include debt service or capital transfer. Including those items, the School Division's budgen represents approximately 68 percent of the total budgen. Mrs. Humphris opened the public hearing. MS. Karen Lilleleht, speaking on behalf of the new Thomas Jefferson Housing Improvemenn Corporation (TJHIC), asked the County and the City for $50,000 each to help cover the FY 1997-98 operating expenses of TJHIC. Ms. Kathy Verell expressed opposition 5o the School Division's proposed ~maintenance of effort" budget, stating that education would remain at the stanus quo, allowing for no additional growth. Mr. Don Vale spoke on behalf of the Albemarle County Public Schools Principals' Association. He asked that the Board look an the unfunded initiatives as basic needs, not a wish list. Ms. Denise Allen spoke on behalf of the Henley Middel School Parent Teacher Organization (PTO). The PTO requests that the Board support the entire proposed budget which represents a ~maintenance of effort" for the schools. Ms. Martha Redinger, President of the Murray Elementary School PTO, She said that Albemarle must supporn more than a ~maintenance of effort" budgen when maintenance implies mediocriny, and must amend itself to guarannee basic education for all children, including art and music, full-time librarzans in every school, and small class sizes. Murray PTO Board will not support the budgen or any such reduced effort that does not pay for growth or the basic fundamental education that all children should be offered. Mr. Sam Kaplan said that the County has to plan for the future. He proposed that the Board levy a one cenn max increase in the real proper5y tale to be put into two trust funds. One would be an educational initiative fund, receiving two-thirds of the funds, the other, a law enforcement inititative fund, which would receive one-third of the funds. Mrs. Martha Bain, President of the Brownsville Elementary PTO, said the Albemarle County Schools Parent Council was formed in November, 1996, oun of the Superintendent's Advisory Committee. The Council represents each of the County's 23 schools, as well as three at-large members appointed by the Superintendent. The Council supporns the Superintendent and School Board, and the request for additional funds. Mr. Marshall Chase addressed the Board, speaking as President of the Albemarle Education Association. He said this is not s maintenance of effort budgen; it not only does not maintain currrenn services, it falls far short of what the County must do for children. Mr. Karl Monsoor spoke on behalf of Albemarle County Police Deparnment employees. He commented on the numerous pay problems; the most signifiant of which is the compression of salaries. March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 4) Ms. Beth Barden also spoke, representing many officers an the Police Department. She said the officers agree with the Hendrix plan, but want to see it implemented fully as had been the anrenu. Mr. Karl Brown spoke regarding departmental and conLractural overtime. Department overtime consists of callouts, holdovers, investigations or arrests which keep an officer past normal work hours. Mr. Pete Saber also spoke on behalf of the County police officers and employees. He said the employees completely support their Supervisors, the Board and the County Executive. Albemarle County is the nicest communiuy an Central Virganla, due to the quality of services and schools offered. Police officers would like to live ~n the County and take advantage of its servaces as opposed to living outside of the County. Mr. Roger Mathias, a County police officer, also asked that the pay issue be addressed. Mr. John Carter addressed the issue of an unbalanced school budget. Me suggested the School Board be told they must balance the budgeu. Mr. Dewey Cornell, Co-President of the Agnor-Hurt Elementary School PTO, said that all County citizens should be concerned about the school budget because without everyone's tax dollars, many County programs could not be funded, incomang businesses would locate elsewhere to find good schools, and at would cost more co deal with children who fail an school than it does uo provide a good education In his opanaon, Albemarle should nou settle for maanuenance of effort; it should strive for increased effort and ancreased effectiveness in schools. In order ro achieve these goals, uhere musu be an increased effort by the Board. Mr. Dan Dunsmore, President of the Meraweuher Lewis Elementary School PTO, encouraged the Board to provide schools with critical funding. Mr. Brian Clingenpeel, Pastor of Hillsboro Baptist Church in Crozet, spoke zn support of fair pay for Albemarle County Police officers. Mr. Mark Echelberger said that growth is a factor in the budgeu, but that growth also brings resources co the County. He thinks the Board needs uo explore means of increasang revenues for the school and the County an large, non jusu for now, but for the future. Mrs. Elizabeth Way asked that the Board seriously consider the School Board's unbalanced budget, and co reduce the amounn requested by the urkbal- anced amoun5. Ms. Donna Packard, a parent of nwo Murray Elementary School children, spoke against any reduction in funds to Murray Elementary School. Mr. David Carr, Jr., a parenu of a student at Murray Elementary School, said it was clear that growth is a ma3or problem eating away au the school's operating budgen and the future of the educational system. He urged the Board to seek revenue from a meals tax and a property uax increase to supporn that growth, as well as no approach the General Assembly for additional revenues. Mr. Michael Webb addressed the pay scale for the Police Deparnment. Mr. Dan Blake asked the Board no assist officers an making the community a better place in which to live, serve and raise families. There bein9 no other commenns, the public hearing was closed. Mrs. Humphris thanked the public for the excellent input provided mostly on the educational system and the Police pay issue. Agenda Item No. 8. ZM3~-96-17. Mechum River Land Trust (Sign ~rain~gc arca. l "~..~-~ Ilall Dist. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 6) At 9:45 ~.m., the Board reconvened into open session. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall, Eo certify the Executive Session. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded AYES: Mr Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Agenda Item No. 11. Discussion: Process Lo appoln5 additional members to the Developmenm Areas Initiatives Committee This item was not discussed Agenda Item No 12. Other Matters nor Listed on the Agenda from the BOARD. Mr Tucker said that some of the Board members had approached him about increasing the Board's salary for the next year. If the Board wishes to move forward on this item, it must be advertised for public hearing. When asked, Mr. Tucker recommended that the increase be 3.5 percenm, the same as other County employees. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall, no sen a public hearing for May 7, 1997, no increase the Board's salary by 3.5 percenn for FY 1997-98. Roll was called and the monlon carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mrs. Humphris NAYS: None. Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mrs. Humphris said she would be attending the Commonwealth Transporta- tion Board's Pre-allocation Hearing in Culpeper on Friday. Mr. Tucker said tham Senator Emily Couric and Delegane Mitch VanYahres also plan no attend the hearing. Mr. Martin said Board members will be talking to certain individuals about the possibility of their joining the Development Areas Initiatives Committee The Board has non yet decided on the number of people to add no the Committee. landfill. meeting. Thomas questioned whether the Board would be discussing the Mr. Tucker responded that it was on the agenda for the next Mr. Bowerman asked if the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority (RSWA) has a monthly collection day where people, other than commercial haulers, can bring in anything. Mr. Tucker said this has been done on occasion. Mr. Bowerman proposed that once a month citizens be permitted to bring items To the landfill without being charged a tipping fee. Mrs. Humphris mentioned a letter from Mr. Kenneth A. Schwartz, Associate Dean at the University of Virginia School of Architecnure, inviting the Board no a Round Table discussion on Wednesday, April 2, 8:30 a.m. to 10:30 a.m., regarding Universlny and communzny interaction. The Board will begin its regular meeting at 10:30 a.m. Mrs. Humphris asked about a proclamation for the Virglnma Festival of the Book. Mrs. Carey said that she would prepare a proclamation for the April 2, 1997 Board meenlng. Mrs. Humphris said she accepted on behalf of the Board, from the Virginia Foundation for the Humanities and Public Policy, a print entitled March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting} (Page 5) February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Mrs. Numphris said a letter has been received from the applicant, Mr. Hunter Craig, requesting that this item be deferred until April 16, 1997. The motion was offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Marshall, to defer ZMA-96-17 until April 16, 1997. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vone: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. ABSTAINED: Mr. Bowerman. Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas and Agenda Item NO. 9. ZMA-96-22. RHH Development Corp (Sign ~72). ~ub!ic .......... ........... ~ ........... 774 ....... ~ ....... ~n ......... hood 1.) n~ ~-~ (Advertised in the Da Mrs. Humphris said a letter has been received from the applicant, Mr. Robert M. Hauser, requesting that ZMA-96-22 be deferred to allow him no secure the signatures of all of the property owners on the final proffers. Motion was offered by Mr. ZMA-96-22 until April 16, 1997. following recorded vote: Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Perkins, to defer Roll was called and the motion carried by the AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mrs. Humphris NAYS: None. Mr. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Agenda Item No 10. Discussion: Regional Competitiveness Program the Thomas Jefferson Planning District (deferred from March 5, 1997) Mr Tucker said staff provided Board members a copy of an outline drafted by Mrs. Thomas after the last meeting, that gave direction no the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission as it drafted a resolution to go ~o other interested localities. He noted that there are potential changes the Board may want to consider at a later date. Mrs. Thomas distributed a second draft for the Board's review, which incorporated individuals' and organizations' responses uo the first draft. The other jurisdictions have not reviewed the draft. Following a brief discussion, the Board deferred this item until March 19, 1997. Non Agenda. At 9:15 ~.m., motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Martin, no go into Executive Session pursuant to Section 2.1-344(A~ of the Code of Virginla under Subsection (1) to consider personnel manters relating to appointments 5o Boards, Commissions and Commiutees; and under Subsection (7) to consult with legal counsel and staff regarding specific legal matters relating to reversion. Mr. Martin advised the Board that he felt uncomfortable going inno Executive Session nc discuss Boards and Commissions unless a committee other than the Development Areas Initiative Committee was being discussed. As Board representatative no that Committee, he did not have anything to say that the public could not hear. Mrs. Humphris said there were issues that needed to be discussed mn Executive Session than relate no individuals. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded yore: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: Mr. Martin. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 7) ~Encampmen5 of the Convention Army a5 Charlotte Ville" a limited edition produced and designed by Calvin P. Otto. She asked that the print be framed and placed in an appropriate location. Agenda Item No. 13. Adjourn 5o March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m. At 10:00 p.m., motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mrs. Thomas, to adjourn ~o March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m, for a work session on the budges. Roll was called and the moslon carried by the following recorded AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Chairman Approved by Board Date Initials March 12, (Page 1) 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) A regular meetin§ of the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County, Virginia, was held on March 12, 1997, au 7:00 p.m., Room 241, County Office Building, McIntire Road, Charlottesville, Virginia. PRESENT: Mr. David P Bowerman, Mrs. Charlotte Y. Humphris, Mr. Forresu R. Marshall, Jr., Mr. Charles S. Martin, Mr. Walter F. Perkins and Mrs. Sally H. Thomas. ABSENT: None. OFFICERS PRESENT: County Executive, Robert W. Tucker, Jr.; County Attorney, Larry W. Davis; and County Planner, V Wayne Cilimberg. Agenda Item No. 1. The meeting was called uo order at 7:00 p.m., by the Chairman, Mrs. Humphris. Agenda Item No 2 Pledge of Allegiance. Agenda Item No 3 MomenE of Silence. Agenda Item No Public. 4 Other Matters Not Listed on the Agenda from the Agenda Item No. 5 Consent Agenda. Motion was offered by Mr. Marshall, seconded by Mr. Martin, to approve Item 5.1 and no accept the remaining items on the consent agenda as information. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Martin, Mr. Perkins. Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Item No 5.1. Appropriation: Education, $7,893 (Form #96054). The Executive Summary states that at its meeting on January 27 1997, the School Board approved the 5ransfer of $7,893 5o the schools from the Fund Balance for carryover funds and distribution of building rental fees col- lected. School Board Policy KG-R stipulates that 40 percent of building rental fees that are collected are to be distributed no the rented facility to be used toward equipment replacement. As of June 30, 1996, a total of $19,732.50 had been collected from building rental fees. Of this amount, $7,893 (40 percent) should be transferred to the schools per School Board policy. Staff recommends approval of the appropriation in the amounn of $7,893, as detailed on Form 596054. By the above shown vote, the Board adopted the following resolution of appropriation: FISCAL YEAR: 1996/97 NUMBER: 96054 TYPE OF APPROPRIATION: NEW FUND: SCHOOL PURPOSE OF APPROPRIATION: USE OF CARRYOVER FUNDS RESULTING FROM BUILDING RENTAL FEES. EXPENDITURE COST CTR/CATEGORY DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 1220161101800101 1220361101800101 1220561101800101 1220961101800101 1221261101800101 1221461101800101 1221561101800101 1221661101800101 MACH/EQUIP-REPL MACH/EQUIP-REPL MACH/EQUIP-REPL N3kCH/EQUIP-REPL M3~CH/EQUIP-REPL FL~CH/EQUIP-REPL MACH/EQUIP-REPL NL~CH/EQUIP-REPL BROADUS WOOD $28.00 CROZET 4.00 HOLLYI~EAD 30.00 SCOTTSVILLE 60.00 WOODBROOK 146.00 CALE 96.00 MURRAY 10.00 AGNOR-HURT 697.80 March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 2) 1225161101800101 1225261101800101 1225361101800101 1225461101800101 1230161101800101 1230261101800101 MACE/EQUIP-REPL BURLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL HENLEY MACH/EQUIP-REPL JOUETT MACH/EQUIP-REPL WALTON MACH/EQUIP-REPL AHS MAC~/EQUIP-REPL WAHS TOTAL 158.40 187.20 1~788.00 21.00 4,642.60 24.00 S7,893.00 REVENI3E DESCRIPTION AMOUNT 2200051000510100 FUND BALANCE $7,893.00 TOTAL $7~893.00 Item No. 5.2. Copy of Supts. Memo. No. 1, dated February 24, 1997, from Mr. Richard T. La Pointe, Superintendent of Public Instruction, to Division Superintendents, re: Aid ~o Localities Appropriations, 1996-98 Biennium, was received for information. Item No. 5.3. Copy of Planning Commission minutes for February 25, 1997, was received for information. Item No. 5.4. Notice from the Department of Transportation that the Location and Design Public Hearing scheduled for March 25, 1997, on the proposed construction of Greenbrier Drive (Route 866) from 0.026 mile south of the intersection of Hydraulic Road (Route 743) ~o 0.172 mile north of the intersection of Route 29, in Albemarle County, has been canceled, was received for information Agenda Item No. 6. Public Hearing on an Ordinance to Amend and Reenact the County Code in Chapter 4, _~nimals and Fowl, Article II, Dogs, Division 2, Running aE Large, to add Subsection 4-19(a)(36), Lexinguon Subdivision in Earlysville as one of those areas where dogs are prohibited from running at large. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Mr. Tucker said that Lexington Subdivision in Earlysvzlle has requested the Board include the subdivision mn the County's Dog Leash Ordinance area. Of the eight occupied lots, six are mn favor of instituting a dog leash law. Following the County's policy of supporting any subdivision that has au least 51 percent of the residents in favor of the dog leash law, staff recommended setting the public hearing. The Chairman opened the public hearing. Mr. Joseph Becker, a resident of 5830 Lexinqcon Lane, said he was the person who requested the~ordinance after many problems with dogs in the neighborhood. He asked that the Board add this subdivision uo the County's Dog Leash Ordinance area. Mr. Becket then asked if the ordinance only applied to the leash itself, or did it extend co cleanin§ up the dogs' excrement. Mrs. Humphris replied that the ordinance simply prohibits dogs from running aE large in the subdivision. Mr. Becker said that on one occasion a dog on a leash left excremenE on his property. Mrs. Humphris asked Mr. Davis to explain the purpose of the ordinance Mr. Davis said the ordinance sca5es that dogs must be under the control of their owners or on a leash. Regarding the other problems, those would be addressed as trespassing issues and Mr. Becket could take appropriate civil or criminal aeEion. There being no other comments, Mrs. Humphris closed the public hearing. The motion was offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Bowerman, co adopt an Ordinance co amend and reordain Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl, Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running au Large, of the Code of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, co add Subsection 4-19(a} (36), Lexington Subdivision in Earlysville as one of those areas where dogs are prohibited from r%/nning a~ large. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded roue: March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 3) AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs. Humphrms. Nays: None. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and The adopted Ordinance is set out below: ORDINA/~CE NO. 97-4(1) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND A/qD REORDAIN CHAPTER 4, ANIMALS AiTD FOWL, ARTICLE 2, DOGS, DIVISION 2, RUNNING AT LARGE, OF THE CODE OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervmsors of the County of Albemarle~ Virgmnia, that Chapter 4, Animals and Fowl, Article 2, Dogs, Division 2, Running au Large, ms hereby amended and reordained by amending section 4-19, In certain areas, as follows: ARTICLE II. Dogs. Division 2. Runnlnc at Large. Sec. 4-19. In certain areas. (36) Lexington Subdivision as platted and recorded in the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of the County mn Deed Book 564, page 088. Agenda Item No. 7. Public Hearing no receive comments on the County Executive's Recommended Operating Budget for FY 1997-98. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on March 9 and March 11, 1997.; Mrs. Humphris reminded all present no speak at the public hearing mo limit their comments Eo no more than three minutes per individual or five minutes if representing a group, to stick no the facts and to eliminate applause. Mr. Tucker stated that this was the first public hearing on the proposed FY97-98 budget, and that work sessions would follow during March. A final public hearing would be held before the Board on April 9, 1997~ Mr. Tucker presented the County Executive's recommended operating budget for FY 1997-98. The total budge5 is s126.5 million, an increase of 6.5 percent over FY1997. The school budge~ represents an increase of 61 percent, which does no~ include debt service or capital transfer. Including those items, the School Division's budget represents approximately 68 percent of the total budgeu. The transfer no the School Divismon is approximately $45.0 million of local funds, or a 5.7 percent increase. This also provides approximately $1.0 million that has been placed in the Board's reserve uo address additional needs in the school system no meet the $1.4 million shortfall. There is no proposed increase in property taxes, but there is an mncrease in the hotel/motel tax. There is an increase of $350,000 in revenue sharing funds no the City of Charlottesville for a total of $5.5 million. The proposed budge5 funds $7.4 million in debt servmce for new and expanded school facilities, and transfers s2.3 million no the Capital Fund. From 1981 co the present, the cost of servmces has been relatively flat. The budget is being driven by the cost of growth and inflation. State and federal governments have ~iso mandated programs which much be implemented. Welfare reform is a major item in the budgeu, for which the County received both federal and state funds amounting uo approximately $700,000. The Virginia Retirement Sys5em (VRS) mandated a pre-funded cost of livmng adjust- menu (COLA) required for school and local government employees, an $750,000. More than 280 new students are projected to enroll in the school system, an mncrease of almost 2.5 percent over the current year, requiring 15 addi- tional regular teachers and 5.5 special education teachers. Start-up costs for the Monticello High School and support positions in Human Resources, Fiscal Services and Information Services are immpacting growth in the School Division. It is anticipated that 1,600 additional Cou/lty residents will relocate to this area, an approximate 2.0 increase over the current year, resulting in additional support and Human Resources positions needed in March 12~ 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 4) General Government. Additional staffing is needed in the Registrar's Office, the Commonwealth Attorney's office, the Police Department, and the development departments, as well as an Information Technology Trainer. A comparison of Albemarle County's per capita expenditure Eo the Commonwealth of Virginia shows the County being below ~he average in every category excep~ education and miscellaneous. The miscellaneous category includes the revenue sharin~ agreemenE. Charlottesville and Albemarle is the only city/county in Virginia that have a revenue sharing agreement. The County has been able to provide a quality level of service to citizens, while increasing only one staff member per 1,000 citizens during the past 12 to 13 years. The Police Department accounts for about 40 percent of that increase. The County's effective tax ra~e Ks 72 cents. The County actually operates on 62 cents per $100 value The average tax rate among top populated 20 counties is about 86 cenEs. The average for all counties is 69 cents. The average for all Virginia cities is $1.04, therefore, Albemarle compares favorably. Regarding changes in revenue, Mr. Tucker said in 1988, property taxes accounted for about 39 percent of the County's total budges. For FY 1998 the reliance has increased to 48 percen~ of the total budget. In 1988, the County received 35 percen~ of the budge5 from shale ~axes; in FY 1998 it dropped to 23 percent, due to devolution. The General Assembly determines the type of revenue the County can generate, which is primarily tied ~o property taxes. The County's reassess- ment increases have changed significantly. At the beginning of the decade there was a 22 percent average increase in reassessments. The County reassesses propersy every two years. In 1991 the County realized there would be a correction in real estate property. Since then, each year, the assess- menE has decreased one-half and it is now 2.26 percent. ~t is becoming more difficult to rely entirely on property Eaxes. Mr. Tucker reminded the Board that FY 1999 will be critical, due to the opening of the new high school. Additional costs for Monticello High School include: $~.3 million for operating costs, 300 additional students at a cos5 of $1.4 million, increased debt service for the new high school at $400,000, IrRS COLA for the schools at $400,000, as well as unknown costs such as reversion, and expansion of the Joint Security Complex. In the past, the Board has relied on its reserves, contingencies, creative financing and cutting back on expenditures 5o balance the bud~eE without increasing the properEy tax. However, Mr. Tucker said he is now concerned that FY 1999 will be a challenge unless there is a meals tax, property tax or expenditure cutbacks. Mr. Martin clarified that when Mr. Tucker said the County operated on 62 cents as opposed Lo 72 cents, ~n should be mentioned that revenue sharin~ creates the. difference. With no further comments from the Board, Mrs. Humphris opened the public hearing. Ms. Karen Lilleleht, speakin~ on behalf of the new Thomas Jefferson Housing Improvement Corporation (TJHIC), asked the County and the City for $50,000 each 5o help cover the FY 1997-98 operaEing expenses of TJHIC. Rural counties will also be asked 5o provide some funding in conjunction with zheir own housing provider organizations. TJHIC hopes ~o pu~ the money into a capital fund available in Charlottesville and Albemarle to help leverage other monies Projects specific to Albemarle County include Crozet Crossing and an elderly housing projec5 in partnership with the Jefferson Area Board for Aging (JABA). Ms. Lilleleht said that ra~s~n9 private funds ~s mu~h more difficult than it used ~o be. (~he County will benefit from working with smaller counties' housing developmen5 organizations. TJ~IC is a 5ested fundraising group with granE writing expertise, and experience obtaining money through the s~aEe's new Regional Competitiveness Act. Ms. Kathy Verell expressed opposition to the School Division's proposed ~maintenance of effort" budge5, statin~ that education would remain a5 the status quo, allowin~ for no additional growth Because of the new differenti- ated ssaffing ratio, some schools are losing programs or positions. The money March 12, 1997 {Regular Night Meeting) (Page 5) gained from this process will be spent on support personnel aE schools with a higher concentration of at-risk students. The ~chool system defines at-risk based on the numbers of students on free or reduced lunches. In her opinion, this is economic bigotry and educational discrimination aga±nst students who pack their lunch. Some principals have to make difficult decisions about where to cut programs, while others hire staff, resulting in an inconsistent staffing ratio between schools. Ms. Verell said she takes it personally when parents place children ~n private schools, but understands that they may feel there is no alternative Children who wane smaller class s~zes and access co support personnel must be "special needs" children, intellectually gifted. She said that average students should noc have co pay a price. In closing, sh easked the Board to fund growth. Mr. Don Vale spoke on behalf of the Albemarle County Public Schools Principals' Association. He congratulated Dr. Castner and his immediate staff for their intuition, creativity, and sensitivity in developin~ the schools' ~maintenance of effort" budget, and Ms. Powell and others for the time they spent studying the proposed school budget. Mr. Vale said it ~s imporsan5 to a5 lease maintain efforts co provide for the education of children. He thanked Mr. Tucker for his proposed budget without increasing the tax burden, and said that the education of children is the community's slngle mos~ important task. The school system is one co be proud of, as it has achieved many successes and continues co ousperform resources. However, for several years there has been significant growth without growth in funding. Mr. Vale then provided statistics co compare 1992 to 1996 school level funding. He said it has become increasingly more difficult 5o maintain efforts in operat- ±n~ schools, when added to ~his difficulty is the concept of differentiated fundin~ and staffin~ as a straEegy Eo deal with the diverse needs of various schools. The Principal's Association supports the concept, but some schools gain, while some lose. Mr Vale said this can no longer take place without a significant cost 5o children. He asked that the Board look a~ the unfunded initiatives as basic needs, no5 ~ wish list. He added that schools and deparcmenss have put in place a variety of ssraze~ies to meet the needs in each area. Ms Denise Allen spoke on behalf of ~he Henley Middel School Parent Teacher Organization (PTO). The PT© requesss that ~he Board support the entire proposed budget which represents a ~maintenance of effort" for the schools. While Mr. Tucker was able to balance the budget for the upcoming year, it is imperative that the Board find viable revenue resources so that the County does no~ face a "stop ~ap" future. With a minimal maintenance of effort budget, teachers will lose jobs, class s~ze will increase, and out-of- date textbooks will no5 be replaced. Ms. Allen said that some teachers are already involved in fund raising ~o cover the basics such as rep!acin~ out-of- date audio-visual equipmenE and maps, or spend their own money ~o purchase books and other materials students need. This should concern all citizens. The basics of education are not bein~ meE. This budqeE does not address the issues of growth and inflation, which will no~ go away. The Board needs to take politics out of education and look seriously aE a meals ~a~ and other revenue sources. Further, she invited each Board member and critics of the proposed budget to spend time volunteering ~n the schools, including spending time working ~ith at-risk populations. Ms. Martha Redinger, President of the Murray Elementary School PTO, thanked the Board for the extraordinary effor~ they make serving the County. She said that Virginia L. Murray Elementary School has an active and well- informed PTO. At a recen~ board meeting, when FY 1998's budget allocation was reviewed, it was apparenE that Murray Elementary School lacked support, and that the County had reduced its commitment zo public education in general. Murray's board expressed concern and disapproved the proposal, saying that the recommended budget does not accommodate growth in the County and reduces support for individual schools Ms. Redinger stated thac Albemarle County has been allowed Eo grow with no concern for the impact on education budgeEs, and that the County stands aE a crossroads. She said that a ~m~intenance of effort" budget would represent mediocrity, and the proposed bud~e~ is some- thing less than that. Stating that differentiated fundin~ addresses those schools that have more inherenE hurdles ~o overcome Eo achLeve success, she agreed that some schools do have greaner needs. However, it is no~ fair to reduce support elsewhere. With new staffing allocations, Murray Elementary stands to lose. The full~~ime employee (FTE) numbers are the same next year, but there will no longer be a full-time librarian without making reductions elsewhere, plus other requiremenns have been added without the additional staff. Ms. Redinger said that Albemarle's minimum standards are lacking. A March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 6) full-time librarian is not guaranteed in any school. To keep a full-time media specialist, the school has to sacrifice its art teacher. The failure to require and fund a surong music and art curriculum reflects a misunderstand- ing; art education is basic education, and that, for some, art education ms what unlocks the key in the academic experzence. She said experts agree that a strong commitment co the arcs stimulates learning ability, improves test scores, aids in understanding other subjecus enhances self-esteem and produc- tivity, and teaches discipline. Ms. Redinger said that Albemarle County has never supported an orchestral program in its high schools, while Charlottes- vitle impresses us with its strong supporu of uhe ares despite its financial difficulties and special student needs. She said that Albemarle must support more than a ~maintenance of effort" budget when maintenance implies medioc- rity, and muse amend itself to guarantee basic education for all children, including art and musmc full-time librarians in every school, and small class smzes. Saying that this budget is less than a maintenance of effort, she said that the Murray PTO Board will not support it or any such reduced effort that does not pay for growth or the basic fundamental education that all children should be offered. Mr. Sam Kaplan said than the County has to plan for the future. He proposed that the Board levy a one cent tax increase in the real properuy rate co be put into two urusn funds. One would be an educational initiative fund, recemving two-thirds of the funds, the other, a law enforcement inititative fund, which would recezve one-third of the funds. During prosperity, funds would be allowed to accumulate. By providing these funds, he believes the County will be able ~o mae5 the challenge of growth and make qualititative improvements in the educational system in the ~uture~ as well as in law enforcement efforts. Mrs. Martha Bain, President of the Brownsville Elementary PTO, said the Albemarle County Schools Parent Council was formed in November, 1996, out of the Superintendent's Advisory Committee. The Council represents each of the County's 23 schools, as well as three at-large members appointed by the Superintendent The Council supports the Superintendent and School Board, and the request for additional funds. Although additional funds have been promised, the Council does not feel this is sufficient, and that the budget proposal represents a reduction in effort, rather than maintenance. Educators cannot lead the children into the 21st Century as leaders, with school cutbacks. Differentiated funding, which brings more funds to schools with a higher number of children in need, should hoc occur at the expense of schools with lesser needs. The current system is growing by the size of a small elementary school each year. With 282 new students projected for next year and a new high school commng on~line she believes the budget should be progressive in effort, and that there should not be a list of unfunded initiatives that include the basics There ms no waste in Brownsville Elementary School, and probably non in any of the other schools. Adminisnra- tion works co manage available funds but some areas must go without. Mrs. Bain asked the Board whether or nou the schools are mn the buszness of educating the whole child, regardless of where talent lies. She said the County will lose valuable teaching staff if it does not support their efforts. As a product of Albemarle County public schools, she ms a faithful supporter of public education. She added that Albemarle public education is good, and should be the best. She said that parents want quality in the education of their children that will last. Mrs. Bain said that teaching basics is hOC good enough any longer; times have changed, children's needs have changed, and society has changed. The state's composit index for Albemarle says the County has a better ability co pay, and she said the County must do so. She proposed that the Board supporn a meals tax, charge developers mmpact fees, consider a real estate nax mncrease and slow the fane of growth. She concluded by adding that all County governmenn and services need more funding, including the police deparument, parks and recreatmon, libraries and senior programs. Mr. Marshall Chase addressed the Board, speaking as President of the Albemarle Education Association. He said this is not a maintenance of efforn budget; it not only does non maintain currren~ services, it falls far short of what the Counny muse do for children. The School Division's budget includes a new differentiated staffing formula. Mr. Chase said it ms past time that the County begin an inititative uo serve children who need all the help they can geE, but added that this program comes with a heavy price. That is the reduction of effort in the instruction of art, music, physical education, elementary guidance and media sciences It is the reduction in the number of teaching assisnants and concraen staff. It is an mncrease in class size Fine ams are an essential parn of human intelligence. Physical education is March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meetmng) (Page 7) essential co the developmenu of healthy bodies and minds History is on CD ROM. The Schools no longer have librarians; they have media specialists Guidance counselors are becoming school-based social workers. Mr. Chase said that children who are at-risk go far beyond the buildings that have the highest percennage of free and reduced lunch, citing that they are in every school and in every classroom. Et is time for the County to decide what it warms as a community. All children deserve the best the County can give them. He said the biggesn mistake this budget makes is that it asks coo little for all of the children. Unfunded initatives include full funding of ACADEMIC LEARNING PROJECT Schools Plus (ALPS), health clinicians, Summer School acceleration, a K-5 language arcs specialist, textbooks, increase of the Master's Degree stipend for teachers, and the pony van. Next March the budget will include the opening of a new high school. Mr. Chase concluded ~hat nexn year the County is going co need a meals nax ]usn co hold its ground. He said if the County wants no do more, the people will either have co ean ouc a lot or add other new sources of revenue. Mr Karl Monsoor spoke on behalf of Albemarle County Police Deparnment employees. He asked those persons mn the room mn support of his comments no stand. Approximately 60 stood. He said the employees support Chief Miller and are committed to doing their best for the County. They are also committed to seeing that pay ms administered in a fair manner and at a level that ms consistent with risk and responsibility. The employees understand that running a County properly is a difficult and complex task. However, Mr. Monsoor said there are numerous pay problems; the most slgnifiant of which is the compression of salaries. There are many junior level officers whose pay is close co or equal co officers senior no them, although both have done satisfactory, or better, work. He said that numerous employees do excellent work, but do non receive pay raises, including some outstanding officers Mr. Monsoor said the Hendrix pay plan indicates a mid-point in salary which should be consistent with the mid-point in a career, but many officers who are close to retirement are still at mid-career level pay. This plan actually caused more pay compression when it was zmplemented. A consultann is not needed to fir this; instead, the County should ramse employees' base pay to a level that reflects their years of servmce. Additionally, whenever the starting salary is raised, other salaries should be raised the same percennage, eliminating the compression problem. Mr Monsoor also said the evaluation system needs to be changed so that satisfactory or better performance merits a raise. Another problem is the overall low pay for the majority of Police Department employ- ees, sworn officers and civilian personnel, adding that pay problems have an effect on the services that citizens receive. He said the Department has lost many employees due no pay problems, and others seek outside employment to pay their bills, leaving them exhausted and unable to concentrate on their mamn job. Mr. Monsoor said this ms such a high priority that it needs no be fixed now. This issue is very important no the employees. He concluded his remarks by providing the Board a list of 74 signanures from employees of the Police Department who supporn this position. Ms. Beth Barden also spoke, representing many officers in the Police Department. She said the officers agree with the Hendrix plan, but want to see it implemented fully as had been the intent~ The Department serves as a training facility for aspiring law enforcement professionals. Professionals can get their training here, then transfer no larger departments offering higher salaries, more speciality options, more promotions, more prestige and other attractions. Officers faced with few promotional opportunities and low salaries often choose to move. This trend has created a chronic problem of turnover and understaffing. Ms. Barden said the Department is committed co community-oriented policing and proactive law enforcement, but it is hard no be creative when pay is an minimum or below average. She said it is impossi- ble if employees have no concencrane on simply getting the basics done. She pointed out that officers new no a Deparcmenn require a huge investment ($65,200 for equipment, training, etc.), and a good officer is made, non born, and it takes time. Officers who come with prior experience must be reormented to the Albemarle County way of doing things, and muse comple%e the Virginia certification requmrement, regardless of how much expermence they have. Hiring one officer involves the efforts of many, from recruitment, to testing, to interviewing and background checks, mo reinterviewing and hiring. Time is sperm away from the Police Department's primary function, which is to provide police services. Once an officer is hired, there is a long training and orientation process, and problems with salaries have taken a toll on that process. Many former training officers found that new officers mn training made the same salary the training officers made, and would soon surpass that salary, because of the way the pay plan ms administered. Consequently, March 12, 1997 (Regulaz Night Meeting) (Page 8) experienced officers have declined the extra work and responsibility of being a training officer, and currently, the average time in service within Albemarle County as a training officer ms short Ms. Barden said it takes nearly a year to recruit, hire, train and release an officer each time the County loses an experienced officer. There are times areas of the County muse make due with occasional patrols and officers only respond to calls for service. Officers have ~o answer more calls, and therefore cannot be as thorough as they would like on each call, and mistakes can be made and citizens left unsatisfied. The Police Department would like to do better. The employees believe Albemarle's citizens deserve better, but the Department needs the Board's help in fixing the budge5 in order Eo keep good officers. This County has all the tools it needs to serve the citizens. The County needs 5o keep good officers through good and adequate pay, so that it can realize the long-term savings and improve service. Mr. Karl Brown spoke regarding departmental and contractural overtime. Department overtime consists of callouts holdovers, investigations or arrests which keep an officer past normal work hours. It is sometimes paid at a normal rate, sometimes at time and a half, sometimes compensatory time and sometimes forced time off. Staff does not understand the pay methods. Mr. Brown then attempted to explain the various pay mehtods, i.e., time-and-a- half, contractural overtime, etc. In concluding, he said the Police Officers ask that the Board help make the pay situation better so that officers are not so tired when reporting to work for the County. Mr. Pete Baber also spoke on behalf of the County police officers and employees. He said the employees completely suppor~ their Supervisors, the Board and the County Executive. Albemarle County is the nicest community in Central Virginia, due to the quality of services and ~chools offered. Funding for the schools musu be maintained at a level to support teachers in their endeavor. However, Police officers would like ~o live in the County and take advantage of its services as opposed no living outside of the County. A recent poll showed that only 38 percent of County officers could afford to own a home in the County. Of the homes owned by officers, 86 percent are below the County's average for the cost of a szngle-family dwelling. Every officer who lives outside the County responded that they do so because they cannot live mn Albemarle; however, 68 percent would move here if pay problems were handled so they could be a par5 of the community they serve. Ninety-four percenu of officers rely on other sources of income to pay bills; working an average of 8.2 hours per week part-time, which can add up to between 51 and 60 hours worked per week, no5 including couru, overtime or training. Mr. Roger Mathias, a County police officer, said in 1996 ~he Police Department handled 33,778 calls for service; an increase in the workload of approximately 13 to 14 percent from the previous year. Manpower levels did not increase by this percentage, yen Police officers handled the workload. Officers serve as counselors or mediators for spousal abuse, to lost, aban- doned, or in3ured children or adults, etc. Officers arrest petty thieves, drug dealers, drug users, rapists, shoplifters, and murderers, and they deliver death notifications to families. He sa.id that officers are rookies, veterans, married, single, single parents with children, neigh-bors, coaches and deacons. Officers are bart of the community. Last year one-third of all injured Police officers were injured while working in their official capacity. Last year assaults on officers were up 100 percent over the previous year. He said that employees are dedicated to serving their Chief of Police, the County govern- ment, and the people of the County to the best of their ability. However, pay issues need to be addressed. Mr. John Carter addressed the issue of an unbalanced school budgeu. He suggested the School Board be told they must balance the budget. The County Executive performs this task every year, telling the County's departments and agencies what they will have ~o spend, not what they would like ~o spend. The School Board has failed to perform this essential task of school administra- tion. Mr. Carter said that is a deficit, a self-inflicted wound that does not deserve sympathy from County government. In his opinion, the rationale for the excess spending is two-fold. First, effort must be maintained, and secondly, salaries muse be or become competitive. Maintaining effort and competitive salaries translates into a spending spree that has little to do with the children in the classrooms. He said that if it did, there would not be $200,000 unfunded for textbooks and $185,000 spent on school operating budgets. Mr. Carter recommended that the School Board develop a balanced budget. If any essential services for educating children are omitted or reduced, they should be listed in a separame document for the Board's consid- March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 9) eration, so that any exEra monies are spent on them. Mr, Carter added that he is currently working on an analysis of past and proposed spending, and will provide it co the Board. Mr. Dewey Cornell, Co-President of the Agnor-Hurt Elementary School PTO, said that all County citizens should be concerned aboum the school budgen because without everyone's tax dollars, many County programs could not be funded, mncomlng businesses would locate elsewhere to find good schools, and it would cost more to deal with children who fail in school than it does to provide a good education. Failed students of today become the failed parents of tomorrow, etc. Education is the key ~o stopping the cycle of poverty and education. The proposed school budget is not a maintenance of effort budget. The term really means "maintenance of expenditures" or "staymng within the guidelines of the Board of Supervisors". Mr. Cornell said the real cosn of maintaining effort is only a secondary consideration, and that effort is not being maintained in public schools. The dollar amounts grow, but not mn proportion to increased encrollment, increased cost and increased needs. Teachers, administrators and support personnel are expected to increase their efforms by doing more and more with less and less. Teachers are underpaid and pupil expenditures are below average. Since Albemarle is not an impoverished, or even ~average" community, schools should not be either. Substantial numbers of children are economically disadvantaged and hundreds fail the literacy passport test, yet schools are being asked ~o cut services to some children to shift money to others. There are children with special education needs who must go outside the school to get services the schools should provide. Textbooks cannot be updated; there are staff shortages; schools have to cutback in physical education, arts and musmc; students are transported in buses that should be replaced; building improvements are needed; caseloads are heavy outside classrooms; and building administrators have difficulty main- taining effort while budgets are frozen. Mr. Cornell said tnat Albemarle's property taxes are low compared to the rest of the state and the nation, and local government ms no~ pulling its own weight in funding local services. The Board has a responsibility to ensure that schools and other services are adequately funded Properny taxes are not the most desireable forms of taxation, but unfortunately, this is what is available ~o work with. In conclusmon, Albemarle should no5 settle for maintenance of effort; it should strive for increased effort and increased effectiveness in schools. In order to achieve these goals, there must be an increased effort by the Board. Mr. Dan Dunsmore, President of the Meriwether Lewis Elementary School PTO, encouraged the Board to provide schools with critical funding. He said that the School Board has approved a maintenance of effort budget, which is acceptable if it ms a maintenance of effort for all children. What is noz acceptable is a budge£ that results mn a decrease in services for some students All children should continue to benefit from at least a maintenance of effort. An effective education has a positive impact on the entire community. Mr Brian Cling~npeel, Pastor of Hillsboro Baptist Church in Crozet, spoke in supporm of fair pay foz Albemarle County Police officers. He rides as an observer with officers. He is also a graduate of the Citizens Police Aoademy, has %xperienced excellent response from police officers when needed, and has had the opportunity to minister to some of the officers Employees of the Police Department are top-notch individuals who take their job seriously and perform their duties with professionalism and care for people. Officers endure many hours of training, extra assignments and cour~ appearances in order to do their jobs, and wear many different hats, including nurse, medianor, rescue worker, psychologist and police officer. Offi6ers put their lives on the line, and assaults on officers are rising. Mr. Clingenpeel said he was amazed no find that the starting pay for a new officer is less than that of a preacher of a small, rural Baptist church. Officers who have been here for several years, and intend ~o stay, do not make much more. He said that officers are due fair pay, and the pay should be based upon performance. However, if the Department stresses community-ormented poliding and problem solving, rather than strictly law enforcement, then performance should be based on community relations, not how many tickets are written and arrests made. He concluded by saymng that the Board needs to support not only equipment and training, but also the people in the deparmment. Mr. Mark Echelberger said that growth is a factor in the budge~, but that growth also brings resources no the County. The issue is much larger than just growth. This year's budgen requests additional expenditures of approximately $4.3 million. Of that increase, approximately $2.5 million March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 10) represents increases in salaries and benefits co maintain a competitive level of employee compensation. From FY 1994 until FY 1998, the number of students increased by approximately 9.9 percent, but instructional salaries and benefits have increased by 26.22 percent. There is a need to contmnue to attract good teachers, which is hOE a growth mssue. The number of computers in use has increased more than 1,000, and the number of instructional networks has increased by 20. Mr. Echelberger said this reflects a fundamental way'in which children must be educated if they are to have a chance to survive in the new information age. Over the pas~ three years the number of children attending summer school has increased from 275 in 1994 to 675 in 1996, aEa cost of $180 per student. These efforts need co continue, but they do cost money. Mr. Echelberger said he is concrned about the list of unfunded priorities: textbooks, summer school, remediation and geometry. Gifted children can also be a5 risk. These are only some of the issues, and there are many more of equal importance. He pointed ou5 that it costs more Eo educate children today than it did in the pass. Increases in salaries and benefits, changing technology, unfunded mandates and regulatory requirements, as well as past maintenance of effort budgets have all put pressure on the School Division. All these are impormanE, and musm be funded to ensure the future success of the School Divmsion and children. Citizens of the County need to decide whether quality education is important. The Board needs to explore means of increasing revenues for the school and the County aE large, not just for now, but for the future. Mrs. Elizabeth Way asked tham the Board seriously consider the School Board's unbalanced budget, and to reduce the amount requested by the unbal- anced amount. She said that a few years ago an unbalanced budget was pre- sented, and the following year a balanced budget was proposed. She belmeves that in the past 5wo years, as the result of elected School Boards, there seems no be an attitude that the School Board now has a mandate ~o ask for whatever they want. Mrs. Way said that the demand is an arrogant one, as the service rendered by the schools is nowhere near commenserate with the monies put into them. She added that the School Divismon's information is not objective; it is more interested in a beaurocracy than in expanding services. In K-3, there are few teachers teaching children how to read. She said there ms a mounting concern that County parents feel that servmces provided are nowhere near what is expected Ms. Donna Packard, a parent of 5wo Murray Elementary School children, spoke against any reduction in funds 5o Murray Elementary School. A reduction in funds at any school serves to increase enrollment ac the area's private schools. She said that may be good for the private schools, but detracts from public education. She then asked how many of these Board members attended a school system funded with a mamntenance of effort budget. Mr. David Carr, Jr., a parenE of a student at Murray Elementary Schoolr said it was clear that growth ms a major problem eating away at the school's operating budget and the future of the educational sysEem There will be a 2.5 percent increase in students this year, which means increased operating expenses throughout the school system. He mentioned that a propozed rezonlng request for the Mechums River Land will increase the density on that trace from seven units 5o 101 units. He pointed out that there needs to be a connection between growth and rezoning and the demands placed on the schools' operating budgets. Mr Carr noted that Mr. Tucker's presentation emphasized the cost of growth ~o the County, and said that citizens need to become educated regarding these costs. He urged the Board co seek revenue from a meals tax and a property nax zncrease ~o supporn that growth, as well as to approach the General Assembly for additional revenues. He said"~hat the proposed school budgeE is called a mainmenance of effort budget, but it forces administration to make a choice between meeting additional requirements, meeting the needs of at-risk children and meetmng additional requirements on technology. To meet those requirements the Murray Elementary princmpal has to eliminate the art teacher, who is only hhere one-and-a-half days a week now, and cut the physical education teacher from full-time to haif-time. This is done co preserve the full-time librarian. Mr. Carr said there must be a quality education and environmen~ ~o ensure a strong economy for the future. Mr. Michael Webb addressed the pay scale for the Police Department. AS a result of Police officers responding mo his needs, he became s volunteer with both the City and County Police Departments. He feels that officers are not compensated enough for their work. Every situation is handled profession- ally, and officers muse maintain self-control and discipline. He encouraged Board members ~o ride along with police officers to watch their performance March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 11) before evaluatin§ the pay scale. He added that the Police Department is the foundation of the community. Mr. Dan Blake asked the Board ~o assist officers in making the community a better place in which to ~ive, serve and raise families. There being no other commen~s, the public hearing was closed. Mrs. Humphris thanked the public for the excellent input provided mostly on the educational system and the Police pay issue She asked if Board members had any commen~s. Mrs. Humphris commented that one speaker sa~d the Board should slow the ra~e of growth, but it does no~ have the power co do so. The Board was also asked to impose impac5 fees on developers, but it canno5 do this without the General Assembly giving it the power 5o do so. Mrs Humphris added that the first budget work session will be held on March 17, 1997, at 1:00 p.m., in Room 241. Agenda Item No. 8. ZMA-96-17. Mec~um River Land TrusE (Sign #33). ~a~in ~r&ina~c area.) White Ilall Dist. (Advertised in the Daily Progress on February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Mrs. Humphris said a letter has been received from the applicant, Mr. Hunter Craig, requesting that this item be deferred until April 16 1997 The motion was offered by Mr. Perkins, seconded by Mr. Marshall, to defer ZMA-96~17 until April 16, 1997. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Mrs. Numphris. NAYS: None. ABSTAINED: Mr. ~owerman. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas and Agenda Item No. 9. ZMA-96-22. RHN Development Corp (Sign #72). Public ........ ~ ~ ~ radical ......... apprcx~.~ ~ from ~ ~ to CO & 2.77~ ao ....... ; .................... = ............ R~o Dist. (Advertised in the Da Progress on February 24 and March 3, 1997.) Mrs. Mr. Robert secure the Numphris said a letter has been received from the applicant, M. Hauser, requesting that ZMA-96-22 be deferred ~o allow him to signatures of all of the property owners on the final proffers. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Perkins, to defer ZM3t-96-22 until April 16, 1997. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. B~werman and developer 16. Bowerman added that there will be meetings between residents, the and himself to attemp5 to resolve outstandin~ ~ssues before April Agenda Item No. 10. Discussion: Regional Competitiveness Program the Thomas Jefferson Planning District (deferred from ~arch 5, 1997). Mr. Tucker said staff provided Board members a copy of an outline drafted by Mrs. Thomas after the last meeting, that gave direction to the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commmssion as it drafted a resolution to No March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 12) co other interested localities. He noted that there are potential changes the Board may want to consider at a later date. Mrs. Thomas distributed @ second draft for the Board's review, which incorporated individuals' and organizations' responses to the first draft. The other jurisdictions have not reviewed the draft. Mrs. Thomas suggested the Board discuss the sub3ect, but noc vote until the draft is discussed with the other jurisdictions. Jurisdictions will be asked to approve the member- ship of the partnership, its charter and bylaws, the plan and the application for funds. The incentive fund distribution formula is required by the state. The other approvals are not required by the regulations, but she said they seem to be responsive to the concerns expressed by individuals. The proposed plan follows the County's Comprehensive Plan Economic Development Policy developed last year. Other juridictions may or may not have similar policies. Giving each jurisdiction a chance to approve it will ensure that the policy is followed. Mrs. Thomas said that partnerships that are formed by the July deadline will get a share of the funds provided by ~he state from last year and this year, which amounts to $3.0 million. Jurisdictions who get applica- tions in before the December deadline will split another $3.0 million, There is an incentive to meet ~he July deadline. Mrs Humphris said that, as Chairman of the Plann±ng District Commis- sion, she thinks it would be a good idea for Mrs. Thomas to contact Fluvanna and Louisa Counties co review the draft. Mrs. Thomas added that Nelson County has also agreed to the partnership. Mrs Humphris asked where the funds came from to fund staff work in developing the funding formula. Mrs. Thomas said that Planning Distrit Commissions around the state have been level-funded for several years, and were given the new responsibility of developing a strategic plan, with no additional funds. They do receive some funding from the state for planning purposes. The bigges5 change to the Planning District Commission's charge is chat the deadline was moved up from next year. Mrs. Humphris commented that if the Planning District Commission was not developing the formula, someone else would ge~ paid to do it. Mr. Marshall said without Albemarle County's participation this partnership cannot move forward. Mrs. Humphris said that was understood. Mr. Bowerman asked if the Board could be given a complete and revised draft of everything that has been assimilated by Friday. Mr. Tucker replied, ~Yes." This draft could simply be incorporated into what has already been prepared. Mr. Martin commented that several areas were s~ngled out, i.e., historic preservation, environmental issues and rural conservation. He asked why not include other mssues such as housing and transportation. Mrs. Thomas said the list could be made longer, or the Board could azsume that the Comprehensive Plan includes these zcems. She noted that there is anxiety about the words ~economic development"; the added words were intended to overcome that anxiety. Housing, nransportation and other mssues can be added. Mr. Martin said it would-be good ~o do so, as there are other important concerns too. With no further comments, the Board deferred this item until March 19, 1997. Non Agenda. At 9:15 p.m., motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr, Martin, no go into Executive Session pursuant to Section 2.1-344(A) of the Code of Virginia under Subsection (1) to consider personnel matters relating to appomntments to Boards, Commissions and Committees; and under Subsection (7) no consult with legal counsel and staff regarding specific legal matters relating [o reversmon. Mr Martin advised the Board that he felt uncomfortable going into Executive Session to discuss Boards and Commissions unless a committee other than the Development Areas Initiative Committee was being discussed. As Board representatative to that Committee, he did not have anything Eo say that the public could non hear. Mrs. Humphris said ~here were issues that needed to be discussed in Executive Session that relate to individuals. March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 13) Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded voEe: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Perkins, Mrs~ Thomas, Mr Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: Mr. Martin. Bowerman and At 9:45 p.m., the Board reconvened into open session. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall, uo certify the Executive Session. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded voEe: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr. Martin, Mr. Mrs Humphris. NAYS: None. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas Mr. Bowerman and Agenda Item No 11~ Discussion: Process uo appoint additional members to the Development Areas Initiatives Committee. This item was hOE discussed. Agenda Item No 12. Other Matters not Listed on the Agenda from the BOARD. Mr. Tucker said that some of the Board members had approached him about increasing the Board's salary for the next year. If the Board wishes Eo move forward on this item, it muse be advertised for public hearing. When asked, Mr. Tucker recommended that the increase be 3.5 percent, the same as other County employees. Motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mr. Marshall, Eo see a public hearing for May 7, 1997, to increase the Board's salary by 3.5 percent for FY 1997-98. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded vote AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mr Mrs. Humphris. NAYS: None. Martin, Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Mrs. Humphris said she would be attending the Commonwealth TransporEa- ulon Board's Pre-allocation Hearing in Culpeper on Friday. Mr. Tucker said that Senator Emily Couric and DelegaEe Mitch VanYahres also plan to attend the hearing. Mr. Martin said Board members will be talking to certain individuals about the possibility of their joinln9 the Development Areas Initiatives Committee. T~e Board has not yet decided on the number of people to add to the Committee. Mrs. Thomas questioned whether the Board would be discussing the landfill. Mr. Tucker responded that z[ was on the agenda for the next meeting. Mr. Bowerman asked if the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority (RSWA) has a monthly collection day where people, other than commercial haulers, can bring in anyEhing. Mr Tucker said this has been done on occasion. Mr. Bowerman proposed that once a month citizens be permitted uo bring items to the landfill without being charged a tlppin9 fee. People then could not complain about the tipping fees. He showed the Board photographs taken of some illegal dumping on a cwo mile stretch near Walton Middle School. Mr. Tucker said the County may have to pay co cover the cosE of the tip fee. Mr. Bowerman said he thought it may be worthwhile uo do so He added tha5 he would also like to see the County penalize people caught dumping trash improperly. Other Board members concurred. Mr. Tucker said he would discuss this with RSWA. March 12, 1997 (Regular Night Meeting) (Page 14) Mrs. Humphris mentioned a letter from Mr. Kenneth A. Schwartz, Associate Dean at the University of Virginia School of Architecture, inviting the Board to a Round Table discussion on Wednesday, April 2, 8:30 a.m. ~o 10:30 a.m., re~arding University and community interaction. The Board will begin its regular meeting a~ 10:30 a.m Mrs. Humphris asked about a proclamation for the Virginia Festival of the Book Mrs. Carey said that she would prepare a proclamation for the April 2, 1997 Board meeting. Mrs. Humphris said she accepted on behalf of the Board, from the Virginia Foundation for the Humanities and Public Policy, a print entitled ~Encampmen~ o~ the Convention Army at Charlotte Ville" a limited edition produced and designed by Calvin P. Otto. She asked that the print be framed and placed in an appropriate location. Age~da Item No. 13. Adjourn to March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m. At 10:00 p.m., motion was offered by Mr. Bowerman, seconded by Mrs. Thomas, to adjourn to March 17, 1997, 1:00 p.m, for a work session on the budget. Roll was called and the motion carried by the following recorded voEe: AYES: Mr. Marshall, Mrs. Humphris NAYS: None. Mr. Martin Mr. Perkins, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Bowerman and Chairman i977-78 Va. Op. Atty. Gen. 39 P~el *6543 1977-78 Va. Rep. Atty. Gen. 39 Office of the Attorney General Commonwealth of Virginia August I5. 1977 BOARDS OF SUPERVISORS Minutes Of Meetings-What constitutes complete official minutes of proceedings of board. BOARDS OF SUPERVISORS Minutes Of Meetings~Motion which dies for lack of a second is official matter considered by board. COUNTIES Boards Of Supervisors-Minutes of-Should include brief summary of all questions of a pubic nature discussed by board. The Honorable Henry Lee Carter Commonwealth's Attorney for Orange County This is in reply ro your letter concermng the official minutes of the meetings and proceedings of the Orange County Board of Supervisors. You request my opimun in regard m the following matters: 1. May supporting documents relating to Board action be made a part of the official mthures of the proceedings of the Orange County Board of Supervisors and recorded in the Board's minute book? In the alternative, may only a general synopsis of action taken by the Board be recorded on the pages of the minute book with the supperung documents filed in the pocket part of the minute book? 2_ Ma5' a supervisor, in order to adequately mfleet his position on issues before the Board, tender the documents outlined above m the cftairman or clerk of the Board, and thereby cause them to be loOged with and filed with the mmmes of the meeting, even if said documents are not made a part of the minutes by Board action? 3. If a Board member makes a motion and it dies for me lack of a second, should that motion be recorded on the pages of the mhime book? I shall answer your quesnons seriatim. Section 15.1-543 of the Code of Virginia (1950). ns amended, provides: "The boards of supervisors shall cause m be recorded in welt-bound books complete minutes of all their respective meetings and proceedings, including all bids submitted on any building, materials, supplies, work. or project to be let m contract by any such board of supervisors. Such books shall be kept open to public inspection of such minutes at all reasonable times for a period of tltree years afIer the recordation thereof." tn an Opinion to the Honorable W. Cary Crismond. Clerk of the Circuit Court of Spotsylvania County, the Attorney General considered the meaning of the terms "minutes" and "complete" in § 15~248. the predecessor statute to § 15.1-543. In that Opinion, found in Report of the Attorney General t1959-t96~3~ at 77. the Attorney General concluded as follows: ... the official actions of the Board shall be incorporated in the minums. The term minutes' as used in this section means a brief summary of what the Board has considered at the meeting, Of course, all resolutions and ordinances must be transcribed in full. [ believe that the minutes should coutain alt quesoons of a public nature which have been discussed and considered by the Board. even though a determination of such questions may have been deferred instead of being voted upon. The word complete' as used in this section does not. in my opinion, mean thru a stenographic record of the proceedings is required. While the Board is the judge of wlmt it shall have included in the minmes. I do not feel that their judgment should be exercised in such manner as to exclude therefrom any questmn of official nature that has been considered by the Board. ' In light of the above<luoted language. I conclude that the Board's minutes must niclude, as a minimum_ a brief summary of the matters considered by the Board. Supporting documents. which are presented to the Board for background. may be included as a part of the ininutes, flied with the official minnies, or excluded therefrom, at the discretion of the Board. A supervisor may render supporting documents for Copyright (c) West Group 1997 No claim m original U.S. Govt. works ATTACHMENT F t977-78 Va. Op. Arty: Gen, 39 inclusion in the minutes of Board meetings. That body is pot required, however, to accept the documents tendered. As tong as the Board includes within the minutes a brief summary of matters cm~sidered, it is free to accept or reject supporting documents as it deems proper. A motion which dies for the lack of a second is an official matter which has been considered by the Page 2 Board at its meeting. Such matters must be included in the minutes in order to provide a complete record of ali questions of a public nature which were considered and accepted or rejected by the Board. Anthony F. Troy Attorney General Copyright (c) West Group 1997 No claim to original U.S. Govt. works t984-85 Va. Op. Atty. Gen. 427 *3286 1984-85 Va. Rep. Atty. Gen. 427 Office of the Attorney General Conmmnwealth of Virginia October 3t. 1984 VIRGINIA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT. MINUTES. PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC BODY FOR PURPOSES OF ACT AND MUST RECORD MINUTES AT ALL PUBLIC MEETINGS. The Honorable Mitchell Van Yahres Member House of Delegams This is in response to your request for my opinion whether ~he Albemarle County Planning Conmlission ("ACPC") is required by Virginia law to record minutes of its meetings. You specifically cite for my considermion § 15.1-444(d/ of tb.e Code of Virginia. !this section requires a planning commission m "[k]eep a complete record of its proceedings; and be responsible for the cnsmdy and preservation of its papers and documents." The facts which you present indicate that ~e ACPC has tape recordings and rough auras of us proceedings; however, no formal, written minutes are available at present for the nme period of October 1982 through Augusl 1984. The president of Citizens for Albemarle. Inc. has suggested that you propose an amendment lo § [5.1-444(d), requiring planning coramissiuns to keep 'minutes' of all proceedings. All public bodies are required by la~v m record Page I minutes ar all public meetings. See § 2.1-343. a part of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act. §§ 2.1-340 through 2.1-346.1 (the "Act"). The ACPC ts a "public body" for purposes of the Acl and ts. therefore_ subject m the requirements of the Act. See § 2.1-341la), (el. The General Assembly has determined that the provisions of the Act are to be liberally construed so that citizens are aflbrded the opporumiW to witness the operations of govermment. See ~ 2.14340.1: see al~so 1979-1980 Report of the Attorney General a~ 236. il is my opimon, therefore, that in addition m the record-keeping requirements of § 15.1444(d), the ACPC must keep minutes of all public meetings in order to meet its obligation under the Act. See t978-1979 Report of the Attorney General at 313. The Act does not specify the form "minutes" must take. tn the absence of statutory direction ro the contrary, tape recorded minutes would comply with the reqmrements of the Act. inasmuch as recording ks an acceptable method of memorializii~g a meeting. See 1983-1984 Report of the Attorney General at 441 Section 2.1-341(b) defines "official records" as being inclusive of tapes and sound recorthngs; hence, applies to recorded minutes of a meeting. It should be noted, however, that § 2.1-342(a) requires a public body m make official records avmlable for copying, as ~veli as inspection. Such a requkemem should be considered by a public body ~vben determining the form for preparing minutes of irs proceeding. Gerald L. Batites Attorney General Copyright (c) West Group 1997 No claim to original U_S_ Govt. works 1982-83 Va. Op. Arty- Gert_ 722 *4502 1982-83 Va. Rep. Atty. Gert 722 Office of the Attorney General Commonwealth of Virginia September t0, 1982 VIRGINIA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT. "OFFICIAL RECORDS" DO NOT INCLUDE TAPE RECORDINGS MADE AS BACK-UP FOR SHORTHAND NOTES TAKEN TO PREPARE MINUTES OF MEETING, The Honorable Robert E. Kowalsky, Jr, Commonwe~th's Attorney for the Chesapeake City of This is in reply to your letter of August 27. 1982, inquiring whether any provisron of Virginia law prohibits the erasure of tape recordings of school board meetings after lire minutes of the meeting have been prepared. You have advised that shorthand notes are taken during the meeting and later transcribed as mimues of the meeting and that the rape recording is used for reference in case there ts a question in rite transcription of the shorthand notes. The tape is then reused at the next meeting. The Virginia Freedom of Information Act and the Page 1 Virginia Public Records Act (the "Acts% provide for disclosure and reremion of public records. In this case. however, ir appears from the pracuces you describe that the tape recording is not intended to be tire record of the school board meeting, but rather it is intended to serve as an aid in preparing the minutes which are required by the Freedom of Information Act. It is. therefore_ my opinion that the minutes of the meeting would be the records that are governed by each of the Acts and that the rape recordings are simply aids in producing such records. (FND [ am unaware of any other provision of law which would prohibit the erasure of the rapes under the circumstances you describe. Accordingly, I conclude that Virginia law does not prohibit the erasure of tape recordings of a school board meeting which are made for reference purposes in preparing the minutes of the meeting. Gerald L. Baliles Aaorney General FN1 If, however, the tape recordings were intended to be the records of the meeting, they would fall within the purview of the Acts. Copyright (c) West Group 1997 No claim m original U.S. Govt. works COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Office of Board of Supervisors 401 McIn~im Road Charlottesville, Virginia 229024596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins SalIv H. Thomas March 9, t998 Mr. Alan C. Tobias Virginia Deparunent of Rail and Public Transportation 1401 E. Broad Street Richmond, VA 23219-1939 Dear Mr. Tobias: At its March 4, 1998 meeting, the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors adopted the attached resolution endorsing the provision of rail service from Washington, D.C. and Richmond, Virginia, to Bristol, Virgtnia. Sincerely, Laurel B. Hall Senior Deputy Clerk Enclosure cc: Bob Tucker Printed on recucIed ~:~ver COUNTY OF ALBEMA I oFsupERwsoR EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Comprehensive Services Act (CSA1 Supplemental Funding Request SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Information on the Community Policy and Management Team's Supplemental Request to the State for additional CSA pool funds. STAFF CONTACT(S): Tucker, White, Ralston AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTACH MENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: X BACKGROUND: The Comprehensive ServicesAct (CSA), implemented in 1995, is the pdmary funding source for at dsk children and families that enter the foster care, residential special education or juvenile court systems. The fund is managed by the Community Policy and Management Team (CPMT) comprised of the directors of Social Services, Community Services Board, Dept. Of Health, Court Services and Special Education along with some specifically appointed community representatives. Children and families served with these funds are mandated to be served by the Code and include 1) children placed forpurposes of special education; 2) disabled children placed by local social services orthe court in pdvate residential facilities and whose Individual Education Program (IEP) indicates such schooling is appropriate and needed; 3) foster care children; and 4) childre~ and families served to prevent foster care placement. Additionally, certain groups of children and families are considered targeted groups and include 1) children placed by a juvenile and domestic relations distdct court and 21 children committed to the Department of Juvenile Justice and placed in a pdvate or locally operated public facility or nonresidential program. These children are not considered mandated but could easily become mandated if they are not served. To provide these services, the Comprehensive Services Act requires that localities match the state funds at the same ratio as their HealthDepartment matching rate. For Albemarle, the match rate is 45% local funds, 55% state funds. Each year the State allocates a pool of funds to each locality based on a 94/95 base year with slight adjustments for growth. For FY 97/98, Albemarle's total pool is $1,349,307, $603,114 in local funds and $746,193 in state funds. Since most localities are not able to meet the mandated services within their initial pool allocation, the State allows localities to submitsupplemental funding requests based on the CPMT's best estimate of projected costs for the remainder of the year. For FY 98 the Community Policy and Management Team (CPMT) will be submitting a supplemental funding request to the state for $1,077,847 to address the dramatic rise in Albemade's foster care case load. The FY 98 supplemental request is discussed below. DISCUSSION: The supplemental request to the state for $1,077,847 will require a 45% local match of $485,031. Of that amount, the County has approximately $105,O00 in FY 96/97 carry-over funds in the CSA fund and $129,000 in local funds that were budgeted over the required match in the Department of Social Services FY 98 budget. Therefore. the remaining local dollars that the County would need to allocate at the end of the year is approximately $250,000. This estimate is based on 101 foster care children currently under DSS custody at an average cost of $200,000 per month with an expectation of eight more children coming into foster care in the next month. Staff is pursuing Virginia Community Crime Control Act (VJCCCA) funds for some of the unmandated court cases, which may be able to reduce the need for additional funds by approximately $35: O00. ,AGENDA TITLE: Comprehensive Services Act (CSA) SupplementalFunding Request March 4~ 1998 Page 2 The CPMT has taken several measures over the past few years to curtail spending in this program. However, the driving force behind the current increase is: 1) the number of children entering foster care and; 2) the sevedty of emotional and behavioral problems of the children. Forty two children have been taken into care since July 1997 compared with 48 children for the entira prewous year. We anticipate eight more children coming into care within the next month; two due to be'rog released from Beaumont Learning Center and six from our child protective services caseload. The percentage of cases requinng specialized care has grown steadily since 1994 costing the system an average of $30,000 per year per child. Temporary care for seriously emotionally disturbed children with a history of aggressiveness, chronic runaway behavior and/or suicidal behavior can cost as much as $300 per day to maintain them in a secure setting in order to stabilize them enough to transition to a less restrictive and less costly setting. (See attached charts). A complete analysis of these increases has not been completed by the CPMT. However, factors, we believe to be contributing to the increases include: 1) an increasing urbanized population; 2) increase in overall population and 3} a shift in family praservation efforts to shorter time frames before removal. Other factors may include changes in the poverty population and fewer op§ons for local placements resulting in higher cost placements outside the community. The CPMT has implemented several cost control measures that are working well. However, they cannot be effective at keeping costsdown while the number of children being orderedinto care, either through court intervention or child protective service intervention is dramatically increasing. Following are policies implemented bythe CPMT to try and control costs: All foster care cases are referred to the state Division of Child Support Enforcement for establishment of support. Currently these cases represent 62% of the caseload. Since Ju~y we have collected $ 5,157. The average COllection for foster care is between $200-$300 monthly. Although small compared to the cost of care in most: cases, these payments help defray the total cost of the child's care. Allparents in non-foster care cases are expected to contribute to the cost of care fortheir children. While most parents are unable to contribute significantt~, to the cost of services, it is our poticy that all should contribute based on ability to pay, however limited. Alternative funding sources are aggressively pursued. Federal IV-E foster care funds pay for room, board and clothing for 75% of the current foster care caseload Medicaid, private insurance and SSI defray the costs of medical and psychological care in most cases depending on the vendor. Juvenile Justice funding is used to the extent possible for children served through the court services unit. The CPMT has developed automated financial reports to track and analyze expenditures on a case by case basis, as well as on a program basis. This year, an analysis of the 36 cases in residential facilities was completed indicating that services were not only necessary, Put that lower cost alternatives were not available. The CPMT has created a full time case manager, using pdmadly Medicaid funds, to assist the pool agencies in efforts to support foster care prevention, to keep foster care children in community placements and to closely monitor non-foster care residential placements. This year the CPMT finalized a new vendor contract with tighter specifications for fiscal accountability and reporting on services provided. The CPMT has developed a Utilization Review process (required by the General Assembly) that will review cases on a sevedty scale to determine whether services are appropriate for the child(ten). The state suggested model has already been put in place by the CPMT. Furthermore, the process established by the CPMT is a joint system for both Charlottesville and Albemarle County. Since Charlottesville is not experiencing the same increased funding demands this year as Albemarle, the increases do not seem to be attributable to a weakness in the cost control system, but more to a greater number of children in need in Albemarle County. AGENDA TITLE: Comprehensive Services Act (CSA) Supplemental Funding Request March 4, 1998 Page 2 A recent review ef other CPMTs around the state indicates that Albemarle is not alone, but shares similar increases with counties surrounding urban areas, as well as urban areas in general. The number of Albemarle youth served with CSA funds increased by43% from 1996-'1997. In the same time pedod, Stafford County increased by 71%, James City County by 208%, Roanoke County by 53%, Franklin County by 48%, Bedford County by 30%, Montgomery County by 41% and Floyd County by 257%. Cities compared similarly. While Chartoffesville increased by 21%, Waynesboro increased by 115%, Lynchburg by 39%, Newport News by 29% and Hampton by 29%. Attached is a list of the high cost foster care placements made by the Department of Social Services this year. As you can see by the bdef descriptions of the children placed, the behavioral and emotional problems faced by these children are sign'~icant. Children with these types of needs cannot be placed in Iow cost foster homes, especially in the initial phase of their care. Finally, a recent study by JLARC resulted in several bills being introduced in the General Assembly regarding CSA. One bill would allow Medicaid funds f.o be used for most of the services currently funded out of CSA pool funds. If passed, this bill could offer some relief to localities experiencing these cost increases, if the state was able to pull down Medicaid funds on a 50%/50% state/federal match and AIbemarle's local match remained the same, Albemarle would be able to access Medicaid funds at roughly a 23% match, rather than state pool funds at a 45% match. RECOMMENDATION: This information is brought forward at this time to keeo the Board apprised of the impending local financial responsibilities for mandated foster care. Unless significant changes occur between now'and June, the Board needs to anticipate additional funding in the amount of $200,000 to $250,000 for required CSA match funds at the end of the fiscal year. 98.035 New Foster Care Cases (Chart ~ 3O 10 1992 1993 1994 i995 1996 1997 1998 Fiscal Year New Cases Requiring Specialized Placement (Chart #2) 50 15 t0 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 l~scal Year [] New Cases [] Req. Spec. Placement % of New Foster Care Cases Requiring Speciuiized Placement (Chart #3) Specialized and Residential Care Cases Over the Last 24 Months (Chart #4) 1oo ~ . ~ 75 5o ~.~:..: . 25 o 1994 t995 1996 Fiscal Year 1997 1998 35 36 2(9-; ............... I(L: $: 0 6 12 Month 18 24 Foster Care Caseload Trend Over Ten Years 6O 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 Year New Foster Care Cases Since July 1997 Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Month Foster Care Youth 16 and Up (ILP) (Chart 6) ~'~ 25i ~ 20 15 ~c~ o 1988 1992 '24. 23 22, 1995 1996 1997 1998 Fiscal Year 0 U 0 O 0 © 0 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE AGENDA TITLE: December 1997 Financial Report SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: December 1997 Financial Report for the General, School, and Capital Funds STAFF CONTACT(S): Ms. White, Messrs. Tucker, Breeden, Waiters BACKGROUND: AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: CONSENTAGEND~ ACTION: X ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: Yes / Attached are the December 31, 1997 Mont~ [y Financial Reports for the General, School, and Capital Funds. General Fund revenue projections were revised as of December 31,1997. Preliminary estimates indicate that General Property Tax collections will be approximately $1.7 million less than budgeted. Permit fees and the GE loan repayment will help offset the estimated reduction in property tax collections resulting in a net estimated revenue reduction of $1,4 million. General Fund expenditure projections have been revised to reflect a 2% holdback for operating expenses and a holdback of $499~329 in the capital trensfer to reflect deferred 1998 capital projects. Education revenue projections have been revised to reflect a $1.1 million General Fund holdback, Education expenditure projections reflect a 7.5% holdback, net compensation adjustment, RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends acceptance of the December 1997 Financial Report. 98.027 I-- ,-I I.- LU ~o ~ LU W 0 ~ w~ ~ ~ ~< ~z ~ O~ ~ ~ O~zwOoZ ~ ~<0>0~ ~J Z ~n r~ Z - ABG 'FINANCIAL SERVICES. INC. February 18, 1998 Box 8 CHU~CHV,LLE, ~L~tTM SUPER¥1SORS 410-879-9918 Fax 410-838-5360 72-25-}8P3 :55 RCVi Ms. Arlene Hemandez Assistant Treasurer The Bank of New York 101 Barclay Street, 21W New York, New York 10286 Re: Arbor Crest Apartments (Hydraur ¢ Road Apts.) Dear Ms. Hemandez: Enclosed please find a copy of the Bond Program Report for the above referenced project for the month of February 1998. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call me. Sincerely, SheilaH. Moynihan ~' Project Monitor /shm enclosure cc:Ms. Ella W. Carey, Clerk, CMC Albemarle County Board of Supervisors 401 Mclnfire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Effective January 31, 1998 MONTHLY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 7(a) OF THE DEED RESTRICTIONS ABG Associates, Inc. 300 El L~rd Street Baltimore, Maryland 21202 RE.- Hydraulic Road Apartments -ArborCrestApartments Charlottesville, Virginia Pursuant to Section 7(a) of the Deed Restrictions (the "Deed Restrictions"), as defined in an Indenture of Trust dated as of April 1, 1983, between the Industrial Development Authority of Albemarle County~ Virginia (the "Authority")~ and your bank~ as trustee, the undersigned authorized representative of Richmond-Albemarle Limited Partnership, a Virginia Limited Partnership (the "Purchaser"), hereby certifies with respect to the operation and management of Hydraulic Road Apartments, Charlottesville, Virginia (the "Project"), that as of the date shown below: 1) The number of units in the Project occupied by lower income tenants is 14 The number of units in the Project unoccupied and held available for Lower Income Tenants is -0- 3) The number of units rented and the number of units held available for rental other than as described (1) and (2) is 52 . in 4) The percentage that the number of units described in (1) and (2) hereof constitute of the total number of units in the Project is 21% . 5) The information contained in this report is true, accuzate and correct as of the date hereof. 6) As of the date hereof, the Purchaser is not in default under any covenant or agreement contained in the Deed Restrictions or in an Agreement of Sale dated as of April 1, 1983, between the Authority and the Purchaser. IN WITN~SS WHEREOF. the undersigned has signed this Report as of eDruary 5, 1998 RICHMOND-ALBEMARLE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, a Virginia limited partnership Authorized Representative - ~ I~OflD* PROGRA&[ REPORT ~nth Januar}~ Y~af 1998 P~olberly: I.o~ati0n:' Charlottesville, VA Subm,;te¢ ~y** Loretta Wyatt Ma~.~r L LOW[R INC;OME Arbor Crest Apartments (Hydraulic Road A~ts.)~o~l: 051-35371 Numb~ofUmts 66 7ebruary 5, 1998 Effective 1/31/98 DiTe Total Occupied 66 Bond Occupied 14 Arbor Crest Dr 21. Beverly T, Lane Arbor Crest Dr 22 Wilma M. Atkinson Arbor Crest Dr 23 Ruth Jones Arbor Crest Dr 24 Virginia Burton Arbor Crest Dr ~5 Betty L. Reed 18 Arbor Crest Dr 26. Ann S. Kemp 30 Arbor Crest Dr 27 Mary Cox Allen 44 Arbor Crest Dr ~, 70 Arbor. Crest Dr t0 76 Arbor Crest Dr 84 Arbor Crest Dr Sam Atherton 29 Ernest M. Nease Ann G. Saylor Juanita Boliek 12. 88 Arbor Crest Dr 32. Nancy G, Foley ~3 90 Arbor Crest Dr 33 Betty B. Elliott ~ ~4 Arbor Crest Dr 34 M. Eileen Knick ~5 .. 35 t6 36 t ? ~$ 38 20 40 41 . 61. 42 . ~.. 43. ~3. 4.4 64. 4.5, 45 ~.. 48- 68 49. 5} , 71. 52 72 53 73. ~ 74. 55 75. 77. , ~' 56 Arbor Crest Dr Harlan W. Hooe ! 41 I 11.. 2 12 2 ,, 12. 3 13 3. 13. 4_ 14 .,, 4., 14. 6 16., 6 18. 7 17 7 17, 8 18 .. $- 18_ 9 19 9 19. 10 20 10., 20, To: Members, Board of Supervisors From: Ella Washington Carey, CMC, Clerk,~'~-~' Subject: Reading List for March 4. 998 Date: February 27. 1998 Apri 0, 996: Page - 10-Mrs. Humpnns Pages 0 - eno - Mr. Perkins November 6. 996: Pages ] - Pages 5 - Mrs. Thomas Pages 15 (Item # 10) - end - Mr, Martin /ewc COUNTY OF ALBEMAI EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Albemarle County Six Year Primary Road Improvement Plan. SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Revisions to County recommendations for road improvements to be presented at the 1998 VDOT Pre- Allocation Public Hearing on the Interstate, Primary and Urban Systems Plan. STAFF CONTACT~S): Messrs. Tucker, Cilimberg, Benish, Wade AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: X CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: BACKGROUND: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Yes (2) On February 4. 1998, staff presented the Board of Supervisors with recommendations for primary road improvements to be presented at the VDOT pre-allocation public hearing. The hearing will be held at the Culpeper District Offices April 2, 1998. DISCUSSION: Attached is a revised draft of the County's list of recommendations based on the Board's prior rewew and comments. Also attached is a draft speech for presentation at the pre-allocation hearing. RECOMMENDATION: For Board review and approval 98.028 VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 1998 SPRING PRE-ALLOCATION MEETING ]FOR THE INTERSTATE, PRIMARY, AND URBAN SYSTEMS, AND FOR MASS TRANSIT RECOMMENDED ALBEMARLE COUNTY PRIORITIES The following addresses Albemarle County's priorities for each allocation of the Intermodal Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA) and each sub-allocation of the Surface Transportation Program (STP) funds. Surface Transportation Program (ST?] Standard Pr~ ects: The following projects, listed in priority order, are eligible for STP funds not set aside. The County supports these projects as referenced. 1) Undertake those Charlottesville Area Transportation Study (CATS) projects eligible for the primary program in sequence as called for in the February 2, 1992 joint resolution between the City, County and University and agreed to by VDOT. In addition to Route 29 improvements already underway, construct Meadow Creek Parkway from the Route 250 Bypass to Route 29 North. The Parkway is the County's next highest priority project, and is of the utmost importance in order to maintain an adequate level of service on Route 29 and to improve the overall roadway system sereing the urbanizing area north of the City. The first phase of this project from the Route 250 Bypass to Rio Road is being funded in the County's secondary program. In an effort to further this project, the County also is receiving funding within its Secondary Priority Plan for planning and design of the Meadow Creek Parkway from Rio Road to Route 29 North. However, it is not possible to construct this project solely with secondary funding due to the cost and dramatic impact it will have on the timing for completion of other important secondary projects. The County believes the Parkway will meet the criteria for inclusion in the primary system. With the Commonwealth Transportation Board's decision to eliminate the Route 29 interchanges, the County believes primary funds should be redirected to the Parkway and wants to work with VDOT staff to evaluate construction of subsequent phases as a primary road, provided it will accelerate the Parkway's completion. VDOT is urged to investigate all possible funding sources to achieve the quickest construction of this vitally important roadway. Other projects listed in CATS in the northern urbanized area also should be actively pursued. 2) The County is closely following the Route 29 Corridor Study. The Route 29 North Corridor Study reconanendations were forwarded to the Commonwealth Transportation Board last year with the County's endorsement. The recommendations emphasized use of an access management approach in lieu of a limited access road design (recommendations provided 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) 8) 9) as Attachmenl A). It is hoped that the Commonwealth Transportation Board will act favorably on these recommendations and implement them in developing plans for the third phase of the Route 29 widening project from the South Fork of the Rivanna River to the Akport/Proffit Road intersectior~ The Route 29 South Corridor Study is in the early stages, with a consultant now hired and the first Steering Committee meeting recently held in Lyncburg. R is desired that high priority once again be established for public input in this study's process, including public hearings in Albemarle County. Undertake the widening of Route 20 south from I~64 to the Route 20/742 connector mad that will serve the traffic from Monticello High School. Construct sidewalks and bike lane facilities on both sides of Route 29 from the South Fork of the Rivanna River to Airport Road (Route 649). Undertake road projects parallel to the Route 29 North Corridor which will relieve traffic on Route 29. Widen Route 250 west from Emmet Street to the Route 29/250 Bypass~ This section is covered by a joint design study by the City, County and University of Virginia and was recognized for improvement in the Lewis Mountain Neighborhood Study. The joint study should be used as a guide in developing the widening plans. The remaining portions of Rt~ 250 West to Yancey Mills (the 1-64/250 interchange) is now under study by VDOT to determine long term needs for this road. VDOT will also conduct a similar study of Rt. 250 East from Frae Bridge to the Fluvauna County line. The County supports and appreciates this effort and encourages public participation and consideration of recommendations. Present the recommendations of the VDOT corridor study of Route 240 in Crozet (pending completion) to the County and improve Route 240 in accord with County recommendations regarding this study. Undertake improvements of Fontaine Avenue from Jefferson Park Avenue to the improvements along the frontage of the University Real Estate Foundation development. The County supports the recommendations identified by the Fontaine Avenue Task Force. Undertake improvements to the Bellair/Route 250 intersection as generally proposed at the VDOT Location and Design Public Hearing. 2 Safety Improvements: Several projects in the County seem m qualify under this 10% set-aside. They are, in priority order: 1) Construct pedestrian walkways along various primary routes with'm the County's Urban Neighborhoods, in particular: 1) Route 20 north from Route 250 to Wilton Farm Apartments and Darden Towe Park; 2) Route 20 south from the City Ime to the new Route 20/742 connector road; 3) along Route 250 east in the Pantops area as an extension to existing sidewalks; and, 4) along Route 250 west from City to Bypass (as part of the overall improvements to this road). Of these, the walkways along Route 20 north are the most important improvement. Pedestrian travel along this road has increased significantly with the development of the Wilton Farm Apartments. Residents have raised concerns with the safety of walking along this segment of road as currently constructed. 2) Installation of traffic signals at the 1-64 interchange of Route 250 east; at Route 22 and Route 250; Route 729 and Route 250 east; and the 1-64 interchange at Fifth Street. 3) Improvements to Route 250 west along the business corridor in Ivy (from just east of the intersection of Route 637 to just west of the intersection of Route 678) to address existing and short-term traffic circtflation problems, including access to developed properties in this area. The Route 250 West Corridor Study currently underway should address these safety improvements. 4) Improvements to the Route 240 underpass at the CSX Railroad tracks in Crozet. 5) Functional plans for Route 20 North and South for alignmem improvements. Functional plans, including an analysis of possible safety Improvements, for Routes 22 and 231. The County remains concerned with overall public safety as it relates to traffic created by large tracks along these road segments, and encourages all appropriate measures be considered to ensure that tracks travel safely along these roadways in the future. Restriction of through truck traffic is still considered the most effective measure by the County. Enhancement Projects: Several projects appear to be eligible for enhancement funds. They are, in priority order: 1) Construction of pedestrian walkways. (see #1, Safety Improvements above). 2) Beautification of entrance corridors (particularly Route 20, 29 and Route 250) and Airport Road connecting Route 29 and the Charlottesville/Albemarle A'~port - landscaping, signage, placement of overhead ufflities underground. 3) 4) 5) Construction of bikeway facilities as prioritized in the Bicycle Plan for the City of Charlottesville and Albemarle County (adopted by the Board of Supervisors as an element of the Comprehensive Plan on July 17, 1991). Development of portions of the Rivauna River Greenway path system. Removal of non-conforming billboards. National Highway System (NITS) The Charlottesville-Albemarle MPO Policy Board approved the NHS as proposed by VDOT in this area excluding the Route 29 Bypass. The Federal Highway Administration CFHWA) has approved the NHS which includes the existing Route 29 and the Route 29 Bypass. The County's highest priority project in the proposed NHS is the completion of the widening of Route 29 North from the Corporate limits of Charlottesville m Airport Road. The County desires to continue active participation in Route 29 Corridor studies, including the Route 29 Corridor Study south of Charlottesville which is currently underway. The County will monitor the progress and recommendations of the Route 29 Corridor Studies which are part of the NHS (additional information is provided under Standard Projects #2). Congestion Mitigation and Air Oualitv Improvement Program This does not apply to Albemarle County. The County is not in an area of non-attainment for ozone or carbon monoxide. 4 US Route 29 Corridor Development Study Recommendation on Findings and Conclusions US Route 29 Corridor Development Study A Resolution that Presents the Study Team's Findings and the Steering Committee's Conclusions and Recommendations for Future Actions. WHEREAS, in regard to the US Route 29 Corridor Development Study, the Steering Committee acknowledges: That the US Route 29 Corridor was identified in the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA) of 1991 as a Corridor of National Significance and that a t~asibility study should be completed to determine the most effective way to provide a continuous, efficient roadway as pan of the National Highway System. This Feasibility Study was designated as the US Route 29 Corridor Development Study. As a feasibility study, this is tbe first phase ora continuing developmental process that would require more detailed investigation and evaluation before specific improvements could be approved and/ur implemented. That the designation of US Route 29 as a Corridor of National Significance indicates its role as part of the National Highway System. It also has an importance m serving the [ravel needs of the Commonwealth of Virginia and the local travel needs of the citizens and businesses located within the corridor. Any improvements to US Route 29 would be for the purpose of preserving and enhancing mobility and access within and through the corridor while conserving the character of the US Route 29 Corridor as a part of the Virginia countryside. That if any improvemems to US Rome 29 were proposed based on the determination of feasibility, that this Study would serve as the basis for further developing an Environmental Document to satisfy the requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969. 4. That as part of this process to determine feasibility, a set of Evaluation Criteria was developed as part of the ongoing efforts of the various agencies and officials involved in the Study. That the Study--directed by the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT)and a Study Team of professional planners and scientists--followed the requirements of ISTEA regarding such studies and developed the required documentation of potential impacts and benefits for the preliminary concepts considered. Attached are the Study Team's findings and technical recommendations. That a public participation program lnctuded a series of public informational meetings. The program wm enhanced to include workshops with local groups and a modified format for public meetings which included not only an interactive information displaybut also a Question and Answer Panel Session which provided an opportunity for citizens and officials'to share concerns and obtain informatbn about various aspects of the Study and the preliminary concepts under consideration. That the Study was conducted with opportunities for public input and that the costs and benefits of the transportation concepts presented were discussed with the public. Moreover, it is the understanding of the Steering Committee that issues were investigated and analyzed, including but not limited to the following: Steering Committee Resolution Page I August 12, 1996 US Route 29 Corridor Development Study Recommendation on Findingg and Conclusions Travel Demands and Transportation Deficiencies. Through the analysis ofthe existing and future travel demands both within and through the corridor, transportation deficiencies were identified based on, but not limited to, the following: Growth in population and employment within the study corridor is projected to double over the next 25 years with variations in the rate of growth among the localities. This growth in the corridor will generate local travel demands. The role of US Route 29 as a regional carrier will also result in an increase in travel demand This growth in local and regional traffic will result in congestion in the corridor along segments of US Route 29 and at a number of intersections without the implementation of access management strategies. US Route 29 provides intermodal connections with the airports and transit stations in the corridor; in addition, there are limited facilities for bicycle travel along the corridor. There are currently some areas with safety problems and these will only get worse with an increase in traffic and access to and from US Route 29. Analysis of Transportation Alternatives. A range of conceptual transportation tmprovements within the US Route 29 Corridor were considered including alternative highway improvements, improvements to existing highways, and the impacts of theNo-Build or Base Case scenario. In addition, issues related to safety, congestion mitigation, and the preservation of the capacity of the existing US Route 29 using modified land use poli~ies were also taken into account. Environmental Impacts. As a growing region in the Commonwealth, the issues related to air qnality, noise pollution, scenic qualities wetland impacts, loss of farmland, protection of endangered spedes and habitat and other sensitive areas were analyzed. Cultural Impacts. An inventory was completed of the Local, State, and Federal historic, cultural and archaeological sites and the impacts thetransportation concepts would have on these sites were identified Economic and Social Impacts. The individual and community disruptions of the concepts were tabulated. A general analysis for the economic effects of the ~ttematives on the developed centers in the study corridor:-as well as tourism in general--was completed including the implications of alternatives to planned land use patterns and future developments. Finally, that the Study Team's Findings, noted above and documented in a series of Technical Memoranda and Technical Reports, were developed as part of the Study based on a multi-discipline study process and activities as described above. Steering Committee Resolution Page 2 August 12, 1996 US Route 29 Corridor Development Study Recommendation on Findings and Conclusions Now therefore be it resolved by the US Route 29 Corridor Development Study Steering Committee: That based on an assessment of the Study Team evaluations as well as comments and inputs received from citizens and agencies at a series of public meetings and workshops, neither the No Action Option nor the Continuous Limited Access Highway Option through the Corridorare acceptable options. 2. That the goal for this section ofthe US Route 29 Corridor is that rural sections ofthe h ~ghway should operate at least at Level of Service C and that the urban sections operate at least at Level of Service D. 3. That we recognize the need for integrated and improved intermodal facilities along or adjacent to the corridor and encourage the development of air, rail, bicycle and other modes of travel. That the Commonwealth Transportation Board (Board) support the nextphase of implementation which is to ask the localities to work together to develop in detail anAccess Management Plan (AMP) for that portion of US Route 29 from Warrenton to Charlottesville The AMP will recognize the fact that roads, industries, commerce, residences, and farms are all uses of land. The AMP wll include modifications of each component to achieve the best mix to meet the goals for theUS Route 29 Corridor as they relate m local, state, and national users. The Access Management Plan may recommend modifications to existing land use plans and policies of the jurisdictions within the corridor in combination with physical transportation improvements in order to adequately address future travel demands for local, regional, and interregional travel. This recommendation by the Steering Committee encourages the local jurisdictions to join in creating and adopting the AMP as a portion of their respective Comprehensive Plans with the following understandings: Development of the Access Management Plan would include a public involvement program which meaningfully involves the poblic--as outlined in ISTEA--in selecting the mix of improvements and solutions that will best solve the transportation and land use problems along US Route 29 from Charlottesville to Warrenton to provide the appropriate measures for adequate accessibility and molility. The modifications to the land use policiesto be considered would include those changes which would provide access management of US Route 29. Physical transportation improvements to be studied include--but should not be limited to-4hoseto US Route 29 and other existing roads, addition of secondary roads, improvements at intersections, access management techniques and strategies, transportation demand management strategies, and transportatbn systems management strategies. That the Access Management Plan should be carried out in a manner consistent with the National Environmental Policy Act process. The AMP would support the required environment documents that would have to be completed later. Steering Committee Resolution Page 3 August 12, 1996 US Route 29 Corridor Development Study Recommendation on Findings and Conclusions 6. That the following are some of the suggested goals and components for the Access Management Plan: Develop a plan and recommendations for tiffs section of the US Route 29 corridor in Virginia. Encourage cooperation with the studies on the segments to the north and south to achieves plan that will be consistent for the corridor. Recognize that local options and needs vary within the corridor. Develop a process which will result in improvements responsive to local goals and objectives. Include local citizens and agencies as part of the process to develop responses to travel demand increases either through changes to land use policies or by roadway ~mprovements. Acknowledge that the mix of land uses affects US Route 29. Growth pressures have the potential to increase congestion and decrease access and mobility on US Route 29. Identify those land use or access management controls which can best meet the goals for level of service and other aspects along the Corridor. Institute a process for implementation of individual improvements that respect and are consistent with the overall AMP. Seek funding for the establishment of a corridor committee comprised of representatives from the localities, for the developmentofan Access Management Plan and for the ultimate implementation of an Access Management Plan from the Federal Highway Admhistration, VDOT or other sources. That the necessary legislation be enacted and funding ~ provided by the State Legislature by July 1, 1997 to establish a corridor committee to develop (with public participation) and inplement this Access Management Plan. Thatthe Commomvealth Transportation Board consider these recommendations. It further requests that the Board encourage eacb local jurisdiction to adopt the eonceptand implementation of an Access Management Plan as a portion of their respective Comprehensive Plans. Adopted by unanimous consent by those present of the Steering Committee of the US Route 29 Corridor Development Study at its meeting on August 12th, 1996. Steering Committee Resolution Page 4 August 12, 1996 STATEMENT OF ALBEMARLE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS COMMONWEALTH TRANSPORTATION BOARD PRE-ALLOCATION HEARING ON INTERSTATE AND PRIMARY SYSTEMS CULPEPER DISTRICT (APRIL 2, 1998) GOOD MORNING, I AM FORREST MARSHALL, CHAIRMAN OF THE ALBEMARLE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A FEW BRIEF COMMENTS ABOUT OUR PRIMARY ROAD NEEDS ON BEHALF OF ALBEMARLE COUNTY MY COMMENTS FOCUS ON THE NATIONAL HIGHWAY SYSTEM AND SURFACE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM AND ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE PRIORITIES SUBMITTED TO YOU LAST YEAR. THEY ARE FOUNDED ON THE PROJECTS IDENTIFIED IN THE CHARLOTTESVILLE AREA TRANSPORTATION STUDY (CATS) AND ON THE MUTUAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA, COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE AND COMMONWEALTH TRANSPORTATION BOARD REGARDING THE PHASING OF THESE AND OTHER ROAD PROJECTS. ADHERENCE TO THESE PLANS IS ABSOLUTELY CRITICAl TO ADDRESSING THE TRANSPORTATION NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITY. S URFA CE TRANSPOR TA TION PR 0 GRAM THERE ARE SEVERAL IMPROVEMENTS THAT WE OFFER FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. THESE ARE MORE DEFINITiVELY ADDRESSED 1N A REPORT WE WILL LEAVE WITH YOUR STAFF. THEY INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING SURFACE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM (STP) PROJECTS: STANDARD PROJECTS INCLUDE: UNDERTAKING CATS PROJECTS AS OUTLINED 1N OUR MUTUAL AGREEMENT, WITH PARTICULAR EMPHASIS ON THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE MEADOW CREEK PARKWAY. 1N ADDITION TO THE COMPLETION OF THE IMPROVEMENTS TO ROUTE 29 FROM HYDRAULIC ROAD TO AIRPORT ROAD, THE PARKWAY IS THE COUNTY'S HIGHEST PRIORITY PROJECT. WITH THE COMMONWEALTH TRANSPORTATION BOARD'S DECISION NOT TO CONSTRUCT THE INTERCHANGES ON ROUTE 29, THE NEED FOR THE PARKWAY WILL BECOME EVEN MORE CRITICAL TO MAINTAINING AN ADEQUATE LEVEL OF SERVICE ON ROUTE 29. THE COUNTY HAS REQUESTED CONSIDERATION OF THE MEADOW CREEK PARKWAY FOR PRIMARY FUNDING FOR THE PAST SEVEN YEARS. THE COUNTY WILL ALSO FOLLOW WITH GREAT INTEREST THE ROUTE 29 CORRIDOR STUDIES. IT IS THE BOARD'S HOPE THAT THE COMMONWEALTH TRANSPORTATION BOARD WILL ACT FAVORABLY ON THE 2 RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ROUTE 29 NORTH CORRIDOR STUDY. IT IS ALSO THE BOARD'S HOPE THAT THE ROUTE 29 SOUTH CORRIDOR STUDY WILL CONTINUE TO EMPHASIZE PUBLIC INPUT iN THE STUDY PROCESS. UNDERTAKING THE WIDENING OF ROUTE 20 SOUTH FROM 1-64 ro THE PROPOSED ROUTE 742/20 CONNECTOR ROAD THAT WILL SERVE TRAFFIC FROM THE NEW MONTICELLO HIGH SCHOOL. CONSTRUCTiNG SIDEWALK AND BIKELANE FACILITIES ON BOTH SIDES OF ROUTE 29 FROM THE SOUTH FORK RIVANNA RIVER TO ROUTE 649 (AIRPORT/PROFFIT ROAD). UNDERTAKING PROJECTS PARALLEL TO ROUTE 29 WHICH RELIEVE TRAFFIC ON ROUTE 29, SUCH AS THE GREENBRIER/SEMINOLE SQUARE CONNECTOR. WIDENING ROUTE 250 WEST FROM EMMET STREET TO ROUTE 29/250 BYPASS. THIS SECTION IS COVERED BY A JOINT CITY, COUNTY, AND UNIVERSITY OF VIRGiNIA APPROVED DESIGN STUDY, THE IVY ROAD DESIGN STUDY. THIS STUDY SHOULD BE USED AS A GUIDE iN THE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT OF THIS PROJECT. PRESENTiNG THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ROUTE 240 FUNCTIONAL STUDY iN CROZET ONCE COMPLETE. UNDERTAKING IMPROVEMENTS ro FONTAINE AVENUE FROM JEFFERSON PARK AVENUE TO THE IMPROVEMENT ALONG THE FRONTAGE OF THE UNIVERSITY REAL ESTATE FOUNDATION DEVELOPMENT. THESE IMPROVEMENTS SHOULD REFLECT THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE FONTAINE AVENUE TASK FORCE. UNDERTAKING IMPROVEMENTS TO THE BELLAIRJROUTE 250 WEST INTERSECTION. SAFETY PROJECTS INCLUDE: CONSTRUCTING SIDEWALKS ALONG VARIOUS PRIMARY ROUTES WITHIN THE COUNTY'S URBAN NEIGHBORHOOD, ESPECIALLY ALONG ROUTE 20 NORTH FROM ROUTE 250 TO WILTON FARM APARTMENTS AND DARDEN TO WE PARK. INSTALLING TRAFFIC SIGNALS AT 1-64 INTERCHANGE OF ROUTE 250 EAST; AT ROUTE 22 AND ROUTE 250; ROUTE 729 AND ROUTE 250 EAST; AND, THE 1-64 INTERCHANGE AT FIFTH STREET. IMPROVING ROUTE 250 WEST ALONG THE BUSINESS CORRIDOR IN IVY IN ACCORD WITH THE ULTIMATE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ROUTE 250 WEST CORRIDOR STUDY CURRENTLY UNDERWAY. 4. LMPROVING THE ROUTE 240 UNDERPASS AT THE CSX RAILROAD IN CROZET. DEVELOPING FUNCTIONAL PLANS FOR ROUTE 20 NORTH AND SOUTH, AND ROUTES 22 AND 231, FOR ALIGNMENT AND SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS. ENHANCEMENT PR 0 JE CTS INCLUDE: CONSTRUCTING PEDESTRIAN WALKWAYS ALONG SELECTED PRIMARY ROAD SECTIONS. BEAUTIFICATION OF ENTRANCE CORRIDORS, PARTICULARLY ROUTE 20 SOUTH, ROUTE 29 AND ROUTE 250. CONSTRUCTING BIKEWAY FACILITIES AS RECOMMENDED IN THE BICYCLE PLAN FOR CHARLOTTESVILLE AND ALBEMARLE COUNTY. 4. DEVELOPING PORTIONS OF THE RIVANNA GREENWAY PATH SYSTEM. 5. REMOVING NON-CONFORMING BILLBOARDS. NATIONAL HIGHWA Y SYSTEM THE CHARLOTTESVILLE-ALBEMARLE MPO POLICY BOARD APPROVED THE NHS AS PROPOSED BY VDOT IN THIS AREA EXCLUDING THE ROIYI'E 29 BYPASS. THE FHWA HAS APPROVED AN NHS WHICH INCLUDES THE EXISTING ROUTE 29 AND THE ROUTE 29 BYPASS. THE COUNTY'S HIGHEST PRIORITY PROJECT IN THE PROPOSED NHS IS THE WIDENING OF ROUTE 29 NORTH FROM THE CORPORATE LIMITS OF CHARLOTTESVILLE TO AIRPORT ROAD. THE COUNTY DESIRES TO CONTINUE ACTIVE PARTICIPATION IN ROUTE 29 CORRIDOR STUDIES, AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ROUTE 29 NORTH CORRIDOR STUDY. WE THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THESE ISSUES AND IF QUESTIONS ARISE, OF IF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IS NEEDED REGARDING OUR RECOMMENDATIONS, PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO CONTACT ME OR A MEMBER OF OUR COUNTY STAFF. I:\GENERAL~SI-IARELIUA N~SPEECH.WP 8C, RD OF SUPERVISoRs February 26, 1998 ALBEMARLE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Office of the School Board 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville. Virginia 22902-4596 Mr. Forrest Marshall. Chairman Albemarle County Board of Supervisors 401 McIutire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Mr. Marshall: This letter transmits the Albemarle County Board's Proposed Operating Budget for FY 1998-99. It totals $77,822,988 and will require $888,023 more than the 60% starting point of revenue that is currently projected by the County Executive. The School Board firmly believes that the proposed budget does not meet ail the needs of the School Division. As the budget process began, the Superintendent followed School Board direction to recommend a budget consistent with projected revenues. This direction was followed, even in the face of extraordinary challenges the community faces for the FY 1998-99 budget year. These challenges include continued enrollment growth, the opening of the first new high school in over twenty years, the implementation of the revised I~irginia Standards of Accreditation, a decrease in the percentage of state funding, and our own local revenue situation. Exacerbating the situation is the fact that recent school division budgets have reflected a maintenance of effort only and have had little room for needed improvements. Within those parameters, the School Board was unable to approve the Superintendent's proposed budget because it represented such a major deterrent to the continued academic excellence of our educational programs and students. Therefore, the School Board was compelled to include into the base budget proposal several initiatives that the Superintendent had reluctantly recommended remain unfunded. These initiatives include: full funding for growth-related teaching positions, maintenance of high school athletic programs at current levels, restored funding for CATEC, partial funding for elementary school Health Clinicians, textbooks, support for Gifted Education, and programs m provide additional instructional resoumes for our most at-risk students. Other unfunded items constitute our "unfunded needs." In a further effort not to propose budgeting beyond projected revenues, reductions of approximately $528,000 were made from a variety of central supports to school programs including materials, textbooks, teacher training, and building nnprovements. We also adopted changes in school starting and dismissal times to generate short and long-term savings in transportation costs, and reallocated existing staffing resources to better serve our economically disadvantaged students. We recount these management strategies to you to demonstrate our firm commitment to adapting and optimizing what we have, before requesting more, I would also emphasize that these strategies are in addition to holding department and school budgets at level-funding for four of the past five years. It is our considered judgement that the School Board and Board of Supervisors share a common understanding that the exemplary quality of our schools attract economic growth to the area and must be a shining example of the exceptional quality of life that we all enjoy in Albemarle County. You have supported that vision in the past by designating the School Division with an appropriate priority within your other considerations for funding the operation of the County. We trust that you and the other Supervisors will again give due consideration to this budget proposal. We look forward to your continued demonstration to the community of your dedication to quality education, dedication that is exemplified by your financial commitment to the construction of Monticello High School. Sincerely, John E. Baker Chairman "We Expect Success" DAVID R. GEHR COMMISS[ONEF COMMONWEALTH o,f VIRQINI. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPOR'rATION 1601-ORANGE ROAD CULPEPER. 22701-3819 DONALD R. ASKEW DISTRICT ADMINISTRATOR February 24, 1998 Mr. Robert W. Tucker, Jr. Albemarle County Executive 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Tucker: The Culpeper District preallocation hearing will be held on Thursday, April 2, at 9:00 a.m. The purpose of this hearing is to solicit input on the allocation of fiscal year 1998-99 funds and on updating the Six-Year Improvement Program for the interstate, primary, and urban systems. Speaking ord.er will be as follows: Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa, Madison, Orange, Rappahannock, _Albemarle., Culpeper, and Fauquier. Towns and cities will fall under the appropriate county. The site of the Culpeper hearing is the auditorium in the VDOT District Office complex at 1601 Orange Road in Culpeper. Parking is available to the left of the forked entrance, in what is called "the pines." The most convenient building access is in the rear, across from the parking area. We look forward to seeing you on April 2. Sincerely, Donald R. Askew 'DistriCt Administrator :wlr TRANSPORTATION FOR THE 21ST CENTURY COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY B()ARD LPERVISORS AGENDA TITLE: Albemarle County Jurisdictional Area request for water and sewer service-- Hurt investment Co. (Fontana Subdivision) SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST:. ~)nsider holding a public hearing to amend the ACSA Jurisdictional Area to provide water and sewer service to /the proposed Fontana Subdivision ~-'~, Citimberg, Benish M~er, Cil~mberg, ~emsn AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1997 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACT ON.: X INFORMATION: REVIEWED BY BACKGROUND: The Applicant, Hurt Investment Company, requests Jurisdictional Area designation for water and sewer service to 119 acres located on Tax Map 78 Parcel 57 (portion). This 119 acres is part of the proposed Fontana development which received preliminary subdivision plat approval for 167 lots on December 19, 1997. A Special Use Permit was also recently approved for the Frost Montesorri School on the property near Route 20. The property was part of the larger "Luxor property," and is located on the east side of Route 20 North, north of Phase III of the Wilton Farms Apartments and the Garnett Treatment Center, lying within a designated Development Area (Neighborhood 3). The southern portion of parcel 57 is already in the Jurisdictional Area for both water and sewer (Attachment A). DISCUSSION: The subject property is within Urban Area Neighborhood 3. The Land Use Plan provides the following concerning water and sewer service to a Development Area: Facilities Planning: "Strongly support and effectively implement the County's growth management priorities in the planning and provision of transportation, public facilities and public utilities (p. 5)." Land Use Plan General Principle: "Urban Areas, Communities and Villages are to be served by public water and sewer (p. f 7)." Part of the eastern boundary for Neighborhood 3 is the 600 foot contour of the Southwest Mountains. There is one small area of less than one acre which is slightly above the 600 foot elevation. It is a separate knoll located west of the continuous 600 foot contour that forms the boundary of the Development Area. Water service is available on-site and sewer service is approximately 800 feet from the property. RECOMMENDATION: As a general policy, staff has advised that public utility capacities should be reserved to support development of designated Development Areas. This request is consistent with the public utility policy of the Land Use Plan. Therefore, staff recommends proceeding to public hearing to consider providing water and sewer service for the property noted as Tax Map 62, Parcel 57 (portion). 98.033 ALBEMARLE COUNTY IATTACHMENT Ai Monticello boundary lines represen~ perimeter road or tree lines (as on Air Photographics Dec. 1980 Aerialx Photo of TM 78) to include all / existing buildings. ~' SCOTTSVILEE AND SECTION FRANKLIN ASHCROFT roA MONT ICEI LOOP MAP C URBAN NE I OBORHOOD To: TO WHOM ADDRESSED From: Laurel B. Hall. Sel~ior Deputy Clerk Subject: Ordinance Adopted by Board on March 4. 1998 Date: March 1 I. 1998 Attached for your use is a copy of an ordinance which was adopted by the Board of Supervisors on March 4, 1998: (I An Ordinance to amend and reordain Chapter 8, Finance and Taxation of the Albemarle County code by mending §8-66, time Limits for appeals of Real Estate Assessments which shall establish time limits for appeals of real estate assessments. Attachment CC: The Honorable James L. Camblos. III Melvin Breeden Brtice WQodzell Bob Tucker Larry Davis File COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Amendment of Time Limits for Appeals of Real Estate Assessments SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Public hearing to amend Section 8-66 of the County Code establishing time limits for appeals of real estate assessments. STAFF CONTACT(S~I: Messrs. Tucker, Huff, Davis, Woodzell AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: X CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: Draft Ordinance BACKGROUND: Virginia Code § 58.1-3330 requires the County to provide notice of any changes in the assessed value of real estate and to provide a taxpayer at least 15 days to request a hearing before the assessing officer to protest such changes. Virginia Code § 58.1-3378 provides that the board of equalization may also hear applications for -elief from real estate assessments and that the Board of Superwsors may establish a deadline for such applications, provided that the deadline is at least 30 days after the date of the hearing [3efore the assessing officer under § 58.1-3330. Finally, § 58.1-3378 provides that the Board of Supervisors may establish the deadline by which all applications must be f'mally disposed of' by the board of equalization. DISCUSSION: Albemarle Count':/Code § 8-66, which establishes time limits for appeals of real estate assessments, is ambiguous with respect to the deadline for an application to the board of equalization. Specifically, Section 8-66 currently states that any additional appeal must be made to the board of equalization within thirty (30) days, but does not clearly state what event triggers the thirty-day limit. Moreover, current Section 8-66 does not establish a deadline for the final dispositions by the board of equalization as provided.in Virginia Code § 58.1-3378. The attached ordinance clarifies the thidy-day time limit and establishes a deadline of September 1 for the disposition of all biennial assessment appeals and a deadline of December 31 for all supplemental and pro rata assessment appeals. RECOM M ENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the attached Ordinance amending and reordaining Section 8-66. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS 98.031 ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REORDAIN CHAPTER 8 OF THE CODE OF THE COUNTY OF Al 3qEMARLE, VIRGINIA. BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervisors of the County of Albemarle, Virginia. that Chapter 8 is hereby amended and reordained by amending section 8- 66, Time limits for appeals of real estate assessments, as follows: Sec. 8-66. Time limits for appeals of real estate assessments. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 58.1-3330 of the Code of Virginia, all applications for appeals from any biennial assessment of real estate must be made by the property owner or lessee --4'~-:- -: ..... '~ ~ ....c ..... ~, .... :__ ~ .... c .~ .... ~ A '°"~ ~' th C t.vAs byth 1 tbu d f ~ ~.._~, o, ~p oun sessor e as siness av o ........ or, tH o,, ~,cad2i':nc$. to e February of the year in which the assessment takes effect. A ~rol~ertv owner or lessee may also aopeal any biennial assessment by making an application directly to the board of eoualization bv the last business day of March of the year in which the assessment takes effect, or if an al)Deal has been made to the County Assessor within To: From: Subject: Date: TO WHOM ADDRESSED Laurel B. Hall_ Senior Deputy Cleric ~ - Ordinance Adopted by Board on March 4, 1998 March 11. 1998 Attached for your use is a copy of an ordinance which was adopted by the Board of Supervisors on March 4. I998: An Ordinance to amend and reordain Chapter 8. Finmace mad Taxation of the Albemarle County code by mending §8-66, time Limits for appeals of Real Estate Assessments which shall establish time limits for appeals of real estate assessments. Attachment CC: The Honorable James L. Camblos. III Melvin Breeden Brace Woodzell Bob Tudcer Larry Davis File ORDINANCE NO. 98-8( 1 ) AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REORDAiN CHAPTER 8. FINANCE AND TAXATION, OF THE CODE OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA. BE IT ORDAINED By the Board of Supervisors of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, that Chapter 8, Finance and Taxation, is hereby amended and reordained by amending section 8-66, Time limits for appeals of real estate assessments, as follows: Sec. 8-66. Time limits for appeals of real estate assessments. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 58.1-3330 of the Code of Virginia, ali applications for appeals from any biennial assessment of real estate must be made by the property owner or lessee to the County Assessor by the last business day of February of the year in which the assessment tal<es effect. A property owner or lessee may also appeal any biennial assessment by making an application directly to the board of equalization by the last business day of March of the year in which the assessment takes effect, or if an appeal has been made to the County Assessor within thirty (30) days from the date of the decision of the County Assessor denying an appeal for such assessment, whichever date is later. Applications for appeals from any supplemental assessment or pro rata assessment for new construction assessed between January 1 and October 31 must be made by the property owner or lessee to the County Assessor within fifteen (15) days of the date of the notice of the supplemental or pro rata assessment. A property owner or lessee may also appeal any supplemental or pro. rata assessment by malting an application directly to the board of equalization within thirty (30~ days of the date of the notice of the supplemental or pro rata assessment, or if an appeal has been made to the County Assessor within thirty (30~ days from the date of the decision of the County Assessor denying an appeal for such supplemental or pro rata assessment, whichever date is later. The board of equalization shall finally dispose of all biennial assessment appeals by September 1 of the year in which the assessment takes effect and of all supplemental or pro rata assessment appeals for new construction by December 31 of the year in which the supplemental or pro rata assessment takes effect. (Sec. 8-1.7, 7-12-89; Ord. Of 2-5-92) XXXXX I, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of a Resolution dtdy adopted by the Board of County Supervisors of Albemarle Countyby avote of 6 to 0n Marc.,J~ 1998. Cle~, Board of County S~p,~sors Page 2 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA TITLE: Resolution to Designate Whitewood Park as Open- Space Land SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Designation of Whitewood Park as Open-Space Land under Open-Space Land Act STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs. Tucker, Huff, Davis AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: X CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: INFORMATION: ATTACHMENTS: Resolution REVIEWED BY: / BACKGROUND: The Whitewood Park properly consists of 22.709 acres, Tax Map 61 Parcel 28 which contains 20.937 acres, was acquired by the County School Board in 1919 by a deed from John Fishbume and other persons. Tax Map 61, Parcel 29A, which contains 1.772 acres, was acquired by the School Board in 1971 in a deed of exchange with David Wood and other persons, Both parcels were acquired by the County in a deed of exchange with the School Board in 1990. The ~roperty conveyed by the County to the School Board in that exchange was the Agnor-Hurt Elementary School site. DISCUSSION: The Open-Space Land Act authorizes the Board of Supervisors to designate property acquired by the County as open-space land. The sign'lficance of this designation is that after such designation the property cannot be converted or diverted from open-space land use unless: 1. The Board of Supervisors determines the conversion or diversion is: a. Essential to the orderly growth of the County; and b. In accordance with the Comprehensive Plan. There is substituted other real property which is: a. Of at least equal fair market value; and b. Of greater value as permanent open-space land; and c. Of as heady as feasible equivalent usefulness and location for use as permanent open- space land. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA TITLE: Resolution to Designate Whitewood Park as Open-Space Land March 4, 1998 Page 2 The responsibility for assuring such substitution is upon the board of Supervisors at the time of conversion or diversion of the property. Designation as open-space property does not prevent any state agency from acquiring the property for an alternative public use by eminent domain. Under such process the above described protection of the Open- Space Land Act would not apply. The Board of Supervisors can designate Whitewood Park as open-space land to assure that a future Board of Supervisors cannot change the use of the property without complying with the procedures and requirements of the Open-Space Land Act. ~Arithout such a designation, a future Board of Supervisors could change the use of the property as it deemed appropriate. RECOM M ENDATION: If the Board desires to designate Whitewood Park as oper>space land pursuant to the Open Space Land Act, it should adopt the attached Resolution. 98.030 David E Bowecrnan Charlotte Y. Humphtis Form.st R. Marshall. Jr. COUNTY OF ALBEIViARLE Office of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclntim Road Charlott~'ville, Virginia 22902-4596 (804} 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles $. Marlin F6vanna Walter E Pmt~im Wh?te Hat Sall!; H. Thom~z MEMORANDUM TO: Pat Mulltmey, DirecTor Parks and Recreation FROM: Laurel B. Hall Senior Deputy Ct RE: Resolution to Designate Whitewood Park as Open-Space Land DATE: March 9, 1998 At its March 4, 1998 meet'rog the Albemarle Board of County Supervisors adopted a resolution to designate Whitewood Park as open-space land. [ have attached a copy of the resolution for your records. Enclosure cc: Bob Tucker Wayne Cilimberg Larry Davis Printed on recycled paper Resolution to Designate Whitewood Park Property as Open-Space Land WHEREAS, the Open Space Land Act (Va. Code Section 10.1-1700 et seq.) provides for the preservation of land in an urban area for park and recreational purposes; and WHEREAS, the Whitewood Park property is a unique and valuable park and recreational resource within an urbanized area of the County; and WHEREAS, the Board of Supervisors desires to designate the Whitewood Park property as open-space land to preserve and protect this valuable resource. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors pursuant to the Open-Space Land Act {Va. Code Section 10.1-1700 et seq.) hereby designates the Whitewood Park property as opemspace land. The Whitewood Park property, referred to herein, shall include the following more particularly described property: All those certain tracts or parcels of land in the Rio Magisterial District of Albemarle County containing a total of 22.709 acres, more or less, and consisting of Tax Map 61, Parcel 28, containing 20.937 acres, and Tax Map 61, Parcel 29A, containing 1.772 acres, as identified in that deed of exchange between the County School Board of Albemarle County and the County of Albemarle dated October 31, 1990, and which is of record in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of Albemarle County in Deed Book 1128, Page 650. I, Ella W. Carey, do hereby certify that the foregoing writing is a true, correct copy of a Resolution duly adopted by the Board of County Supervisors of Albemarle County by a vote of 6 to O on March 4, 1998. Clerk, Board (~f Coun~'Sup~Ls I I:~GENERAL~SHAREL~TTORNEY~WHTTEWOO.WPD March 4, 1998 Good morning. My name is Mary Morris and I am a resident of the Minor Hill ManorHomes community. As a member of the group of concerned citizens who were before you last year regarding the Cn-eenbrier Road Extension and its impact on the surrounding residenfml commun/ties, I would like to convey our sincerest hope that the Board will take the action necessary to designate the Whitewood Park property as Open-Space Land under the Open-Space Land Act. By so doing, the Board will be protecting the sustainable Commonwealth community which is a balance of residential, recreational, commercial and industry which currently exists. By voting in favor of this resolution, the Board will be taloxg an important step in preserving our urban communities. Thank you. Mary Morris 352 Westfield Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA TITLE: Dance Hall Ordinance SUBJECT/PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Dance Hall Permit Guidelines from other VA localities STAFF CONTACT(S): Messrs Tucker Huff & Davis AGENDA DATE: March 4, 1998 ACTION: CONSENT AGENDA: ACTION: ATTACHMENTS: REVIEWED BY: ITEM NUMBER: INFORMATION: X INFORMATION: / DISCUSSION: The Board recently requested staffto research how other localities handle the permitting and regulation of dance halls. Since the County has issued only one dance hall permit in approximately 10 years, the current County policy has not been extensively reviewed to take into consideration current concerns. As you see in Attachment A, a variety of options are available to the County if we are interested Jn regulating the operation of dance halls Jn a more comprehensive fashion. Of course, as is the case currently, exceptions to the regulations can be made for education, religious and military dance events. The key points of interest regarding this issue are noted as possibilities below: 1) Security Comeonents - some localities allow for police access to the premises at any time to ensure peace and quiet; some localities require private security while others hold management accountable. 2) Adult.versus Teen Dance Halls - several localities make a distinction between age groups to provide more appropriate settings for teenage patrons, including earlier closing times. 3) .Applicant Responsibility - one County reqmres complete criminal background checks for teen dance hall employees and ownership before a permit will be issued; others explicitly prohibit intoxicated patrons. 4) Igevocation - our current provisions for revocation of a dance hall permit appear to be less restrictive than the State Cede allows. State Cede 18.2-433 notes that the local ordinance shall prescribe for "grounds for revocation and procedure for revocation of such permits." The County Code refers to revocation in cases of violation of the provisions of the Code or for any false statement made on the application, Revocation could be expanded to include violations of any provisions of this Code. state law or special use permit. An example could be "A dance hall permR shall be revocable if the operation of the public dance hall covered thereby is found to violate any provision of this Code or of state law or of the special use permit, including, but not limited to, the creation or facilitation of an,/firs or other safety hazard on the dance hall premises; any traffic hazard within the parking area serving the dance hail or on the public highway; any public nuisance on the dance hall premises; any undue overcrowding within the dance hall facility or within the parking area serving the dance hall; any public disturbance resulting from the lack of adequate security guards on the dance hall premises; or, any unlawful activities on the dance hall premises." 5) AI)nroval Process - other locality codes establish a process which includes several additional levels of approval, clarification and limitations. Our current code only requires 2 weeks lead time prior to the Board meeting - additional time could be justitied to review the permit. HenrJco, for instance, requires the permit to be approved by the Police Chief, Planning Director & Fire Chief before issuance. Also. iftbe Board is interested, Albemarle could have an internal administrative approval process for these types of permits, rather than Board approval. 6) Notification Provision - Currently the Board can issue a dance hall permit without notifying adjoining landowners. Such a requirement could be instituted. AGENDA TITLE: Dance Hall Permit March 4. 1998 Page 2 7) Curfew - The County's current curfew limits minors from being in motor vehicles from 1:00am through 5:00am, unless they have written parental censent. The City of CharlottesvilJe's curfew prohibits minors under the age of 17 to remain in any public place or motor vehicle from 12:01am through 5:00am Menday-Frlday, and 1:00am through 5:0gam Saturday & Sunday, unless they have written parental consent, RECOMMENDATION: This material is presented to the Board for theirinformation. A request to issue a dance hall permit is before the Board (attached) and on hold pending direction as to whether the current ordinance needs to be amended prior to acting on it. Under the current County ordinance, minors under the age of 18 would have to have parental permission in order to attend an event such as the ones proposed by the applicant. The Board may choose to leave that provision in place or amend it with any of the options mentioned in this report. Any changes Jn the current ordinance would require a public hearing under the Board's current practice. 98.032 DANCE HALL PERMIT GUIDELINES IN SELECTED VIRGINIA LOCALITIES (Attachment A) Albemarle Adult i Must be over 'I8 or N/A N/A I requires a parent or parental note James City Adult N/A N/A Police allowed to enter at all times to ensure peace and quiet of the County is preserved Roanoke City Teen Maximum age of 19 12:00am 1) Background checks conducted on all applicants and staff. 2) Adequate security must be in place to ensure no alcohol, drugs or weapons are on premises Newport Public/Teen Over 18 (public) and 11:30pm 1) Police allowed to enter at all times to News 14-20 (teen) ~ for teen ensure peace and quiet, 2) Must have one police officer for very 100 patrons in teen club. 3) No person under the influence of alcohol allowed' to remain in club 4) patrons of teen club are not I allowed to leave and re-enter premises during event 5) no loitering Henrico Adult N/A 1:00am Approval from police chief, fire chief and director planning. It must be determined the applicant is of "good moral character" Goochland Adult Must be over 18 unless 9:00pm- N/A w/parent 1:00am on Fri. & Sat. only N/A = not available in ordinance 475 WEstfiEId Rd. Charlottesville. VA ;~2901 (804) 978-STAR January 27, 1998 Albemarle Cotmty Board of Supervisors County Office Building 401 Mclnth-e Road Charlottesville, VA 2-2901 RE: Permit for Operation of Dance Hall (Revised) Ladies and Gentlemen: Please consider this letter an application on behalf of Piedmont Amusements Corp., dgo/a StarBase Alpha, for a permit to operate a Dauee Hail pttrsuant to S3: I t et seq. of the Albemarle County Code. The relevant information is as follows: 1. Owner: Piedmont Amusements, Corp., a Virginia Corpo~m/on. 2. Managen. Robert C. Cotley, President of Piedmont Amusements Crop. 3. Locationz 475 Westfield Rd., Albemarle County, Virginia 4. Alcoholic Beverages: No alcoholic beverages will be served or allowed on the premises. 5. Building Inspection Certification: Both the building officials and the Fire Marshall have inspected the premises. In addition to the above: 1. I wilt limit the number of participants to 100. 2. I will market to a 14-20 year old audience playing primarily alternative rock, classic rock and folk music formats. 3. I will offer the music on Friday or Saturday nights between 9 and 1 lpm. 4. Our managers will be in charge of security. They will call the County Police ifa situation arises that they cannot handle. 5. I will post my parking lot for no loitering and no trespassing. 6. [ will give the County Police permission to enter my property to make arrests for any illegal activity. Respectfully Submitted, Robert C. Coltey President, Piedmont Amusements Corp. COUNTY OF ALBEMAR s os a3dns do MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Richard E. Huff, II, Deputy County Executive February 13, 1998 Technolog3, Plan Attached is a copy of a Technology Planning Report prepared in response to Mr. Martin's question regarding our plans for computer replacement. It covers both schools and local government and attempts to describe the multitude of different projects that are on-going in an attempt to use technology to improve productivity. If you should have any questions, please give Fred Kruger or me a call or if the Board wishes to discuss any portion of the report, please feel flee to bring up the report at one of our meetings. I trust that this meets your request to explain the County's technology planning strategies. REH, Ilkdbm 98.003 Attachment pc: Mr. Fred Kruger ALBEMARLE COUNTY INFORMATION SERVICES TECHNOLOGY PLANNING REPORT JANUARY 22, 1998 TABLE OF CONTENTS Responsibilities ........................................................................................................................... 1 Mission Statement ....................................................................................................................... 1 Vision .......................................................................................................... : ............................... 2 Technology Changes ................................................................................................................... 2 Decision Making ........................................................................................................................ 3 Planning Directed to Infrastructure, Standards and Training ..................................................... 3 The Technology Plan - Projects .................................................................................................. 4 Hardware Standards .................................................................................................................... 6 Instructional Technology Planning ............................................................................................. 6 The Year 2000 Project ................................................................................................................ 7 Attachments Attachment A: Information Services 5 Year Technology Plan Fiscal Years 1998-1999 through 2002-2003 Attachment B: Information Services Department Objectives for t997-1998 Attachment C: Albemarle County Public Schools Instructional Technology Plan, Amended January 1998 Attachment D: Memorandum "Planning for the Year 2000", dated September 10, 1996 Attachment E: Memorandum "Year 2000 Project Status", dated August 25, 1997 Responsibilities The Department of Information Services provides technology and telecommnnications services to all County employees, including the School Division and ali constitutional officers. Currently, Information Services is divided into five divisions with specific responsibilities. Frequently, these responsibilities overlap reqmring constant interaction and teamworL The following is a brief summary of each division. Administration is responsible for the overall management of the department including technology planning, budg~ preparation, financial management, purchasing, and other tasks related to personnel management. Instructional Technology is responsible for providing direction and guidance for training School Division staff on the use of technology in classroom and administrative functions. It provides support of school instructional and adm'mistrative computers, audio-visual equipment, and local area~networks. Instructional Technology Staff conducts evaluations of various technology products for potential use by the schools. The Manager also provides leadership for dounty wide computer technology education including the General Government. Applications provides analytical and programming development services for the design, creation and maintenance of computer applications for both the General Government and the School Division. Applications also provides microcomputer hardware and software support, maintenance services and help desk services for the County Office Building and the Courthouse Complex. Engineering provides high end technical support for the mainframe, the WAN (Wide Area Network), the Internet, the Intranet, and the County Office Building LAN (Local Area Network). Computer Operations provides centralized control, processing and data backup for ma'mframe and County Office Building LAN applications for both the General Government and the School Div/sior~ Mission Statement The Mission of Information Services is to provide efficient, effective and reliable information and telecommunications processing for all departments, within Albemarle County including but not limited to the County Government and School Division. Additionally, part of the mission is to provide a vision of how technology can be a key element in the efficient execution of county and school services. In order to fulfill its mission, Information Services has created a vision to lay the groundwork for tomorrow's technology. Technology Planning January 1998 Page 1 Vision Provide technologies, which offer quick and reliable access to information and communications services. These technologies should enhance County Government and School Division staffs' decision making, ability to communicate with internal and external contacts, and the performance of basic tasks. Information Services maintains a 5 Year Technology Plan (Attachment A). This plan helps Information Services manage planned purchases made under both the Capital Improvements Plan (CIP) and Operating Budgets. It is reviewed with and approved by the Deputy County Executive annually. Each year Information Services develops department~ objectives (Attachment B) which reflect the next year's implementation of the various projects related to the 5 Year Technology Plan. Because of changes in technology and priorities, Information Services may request modifications to details of the Plan within available funding. Technology_ Changes Greater Opportunities with Greater Efforts The fields of technology and telecommunications face change daily. With these changes there are great opportunities and challenges. Management and support of today's technology have grown more difficult and complex. Today's technology provides an open architecture where hardware and software products from many vendors can form an integrated network. The ability to communicate quickly via e-mail and to share and manipulate data are products of this networking. The Intemet provides access to staff at other organizations across the state and the world. Access ~.o information for research has become almost instantaneous and limitless. Decision-making, supported by better information, is improved. Supporting this new open environment takes more effort. An open environment requires that technology staff answer more questions about software, respond to network printer problems, resolve access to local networks and the Intemet, troubleshoot at the employee desktop for hard,ware and network problems and more. Providing support requires more staff. Various articles and reports suggest that one support person is needed for every 100 computers. The challenge is to improve support by continuously refining the use of all resources within limited funding including staff, hardware, and sof~ware. Technology Planning January 1998 Page 2 Decision Making Information Sermces recognizes the importance that many of its decisions have on the entire County. When acquiring new technology the most important consideration is the value received by the County/n sawngs or improved services. That value is then compared to costs and availability offunds. Based uponthis evaluation, the proposed technology must be prioritized with existing and planned efforts. Because change is sueh an integral part of Information Services, staff must confmuously re-evaluate the Plan; retain what still provides strong value; and, delay or eliminate that which now provides little value. Besides estimating value and costs, the following considemt'mns are used for long-term pl~nnlng and for choice ofproduets: 1. Integration with current and planned technology; 2. Comparisons'of similar products; 3. Availability of reliable vendor support; 4. References from customers; 5. Information from: a) Technical journals and publications; b) lntemet sites; and, c) Vendors; and, d) Classes. 6. Trials and on-site evaluations performed by Information Services staff and other County staff; 7. Informal and formal bid responses. Recently, Information Services created a users group for departments within the County Office Building (COB). COBTUG (COB Technology Users Group) was formed to provide better communications between Information Services staffand departments. Through COBTUG, it is hoped that Information Services can focus on the needs of its customers better during all phases of technology planning. Planning Directed to Infrastructure, Standards and Training In order to provide improved management and support for technology, Information Services has focUSed on three broad areas: 1. Maintenance and continuous improvement to technology infrastructure; 2. Implementation and support of new software standards; and, 3. Expand'mg technology training. Technology Planning January 1998 Page 3 First, supporting technology requires continuous improvement to infrastructure. The Albemarle County technology infrastructure consists of: Local Area Networks (LANs), the fibe~ optic Wide Area Network (WAN), InteraCt Access, desktop computers, mainframe, phone switches, phone lines and alt the software and peripheral hardware which support this envkonmem. Furore networks will carry greater traffic. Computers will need to be upgraded or replaced as newer software adds valuable new capabilities. As more information is stored electronically, additional resources will be required. Operating System sof~ware on the networks and at the desktops will need to be upgraded'. Note: Technology, which is not part of this infrastructure, includes application Software systems on the mainframe such asthe Financial Management System and similar applications on the LANs. Second, it is important to provide employees with a strong set of software products. Recent decisions established the following products as the standard desktop software applications for the County: 1. Desktop Operating System- Microsoft Windows 95: 2. Desktop Application Suite -Microsoft Office '97; 3. E-mall - Microsoft Exchange; and, 4. Interact Browser - Microsoft Intemet Explorer. The choice of these products was based on their ability m provide strong functional integration, and the ability to ran on both Windows and Macintosh (for the School Division) Operating Systems. Today, there has been broad acceptance by many (public and private) organizations of these products as their new standards. Many journals have rated the newest versions of each of these products as best in their class. By focusing 6n these strategic products, support staff can concentrate their efforts and provide better services. Third, training of County employees has been a major point of emphasis over the last several years. A better-educated employee should requke less support ~o resolve fewer problems. The Technology Plan - Proiects During the last three years, the Technology Plan has focused on the creation of an infrastructure to serve the vision. The following projects have been completed which have set the groundwork for the infrastructure: 1. High speed, reliable fiber optic Wide Area Network (WAN) .cormecting the County Office Building, the Courthouse Complex and all School Division facilities. 2. School Division facilities have new or upgraded Local Area Networks (LANs). 3. New mainframe and disk storage system. 4. High speed direct access to the Intemet. 5. Firewall/proxy gateway software to help protect access from the Interact into the County networks. Current projects will continue the construction of the technology infrastructure as well as beginning the implementation of new technology as it be comes available and cost effective. Technology Planning January1998 Page 4 The following projects are currently underway: 1. Upgrading employees' desktops to new standards (Microsoft Windows 95, Microsoft Office '97, Microsoft Exchange and Microsoft Imernet Explorer); 2. Development of applications on the LAN; 3. Intranet server and Data Warehousmg; 4. Phone Operating System and Voice Mail System software upgrades; 5. Year 2000 upgrades for software onthe mainframe and employ&e microcomputersi 6. Enhancements to the County Office Building LAN; 7. LAN fax server; 8. Imaging Pilot; 9. Distance Learning Pilot between 2 Albemarle County Schools; and, 10. Upgrading microcomputers for staff Future projects for the next three years include, but are not limited to: 1. Expansion of Imaging; 2. Expansion of Distance Learning (as feasible). 3. Expansion of Intranet services; and, 4. Expansion of Intemet services. Many infrastructure projects represent on-going efforts. Throughout the year microcomputers require replacement. Based upon funding, microcomputers are normally replaced when the need of the individual employee requires greater resources. As each employee begins to use multiple products frequently, such as Word, Excel, and Exchange, greater memory is required. Depending upon usage, greater processor power may be necessary. The more advanced users will distinguish themselves as "Power Users." As more users take advantage of the training that is offered, more "Power Users" are developed. It is important that these employees receive the necessary computing resources as required to perform their job tasks efficiently and effectively. With appropriate support these employees can provide the impetus for the County to achieve the potential gains that new technology offers. As new computers are installed, the older computers which meet standards are installed at other employees' desks. When replacing computers which no longer meet current standards they are recycled into the schools. Similar movements of computers exist within the School Division. I'he lowest levels of Computers are placed in areas of minimum requirement such as in School keyboarding labs. Computers, wkich are broken, are fixed if the value warrants it. If it is not feasible to fix a computer, it is frequently stripped for parts. This inventory of spare parts is then used by Information Services staff and outsourced maintenance providers for future repairs. Technology Planning January 1998 Page 5 Hardware Standards Continuously Being Refined The minimum de'sktop computer for General Government and School Division classified and administrative staff currently is a computer with/t 486/33MHz, 32 MB RAM and 1.2 GB hard drive. Current efforts include upgrading and replacing existing machines to meet or exceed these standards. There are a number of these computers still working throughout the County. This configuration can marginally nm the Current software. Most recently purchased computers are either Pentium 166 MHz or 200 MHz processors, have 32 MB RAM, and hard drives in excess of 2GB. Some School Division administrative staffhaVe choSento use Macintosh computers to malmain commonality with the majority of instructional computers installed within their schools. These Macintosh computers reflect similar specifications as the Windows baSed computers. While the capabilities of desktop computers have rapidly improved, costs have declined. Information Services has had to constantly re-evaluate what is available and what functionality is required by staff~ With these frequent technology changes, desktop computer standards are refined on a continuous basis. The objective of this evaluation process has been t0 provide equipment which: 1 Meets the short term and near furore requirements of County employees; 2. Provides sound value for the dollars spent; and, 3. Does nor represent state of the art desktops which can require state of the art cost. With rapid change, setting standards, like the entire technology field, requires constant management to insure that available funds are providing for a growing demand for resources. Instructional Technology_ Planning Information Services has managed and supported all Instructional Technology areas since August 1992. Under the direction and leadership of the Information Services Technology Steering Committee, the first Albemarle County School Division Instructional Technology Plan was presented to the School Board on November 22, 1993. Since that time, with great support from the Board of Supervisors, the School Board and timely funding by the State, the County's School Division has received an infusion of Instructional computers Which has allowed the ratio of students to computers meeting standard to improve to 9.5 to 1. A copy of the most current Instructional Technology Plan (Amended January I998) is attached (Attachment C). Technology. Planning January 1998 Page 6 The Year 2000 Project The Year 2000 problem has been well documented. "On January 1, 2000, a number of computers throughout the world will cease to function properly because they will not be prepared to handle the first two year digits which reflect the century. Therefore, 01/01/2000 will appear as 01/01/1900 in numerous calculations. This is a problem!" * Information Services has been working towards resolving the Year 2000 issues for several years. Although evaluafmg and upgrading all County Ma'mframe, LAN and desktop software represents a huge task, Information Services has planned much of this work to be done at the same time other projects are being worked on. For example, while upgrading date roufmes within the mainframe's Financial Management System (FMS), other requests for FMS modifications have been completed wherever appropriate. In a similar manner, upgrades to WIndows 95 on all Windows based desktops is a project which also provides Year 2000 compliance. Resolving the Year 2000 problem involves the help and support of employees throughout the entire County. On September 10, 1996, Information Services sent a memorandum, "Planning for the Year 2000" (Attachment D), to County and School Division Department Heads and School Principals requesting assistance in evaluating what software and hardware might require attention. A number of responses were received. On August 25, 1997, Information Services sent another memorandum, "Year 2000 Project Status," (Attachment E) to the same adrain/strators providing a brief summary on this project. In February 1998, a meeting is planned to provide "brain storming" session about Year 2000 issues with staff from many areas of the entire County. Hopefully, this meeting will pInpoint, for future consideration, Year 2000 requirements falling both within Information Services' responsibility and those of the other participants. In short, Information Services recognizes the seriousness of this task and because of the hard work of dedicated staff, the Year 2000 Project is on schedule today. *Memorandum. Plarming for the Year 2000, dated September 10, 1996. Technology Planning January 1998 Page 7 A VISION FOR THE FUTURE ALBEMARLE SCHOOL DMSION 6 YEAR TECHNOLOGY PLAN Full UtilLzation of the W~d~: Full l~ategratlon of Technology ~ncreased Use of Technolo for Use of Distance Learning for into Instruction: Classroom Management ~g~ Studex~ts/Staff: average (199%98) (1997-98) openings (1997-9g~ Instructional Technology Plan January 1998 Page 4 TECHNOLOGY RESPONSIBILITY FLOW CHART APPENDIX A Becky Fisher Instructional Teehnolo~ IAr~lo:t ~,I,LDHI~tO X~)O~IONHD~I& 'IVNOLLDflH.I.SNI S~IOOHDS DI~lltfltI X,LNI10D ~ThrVIAIitItT~ '1 0 ~ mm mmm m 07~ · 0 0 OF SUPER February 26, 1998 ALBEMARLE COUNTY PUBL[C SCHOOLS Office of the School Board 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesv/lle, Virginia 22902-4596 Mr. Forrest Marshall, Chaimtan Albemarle County Board of Supervisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Mr. Marshall: This letter transmits the Albemarle County Board's Proposed Operating Budget for FY 1998-99. It totals $77,822,988 and will require $888,023 more than the 60% starting point of revenue that is currently projected by the County Executive. The School Board firmly believes that the proposed budget does not meet all the needs of the School Division. As the budget process began, the Superintendent followed School Board d/recfion to recommend a budget consistent with projected revenues. This direction was followed, even in the face of extraordinary challenges the community faces for the FY 1998-.99 budget year. These challenges include continued enrollment growth, the opening of the first new high sch6ol in over twenty years, the implementation of the revised Virginia Standards of Accreditation, a decrease in the percentage of state funding, and our own local revenue situation. Exacerbating the situation is the fact that recent school division budgets have reflected a maintenance of effort only and have had little room for needed improvements. Within those parameters, the School Board was unable to approve the Superintendent's proposed budget becanse it represented such.a major deterrent to the continued academic excellence of our educational programs and students. Therefore, the School Board was compelled to include into the base budget proposal several initiatives that the Superintendent had reluctantly recommended remain unfunded. These initiatives include: full funding for growth-related teaching positions, maintenance of high school athletic programs at current levels, restored funding for CATEC, partial funding for elementary school Health Clinicians, textbooks, support for Gifted Education, and programs to provide additional instructional resources for our most at-risk students. Other unfunded items constitute our "unfunded needs." In a further effort not to propose budgeting beyond projected revenues, reductions of approximately $528,000 were made fi.om a variety of central supports to school prot~mms including materials, textbooks, teacher training, and building improvements. We also adopted changes in school starting and dismissal times to generate short and long-term savings in transportation costs, and reallocated existing staffing resources to better serve our economically disadvantaged students. We recount these management strategies to you to demonstrate our £u'm commitment to adapting and optimizing what we have, before requesting more. I would also emphasize that these strategies are in addition to holding department and school budgets at level-funding for four of the past five years. It is our considered judgement that the School Board and Board of Supervisors share a common understanding that the exemplary quality of our schools attract economic growth to the area and must be a shining example of the exceptional quality of life that we all enjoy in Albemarle County. You have supported that vision in the past by designating the School Division with an appropriate priority within your other considerations for funding the operation of the County. We trust that you and the other Supervisors will again give due consideration to this budget proposal. We look forward to your continued demonstration to the community of your dedication to quality education, dedication that is exemplified by your financial commitment to the construction of Munticello High School. Sincerely, John E. Baker ~Vvre Expect Success" Chairman MARCH 4, 1998 EXECUTIVE SESSION MOTION I MOVE THAT THE BOARD GO INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION PURSUANT TO SECTION 2. I -344(A) OF THE CODE OF VIRGINIA: UNDER SUBSECTION ( I ) TO CONSIDER APPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS AND TO DISCUSS A STAFF ISSUE; UNDER SUBSECTION (7) TO CONSULT WITH LEGAL COUNSEL AND STAFF REGARDING SPECIFIC LEGAL MA~rERS RELATING TO CHARLO]-FESVILLE'S TRANSITION TO TOWN STATUS; AND UNDER SUBSECTION (7) TO CONSULT WITH LEGAL COUNSEL AND STAFF REGARDING TWO SERVICE AGREEMENTS. David R Bowerman Charlotte Y. Humphris Forest R. Mamhall. Or. COUNTY OF ALBEMAR! E Office of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclntim Road Charlof~ville. Virginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins Sal~ H. Thomas April 2. 1998 Mr. Jeffrey Sobel 3610 Ironwood Lane Charlottesville, VA 22901 Dear Mr. Sobel: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, and at the March 18, 1998 Charlottesville City Council meeting, you were appointed to the Commission on Children and Families. Your term will begin July 1, 1998 and run through June 30, 2000. On behalf of ~e Board, I would like to take this opportunity To express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to serve the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall. Jr. Chairman FRM:ibh cc: James L. Camblos, III Larry Davis Roxatme White c:\wpdoc$\b ds& corem\appoint Printed on recycled paper David l~ Bowerma.n Charloil~ Y. Humphrls Formst 1~ Mamh~dl. Jr. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Office of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville. V'nginia 22902-4,596 (804) 296-58'k3 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin I~vanna Walter E Perkins White Ha~ Sally H. Thomas Sara~el Mi~er March 9, 1998 Mr. Jeffrey W. Sobel 3610 Ironwood Lane Charlottesville, VA 22901 Dear Mr. Sobel: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, you were appointed to the Commission on Children and Families, as the Joint City/Appointee, with term to begin on March 4, 1398. You will be contacted in the near furore regarding your first meeting, and during the meeting the term limits will be set. On behalf of the Board, I would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to serve the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall. Jr. Chairman FRM/lbh cc: James L. Camblos, III Larry Davis Roxarme White o:mpdocsXbds&commkappoint Printed on recycled Daper County of Albemarle Office of Board of County S.upervisors 401 Mo/afire Koaa Charlottesville. VA 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD / COMMISSION / COMMITTEE (.plea..~ type or print) Board/Commission/Committee Co~,,~'~s(o~ on C..l~dg,¢~.,~ a~,-~ Applicaut'sName 3c_.~f'-c~-~) ~O. ~% bc~ Home Phone Magisterial District in which your home residence is located go.~totJ( EmployerCh*.~-~r I~he,~,.v~ ~tfk 5~_~k.~ of ©k~c~o~c Phone DateofEmployment ~1~1~7 Occupation/Tide m~,f2 t~c)~s~o~9 Years Resident in Albemarle County ~ o Previous Residence C k~ ~,~ cs o Spouse's Name L;~c~. L. t~--~M NumberofChildren Educa~ion(De~reesandGraduafionDates) ~.Pv x/o~\e_ , tq?l i M'~'&' ©'~/~ Memberships in Fraternal. Bus[ness. Church and/or Social Groups ~blic. C~ie ~d Ch~ble O~ce ~d / or ~er Activities or , Re~on(s/for Desi~ to Se~e on this go~d / Commission / Co~i~ee ~ ~o~on pmvid~ on ~ ~plicafion ~ ~ mI~ m ~ public ~n ~ue~ Si~ R~ W: Cle~ B~ of Co~W ~le Co~ 401 Mc~ Ro~ C~lo~flle, VA 22902~596 David P, Bowerrnan Rio Charlotte Y. Humphtis Form~ R. Mamhal. ,Jr. COUNTY OF Al ~EMAR! E Office of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclnfim Road Charlottesville, V'~mia 22902-4596 (804) 296-584,3 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins Wh~H~ Sally H. Thomas March 9, 1998 Ms. Meredith Strohm Gunter 448 Ednam Drive Charlottesville, VA 22903-4717 Dear Ms. Gunter: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, you were appointed to the Commission on Children and Families, with term to begin on March 4, 1998. You will be contacted in the near future regarding your first meeting, and during the meeting the term limits will be set. On behalf of the Board, I would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to serve the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall, Jr. Chairman FRMJlbh cc: James L. Camblos, III Larry Davis Roxanne White c:\wp docs\bds&comm\ap point Printed on recycled paper County of Albemarle :47 RCVD Office of Board of Counpf Supervisors 401 Mclntire Koad Charlottesville, VA 229024596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD / COMMISSION / COMZM~ I-lEE (please type or print) Board/Commission/Committee ~o~,'lr,~Js~to~ ~,-~ ~t~o'rH- ~ Applicant's Name ~ Egl~D tT,,4 Sw~.o'~wt C~ o ~'~.t_ Home Phone Home Address qq9 ~BlO~tm ~o~ O--~.LOTI~_~,'O~LL{. UOr Magisterial District in which your home residence is located 3~t~u~. Employer 5~_~-{: £~uo ~/~.b Phone Business Address ~o,.,~. o.~ ~ooo t_ ~e ¢~v~',~ Occupation/Title ~-~i~.~ ~'~r~_¢ Date of Employment Years Resident in Albemarle County /-- ~ Previous Residence Spouse's Name l~taqt~u~_¥ t4. C~uto~w_~. NumberofChildren Education (Degrees and Graduation Dates) ?\~.e~se se t ce~s u ~-- ¢ Memberships in Fraternal Business. Church and/or Social Groups Public. Civic and Charitab[e Office and / or Other Activities or Interests Reason(s~ for Desire to Serve on this Board / Commission / Committee The information provided on this application will be released to the public upon request. ' Signature k2 Return to: Clerk, Board of County Supervisors Albemarle County 401 M¢Intirc Road Charlottesville, VA 229024596 MEREDITH STROHM GUNTER 448 Edaam Drive Charlottesville, Virginia 22903-4717 msg~cfw.com BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Phone: 804 923-3870 Fax: 804 923-8224 EDUCATION Doctor of Philosophy in Education, University of Maryland College Park, Maryland 1987. Certificate in Aging Studies, Virginia Commonwealth University Richmond, Virginia 1980. Master of Science in Education, Indiana University Bloomington, Indiana 1976. Bachelor of Arts in Sociology, Miami University Oxford, Ohio 1974 EMPLOYMENT HISTORY FREE LANCE WRITER/EDITOR 7/1995 - present PROVOST, NEW COLLEGE OF GLOBAL STUD]liS 2/1993 - 6/1995 1Ladford University, Radford, Virginia. DIRECTOR OF INTERNATIONAL SERVICES Hunton & Williams [law firm), Richmond, VirgInia. SPECIAL ASSISTANT TO THI~ GOVERNOR Commonwealth of Virgima. ASSISTANT TO THE PRESIDENT DIRECTOR OF STUDENT SERVICES INSTRUCTOR OF SOCIAL WORK Longwood College, Virginia. FACIfLTY ASSOCIATE STAFF University of Maryland. COORDINATOR OF RESIDENCE EDUCATION INSTRUCTOR OF EDUCATION Virginia Commonwealth University. 2/1990 - 2/1993 1/1986 - 1/1990 8/1983 - 1/1986 8/1981 - 8/1983 8/1976 - 8/1981 MEREDITH STROItM GUNTER SELECTED BOARD MEMBERSHIPS AND RECOGNITIONS Board of Directors, ForCHILDREN, Inc., an international children's relief organization. 1994 - present Vice Chair, STARGATE, a not-for-profit organization provid'mg after-school arts education and academic enrichment to children. 1995 - 1997 Vice Chah', U.S. District Export Council 1994 - 1997 (appointed by the United States Secretary of Commerce) Chair, Foundation Board for the Governor% School for Govemment and International Studies, Richmond, Virginia. 1994 - 1997 Contributor, Report on Change in Higher Education, The Southern Regional Education Board, 1994. Thomas Magoon Distinguished Graduate Award, University of Maryland, 1994. Hardy Cross Dillard Award for Outstanding Contributions to the Commonwealth in International Trade Development, The Virginia State Bar, 1989. SELECTED PRESENTATIONS Presenter, "New Colleges: Innovative Alternatives in Response to Change in [-Iigher Education"; Southern Association of Colleges and Schools annual meeting, 1994. Presenter, Intematiunal Conference on Experiential Learning, 1994. Keynote Speaker, Center for the Advancement of Language Learning Colloquium on New Goals In Foreign Language Education, 1994. Keynote Speaker, 'Wirginia's Economic Outlook within the Global Marketplace": 23rd Annual Accounting and Auditing Conference, I993. PERSONAL Married to Bradley Hunt Gunter; with three cl-dldren, Hunt (30), Valerie (28), Macon (11), and three grandchildren. 448 Ednam Drive Charlottesville, Virginia 22903 January 8, 1998 Clerk, Board of County Supervisors Albemarle County 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596 Dear Members of the Board of Supervisors: As a new resident of Albemarle County, I write to introduce myself and to explain my interest in serving as a member of the Commission on Youth and Families. As most of my previous activities and organizational involvement occurred outside the county, I hope this letter and my resume will assist you m evaluating my potential to contribute to the important work of the Commission. My resume captures the highlights of twenty years of work experience, including four years as a policy analyst in the Office of the Governor. In 1995, I "retired" from full-time work to devote my time to a new family, including my stepson, Macon, who lost his mother to breast cancer. The reprieve from professional responsibilities has given me the opportunity to contribute not only to the lives of my family members, but also to the community. This is a change I wholeheartedly welcome. I have been particularly pleased to work with two organizations devoted tO the welfare of children: Since 1 995 I have served on the Board of ForCHILDREN an organization providing medical supplies, educational materials, and other necessary resources to children in developing countries and in economically disadvantaged regions of this country. ForCHILDREN has directed donated antibiotics, medicines, and medical assistance to Guyana, Belize, and Guatemala as well as clothing, books, and toys to children in the United States; STARGATE is a three-year-old organization which provides after- school arts education and academic enrichment to children from economically disadvantaged neighborhood s in Richmond. As Vice Chair of the Board, I assisted STARGATE in grant writing and in developing an innovative partnership with the Richmond Public Schools which expanded the program while reducing operating expenses by more than 75%. Board of Superwsors Page Two My family moved to Charlottesville in July of 1997, which resulted n my resignation from several of the Richmond-based organizations with which I had been affiliated. After unpacking the boxes and helping Macon adjust to a new school and surroundings, my husband and I have started to become involved in local civic activities. I have recently begun working with the Friends of the Cancer Center for the University of Virginia and also agreed to serve on the advisory board for LINC, an organization which helps cancer patients find pro bono assistance with legal issues r~lated to insurance or employment. My commitment to LINC includes grant writing from my home and helping LINC to expand from its predominantly Richmond presence to Charlottesville, and possibly statewide. While I am new to the area, am eager to contribute locally in ways which advance the welfare of children and families. I am a hard worker, an active board member, and a "quick study" who is familiar with governmental and inter-governmental operations. Most importantly, I believe that responsible and prudent investments in children and families secure the future for our communities. Thank you for your service to the County and for your attention to these materials. With kindest regards, I remain Sincerely, Meredith Strohm Gunter David R Bowerman Charlofle~ Humphris Fo,,~:~t R. Mamhall. ,Jr. COUNTY OF ALBEMARI ,E Off/ce of Board of Supervisors 401 Mcln~re Road Charlottesville, Vkginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins Sally H. Thomas March 9, 1998 Mr. Larry Miller 1706 Jumpers Run Charlottesville, VA 22911 Dear Mr. Miller: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, you were appointed to the Commission on Children and Families, with term to begin on March 4, 1998. You will be contacted in the near future regarding your first meeting, and during the meeting the term limits will be set. On behalf of the Board, ! would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to serve the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall, Jr. Clmirman FRMAbh cc: James L. Carnblos, III Larry Davis Roxanne White c:\wpdocs\bds& ¢ommkapp oint Printed on recycled paper County of Albemarle BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ^ Office of Board of County Supervisors 401 Mclntire R6ad Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD / COMMISSION / COMMITTEE (please type or print) Board/Commission/Cornmittce Commission on Children and Fatuities Home Phone 974-6716 22911 Phone (540)943-6675 Applicant's Name Larry L. Miller __ __ HomeAddress 1706 Jumpers Run Charlottesville, VA Magisterial District in which your home residence is located Employer Boy Scouts of America ' 801 Hopemafi Parkway Waynesboro~ VA 22980 Occupation/Title District Executive PreviousResidenc¢ Des Moines~ Iowa Nmber of Children 2 BS-1979 Doctor of Jurisprudence-1982 Business Address Date of Employment April, 1996 Years Resident in Albemarl~ County 2 Spouse's Name Sandra Kay Miller Education (Degrees and Graduation Dates) Memberships in Fraternal. Business. Church and/or Social Groups Immanuel Lutheran Church Public. Ci~cand Charimble Offiee and/orOtberActivitiesorln~msts Blue Ridge Mountains Rotary Club~ Lane League Board of Directors (Babe Ruth Baseball)? Charlottesville Albemarle Girls Softball coach (CAGS), Albemarle Patriots Booster Club (Football)~ Assistant Scoutmaster and Committee member Troop 111 BSA Re~on~) for De,re to Serve on ~is Board / Commission / Gommi~ee I am very interested in youth and I would like to ensure that they hage opportunities and services provided to them without being subject to misuse and waste of the resources available necessary to provide and modify these functions in our changing community. The information prodded on his applic~n will be released ~ the public upon request Return to: Clerk, Board of County Supervisors Albemarle County 401 Mchatim Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 January 12, 1998 Date David P. Bowerman C~lotte Y. Humph~ F-ormst R. Ma~halk &. COUNTY OF ALBEMARt F C~c.e o~ Board o~ Supennsors 401 Mdnttre Rond Charlottesville. Vkginia 22902-4,596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walt*r E Perkins Whi~ Hal Sally H. Thom~ Samuel Mi~er March 9. 1998 Ms. Maria Bell 520 Nottingham Road Charlottesville. VA 22901 Dear Ms. Bell: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, you were appointed to the Commission on Children and Families, with term to begin on March 4, 1998. You will be contacted in the near future regarding your first meeting, and during the meeting the term limits will be set. On behalf of the Board, I would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness re serve the Cotmty in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall, Jr. Chairman FRM:ibh cc: James L. Camblos, III Larry Davis Roxanne White o:\wpdo cs\bds&comm\appoint t:54nted on recycled paper 6 County of Albema -i-6 BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Office of Board of Coun~ Supervisors 401 Mclntire Rbad Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 APPLICATION TO SERVE ON BOARD / COMMISSION / COMMITTEE (please type or print) Board/Commission/Committee_ ~/~ry/~.~,- 0~,- I//~'P7,, ~t~ Applicant's Name_~h ~//~' ~x_. ~ !~ Home Phone ._~ ~ ~,~-~(~ ~ - : Magisterial D/strict in which your hl~me residence is locatexl ~/C Employer ]~tqc({ r~ Phone , :2, · Business Address ,,,Jr/D- D ~-a~.~n [~iqew ~lh,~e.a m' r , ateofEmployment ~ I~<~T · · ,-> ~ ' Occupation / Title _ P~gi¥'~,j~>r't4 .~/.I~'~,~ Years Resident in Albemarle C~unty / 0 · ~ ' - ' ' Prev,ous Residence, "J~/jA~/¥ Spouse's Name _ C/tx Dt/~ ¢~J~ ,~] NumberofChildren_ / · ) mucation(DegreesandOraduationDates) ~k,'/,3 &[~C~ Ig~ ~j /Xq, ~'~ /~7g ~ ]']a~ )'~'.a~ /97.5- Membership5 in Fraternal. Business. Church and/or Social Gren,,- Public. Civic and Charitable Office and / or Other Activities or Interestq Reason(s) for Desire to Serve on this Board / C~n,-,l~slon / Committe., Si~ Date Re~ to: Cle~, Bo~ of~un~ Su~i~ Albem~le 401 McIn~e Road Ch~loRe~ille, VA 229024596 COUNTY OF A~ R~J~RI .E Office of Board of Supen~isors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Ukgfnia 22902-4~596 (804) 296~5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles S. Mard~ Walt~r E Perkins March 9, 1998 Mr. Albert Humbertson, Jr. 1440 Beacon Hill Alton, VA 22920 Dear Mr. Humbertson: At the Board of Supervisors meeting held on March 4, 1998, you were reappointed to the Equ~zation Board, as the White Hall representative, with term to begin on January 1, 1998 and expire on December 31, 1998. On behalf of the Board, I would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to continue serving the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall, Jr. Chairman FRM/lbh cc: James L. Camblos, III Larry Davis Bruce Woodzell Prfnted on recycled paper COUNTY OF .~ R~-'jV~R[ ~ Offic~ of Board of Supervisors 401 Mclnfire Road Charlottm~lle, Vtrcjinia 229024596 (804) 296-5843 FAX I804) 296-5800 Charles S. Martin Walter E Perkins Sa~y H. ~om~ March 11.1998 Mr. Robert C. Pianta Department of Hurnm~ Resources 405 Ermnet Street Ruffner Hall, Room 147 Charlottesville, Va 2290,3. Dear Mr. Pianta: The Albemarle Board of County Supervisors is pleased to confirm your appointment as the University of Virginia representative to the Commission on Children and Families, with said term to begin March 4, 1998. You will be contacted in the near future regarding your first meeting, and during the meeting the term limits will be set, On beha!f of the Board, [ would like to take this opportunity to express the Board's appreciation for your willingness to serve the County in this capacity. Sincerely, Forrest R. Marshall, Jr. Chairman FRM:lbh cc: James L. Camblos, Larry Davis Roxanne White enwpdocs\bds&comm\appoint Printed on recycled paper Madison Hall ' P.O, Box 9014 EXECUTIVE VlC~ PRESlDEqT AND CHII~ FINANCIAL OFFICER Mania 2, 19!}8 M~. Roxanne White A~sistant County Executive County of~b~ 401 Mc~ RO~ ~lo~s~li~, V~ia 2290~96 I nm pl .e~,d that mo University wi~ ~e able to ¢on~.'bu~ meanin~,ly tO the w.o~.k of the ltew Commzsdoll on Children and Famih~, We appre~lat~ the opporllaity to appolIlt a member to iervc a fl~ree-year tel'm, 4~Fartment of Human Services F. mmet Stre~ Hall Room 147 Chadott~vilk Virgini~ 22903 Phone: 924-07!}2 Fax: 2434480 F-mail. rcp4pl~V~rllmta, ichl ] ad that once the commission ~t~ going..t:he intent is to l~ve m.~n~ serve stq~ered ?rn~ of. appoi~ _tm~t., ?~_othtr f~/mern~b~ ul thc CIm'y Soho, ol, M~. Shall, ~pre~,, in .t?eet tn working with the a~an'tission aaa ~a~ed that I tx~vard her name m you for ~msid~ation next year or ai~ward. Please let me know if you ~ additional infatuation. Thank you. and Chief l~inanoial Offi~r ~; .Mr. Rob~t C. Pianta David R Bowerman Charlot~ Y. Hurnphris Forms~ ~. Mamha~. 3r. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Office of Board of Supewisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Vn~ginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 FAX (804) 296-5800 Charles $. Martin Walter F. Perkins Sally H. Thomm March 9, 1998 Town of Scottsville P.O. Box 395 Scottsville, VA 24590 Dear S/rs: The Albemarle Board of County Supervisors, at its March 4, 1998 meet'rog, authorized the Chair of the Board of County Supervisor to execute the amended service agreement between the Town of Scottsville and Albemarle County Sheriff's Department and Albemarle County for January 1, 1998 through June 30, 1999. I have attached an original signed copy for your records. Sincerely, Laurel B. Hall Senior Deputy Clerk Attachment cc: Sheriff Hawkins Rick Huff Printed on recycled paper AMENDED SERVICE AGREEMENT BETWEEN TOWN OF SCOTTSVILLE AND ALBEMARLE COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT AND ALBEMARLE COUNTY JANUARY 1, 1998 - JUNE 30. 1999 THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this 1st day of January, 1998, by and between the Town of Scottswille, Virginia, (hereafter "Town"), the Sheriff of the County of Albemarle, Virginia. (hereafter "Sheriff'), and the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "County"), WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the Circuit Court of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, duly approved a boundary adjustment, "Agreement ro Relocate Boundary Line Between the Town of Scottsville and the County of Albemarle," pursuant to Section 15.2-3106, Code of Virginia, (1950), as mended, on September 27, 1993; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Sections 14.1-70 and 15.2-1726 of the Code of Virginia (1950), the Town, the Sheriff, and the Coumy entered into a tripartite Service Agreement dated January 31, 1994 and amended December 21, 1994 and June 21, 1996, for the purpose of having the Sheriff furnish taw enforcement services in the Town; and WHEREAS, the Town, the Sheriff, and the County now wish to amend the Service Agmemeur to recognize that the County will no longer fund any deputy positions assigned for law enforcement services in the Town; and WHEREAS, the Sheriff has provided full-time police protection in the Towm for the past three years; and WHEREAS, the Town has been pleased with the police protection provided by the Sheriff and his Deparunent; and WHEREAS, the Town and the Sheriff have worked well together to provide safer streets, quiet evenings and pleasant surroundings to both the residents and the visitors of the Town; NOW THEREFORE, the Town, the Sheriff, and the County hereby agree as follows: I. The Service Agreement between the Town, the Sheriff and the County dated January 31, 1994 and amended December 21, 1994 and June 21, 1996, attached hereto as Exhibit "A", and incorporated herein by reference, is hereby mended by replacing paragraph 4 and paragraph 5 and paragraph 9 therein with a new paragraph 4 and paragraph 5 and paragraph 9 fully set our below and also by adding a new paragraph t3: 4. The deputies shall be selected by the both the Town and the Sheriff. If the Town and the Sheriff agree to reassign a deputy and a new replacement deputy sheriffis assigned to Scottsvitle, the replacement deputy shall only be appointed as a Town deputy if the deputy has the support and approval of the Town. The purpose for the approval of the deputy sheriffby both the Sheriff and the Town is to ensure a competent law enforcement professional assigned to the Town who has good working relations with the Town goverranent. 5. A. Funding shall be provided by the Town, either from Town tax revenues, fees and gifts, or from revenues paid to the Town from state, federal or private grants. B. All grants initiated by the Town and awarded to the Town orto its police depamnent shall remain under the control and the direction of the Town and if the grants are for the funding of Sheriff's Deputies assigned to the Town. the Town will seek the advice and input 2 of the Sheriff before making a final decision on the allocation of the grant funds. C. Salaries of the deputies shall be paid solely by the Town or.the State Compensation Board, and all other costs not covered by the State including, but not limited to, vehicles, police equipment, supplies, uniforms, medical insurance, liability insurance, FICA, retirement benefits and xelated costs shall be paid by the Town. 9. This Agreement may be terminated by mutual agreement of the parties at anytime, or by either party for good cause after providing 6 months wriuen notice to the other parties of the intent to terminate the Agreement on a date certain. All parties shall review the Agreement on an annual basis within 60 days of the end of the fiscal year, however the first annual review shall not occur prior June 30, 1999. 13. The primary responsibility for the taw enforcement officers of the Town is law enforcement within the Town limits of Scottsville; These officers shall respond to calls outside the Town limits only when such calls involve life-threatening situations; However, the Town Officers may offer their assistance outside the town limits in non-emergency situations at their discretion. II. Ali other terms, conditions, requirements, and obligations of the Service Agreemem, referenced above, shall remain unchanged and shall continue in full force and effec~ IN WITNESS WltEREOF~ the parties have caused this Agreement to be duly executed in several counterparts, each of which- shall constitute an original 3 Approved as to Form: Town Attorney COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA Forrest R. Marshall, Jr., Chairman Approved as to Form: SHERIFF OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA 4 AMENDED SERVICE AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT, made'and entered into this ,,~ / ~¢'day of Apr4~, 1996, by and 3etween the Town of $cott~sville, Virginia, (hereafter 'q'own"), the Sheriff of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "Sheriff'), and the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "County"), WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the Circuit Court of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, dui,/ap~3roved a boundary adjustment, "Agreement to Relocate Boundary Line Between the Town of Scottsviile and the County of Albemarle", pursuant to Section 15.1~1031.1, Code of Virginia, (1950), as amended, en September 27, 1993; and, WHEREAS, the Town agreed with the County to provide full-time police protection in the Town when the said Boundary Adjustment became effective at midnight of December 31, 1993; and. WHEREAS, pursuant to Sections 14. t-70 and 15.1-131.3 of the Code of Virginia (1950), the Town. the Sheriff, and the County entered into a tripartite Service Agreement dated January 31. 1994 and amended December 21, 1994, for the purpose of having the Sheriff furnish law enforcement services in the Town; and, WHEREAS, the Town, the Sheriff, and the County now wish to amend the Service Agreemen~ ~o recognize the County's willingness to temporarily continue to contribute to_ funding for law enforcement services fn the Town until July 1, 1997, ~nd to further recognize that, thereafter, the County will no longer fund any deputy positions ass'~ned for law enforcement services in the Town.- . NOW THEREFORE, the Town, the Shedff, and the County hereby agree as follows: The Service Agreement between the Town, the Shedff, and the County dated January 31, 1994 and amended December 21, 1994, attached hereto as Exhibit "A", and '~ncorporated herein by reference, is hereby amended by replacing paragraph 5 therein with a new paragraph 5 fully set out below: Funding shall be provided entirely by soumes other than the County, Salaries of the deputies shall be paid solely by the Town or the State Compensation Board, and all other costs not covered by the State including, but not limited to, vehicles, police equipment, sucplies, uniforms, medical insurance, liability insurance, FICA. retirement benefits and related costs shatl be paid by the Town. Notwithstanding the above, the County shall allow one locally County funded deputy position to be assigned for law enforcement services in,he Town until July 1, 1997, provided that the State Compensation Board has not funded a law enforcement position for the Town. Thereafter. no locally County funded deputy positions shall be assigned for law enforcement services in the Town. All other terms, conditions, requirements, and obligations of the Service Agreement, referenced above, shall remain unchanged and shall continue in full force and effect IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be duly executed in several counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original TOWN OF SCOTTSVILLE. VIRGINIA 2 A'IU'EST: Clerk Approved as to Form: Town Attdrney COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA By Charlotte Y. Humphds. Chai~Tnan Approved as to Form: County Attorney ' SHERIFF OF THE COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE. VIRGINIA T e~y"~.-l~awkins, Shedff 3 E~B ibit A AMENDED SERVICE AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this .~1 ¢r day of December, 1994, by and between the Town of Scott~ville, Virginia, (hereafter 'q~own"), the Sheriff of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "Sheriff'), and the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "County"), WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the Circuit Court of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, duty approved a boundary adjustment, "Agreement to Relocate Boundary Line Between the Town of Scottsviiie and the County of Albemarle", pursuant to Section 15.1-1031.1, Code of Virginia, .(1950), as amended, on September 27, 1993; and, WHEREAS, the Town agreed with the County to provide full-tlme police protection '~n the Town when the said Boundary Adjustment became effective at midnight of December 31, 1993; and, WHEREAS, pursuant to Sections 14.1-70 and 15.l-13t .3 of the Code of Virginia (1950), the Town, the Sheriff, and the County entered into a bipartite Service Agreement dated January 31, 1994, for the purpose of having the Sheriff furnish taw enforcement services in the Town; and, WHEREAS, the Town, the sheriff, and the County now wish to amend the Service Agreement to recognize a funding opportunity to provide taw enforcement services in the NOW THEREFORE, the Town. the She£~, and the County hereby agree as follows; The Service Agreement between the Town, the Sheriff, and the County dated January 31, 1994, attached hereto as 'Exhibit "A", and incorporated herein by reference, is hereby amended by replacing paragraph 5 therein with a new paragraph 5 fully set out below: Funding shall be provided entirely by sources other than the County. Salaries of the deputies shall be paid solely by the Town or the State Compensation Board, and alt other costs not covered by the State including, but not limited to, vehicles, police equipment, supplies, uniforms, medical · nsurance, liabitity insurance, FICA, retirement benefits and related costs shall be paid by the Town. Notwithstandind the above, the County shall allow one locally County funded det~utV oositio8 to be assiened for taw enforcement services An the Town until Jutv 1. 1996. orovided that the State Com0ensation Board has not funded a law enforcement position for the Town. Thereafter-, no locaflv County funded deputy positions shall be assiqned for law enforcement services in the Town. o All other terms, conditions, requirements, and obligations of the Service Agreement. referenced above, shall remain unchanged and shalt continue in full force and effect. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be duly execute~ ir~ ~verat counterparts, each of which shall consutute an original. 2 ATTEST: , Clerk TOWN OF SCO'Ft-SV1LLE, VIRGINIA Approved as to Form: , Walter F. Perkins, Chairman A'FTEST: Approved as to Form:" SHERIFF OF THE COUNTY OF A' EMARLE, Terry W. Ha~vkins, Sheriff $ E~R.VICE AGRE]~fE/'U~ THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this ~_A~.._ day of January, 1994~ by and between the Town of S~ottsvi!Ie, Virg~ia, (hereafter "ToWn") , the Sheriff of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "Sheriff"), and the County of Albemarle, Virginia, (hereafter "County"), w I TN E S S E T H: WI~EP~EAS the Circuit Court of the County of Albemarle, Virginia, duly approved a boundary adjustment, "Agreement to Relocate Boundary Line Between the ToWn of Scottsvi!le and the County of Albemarle", pursuant to Section I5.1-iG31.1, Code of Virgiriia, (!950) } as amended, on Septm~her 27, 1993; and, W~'~F2~S the Town has agreed with the County to provide full- time police protection in the Town when the said Boundary Adjustment becomes effective on or at midnight of December 31, 1993; and, WHEREAS th~ Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, provides under Sections !4.!-70 and 15.1-131.3 that the Town, the Sheriff, and the County may enter into a ~riparti~e agreement for the purpose of having the Sheriff furnish law enforcement services in the Town; and, WHEREAS the Town now desires to enter into such an agreement for taw enforcement services with the Sheriff and the County pursuant to Section !5. i-13!.3, NOW THEREFORE, the Town, the Sheriff, and the County hereby agree as fol'iows: 1 The Sheriff shall provide two (2) full time deputies for the purpose of providing law enforcement services in the Tow~. A reduced nu/~ber of deputies may be provided upon the consent or request of the Tow~. The said deputies shall be deputies of the Sheriff,s Office and wear Sheriff's office uniforms. The deputies shall be specifically assigned to the Town and may, in the discretion of the Sheriff, assist deputies outside ~he Town when called upon to do so. The deputies shall be selected by the Sheriff with the full advice and consent of the Town. F=nding shall be provided entirely by sources other than t/le Cc~/%t~/. Salaries of the deputies shall be paid solely by the State Compensation Board, and al! other costs not covered by the St=re including, but not !~ted to, vehicles, police ec/~ipment, s~ppties, ~niforms, medical insurance, liability insurance, FICA, retirement benefits and related costs shall be paid by the Town. The Sheriff and any deputy sheriff serving as a Town law enforcement Officer shall have authority to enforce the ordinances of the Town. The Sheriff and any deputy sheriff, while serving as law enforcement officers of the Town, shall have the same powers, rights, benefits, privileges and immu3aities as those of regular Town police officers. Under this Aqreement, the Sheriff shall be the Chief of Police of the Town. 2 10. This Agreement may be terminated by mutual agreement of the parties at any time, or by any party for good ca~se after providing six months written notice to the other pa~rties of the intent ~o terminate the Agreement on a date certain. The Town shall pay its pro-rata share of dispatch costs of the Chartottesvi!le-2%lbemarle County Emergency Operations Center based on the same formula used for other law enforcement agencies ~hat are dispatched by the Center. These costs shall be assessed after a full year of da=a for calls for service is collected. The Town and the county shall enter into a reciprocal agreement for mutual assistance between the Sheriff and r_he County's Police Department prior to any services being provided to the Town under this Agreement. This reciprocal agreement shall determine which agency shall have primary responsibility for responding to calls for service, for handling criminal investigations, and for any other matters. In addition, the reciprocal agreement shall determine the procedure for Federal and State crime reporting requirements so that there will be no duplicate reporting of crime s~atiszics. Notwithstanding paragraph 9~ above, upon any final deteannination by the County that the amount of State aid received by the County for its Police Department pursuant to ChapTer !, Article i0 of Title 1%.1 (Sectioils 1~.1-8~ through I%.1-84.7) of the Code of Virginia, also known as "599" funds, Ss diminished or reduced as a result ~f this AgreemenT, the Couglty may void this kgreemen~ au any such tlme so as uo restore ~hau funding for that fiscal year or any subsequenu fiscal year. iN WITNESS W~IER~OF, the p~/~aies have caused this AgreemenC ~o be duly execu=ed in several countez-par~s, each of which shall constitute an original. ~TTEST: ~ CIe~k TOWN OF SCOTTSVZLLE, VIRGINIA Approved as ~:0 Form: Town Attorney COUNTY OF ALBE~E, VIRG!NZA W~lter F. P ' , Ch~__~n Approved as to Form: ATTEST: '~ ~ ~ un y I torney SHERIFF OF'THE. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE, VIRGINIA Ha~kins, Sheriff 94.008 F~,~?. i998 11: 54AM HtRSCHLER FLEISCHER ~IRS~H~,ER~ RICl;D4OND 7011 LAW , Cox & Aic s I0~ 1;REDItR[C'Ii~rdIIG ~D~E~II3[SBII~G, VA 22401-~74~ February 27, 1998 VIA FACSIMILE (804) 972,4068 Greg Kamptner; Esquire Assistant County Attorney 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Re: Rezoning Application - GrOup, LLC Dear G~eg: In accordance with ou: rec~nt Amended and Restated Proffe: Crescent Development Group, LLC, You will fi~d a clean cop~ which shews the changes made since This Amended agreed to at our meeting I deeply apprsciate the time which Proffered Conditions and enabling us t ~7-01/Crescent Development coz~fersness, please find enclosed an case ZMA-97-01. the case and a highlighted copy on Februa_~y 13, 1998. the changes which we leaders this past Monday evening, devoted ~o reviewing these ~ acceptable form. F£~27.19~ 11:55RM HIR$CHLER FLEISCHER HO.~O P.3/'18 A I~RO~ESSIONAL CORPORATIO~ It is my u~derstanding that th' a~e ' be heard before the ,B, oard of Supe~sa~of~berm~leOo~onle~et~,M,~ch4. . . -- ~[ .1998at3,30p.m. Wit~ s~c~e appre~a~on for ~d assistance, ~d with ~ghest respe~, I rem~, Feb:uary 27, 1998 Page 2 Enclosure cc: Mr. Sco~t Williams Mr. O:eg Juriak Mr. WaFne Cillemberg ~ ] ~inc.~rely yo_urs, FEB. 87.1998 ll:5SAM HIRSCHLER ~'L~ AMENDE~ AN PROFFER ST CRESCENT DEVELOP~ REZONINO APPLIC~ Cre~cent Development Croup, L.L,~ ~s arid Florence L. Fxtzg~rsld, Still Meadow Land T= cartain property located in Albemarle Count/(the ZMA-97-01 as Tax Map 46 Parcel 21 and portiere "Property"), The contract purchaser and th~ owne are here,_'~m~er, oollectively, refereed ~o as tlie "O~ if the Property is. re2-oned by the Board of SBpervi! planned residential developm? (the "PRDIg, der accordance with the plan submittal herewith last '?rel~mlnm? Plan Showing Lots 1 Thru 151i Still County, Vhl~inia" prepared by B, Aubrey I-hiffma subject to the following proffers pursuant la Secti~ amended (th~ "Code"), and applicable provisions (the "Ordlnance'9. All references to numb¢~d . If Ownars' rczoning applicatibn is cl~.m.'ed, void and of no further force or effect. All of[hose Ordinance and relevant sections of tim COd~. The anthoriz¢ any person to apply lesser standanis regulatory or code minimum standards, or (ii) Cot Ordinance, except as permMed by the regulations shall supersede all other proffers made l~iOi hereu 1. ~.Lq.~, P~or to or c4.ncurrc approved by the County and before ~he covered by said subdivision plat (o~er th~ utilities), Owners sbs!! record ~ Office ofth~ Circuit Court of Albemarle development and require.men, ts for n~ainte~ Com ,~m Areas or facilities includel,ere CI~_!_I_I_I_I_I_I~_~. To the extent reasonably practic and Cor~munity Dc, v¢lopment or hi~ d~s mature ~ on remdent/al lots shall[be the structure and its normal and cu~o_ nm am~s requir~ to permit utility servi~s, such trees which trove bccn saved ~ay u&hout thc consent of the Archit~ural N0,9~ P.4/1B RESTATED TEMEN~r ION. ZMA-97-01 ~.7, 1998 mntract purchaser, Ollie L, ¥it~gerald, Ir. ,I and Sane Will?m~on are thc owners of that 2ounty") dcscnbed in rezoning application ~fTax Map 45B2 Parcels 2 and 4 (the , and their respective successors and assigns ~rs". Owners hereby voluntarily proffer that rs of Albemarle County (the '~Board') to thc opment of the Property ~1 be in vis~ September 18, 1997, entitled -~tow, Rio Magisterial District, Albemarle ~ Associates (the 'Tiaa"), and shall be 15,2-2295 of thc Code of Virginia 0 950), as :khe Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance are to those lots as numbered on the Plan. ~se proifer~ sh~ll b~ inuuediately null and offers ~ offer~ vol~ily p~u~t m ~e roffe~ ~rc~ s~I not be ~re~ m ~ose centred ~ ~y: (i) m~ mt~ow, ~ or--ce or m~on, ~clud~g ~c ~ p~ ~i~g ~s~ct, ~so pro~s : with the mcordaion of a subdivision plat eyanc¢ of any posen of the Property br the ded/catlon of casements, roads or the"Pro~ectivc Covenants'9 in the Clerk's unty, Virginia, s~lling forth controls on the nco of such portions of thc Property. and any ~ and at a rn!rdm.m as se~ forth her=in. :1¢, as determined by the Director of Planning .-c, at the time of development thc clearing of ~d to ~rces in ~rcas required to accommodate ~:cess.orias, open yard areas and those lhr~ed m dr~,n~ge facilities and driveways. Any cleared by any ftmzre owner of any lo: ~'ol Co__mwRte~ of the Hom¢owner~ f7 F15B.~7.1998 11:~:J4M HIR$CHLER FM5t~ ~0.988 P.5/18 Association provided for in the Prote~'vc C pr~ticable, as determined by ~e Dire'ctor o~ his designee, at the time of development the inches (6') in caliper me~.sured two f~et (2') be tire, ted to trees in areas required to:accon drainage facilities and other open ar~s, and services and driveways. The compliar~ with this Proffered Cond',Sion provided for in the Protective 3. Rivanna River Green Belt. Owners s~ll along the boundary of the Property ~d edji No structural impmvem.en, ts (other th~n ped eonsu-ucted or erected vmhln the Green Bal Green Belt shall be preserve.cl, in. its c~rent ~ measures including, but no~ limited ~, the and shrubs, and clean up along the ri~cr. O easements, and aeces$ ea.semonts to ~ development and their gue~, and may, at or. slmjler recreational uses. At such ~ime P. ivanna River a public area or park County, Owners sha~!, convey.the trails or other uses ~dentified in this may continue to be maintal-cd by O~aer. s such mainte~.ce, Albemarle County at desitnated by the County may maintiain spaces as shown on the approved suIMiv/si, documented with photographs or vi~eomp, 4. Water.Oualiw Concept Plan. In ord~.r to detention requirements, Owners ~impk Concept Plan: Storm w.ae. r deta,n.~on facili~es water, which shall include bgt not accommodate one h~!t'(1/'2) klch impervious area in dr~i-.~ ~ea; features as may be approvediby sbown generally T the plau ~ An age 2 '7 Ilenan. ts. To the extent.reasonably annmg and Community Devclopmem or leafing ofma~.a'~ trees (no less than six bore ground level) in COmmOn ereas shall aodate pedestrian paths, playing fields, ~ose limited areas required to permit utility [bility for tl~ impIemen~ation and rest with the Homeowners Association ~ve a one hundred (100) foot wide area nt to the Rivanna River (the "Oreen Belt"). ~rian and riding txails and utilities) shall be ithout the consent of the County. The dition except for general beautification :axing of underbrush, removal of dead tr~s ner~ may grant, across the Green Belt, utility ma River for the residents of the ~ir option, build pedestrian and riding ~xails · he County decides to establish along the ~ Green Belt, and upon a request by the itle ~o the GreenBelt to the County without owed for utilities, and pedesa'ian and riding are reserved in the deed. The Orcen Belt ~th¢ Property; however~ in the absence of ption or a~y public agency ~r authority me hundred (100) fo~t vdde Crreen Belt, ~ed Green Belt ancl two (2) visitor parldng ~plat. The curcem condition will be re water quality in excess of normal water cut the following three (3) tier Water Quality ~dli.ze BM? De.sign Criteria to filter storm limited to facilities designed to ~orege per acre of ultimate development [iment forebays; aquatic benches; ~d such ~ngineering Department, These facilities are A, Area B mad Area C. water that is not required to be detained MP Design Crit~ia as stated in subparagraph he plan as Area D, FEB. ~'7. 1998 N0.900 ~.6/1W shall hun&~ (100) feet !ma~,~pt to' facilities are strewn A riparian buffe~ of t as shown generally on the and shrubs pursuant m A m~n,made weflani TI~ properties, and is generally Either a level f~r water not being m thc approval, the Engineering Dapmt~Uent mci alon~ the Rivama River, Owners ', making such buffer one These (30) feet will be planted along the stream Th~ buffer will consist of rip,an trees )y the Engineering Deparunent. to set .~ a regioml water quality facility. site as well as many up-s~ream ~Area G, will be built m control wa~r quality ~.enerally shown on the plan as Area been designed to comply with the County's e impl~mentexl pursuant to a design subject only be modified with the approval of .1 be Critical Slopes? ' ¢~tical slope on the subdivision lots; lots 96 through 142 ~ are currently slope areas throu~ utility li~s and laterals. Buffer Aze~ width, the rear most forty (40) feet c mainteinad across the rear lot li~es c Nortl~elds and Westmoreland Subd condition except for the removal of 1 of a sanit~y s~wer line in the sa~t~ required by the County or any other approval, and for essential utilities. and othe~ vegetation may be remove vegetation sbiC! be removed. Thc r~ sanitary s~wcr ~asement ~1~11 not e~ and other ve~etatio~ nol withi~ the ~ plan shsl! deslgnatc the areas of on thc applicable plat as "Restricted Areas" the portions of the use of the critical The Protective Covenants shall limit the shall ~llow for the construction of isio: es a and of seventy (70) feet in .. shall be ~ on the Plan. adjoining This buffer shsn remain in ~ undisturbed other vegetation required for the installation easement, for improvemems as may. be ;ntal body as a condition of subdivision me s~itm~ sewer easemem, existin~ trees ~Ilen, diseased or dead trees and other ~ftrees and o~er v.egeta~on w/thin the ~nty (20) feet m width. The removal of trees ~ewer easement shall be limited to the '7 F~B. ~?. 1998 11: 5~AM HIRSCHLER F~EIS~ 10, minimum extent necessary to provide for t Any trees or other vegetation removgd she departments of the Count~. The subs~c~ of g-ds Proffer'shell covanants referred to in Proffer 1, The Ho: W~u~ordand Subdivmons wMch a~jom 1 specifically be identified as th/rd ~ ben fight under the Protective Cove~TM to en Lo__tWidth, Lots 1-17 ,i~c, lusiv¢ as s~own Wesunorelend $ubdivis:ans shall be{at they abut in Nor~ickis end Wesm~rehn Pedesl~an Paths. Owners agrees ua ~onsl~ paved pe~a~a paths four (4) feet in widt (to mad ¥), ¥, end O, end for two (2~ pcdes Said ~oeds are shown on the Plan. ~mners paths from road A to Cemsbrook Dri~,e end Department ofTr~sportation C%rD~)T road rights-of-way. U ' ~.d. er~rotmd Utility Lines. Except utility ~ines and wetlands, ffeny, ell ~ttility. be underground, Chinmev . chim ys or veauaits: all .fir. eplace ch,mney$ slmll be brick pr of a residence, This Proffer shall mat ~PtY~ exposed bases of all chimneys shall I~ I 1,Foundations..,Th,e exposed ext /or oCdom constracted o£bfizk or natural stome4!provi~ residence foundations may be comcmlcted e pro ided the ex.or of., 13. ~. The proposed Re~eafioI complemd no later than the complain of ti / 14, Tra~c Sier~l. Owaers shall, upm ~rilten hundred dollars [$10.200.00) toward ~h~ co. P~g~ 4 c N0.900 P.7/1$ required improvemtmts or essential utilities. .be r~plsaed, ifpr~'mitted by the appropriate included as a restr/ction in the Protective ,,owners Association shall monitor and owners of the lots in Northfields and $1-I~, inclusive, as shown on the Plan, shall [cierics of this restriction, and shall have the ~e this res~iction, the Plan adjoiming Nonkfidds and ~tuel in width to the rear lot lines or,he lots ,ubdivisious as shown on the Plan. ~ with each phase of development asphalt- on one side of roads A, B, C¢o road D), D 4an access easements m the Open Spa~e. 11 cons~uct the asphalt-paved l~dest~s~ orflffields Road provided the Virginia roves the paths m be committed within t~ boxes, meters end exis'dng overhead les, to the extent reasonably practical, shall eli be cantilevered. The exposed portions of tding similar to thc cxt~"fior tr~amaent of the ,~ct vent gas fireplaces or appliances, The same material as the residence foundation. >f exterior residence foundations shall be d, however, the exposed portions of exu~rior drivit or stucco if applied to a mason~ ~h rosidenc~ are primarily of dr/vit or ,c a two- (2) ear gmage, ~as as shown on the Plan shall be second phase of development. quest therefor, contribute ten thousand two ffthe traffic sisal instell~i a~ the ~7 FEB. ~7.1998 11:58AM HIRSC~R FLEIS~H~R N0,900 P,Bx18 15. 16. 17. 18. ~0. Pavement Strioin~z. Owners shal pavement markings Road and Cartsbrook Drive Road and Fdo Road and Huntington on Old Brook Road to create two re~o~.r.ended in that lewr markings to fl~ (lOOth) lotin the project. !~rovid~ additio~l right.of-way or ~ No more than forty shall be requested in any approval of thc cumulative basis so that any lass~t over and added ~ Cash Payment. Owners shall impwvements and hnpac~ the seswicc district for the for schools wkich serve the Rio be equal to one thousand dollars shall bc due at the time of f~sl plat of residential lots included/n such any of such funds are not r~ expended for the (10) years from thc date ofpaym~t, County Plavln~ Field. In order to reduce the Rocre. ation Depm'tmcnt, thc ~ developed at a ml-~um for an soccer field for Number of Lots. one hun&cd thirty, five (135~ Berms. An undulat/n~ Payment will be made at thc time of final of lanes by adding additional t at the intersections of Old Brook Kio Road and Northfields [ will provide additional pavement markings and one (1) receiving lane, ali as Bill Fr/tz, Department of Plauning and Owners will complete these l~avemem final plat approval of thc on~-hun&edth to require Owners to , of the roads where said strip'mg will be certificates of occupancy ("C.O.'s'~ period follovd_'-g the final Such calculation shall be made on a 'C.O.'s in any such period may be carriexl subsequent period or periods. ' for facility quested herein within paymcntshall th~ County that my of such funds are not gram within ten anywhere in the County. development on the Parks and 55) acres of open area shall be field no less than a regulation-size guests as shown on the md shall be of lots shown on the Pl~ no more than (3) feet and six (63 feet inclusive, and Lots 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 145 through 154, inclusive, to provide pfi lots. Exterior Li~htln~ at Reereagon At.ss. ~ Areas shall not exceed twenty (20) fe~t in of the lighting standard, shall be produced type), md shall not exceed one-lmlf (IF.I) Severance. The ~nenforceabiliw, e~mi~ati forth here~, in whole o~ in parr. ,~!I not a protT~rs or the w~ffecr~d p~-~ of any such Si~torV, These Profits sl~I1 ~ with withi, these Proffers shall n-~an the then and shall be bindin! upon, Own~s' succes Property or any pon/on ofth~ Prot~'ty. Homeowners Association. Carrsbrook, W~ be entitled to appoint one vogng r~-mber f Directors of thc Still Meado. w~ Homeowne Cov~ants so lon~ as there ~s any undevelo Alternate Access. Owllers a~re~ to use way from Clarence Wetzel and th~ house a attbe ter~l~ts of Westmoreland Road to entrance from Ca~rsbrook Drive to i~s in~er~ said propertias can be obmln~i at commercl govemm~t~l and legal approvals can be or is given that such properties can be obi: M0.900 and screening for the residents of such z exterior li~atin~ fi,mares at the Recreation eight as measured from the grade at the base ¥orn concealed sources o~light (i.e., shoe box ,et camtl¢ at the boundaries of the Prol~sy. revision or ~.m~_men: o~any Proffer set Fect the validity or enforceability of the other Property and each reference to Owners ~rent owner of tho Property or potion thereof ;or(s) in interest and/or th~ developer of the s~moreland a~.,d Northflelds Sutxlivisions shall om ~h subdivision to serve on the Board of Association provi~d for in the Protective ,~ed lot in Still Meadows Subdivision. Owners.sl~]l participate with Carribrook, s/n seeking assistant; from the County and sures/n th~ ir~r~ediate area including, but not ~l, Westmoreland !~ad, NorrMields Road sums may include, but are not limited to, i~hment of four-way srnps, increased ,ar~i¢ipation sh~ll include paying for the ~ost ~or wrir~ notice by the County to do so, f these Proffers by the Board, if such four- :'ftc calming measures fmcl sr~ not paid for by ~able efforts to purchas~ sm~flcient fight-of- lot from thc owner of the property located com~odat~ the relocation of the proposed ,-ction with Westmomhnd Road, provided ~lly reasonable prices and all required mined for such relocation. No assurance can ~d or that such ~ntrancc can be relocated. P~gc 6 7 Wimess thc following si~ugurc and seal: Cl~ OLL] FIZZ By: STIL By: SAN] By: COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINL~ CITY 0F CHARLOTTESVILLE, to-w/t: My commission expires: ..~,' -~ ~ ~ #$0~2- 20~07.01058 ~0.900 P,1B/18 ~CENT DEVELOPMENT GROLrP, L.L.C. )~: A. Wflfiam% Manager ~ L. FITZGERALD, J1L and FLOR.IK~CE L. ~P, ALD ~cott A. Williams, The/r Attorney-in-Fact , ~OW LAND TRUST Se, otl A. Williams, I~s Attorney-in-Fact WILLIAMSON Scott A. Williams, Her Attorney. in-Fact Nora Public ~/ Pag~ ?c~? CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C. February 17, 1998 Mr. Wittiam D~ Fritz Senior Planner County of Albemarle De~. of Planning & Community Development 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 RE: ZMA 97-01 Still Meadow DearMr. Ffi~: With this letter, we request that the referenced rezoning request be deferred from the February t8, 1998 Board of Supervisors meeting to the Board's March 4, 1998 meeting. If you have any questions about our request, or if we can provide any additional information in support of this, please let us know. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Scott A. Williams Manager cc: Ella Carey February 13, 1998 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Dept. of Planning & Community Developmem 40] Mclntire Road Charlottesville. Virginia 22902-4596 [804) 296-5823 BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Scott A. Williams HCR 1, Box 3 Charlottesville, VA 22901 RE: ZMA-97-01 Still Meadows Dear Mr. Williams: The Albemarle County Planning Commission, at its meeting on February 10, 1998, by a vote of 5-1, recommended approval of the above-noted petition to the Board of Supervisors. Please note that this approval is subject to acceptance of the applicant's proffers. With the understanding that the following proffers will be amended as follows: No. 2 (Clearing) - Trees may be removed only with approval of an architectural review board. No. 4 IWater Quality Concept Plan) - Water quality protection measures, including maintenance, shall be subject to the review and approval of the County Engineer. No. 6 (Buffer Area) - The buffer area will be protected in the covenants and must be maintained by the Homeowner's Association. Adjoining lots, outside the subdivision, will have rights as third party beneficiaries, to require enforcement of the homeowners' responsibilities. Lighting (for Recreation Areas and Playing Fields) - Lighting shall be no brighter than ~ foot candle at property boundary lines and no higher than 20 feet. Add a Proffer: Berms: - An undulating, landscaped, earthen berm between three (3) feet and six (6) feet in height shall be developed along the rear of Lots 128 through 135, inclusive, and Lots 145 through 154, inclusive, to provide privacy and screening for the residents of such lots. No.7 - Pathways to be 4 feet wide. (deleted 3 feet) Pathways will be made of aSphalt, and will be on one side of the road. Add a proffer saying that the lots which abut NorthfieldS lots will have the same width dimensions as the Northfieids lotS. Page 2 February 13, 1998 No. 6 - Add wording that "additional plants shall be required to replace those which must be removed for the installation of the sanitary sewer." The Planning Commission also approved the following modifications/waivers: Modification of Section 4.2 to allow activity on critical slopes located on lots 58, 59, 60, 68, 69, 70, 79, 118, 119, 120 and 144, be granted for ZMA 97-01. Where slopes are to be constructed they shall be at a maximum slope of 3:1. Modification of Section 5.1.16 to allow the recreation area to be located as shown on the application plan, be approved for ZMA 97-01. Waiver of the stormwater detention requirements for those portions of the property which drain directly to the Rivanna River, be approved, subject to the approval of the Engineering Department. Please be advised that the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors will review this petition and receive public comment at their meeting on February 18, 1998. Any new or additional information regarding your application must be submitted to the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors at least seven days prior to your scheduled hearing date. If you should have any questions or comments regarding the above noted action. please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, William D. Fritz, AICP Senior Planner WDF/jcf CC: Ella Carey Amelia McCulley Jack Kelsey Joseph Richmond Crescent Development Group -: 0~¢~2798 11:03 804.~44.0957 -> 1-804-971-5841 HFNCA^ ?§ 002 AMENDED AND RESTATED PROFFER STATEMENT CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C. REZONING APPLICATION: ZMAo97-01 FEBRUARY 13, I998 Piannin9 Dept, Crescent Development Group, L.L.C. is the contract purchaser, Ollie L. Fitzgerald, Jr. and Florence L. Fkzgerald, Still Meadow Land Trust and Jane Williamson are the owners of that certain property located in Albemarle County (the "County") described in rezoning application ZMA-97~01 as Tax Map 46 Parcel 21 and portions of Tax Map 45B2 Parcels 2 and 4 (the "Property"). The contract purchaser and the owners, and their respective successors and assigns are hereina~er, collectively, referred to as the "Owners:'. Owners hereby voluntarily proffer that if the Property is rezoned by the Board of Supervisors of Albemarle County (the "Board"') to the planned residential development (the "PRD"), development of the Property shall be in accordance with the plan submitted herewith last revised September 18, 1997, entitled "Pre 'lanimry Plan Showing Lots 1 Thru 155 Still Meadow, Rio Magisterial District, Albemarle County, Virginii' prepared by B. Aubrey Huffinan & Associates (the ~'Plan"), and shall be subject to the following proffers pursuant to Section 15.2-2298 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended (the "Code"), and applicable provisions of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance (the "Ordinance"). All references to numbered lots are to those lots as numbered on the Plan. If Owners' rezoning application is denied, these proffers shall be immediately null and void and of no further force or effect. All of these proffers are offered voluntarily pursuant to the Ordinance and relevant sections of the Code. The proffers herein shall not be interpreted to authorize any person to apply lesser standards than those contahaed in any: (i) state statutory, regulatory or code minimum standards, or (ii) County ordinance or regulation, including the Ordinance, except as permitted bythe regulations of the PRE) Zoning District. These proffers shall supersede all other proffers made prior hereto. Protective Covenants. Prior to or concurrent with the recordation ora subdivision plat approved by the County and before the conveyance of any portion of the Property covered by said subdivision plat (other than for the dedication of easements, roads or utilities), Ow:~ers shall record a document (the ''Protective Covenants") in the Clerk's Office of the Ch cuit Court of Albemarle County, Virginia, setting forth controls on the development and requirements for maintenance of such portions of the Property and any Common Areas or facilities included therein and at a minimum as set forth herein. Clearing_ To the extent reasonably practicable, as determined by the Director of Planning and Community Development or his designee, at the time of development the clearing of mature trees on residential Iots shall be limited to trees in areas required to accommodate the structure and its normal and customary accessories, open yard areas and those limited areas required to permit utility services, storm drainage facilities and driveways. Any such trees which have been saved may not be cleared by any future o~mer of any lot Without the consent of the Architectural Control Committee of the Homeowners Association Page 1 of 7 02Y12/98 ~1:04 804.644.0957 -> 1-804-971-5841 HFWC&^ Pg 003 provided for in the Protective Covenants. To the extent reasonably practicable, as determi.'ned by the Director of Plarming and Community Development or his designee, at the time of development the clearing of mature trees (no less than six inches (6") in caliper measured two feet (2') above ground level) in common areas shall be limited to trees m areas required to accommodate pedestrian paths, playing fields, drainage facilities and other open areas, and those limited areas required to permit utility services and driveways. The primary responsibility for the implementation and compliance with this Proffered Condition shall rest with the Homeowners Association provided for in the Protective Covenants. Rivanna River Green Belt. Owners shall reserve a one hundred (100) foot wide area along the boundary of the Property and adjacent to the Rivanna River (the "Green Belt;!). No structural improvements (other than pedestrian and riding trails mad utilities) shall be constructed or erected within the Green Belt without the consent of the County. The Green Belt shall be preserved in its current condition except for general beautification measures including but not limited to, the cleating of underbrush, removal of dead trees and shmbs, and clean up along the river. Owners may grant, across the Green Belt, utility easements, and access easements ro the Rivarma River for the residents of the development and their guests, and may, at their option, build pedestrian and riding trails or similar recreational uses. At such time as the County decides to establish along the Rivanna River a public area or park within the Green Belt, and upon a request by the County, Owners shall convey the fee simple title to the Green Belt to the County without monetary consideration, provided the uses allowed for utilities, and pedestrian and riding trails or other uses identified in this Proffer 3 are reserved in the deed. The Green Belt may continue to be maintained by Owners of the Property; however, in the absence of such maintenance, Albemarle County at its option or any public agency or authority designated by the County may maintain the one hundred (100) foot wide Green Belt. Owners shall provide public access to the deeded Green Belt and two (2)visitor parking spaces as shown on the approved subdivision plat. The current condition will be documented with photographs or videotape. Water Quality Concept Plan In order to assure water quality in excess of normal water detention requi.,ements, Owners will implement the following three (3) tier Water Quality Concept Plan: Storm water detention facilities will utilize BMP Design Criteria to filter storm water, which shall include but not be limited to facilities designed to accommodate one half(I/2) inch of storage per acre of ultimate development impervious area m drainage area; sediment forehays; aquatic benches; and such features as may be approved by the Engineering Department. These facilities are shown generally on the plan as Area A, Area B and Area C. Water quality basins to filter the storm water that is not required to be detained shall be constructed with the same BMP DesXgn Criteria as stated in subparagraph a. above and as shown generally on the plan as Area D. Page 2 of 7 02/12/98 11:05 804.644.0957 -> 1-804-971-5841 HFWC6A Pg 004 In addition to the existing fir3' (50) foot buffer along the Rivanna River, Owners shall provide an additional fiity (50) feet of buffer, making such buffer one hundred (100) feet in the aggregate and will consist of riparian trees and shrubs pursuant to planting plan approved by the Engineering Department These facilities are shown generally on the plan as Area E. A r/parian buffer of approximately thirty (30) feet will be planted along the stream as shown generally on the plan as Area F. The buffer will comist of riparian trees and shrubs pursuant to planting plan approved by the Engineering Department. A man-made wetland area will be built to act as a regional water quality facility. The wetland area will filter storm water from this site as well as many up-s~mam properties, and is generally shown on the plan as Area G. Either a level spreader or a bio-retention area will be built to control water qnatlty for water not being detained. This facility is generally shown on the plan as Area H. This Water Quality Concept Plan has been designed to comply with the County's proposed Water Protection Ordinance, shall be implemented pursuant to a design subject to the approval of the Engineering Department, can only be modified with the approval of the Engineering Department and future rna~enance of the aforesaid facilities shall be subjec1 to inspection by the Engineering Department. Critical Slopes. The engineer preparing the subdivision plan shall desigmte the areas of critical slope on the subdivision plat prior to construction ora residence on the applicable lots. The engineer will designate onthe final plat as "Restricted Areas" the portions of lots 96 through t42 as are currently shown on the Plan, by limiting the use of the critical slope areas through the Protective Covenants. The Protective Covenants shall limit the removal of live trees within the Restricted Areas but shall allow for the construction of utility lines and laterals. Buffer Area. A natural and/or landscaped buffer area a minimum offffiy (50) feet in width shall be maintained across the rear lot lines of lots 1-15 inclumve as sho~m on the Plan, adjoining Nortkfields and Westmoreland Subdivisions, except for the sanitary sewer line included within such buffer and such other purposes as may be required or permitted by the County at the time of subdivision approval or by any other gnvemmental body. In connection with the sanitary sewer tine, if required, existing vegetation ma5; and fallen, deceased or dead plant growth shall, be removed from the buffer area..Additional plantings shall be added to replace any such removals if permitted by the appropriate departments of the County. The Protective Covenants referred to in Proffer 1 shall specifically provide that the owners of lots in Nortkfields and Westmoreland Subdivisions which adjoin lots t-15 inclusive as shown on the Plan shall specifically be deemed third party beneficiaries of this Proffer and shall have the right to enfome compliance with the provisions hereof. The primary responsibility for the implementation and compliance with Page 3 of 7 02/12/98 11:0Z 804.644.0957 -> 1-804-971-5841 HFWO&A Pg 005 10. I1. 12. 13. I4. 15. this Proffered Condition shaft rest with the Homeowners Association provided for in the Protective Covenants. .Lot Width. Lots 1-1 $ inclusive as shown on the Plan adjoining Norttffields and Westmoreland Subdivisions shall be at least equal in width to the rear lot lines of the lots they abut inNorthfields and Westmoreland Subdivisions as shown on the Plan. Pedestrian Paths. Owners agrees to construct with each phase ofdevelopment asphalt- paved pedestrian paths tour (4) feet in width on one side of roads & B, C (to road D), D (to road F), F, and G, and for two (2) pedestrian access easements to the Open Space. Said roads are shown on the Plan. Owners will construct the asphalt-paved pedestrian paths fi.om road A to Carrsbrook Drive and Northfields Road provided the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT') approves the paths to be constructed within the road rights-of-way. .Under~round Utility Lines~. Except for junction boxes, meters and existing overhead utility lines and wetlands, if any, all utility lines, to the extent reasonably practical, shall be underground. Chimneys. No chimneys or gas vent units shall be cantilevered. The exposed portions of all fireplace chimneys shall be brick or of a siding similar to the exterior treatment of the residence. This Proffer shall not apply to direct vent gas fireplaces or appliances The exposed bases of all chimneys shall be of the same material as the residence foundation. .Foundatiom_ The exposed exterior portions of exterior residence foundations shall be constructed of brick or natural stone; provided, however, the exposed portions of exterior residence foundations maybe constructed of drivit or stucco if applied to a masonry surface, provided that the exterior walls of such residence are primarily of drivit or stucco. Residence Parking. Each residence shall have a two- (2) car garage. Recreation Areas. The proposed Recreation Areas as shown on the Plan shall be ' completed no later than the completion of the second phase of development. Traffic Signal. Owners shall, upon written request therefor, contribute ten thousand two hundred dollars ($10,200.00) toward the cost of the traffic signal installed at the intersection of Rio Road and Old Brook Road. Paymem will be made at the time of final approval of the first phase subdivision plat. pavement Striping Owners shall improve the geometrics of lanes by adding additional pavement markings within the existing fight-of-way at the intersections of Old Brook Road and Carrsbrook Drive, Rio Road and Old Brook Road, Rio Road and Northfields Road and Rio Road and Huntington Road and will provide additional pavement markings on Old Brook Road to create two (2) out lanes and one (1) receiving lane, all as recommended in that letter fi.om VDOT to Mr. Bill Fritz, Department of Planning and Community Development dated May 5, 1997. Owners will complete these pavement Page 4 oF7 02/12£98 11:08 804.644.0957 -> 1-804-971-584! HFNC&^ Pg 006 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21 22. markings to the satisfaction of VDOT prior to final plat approval of the one-hundredth (100th) lot in the project. This Proffer shall not be construed to require Owners to provide additional right-of-way or paving on any of the roads where said striping will be provided. Phasing Plag_. No more than forty (40) residential cert'rficates of occupancy ("C.O.'s') shall be requested in any twelve (12) consecutive months period following the final approval of the preliminary subdivision plat. Such calculation shall be made on a cumulative basis so that any lesser number of C.O.'s in any such period may be carried over and added to the number of C.O.'s permitted in any subsequent period or periods. _Cash Payment. Owners shall make a cash payment to the County for fac'dity improvements and impacts related to the residential development requested herein within the service district for the Property as designated by the Capital Improvement Program The amount of such payment shall be one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00) inthe aggregate. The prorata portion of such payment shall be due at the time of final plat approval on a section-by-section basis for the number of residential lots included in such plat. If at any time it is determined by the County that any of such cash proffer funds are not required for such purposes or if any of such cash proffer funds are not expended for the purposes designated by the Capital Improvement Program wqthin ten (10) years from the date of payment, such excess shall be distributed to the Albemarle County School Board for such educational purposes within the Rio Magisterial District as the School Board deems appropriate. Playing Field. In order to reduce the impact of the development on the Parks and Recreation Department, the approximately fifty-five (55) acres of open area shall be developed at a minimum for an all-purpose playing field no less than a regulation-size soccer field for the use of residents of Still Meadows and their guests as shown on the Plan no later than the completion of the second phase of development and shall be maintained by the Homeowners Association provided for in the Protective Covenants. Number ofLots. Notwithstanding the number of lots shown on the Plan, no more than one hundred thirty-free (135) lots shall be developed on the Property. Berms. An undulating, landscaped, earthen berm between three (3) feet and six (6) feet in height shall be developed along the rear of Lots 128 through 135, inclusive, and Lots 145 through 154, inclusive, to provide privacy and screening for the residents of such lots. Exterior Lighting at Recreation Areas. Any exterior lighting fixtures at the Recreation Areas shall not exceed twenty (20) feet in height as measured from the grade at the base of the lighting standard, shall be produced from concealed sources of light (i.e., shoe box type), and shall not exceed one-half(I/2) foot candle at the boundaries of the Property. Severance. The unenforceability, elimination, revision or amendment of any Proffer set forth hereir~ in whole or in part, shall not affect the validity or enforceability of the other proffers or the unaffected part of any such proffer. Page 5 of 7 0~/~2~g8 ~:09 804.644.0957 -> ~-804-g7~-5841 HFWC&~ Pg 007 23. Si_~atotT. These Proffers shall run with the Property and each reference to Owners within these Proffers shall mean the then current owner of the Property or portion thereof and shall be binding upon, Owners' successor(s) in interest and/or the developer of the Property or any portion of'the Property. Witness the following signature and seal: CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C, Scott A. Williams, Manager OLLIE L. FITZGERAI.B, JR. and FLORENCE L. FITZGERALD Scott A~ Williams, Their Attorney-in-Fact STILL MEADOW LAND TRUST Scott A Willia~ni Its Attorney-in-Fact JANE WILLIAM_SON ~cott A. Williams, Her Attorney-in-Fact Page 6 of 7 0271~/~8 11:10 804.644.0~§Z ~> 1-804-971-584] HFWC&A Pg 008 COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, to-wit: g (/t'~1998, by Scott A. Williams in his capacity as Mamger o'f~'rresce;nt Developmem Gi'oup, L.L.C. ~d as Attomey-imFact for Ollie L. Fitzgerald, Jr., Florence L. Fitzgerald and Still Meadow Land Trust and Jane Will/amson. My commission expires: J £/,4C~ z2~/[ ~ [ #50642 - 20507.01068 Page 7 of 7 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Department of Planning & Community Dev¢lopmcm MEMORANDUM TO: Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Albemarle County Planning Commission FROM: William D. Fritz, AICP DATE: Febmaryl2, 1998 ZMA 97-01 Still Meadows The Planning Commission originally reviewed this application on June 3, 1997 at which time it recommended denial &the application. Staffhas attached the minutes of that meeting to this memorandum. On February 10, 1998 the Planning Commission reviewed this application and recommended approval. Staff has revised the original staff report to reflect the changes in the application. The major areas of revision to the request are: 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Reduction of the number of lots from 155 to 135: Provision of proffers designed to offset the fiscal impact of the development; Provision of a buffer adjacent to existing development; Provision of proffers for water quality measures; Increased proffers for protection of critical slopes and existing wooded areas; Provision of parking spaces for use by the general public making use of the access to the Rivanna G-reenway; Provision of road improvements; Provision of a phasing plan; Provision of recreation fields in the open space. Other proffers have also been provided. The above notes only the most significant revisions to the proposal. The current proffers are attached to this memorandum. Staffhas reviewed and provided comment on the design standards and pr'mciples of development contained in the Comprehensive Plan. The contem of the Comprehensive Plan and the comments of staffare attached to this memorandum. This information is provided in support of the staff conclusion that the development on the whole is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan. In the prior review staffhad calculated that "by-right" development of the property could result in 106 lots. This"by-right"development potentialincluded a 10%bonus for the use ofintemal roads. "By-right" development potential without adjustment for bonuses was calculated to be 97 lots. Potential by-right bonuses, if qualified for, affect the number of lots as follows: 1) A 10% bonus for use of internal roads. 97 times 10% = 9 lots. 97 + 9 = 106 2) A5%bonusforprowsionofsU:eettrees. 97times5%=41ots. 106+4=110 3) A10% bonus for preservation ofexisting trees. 97times10%=91ots. 110+9=119 To achieve this bonus, 20% of the site must remain wooded. 20% of 149 acres is 29.8 acres. Review of the most recent plan submitted by the applicant indicates that approximately 54.47 acres will remain wooded. [This does not include area proposed to be dedicated for the Greenway.] Potential bonuses which may be granted at the discretion of the Planning Commission/Board of Supervisors, affect the number of lots as follows: 1) A maximum 15% bonus for dedication of 7.5 acres for the greenway. 7.5 acres times twice the density is 7.5 acres times 43,560 (number of square feet in an acre) =326,700 square feet divided by 45,000 square fret (min lot size) = 7 lots times 2 = 14. 119 + 14 = 133 2) A maximum 20% bonus for offsite road improvements. 97 times 20% = 19 lots. 133 - 19-- 152 The maximum potential cumulative increase in density by use of the bonus provision is 50%. 97 times 50% = 48 additional lots. 97+ 48 equals 145 lots. Therefore, the full 152 lots noted above could not be achieved. In order for all of the potential bonuses to be achieved the Planulng Commission would have to make certain findings which supported the bonus and would have to determine the appropriate bonus level for those items which are discretionary. The Board of Supervisors would have to agree m accept land for dedication and determine the appropriate bonus factor. It should be noted that the "by-right" development potential assumes that little if any undevelopable land is included in any proposed lot. Undevelopable land can be included in a lot provided that an adequate building site is also provided. The inclusion of tmdevelopable land in lots could increase the number of potential "by-right" lots. WDF/ C:\WPDOCS\STILL\STILL2.MEM THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REVISED TO REFLECT THE REDUCTION OF TIlE NUMBER OF LOTS FROM 150 LOTS TO 135 LOTS. PRINCIPLES FOR LAND USE IN DESIGNATED GROWTH AREAS STILL MEADOW REZONING ZMA 97-01 The following is an outline of the County's Comprehensive Plan principles for land use decisions as applied to the application for the Still Meadows property in ZMA 97-01 General Principles for Land Use in Designated Development Areas: For the County's growth management goals to be achieved, the Development Areas must be attractive places to live and work The land within the Development Areas must also be used efficiently if designation of these Areas is to realistically help prevent sprawl development. To this end, the Land Use Plan for the Development Areas is designed to concentrate development in the Development Areas, particularly in the locations designated "Urban Areas" or "Communities. "Planning for future development in the Development Areas is at densities higher than in the past, with more varied uses. Furthermore, revised plans for the Development Areas emphasize the County's desire for design strategies that are more characteristic of smcdl, well-planned city neighborhoods or towns than of typical low density suburban areas. Inevitably, some people will experience more significant change than others and will find that nearby land uses may not be the same character as their residential area. However, through careful design of the land use plan and its development standards and recommendations, this situation may not be necessarily bad. and in fact can be beneficial for the community. Listed below are the principles that guide development of Development Areas. The Development Areas Land Use Plan, as well as subsequent decisions regarding land use in these areas should be reflective of, and consistent with, these principles: 1. Accommodate new growth in the County within Development Areas. Comment: This site is situated within Neighborhood 2 as designated in the Comprehensive Plan and this rezoning is consistent with this general principal. 2. Encourage greater utilization of land in designated Development Areas by achieving higher gross densitie's for residential and non,residential development than in the past. Comment: This rezoning would increase residential densiW, on this site from 0.74 dwelling units per acres to 0.90 dwelling units per acre. Density of the developable portion of the site is increased from 1.37 dwelling units per acre to 1.71 dwelling units per acre. To an extent, this rezoning is consistent with this principle. Encourage mfill development of vacant lands and development of under- used areas within the designated Development Areas. Comment: This site is currently in pasture and woodland use. Agriculture is not a permitted use in development areas zoning districts. This rezoning is consistent with this principle. Development Areas shall not encroach into water supply watersheds. except for the Crozet Community, which shall not be expanded beyond the watershed boundary of the Lickinghole Creek detention basin. Comment: This site is not located within a water supply watershed and therefore is consistent with this principle. Avoid development of"Significant Areas" as designated in the Open Space Plan. Comment: This property has floodplain, stream valley and critical slopes which are identified as "Significant Areas" in the Open Space Plan. The layout of the development includes aH of the floodplain land and significant portions of the critical slopes in the Open Space of the deVelopment. Further, the applicant has proffered protection for all critical slopes contained in lots adjacent to the floodplain and in the Open Space of the development. It is the opinion of staff that the proposed development is consistent with this principle, although the best proposal would be one in which all signficant areas of critical slopes are in common area and not part of lots. Discourage extensive linear style development along mai'or roads. Comment: All lots in the subdivision will be served by internal public roads. The new roads internal to the development will access the existing road network. It is the opinion of staff that the proposed development is consistent with this principle. All Development Areas shall be served by public sewer and water. Comment: All lots within the development will be served by public sewer and water. Therefore, this development is consistent with this principle. Plan for a system of transportation and community facilities and services that support and enhance the Development Areas. Comment: The existing transportation network in the area of this development is operating below design capacity. ~he applicant is proffering i.~provements recommended by the Department of Transportation. It is anticipated that w~th the surplus capacity in the transportation network and the improvements proposed by the applicant that the transportation network will remain at an acceptable level of servi~c~. The community facility most impacted by the development will likely be the school system. This development will affect the Woodbrook Elementary, Sutherland Middle and Albemarle 2 High Schools. Staff has provided the capacity, enrollment and anticipated impact caused by the proposed development for each school. School Capacity Current Additional Current Enrollment Students due to Enrollment as of Sept. 1997 Still Meadow plus Still (Based on 135 Meadow lots) Woodbrook 440 312 31 343 Elementary Sutherland 769 571 15 586 Middle Albemarle 1,685 1998 18 1,569 High Enrollment 1,551 Review of the Community Facilities Plan does not indicate that facilities which serve the area of the proposed develop.ment are operating above capacity or require improvements. Therefore, this development is consistent with this prmciple. Land Use Standards for Designated Development Areas Land Use standards provide guidelines for development which are consistent with the Growth Management goals and are in keeping with the man-made and natural environment. These standards provide the basic framework for the review of development proposals for the Development Areas, in conj'unction with other applicable ordinances and regulations. General Land Use Standards Standards that apply to all types of development in the Development Areas are provided as "General Land Use Standards. "More specific standards for commercial, industrial, and residential land uses are provided to address the different locational and surrounding character aspects of those categortes. General Land Use Standards_for Designated Development Areas Development should be concentrated and clustered to the maximum extent possible to protect environmental features (floodplain, critical slopes, 'etc.), sceni~ vistas, and historic sites, to provide for open space (for either passive or active recreation), and to minimize traffic 'hazards, conflicts with other land uses, and adverse visual aspects associated with linear/strip development The Open Space Plan should be used to identify areas that need to be preserved. Comment: As stated previously .~his development '.melu.des floodplain, and crifica! slopes as open space. Frequently floodplain lands hold prehistoric archeolog~eal sites. While no specific archeological sites have been identified on this site, the inclusion of the floodplain in open space will serve to protect any sites which may exist. This inclusion of features in the project's open space is consistent with the Open Space Plan. The development is clustered on the portion of the property which is developable. Staff does note that the density proposed by the applicant in the developable area, 1.71 dwelling units per acre, appears to be below that which the land could accommodate. Further, by changing unit type from single family detached, further clustering could be accomplished. Approximately 65 acres is in the op.en space: This area will provide for .b. oth pas. sive and active recreation. An active recreation facihty is also proposed which will provide pool and tennis facilities. This active recreation facility is not located in the open space which incorporates floodplain and critical slopes. The layout of the development is such that it will have limited visibility from existing public roads, the proposed Green. way or the Ri.yunna Ri.v. er. Visibility of the developme.nt will be !argely Ii.re. ired to those existing houses directly adjacent to the prope~rty: No scenic v~stas identified in the Open Space Plan are affected by this developnient. Th~s development is consistent with this design standard. 2. Maintain existing forested areas acting as buffers between subdivisions. Comment: The applicant has proffered the preservation of a wooded buffer between this development and the existing houses in Northfields. This development is consistent with this design standard. Minimize the impact of developments on major roads to the greatest extent feasible by limiting access points to major roads, providing side street access, service roads anddorjoint accesses. Comment: Access to the development is limited to two points. No alternative access points are available. Review of traffic studies indicates that the intersections and roads serving the development are currently at an acceptable level of service and that the level of service will remain acceptable after this site is development. This development is consistent with this design standard. Connections between developments with an appropriately scaled transportation network should be provided to ~naximize a sense of community and provide additional transportation links. Connection of multiple developments may provide for additional recreation facilities, increased open space area, bicycle/pedestrian links, improved public transit, emergency access, and access to schools, parks and other public facilities. The emphasis is on linkage between developments and just not within each development. Comment: The applicant has proffered the inclusion of sidewalks within the development and has allowed for connection of these sidewalks to the existing road network in the area. This helps to create a sense of community. The applicant has proffered access, including two parking spaces, to the Greenway across this development. This will allow individuals living in the immediate area of the development more immediate 4 access to the Greenway. Linkage of this development with other developments is limited due to its location at the end of the developable area of neighborhood two. To the extent geographically possible, this development is consistent with this design standard. Provide for ultimate future transportation improvements and new road locations through the reservation of adequate right-of-way and by designing and constructing utilities in a manner consistent with planned transportation tmprovements. Transportation improvements shouM include all modes of travel (auto, bus, bicycle, pedestriang. Comment: The road network serving this development is currently adequate and no gener? im.p. rovements are warranted. Spot improvements to serve this development have been identified and the applicant has proffered to make those improvements.. As s..ta, ted pr. eviously, the applicant has proffered sidewalks within the development which wffi link w~th the existing road network anti any. future sidewalks constructed in the area. This development is consistent with th~s design standard. Require underground utilities in new residential and non-residential developments, including new lines and major improvements to existing lines. Comment: All utilities will be located underground as required by the subdivision ordinance. Therefore, this development is consistent with this design standard. New development or major redevelopment design plans shouM include features to prevent impact from impervious surfaces on water quality. Parking areas, roads, and other impervious areas should meet only the reasonable needs of the proposed use and possible future uses. Avoid parking areas which exceed that which is necessary for the anticipated development. For large retail developments, parking capacity needed only on a few peak shopping days of the year is amenable to design alternatives to fiat blacktop. Creatively designed alternative parking areas could serve as buffer zones to adjacent land uses or road frontage. Comment: The applicant has, with the assistance of the Water Resource Manager, developed proffers which address water quality. No significant parking areas are proposed. This development is consistent with this design standard. To the extent reasonable and feasible given site constraints, site development shouM encourdge building orientation to public streets. Parking areas do not need to be located exclusively in front of buildings. Comment: This development has a standard residential orientation to the internal roads. Parking areas have not been identified other than those associated with the recreation area. However, it is reasonable to assume that the layout of parking will be similar to that of existing residential areas. This development could, with alternative design, locate parking on the side or behind the houses. Staffviews this design standard as more applicable to commercial and industrial developments. This development is somewhat consistent with this design standard. Encourage the use of external lighting, when site illumination is proposed which is efficient, provides necessar~ security, and is down-directed and shielded to minimize light trespass. 5 Comment.'. This.design standard is intended primaril.y for non-residential developmen, t. No limitations on fights have been proposed by ~he apphcant. Staff is not able to determine that this development is consistent with this design standard. 10. Adaptive re-use of historic buildings to uses which preserve the building's architecture and site character should be encouraged as a method of historic preservation. Comment: This design standard is not applicable to this development. 11. Ensure evaluation of future land use changes under the fiscal impact model prior ro rezoning approvals. ~4ppropriate planning/phasing of development to match service/infrastructure availability and capacity should be established Comment: The position of Fiscal Impact Planner remains vacant and, therefore, no "official" model is currently being utilized for rezonings. Staffhas prepared a fiscal impact analysis which is included in the body of the staff report. The fiscal impact caused by the rezoning of this site is minimal as few CIP projects are affected by the development. The applicant, has pro. fie, red a cash payment.which is. intended to offset fiscal impacts caused by the rezonmg. Thts development ts consistent w~th this design standard. Specific Standards for Residential, Commercial, and Industrial Land Uses Residential Land Use Standards In addition to the general standards noted above, residential standards are presented here as a basic framework to guide futurb residential development proposals. It should be recognized that substantial changes in the economy, housing market, and housing industry may warrant flexibility in the application of these standards These standards are intended to encourage the provision of various housing types and provide for affordable housing. It is intended that all dwelling types and forms of ownership be permitted within the County. Residential Densities and Relationships to Other Land Uses It is intended that where possible, and practical due to terrain, availability of public utilities and adequate public infrastructure, that overall development density be at as high a level as practical. The use of bonus ~rovisions to increase density and provide for affordable housing should e encouraged W-here demonstrated, by economic or other considerations, that density in excess of that recommended by the Plan is warranted to accommodate an affordable housing proposal, a reasonable density increase should be provided Comment: The Comprehensive Plan designation for this area is Neighborhood Residential. The recommended density is 3 to 6 dwelling units per acre. The proposed zoning results in a gross den. siW. of 0.90 dwelling u. nits per acre. The net dens.itT on .the developable portion of the s~te ts 1.71 dwelling umts per acre. Staff can identify no issues of terrain, availability of public utilities or adequate public infrastructure which would tend to indicate that a signfficantly higher density could not be achieved. In addition, no 6 proposal is made to provide for affordable housing. This development does not comply with this standard. In rezoning deliberations, the County should be mindful of the intent to encourage infill development, contain most future growth within designated Development ~treas, and avoid rural development pressure. Unless contrary to matters of pubHc health and safety, residehtial rezoning to the upper end of the Comprehensive Plan recommended land use density-ranges (i.e., Neighborhood or Urban scale) should be favored even if the density exceeds that of surrounding developments. Comment: This development represents the only sizeable area of undeveloped residential land remaining in Neighborhood 2. Therefore, this development is considered to be infill development. During pri.or review of this application concern was raised that the increased traffic generated by th~s development represents a safety concern. Staff opinion is that the roads which serve the proposed development are substantially below their design capacity and that they will remain acceptable after full build out of the Still Meadows project. Any infill development will result in an increase in traffic on existing roads. As pubic investment has been made in the road network of t~.e area it is a.ppropriate to make use of the resources of the County provided that the impact rs such that ~t does not cause the level of service to drop below an acceptable level. It is the opinion of staffthat this development is consistent with the public health and safety aspect of this standard. As stated previously the infrastructure to support the proposed development is currently in place. The Comprehensive Plan recommends rezoning to the upper end of the density- ranges even if the. density exceeds that of surrounding developments. Sufficient capacity in infrastructure exasts to support a more dense develop, merit than proposed by the applicant. Therefore, this development is not consistent with th~s standard. Maintenance qf the integrity of residential areas can be accomplished with standards for the relationship of residential use to adjacent non- residential uses. Buffering, screening and physical separation of non- residential uses can alleviate such relational problems. The current provisions of the Zoning Ordinance addressing the screening of objectionable features and dissimilar uses provide for appropriate protection. These features shouM be retained In addition to these regulatory requirements, care should be taken in residential design to provide for buffering, orientation, and other measures to avoid conflicts with surrounding uJes. Identification of appropriate land use relationships is tmportant in applying land use designations as welt as tn considering development proposal~. Comment: This standard addresses residential development adjacent to non-residential development which is not the situation in this review. However, as previously stated, the applicant has pr.offered the maintenance of a buffer adjacent.to existing residential development which exceeds that which ~s required by the zonmg ordinance for non- residential development adjacent to residential development. Therefore, this development is consistent with this standard. Residential Development Design Residential development shouM be designed with an internal orientation to foster a sense of place and avoid the image of continuous suburban 7 sprawl. To encourage such design, conventional and duster options as well as density bonuses are provided in all residential zoning districts. Comment: This development is oriented internally. It does represent development of a similar pattern to recent developments in the County. However, it is unlike the developments adjoining Still Meadows. Most of the adjoining developments do not have sidewalks, recreational areas, open space or an internal orientation. The Still Meadows development incorporates features which will provide for a liveable community. Staff opinion is that this development is consistent with this standard. Make available a variety of development approaches to the developer that encourage innovative design and reduce housing costs, including zero lot line subdivisions, and sustainable design incentives. Comment: Staff did discuss the concept of zero lot lines within this development. However, thc applicant has not requested the use of zero lot lines. The applicant is making use of Planned Development zoning, PRD. This does allow the use of cluster provisions. This development is somewhat consistent with this standard. Lot design and residential layout shouM be based on a rational use of land that reflects topographic and other physical features rather than imposing a layout intended solely to satisfy minimum ordinance requirements. Comment: The layout of lots makes use of the portions of the property which have reasonable topography for development. Minimal earthwork will be required for the establishment of the road network. Staffdoes note that not all areas of critical slopes are included in the open space. Some critical slope areas are incorporated within lots. These lots will have restrictions on disturbance of the slopes, This development generally complies with this standard. For larger developments, layout and design should provide for varying building orientation and setback dwelling unit type, facade treatment, and lot size to avoid repetitiveness. Open space should be employed as a design feature to establish and define smaller neighborhood areas within the larger development. The PRD/PUD approach is particularly applicable far larger developments. Comment: The proposed development has little, if any, significant, variation in lot design, shape or configuration. Houses within the development are all single family detached and will likely be of similar construction and style as is the norm in most developments. Use of increased density within the development would allow for variation of lot size and unit type. This development is not consistent with this standard. 5. Maintain requirements for recreational facilities for developments where the density and lot size do not allow for meanin~Cul recreational space. Comment: This development provides for active recreation and significant areas for passive recreation. This development is consistent with this standard. Land Use Designations Residential Land Use OBJECTIVE: Establish flexible residential land use densities for the designated Development Areas. The success of Development Area development will depend greatly on the provision of residential land use areas that are developable, locationally desirable, and responsive to changing market demands. Two density categories are provided in the Development Area, each with a range of acceptable density. Flexibility in residential density ranges leaves some discretion to the market in proposing development characteristics (such as housing type and arrangements), but relies heavily on County standards to evaluate the suitability and acceptability of the proposal. Strategy: Establish maximum gross development density of each residential category, but determine density of development up to maximum based on speciftc standards. Two ranges of residential development densities applicable in the Development Areas stipulated below are as follows: NOTE: THIS DEVELOPMENT IS WITHIN AN AREA RECOMMENDED BY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR NEIGHBORHOOD DENSITY AND THEREFORE, ONLY STANDARDS RELATIVE TO NEIGHBORHOOD DENSITY ARE ADDRESSED Recommendations Neighborhood Density Residential Neighborhood Density Residential areas are intended to have a gross density of between 3 to 6 dwellings per acre. Comment: At a density of 1.71 dwelling units per acre, this rezoning petition is not consistent with this residential density objective. Neighborhood Density Residential may be located within the Urban Area, Communities and Villages. Comment: This property is located with the Urban Area as designated in the Comprehensive Plan. · Neighborhood Density Residential areas are intended to accommodate all dwelling unit types. Comment: The proposed development is intended for single family detached units only. 9 Any new development within an existing subdivision shall be in keeping with the character and density of the existing development. New developments adjacent to existing subdivisions shall be developed at higher densities to support infill development efforts. Comment: The proposed development is located adjacent to existing subdivisions. Staff opinion is that the boundaries of this site, abutting existing subdivisions could preserve the character and density of development while the interior of the development could be developed at a higher density. As proposed the Still Meadows project is at a density comparable to the existing developments surrounding the site. Staffopinion is that this rezoning request is not consistent with this design recommendation of fl~e Comprehensive Plan. Recommendations.for Neighborhood 2 include, in part: Utility improvements include: Upg~.ade water distribution in the entire Neighborhood to ensure adequate service. Comment~ No deficiency in water service has been identified in the area of this development. Retain open space areas in the Meadow Creek floodplain, the area along the proposed Meadow Creek Parkway corridor, the lake and stream system north of Rio Road in the Woodbrook, Carrsbrook and Northfields areas, and along the Rivanna River floodplain. Comment: space. This development incorporates the floodplain of the Rivanna River in open Construct a greenway along the South Fork of the Rivanna River and Rivanna River. This provides a pedestrian connection of the Ivy Creek Natural Area to the Urban Area and an opportunity for passive recreation adjacent to the Urban Area. Develop the greenway to meet the recreational and conservation needs of the residents in Neighborhood Two, and the entire County. Comment: This development proffers the dedication of area for the Greenway and provides for public access, including parking, to the Greenway. C:\WPDOCS\STILL\STILL2.PLN 10 THIS REPORT HAS BEEN MODIFIED SINCE THE FEBRUARY 10, 1998 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING TO REFLECT THE REDUCTION IN THE PROPOSED NUMBER OF LOTS FROM 150 TO 135. STAFF PERSON: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS: William D. Fritz, AICP February 18, 1998 ZMA 9%01 Still Meadow Land Trust Applicant's Proposal: The applicant is proposing to rezone approximately 142 acres to allow for the development of 135 single family lots. The development will include public roads, a recreation area and approximately 65 acres of open space, much of it in the floodplain. Provision for the construction of the Rivanna Greenway has been made. Petition: Proposal to rezone approximately 142 acres from R-l, residential to PRD, Planned Developmem Residential with a maximum of 135 lots. Property, described as Tax Map 46, Parcel 21 and Tax Map 45B2, Parcel 2 (part) and 4 (part) is located at the end of Northfields Road. Access is proposed to both Northfields Road and Carrsbrook Drive. This site is located in the Rio Magisterial District and is recommended for Neighborhood Density (3 to 6 dwelling units per acre) in Neighborhood 2 of the Comprehensive Plan. (Staff notes that the original application for this project was 160 units. This was reflected in the legal ad for this proposal. The applicant however, has reduced the development proposal to 135 units.) Character of the Area: The site proposed for rezoning is a mixture of woods and pasture. The floodplain area is exclusivel3 pastur~ Steep slopes are present at the boundary of the floodpla'm and at scattered points on the property. The site has access from two existing roads, Carrsbrook Drive and Northfields Rd. Existing single family residential development abuts the proposed development. RECOMMENDATION: Staff has reviewed this request for compliance with the provisions of the Comprehensive Plan and the Zoning Ordinance and recommends approval. Planning and Zoning History_: June 3, 1997 - Planning Commission recommended denial or Pill) zoning to permit 155 lots. August 13, 1997 - Board of Supervisors refers application back to the Planning Commission to allow for consideration of additional information. The applicant offered to allow the Development Area Initiatives Steering Committee, DISC, the opportunity m consider this site in a design charrette. DISC decided not to use this site. The application was then scheduled for Planning Commission and Board review. Comprehensive Plan: This area is recommended for Neighborhood Density in the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Plan, a designation which calls for a density of 3 to 6 dwelling units per acre. The density of the proposed development is 0.90 dwelling units per acre. The density of the developablepordon of the site is 1.71 dwelling units per acre. The lot sizes range from 12,530 to 34,850 square feet. The density of the proposed development is below that recommended by the Comprehensive Plan Land Use'Plan for this area. Staff d0es note that substantially increasing the density above that currently proposed may be inconsistent with the prextailing building pattern of the area. (Westmoreland - 2.7 dwelling units per acre or an average lot size of 16,000 square feet; Northfields - 1.4 dwelling units per acre or an average lot size of 31,500 square feet; Raintree 2.2 dwelling units per acre with an average lot size of approximately 11,000 square feet with additional Open Space provided; Carrsbrook 1 to 1.6 dwelling.units per acre or an average lot size of 27,000 to 43,700 square feet with the lots adjacent to the lake abutting the proposed development at 0.69 dwelling units per acre or an average lot size of 63,000 square feet, All densities are approximate.) The Comprehensive Plan contains "Principles Governing Land Use in Designated Development Areas", (Attachment C). The plan states in part "For the County's growth management goals to be achieved, the . Development Areas must be attractive places to live and work. The land within the Development Areas must also be used efficiently if designation of these Areas is to realistically help prevent sprawl development. To this end, the Land Use Plan for the Development Areas is designed to concentrate development in the Development Areas, particularly in the locations designated 'Urban Areas' or 'Communities.' Planning for future development in the Development Areas is at densities higher than in the past, with more varied uses. Furthermore, revised plans for the Development Areas emphasize the County's desire for design strategies that are more characteristic of small, well-planned city neighborhoods or towns than of typical low density suburban areas. Inevitably, some people will experience more significant change than others and will fred that nearby land uses may not be the same character as their residential area. However, through careful design of the land use plan and its development standards and recommendations, this situation may not be necessarily bad, and in fact can be beneficial for the community." [page 17] To this end, the County has established the DISC to undertake a planning process to establish an overall vision for the character/design of designated Development Areas. This process, currently underway with consultant assistance, will provide a clearer picture of how the County can achieve quality infill development which is acceptable to the larger community. The proposed development has addressed many of the design guidelines for the Development Areas. Staff has more completely discussed the relationship of this development to the design guidelines in the attached memo. The area of development has been clustered to protect those items idemified as resources in the Open Space Plan, critical slopes and floodplain most notably. Impact on the transportation network is not anticipated to be excessive. (Staffwill provide full analysis of the transportation impact of this development in later portions of this report.) Connection to existing neighborhoods will be provided by sidewalks and access to the proposed Greenway has been provided for. The development is internally 2 oriented with recreation located in the center of the developmen~ The Comprehensive Plan states in part as a Residential Land Use Standard "Unless contrasy to matters of public health and safety, residential rezoning to the upper end of the Comprehensive Plan recommended land use density-ranges (i.e., Neighborhood or Urban scale) should be favored even if the density exceeds that of surrounding developments." Staff opinion is that the design of the project is generally consistant with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Plan. The density, however, is below that recommended by the plon. It is the opinion of staff that increased density could be achieved in this project with the use of zero lot lines, attached or multi-family units. The character of the property is such that attached or multi- family units could be provided internal to the development with single family detached units located on the perimeter of the development adjacent to the existing developments, without changing the character of the area. Due to the density of the proposed development at less than the minimum recommended by the Land Use Plan, it is the opinion of staff that this request is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan density recommendations. The Comprehensive Plan also contains as a recommendation for Neighborhood Density Residential areas, "Any new development within an existing subdivision shall be in keeping with the character and density of the existing development. New developments adjacent to existing subdivisions shall be developed at higher densities to support infill development efforts". [page 26] The proposed development does maintain the character of the existing area~ Staff is sensitive to the possible change in the character of the area which could be generated by increasing the density of the proposed development, particularly if attached or multi-family units were added. This application moves towards the density recommended by the Comprehensive Plan and is more in keeping with these recommendations than the existing zoning: However, this is less the case than was reviewed previously by the Planning Commission. Staffhas previously noted that the DISC is working on the issue of the character/design of development in Development Areas. While it would be helpful if the County~had the benefit of the committee findings in the review of this application, staffnotes that the existing recommendations of the Comprehensive Plan do not call for a delay in the review of development proposals to allow the committeeto complete its work. Based on the fact that this development is consistent with the design guidelines for residential development and that this proposal achieves increased density without changing the character of the area, staffopmxon is that this request on balance complies with the recommendations o~fthe Comprehensive Plan. STAFF COMMENT: All applications for Planned Deveiopmems are reviewed for compliance with the provisions of Section 8 which addresses Planned Developments Generally and Section 8.5.4 which provides for specific review criteria. 8.5.4 PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS "At such time as further conferences appear unnecessary, or at any time on request of the applicant, the commission shall proceed to prepare its recommendations to the board of supervisors. The date of the commission's determination to proceed, or of the applicanfs request for preparation of recommendations, shall be deemed the formal date of submission of the application. Specifically, recommendations of the commission shall include findings as to: a. The suitability of the tract for the general type of PD district proposed in terms off 3 relation to the comprehensive plan; physical characteristics of the land; and its relation to surrounding area; b. Relation to major roads, utilities, public facilities and services; Adequacy of evidence on unified control and suitability of any proposed agreements, contracts, deed restrictions, sureties, dedications, contributions, guarantees, or other instruments, or the need for such instruments or for amendments in those proposed; and Specific modifications in PD or general regulations as applied to the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are necessary or justified by demonstration that the public purPoses of PD or general regulations as applied would be satisfied to at least an equivalent degree by such modifications. Based on such findings, the commission shall recommend approval of the PD amendment as proposed, approval conditioned upon stipulated modifications, or disapproval." Staff witl address each provision of section 8.5.4. The suitability of the tract for the general~pe of PD district proposed in terms of: relation to the comprehensive plan: ohvsieal characteristics of the land: and its relation to surroundin~ area, This development does provide for a buffer between the proposed lots and existing lots in adjoining subdivisions. This issue has been raised by abutting property owners. Staff opinion is that the Comprehensive PIan and Zoning Ordinance comments regarding buffering apply to the buffering of different unit types, such as multi-family adjacent to single family detached units, or to commemial uses adjacent to residential uses. Although, it is the opinion of staff that no buffering is required for this proposal to be compatible with adjoining uses and the provisions of the zoning ordinance, the applicant has proffered a buffer which in staff opinion is not contrary to the Comprehensive Plan. Matters regarding the Comprehensive Plan have been addressed. As stated previously, this site is recommended for Neighborhood Density residential use in the Comprehensive Plan. The land proposed for development is such that a significant portion of the site is not suitable for development due to critical slopes or floodplain. By-right lots could include both critical slopes and floodplain area. While these areas are not developable they would not have the same protection as is proposed with ~is development. The floodplain and the critical sIopes associated with the Rivanna River system are identified in the Open Space Plan. The areas identified in the Open Space Plan as a resource have been included in the open space of the proposed development. The lots have been clustered onto the buildable area. The plan has been reviewed by the Site Review Committee and limited obstacles to development of the site have been identified. Scattered areas of critical slopes do exist within the development. These critical slope areas are not associated with the Rivanna River and cover a relatively small area. A modification to allow activity on these isolated areas of critical slopes has been applied for. Staffwill address the modification request in latter portions ofthis report. Th6 areas surrounding the proposed development aremature subdivisions. Lo~ sizes in these adjacent subdivisions are similar to and in some cases larger, than proposed in the Still Meadow development. The Westmoreland development is similar in density and lot size to that proposed in the Still Meadow development. Staff opinion is that the proposed development is compatible to the surrounding area. Relation to ma_ior roads, utilities, public facilities and services. Staff has received and reviewed a traffic study for the proposed development. The comments of the Department of. Transportation are included as Attachment D. Additional information regarding observed travel speeds is included as Attachment E, this information was obtained from the "smart sign" used by the County. Staff has included as Attachment F one page from the traffic study "2001 Traffic Intersection Capacity Analysis Results" which provides a quick summary of the anticipated impacts of this developmem on various intersections. The proposed development will not result in a reduction in the level of service for any of the intersections internal m existing developments. The intersections of existing streets with Rio Road will be the ones most significantly impacted by the proposed development. Two of these intersections with Rio Road, Huntington and Old Brook, currently have failing levels of service for certain turning movements. The Old Brook intersection with Rio Rd. Was signalized in the summer of 1997. The Department of the Transportation has recommended that improvements, in the form of pavement stripping, occur at the Northfields, Old Brook and Huntington intersections with Rio Road. The applicant has proffered these improvements. The applicant has also proffered to provide stripping atthe Westmoreland/Old Brook intersection with Carrsbrook. The establishment of turn lanes on Carrsbrook into the development can be required at the time of subdivision plat approval and no proffer is needed to address this issue. The Depa~h,,ent of Transportation has suggested realignment of the entrance location onto Carrsbrook so as to line up with Westmoreland. This would require acquisition of not only a parcel fronting on Cartsbrnok, but also a parcel which separates Still Meadow from the houses fronting on Carrsbrook. The Department of Transportation has also requested that the developer participate in the cost of the signal at the intersection of Rio Rd and Old Brook installed this past summer. The applicant has proffered cost participation. The Comprehensive Plan recommendations for Infill Development include: · Schedule public improvements needed to support/encourage infill development within undeveloped portions of the Development Areas; · Develop plans for proposed public projects in a timely fashion so that they may be incorporated into new developments, as necessary. The traffic study analyzed only the intersections. Staff analyzed the capacity of the various roadways m accommodate the volume of traffic which the Still Meadow development is anticipated to develop. The following tables shows the results of the staff analysis. 5 Road Name Current Traffic Anticipated Current Traffic Capacity of (% of capacity) Additional plus Anticipated Road Traffic based on Traffic 135 lots (% of capacity) (% of capacity) Carrsbrook 1,475 (37%) 270 (7%) 1,745 (44%) 3,999 Huntington 1,185 (16%) 202 (3%) 1,387 08%) 7,500 Northfield 5,371 (72%) 459 (6%) 5,830 (78%) 7,500 Wesmaoreland 2,634 (44%) 419 (7%) 3,053 (51%) 5,999 Old Brook Current traffic volumes are based on traffic counts taken by VDOT in 1992 and 1994. Based on this information, alt roads have sufficient capacity to accommodate the prgposed development The analysis of the traffic impact of the proposed development indicates that the existing/planned infrastructure, with minimal improvements, will be able to accommodate the proposed development within acceptable levels of service. It should be noted that the traffic study assumed a development of 160 lots and the plan submitted for approval indicates only 135 lots. Further, it appears that the existing/planned infrastructure would be capable of accommodating more units than included in the traffic study. (Staff does note that with the exception of some relatively small parcels the area making use of the road network is completely developed.) the development will be served by public water and sewer and adequate capacity exists in the existing system. An internal sidewalk/path network is proposed by the applicant. - The applicant has proffered to provide area for the R.ivanna Greenway and public access including limited parking, from the proposed public roads within Still Meadow to the Greenway. The provision of area for the Grnenway and access to it is consistent with the proposed Greanway Plan. To address impact on other facilities/services staffhas conducted a fiscal impact analysis. Develonment Impact to Public Facilities (Revised from previous analysis. Previous analysis was based on 155 units. This analysis is based on 150 units.) THIS ANALYSIS HAS NOT BEEN REVISED TO REFLECT TIlE REDUCTION IN PROPOSED LOTS TO 135. ALL COM1VIENT IS BASED ON 150 LOTS. ANY REDUCTION IN LOTS WOULD TEND TO REDUCE I'H ~; FISCAL IMPACT. At the request of the Board of Supervisors, the planning staffreviews'rezoning requests for their fiscal impact on public and transportation facilities. This analysis is limited to those rezonings that have some affect on facilities that are identified in our CIP or Six Year Road Plans and have a cost associated with them. The analysis will be based on a fair share determination ora particular development's impact to affected facilities. It must be pointed out that this analysis is cursory, due to lack of information on revenues and the amount attributable to this development. The costs outlined by staff only indicate the proportionate share of construction cost for the additional ~levelopmem generated by the rezoning over by-fight development. [Staffhas calculated by-right development as 106 lots. An additional 14 lots could be permitted under the bonus provisions of the ordinance with the acceptance of the dedication for the area for the Rivanna Greenway. As this is discretionary on the part of the Board in the review cfa subdivision plat staff has not included these potential lots in the fiscal~impact analysis. If the additional lots were to be included in the analysis they would tend to reduce the impact of the proposed development.] Facility Improvement and Impacts: The following are those facilities which will be affected by the rezoning request: A. Transportation - No projects are identified in the CIP or Six Year Plan Schools - Schools affected by this proposal are Woodbrook Elementary, Sutherland Middle and Albemarle High School. Only Albemarle HighSehool has a project in the current CIP. This project is for the Phase It and li restorations, $699,000. Based on students multipliers currently used by the County this project will result in a total of 34 elementary school students, 16 middle school students and 20 high school students. This is an increase of 10 elementary school students, 4 middle school students and 6 high school students over what would be generated under the existing zoning. Cost attributable to this development based on the proportion of students is $2,341.50 or $15.61 per unit. C. Parks and Recreation - No projects are identified in the CIP: D. Libraries - This proposal is considered to be in the service area of the Main Library. Twoprojects are identified in the CIP: Library Computer Upgrade - $300,000 Library Maintenance/Replacement Projects - $ I 18,500 Based on the service area and capacity of the facility and residents located in the ~ervice area a total of $2,511 is attributable to this development or $16.74 per unit. Summary_ of fiscal impacts: Proiects Total Cost Prooosed Share Cost/DU Albemarle HS ' $669,000 $2,341.50 $15.61 Library Computer $300,000 $1,800.00 $12 00 Upgrade Libra~ Maintenance/ $118,500 $711.00 $4.74 Replacement Projects Total $1.087.500 $4.852.50 $32.35 Because of the very general nature of this analysis, staff is not recommending any action based on these estimates. They are presented for the Commission and Board's information concerning the fair share determination of a particular development's impact on facilities based on the cost of the proposed improvements and without regard to revenue sources and proportionate share of revenues generated by the development. Adequacy of evidence on unified control and suitability of any proposed am~eements. contracts, deed restrictions, sureties, dedications, contributions, guarantees, or other instmmants, or the need for such instruments or for amendments in those proposed The applicant has submitted the necessary documents to address this provision of the ordinance. Specific modifications in PD or general regulations as applied to the particular'case, based on determination that such modifications are necessary or instified bv demonstration that the oublic pure_ osas of PD or general regulations as annlied would be satisfied to at least an equivalent degree by such modifications. The plan submitted in suppOrt of this application does comply with the plan requirements for Planned Districts. Two modifications of general regulations have bean identified: 1. Waiver of Section 4.2 to allow development on areas containing critical slopes. 2. Modification of Section 5.1.16 to allow the recreation area to be located closer than 75 feet to the nearest properq~ line. Waiver of Section 4.2. The applicant has requested a waiver of Section 4.2 to allow disturbance of areas of critical slopes. The site has scattered areas of critical slopes which affect portions of various lots. A contiguous area of critical slopes which is associated with the Rivanna River is also present. Those areas of critical slopes which are part of the Rivanna River system are not proposed for disturbance. The areas proposed for disturbance are found on lots 58, 59, 60, 68, 69, 70, 79, 118, 119, 120, and 144. The applicant has submitted a request for the modification which has been reviewed by the Engineering Department, Attachment G. The Engineering Department can support the request subject to the resulting slopes being established at 3:1. The area of slopes on which the applicant has requested a waiver are not identified in the Open Space Plan 8 as a resource. Historically, request for disturbance of areas of critical slopes which are supported by the Engineering Depmtment and which involve slopes in Urban Areas not identified in the Open Space Plan have been approved. Staff can identify no justification for denial of this request for activity on critical slopes. Modification of Section 5.1.16 The applicant has requested modification of the provisions of Section 5.1.16 which addresses the relationship of recreational facilities to adjoining property. The appl!cant's request and the provisions of Section 5.1.16 are included as Attachment H. Staff has interpreted this provision of the ordinance as designed to protect properties from the establishment of recreational facilities adjacent to them. Staffdoes not believe that the provis~ons of the ordinancewere designed to prohibit the location of recreational facilities internal to a new development adjacent to proposed lots. Potential owners of the lots adjacent to the recreation area will have the opportunity to have full knowledge of the presence of the recreation area. S~f can envision situations where proximity to the recreation area is desired. Based on this analysis, staff can support modification of the provisions of Section 5.1.16. While not a modification of general regulations, the applicant has requested relief from the stormwater detention requirements. This modification request has been reviewed by the Engineering Department. All information regarding this modification is included as Attachment I. This modification would apply only to those portions of the development which drain directly to the Rivanna. Those areas which drain to adjoining properties would remain subject to the stormwater detention requiremems. The Engineering Department is able to support this request. SUMMARY: Staff has identified the following factors which are favorable to this request: The immediate transportation system is adequate to accommodate the proposed development; The design of the development is generally consistent with the design standards of the Comprehensive Plan; Provision has been made for the Rivanna Greenway and for public access to the Greenway; The proposal generally maintains the character of the area while providing some increase in gross density over the existing zoning of the property; The applicant has provided proffers designed to offset the fiscal impact of the development; The applicant has provided a buffer adjacent to existing residential development. Staff has identified the following factors which are unfavorable to this request: The density of the development is below that which is recommended by the Comprehensive Plan: The proposal contributes additional traffic to the Huntington/Rio Road intersection which currently has a failing level of service for certain turning movements. However, the problems associated with this intersection is due to existing and/or prior approved development, and staff opinion is that the need for any improvements to this intersection is not substantially generated by this project alone. 9 Staff notes that the applicant has proffered road improvements which will serve to minimize the adverse impact created by the development. While not cited as a factor favorable or unfavorable, the timing of this request precedes the completion of the Development Area Initiatives Committee work. Ideally, it would be preferable to have the committee complete its work prior to the review of this request. This would enable the County to better evaluate and balance the issues of achieving higher densities in keeping with the character of with the adjacent neighborhoods. However, if the Board chooses to take action, staffis able to recommend approval of this request based on the facts at hand and standards of development currently in the Comprehensive Plan. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Should the Board choose to act on this request at this time staff recommends approval subject to the following: 1. Acceptance of the applicant's proffers. 2 Approval of a modification of Section 4.2 to allow activity on critical slopes located on lots 58, 59, 60, 68, 69, 70, 79, 118, 119, 120, and 144. Where slopes are to be constructed they shall be at a maximum slope of3:l. 4. Approval of a modification of Section 5.1.16 to allow the recreation area tO be located as showa on the application plan. 5. Approval of a waiver of the stormwater detention requirements for those portions of the property which drain directly to the Rivanna River subject to the approval of the Engineering Department. ATTACHMENTS: A - Location Map B - Tax Map C - Comprehensive Plan - "Principles Governing Land Use in Designated Development Areas" D - VDOT Comments E - Smart Sign Information F - Intersection Analysis G - Information regarding waiver of Section 4.2 H - Information regarding modification of Section 5.1.16 I - Stormwater Detention Information J - Applicant's description and justification of the proposal K - Letters from the public. C:\WPDOCS\STILL\STILL2.RPT l0 IA'rTACHME .NT AJ ALBEMARLE 32 ~ I ZMA 97-1 ~ Still Meadow 45 CHARLOTTESVILLE AND RIVANNA DISTRICTS SECTION 46 ALBEMARLE COUNTY I II ZMA 97-1 Still Meadow 6 7 SECTION 45B3 ./ -O HARLOTT£SVlLL£ DI STR lOT s£c'r c ly of Albemarle Land Use Plan Principles Governing Land Use in Designated Development Areas For the County's growth management goals to be achieved, the Development Areas must be attractive places to live and work. The land within the Development Areas must also be used efficiently if designation of these Areas is to realistically help prevent sprawl development. To this end, the Land Use Plan for the Development Areas is designed to eoneentrafe development in the Development Areas, particularly in the locations designated "Urban Areas" or "Communities." Planning for future development in the Development Areas is at densities higher than in the past, with more varied uses. Furthermore, revised plans for the Development Areas emphasize the County's desire for design strategies that are more characteristic of small, well-planned city neighborhoods or towns than of typical low density suburban areas. Inevitably, some people will experience more significant change than others and will find that nearby land uses may not be the same character as their residential area. However, through careful design of the land use plan and its development standards and recommendations, this situation may not be necessarily bad, and in fact can be beneficial for the community. Listed below are the principles that guide development of Development Areas. The Development Areas Land Use Plan, as well as subsequent decisions regarding land use in these areas should be reflective of, and consistent with, these principles: 1. Accommodate new growth in the County within Development Areas. 2..Encourage greater utilization of land in designated Development Areas by achieving h~gher gross densities for residential and non-residential development than n the past. 3. Encourage infill development of vacant lands and development of under-used areas within the designated Development Areas. 4. Development Areas shall not encroach into water supply watersheds, except for the Crozet Community, which shall not be expanded beyond the watershed boundary of the Lickinghole Creek detention basin. 5. Avoid developmant of"Significant Areas" as designated in the Open Space Plan. 6. Discourage extensive linear style development along major roads. 7. All Development Areas shall be served by public sewer and water. 8. Plan for a system oftransportation and community facilities and services that support and enhance the Development Areas. 21 County of ~emafle Land Use Plan I ATTACHHENT C I · Infill Development Policy OBJECTIVE: Develop and adopt an infdl policy for the County. Facilitate infdl development, including redevelopment of existing structures or new development of vacant and nnder-utilized areas, within existing Development Areas. For the purposes of this Plan, infill development is defined as the establishment of new land uses, either residential or non-residential, on undeveloped or under-developed sites within the designated Development Areas. Infill development is considered one of the key initiatives for implementing the growth management policy and is encouraged for the following reasons: · To use Development Area lands in the most efficient manner possible · To discourage sprawl development -· To maximize the use/support of community services and facilities (roads, ntilities, transit, other services) In the Development Areas, undeveloped areas consist of both small tracts of land (5 acres or less) and large tracts (over 100 acres). The reasons why these areas haven't developed to date vary, but the primary reasons which can be cited are: · The property owners desire to retain existing use and/or are unwilling to sell for development at this time · Physical characteristics such as topography (slopes, soils, streams), size/shape of property, or incompatible existing adjacent uses · Condition of existing roads, utilities or possibly other community services are not able to accommodate anticipated scales of development · Proposed public projects on, or near, vacant areas (which affect planning and development potential of an area) Also, the cost to develop inflll lots is often relatively high compared to other sites. This is due to the fact that these areas are often surrounded by developed or zoned properties which tend to escalate the speculative value of the property. The potential for public/neighborhood opposition to new development proposals adjacent to existing developed areas can also limit developer interest, particularly for smaller sites. Consideration of more intensive uses or densities on some properties may be necessary to offset development costs including measures necessary to minimize impacts of development. A commitment of the County to support infill development proposals consistent with the Comprehensive Plan is essential in facilitating infill development. 22 -'~unfy of Albemarle Land Use Plan J ATTACHHENT C J A comprehensive strategy for implementing infil! development will address impediments limiting the opportunity or attractiveness of sites for development. It will also encourage market forces to operate in a manner that makes these areas attractive for development. · Strategies for Infill Development Strategy: Plan/provide for necessary infrastructure improvements that are currently impediments to development of vacant sites. Recommendations: · Schedule public impmvements needed to support/encourage infill development within undeveloped portions of the Development Areas; · Develop plans for proposed public projects in a timely fashion so that they may be incorporated into new developments, as necessary. Strategy: Provide for greater flexibility in type of use and density of development. Recommendations: · Provide for greater flexibility in gross development densities within the Land Use Plan residential categories, with a focus on increasing gross densities · Consider rezoning vacant properties designated for residential use to reflect time recommended densities of the Land Use Plan · Support innovative development and design concepts, particularly those that maximize gross density of development ~, Strategy: Consider greater flexibility in development regulations which may limit development opportunities (without compromising issues of general health or safety); Recommendations: Evaluate and amend zoning and subdivision regulations in a manner that results in opportunities for increased development densities (including, but not limited to: critical slope regulations; open space requirements; reduction of area requirements for planned developments; density bonus provisions; commercial parking requirements~ subdivision street and lot access requirements; possible impediments to "alternative" development designs) Utilize the Open Space Plan Development Area Composite Maps as a guide for waiver requests from the critical slopes regulations 23 County of P'hemarle Land Use Plan Through an ad hoc advisory committee, develop strategies and standards to promote infilt development. Use these strategies and standards to work as needed for changes in state legislation and agencies, and to evaluate proposals for new Development Areas Land Use Standards for Designated Development Areas Land Use standards provide guidelines for developmem which are consistent with the Growth Management goals and are in keeping with the man-made and natural environment. These standards provide the basic framework for the review of development proposals for the Development Areas, in conjunction with other applicable ordinances and regulations. · General Land Use Standards Standards that apply to all types of development in the Development Areas are provided as "General Land Use Standards." More specific standards for commercial, industrial, and residential land uses are provided to address the different loeational and surrounding character aspects of those categories. General Land Use Standards for Desienated Development Areas: 1.. Development should be concentrated and clustered to the maximum extent possible to protect environmental features (floodplain, critical slopes, etc.), scenic vistas, and hi.storic sites, to provide for open space/(for either passive or active recreation), and to minimize traffic hazards, conflicts with other land uses, and adverse visUal aspects associated with linear/strip development. The Open Space Plan should be used to identify areas that need to be preserved. 2. Maintain existing forested areas acting as buffers between subdivisions. 3. Minimize the impact of developments on major roads to the greatest extent feasible by limiting access points to major roads, providing side street access, service roads and/or joint accesses. 4. Connections between developments with an appropriately scaled transportation network should be provided to m~imize a sense of community and provide additional transportation links. Connection of multiple developments may provide for additional recreation facilities, increased open space area, bicycle/pedestrian links, impro, ved public transit, .em. erge.n.cy access, and access to schools, parks and other public facdities. The emphas~s Is on hnkage between developments and just not within each development. 5. Provide for ultimate future transportation improvements and new road locations through the reservation of adequate right-o£~way and by designing and constructing utilities in a manner consistent with planned transportation iifiprovements. Transportation improvements should include all modes of travel (auto, bus, bicycle, pedestrifin). 6. Require underground utilities in new residential and non-residential developments, including new lines and major improvements to existing lines. 24 Co' ~y of Albemarle Land Use Plan New developmem or major redevelopment design plans should include features to prevent impact from impervious surfaces on water quality. Parking areas, roads, and othe.r impervious areas should meet only the reasonable needs of the proposed use and possible future uses. Avoid parking areas which exceed that which is necessary for the anticipated development. For large retail developments, parking capacity needed only on a few peak shopping days of the year is amenable to design alternatives to flat blacktop. Creatively designed alternative parking areas could serve as buffer zones to adjacent land uses or road frontage. 8. To the extent reasonable and feasible given site constraints, site development should encourage building orientation to public streets. Parking areas do not need to be located exclusively in front of buildings. When site illumination is proposed, encourage the use of external lighting which is efficient, provides necessary security and is dom-directed and shielded to minimize light trespass. 10. Adap.tive re-use of historic buildings to uses which preserve the building's architecture and site character should be encouraged as a method of historic preservation. 11. Ensure evaluation of future land use changes under the fiscal impact model prior to rezoning approvals. Appropriate planning/phasing of development to match service/infrastructure availability and capacity should be established. Specific Standards for:Residential, Commercial, and Industrial Land Uses Residential Land Use Standards In addition to the general standards noted above, residential standards are presented here as a basic framework to guide future residential development proposals. It should be recognized that substantial changes in the economy, housing market, and housing industry may warrant flexibility in the application of these standards. These standards are intended to encourage the provision ofvarions housing types and provide for affordable housing. It is intended that all dwelling types and forms Of ownership be permitted within the County. Residential Densities and Relationships to Other Land Uses: It is intended thiit where po. ssible, and practical due to terrain, availability of public utilities and adequate public Infrastructure, that overall development density b~ at as high a level as practical. The use of bonus provisions to increase density and provide for affordable housing should be encouraged. Where demonstrated, by economic or other COnsiderations, that density in excess of that recommended by the Plan is warranted to accommodate an affordable housing proposal, a reasonable density increase should be provided. 2. in rezoning deliberations, the County should be mindful of the intent to encourage infill development, contain most furore growth within designated Development Areas, and 25 C ~nt¥ oJ Albemarle Land Use Plan avoi.d ru~..1 development pressure. Unless contrary to matters of public health and safety, residential rezoning to .the upper end of the Comprehensive Plan recommended land use density-ranges (i.e., Neighborhood or Urban scale) should be favored even iftbe density exceeds that of surrounding developments. Maintenance .of the integrity of residen!iai areas can be accomplished with standards for the relatinush~p of res. idential use to adjacent non-residential uses. Buffering, screening and physical separatton of non-residential uses can alleviate Such relational problems. The .c. urrent provisions of. the Zoning Ordi.nanee addressi.ng the screening of objectionable fca ~tm-es and dissimilar uses provide for appropriate protection. These features should .~. retained. In addition to the~e r.egnlatory reqmrements, care should be take. n in residential design to provide for b. uffaring, orientatio, n, and other me..~ures to avmd eordlicts with surrounding uses. Identification of appropriate land use relationships is important in applying land use designations us well as in considering development proposals. Residential Development Desi_~n: !. Residential development should be designed with an internal orientation to foster a sense of place.and avoid the image of continuous suburban sprawl. To enc. ourage such design, conventional and cluster options as welt as density bonuses are pro,aded in all residential zoning districts. 2. M~ike available a variety,of development approaches to the developer that encourage innovative design and redfii:e housing costs, including zero lot line subdivisions, and sustainable design incentives. 3. Lot design, and residential layout should be based on a rational use of land that reflects topographic and other physical features rather than imposing a layout intended Solely to satisfy minimum ordinance requirements. For larl~er developments, layout an.d design should provide for varying building orientauon and setback, dwelling umt type, facade treatment, and lot size to avoid repetitiveness. Open space sho.uld, be employed as a design feature to establish and defin, e smaller neighborhood areas w~th~n the l~rger development. The PRD/PUD approach is particularly applicable for larger developments. 5. Maintain requirements for recreational facilities for developments where the density and lot size do not allow for meaningful recreational space. Commereial Land Use Standards In addition to the general standards noted above, the following standards are recommended to guide commercial development. These standards apply to commercial, commercial-office and service type uses. 26 Cour'", of Albemarle Land Use Plan J. Commerci.al zoning districts' should .be permitted .only in de.signated ¥illages, u u~ mciuaeo lB me KuralAreas zoning provisions. .2. Highway~oriented commercial development should be located in clusters with common access poi.htS. Highway-oriented commercial deve!opm, ent not locate~i, hi. such clusters sh, o. uld utihze service roads or shared access with adjolmng sites to mimrmze the number oI intersections on higher volume roads. To encourage this approach, areas designated for commercial development should not be less than three acres and should be of reasonable topography to allow unified access. 3. Rezonin}g to a commercial designation for sites of three acres or more should be accomplished under a planned approach accompanied by a traffic analysis, 4, Commercial uses adjacent to residential areas should be effectively buffered and ~DueC, n. ,ed in accord.ance with zoning regulations. Generally, commercial office uses Id Ge. e, mpJ.oy,cd as.. transitional areas between residential development and heavier cojnmer, c!al or l.n, au..str~jal areas., An,y, u, ses (includin. g commercial office uses) allowed aujacem to resiaenua, areas si~omd be compatible in operational aspects, and any potentially objectionable aspectst should be adequately addressed at reiGning. 5, .Mixed dommercial and residential areas as well as mixed uses within huildin~,q qh,~,,Irl be encoura.ged as land and energy-efficient develooments, alont wi~ commercial areas. - jommercial us?s should locate !n areas where public utilities and facilities are adequate support s.ucn.uses. Upgrading and extension of roads, water, sewer, electrical. epnone, na .m.r. ai. gas systems, and community facilities should be considere~l in revieu~ a commercial rezonlng request. Industrial Land Use Standards In addition to the general standards, the following standards are recommended to guide industrial development. These standards apply to light and heavy industrial uses, warehousing, "flex" type uses, and research/developmentdtechnology centers having characteristics more in keeping with industrial type uses. 1. Industrial zoning districts should be permitted only in designated Communities and.the Urban Area. 2. While sin[~le-use industrial sites must be accommodated, rezonings which propose multiple sties served by common accesspoints should be encouraged. To encourage multiple-site de~,elopment, areas designated for industrial development should not be less than five acres and should be of reasonable topography to allow unified access. 3. Industrial sites should locate adjacent to compatible uses (co. mmercial, other industrial site or employment center, etc.) as opposed to residential, agricultural, or other sensitive Objcctmnabic aspccLm are factors which could reasonably be anticipated lo disrupt a residential atmos here includin such as ~,xt~i¥~ hours of ol~ral on (i *. del very lraffi¢), and factors which ma', ,- ...... ; ..... :a ...... P . . ~ ..fa,~o~ 27 County of Albemarle Land Use Plan areas. Industrial traffic should avoid residential areas and roadways not designed for such traffic. Objec.tionable aspects of an industrial use should be addressed through a combination of realisUc performance standards, buff. e. ring, and .special setback regulations. This approach should be flexible so as to accomphsh the objective without creating burdensome and arbitrary regulations. Methods to mitigate objectionable aspects should be addressed at time of rezoning. Indusirial uses should locate in areas where public utilities and facilities are adequate to support such uses. Upgrading and extension of roads, water, sewer, electrical: telephone, and natural gas systems should be considered in review of an industrial rezomng request. Rezoning to indusUial designations for sites of 20 acres or more should be accomplished under a planned approach accompanied by a traffic analysis. Land Use Designations Residential Land Use OBJECTIVE: ,Establish flexible residential land as* densities for the designated Development Areas. The success of Development Area development will depend greatly on the provision of residential land use areas that are developable, incationalty desirable, and responsive to changing market demands. Two density categories are provided in the Development Area, each with a range of acceptable density. Flexibility in residential density ranges leaves some discretion to the market in proposing development characteristics (such as housing type and arrangements), but relies beavily on County standards to evaluate the suitabilityamd acceptability of the proposal. Strategy: Establish maximum gross development density of each residential category, but determine density of development up to maximum based on specific standards. Two ral~ges of residential development densities applicable'in the Development Areas stipulated below are as follows: Recommendations: Neighborhood Density Residential Neighborhood Density Residential areas are intended to have a gross density of between 3 to 6 dwellings per acre. Neighborhood Density Residential may be located within the Urban Area, Communities and Villages. 28 CouW ",f Albemarle Land Use Plan I i I I I ! ii II !l ! · Neighborhood Density Residential areas are intended to accommodate ail dwelling unit types. Any new dev¢lopmant within an existing subdivision shall be in keeping with the character and density of the existing development. New developments adjacent to existing subdivisions shall be developed at higher densities to support infill development efforts. Urban Density Residential Urban Density Residentiai areas are intended to have a gross density of between 6.01 to 20 dwellings per acre, with possible densities of up to 34 dwellings per acre under a planned development approach (PRD/PUD). · Urban Density Residentiai areas may be located within the Urban Area and Communities only. This designation is not appropriate within Villages. · Urban Density Residantiai areas are intended to accommodate residential uses other-than single family dataehed dwellings. · Urban Density Residential designations are not intended for development at densities below 6 dwellings per acre. Developments within an Urban Density Residential areas are expected to occur within the designated range of 6.01 to 34 dwelling units per acre and, to the greatest extent practicable, to maximize the developed density. Development densities within the Urban Density Residential area should ultimately be based on ~nvironmentai criteria, road function and condition, available utilities, adjacent land uses, and site requirements. · Maintain statements in the Zoning Ordinance that site development within Urban Density residential areas be based on standards in both the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance. · All Comprehensive Plan standards should be reviewed in conjunction with development proposals within Urban Density Residential areas. Transitional Transitional areas are intended to be used primarily between residential areas and commercial or industrial areas, or in areas where flexibility of land uses may be necessary or appropriate to blend changing circumstances (e.g., where long-term public improvements are anticipated, or areas where redevelopment/re-use is encouraged). Transitional areas provide an opportunity to develop mixed use areas with Urban, Density Residential us6s and non-residential,land uses on the scale of Neighborhood Service and Office Service, as defined in the next section of this chapter. 29 DAVID R. GEHR COMMISSIONER 0 o 1997 COMMONWEALTH o[ VIRQI ning Dept. DEPARTMENT OF ~ANSPORTATION 701 VDOT WAY CHARLO~ESVILLE. ~11 ~ G. ~CKER May 5, 1997 Still Meadows Route 854 Mr. Bill Fritz Dept. of Planning & Community Development 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Mr. Fritz: This is in reference co the Carrsbrook Road Development Traffic Impact Study dated April 9, 1997. The total site traffic of 1600 daily vehicle trips (study 1591) Ks basically distributed over four (4) different routes. Below is a chart showing existing, traffic per date of count and the increase from the site. Route ADT Site Traffic Percent Increase 854 1740-1995 320 18% 652 3429-1996 496 14% 1427 1186-1994 544 46% 1248 1181-1994 244 20% The above stated routes would meet todays subdivision standard for projected traffic as far as width of road is concerned, with the possible exception on Carrsbrook Drive which has only a 20 foot surface between Route 1419 and RouTe 1432, a distance of 0.28 miles. In addition, there may be a curve on Carrsbrook Drive that woul~ not meet design, although we do no~ have plans for Carrsbrook Drive. An intersection alignmen~ of Old Brook Road with the site would be preferable, however, this would most likely change the site ~raffic along Old Brook Road. Although the numbers by themselves would not require left turn lanes for this offset intersection, we feel that for safety in ~his operational area of the cwo offset intersections, left turn lanes will be required. This can be accomplished with some minor pavement widening and two short left turns for each intersection. A right [urn lane for the site from Route 854 most likely cannot be achieved within the Right of Way, however, maximum use of a large radius and wedge should be sought for easier movement from the roadway. This can be addressed in ~he site plan review. The aforementioned intersection could perhaps line up if the proper~y directly opposite Old Brook Road was purchased; we note it as for sale. TRANSPORTATION FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Mr. Bill Fritz Still Meadows Page 2 Route 854 May 5, 1997 There are presently ~wo unsignalized intersections with Rio Road that function at a level of service "F" for several movements in peak hour. {Old Brook Road/Rio Road - Huntington Road/Rio Road) The additional site traffic worsens these movements by increasing the delay up to 3 times as long, We recommend that the developer participate in the cost of s s~gnal for Old Brook Road with Rio Road by. the percentage of site traffic to Old Brook Road. This is apDroximately 14% as shown in the previous chart. It is our opinion that a signal may be required at this location ultimately and the developer should participate in this cost. In addition, we recommend the developer improve geometrics of lanes by adding additional pavement markings to create three (3) lanes at the intersections with Rio Road which will allow for less restricted movements. This can be accomplished for very short distances with the three (3) roads intersectin9 Rio Road, The same geometrics can be accomplished at the intersection of Old Brook Road and Carrebrook Drive. By adding pavement markings on Old Brook Road there can be two (2) out lanes and one receiving tane~ the same as for the Rio Road intersections. If you have any questions, please advise before releasing these comments to the developer. HWM/llc cc: Jeff Horea Irma yon Kutzleben J. H. Kesterson ~e Truly, Asst. Resident Engineer Smart Sign Data Summary Location On Northfields Road about 3/4 miles from Rio Road The data was collected from 4-07-97 starting at 4:47 pm to 4-08-97 ending at 4:42 pm. Hour Total Vehicles 5 - 6 pm 113 6 - 7 pm 61 7 ? 8 pm 27 8 - 9 pm 29 9 ? 10 pm 20 11-12 am 2 12.1 am 2 1 - ~ am 2 3 -'4 am 1 4:5 am 3 5 - 6 am 17 6 - 7 am 102 7 - 8 am 99 8 - 9 am 62 9- 10 am 53 10- 11 am 62 12- 1 pm 74 1 - 2 pm 75 2 - 3 pm 73 3 - 4 pm 99 4 - 5 pm 114 I ATTACHiVlENT E [~ Total cars for a twenty four hour period was 1156 Minimum MPH 11 Maximum MPH 56 Average MPH 31 50% of the cars average speed was 32 85% of the cars average speed was 38 There were 2 accidems on Northfields between 1/t/92 to 12/31/96. The accidents took place between 12 pm and 2 pm. Conclusions; Based on the above information, Northfield Road is experiencing a slight speeding problem, Eighty-five percent of the vehicles counted were going three miles over the speed limit. Northfield Road has had two accidents over the past four years. As expected, the largest traffic count occurs during the Am and Pm peak hours. I:\g\s\juan\smartda2.wp Smart Sign Data Summary Location On Carrsbrook Drive between Carrsbrook Ct and Westmoreland Rd The data was collected from 3-24-97 starting at 5:30 pm to 3-25-97 ending at 7:25 pm. Hour Total Vehicles 5 - 6 pm 160 6 - 7 pm 127 7 - 8 pm 117 8 - 9 pm 42 9- 10 pm 32 10- 11 pm 16 11 - 12 am 8 12 - 1 am 3 1 - 2 am 0 2 - 3 am 0 3~4 am 3 4 - 5 am 5 5 - 6 am 5 6 - 7 am 15 7 ~ 8 am 89 8 - 9 am 96 9- 10 am 61 10.11 am 52 11 -~ 12am 64 12 -~ 1 pm 67 1 - 2 pm 83 2 - 3 pm 80 3 - 4 pm 91 4 - 5 pm 80 LATTACHMENT E j- Total cars for a twenty four hour period was 1291 Minimum MPH 11 Maximum MPH 59 Average MPH 28.2 50% of the cars average speed was 29 85% of the cars average speed was 33 There were 16 accidents on Carrsbrook Drive between 1 / 1/92 to 12/31/96. Twelve of these accidents involved two vehicles, which is greater than average. The remaining four accidents involved one vehicle2 Ten persons were injured as a result of these 16 accidents. The majority of these accidents took place between 4 - 6 pm. Conclusions: Bas0d on the above information, Carrsbrook Dr. is not experiencing a speeding problem. Eighty-five percent of the vehicles counted were going two miles under the speed limit. Carrsbrook Drive has averaged four accidents a year over the past four years. As expected, the largest traffic count occurs during the Am and Pm peak hours. I:\g\s\juan\smartda I .wp IATTACHMENT G~ CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C. March 24, 1997 Mr. Wilham D. Fritz Senior Planner County of Albemarle Dept. of Planning & Community Development 401 Mcintiro Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 RE: ZMA 97-01 Still Meadow Dear Mr. Fritz: With this letter, we request a modification of Seetion 4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance of Albemarle County to allow for grading and construction in areas of critical slopes associated with our preliminary plan for the referenced rezoning. Our plan identifies several areas of critical slopes, most of which are shown on the Comprehensive Plan Open Space plan. We are not asking for a modification for the areas of critical slopes that are shown on the Open Space plan. Th~ ~eas of critical slopes that we are seeking a modification for are mostly small, isolated, non-contiguous areas. We would like to address the specific concerns as noted in Section 4.2, as the responses to the concerns will be the same for each area, and later to make specific comments about certain areas. Section 4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance identifies five concerns with respect to the development of critical slopes. Below, we list the five concerns with our response to e~ch: Rapid and/or lar~_e-scale movement qf soil and rock: Our proposed developmem would not cause rapid and/or large-scale movement of soil and rock because we would use sound engineering and construction methods to ensure that. In several cases we would take an area of critical slopes marked by a depression, and fill in the depression, eliminating the slopes(and the possibility of large-scale movement of material) altogether. In all cases, areas that are graded will be immediately and permanently stabilized to prevent large-scale(and small-scale) movement. We propose to have an engineer monitor the activities to ensure that the falls are properly benched or notched and compacted. Excessive stornnvater rtm~..ff: Our proposed deVelopment of areas of critical slopes would not cause or create excessive stormwater run-off Our request for modification, if approved, does not create additional impervious surfaces with respect to what could be done without a modification; it does, however, allow for a more prudent use of space. Again, in areas where a depression is filled in, we would improve stormwater run-offby eliminating some areas of steep slopes. ATTACHMENT Siltation q£natural and man-made bodies q£water: Wtfile we believe this to be the most sensitive of the concerns listed in the Zoning Ordinance, we do not think our request will result in s'dtafion of natural and man-made bodies of water. The pond between our property and Carrsbrook is an area that needs to be protected, and we intend to aggressively protect this pond with our erosion and sediment control plans. We have moved our recreation area away form the pond in order to better protect this areas from siltation. The new area for our recreation area will still be in areas of critical slopes, but the development of this area will no longer impact the Carrsbrook pond~ Beause we have identified this area at'the beginning, we can make specific plans to protect the pond from all siltation, not just from the development of critical slopes, which will be much less, if any now that we have moved the recreation area. All parts of this site will be protected with erosion and sediment control devices, eliminating the chance of any body of water silting in. Loss o_£an aesthetic resource: Approval of our request for modifieation will not result in a loss of an aesthetic resource. We are making a substantial effort to ensure that the areas of critical slopes that are an aesthetic resource, are protected. The long, continuous bands of slopes that divide the flood plain and our meadows are certainly a resource, and we are doing everything within our power to protect these areas. As previously noted, we are not requesting a modification for these slopes. The areas we are requestin~ a modification for are mostly small bands of slopes in the middle of an open field. We believe these areas of critical slopes have no aesthetic value. In the event ora septic failure, a_vreater travel distance of septic e._~luent: Tl~s site will be served by public water and sewer, therefore, this concern does not apply to our project. Several areas of critical slopes for which we are requesting a modification would be eliminated with road grading, or the areas could be corrected with additional grading in conjunction with road building. The area of slopes on lots: 58, 59, 60; 79, 119, 120; 144 will be significantly changed with road construction. In all cases, additional grading with road construction would correct areas of critical slopes by improving the topography, creating flatter areas for building sites and om' recreation facilities. In all areas noted above, the development of critical slopes will not cause or make worse any of the concerns noted in Section 4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance. Approval of this request will not endanger ~be public health, safety and/or welfare. The area of critical slopes that runs along or through lots: 70,69,68,79, and 118 were largely created when the old fanning road was built. Approving our request to develop portions this man-made slope will improve the overall condition of the property, and not create problems, flour request is not approved, we will not loose any lots. We could adjust lot lines and move around our amenities. We believe prohibiting development on small areas of critical slopes does not make sense and is not consistent with the goals 0f the Comprehensive Plan- to prOtect the areas of critical slopes that are~ an aesthetic resource. We believe our plan and our request for modification of section 4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance complies with the intent of the Comprehensive Plan. We are protecting the areas of critical slopes that need to be protected. [ hope that the staff feels that we have taken extreme measures to protect these slopes. We agree that these areas of critical IATTACHMEN_ T._G J slopes(the slopes separating the ridges and flood plain) are an aesthetic resource and should be protected. However, we feel strongly that the other, smaller areas of critical slopes within the. project are not slopes that the Comprehensive Plan seeks to protect. These slopes are not an aesthetic resource, and by developing them, we will not adversely effect the property or that of our neighbors. Approval of our request for modification will not result in more profits for the developer. What it will provide for is the efficient use of a piece of property located in the growth area without negatively impacting the neighboring properties or endangering public health, safety and/or welfare while still protecting areas of critical slope that are of importance to the community. If you have any questions about our request, or if we can provide any additional information in support of this, please let us know. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Manager RECEIVEP APR 5 1997 Planning Dept. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Department of Engineering & Publio Works MEMORANDUM [ATTACHMENT<: 1 TO; FROM: DATE: RE: Bill Fritz, Senior Planner Glenn E. Brooks, Senior Engineer 25 April 1997 Still Meadow The Waiver Requests for development on critical slopes and relief from the detention requirement oftha Zoning Ordinances received on 25 March 1997 have been reviewed. Comments on the Traffic Study, received on 17 April 1997 will be provided when comments from VDOT have been reviewed, The Engineering department recommends approval of the detention waiver for those portions which drain directly to the Rivanna River. This is similar to other detention waivers in that runoff from this development should pass through the river corridor before flooding has time to develop and peak.~ Also similar to other recent detention waivers, the Engineering Department and the Water Resources Manager have the following conditions to be attached to the detention waiver which pertains to water - quality. Engineering Department approval of Water Quality BMP's to be provided in lieu of detention to treat a minimum of the first ½ inch ofrunofffrom all impervious areas. The locations are to be approved by the Engineering Department. Engineering Depamnent receipt of proof of recordation and copies of Stormwater Management BMP Facilities Maintenance Agreements for all BMP's. The majority of slopes under consideration are along the Rivanna River floodplain, and in the three major ravines leading into the Rivanna River floodplain and Carrsbrook pond. For a delineation of the areas under discussion, please refer to the plan provided by the applicant. Below each of the concerns specified in the Zoning Ordinance section 4.2 is addressed. rapid and/or large-scale movement of soil and rock The critical slopes are to be graded to provide a more level area for subdivision developmem. Proper fill construction, surface stabilization, and controlled drainage from the roadways will minimize the possibility of slope failure in those areas where slopes will remain. Surface stabilization will be assured by an erosion and sediment control plan. excessive stormwater runoff The site will not experience an increase in Storm water runoffas a result of steep slopes. Page 2 Memorandum: Still Meadow 25 April 1997 IGATTACHMENT GI Drainage from impervious areas, and any newly created slopes will be controlled through the drainage system shown on the site plan. siltg0on ofn0tural and manmade bodies of water Siltation will be controlled through an erosion and sediment control plan for the development. As a condition of this erosion control plan, the site will be permanently stabilized prior to completion. To better ensure that siltation is eliminated, a 3:1 slope is recommended where slopes are to be constructed. We recommend that lots be moved back off the slopes which border the Rivanna River's floodplain and Carrsbrook pond, and sewer lines be moved up or back from these slopes wherever possible. Any disturbance ofthase steep slopes which make up'the Rivanna River stream valley will be very difficult to stabilize, as well as damage a identifiable critical resource. It appears as though the lots and sewer line along the Rivanna River have been moved back. However, a few of the lots and the sewer line above Carrsbrook pond could be relocated or rearranged. 1o~ of aesthetic resource The slopes being addressed are wooded. They are visible in portions from across the Rivanna River, and partially from the residences along Carrsbrook Drive and Northfield Road and Dover Road. a greater travel distance of septic effluent This is not an issue as the site will be serviced by public sewers. Provided the plan is revised to reduce disturbance of the slopes bordering the Rivanna River and Carrsbrook pond as mentioned above, Albemarle County Engineering recommends modification of Section 4.2 for development of the critical slopes. Please contact me at your earliest convenience if you have questions or requir~ additional information. GEB/ss Copy: ZMA-97-01 File: glenn~STILLMEA.Z 1 CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C. March 24, 1997 Mr. W'dliam D. Fritz Senior Planner County of Albemarle Dept, of Planning & Community Development 401 McInfire Road Cl~rlottesville, VA 22902-4596 RE: ZMA 97-01 Still Meadow Dear Mr. Fritz: We would like to request a modification of Section 5.1.16 of the Zoning Ordinance to allow for the location of our recreation facilities less than 75 feet fxom the nearest property line and 125 feet fi.om the nearest dwelling. We believe that our request should be approved because it will not effect any existing dwellings, only those to be d~ev.eloped in our project. Because we are showing this on our plan fi.om its inception, purchasers in Still Meadow will see the location of the recreation facilities and the proximity to their homes. We believe that having the amenities located close to homes is an attraction, not a distraction, for many buyers. It makes it much easier for people to enjoy the facilities without having to get in their ears and drive some place. In addition to not causing a problem for Still Meadow's residents, this will not cause a problem for the surrounding properly owners because of the significant distance to the nearest home. We believe the justification for our request for modification of Seefion 5.1.16 is sound and consistant with the view we have for Still Meadow. We acknowledge that all other provisions of Section 5.1.16 will have to bo met. As is the case with our request for modification of Section 4.2, approval of this request will not result in a financial windfall for the developer. It will allow for the prudent and efficient use of a piece of land designated for residential growth. ffthere are any questions, or if we can provide any additional information in support of our request, please let us know. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, SCO~ h. W'llliarflS Manager 5.1.17 IATTACHMENT SWIMMING, GOLF, TENNIS CLUBS ae The swimming pool, including the apron, filtering and pumping equipment, and any buildings, shall be at least seventy-five (75) feet from the nearest property line and at least one hundred twenty-five (125) feet from any existing dwelling on an adjoining property, except that, where the lot upon which it is located abuts land in a commercial or industrial district, the pool may be constructed no less than twenty-five (25) feet from the nearest property line of such land in a commercial or industrial district; · When the lot on which any such pool is located abuts the rear or side line of, or is across the street from, any residential district, a substantial, sightly wall, fence, or shrubbery shall be erected or planted, so as to screen effectively'said pool from view from the nearest property in such residential district; The sound from any radio, recording device, public address system or other speaker shall be limited to forty (40) decibels at the nearest residential property line; The board of supervisors may, for the protection of the health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community, require such additional conditions as it deems necessary, including but not limited to provi- sions for additional fencing and/or planting or other landscaping, additional setback from property lines, additional parking space, location and arrangement of lighting, and other reasonable requirements; ee Provision for concessions for the serving of food, refreshments or e~tertainment for club members and guests may be permitted under special use permit procedures. TOURIST LODGING The zoning administrator may issue a permit for such use for a period not exceeding five [5) years and renewable for five (5) year periods thereafter, provided that: Approval for such use has been obtained from the Albemarle County fire official. The fire official shall thereafter inspect the premises at his discre- tion; Approval of permit has been obtained from the Bureau of Tourist Establishment Sanitation of the Virginia Department of Health. -66- iATTAC HM ENT B. A ) ,REY HUFFMAN ASSOCIATEo, LTD. CIVIZ ENGINEERING- LAND SURVEYING- LAND PLANNING 195 RIVERBEND DRIVE, SU1~11~' 2 MAILING ADDRESS- P.O. BOX 6124 CHARZOTTESIfI_LLE, VIRGINIA 22906 Mr. William Fritz, Senior Planner Dept. of Planning & Community Development County of Albemarle 401McIntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 March 24, 1997 RE: Still Meadows ZMA 97-01 Dear Mr. Fritz, This letter is in response to your comments and other departments comments concerning the above mentioned project. In regards to critical slopes shown on the plan, feel that we have shown all of them. In regards to site distance at our two entrances, we made an examination and found both to have in excess of the required 350 feet. In regards to stormwater detention, we show proposed detention basins that will serve the areas of the site that will drain across other properties. The rest of the site, which is the majority, drains across flood plain and then directly into the South Fork Of the Rivanna River. A waiver of the stormwater detention requirement for this portion of the site should be granted because of its proximity to the above mentioned river. Also, because of this sites location within the drainage basin of the river, there should be no detrimental impact on any downstream properties during storms of any consequence. If you have any questions or comments regarding the above or need further information, please contact my office at your earliest convenience. Sin erely, cc Mr. Scott Williams [ ATTACHMEN;rl ! TO: FROM: DATE: RE: COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Department of Engineering & Public Works MEMORANDUM Bill Fritz, Senior Planner Glenn E. Brooks, Senior Engineer 30 January 1998 Still Meadows, detention waiver The applicant has requested a waiver of the detention requirements of the Zoning Ordinance (sec. 32.7.4) for those portions of the Still Meadows development which drain directly to the Rivanna Pdver. In a memorandum dated 25 April 1997, the Engineering Department recommended approval of this waiver with two conditions addressing water quality measures to be provided in lieu of detention measures. This is consistent with past engineering policy regarding detention waivers. We continue to support this recommendation with the two conditions, and our reasoning is expressed below. In a generic sense, based on the review of specific plans, the Engineering Department will -support Planning Commission waivers of the detention requirements for sites adjacent to rivers or large watercourses. Such waivers are typically justified by the timing of peak discharges from the development not coinciding with the watercourse's flood crest, and by the fact that there are no downstream properties to protect, other than those on the large watercourse. However, EngineerIng Department support of these stormwater detention waivers is conditional upon satisfactory measures being proposed which address issues of water quality. Some examples of sites for which detention was waived and water quality measures were provided are the PantQps Shopping Center, Woolen Mills Warehouse, and Charlottesville Self Storage. Water quality measures are asked for because, just as we recognize the advantages to being adjacent to a large watercourse; namely the quick discharge of stormwater and the convenience of an adequate receiving channel, we also recognize the disadvantages, some of which can be the loss ofnamr~ al buffers, and the direct discharge of pollutants in rnnoff into receiving waters. With this in mind, there are stormwater treatment aitematives which can be provided in lieu of stormwater detention facilities to address the disadvantages of close proximity to major watercourses. Addressing Still Meadows specifically, it is beleived that releas'mg rnnoff from the site quickly into the river without detention will be better than providing detention to reduce the runoff rate, and possibly delaying the release ofnmoff such that it contributes to peak water levels in the Rivarma. There are no immediate downstream properties under different owners to protect, and the impacts to the river valley slopes and the wide floodplain can be addressed without detention provisions. Page 2 Memorandum: Still Meadows, detention waiver 30 January 1998 ATTACHMENT,,! i~ Water quality in the Rivanna is also a growing concem based on Department of Environmental Quality reports and local efforts with the Rivanna River Basin Project. At Still Meadows, because runoff from the site will be released directly into the fiver, and because of the detention reasoning above, water quality concerns are more important than detention concerns. Please contact me at your earliest convenience if you have questions or require additional information. GEB/ Copy: ZMA-97-01 File: STILLM.DET IATTAC H MENT ~ ATTACHMENT A TO REZONING APPLICATION DESCPdlaTION OF REQUEST Crescent Development Group, L.L.C., is requesting that approximately 142 acres be rezoned from R-1 Residential to PRD Residential in order to create Still Meadow, a planned community of not more than 160 units. Crescent Development has agreements to purchase 135 acres ( TM46-21 ) from Still Meadow Land Trust and 7 acres ( TM45B2-2, a portion of) from Ollie and Florence Fitzgerald. Both of these properties are currently zoned Rt, and our plan shows creating 151 lots out of TM46-21, and 4 lots out of the 7 acre portion of TM45B2-2. Jane Williamson has joined a portion of her property (TM45B2-4), approximately 10,000 square feet, to our rezoning request. Crescent Development is the contract purchaser of the I 0,000 square foot area to be rezoned. TM45B2-4 ia already recognized as a subdivided lot, but its access is across the spillway of the pond. In exchange for the 10,000 square feet and a sanitary sewer easement, Crescent Development sell Jane Williamson a piece of land that will provide her tot with road frontage on our subdivision road. Therefore, the transactions with TM45B2-4 will not create an additional lot, they will provide an existing lot with better and safer access. Jane Williamson will provide Crescent Development with a sanitary sewer easement across her property. We have enclosed a preliminary plan for Still Meadow to be part of our application. The property that will become Still Meadow has some unique characteristics. The 142 acre property is comprised of $$ acres that are undevelopable because of being in the flood plain of the South Fork of the Rivanna River,'~,ith the remaining 87 acres being pastures and wooded ridges. The property has access to Carrsbrook Drive through a dedicated right of way, and it has access tc Northfields Road. The property can he served by public water which exists at both of the road accesses. Still Meadow can be served by public sewer with the Woodbrook interceptor running through the property's flood plain, and a smaller line that runs along Still Meadow's boundary with Northfields. Still Meadow is surrounded by the established residential developments ofNorthfields, Carrsbrook, and Westmoreland, and is one of the few undeveloped parcels in this urban area. The proposed development, Still Meado% is a community of not more than 160 single family detached homes situated in the pastures and along the ridges of the property. The homes in Still Meadow will be constructed by the area's best builders, and will range in price from $200,000 to well over $300,000. The homes and lots will be protected by Covenants and Restrictions that will ensure that homes are built to the highest standards, and that will protect and preserve the wooded areas not dedicated for homesites. All homes will be served by public water and sewer. The subdivision streets in Still Meadow will be built to the Virginia Department of Transportation (" VDOT ") standards, and '//itl be accepted into VDOT's secondary road system. Still Meadow will have a significant amount of area dedicated to Open Space: the 55 acres of flood plain; and large portions of the ridges. In addition to the Open Space, this community will have its own amenities. The amenities in Still Meadow will be for the use of the community's residents and guests only. We plan to build an adult pool, a toddler pool, a clubhouse/bathroom facility, a tennis court, and a playground. We have dedicated a site on the preliminary plan for the recreation facilities, but because we are still evaluating the site, we would like to reserve the right to relocate the facilities. Should we elect to keep the amenities where they are shown, we would submit a request for a waiver or modification of Section 4.2 oftbe Zoning Ordinance to allow for the grading on critical slopes on the recreation lot. We would also like to explore the possibility of providing less parking than is required in the Zoning Ordinance because it is our experience that most residents will walk to the facilities. By providing less than required but certainly adequate parking we may be able to provide additional amenities for the community. If we decide to relocate the recreation lot, we would move it to the area shown as lots 78,79 and 80, and we would create 3 lots where the amenities are currently shown, ffthe amenities are built in the location shown on the plan, we would want to have the ability to move the facilities around in the d.esignated area. As nice as our amenities witl be, the large amount of Open Space may be the most attractive aspect of Still Meadow. The Open Space in Still Meadow will encompass most oftbe environmentally sensitive areas on the property. All oftbe 55 acres in the flood plain will be designated as Open Space, and will have pedestrian access to the flood plain as well as the Rivanna River. We plan to provide at least two accesses to the Open Space: one being a trail from the recreation lot down to the pond be[ween Carrsbrook and Still Meadow', and another between lots 117 and l i 8. In addition to the flood plain, significant portions of the critical slopes will be preserved as Open Space, and additional protective measures will be employed to preserve the wooded slopes on lots. HOmesites will be located on lots in such a way as to preserve as many trees as~practical. We have also shown two potential pond sites located in the Open Space that we are currently evaluating. Still Meadow will be served by public water and sewer, as previously mentioned. Most of the site will be served by gravity sewer with~the exception of 21 lots in the southern corner we are serving with a litt station and forced main. We are currently evaluating whether this area can be served by gravity sewer connecting to an existing line in Northfields. We have an agreement from Jane Williamson to grant us a sewer easement across her property. All other sewer lines originate from and mn on our property. We believe that there is sufficient fire flow in the water lines to allow us to reduce the side yard stebacks to 10 feet. We have identified 3 areas for storm water'detention facilities, if they are required. Still Meadow will be developed in 3 or 4 phases. We hope to begin site development in the late summer or early fail of this year, and we expect that Still Meadow will be substantially complete in 5 years. At this early stage, we are not prepared to make any proffers, however, we are reviewing several items which may lead to future proffers. At the suggestion of VDOT IATTACHMENTdl and the Planning staff', we have engaged a firm in Richmond to prepare a traffic analysis to determine the impact Still Meadow will have on area roads. We expect to submit this analysis in 3 to 4 weeks. We will be meeting with neighborhood association representatives, and with adjoining property owners to assess their concerns. We expect these meeting to occur in the next 2 weeks. In addition, Crescent Development is willing to discuss the possible participation in the County's Greenway project. ATTACHMENT B TO REZONING APPLICATION JUSTIFICATION OF REQUEST Crescent Development Group, L.L.C., ("Crescent"), believes this rezonmg request should be approved because it will create a planned community that conforms to the surrounding neighborhoods, and it efficiently uses the developable area of this growth area property. We believe that our rezoning request and our plan comply with Albemarle County's Comprehensive Plan. Still Meadow, the proposed community, will have most of its environmentally sensitive areas protected as Open Space. We believe that Still Meadow will help meet the growing market demand for a family oriented community that is conveniently located to businesses, schools and shopping. And perhaps most importantly, we~believe our request represents a growing tren.d in the County where it is becoming increasingly more important to get the most out ofinfill sites. The property that comprises this rezoning request is currently zoned R-1 Residential, and recommended in the Comprehensive Plan for low density residential development, 1 to 4 units per acre. The 1996 Comprehensive Plan Update recommends the site for neighborhood density residential, 1 to 6 units per acre. Our proposed plan will have a gross density ora little more than 1 unit per ai:re. As recommended in the Comprehensive Plan, our community will fit in well with the surrounding ,eighborhoods. We expect our average sales price to be well over $250,000 with many homes being well over $300,000. The lot sizes in Still Meadow will be similar to those in Westmoreland and smaller than many in Northfields and Carrsbrook; however, this Should not be seen as not complying with the Comprehensive Plan because the lots in Carrsbrook and Northfields had to be larger to accommodate septic systems. The site is located withiri a designated growth area, and our proposed plan is consistent with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Plan. We believe that our plan also complies with the Open Space Plan in the Comprehensive Plan. The Open Space Plan recommends that the flood plain of the South Fork of the Rivanna'River be maintained as Open Space, and our plan does that. The Open Space Plan also recognizes several areas ot'critical slopes on the hills between the flood plain and the ridges. Our plan proposes that large portions of these critical slopes be designated as Open Space. The balance of the remaining areas of these slopes will be protected by the community's covenants and restrictions, and also tree protection easements. When building sites are located on the lots, great care will be taken preserve as many trees as practical. With the exception of the gravity sanitary sewer system, very little clearing will occur on the wooded slopes. We believe that Still Meadow complies with the provisions of the Open Space Plan oflhe Comprehensive Plan, and in many cases, will take extra steps to protect these and other sensitive areas. Crescent believes that our rezoning request is not seeking much more density than could be done by right. Because of the large amount of flood plain, I do not believe we could obtain 142 lots by fight; however, given the bonus level/cluster development provisions in R-1 Residential, I believe we would be close to 140 Io{s. We believe that th~ effect that Still Meadow has on the area versus what could be done by fight will be negligible. We realize that there will be more homes, more students and more traffic, but not much more than if the property were developed with out a rezoning. We believe that Still Meadow will not have a negative impact on the values of the surrounding properties. Actually, because our average price will be higher than many existing homes in the area, we believe that Still Meadow may have a positive effect on property values. We believe that Still Meadow will meet the demands cfa growing area of the new home market, homes between $200,000 and $300,000 Currently, this demand is served by Dunlora and the upper end in Forest Lakes. Dunlora is beginning its final phase and should be built out in the next two years. The market wants amenities, and our residents will be able to enjoy numerous amenities with out having to leave Still Meadow. Because many of the homes in Still Meadow will back up to Open Space, it will feel like a rural subdivision and yet it will be in a designated growth area. I think that it is important to continue to be able to offer new home buyers communities like Still Meadow in order to limit the number homes being built outside of the growth areas. While Crescent knows that Albemarle County has not yet adopted an infill policy, we believe that it is important that infill sites like Still~Meadow are developed in such a way as to maximize their potential, yet doing so not at' the expense of the neighbors. We believe Still Meadow accomplishes just that; a thoughtfully planned community that takes advantage of its usable space with out negatively impacting the surrounding properties. We believe that Still Meadow achieves a growing goal of the County, to effectively develop the infill sites in the growth areas before adding additional property to growth areas. Still Meadow will use and take advantage ofthe existing roads, water and sewer lines that it has access to. Crescent believes that Still Meadow fits in well Albemarle County's Comprehensive Plan; and can serve as a model for the County's developing infill policy. We hope that our rezoning request is looked at favorably. We currently have a consultaht preparing a traffic analysis to determine what impact Still Meadow will have on the existing roads. Once we have received the traffic analysis, and we have been able to meet with the neighbors, we will be in a position to meet with the Planning staffto discuss what proffers we will make. IATTACHMENTJI PROFFER STATEMENT CRES~EN~'~DEvELOPMENT ~t.f~-97-01 II' cHH NT PROFFER STATEMENT CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT ~ROUPt REZONIN~ APPLICATION= ZM~-97-01 May 21, 1997 Crescent Development Group, L.L.C. (the "Applicant") is the contract purchaser of that certain property located in Albemarle County (the "Co~mty") described in rezoning application ZMA-97-01 as Tax Map 46 Parcel 21 and portions of Tax Map 45B2 Parcels 2 and 4 (the "Property"). Applicant, hereby voluntarily proffers that if the Property ~s rezoned by the Board of Supervi~ors of Albemarle County (the "Board") to the planned residential development (the "PRD"), development of the Property shall be in accordance with the following proffers pursuant to Section 15.1- 491.2:1 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended (the "Code"), and applicable provisions of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance (the "Ordinance"). If Applicant's rezoning application is denied; these proffers shall be immediately null and void and of no further force or effect. All of these proffers are offered Voluntarily pursuant to the Ordinance and relevant sections of the Code. The proffers herein shall not be interpreted to authorize any person to apply lesser standards than those contained in any~ (1) state statutory, regulatory or code minimum standardS, or (il) County ordinance or regulation,.including the Ordinance{ except as permitted by the regulations of the PRD Zoning DlstrlCt, These proffers shall supersede all other proffers made prior hereto, A. RIVANNA RIVER ~REEN BELT Applicant shall reserve a t00' wide area along the boundary of the Property and adjacent to the Rivanna River (the "Green ~Belt"). ND structural improvements (other than pedestrian and riding trails and utilities) shall be constructed or erected within the Green Belt without the consent of the County~ The Green Belt shall be preserved in its current condition except for general beautification measures including but not limited to the clearing of underbrush, removal of dead trees and shrubs, and clean up of the river. Applicant may grant across the Green Belt utility easements, and access easements to the Riganna River for the residents of the development and their guests~ and may at its option, build pedestrian and riding trails or similar uses. At such time as the County decides to establish along the Rivanna River a public area or park within the Green Belt, and upon a (1) request by the County, Applicant shall convey the Green Belt to the County without consideration, provided the uses allowed for utilities, and pedestrian and riding trails, etc. are reserVed in the deed. The Green Belt may continue to be maintained by the owner of the Property, however, in the absence Of such maintenance, Albemarle County at its option may maintain the 100' wide Green Belt. Applicant shall provide public access to the deeded Green Belt. B. PEDESTRIAN PATHS Applicant agrees to construct paved pedestrian paths, 3-4 feet wide on one side of roads A, B, C (to road D), D (to road F), F, and G, and for two pedestrian access easements to the Open Space, said roads are shown on the plan of development dated February 24, 1997, revised March 24, 1997, and submitted with the rezoning application (the "Plan"). Applicant will construct the paved pedestrian paths from road A to Carrsbrook Drive and Northfields Road provided the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") approves the paths to be constructed within the road rights-of-way. CRITICAL SLOPES Applicant will designate on the final plat as "Restricted Areas" those areas of lots 99 through 142 upon which are located critical slopes, as are currently shown on the Plan, by limiting the use of those areas through the project Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions (the "Declaration"). The Declaration shall limit the removal of live trees Within the Restricted Areas but shall allow for the construction of sanitary sewer lines and laterals. D. PAVEMENT STRIPING Applicant shall improve the geometrics of lanes by adding additional pavement markings at the intersection of Old Brook Road and Carrsbrook Drive and will provide additional pavement markings on Old Brook Road to create two out lanes and one receiving lane. Applicant will complete these pavement markings to VDOT's satisfaction prior to final plat approval of the one- hundredth lot in the project. This proffer shall not be construed to require the Applicant to provide additional paving on any of the roads where said striping will be provided~ (2) E. SIgNaTORY These proffers shall run with the Property and each reference to the Applicant within these proffers shall include within its meaning, and shall be binding upon, Applicant's successor(s) in interest and/or the.developer of the Property or an portion of the Property. Witness the following signature and seal: CRESCENT DEVELOPMENT GROUP, L.L.C~ Scott A. Williams~ Manage4~-' STATE OF VIRGINIA, At Large CITY' OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, to-wit: The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this ~/~day of May, 1997, by Scott A. Williams, Manager of Crescent Development Group, L.L.C. My coBmission expires: 9?-crescent. pro NO~/(RY fUBLIC (3) XXAcH i RECEIVED Mr. William D. Fritz Dept. of Planning and Comm. Dvlpmnt. Albemarle County 401 Mclntire Rd. Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 April 5, 1997 1 Planning Dept. Dear Mr. Fritz: We are writing to express our concerns about the proposed Still Meadows Development in conjunction with the implementation of this brand-new oreature called the Land Use Plan for Albemarle County. In particular, we are concerned about the use of this plan exclusively to support the rezoning to the aforementioned higher intensity development right in our back yards. We have 3 major concerns: that the land use plan is still too new and too different from traditional police to rush into implementation right now, that the surrounding residents are having less influence on the planning process than they should (given the unusual situation of using a PRD in an already developed area), and that the land use plan is not as supportive of the developer's proposal as they would have Us believe. I. PREMATURE, PREEMPTIVE IMPLEMENTATION Albemarle County's Land Use [nfill Police includes a recommendation that changes occur "through an ad hoe advisory committee, which should "develop strategies and standards to promote infill development." (p. 24). However when the developer's plan was filed, this committee had not even been chosen yet, much less COnvened. Thus, we worry that our small, established neighborhoods will be adversely impacted in the county's rush to implement the infill plan without agrecd-upon standards, guidelines, or consideration of how this vastly differing police affects the current neighborhoods. [n particular, Northfieids and Carrsbrook have existed very well here under a different police for over 30 years. There's an old saying, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." We would add "Don't fix it before you even have a crystallized, finished process to use!" The county should not approve the proposed zoning change until receiving input from the new consultant being hired by the Albemarle Neighborhood Association. We know that the booklet for this policy was STILL in unfinished, dratt form as recently as 2 months ago (afier the developer's plans were filed), ls it really fair to implement such broad, sweeping changes for the first time, when the community owners involved can't even get a final, definite copy of what policies are being used to decide their fate? We have no quarrel with the county planning department, as we believe they are in the same boat as we are and they have been very fair about trying to provide access to the current drafts. However, they seem to be making important and lasting deeislons based on this still-changing draft ora policy, and this seems unfair. The infill policy makes a certain amount of sense and we understand why it is in the process of being adopted by the county. However, it does mean an end to the old Chartottesville....a 10-minute drive from town and deer in the backyard (along with, for example, 4 species ofwoodpeckars: hairy, red-bellied, yellow-bellied, and pileated). And the people being asked to make this sacrifice are not the developers (who will be allowed to build higher density developments in the most prime areas right next to the city) but the ordinary people in the "infill neighborhoods." Speaking for Carrsbrook and Northfields alone, these neighborhoods have enjoyed great popularity and stability throughout their 30-year livos. This neW development will substantially change the character of these neighborhoods fi.om a country setting to an urban one, We do not feel that such a different land use police should be rushed into implementation, as it does violate the expectations of all the people in these neighborhoods who bought their houses in good faith thinking that the previous slower-growth police was the one that would be maintained. I1. AT THE VERY LEAST, LET RESIDENTS HAVE MORE INPUT Even if the County does choose to implement this somewha! premature police and make an example of our neighborhoods, it seems only fair to give us influence over the process (more than if the rezoning request was straightforward and for a similar neighborhood). A TEST CASE We believe that other communities and the media will be watching as this request ~r a PRD rezuning Is proposed and goes through the planning process. It is likely that our experiences will influence how receptive they are to these new ideas of PRD's and infill development. Our initial neighborhood meeting with the developer was distinctly unpromising. The meeting was ostensibly to address neighborhood concerns, but many times the developer (Scott Williams) said that he "did not know" the answers to basic questions about (for example) the planned sewer systems and their effects on adjacent waterways. A casual listener may even have thought Mr. Williams was at~emptlng to mislead us at certain times, such as when he said that the existing R-I zoning would permit approximately 140 homes on the property, not 105 as noted by the county. In addition, the neighborhood residents repeatedly asked Mr. Williams what he could do to make the development less ora burden to existing neighborhoods. Mr. Williams refused to address this idea in any way, maintaining that he was merely there to explain th~ development, not to consider any proffers that could benefit existing eommunitles. Thus, he did not seem very interested in talking about neighborhood concerns, apparently changing his mind al~er he noted in his development proposal to the county that he would be meeting with us about our concerns. Such a beginning does not give us confidence in our ability to influence the developers at all or reach any kind of compromise. It worries us that he seemed so casual, unprepared, and confident in his meeting with us a~nd we fear that he knows something we don't about the likelihood of his current proposal succeeding as is, without any compromises. If we have only a minimal influence on the process, we would have no alternative but to tell others honestly that the thrill policy means that the county has adopted a pro-development "great blob" approach to Charlottesville and surrounding Albemarle. Hopefully, it will be evident that the flexibility of the PRD can work in eVeryone's favor to lessen tension between new and existing neighborhoods through creative planning ensuring that new neighberhoods do not destroy the plensures and amenities of the older, inure established ones. lfthis is the case, we wilt be the first to point to the positive aspects of the new PRD-type zoning. We trust our elected and appointed public officials, and we know that they would not let stand (without significant and measurable modifications) a development plan which would cause a drastic degradation of the quality of life in our community, since to do so would be to betray the public trust placed in them by their constituents Ill. HOW THE LAND USE PLAN IS CONTRARY TO TIIE'CURRENT STILL MEADOW PROPOSAL Below we specifically describe some of the areas of the Land Use Plan that we believe are contrary to the Still Meadow Development proposal currently on the table. DEFINITION OF THE LAND USE PLAN The new infill development policy cited in the County's Land Use Plan booklet is defined as "to facilitate infill development including development of existing structures vr new development of vacant and under-utilized areas, within existing Development Areas. ' It has 3 objectives: 1) "to use Development Area lands in the most efficient manner possible;" 2) "to discourage sprawl development;" and 3) "to maximize the use/support of community services and facilities (roads, utilities, trafisit, other services)." (p.22) One of the recommendations of this policy is to "consider rezoning vacant properties designated for residential use to reflect the recommended densities of the Land Use Plan." Bat without "compromising issues of general health or safety" (their italics, p.23). Clearly, putting more traffic on roads like Carrshrook, Northfields, Huntington, and Old Brook would compromise the safety of ne~ghberhood pedestrians, joggers, and especially children playing in their own yards (most of these roads don't even have sidewalks!). In addition, points further noted below imply a county concern about the capacity of the water and sewer systems as they currently are to take on this additional demand. In addition, general lahd use standards note that "developments should be concentrated and clustered to the maximum extent possible to protect environmental features (floodplain, critical slopes, etc.), scenic vistas (our italics)....to minimize traffic hazards, conflicts with other land Uses, and adverse IATT' CHMENT KJ 3 visual impacts associated with linear/strip development." It urges planners to "maintain existing forested areas acting as buffers between subdivisions." (our italics). In addition, it notes that "connections between developments...shoald be provided to maximize a sense of commonity and provide additional transportation links.....additional recreation facilities, bicYcle/pedestrian links, improved public transit, and access to schools, parks, end other public fa(~ilities." (p. 24). The developer has made no offers to improve the neighboring communities as a way of compensating for the increased problems their development would impose. They currently have no plans for a buffer between the neighborhoods and are not retaining many of the scenic vistas that exist for either the residents of Northfieids and Carrsbrook, nor for their own Still Meadow residents, except those paying for the high priced sites next to the [undevelopabla] floodplain. DEFINITION OF NEIGHBORHOOD TWO "Bounded on the east by the Rivanna River, on the south by the City, on the west by Route 29, and on the north by the South Fork Rivanna River,....major residential areas include Woodbruck, Carrsbronk, Westmoreland, Dunlora, Stonehenge, Squire Hill and Raintrea subdivisions." (p.49) it is clear that Northfieids is also included in this area, as is Fieidbrook. "Neighborhood Two contains 2,901 housing units with a population of 6,965 people...the second largest population concentration in th~ County. 46% of the housing units are either townhouses, single family attached or duplexes, 30% are multi-family, and less than I% are mobile homes as of Juty 1996." (our italics). It "provides the largest volume of retail services in the County." "The Northwest portion of the Neighburhood is characteriz ~ed by relatively steep slopes along the floodplain fringe. These steeply sloped areas and the floodplain along streams draining to the Rivanna River limit development potential in these areas." (our italics, p. 49) The County's recommendations for this neighborhood include: "Provide bicycle facilities and walkways in conjunction with all major read improvements in the area", end for utilities, "Upgrade water distribution in the entire Neighborhood to ensure adequate service," "construct the Carrsbrook sewer to provide service to the area," and "evaluate Woodbrook Channel to determine the need to widen in the vicinity of the area upstream of the old Wondbrook sewage lagoons." Recommendations also include: "retain open space areas in the Meadow Creek floodplain, the area along the proposed Meadow Creek Parkway corridor, the lake and stream system north of Rio Rd. in the WeodbroulL, Carrsbrenk, and Northflelds areas, and along the Rivanna River floodplain. (our italics)" and "construct a greenway along the South Fork of the Rivanna River .....Develop the greenway to meet the recreational and conservation needs of the residents in Neighborhood Two, and the entire County." (p.51 ) First, hasn't Neighborhood Two already done our part to help the county? As the plan notes, Neighborhood Two is already the second most populated neighborhood in the county. It appears that this greater population has occurred slowly over many years and has not substantially altered the character of many neighborhoods involved: Woodbrook, Fieldbrook, Raintree, Carrsbr0ok, Westmoreland, and Northfieids. Why now accelerate growth so much and risk alienating existing owners, who will then move out to the country, leading to the very suburban growth planners so greatly desire to minimize? If the county truly wants this infill policY to work, they must give the homeowners who will be most affected a seat atthe table and some reason to buy into this overall plan, rather than moving with their feet (and with their votes), in other words, we should bo able to see our influence on th~ process and the developer and county should truly pay attention to our concerns, and alter their plans accordingly. Second, very few roads in the area have walkways or bicYcle routes (as far as we can tee. all, oily Old Brook Rd. has sidewalks and we can't think of any read with bicYcle lanes in our neighborhoods). There has been no mention that we know Of for upgrading water distribution or sewer facilities in existing neighborhoods to take care of increased demand from this new development. Third, it doesn't seem that much of the proposed development is really retaining open space (except for the floodplain area, which can't bo built on enyvcay). While there are some steep slopes that will remain wooded, the proposed Still Meadows plan seems to put buildings wherever they can to maximize their density. In addition, the proposed recreational areas are noted on the Still Meadow pla~ as being for the exclusive use of the Still Meadow residents....thereby ignoring the "recreational and IATTACHMEN-I conservation needs of the [existing] residents in Neighborhood Two." That doesn't seem very neighborly to us! Nor is it in line with the county idea of neighboring communities linking together to share reereationei sources. IN SUMMARY, THE STILL MEADOW LAND TRUST DEVELOPMENT PROPOSAL We are troubled by several aspects of the initial set of plons formally submitted by Still Meadow Land Trust for development of the old Wetsel farm. In particular, we are troubled by the face that this plan seems to offer little to the surrounding community. For example, a) some of the assumptions in the planning do not seem feasible to us b) there are no buffem at all oetwecn current neighborhoods and the proposed neighborhood. c) the greatest density of houses occurs in areas of the plan directly adjacent to Carrsbrook and Northfields ne!ghborhoods. While geographically, this is understandable, the current houses bordering this area would be better suited by a straight R-I development, rather than the current no-buffer PPI), which allows many more homes on the outside areas of the development than would be possible, with the current zoning. d) Most of the amenities noted by the developer (swimming pool, club house, walking trails) are reserved for the exclusive right ofihose moving into the new community. Clearly, for the surrounding neighborhoods, the developers could build more houses on that land and fewer houses right by us. Much has been made of the flexibility of the PRD. However, no proffers have been suggested by the developer, and we feel that the flexibility at this point benefits only the developer. A more convincing case will have to made by the developer and/or the county for why a rezoning to a PRD would be better for the existing surrounding neighborhoods, rather than worse. FEASIBILITY OF THE CURRENT PLAN 1. An article from the Daily Progress (1/29/97) notes that, aeenrding to Melvin Breeden, Albemarle County finance director, many homes in the $200,000 to $400,000 range have declined in Value because Albemarle has a surfeit of these kinds of homes already on the market. What is the likelihood that this development will not suffer from the glut on the market already of these kinds of homes? 2. The developer notes that public access will be given t~ the river and the county is planning a walking trail along their Rivaona greenbelt. The people in the now development can walk to the river, most of the surrounding neighborhoods can walk to the river, but what about other people itl the county? Where will they park? How can they access the river when there are no extra parking spaces? In addition, the roads in the development will be too narrow to allow on-street parking. Thus, is there truly access for the city and county, or just the apl~earanea of access to the natural area by the river? This development seems to be taking place in a vacuum. TRAFFIC a. We still have not senn the results of the traffic study on our roads. We eagerly await the planned study but would like to know exactly what it entails. Will consideration be given to the current residential character of the streets? If the study only considers traffic intersections and not pedestrian traffic along such roads as Carrsbrook Dr., Huntington Rd., Northfield Rd. and Old Brook/Westmoreland, it will not be a comprehensive enough study. Also, if it only studies non-Rio intersections, it will miss much of the traffic that might be a problem. Yet, as of now, we have no idea what kind of study is being done nor who will evaluate it after it is completed. There are now only 134 homes in all of Carrsbrook. The addition of 155 homes, as proposed in the current PRD plan, without any improvement in local roads, would increase traffic [ATTACHMENT K1 $ ii. iii. iv. density by a factor of over 10 on the upper reaches of Northfields Rd. It would double traffic on Carrsbrook Rd. and on the lower reaches of Northfietds Rd., and lead to significant increases in traffic on Huntingdon and Old Brook roads. Currently, many children ride their bicycles on all of these roads. We believe that in warmer weather on a weakly basis more than en~third of area residents either jog, walk, ride bikes, or walk their dogs on Northfields, Huntingdon, Carrsbrook, and other area roads. With the additional traffic from the new PRD, this will become dangerous, especially for our children and senior citizens, some of whom already have difficulty coping with existing traffic on Carrsbrook. lfthesa issues are not addressed, we fear that people will die. Because roads in the ncw neighborhood will be very narrow (only 22 feet wide, as opposed to more than 30 feet for existing roads), they will not offer the same safe recreational possthilities. Accordingly, w~ recommend: A traffic study by a neutral party, such as the University of Virginia Urban Planning Department. That significantly fewer than 155 new homes be built, to mitigate the effects of traffic danger on our children and senior citizens. That the developer pay for sidewalks and bike lanes for Carrsbrook, Northfield, and Huntingdon se that area children and adults can still safely use the area for walking and other recreational purposes. The strategic installation of specdbumps for the safety of eot-children and senior citizens. SCHOOLS The surrounding schools are apparently close to capacity, if not full already. If there are even 150 more children (one for each house, a low.estimate), where will they go? How will a new school be built? Hasn't the building ora new Northern Albemarle school already been delayed greatly, due to funding problems? Al§o, what about other developments, like Dunlora and Forest Lakes, that aren't even "built out" yet? This development will not be the only one adding children to currently full schools. Where will they all go? We can't see how this higher level development benefits the county at all, since new schools will have to be built or existing schools will be overcrowded. BUFFERS PRDs supposedly offer significant advantages in encouraging innovative urban planning designs allowing new neighborhoods to enjoy the amenities values (such as woodlands) so typical of old-style Charlottesville neighborhoods. In its justification for the proposed PRD to the county, Still Meadow Land Trust notes no fewer than six times that this new neighborhood will offer its residents homes with woodlands and other amenities. Unfortunately, this is not exactly the ease for the current PRE) proposal. In the current plan, only 35 of the 155 proposed homes would border a wooded area or an open field. In each case the house fronts either floodplains or slopes too steep to build upon. Accordingly, the developer is not making a sacrifice in failing to build on such areas. Because the current proposal would build large (Donlora style) homes on very small lots, averaging .3 acres or tess, very few of the other homes would even be within sight ora wooded area. In essence, the new PRD wonld offer residents a northern Virginia style urban neighborhood in a Charlottesville location. Good planning can accomplish far more. Further, since the new neighborhood would have no buffer between itself and the existing neighborhoods, the new PRD would destroy the scenic views of 26 inng-existing hbmes in Northfields and Can'shrank, homes which now face woodlands. This would greatly decrease property values for existing landowners, since studies suggest that woodlands can increase the value ora house by over 10%. Accordingly, we stroagl~ recommend that lots 1-35 and possibly 50-55 be left as woodlands. (Currently 1-35 are entirely wooded while 50-55 are a mix of woods and fields.) This would provide a green donut surrounding the property, as is suggested in the most innovative urban planning designs. L.ATTACHMEN This would cost only about 15 acres of the total [40 acre property. Yet it would have thee following advantages: First, and most importantly, this would safeguard tho interests of the 26 adjacent landowners by maintaining their scenic views and mitigating the noise~ unsightliness, and erosion attendant to the construction of the n~w PRD. This would protect their property values and enable them the possibility of selling their homes during the tive year pcrind during which the PRD will be constructed. Without a significant green buffer, it is unlikely that existing home owners will be able to sell their homes without significant losses. In its proposal Still Meadow states that development will oecor over a five year period. As any t:cal estate ageat knows~ n~v home buyers are reluctant to buy in an area under construction since they cannot visualize the final appearanco of the site, and are discouraged by the noise and unsightllness of construction. Since many of the homeowners in the area are senior citizens contemplating moving to smaller houses or apartments in the near f~ture, this loss of immediate market value could cause serious and unanticipated harm. tt would also cost the county in property taxes eotlected. Second, the green donut would safeguard the interests of the n~v neighborhood. Under the earrent PRD, only 35 of the 155 proposed homes would border a wooded or field area. If the proposed green donut ware set aside, 97 of 115 homes would border a woodland or field'area, and some of the other homes would be within sight of soch an area. This would allow the homos to be sold for a far higher price, making more money for Still Meadow and making for a far more pleasant neighborhood making full use of existing natural amenities. It would be a neighborhood the developer and the county could be proud of. Third, the green donut would save the developer the expense of building approximately 1600 feet of road, for an approximate ballpark cost of $500,000, It would also save the county the expense of maintaining said road. Finally, since proposed lots 3-8 and 11-29 are either on steep slopes or in wet areas which would need either grading or drainage work, these lots would in any event be relatively expensive to build on. These lots would accordingly offer relatively limited profits and could present unwary homeowners with long term drainage and erosion problems. The interests of possible homeowners must be considered, as wall as their neighbors who might face erosion onto their property. A green donut would also help safeguard area wildlife populations. The existing neighborhoods boost large numbers of soch uncommon species as red-backed and red eR salamanders, eastern bluebirds, Coopers Hawks, and pileated woodpeckers. Without keeping some of the woodlands (not just the marsh by the river), these specios will be lost. AMENITIES There is frequent mention in the developer's rationale of every effort being made to save existing woodlands, yet, as noted above, most of the wooded areas will bo torn down for houses. Only the floodplains (a marshy area) and steep slopes, both areas unsuitable for building, remain untouched. Let's call a spade a spade here. If the developer truly wants to keep amenities, not only for their new homeowners, but also for the adjacent homeowners, they will put in the buffers we request. The new development is taking up land to have swimming pools and tennis courts; the county's new comprehensive plan notes the importance of extending links between communities and having recreational facilities nearby. Obviously, enabling our neighborhoods to use these facilities would be g~ving us some recompense for the greater traffic density on our roads and the loss of our woodland views. ADHERENCE TO PROMISES While developers otten make good on their promises and plans during the initial planning stage, such scenarios are not what concern us here. As the adjacent neighbors who will be adversely impacted by failures to comply with plans, we have been told both by those in thecounty and those in other neighborhoods that we will have to be the "watchdogs" that keep the developers from changing their minds once they decide the original plan no longer suits them. Since we will bear the burden and responsibility of "enforcing" promises, we must be prepared for a worst case scenarm, while always hoping and expecting that developer compliance will not be a problem. 6 7 However, what if the developer does change their mind and decides to take down more trees than originally planned? We want tc know what our options are in such a case. 1. If the only option is to take the developer to courL that is not acceptable to us. The developer obviously has deeper pockets and more political connections than we do. Il is unfair for us to have to taka on Goliaths, using our own money and time, just to ensure that promises are kept. Thus, we want to know how the county plans to enforce these PRDs. For instance, how great a deviation fi.om the original plans must occur before the developer can be determined to be in violation? What kind of documentation must b~ kept on the land in question to show that the developer has in fact violated property? What kind of compensation is due us (and the new homeowners) if the developer violates a promise with an irreversible action (such as taking down trees that are over 40 years old? What consequence is it for the developer if such a violation is found? Will they be restricted in fi~tore developments? Will they pay a fine? Or will they be scolded once and forgiven? [n the anlikely, but not impossible event that the developer violates said proffers, there must be real sanctions. Otherwise communities cannot be expected to trust the PRD process, or the infill development policy generally. We have tried to find out in writing what sanctions would occur, but have been unable to find them. Thus, we hope the county can clarify this for us. o Clearly, these questions are very related to how proffers for this development may be written. We would like to get some information about proffers since we know little about them and for obvious reasons do not want to just rely on th~ ~levelopers' lawyers to draw them up. How must these proffers be written? Who is knowledgeable about proffers but is a neutral party? What are examples of written proffers? When have proffers been violated and what has occurred? The above points represent areas of major concern to us. In addition we have some minor concerns as well. Minor Recommendations: I. The county should urge the developer to take steps to limit construction noise, erosion, and general inconvenience to existing neighborhoods. It is known that the old Wetsel farm contains a significant Indian archeologieal site. Accordingly, we recommend that the University of Virginia Archeology Department and the local tribe have input as to the development plan, to assure that this part of our nation's cultural heritage is not lost. The earrent plan includes three separate spill ponds, including one for a "gravity seWage system." We are conearoed that these areas may be health hazards, particularly to small children. Are there ways to mitigate these hazards, or at least assure that they are made inancessible to children. About 50 acres of the property cannot be built upon since it lies on a floodplain. It is known that the county wants to develop a greenbelt along the river. We think this a good idea, but have two First, the county should not accept this land (and the attendant liability costs) unless county residents can gain access to the"property either through the PR or through other means, the county must recognize that it is very much in the developer's best interest to give this land to the county. 7 MENT K/ Second, since the land cannot be build upon, it offers no revenue source but costs the developer in taxes and liability costs. (Unfortunately, people drown in rivers and their survivors sue.) indeed, Charles Hurt has tried for years to donate area reercational land to the Northfields Neighborhood Association---which has understandably refused the offer for the very reason ofreliability. Accordingly, the county should agree to take the river tloodplain land only if certain of the above development conditions are met. We hope that this case can be a shining example~ of what can be accomplished by a Planned Residential Development--we will do our best to work with the developer and the county if we feel they also are making the same good faith effort. But we have some very understandable apprehensions about this untried process, particularly ~iven the past history of developer-resident interactions in some oftbe 6 neighborhoods surrounding the property. REMEMBER, once this land is developed, it cannot be undeveloped. If this must happen, let's get it ~ right the first time! We thank you for your time. Sincerely, Bob and Apr I Maranto 2821 Northfield Rd. ~. William D. Fritz, Senior Planner Dept. of Planning & Community Development ~O1 ~Intire Road Charlottesville, Va. 22902-4596 I ATTACHHENT ~08 Carrsb=ook Dr. Charlottesville, R~ECEIVF "' 22 Farch i997 Planning Dea~ ~,~r. Fritz: Reference is ms~le to your lette~ dated triarch ?, 1997, a~ our telephone con- ve~ation when the letter w~s delivered on the 12th. As owner and resident at the above a~dress in Westmoreland since late 19~3, it is urgently requested that the property behind Carrsbzook Dr, retain its pres- ent R-1 zoning. ~,~ main concern involves the dangerous increase in traffic, since it appears there will be no access to or from Route 29N except by ws.v of Carrsbrook Drive. (Postal delivery probably also will be even more deism'ed! ) This st=est is winding and hilly in pa_~ts and is not conducive to supporting heavy traffic. I am constantly being warned by neighbors and visitors to be vex-y careful, as the street at this point is on an incline, making it impossible for motorists going toward 29 to see a car be~king out of this driveway in time to stop unless they are driving at a very moderate speed, Dan Roosevelt main- tained time after time at meetings of the Boa~ of Supervisors that individuals drive at the speeds with which they feel comfortable, Unfortunately, this is not always the posted speed, as evidenced by the traffic using Carrsbrook Drive as a shortcut during the widening of the Rio Road/Rte 29 intersection. Filling in vacant spots of land makes sense where the land already is situated on a main thoroughfare that has been built to accommodate through traf£ic Or where roads can be built for easy access to a m~n highway. It also can be a reasonable use of land where large areas can be developed affording residents access to recreational, educational, and even retail facilities within the com- munity itself. It does not seem logical to erect structures to house as many residents as possible ~rithin a limited, confined area suX~unded by established homes built for more space and privacy., An editorial in The Daily Progress, 6 ~=ch 1997, emphasized that ,in-fill" developments must address m number of q,,~ity cf life issues within the already existing neighborhoods, such as traffic, parks~ schools, police protection, dogs running at large, and noise. (The swim,Ling pool and clubhouse proposed for future residents of the land n~w under consideration for re-moning could be a source of noise pollution, especially if electronic devices are used. ) The difference between R-1 and PRD zoning has been estimated to be about 50 houses. Even now, the Supervisors have put on hold the consideration of ~ new zoming ordinance that would allow a form of sero-lot-line development which seems to bode even worse for the use of the Wetsel la~ if applied there. The development of this land will eliminate the visiting deer~ fox~ raccoon~ opos- sam, rabbit, and possibly even diminish the now extensive and varied bird pop- ulation, but this can't be helped, However, there cs.u be help in maintaining the present zoning restrictions, and I hope you will give the above concerns favoz~ble consideration. CC: Wmyne Cilimberg ~/ Dir.Planning & Devel. David Bowerman Bd of Supervisors ['~ria Bell Vex~y tru!y~yours, _ / (l,~s. Walter J. Hurd) Pres., Westmoreland Neighborhood Assn. J ATTACHMENT Carrsbrook Homeowners Association, lnc May 23, 1997 Mr. William D. Fritz, Senior Planner Department of Planning and Community Development 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22901-4596 Dear Mr. Fritz At its annual meeting on 1 May 1997, the Carrsbrook Homeowners Association discussed the proposed development of the Wetzel Farm Property. It was the consensus that Carrsbrook should oppose any change in zoning of this property. There are two reasons for our opposition. Over the last several years there has been a notable increase in traffic density on Carrsbrook Drive and other streets in subdivisions adjacent to Carrsbrook. This is due to two reasons: residential development on Old Brook Road and new home construction on vacant lots in other area subdivisions: people timing quicker and less frustrating routes between East Rio Road and Highway 29N. With increased traffic, there is the potential for an increase in traffic-related accidents and there has been an increase in noise and act~ivity levels. These factors detract from the ambience of Carrsbrook as a safe, quiet and tranquil residential neighborhood. Residential development of the Wetzel Farm Property as presently zoned will exacerbate the situation; rezoning to allow fifty percent more homes than present zoning allows can only further worsen the situation. The other reason is more difficult to define; however, it is equally, if not more important than the traffic issue with its attendant adverse impacts. Zoning ordinances, development covenants and residential deed restrictions are agreements among people and their governmental agencies as to how they will structure their communities. People move into these communities and invest their time, energy and resources in development of homes and life styles based on the assump- tion that they are protected by these legal conventions. To abridge these conventions is a breach of faith which diminishes their personhood by altering the character of their societal identity. And this breach of faith weakens the social order by lessening people's confidence in govern- mental agencies as the protectors of their interests and promoters of their welfare, Represent- ation of the people is a sacred trust which may not be violated without adversely affecting the fabric of society by eroding contidence in its institutions. Except for the most compelling of reasons, to change the plans which are the basis of the assumptions on which people have ordered their lives and affairs is a violation ofthe people's trust. The residents of Carrsbrook oppose the rezoning of the Wetzel Farm Property. Respectfully, Carrsbrook Homeowners Association, Inc. Address 135 Indian Spring Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 Phone 1804) 9784488 Facsimile (804) 978-7785 RECEIVE~ ~Y 23 1997 Planning Dept [ATTACHMENT K March 12, 1997 Mt. Bobby Shaw Albemarle County Erosion Office Albemarle County Office Building 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Re: Still Meadow Development of the Wetzel Farm DearMr. Fritz: Several things about this development concern us. The impact'oftraffic on Carrsbrook Drive and other surrounding roads is worrisome. Most of these outlet roads are already used maximally, and the addition of 155 homes would overwhelm the infrastructure. Without significantly damaging existing home sites, the roads cannot be widened. All the neighborhood roads lead to roads that am strained as well. If the VDOT estimate of 10 trips per house per day is used, 1550 more trips pet day wilt take place on already overburdened roads. These cars are being put On neighborhood streets - streets with families walking and biking on them, most of them with no sidewalks or sate paths. If, as the developer has stated, he can put 140 homes on the silo by righl, then I do not greatly object to the home sites he has proposed. HoWever, if, as a Carrsbrook homeowner has stated, the county estimates that by tights the developer can only put 100 homes on the proper%', then I am opposed to any rezoning of the proper%' lhat allows more homes. I also would like to oppose the placement of the club house. It seems the least ob~ausive place to put a parking lot and part3,' area would be the river side of the properly., where it does not disturb the surrounding neighborhoods, If the buyers of these homes are similar to Dunlora, it is estimated that 75% will be families with school age'children. Should the development go as predicted by the developer - completed in about four to five years - where will these.children go to school? Will the increase properB' tax pay for a new' school and teachers. Where will this school be built? The surface water run off in this area was not well planned for during development lhat took place years ago. Every time it rains heavily, large amounts of water from Colonial Auto, Route 29, Albemarle Square, Rio Road Putt-Puli area, Raintree, Fieldbrook, Woodbrook and Westmoreland, run into the creek that feeds the lake east of Dover Road. With poor erosion measures, with each hard rain, large amounts of mud and silt are washed into the lake and then into the Rivanna River. This is happening now with the development taking place on Rio Road. Taking out a twenty foot wide swalh for a sewer line on a grade that is 45 degrees of slope, which is planned 'for this development, will probably fill in the lake. If the lake survives the sewer installation, the speed with which water will wash offofthe developed land, unimpeded by the trees and undergrov~4a that he is planning to remove, will add to erosion and more silting. Please ha;,'e the developer 'IATTACHMENT KI place this sewer line where it damagea the land the least. The ateep hill on the northweat boundary of the properly cannot be the best place. Siqcerely, F. Michael and Marilyn O. Ashby 327 Dover Road Charlottesville. Virginia 22901 804 978-7127 Copy to Mr. Bobby Shaw Erosion Oll~ce PRODIGY(R) Services Messages 01/28 ET 9:51 AM From: Mail Delivery Subs Subject: Internet Message Date: 01/27 11:19 AM Date: Man, 27 3an 1997 11:02:01 -0500 From: Mail Delivery Subsystem <MAILER-DAEMON> Subject: Returned mail: Host unknown (Name server: matl.co.virginia.us: host not found) The original message was received at 10:25:30 -0500 from mime3.prodigy.com [192.168.253.27] Z7 3an 1997 ..... The following addresses had detivery problems ..... I997 <~cilimberg,Y~.cva~,ail.co.virginia.us> ,(unrecoverable ~ "il 55~ ~cllxmberg~cva~all.co.vlrg~nla. US> Host unknown ~ ~A~'~ ~'~- [192.168. 253.27]) by pimoio~y, p~odi~y. ~om (8.6.1~/~.6.9) ~ith ESBTP id KAB223~Z for ~cil imberg~acvafi~iJ.co.vJrgJ~lO.US>; Mo~ Z7 3an 1997 Received: (from root~localhost) by mime3.prodigy.com (8.6.18/8.6.9) id ~A78484 for ~il imberg%acva~,ail, co.vi rginza, us; Man, 27 3an 1997 1~: 8Z: 18 -0588 Message-Id: <19978127~502. ~A7848~ime3. prodi gy. cam> X-Mailer: Prodigy Internet 6W(vS.9beta) - aeOldm~sc03 From: KF3B?TASprodigy.com (DR ED L RUSHIA) Date: Man, 27 Jan 1997 1~:82:18, -858~ To: wcil imberg%acva~ail, co.virginia, us Subject: Carnage Comes to Carrsbrook W~yn~_.~_~limberg,~.~mgr~e County Director of Planning and Developmentwcilimberg~nail.co.vir~inia.usDeor Mr. Cilimberg:We have just been informed about the purchase of the Wetzel property by Still Meadow Land Trust and !0 acres of Northfields Circle by Charles Hurt. ~e understand that there will soon follow a request for rezoning to o higher density use. This is of great concern to the £arrsbrook people, for the reasons you know so well---overloading of a neighborhood designed for homes of foirIy large size and costing considerably more tho~ one commonly sees in high density neighborhoods, traFFic PRQDIGYCR) Services Hessages 01/28 ET 9:51 A~ problems ~n an already much traveled area. Much money has apparently already been spent to purchase the land involved and ~e fervently hope that some arrangement has not already been made w~th your group to consummate the necessary zoning changes to permit thts ~ll advtsed project . Ed and Mary Anna Rushta228 Carrsbrook DrtveCharlottesvtlte, Virgtnta.3anuary, 29, 19 .......... Original message header follows ........ Return-Path: MAILER-DAEMON Received: from localhost (localhost) by p~maia2y.prodigy.com (8.6.10/8.6.9) with internal id LAA11702; Man, 27 ]an 1997 11:02:01 -OS00- Date: ~on, 27 ]an ~997 11:02:01 -0500 Frm~l: ~ail Delivery Subsystem qqAILER-DAE~ON> Subject: Returned mail: Host unknown (Nome server: mait.co.virginio.us: host not found) ~essag~-Id: <199701271602.LAA11702@pima~aZy.prodigy.com? To: <KF]B77A@prodigy.com> ................ End of message .............. ~, William D. Fritz, Senior Planner Dept. of Planning & Community Development 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, Va. 22902-4596 ATTACHMENT 408 Carrsbrook Dr. 22Charl° tte~~t~D Mai'ch 2 5 199t planning Oept. Dear ~. Fritz: Reference is made to your letter dated I~rch 7, 1997, and our telephone con- versation when the letter w~s delivered on the.12th. As owner and resident at the above address in Westmoreland since late t973~ it is urgently requested that the property behind Caz-~sb~ook Dr. retain its pres- ent R-1 zoning. M~ main concern involves the dmngerous increase in t~fic, since it appea~s there will be no access to or f~om Route 29N except by w~y of C~rrsbrook Drive. (Postal delivery pxcbably also will be even more delaye~l) This street is winding and hilly in parts and is not conducive to supporting heavy tz~.ffic. I am constantly being wa~ned by neighbors and visitors to be very careful, as %he street at this point is on an incline, making it impossible for motorists going towa~ 29 to see a ca~ backing out of this d~iveway in time to stop unless they are driving at a very moderate speed~ Dan Roosevelt main- tained time agter time at meetings of the ROam~ of Supervisors that individ~ls drive mt the speeds with which they feel comfortable, Ur~ortunately, this is not always the posted speed, as evidenced by the t~fic using C~abrook ~mive as a shortcut during the widening of the Rio Road/Rte 29 intersection. Filling in vacant spots of ls~ud makes sense Where the land a~M~ is situated on a main thoroughfare that has been b~ilt to accommodate through t~fic or where roads can be built for easy access to a main highw~y~ It also can be a reasonable use of land where l~ge a~eas can be developed ai~f~ling ~esidente access to recreational, educational, and even retail facilities within the com- munity itself. It does not seem logical to erect structures to house as many residents as possible within a limited, confined a~ea su~zoundnd by established 'homes b~ilt for more space and privacy. An editorial in The Daily P~o~ress, 6 ~.rch 1997, emphasized that "in-fill" developments must address a number of q,,~lity of life issues within the already existing neighborhoods, such as t~fic, pa~ks, schools~ police protection~ dogs z~u~ning at la~ge, and noise. (The swimming pool and clubhouse pzoposed for future residents of the land now under considex~tion fo~ re-zoning could be a source of noise pollution, especially if electronic devices, are used. ) The difference between R-1 and PP~ zoning has been estimated to be about ~0 houses. E~en now, the Supezwisors have put on hold the consi~ez~tion of a new zoning ~x~iinance that ~uld allow a form of ze~o-lot-line development which seems to bode even worse for the use of the Wetzel land if applied there. development of this land will eliminate the visiting deer~ fox, ~accoon, opos- sum, z~bbit, and possibly even diminish the now extensive and varied bird pop- ulation, but this can't be helped. However, there can be help in maintaining the present zoning restrictions, and I hope you will give the above concerns favorable considezation. CC: Wayne Cilimberg Dir.Planning & Devel. D~vid Bowerman Bd of Supervisors Ymria Bell Pres., Westmoreland Neighborhood Assn. I^rr^c,ME,-rkf William Fritz Albemarle County Planning and Community Development Dept 401 McIntyre Rd Charlottesville VA 22902-4596 Dear Mr Fritz: April 14, 1997 RECEIVED APR 1 8 1997 Planning Dept. We have both general and specific concerns about the proposed Still Meadows Development on the old Wetsel Farm. We sugest that you deny their rezoning request. Generally we are concerned about equity, traffic, taxes and schools, the absence of public access to any of the green space by the river; specifically we are concerned about drainage and safety problems inherent in the proposal. EQUITY Put bluntly and quickly, though, we think that the County should act to maintain the current R-1 zoning, or in some other way limit development on this property to the roughly I00 houses an R- 1 zoning would permit. Zoning exists to give current property owners stable expectations about the quantity and qUality of development that is likely to go on around them. When we purchased our house, we did so in the expectation that this zoning was relatively stable, because it conformed to existing density in the three neighborhoods surrounding the Wetsel property. The densest housing in these neighborhoods is roughly one house per half acre in Westmoreland, rising to one house per acre in Northfields and Carrsbmook. In contrast, Still Meadows' proposal seems to average one house per third acre. The County's (still unfinished, still unpublished) comprehensive plan does call for more density in the area bounded by the Rivanna; 29, and the City, but it also calls for limiting development adjacent to the Rivanna floodplain, and for keeping development consistent with existing neighborhoods. Furthermore, when Still Meadows bought the property it was zoned R-l, so they commited their money with the same expectations as we did. If they can't see their way clear to recouping their investment without higher density, then they've made a bad business decision and it's not the County's problem to bail them out at the expense of the existing neighborhoods. It seems m us that this would set a bad precedent that would encourage more speculative development elsewhere. TRAFFIC Carrsbrook, Northfield, and Huntington have no sidewalks (portions of Oldbrook/Westmoreland do have sidewalks), but are used daily by the many elderly poeple living in the neighborhood as well as by children on bikes. Perhaps adult dogwalkers can deal with the dramatic increase in traffic that the proposed subdivision will generate. I doubt that the former groups can, particularly as Huntington and Northfields are relatively narrow, curving roads with limited line of sight in many places. We understand that VDOT has already indicated that they wilt ask for a lefthand turn lane on Carrsbrook into the subdivision to handle to additional traffic. Limiting the development to R-1 will at least cut this traffic by a third. SCHOOLS / TAXES When both this development and the apartments behind Putt-Putt go on-line, there will not be sCace in Woodbrook and Agnor-Hurt to accomodate the school enough population. Woodbrqok's~ current expansion is already 'mortgaged' to the new apartments. Over the long term thislneighborhood is lik~ to generate more school age children as elderly residents sell out or die out and as new families move in. This process is already occuring. Since the County doesnot have the tax base to build the proposed Northern Elementary School without an increase in taxes, and since any family in the new subdivision with one child imposes a net cost of roughly $2000 on the County in additional school expenditure [I will spare you the analysis behind this assertion and instead refer you m Mr Trachta's letter, which t am told lays it out], it seems to us that the County should do anything it can to slow development. [ATT~cHM ENT_ ACCESS TO GREEN SPACE As things stand in the proposal, virtually the entire Rivanna frontage will be closed off by private lots, and there seems to be little~provision for public parking on the proposed narrow roads. So. while there is no access to this green space now, there will be just as little in the future. This is not compensation for the additional traffic and housing density that a PRD would allow, so the County and its residents do not seem to gain anything from the proposal, particularly as the flood plain is unbuildable anyway./ We have specifi6 concerns about drainage and safety in our particular comer of the property. If you check your map you will note that we are the third ho.use up on Carrsbrook from the comer of Carrsbrook and Northfields, backing onto the farm. DRAINAGE As it stands now, we have drainage problems during heavy rains or snows. Water flows done the farm's slope behind us and frequently pools on our property. We have dug and maintained a ditch with our northern neighbor, located (with the Wetsel's permission) on the farm side of the property line, that partly alleviates this problem. Still Meadows' proposal to clear land on this slope for 3 houses, and the clearance associated with their proposed sewer tine just inside the property line here will only aggravate the problem as rain flows offhouses and paved areas. There is no assurance that either the developer or any future homeowner will act to mitigate the additional mn-offcreated by cleating existing forest. Note that this problem affects at least four houses - the one to our north/west and the two south/east of us. SAFETY The proposal has a "detention pond" in the comer of the property proximate to the intersection of Carrsbrook and Northfields. Right now there are at least sevan children (of whom four are under age 7) living adjacent to this proposed pond. Many of the nearby houses are owned by elderiy couples and upon sale would likely be bought by families with children; the neighborhood is undergoing a bit of a generational change. This pond would be a major drowning hazard in the present and future. Again, we urge you to deny th~ r~_n .. Heman Schwartz Charlottesville VA 22901 - 12t8 ~AN 2,7 ATTAC F! 2610 & 2612 IlunLington Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 Febrt3ary 4, 1997 David Bowecman Board of Superv.isor's /~Ol McIntLre Road Char.'LoLtesvil lc, Va. 22902 I)ear ~lr. Bower.mil, As you know, the residents of North[ie[ds have been advised by their neighborhood association of the possible request by the developers to re- zoue the Wetzel Farm property from the cnrreut R-I to higher density such as I'RI). As loug-tlme resideuts of this ~rea, we implore you to deny o.y sncb reqnest for re-zoning. Thc streets m~d feuds .in this area could sot accomodate the large a- mount of traffic this would generate. R-1 ~:i. ll create some bnrde, but this could never compare to the problem created by 800 or more dwellings. As senio~ citize.s, this would present ~ hazard to us that would be intolerable. It is also anbelievable that our representatives would allow our property values to be decreased by such action. We are requesting that you represent us effective] y hy cony incJ ng the P].anni. ng Commi. ssion Lo deny thc t'e-zon.Jllg due to the above mentioned adverse conditions Lo the citizens of No~thfie{ds; ns well as; many other problems such as po.Llution, noise ami crewded schools a the area, We trllsL yo.r judgement in keepi..g the current R-I zonJllg~L ~l. so, the extra traf[~c on Rio Road I~'t~t won.id be an 'i.l~v~LaLJon I.o dis- a~Ler. This fotl~J caano~ Ilnll~le LJlg Lro[[ic a~ iL [8--Lhe pavement crlu. h[illg~ away o]~ Ibc vicJon~ carves and the nnproLeNted si)ccd.Lng and Jack o[ sLgllS Lo iustr.c[ Jarge Lrnck~ to avoid thi~ area, We need acL~on i~nmedJaLely on this dangeroa~ ~iLuat.Lon--we do NOT need the added danger of the large number of vehicles in the area due Lo high deusity buLhli, ng~ We're count:Lng on you to Lake nut request sorJ.OllSly al~d Lo act according- ly. We wJ].l be very grateful to you Jar yonr appropriate acLions]~ PJease keep tim informed of any meetings we need to attend to express oar concerns. Thaak you ~or your aLteution to Lbis ser Lous maLLet-, Yours ira.[y, Jolm O. Parks, Sr. ,.~ eatr~ce W. ParKs Ruby F. Cole.mn " Copy: Dav:Ld Tice, Plann-ing Commission Wayne C[limberg,County l)irector of Planning & Development Al. ice Feehley-Maus, Northfields Neighl)orhood Association To: David Bowerman William D. Fritz"w VDOT From: Robert R. Von Achen Subject: Access Road ~ACHMF-~ I 1 1997 Pl nni g Dept. I live in the Westmoreland Sub Division at 500 Carrsbrook Drive, Charlottesville, VA., 22901. My property is on the corner of Carrsbrook Driv~ and the proposed Still Meadow Development access road. My garage is in the back of my house, one story below the level of the access road. I must back into the access road in order to get onto Carrsbrook Drive, a[~dt'~en ~o my final desLil~ation. There zs no alternat It is.difficult for me to see traffic when I pull out of my driveway due to the differance in levels, and far more difficult for access ~oad traffic to see me. There have been some close calls and one near accident for a person who thought the road was the Indianapolis Speedway In the future I will be at the mercy of a proposd paved access road whic will serve as the main enterance to the development. Future, potentially dangerous problems to myself and oncoming traffic- is forthcoming. Now do I back out of my driveway without risking an accident? Further~ how do I, because of the expanded width of the propos acess road which will come so close to the house that some are questiohi the legalitp of ghat action, construct a privacy barrier without obliterating the questionable views from the driveway and access road? I am faced with a dillemma that I truly cannot solve. I have lived at this address for the past 28 years, have been the past President of the Westmoreland Neighborhood Association, solving complaints without asking for assistance from higher authorities. Now however, I ask for your help and guidance. Thank you for your consideration. Robert R. Von Achen Planning Dep 500 Carrsbrook Drive Charlottesville, VA 2290] March 9, 1997 Hr. William D. Fritz, Senior Planner Dept. of Planning & Community Development 401Mctntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Fritz: As a resident on Carcsbrook Drive who will be directly a[fected by the entrance to Still MeadoWs development, I am writing to express by concerns regarding the change in zoning from R-I to PRD. I live on the corner of the entrance to Still Meadows. Because of the many factors that will be adversely a~fected by rezoning to a greater density in Still Meadows, I am expressing my desire that you do all in your po~er to keep the R-1 designation. I can find no good reason for a greater density. Of the many things that will be affected, the important ones, I believe, are the already over-crowded roads in this area; the local schools; our water system. In addition, this neighborhood is already densely populated, and traffic cutting through on Carrsbrook Drive to 29 North is already excessive. Please give this matter your most thoughtful consideration. Sincerely, ~' Johanna Von Achen I AT ~T~A._C::HMEHT ! q ,.,.apt ?,I.T North~iel¢te R'dad Charlottesville VA 229CJl Harsh ll. ~997 Mr. William D. Senior. Planner Dept of Planniug & Community Deve£or,ment County of Albemarle 401 Melntire Road Charlottesville. VA 22902-4596 [)ear Mr. Fritz [ am writing in regard to the "Wetse] Propertv" proposals which are currently in the official pipeline. Unfortunately. I will be unable to attend meetings or take any other action after bhi~ letter since I will be havin~ hip replacement surBery on Plarch 1S. Otherwise i would be ~b ~hi~ ~:U~L¢~ ieL m~ say t:hat I am ~'irmly opDosed to a~y chalice fi'om thc, pt'esenb designation of tho propel~Cv am Ii-[. When the Coun~ v Plan was adopted, this Was the designation and the neighborhood has accepted that: c.[earl~ some development was ~oin~ to take place in the future and we felt that R-1 was both suitable and acceptabl~. A review of Lhe zoning regulations, both by their staCed intent and permitted uses by right are reasonable, In View of the proximity of the river and the 'wetlands", the special uses are mostly inappropriate, The proposal of the developers, which I have not had an opportunity to study careful].v (and won't, of course in the hospitall pays little attention to the existing neighborhoods and will have a manor and deleterious impact. The existin~ roads cannot handle the traffic. (They are alread.v overburdened by the traffic resulting from the 29 North work. I The other el, emends of the infrastructure will be squally challenged. Water and sewer lines will nave to be recleve[o~>ed o~] ~he p.ropeZ, t. ies of ~.o¥istln_~ ne, i&hboz'hood r'eside~]ts. This ~s surely an unfair imposition. The local schools are already overloaded. While it is inevitable I'.hat some of the forestsd areas will be destroyed, the plans, aa I have seen them, seem to imply clear-cutting. This is hardly an environmental asset. I und~r~t~Tu:l that. lone-rana_'~ planni, n~ calls infiliing' o~ undeveloped areas [n the urban rin~. Thim may be sound planning: I have insufficient understandin~ of it to ~,omment exQ~p~_that t,o r,ursue this goal without ~:.o ~,l'le surrounding n~nghborhoods i.s unwise. I }lave }~een told thab th~,.°, ~s Lh,~ onlY PRD whinh is ent. ire~; surrounded [ATI A HME [ ~~i~tzn{ :%~iehbol'hc, c, cl~ an,fl whfch may prov_~k~ which should be thorouShlv under'stood ahead of time. In closing. ].=_t. me thank you and the Ptanninm (~olmnLssion and. ulhimately, the l~oard of careful and thorough consideration of these and other al'~uments tha% will be made. .t }'loDe that the k-1 designation will be re%ained. Very ~ulu Vours .hr'lstoDher B. Devan IATTACHHE ' March 12, 1997 Mt. Bobby Sha&v Albemarle County Brosion Office Albemarle County Office Building 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Re: Still Meadow Development of the Wetzel Farm Dear Mr. Fritz: Sev~rat things about this development concern us. The impact of traffic on Carrsbrook Drive and other surrounding roads is worrisome. Most of these outlet roads are already used maximally, and the addition of 1~5 homes would overwhelm thc infras~'ue~mre. Withont significantly damaging existing home sites, tim roads cannot be widened. All the neighborhood roads lead m roads that ar~ s~rained as. well. If the VDOT estimate of 10 lrips per house per day is used, 1550 more trips per day will take place on already overburdened roads. These cars are being put on neighborhood s~re~ta - streets with families walking and biking on them, most of th~m With no sidewalks or safe paths. If, as the developer has stated, he can put 140 homes on the site by right, then I do not greatly object to the home sites he has proposed. However, if, as a Carrsbrook homeoxvaer has stated, the county estimates that by rights the developer can only put t00 homes.on the prop~cy, than I em opposed to any r~zoning of the prope'rty that allows more homes. I also would like to oppose the placement of the club house. It seems rite least obtrusive place to put a perking lot and party area would be thc river side of the property, where it does not dishlrb the surrounding neighborhoods. If the buyers of these homes are similar to Dunlora, it is estimated that 75% will be families with school age cMldren. Should the development ge as predicted by the developer - completed in about four to five years - where will these children go to school? Will the increase property tax pay for a new school and teachers. Where will this school be built? The surface water nm off in this area was not well planned for during development that took place years ago, Every time it rains heavily, large amounts of water from Colonial Auto, Route 29, Albemarle Square, Rio Road Putt-Putt area, Raintree, Fieldbrook, Wooflbrook and Westmoreland½ run into the creek that feeds the lake east of Dover Road. With poor erosion measures, with each hard rain, large amounts of mud and silt am washed into the lake and then into the Rivanna River. This is happening now with the development taking place on Rio Road. Taking out'a twanty foot wide swath for a sewer line on a ~ade that is 45 degrees of slope, which is planned for ~ development, will probably fill in the lake. If the lake survives the sewer installation, the slmed With which water will wash off' of the developed land, unimpeded by the ~rees and undergrowth that he is planning to remove, will add to erosion and mom silting. Please have the developer place this server line where it damages the land the least. The steep hill on the northwest boundary of the property cannot be the best place. Sincerely, F. Michael and Mariiyn 13. Ashby 3.27 Dover Road Charlottesville, Virginia 22901 804 97g-7127 Copy to Nit. Bill Fritz Planning Office May 6, 1997 H. WAYNE ELLIOTT {3 7 {997 p anning Dept. Mr. William D. Fritz' Dept. Of Planning & Community Development 401 Melnfire Road Charlottesville, Va. 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Fritz: [ write to state my opposition to the proposed rezoning of the old Wetzel Farm property. As you know the developer requests that the land be rezoned from R-1 to PRD. The rezoning would result in an increase in the number of homes in the development from around 100 to about 160. The additional homes would have an unacceptable impact on nearby roads, property values, and the schools which service the area. [ know the county is now developing an "in-fill" policy. Generally, that might be a good idea. But, the Wetzel farm is in the most developed part oftbe county. The people who live in the area are already burdened with the consequences of in-fill, and it all oeemred before it became a goal of the eoun .ty. A valid in-fill policy would simply make clear that as a general rule land outside the growth area will not be rezoned until land in the growth area is developed to its most appropriate use. The most appropriate use of this land is as it has been zoned--R- I. tn any event, land use policy can not be viewed in a vacuum because no one lives in a vacuum. Whatever is built on the Wetzel Farm will cause an impact on the surrounding neighborhoods and the county. To force the citizens of the county to endure that inconvenience and the public expenses related to development so that a land speculator might make an even greater profit simply makes no sense. I can think of no reason why such a change m zoning is in the interest of either the surrounding neighborhoods or the county as a whole. In short, this is a development the county can not afford. Please make this letter a part of the packet on this project. Sincerely, Lieutenant~olonel, U.S. Army (Retired) ! Carrsbrook Homeowners Association, lnc February 3, 1998 Mr. Jared C. Loewenstein, Chairman Albemarle County Planning Commission 401 McIntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22901-4596 Dear Mr. Loewenstein: Ref. The Still Meadows Development At its annual meeting on 1 May 1997, the Carrsbrook Homeowners Association discussed the proposed development of the Wetzel Farm property. It was the consensus that Carrsbrook should oppose any change in the zoning of that property. A portion of the text of this letter was included in the materials provided for you and other members of the Planning Conunission at the public hearing on June 3, 1997, when the Crescent Developmem Corporation initially presented its Still Meadows Development proposal. During the course of that hearing and as a result of subsequent thought about the matter, it became apparent to me that points in addition to the ones [ and others made should be addressed. I have so attempted in the body of this letter I apologize for my lack of brevity; however, the best interests of Carrsbrook residents and thek reliance on me to represent their interests reqmre my best efforts, even if lengthy, to bring to your attention factors which I believe are germane to your decision making process. RIGHT TO DEVELOP PROPERTY Since any increase in population density will negatively affect numerous safety and quality of life factors, Carrsbrook residents would prefer that the subject site remain undeveloped. However, we affirm the right of the owners to develop their property and do not object to its present "by right" development which, as envisioned bythe developers, will result in a subdivision most complimentary to the existing neighborhoods. We wish them expeditious completion of their project and successful marketing of the resultant homes. TRAFFIC/SAFETY/QUALITY OF LlleE CONCERNS Over the last several years there has been a notable ~ncrease in traffic density on Carrsbrook Drive and other streets in subdivisions adjacent to Carrsbrook. This is due to two reasons: residential development of properties bordering Old Brook Road and new home construction on vacant lots in other area subdivisions; people finding quicker and less frustrating routes between East Rio Road and Highway 29N. With increased traffic, there is the potential for an increase in traffic-related accidents and there has been an increase in noise and activity levels. These factors detract from the ambience of Carrsbrook as a safe, quiet and tranquil residential neighborhood. Residential development of the Wetzel Farm Property as presently zoned will exacerbate the situation; rezoning to allow forty-four more homes than present zoning allows can only further worsen the situation. CONTRACTUAL INTEGRITY This issue is mom difficult to define; however, it is equally, if not more important than any other issue herein discussed. Zoning ordinances, development covenants and residential deed restrictions are agreements among people and their governmental agencies as to how they will structure their communities. People move into these communities and invest their time, energy, and resources in development of homes and life styles based on the assumption that they are protected by these legal conventions. To abridge these conventions is a breach of faith which diminishes their personhood by altering the character of their societal identity. And this breach of faith weakens the social order by lessening people's confidence in governmental agencies as the protectors of their interests and promoters of their welfare. Representation of the people is a sacred trust which may not be violated without adversely affecting the fabric of society by eroding confidence in its institutions. Except for the most compelling of reasons, to change the plans which are the basis of the assumptions on which people have ordered their lives and affairs is a violation of the people's trust. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN/ZONING ORDINANCE CONSIDERATIONS In its presentation to the Planning Commission at its public hearing on 3 lune, the Crescem Development Corporation almost exclusively relied on the "Infill Development Policy" of the County's Comprehensive Plan for support of its request to rezone the Wetzel Farm property to allow the construction of fifty more houses than the present zoning ordinance permits. Indeed, the Comprehensive Plan provides for and strongly encourages implementation of the "Infill Developmem Policy." However, this policy is only an aspect of the Comprehensive Plan and was never intended to be the major, much less the sole criterion for altering zoning decisions based on the County Zoning Ordinance adopted in 1980. The Introduction (Page 13) to The County of Albemarle Land Use Plan adopted June 15, 1996, states: "The Land Use Plan is but one element of the Comprehensive Plan, and must be viewed as interrelated and interdependent with other goals and objectives. Proper Comprehensive Plan decisions must be made by reviewing the Land Use Plan in concert with all other Plan elements." The Plan "reflects the 'Community Vision Statement' as well as the County's projections for economic, population, and housing demands." On Page xii of the Plan adopted July 12, 1989, under the heading THIS DOCUMENT, the Plan specifically states that: "The Comprehensive Plan document is oriented to a theme that the Plan is first and foremost for the citizens of the County. In consideration of citizen interests, the Plan is secondly for the preservation and management of their environment, both natural and man-made." The Plan is not self enabling; a zoning ordinance based on the Plan must exist as the primary method of implementing the Plan. The December 10, 1980 revision of the County Zoning Ordinance adopted on December 22, 1969 in addressing the intent of the Ordinance states (Plan, Page 223): "It also attempts to control the density in each area so that property can be adequately serviced by facilities, such as road, school and utility systems. The Ordinance also places other controls on development to protect the general welfare of the residents of the County." At the June 3 hearing, ample testimony was given by concerned citizens of the Neighborhood Two area as to the negative impact that greater population density in the area would have on traffic and schools. In addition to enjoying a safe, environmentally healthy and aesthetically appealing community with adequate facilities, the general welfare of a citizenry depends on stable environs where only changes occur which are consistent with the premises foundational to individual and community sodal and physical structures. When this stability is altered without the consent of those affected and over their objections, quality of life and sense of well being are diminished in that: assumptions basic to their residential location decisions are abrogated; people are deprived of their right to self determination; and they are left with the sense that they are powerless to prevent future decisions which will further erode benefits guaranteed by statutes extant at the time they invested resources and energies in establishing residences and habitations. The County Zoning Ordinance is the people's guarantee that their interests will be sought and their welfare will be protected; the County Zoning Ordinance is not a document to be manipulated for bureaucratic purposes, is not the unfeeling handmaiden of even a well-reasoned developmental plan, and is not to be exploited for commercial gain. To rezone the Wetzel Farm property in order to allow construction of forty-two percent more houses than allowed for by fight under the provisions of the existing Zoning Ordinance is to make null and void the intent of that Zoning Ordinance to "protect the general welfare of'the residents of the coumy." RESIDENTIAL/COMMERCIAL DENSITY Regarding existing land use in Neighborhood Two, the County of Albemarle Land Use Plan (Page 49) states: ~Residential ~ Neighborhood Two contains 2,901 housing units with a population of 6,965 people. This Neighborhood contains the second largest population concentration m the County." (Note: Housing unit, population and commercial densities have increased since these data were collected.) "Commercial and Office - This Neighborhood provides the largest volume of retail services in the County." The above along with other statistical data cited in the Land Use Plan clearly demonstrate that Neighborhood Two has already absorbed an inordinate percentage of the County's residential and commercial growth. In recognition that Neighborhood Two is an impacted area, the Plan (Appendix C, Page 253) recommends lesser residential density and limitin~ neighborhood service to existing zoned land whereas under less saturated conditions higher density and expanded land for service could be allowed. To rezone the Wetzel Farm property to allow greater residential density would be inconsistem with the Plan which recognizes that Neighborhood Two borders on, if not having already reached, residential and commercial density saturation. ENVIRONMENTAL/ECOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS Regarding Neighborhood Two, frae June 1996 Land Use Plan (Page 51) states: "Retain open space areas in the Meadow Creek flood plain, the area along the proposed Meadow Creek Parkway corridor, the lake and stream system north of Rio Road in the Woodbrook, Carrsbrook, and Northfields areas, and along the Rivanna River flood plain." It is apparent that the intent of the Land Use Plan is to maintain and enhance physical features which contribute to geographical aesthetics, a healthy environment and a balanced ecology. To rezone the Wetzel Farm property to allow approximately forty more units than permitted by the existing ordinance would decrease open space areas and the corollary population density increase would negatively impact the lake and stream system in the Carrsbrook and Nortlxfields areas. Thus, rezoning would be in direct conflict with the clearly expressed design of the Land Use Plan to retain open space areas and the lake and stream system in the Carrsbrook and Northfields areas CONCLUDING STATEMENTS Except for the most extraordinary circumstances, comractual integrity requires that governmental agencies and both appointed and elected governmental representatives honor the ordinances foundational to established neighborhoods. The County Comprehensive Plan subordinates the "In/ill Development Policy" to utilitarian considerations and the general welfare of citizens. Neighborhood Two has reached its residential and commercial saturation points by having already absorbed a disproportionately high percentage of the County's population and commercial growth. The Plan provides for the maintenance and enhancement of aestheticai, environmental and ecological symmetry. Alone, any one of these factors is a compelling reason to disapprove the request to rezone the site; together, they are an indisputable argument for disapproving the present or any future zoning request which would allow the Crescent Development Corporation or any other developer to build more than the 106 single family units authorized by the existing Zoning Ordinance. In a free society where minds and spirits are disciplined by moral precepts and democratic principles, people intuitively know when their rights are being endangered and instinctively rebel against the threat. Not an isolated protest or two, but the citizens of Woodbroolq Fieldbrook, Raintree, Westmoreland, Northfields, and Carrsbrook have in concert voiced opposition to rezoning the Wetzel Farm property as an infringement of their rights and injurious to their welfare. To honor this corporate judgment of a people united in opposition to a proposal conceptually incongruent with community conventions and requiring disapproval for its inconsistency with the County's guiding documents is the fight thing to do. Respectfully, FRANK A. RICE, President Carrsbrook Homeowners Association, Inc. Address 135 Indian Spring Road Charlottesville, VA 22901 Phone (804) 978-4488 Copies All Commissioners 4 Objection to Still Meadow's Revised Proffers and Plan for Development -' 'esday, February 10, 1998 First off, no one is denying that Still Meadow has the right to develop at R1 When I bought my home two years ago, we knew the adjacent property might be developed at R1. Had I any idea that higher density was possible. we would not have bought here. It is fair to say that many of the residents of the affected neighborhoods are hostile to this or any other PRD. They feel their trust in the current RI zoning has been betrayed and see no reason to trust any proffers for future zoning. I'm in the minority. I think the PRD concept has great merit, if it took into account the interests of the county, the interests of my neighborhood, and the interests of our future neighbors who will move into the Still Meadow development. Unfortunately, this PRD fails each of those tests. · Bad for the County First, this development will be bad for Albemarle County. Numbers change day by day, but as near as we can tell now, Crescent Development is asking to build any~vhere between 20-50 more houses than would be allowed by the current R1 zoning. At a likely cost of $200,000 per house, this comes to 4 -10 million additional dollars going to Crescent development. Not too bad. What does the county get for all this? Much is made of the new financial proffers offered by the Crescent Development Corporation. Well, when we add all ofthose financial proffers together they add to $110,220, about one half of the cost of one of those 50 extra homes. Not bad for an additional 4-10 million dollars in revenue for Still Meadow. Meantime, the county will have to provide services for a total of 150 homes. ~r neighborhood, Neighborhood 2, is already the second most populated area in the county. By the County's own estimate, these houses will cost a total of $434,000 in education costs alone for the children added by this enlarged development. Add in police, maintenance on new' and existing roads, and other services, and Albemarle County, particularly Neighborhood 2, will take a big fiscal hit on developing this property. Similarly, Crescent Development is pleased to provide land along the river for a greenbelt. Well, they should be pleased. They can't build on that land. Can't make any money out of it, but they do have to pay taxes and liability insurance on it. So, they give it to a grateful county. Crescent Development is doing pretty welt, getting many kudos for getting rid of what they don't want and can't afford to keep. · Bad for the neighborhoods But most importantly, this development is bad for my neighborhood, and for our new neighbors who will move in. I've been one who said all along that we should work with this developer if they were willing to make reasonable accommodations with the community, such as a green buffer between the existing neighborhood and the new neighborhood, as is required by the county plan. Page 21 of the County plan, General Land Use Standard #2 for designated development areas says that good development should ~maintain existing forested areas acting as buffers between subdivisions." Now, we find it strange that the staff opinion as stated on p.4 of the staff's recent recommendation is that this buffering is not really necessary, even though provided for in the Plan. ~ going to focus on the buffer as an example of how this new proposal does not substantively differ from the previous development proposal. It appears to meet the goals of the Plan, but actually would lead to worse infill development in this case than straight R-1. What is the purpose of a forested buffer between residential neighborhoods? When Scott Williams and Greg Jurik were nice enough to come to my house to explain their proposed buffer, I asked them that. They said they didn't know. Let me suggest that the purpose of a wooded buffer between neighborhoods is to maintain some wildlife habitat, to keep intact the integrity of already thriving existingneighborhoods, and to maintain that woodland beauty for the new neighbors who Mr. Williams and Mr. Jurik plan to bring in. Right now, only 33 of the 140 houses they propose to build will border any wooded land. With a real buffer_ at least half of them would Well, this plan. like the previous one, does r~ot do that. Considering the 30 feet that will be torn up in sewer lines, the total size of the wooded buffer between my neighborhood and the new neighborhood proposed is 20 feet. That's less than the distance between mysblf and the wall! That is merely a cosmetic buffer that won't preserve wildlife or any sense of privacy. Now, personally, we'd like a buffer from here to the parking lot. We know that may not be practical but in our view it wbuld fulfill the intent of the Comprehensive Land Plan far better than the existing offer. And it would be an Albemarle County buffer, not one that fits better in Alexandria or Richmond. Even worse, the proposed buffer might actually do more harm than good~ The so-called buffer will be owned by our ne~v neighbors, who will also pay taxes on it. Isn't it likely that they will want to cut down trees, put in their own gardens, sheds, and tennis courts on their own'land? Ir'they do so, we can only stop them by suing them in a court of law. So if we are willing to hire lawyers to police "our" so-called buffer, then we can have one. This is not a good way to promote amity between neighborhoods. This is trouble waiting to happen. Surely, it is not the goal of urban infill to have adjacent neighbors fighting each other in the courts! Finally, we are concemed with what we see as the continually changing numbers, not only with what Crescem Development is offering, but with what the county estimates they have by right. Less than a week before the meeting, we find out that the county staff report says the developers can get a large number of extra houses (continually varying numbers fly around like insects) by proffering things to get bonuses. If that is the case, why was it never mentioned in the earlier heatings 9 months ago or in the intervening 9 months? And why can the developer get so much more houses without any oversight from the Comission~ We have are surprised at this implication that our input (and the Commission's favorable vote) is not even necessary! With bonus on bonus on bonus, the original development seems more like creeping PRD with less county control than a by-right development. 10 months ago Wayne Cilemburg told us that the County Comprehensive Plan does NOT supercede old plans; it is a guide for future plans. Still Meadow's future and the future of the surrounding neighborhoods should not be held to a straightjacket of bonus clusters and Land Use Provisions that betray the original intent of the zoning and the whole definition of communities. In short, this plan may be good for Crescent Development, but it is bad for Albemarle County, bad for the proposed new neighborhood, and especially bad for the existing neighborhoods. It is not a good example of urban infilt. Long after the Planning Commission and the County staff have gone on to other projects, and the developers are selling land in Nelson County, we will still be here, and we will be living with the consequences of your decisions This is uot just about implementing a plan, it is about the future of our homes. Please consider the consequences carefully. ranto and A' ' pril Greshain Mar' I _ _ anto 2821 Northfields Rd. 974-6067 March 4 , To: The 1998 BOARD OF SUPERVISORS--Albemarle County Ladies and Gentlemen: RE: Still Meadow Development My name is Maxine L. Riddle and I live at 420 Carrsbrook Drive in Albemarle County. In reading the paper last week re~arding concessions on the above development--primarily the attempt to shift the entrance and buy a home, which I believe to be at 422 Carrsbrook, I would like to express my concerns regarding the road being built nexm to my property although I may be late in doing so and may not alter your decision. Let me preface these concerns by saying that I had no knowledge of the above meeting, and I have not been contacted by anyone for my input nor any messages left on my answering machine; although I was told by a neighbor that someone would be contacting me to see if I had any objections to the road being built next to my property. In the past, my husband dealt with this type member of the Westmoreland Homeowners. He passed I am forced to deal with the effects of how a road which zs one of my m~gj~e~= asmets~-, would affect me in 1. Past, present and future value of my property Saleability of the property Enjoyment of my home of issue, and he was a away Nov. 29th, and now next to my property, the future. I am told by real estate people that if the road goes through, the value of my property would be reduced by 20 to 25%. I see what has happened to the properties on Barracks Road where the road has been widened to accomcdate the increase in traffic--many homes are now rental properties because the owners cannot sell them for a fair price. At present, the location is desirable although there has been a steady increase ~n traffic on Carrsbrook; but with the death of my husband, in the future I may need to move closer to my son in Stafford County. There is no doubt in my mind that I would be unable to sell while all of this is pending and during construction. Will I be able to get a fair price for my home? If not, will I be compensated for the decrease in value? 2. Buffer or Shield If the home next to me is purchased to build a road, what type of buffer would be provided between the street and my property? Thank you for allowing me to speak. facsimile TRA N S M ITTA L tO: fax #: re: date: pages: Steve Chidsey 293-8858 Board action on Ivy Landfill March 13. 1998 2, including this cover sheet. Attached is the motion adopted by the Board for the approval of the Ivy Landfill. From the desk of... ELLA WASHINGTON-CAREY, CMC CLERK BOARD OF COUNTY SUPERVISORS 401 MClNTIRE ROAD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA 22902-4596 (804) 296-5843 Fax: (804) 296-5800 ATTACHMENT B Mrs. Thomas made the following three motions on Appeal: SDP-97-110, Ivy landfill Final Site Plan_ which were approved by the Board: "The Board of Supervisors agree with the Planning Commission that recreational use at the proposed site is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, being an opporttmity for cost-effective use/reuse of public land. but. as staff recommended, no County expenditures should occur until the Board has made a positive [-mding under Section 5. t. 14 of the Zoning Ordinance, which has to do with the gas management system, and as the Planning Commission recourmended_ the recreational use will be part ora Board-approved Master Plan that includes the extent and final contours of the grading, tops and slopes of all the cells and proposed cells before settlement, storm water management plan and mitigation measures for the entire property and winch addresses future uses for the entire property. Mitigation measures include location and description of the treatment of gas, surface water and ground water, springs, and streams and monitoring mechanisms, t'he plan must show buffers and plans for management and preservation of the buffers and limits of disturbance within buffers. Also to be included are plans for planfmgs and land forms to reduce visual impacts and erthance the long-term appearance for it to look as much as possible like indigenous pasture land. The detailed Master Plan must be approved by the Board of Supervisors, with citizen participation. The Board also recognizes that permitting of landfill-related activities such as ground-water remedintion and gas management rests in the hands of the Department of Environmental Quality, and we cannot preempt that responsibility." "The site plan which includes the landfill entrance, "encore" center, composting area, municipal solid waste (MSW) transfer station and gas management area should be approved so that burial of MSW at the Ivy Landfill can stop on schedule this summer, but approval is subject to the following conditions, as recommended by the Planning Commission, with a few amendments: a) Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan, b) Engineering Deparunem approval of the location, design and operation of the tire wash facility m prevent off-site tracking of mud from unpaved roadways, c) Engineering Depamnent approval of leachate containment measures for the MSW transfer station and composfmg operation if Engineering Department finds that to be necessary, d) Engineering Department approval of the active aeration system or other process used to capture or reduce any offensive odors assocmted with composting operations at this site, (this was not one of the items the Planning Commission listed, but she said the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority has said there will be an active aeration system at that site) e) Engineering Deparnnent approval of method of MSW transfer to ensure that lransfer activity is designed and managed so as to reduce wind-blown debris and exposure to precipitation, thereby minimizing the volume of leachate and minimizing the danger, ninsance, or unsightliness to adjoining property or activities, f) Planning staff approval of strong measures to prevent uncovered vehicles from entering or using the landfill, including, but not limited to, approval of a sign regarding state and Albemarle County Code applicable to loads being or secured in vehicles. The sign shall be approved as to location and wording by the planning staff and shall be considered as a sign as required by the Planning Commission under Section 32.7.8.1 of the Zoning Ordinance, g) Planning staff approval of landscaping buffering measures of landfill improvements from Route 637, Dick Wood's Road. so as to shield from passing autos the sight of the transferring operations, h) VDoT approval of any landscaping materials within the public road right-of- way, i) demonstration to the County of Attorney of complinnce with all applicable provisions of the Code of Virgjina as related to cemeteries and places of burial of the dead, j) Engineering Department approval of a Stormwater Management Plan consistent with Section 32.7.4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance, k) review and approval by the Facilities Management Subcommittee of the RSWA Citizens Advisory Committee of compost~mixing building's and gas management silo's external appearance, color and design. The Board of Supervisors has reserved reconsideration of the transfer of construction demolition debris (CDD) after 2.5 years. The Board may require installation of a left-mm lane to serve the site at that t/me or at an earlier date upon determination by VDoT that warrants have been satisfied." 3. Defer approval of the preliminary site plan submitted for recreational uses (with its curvilinear parking), at least until the Master Plan has been approved by the Board. January 23, t998 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Dept. of Planning & Community Development 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville. Virginia 22902-4596 (804) 296-5823 Bill Mechnick, ASLA Land Planning & Design Associates, lnc P O Box 1606 Charlottesville, VA 22902 RE: Ivy Landfill, End Use Plan, Final Site Plan Dear Mr. Mechnick: The Albemarle County Planning Commission, at its meeting on January 20, 1998 took the following actions regarding the above-noted site plan: CONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLAN - Unanimously found to be in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan with the understanding that "the recreational use will be a part ora Board-approved master Plan that includes the extent of grading, stormwater management plan and mitigation measures for the entire property and addresses future uses for the entire property. RECREATION AEA SITE PLAN AND CURVILINEAR PARKING FOR RECREATION AREA - Approved by a vote of fi-l, subject to the following conditions: 1. The final site plan shall not be submitted for signature nor accepted for signature until the following conditions have been met a. Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan. b. Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) issuance of a commercial emrance permit to include a taper and right turn lane c. VDOT approval of a planting agreement for any landscape materials within the public road right-of-way; Page 2 January 23, 1998 d. Note on the plan that no outdoor lighting will be installed without Planning Commission approval. e. Engineering Department approval of a Stormwater Management Plan pursuant to Section 32.7.4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance. Planning staff approval of a landscape plan for recreation area. 2. Construction shall not be begun until approval has been obtained from the Board of Supervisors as required by section 5.1.14 of the zoning ordinance. END USE PLAN - Approved by a vote of 6-1, subject to the following conditions: The final site plan shall not be submitted for s~gnature nor accepted for signature until the following conditions have been met: a. Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan. b. Engineering Department approval of the location, design and operation of the tire wash facility to prevent off-site tracking of mud from unpaved roadways. c. Engineering Department approval of leachate containment measures for MSW transfer station Engineering Department approval of method of MSW transfer to ensure that transfer activity is enclosed so as to reduce wind-blown debris and exposure to precipitation, thereby minimizing the volume of leachate. Planning staff approval of strong measures to prevent uncovered vehicles from entering or ustng the landfill, including, but not limited to, approval ora sign regarding state law applicable to load covering vehicles. The sign shall be approved as to location and wording by the Planning staff and shall be considered as a sign as required by the Planning Commission under section 32.7.8.1 of the zoning ordinance. f. Planning staffapproval of landscaping/buffering measures of landfill improvements from Rte. 637; g. VDOT approval of a planting agreement for any landscape materials within the public road right-of-way; Page 3 January 23, 1998 h. Demonstration to the County Attorney of compliance with all applicable provisions of the Code of Virginia as related to cemeteries and places of burial of the dead. 2. The Board of Supervisors has reserved reconsideration of the transfer of CDD after 2 ½ years. The Board may require installation ora left turn lane to serve the site at that time or- at earlier date upon determination by VDOT that warrants have been satisfied. If you have any questions or comments regarding the above-noted action, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning RSK/jcf cc: Amelia McCulley Jack Kelsey Art Petrini Angeta Tucker COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Depax'anent of Plannin$ & Community Development MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Albemarle County. Planning Commission Ron Keeler, Chief of Plannlng'~ Janua~ 20, t998 IVY LANDFILL Tonight you will review SDP- 97- 110 Ivy Landfill End Use Final Site Plan. The purpose of this memo is to provide you background on the procedural handling of this site plan by this office. As a public project and based on prior Commission comments regarding public projects, procedures were altered. The site plan was reviewed by the Site Review Committee on October 23, 1997 and that meeting was attended by the public. There was some confusion about the time of the meeting and one member of the public missed the Committee's discussion but was provided copy of all written commerlts. Under the established review schedule, this site plan would have been before the Planning Commission on Tuesday of Thanksgiving week. Due to concern that holiday plans of the public may interfere with the schedule, the applicant ~Rivanna Solid Waste Authority (RSWA) agreed to a delayed schedule which would have placed the plan before the Commission on December 9, 1997. However, subsequent events delayed this schedule. Upon request, staffmet with several members of the Ivy Steering Committee for about three hours on the night of November 18, 1997. The Committee presented staffwith numerous concerns. Staff advised that: 1) Not all concerns could be addressed through the site plan regulations; and 2) The Zoning Administrator had determined that only a portion of the of the site and activities were subject to site plan review. Staff contacted the RSWA reg.arding the meeting with the Ivy Steering Committee and recommended the RSWA respond in writing to the written concerns of the Steering Committee, whether or not the concerns were subject to the site plan regulations. In order to provide adequate time to respond to the written concerns as well as to provide staff with additional evaluation time, RSWA agreed to a second delay to January 20, 1998. Attached to this memorandum are the list of issues from the Ivy Steering Committee as received by staff on November 18, 1997 together with responses to these issues from RSWA. Please review these documents before reading the Planning staff report. Attached to the Planning staffreport are letters fi'om individuals. Staffbelieves that issues raised in those letters are reflective of the Ivy Steering Committee's list ofissues. In dosing, staffhas approached development on the site plan report under the following: 1) The Board of Supervisors and City Council have endorsed the RSWA alternative "Option 7A" which the site plan seeks to reflect; 2) The site plan regulations are concerned with the physical development of land, not with the question of the uses permitted on the land In the event of site plan disapproval, the Commission must cite specific requirement(s) Which the plan falls to meet as well as instruct the applicant as to what changes to the plan would allow approval of the site plan; 3) Not all public concerns can be addressed through the site plan regulations. Most fill area operations and concerns of stormwater/water pollution are not subject to site plan regulation, but will be governed by the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality under its various regulatory requirements together with the Albemarle County Department of Engineering and Public Works under the Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control regulations to the applicable extent. The Engineering Department has been and will continue to be involved with issues of erosion control and stormwater disposition from this site. Memo to Robert W. Tucker, Jr. V. Wayne Cilimberg Date: November 10, 1997 Page: Agenda ltem No. 13. Presentation ftomNancyO'Brien, Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commissinn. a) Presentatmn of TJPDC Annual Report and Work Plan. Mrs. O'Brien made her presentation. b) Resolution restating Board's support of Thomas Jefferson Venture Regional Strategic Plan. Mrs. O'Brien will bring the resolution back to the Board for adoption. c) Resolution in support of Revised HOME Agreement. AUTHORIZED the County Executive to sign the consortium agreement afar a clause has been drafted by Mrs. O'Brien, and reviewed by the County Attorney, providing a 30-day written notice if a cunnty wishes to drop out because funding may be jeopardized. ~d Agenda Item No. 14. SP-97-30. U.S. Cellular Tower {Ivy) (Sign #69). Request to construct cellular telecommunications tower on 2 ac znd LI. TMSg,P37G. Located on S side of Morgantown Rd (Rt 738), approx l.l mis W of Rt 250, Ivy Rd. Samuel Miller District. (This site is not located in a designated growth area.) (Deferred from October lS, 1997.) ADOPTED the attached resolution denying the request. Agenda Item No, 15. Discussion: Ivy Landfill - Construction Demolition Debris (CDD). REAFFIRMED its support of the recommendations as outlined in the consultant's report for Option 7A. The Board indicated a willingneSs to reconsider the transfer of CDD after two and one-half years which is the time period Art Petrini indicated would take for the first phase oftbe next CDD cell Agenda Item No. 16. Cancel Board of Supervisors' meeting of November 19, 1997. CANCELED the meeting. Agenda Item No. 19. Executive Session: Legal Matters and Appointments to Boards and Commissions. At 12:50 p.m., the Board went into Executive Session. Agenda Item No. 20. ReconVt'ne and Certify Executive Session. At 4:13 p.m., the Board reconvened. The Ivy Steering Committee P. O. Box 6084 Charlottesville, Virginia 22906-6084 November 18, 1997 List of Issues for the Ivy Landfill Site Plan (Planning Commission Pubtic Hearing December 9, 1997) CDD: The site plan is incomplete. It does not show details of the CUD cells 4, 5, & 6 expansion areas of the facility. Final qrades (maximum elevations of 700 feet) and end dates across the site shou d be determined at this time. Final uses of the CDD areas should be shown on this site plan (is the cell 4 area to be a ski slop or a putting green)? The CDD operation is being continued as a fiscal solution. RSWA lacks the economy of scale to make the CDD operation a workable solution. VISUAL AND NOISE BUFFERS: Absolutely No more buffer trees Should be cut on the Ivy site. No construction should be allowed in the buffer area o~ the landfill. Clear language should be included in any site plan approval that will preclude the rswa from further violation of the buffers. NO boundary roads or anything else should be built in the buffers. Define "buffer" for the Authority. The site plan must show the proposed visual buffednq of the strict geometric forms that are: unlined cell ]; cell ;I lined; cell 2; unlined cell 3; cell 3 lined; and the current CDD areafrom all currently visible locations to the North, East, South and West. This site plan should include the scope, extent and details of off site plantinq areas that are required tO visually bUffer neighbors from the landfill. Example: If tree protection from horses is required on Tattershall Farm then it should be designed and provided by the RSWA and included as an integral part of this site plan. Noise Buffers and sound attenuation: The topoqraph¥ at the Ivy landfill amplifies the noise created On site and projects that noise into the neighborhood. Little noise can be heard on the landfill site, however off site, the noise ~s creating a health hazard that must be mitigated by engineered controls. Expansion areas can be seen from the entrance corridors 1-64. This is a clear violation of the solid waste regulations. MAXIMUM ELEVATIONS AND FINAL GRADES: The RSWA Board of Directors has agreed to limit elevations of the landfill to not more than 700 feet above Se~I~¥~L Final rnaximum qrades,for all areas of the landfill should be required on the site plan including the CDD areas to the north and the clean fill areas to the west. Temper and contour existinq slopes to reduce erosion dsk and require the creation of earthen berms for the planting of visual buffers on site. WESTERN BOUNDARY: No further fillinq should occur on the western boundary of the landfill due to the inability to control noise or the impact on surface waters and ground water. No fillinq on, or in the area of, existinq streams in the western area known as the borrow areas should be allowed to occur. The area shown to be clean fill to the southwest is a headwater spring for the reservoir. This sprinq is not shown on the site plan. This area should become a lake and not an area to be landfilled by this authority. RECREATIONAL AREAS: Show the extent of Gas Capture and Control system for both the pnmary and secondary gas capture systems. Include both Soccer and Rugby organizations as final uses of this site. REMEDIATION REOUIREMENTS: Gas Management: No real site plan of the gas capture system is shown. No stack elevation shown. No grading plan or infrastructure link to the gas management systems on site. No power generation tie in to the electrical grid shown. Storm Water and Erosion Control & Surface water remediation: Far too much water is directed to the western streams. Ground water remediation: No remediation facilities shown. Visual Buffers: Incomplete. Noise Buffers and controls: None shown. Wind BloWn Debris control: No building for transfer station. SEWER LINE: The sewer lirie scheduled for the 1-64 rest stop should be tied into the landfill site to deal with leachate that will' be produced for generation to come and to begin the infrastructure for the final uses of the site. ENTRANCE WASH RACK: There is no wash rock provide for the industrial activities proposed at this facility. The off site tracking of mud and solid waste and the air born clouds of dust at the main entrance has been and continues to be a health risk to the Ivy neighbors and any other citizen of the county that approaches the facility. MISCELLANEOUS: The site plan should becomes the leqal document defining the limits of industrial activities along with end use dates and final grades proposed to create the park. The site plan is labeled "End use Plan". It is NOT an end use plan since it does not show what will happen to the site when ALL landfitling has ceased. This plan should be entitled "Interim Use Plan ". These new cells will be a continuation of and an expansion of the landfilling area. The mandate should be given to the RSWA to proceed with the transfer of MSW and CDD to a privately operated facility that has a proven track record of safety and quality control and that is sited in an industrial area. This site plan does not Change the mandate of the rswa to major material recovery and away from landfilling. Set a date to stop landfilling. Your approval of this site plan will be your legacy tO the County of Albemarle. STORM WATER AND EROSION CONTROL: Do away with storm water ponds no longer required on the western boundary and temper the slopes to reduce off site siltation and reduce long term mai ntenance cost. A tremendous amount of water is beinq directed to the western streams. The western streams have already been impacted by the increased flow volume and energy of the water directed to this area. The western streams have been eroded by 2' and the Benthic community disrupted. Plans to restore the western streams should be included in the site plan. TRANSFER STATION: The transfer station is a continuation of an industrial activity takinq place in a qrowinq residential neiqhborhood. Locate a transfer station in a centrally located area of the County. The proposed location of the transfer station is immediately adiacent to the proposed recreational fields. It will very hard to buffer the dust, odor, sounds and s~ghts of industrial Transfer Operation and the Raw Food Waste Compost activities from the recreational activities. This is a plan to fail. Wind blown debris is currently a problem at the Blue bag area. Any transfer fa.cility needs to be enclosed, preferably in a building that would provide real control. Private companies such as the BFI facility at Zion's Crossroads are located in an industrial areas are environmentally and neighborhood friendly by being enclosed in a building and offering noise, odor, leachate and wind blown debris control. A s~te plan requirement to turn away any un-covered truck should be a condition of operation of the Ivy landfill facility, At the Ivy facility even the RSWA trucks are allowed to enter uncovered. Any transfer facility should be enclosed in a buildinq and well buffered from the neighbors and other uses of the site. The rswa will continually seek the cheapest of the cheap method to deal with solid waste i,e. in open trucks with no odor, or debris control. OTHER SOLID WASTE USES OF THE SITE: The site plan does not show any of the site to be used for yard waste, white goods, inert materials. We assume that none of these activities will occur on the Ivy site if not shown on the site plan. CEMETERIES: Access to and protection of the privately owned cemeteries located in the Ivy landfill are not shown on the site plan. APPENDIX Other Issues A. CDD: CDD 1. a. The site plan is incomplete. It does not show details of the CDD cells 4, 5, & 6 expansion areas of the facility. b. Final erades (maximum elevations of 700 feet) and end dates across the site should be determined at this time. Response: a. The details for the CDD Cell 4 have been completed and were recently submitted to DEQ for review. Tiffs includes final grades and cell configurations for Cell 4. The final grades are designed for 700 feet at exterior cell boundaries, after predicted settlement, and the estimated life is approximately 10 years. It is RSWA policy that limits f'mal grades to 700 feet at exterior cell boundaries after settlement. Only conceptual designs exist for future Cells 5 and 6. The Site Plan specifies no future uses other than the designated meadow for Cells 4, 5, and 6. b. The lifes of cells 5 and 6 are projected m be 30 years total, with a maximum elevation of 700 feet at exterior cell boundaries after settlement. The actual life depends on the density of the CDD in the cell, recovery of reusable/resalable items, and CDD tonnage per year. CDD 2. a. Final uses of the CDD areas should be shown on this site plan (is the cell 4 area to be a ski sloplsie] or a putting green)? b. The CDD operation is being continued as a fiscal solution. RSWA lacks the economy of scale to make the CDD operation a workable solution. Response: · There are no future uses designated for cells 4, 5, and 6 other than meadow as shown on the plan. b. The economic projections made by GBB indicate that given the current Authority and private facility locations and the current and projected private induslxy and RSWA costs, CDD processing, recovery and residual landfilling is economically feasible for RSWA. A key test of the GBB report was the confirmation of tip fee projections at a private CDD landfill through a recently issued Request for Proposal. B. VISUAL AND NOISE BUFFERS ("V&N"): V&N 1: Absolutely 1~o more buffer trees should be cut on the Ivy site. 0402-005 A-I Response: Any additional removal fi.om the DEQ-required buffer zone, supplemented by the RSWA voluntary buffer zones will be limited to that requir~ by regnlations and/or to protect punic health and safety (such as installation of additional monitoring wells) and/or as dictated by proper forest management. V&N 2 a.: No construction should be allowed in the buffer area of the landfill. Clear language should be included in any site plan approval that will preclude the RSWA from further violation of the buffers. No boundary roads or anything else should be built in the buffers. b. Define "buffer" for the Authority. Response: a. New landfill construction within the DEQ or voluntary buffer zones is not planned. Please refer to response to previous issue. b. Required buffer areas are those required by law, 50 feet fi.om property lines and 100 feet fi.om streams. Voluntary buffer areas are areas that RSWA will impact to the minimal extem possiblei this buffer adds from 50 feet to 360 feet where applied. V&N 3: The site plan must show the proposed visual buffering of the strict geometric forms that are: unlined cell 1; cell I lined; cell 2; unlined cell 3; cell 3 lined; and the current CDD area from all currently visible locations to the North, East, South, and West. Response: Significant efforts have been made and will continue to be made to reduce the visual impacts of the site, including proposed off-site plantings, improvements of the enrranceway and buildings, and plantings on site and in the buffer zone V&N 4: This site plan should include the scope, extent and details of off-site planting areas that are required to visually buffer neighbors from the landfill. Example: If tree protection from horses is required on Tattershall Farm then it should he designed and provided by the RSWA and included as an integral part of this site plan. Response: RSWA received bids for plantings to be installed on properties designated by the Ivy Steering Committee. It was anticipated that these plantings would occur during the fall of 1997. The IW Steering Committee decided that it would be advantageous to wait until either the spring or fall of 1998 to have those plantings take place. A commiunent of $1 $,000 has been made by the RSWA for these plantings which will occur with special assistance from Land Planning and Design Associates. It is anticipated that the plantings will have a one-year guarantee with each owner responsible for their watering. 0402~005 A-2 V&N 5: Noise Buffers and sound attenuation: The tono~raphv at the Iw landfill amplifies the noise created on site and projects that noise into the neighborhood. Little noise can be heard on the landfill site, however off site, the noise is creating a health hazard that must be mitigated by engineered controls. Response: Operations are within regulatory requirements for noise. A significant amount ofthe noise from current activities is associated with landfilling municipal solid waste (MSW), which includes the use of compaction equ~pmem. MSW landfilling is an activity which RSWA plans to discontinue once the transfer station is up and running (summer, 1998). CDD and clean-fill landfilting are less heavy equipment-intensive, because the same de~ree and type of compaction is not required. To the RSWA's knowledge, no data exists to demonstrate that the site amplifies noise or creates a health hazard. V&N 6: Expansion areas can be seen from the entrance corridors 1-64. This is clear violation of the solid waste regulations. Response: The RSWA is not in violation of the State solid waste regulations with respect to site visibility. DEQ staff have referred us to Section $.l.A.7.d on page v~3 of the State solid waste regulations, which requires I000 feet except where screened so as not to be visible. Screening can be fi'om natural objects, such as trees, which exist between the state highway and the landfill. Activity in the proposed CDD Cell 4 will be screened from the highway. However, to secure additional buffer area, the P, SWA recently purchased 11 acres adjacent to I~te. 1-64. C. MAXIMUM ELEVATIONS AND FINAL GRADES ("GRADES"): GRADES 1: The RSWA Board of Directors has agreed to limit elevations of the landfill to not more than 700 feet above sea level, Final maximum grades for all areas of the landfill should be required on the site plan ineinding the CDD areas to the north and the clean fill areas to the west. Response: All areas covered by the site plan show elevations. The Cell #4 elevation, which was set by the RSWA, will not exceed 700 feet above sea level at its exterior cell boundaries a~ter settling. D. WESTERN BOUNDARY ("WEST"): WEST 1: No further filling should occur on the western boundary of the landfill 6ue to the inability to control noise or the imoaet on surface waters and ground water. 0402-005 A-3 Response: Operations are within regulatory requirements for noise. A significant amount of the noise fi.om current activities is associated with land_filling municipal solid waste (MSW), which includes the use of compaction equipment. MSW landfilling is an activity which RSWA plans to discontinue once the transfer station is up and running. CDD and clean-fill landfilling are less heavy equipment-intensive, because the same degree and type of compaction is not required. Another source of current noise is the use of a rock hammer in CDD Cell 4. This activity will end by January 1998. Regarding surface water impacts: Existing slopes have akeady been planted and stabilized, and both the DEQ and the County Erosion Control Officer have inspected them and found them satisfactory. Both CDD and clean fill areas utilize "best managemc~nt practices" to prevent erosion and control runoff. In the RSWA's submittal to the Planning Commission, several sheets show details of the berm grading and plantings, including L1, L3, L5, L6, L8, LI7, LIS, L19, L20, L22, L26, L27, and L28. Regarding groundwater impacts: Because of the nature of CDD, as well as the construction of those facilities (lining and leachate collection), there should be not impacts to ground water fi.om that activity. Clean fill materials are, by regulatory definition, inert and clean, and should not ~mpact groundwater quality. WEST 2: a. No filling on, or in the area of, existing streams in the western area known as the borrow areas should be allowed to occur. b. The area shown to be clean ~l to the southwest is a headwater spring for the reservoir. This shrine is not shown on the site plan. This area should become a lake and not an area to be landffiled by this Authori~. Response: Because it is outside the Site Plan area, the spring box in the southwest comer of the site is not labeled specifically. That spring has been diverted by pipe to a nearby stream for over a year. Plans call for upgrading that pipe to allow for the placement of non-re~alated clean fill in the long-term future. E. REMEDIATION REQUIREMENTS ("REM"): REM 1: Gas Management: a. No real site plan of the gas capture system is shown. c. No grading plan or infrastructure link to the gas management systems on site. Response: a. The submission of ~e Gas Management ?lan Environmental Quality indicates the linkage and throughout the site leading to a gas management unit. to the Deparunc~nt of the distribution of pipe 0402-005 The gas capture system is below grade so the grades shown on the plan are applicable to the question of a grading plan. The submission of the Gas Management Plan to the Department of Environmental Quality indicates the linkage and the distribution of pipe throughout the site lead'mg to a gas management unit. REM 2: Storm Water and Erosion Control & Surface Water Remediation: Far too much water is directed to the western streams. Response: Existing slopes have already been planted and stabilized, and both the DEQ and the County Erosion Control Officer have inspected them and found them satisfactory. Both CDD and clean fill areas utilize "best management practices" to prevent erosion and control runoff In the RSWA's submittal to the Planning Commission, several sheets show details of the berm grading and plantings, including L1, L3, LS, L6, L8, L17, L18, L19, L20, L22, L26, L27, and L28. Stormwater basins discharge water at locations in the north, south, east, and west of the site. REM 3: Ground water remediation: No remediation facilities shown. Response: The groundwater remediation facility is outside of the Site Plan area, so is not shown in detail. However, it is shown on drawing L-26, in the lower left comer, as a small rectangle just to the upper right of the leachate pond, among some proposed new plantings and adjacent to an existing road. In addition, sheet LDMSP shows and labels the facility. REM 4: Visual Buffers: Incomplete. Response: Significant efforts have been made to reduce the visual impacts of the site, including improvements of the entranceway and buildings, and plantings along the entrance way and the buffer zone. In addition, an offer has been made to the Ivy Steering Committee for plantings to take place on properties no! adjacent to the landfill to enhance the visual screening. Although the western part of the site is outside the Site Plan area, the location of cluster plantings is shown, as well as front entrance improvements. REM 5: Noise Buffers and Controls: None shown. Response: Operations are within regulatory requirements for noise. A significant amount of the noise from currem activities is associated with tandfilling municipal solid waste, which includes the use of compaction equipment. MSW landfilling is an activity which RSWA plans to discontinue once the transfer station is up and running. CDD 0402-005 A-5 and clean-fill landfilling are less heavy equipmentqntensive, because the same degree and type of compaction is not required. REM 6: Wind Blown Debris control: No building for transfer station. Response: The method of transferring waste fi'om collection vehicles to transfer vehicles (the transfer itself is enclosed within the body of the trailer) minimizes the potential for wind-blown debris. The grounds will be maintained daily. F. ENTRANCE WASH RACK: There is no wash rack provide for the industrial activities proposed at this facility. The off site tracking of mud and solid waste and the air born clouds of dust at the main entrance has been and continues to be a health risk to the Ivy neighbors and any other citizen of the county that approaches the facility. Response: Site Wash Rack - Although the tire wash facilities are outside of the Site Plan and therefore are not shown, the un/t has arrived on site and has been installed. G. MISCELLANEOUS ("MISC"): MISC 3: The mandate should be given to the RSWA to proceed with the transfer of MSW and CDD to a privately operated facility that has a proven track record of safeW and quality control and that is sited in an industrial area. Response: Under its existing mandate, the RSWA Board has made, and will continue to make, decisions about the management of solid waste, while providing for broad public input and information. MSW transfer is part of the Site Plan. The RSWA CDD operation, which is not parr of the Site Plan, was carefully examined for cost effectiveness in comparison to transfer of CDD to a privately operated facility. The result of that comparison was a decision to maintain CDD disposal in its proposed location (Cell 4). MISC 4: This site plan does not Change the mandate of the RSWA to major material recovery and away from landfilling. Set a date to stop landfilling. The RSWA has a number of programs taking place that minimize landfilling at the Ivy Landfill, as well as other facilities it manages. The Ivy Landfill grinds almost 10,000 tons of vegetative and yard waste in pallets into mulch on an annual basis. White goods are collected and recycled along with other metals that are brought to the site. The RSWA operates an Encore Center, a facility that reclaims discarded 0402-005 A-6 materials, and resells those materials back to the public or gives them to non-profit organizations. Tires are collected at the facility and shipped to be reused or recycled. Reusable pallets are sold in the market place back to a vendor who utilizes them. Wet-stream materials are received and compostod rather than landfilled. The Authority has purchased a conveyor from which it will begin in the near future, through selected CDD loads, to recover items such as corrugated cardboard, wood and metals. The Authority salvages logs from the incoming vegetative waste and ships them to local mills for lumber. The Authority operates, an conjunction with the County, a blue bag and newspaper drop-off center at the facility and collects hazardous household wastes wkich are destroyed, reused, or recycled. The Authority also operates Mclntire Recycling Center which is a residential drop-off area for newspaper, corrugated cardboard, file stock, boxboard, glass, aluminum, steel cans, textiles, organic waste, and phone books. We also have a reusable center for craft- type materials, and a book exchange center. The Paper Sort operates as a commemial facility, accepting file stock, corrugated, boxboard, and newspaper. The Authority also administers a contract whereby leaves collected are composted by a local farmer. The Authority's commitment to recycling is strong and expanding. These efforts, together with the decision to transfer out all MSW, will lead by the end of 1998 to a 60% decrease in landfilling on a tonnage basis. Tkis is a conservative figure because it does not include recoverables from the CDD. H. STOR.M WATER AND EROSION CONTROL ("E&SC"): E&SC 1: Do away with storm water ponds no longer required on the western boundary and temper the slopes to reduce off site siltation and reduce long term maintenance cost. Response: All of the existing storm water ponds, sediment basins and other best management practices are required by regulations. E&SC 2: A tremendous amount of water is being directed to the western streams. The western streams have already been impacted by the increased flow volume and energy of the water directed to this area. The western streams have been eroded by 2' and the Benthic community disrupted. Plans to restore the western streams should be included in the site plan. Response: The Authority has recently removed the major source of water flowing out of the basin below Cell #2 to the western streams. This spring, which is showing signs of contamination, is being diverted into the leachate management system. Malcolm Pimie, a RSWA consultant, has studied the streams in and around the landfill and has recommended stream improvements that RSWA is currently undertaldng. 0402-005 A-7 I. TRANSFER STATION: A site plan requirement to turn away any un-covered truck should be a condition of operation of the ivy landfill facility. At the Ivy facility even the RSWA trucks are allowed to enter uncovered. Response: Enforcement of the uncovered or unsecured load regulation is a responsibility of the police. The Authority has encouraged the police to enforce this regulation. The RSWA covers its own loaded vehicles leaving or entering the site. To assist in this matter, a sign will be erected at the entrance referencing the State law on covered/secured loads. J. OTHER SOLID WASTE USES OF THE SITE: The site plan does not show any of the site to be used for yard waste, white goods, inert materials. We assume that none of these activities will occur on the Ivy site if not shown on the site plan. Response: Disposal of inert debris is not within the Site Plan area, but is shown as Clean Fill, in the southwest comer of the site. Management of yard waste and white goods are generally mobile, and move around the site in the proximity of the working fill area. K. CEMETERIES: Access to and protection of the privately owned cemeteries located in the Ivy landfill are not shown on the site plan. Response: All of the property shown within the boundaries of the site are the property of the RSWA, not private owners. Although we have found no physical evidence of cemeteries, the Site Plan does not show activiw in or development of those areas about which we are aware of a concern. In any event, we will meet all regulations concermng cemeteries. 0402-005 Set One: Transfer TraiLers Picture 1. These pictures show a "bare bones" facility. Picture one shows a concrete pad running back to a concrete loading dock. A shipping tractor will back a van- trailer onto the concrete pad and place the rear of the trailer against the loading dock. Picture 2, This is the view from the opposite side of the previous picture of the loading dock. The refuse collection vehicle will access the top of the dock by driving up this inexpensive earth ramp covered with stone Picture 3. Here we see the van-trailer with its rear opening against the loading dock. Notice the last twelve feet of this forty-five foot long trailer. The top (roof) hydraulically opens so as to act as a litter screen when the refuse is unloaded into the back of the trailer when not under roof. Picture 4. The rear of the trailer abuts the loading dock with the floor of the trailer actually above the loading dock's surface so as to afford quicker and cleaner loading. Picture 5. The feature that makes these van-trailers unique is the rear twelve feet. Specifically, this last section widens from a typical 96 inches (8 feet) to 116 inches (9.7 feet). Hydraulically, the rear 'Mdens twenty inches to allow for easier reception of material being hydraulically pushed out ora refuse collection vehicle. Typical collection vehicles span 96 inches across in the rear. Hence, the extra twenty inches provides a needed amount of space to minimize spillage and allows easier access for the driver of the unloading vehicle. Picture 6. A refuse collection vehicle is backing up to the "mouth" of the van-trailer. Picture 7, 8 & 9. Notice that the refuse vehicle's tailgate has been raised approximately 156 inches offthe floor and extends out and over the top Of the van-trailer. Because the refuse collection vehicle sits atop the loading dock, the vehicle has a 52 inch height advantage over the trailer, allowing the t. ailgate to easily slip up and over the van- trailer. Picture 10. As with the trailers that unload the wood bulking agents for the Water and Sewer Authority's sludge compost, these trailers also have "walking floors." The metal floor boards are set in such a way that it provides a "push-pull" effect, causing the material loaded onto it to quickly move to the "nose" of the van-trailer. Picture 11. A loaded trailer can hold approximately twenty tons. The total length of the trailer can run from 45 to 53 feet in length; its cargo compartment is approximately 8 feet 7 inches high and eight feet wide Iwith the final twelve feet expm~dable up to another twenty inches). Although a relatively new piece of equipment on the market, ten jurisdiction are now using them. Il} 11 STAFF PERSON: RON KEELER PLANNING COMMISSION: JANUARY 20, 1998 (SDP-97-110) IVY LANDFILL END USE FINAL SITE PLAN Proposal: Proposal for improvements to existing landfill to effectuate "end use" plan including establishment of municipal solid waste (MSW) transfer station, waste-to-compost facility, active and passive gas venting systems and improvements to recycling/reuse facilities. Construction and demolition debris (CDD) would continue to be disposed on-site. In addition, grading and other improvements for conversion ora portion of the site to public recreational use is depicted on the plan. Property, described as Tax Map 73, Parcel 28, consists of 297.2 acres zoned RA Rural Areas and EC Entrance Corridor Overlay District, is situated on the northwest side of Dick Woods Road (Rte. 637) about one mile east of Taylor's Gap Road (Rte. 708) in the Samuel Miller Magisterial District. The site is also adjacent to 1-64, an EC roadway, however the area subject to site plan review will not be visible fi:om 1-64 and therefore, approval of the ARB is not required. This site is located in the watershed of the South Fork Rivanna River Reservoir. This site is not located in a designated development area (See Attachments A & B for location and parcel maps). Reason for Planning Commission Review: This site plan has been referred to the Planning Commission as a public project of significant public interest. Approval of the plan also requires review of thc recreation area for compliance with thc Comprehensive Plan. Foreword: Due to opposition to continued usage of the Ivy landfill, the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority developed various alternatives for phased discontinuance of the site as a landfill. In Spring, 1997, the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors and the Charlottesville City Council endorsed "Option 7A," which calls for transfer of municipal solid waste (MSW) to another landfill and continued on-site disposal of construction and demolition debris (CDD). The Board of Supervisors again discussed Option 7A as it relates to on-site disposal of CDD on November 7, 1997 and reaffirmed its prior commitment to Option 7A. The Board has reserved the right to revisit the issue following completion of Cell 4 in about 2 ½ years. Recreational development of a portion of the site would be a cooperative effort between the RSWA and the Albemarle County Department of Parks and Recreation. Both changes to the landfill operation and the recreational development are presented on one site plan, however, the proposals should be viewed as independent (For more detail on "End Use" plan, see Attachment D). STAFF_ COMM~ Due to public concern regarding this proposal, the "staff comment" section of the report will address each applicable section of 32.0 SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN of the Zoning Ordinance. It should be noted that not all concerns can be addressed through the site plan regulations. The Zoning Administrator has determined that no site plan approval is required for the CDD fill activity; compliance with the Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Ordinance as well as DEQ regulation is required. This is consistent with prior decision regarding site plan review of the Cove Creek Park under which the building, parking, and like hnprovements were subjected to site plan regulation while baseball field development was subject to erosion and stormwater regUlations of the Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Ordinance (Attachment E). 32.7.1 Comprehensive Plan: Section 15.2- 2232 of the Code of Virginia requires that public projects be reviewed for consistency with the local Comprehensive Plan. Establishment of recreational uses at the landfill constitutes a change of use which requires the Planning Commission determination of compliance with the Comprehensive Plan. This project received prior Planning Commission review as a project in the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) for FY 1998/99- 2002/03 and the CIP is currently under consideration by the Board of Supervisors. In assessing this project for compliance with the Comprehensive Plan, staff has utilized the: --- Albemarle County Community Facilities Plan 1990-2000, --- CIP funding request (Attachment F), and --- November 18, 1997 memorandum from the Director of Parks and Recreation (Attachment G) The Community Facilities Plan, an element of the Comprehensive Plan, provides a framework for review and planning of governmental services including police, fire and rescue, schools, libraries, parks and recreation, general governmental administration/services and solid waste facilities. The plan contains nine overall facility objectives of which staffbelieves six to be relevant to this review (Starred items on Attachment H). Staff recommends that the proposal in consistent with Objectives 1, 5.7, 8 and 9. Objective 2 recommends that new facilities be confined to designated development areas. While recreational use of this site would constitute a new use, the property has been in public ownership for many years and there is no site acquisition cost involved in the conversion (See Objective 9, Attachment H). Also, much of the site could be devoted to a natural area/nature trail usage in the furore. As to the specifies of this site, there are two factors that warrant consideration. Firstly, access to the site from 1-64 is good since Route 637 has been improved between the interstate highway and 2 the site. However, access from the Ivy area is by Route 637, which north of 1-64 has not been improved. Route 637 south of the site is currently a gravel road which is scheduled for improvement in fail, 1998. Secondly, a portion of the site has been subjected to fill operation. Section 5.1.14 of the Zoning Ordinance requires that "no improvements shall be constructed in or upon any landfill for a period of twenty (20) years after the termination of the landfill operation without prior approval of the board of supervisors" and provides context for Board review (Attachment I). At this time, the gas capture/venting system(s) has not been approved by the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality and staff is unable to recommend that the proposed recreational use is consistent with the requirements of section 5.1.14. Staff recommends that allocation be made but that no County expenditure occur until the Board has made positive finding under section 5.1.14 of the Zoning Ordinance. Field sports generally require relatively large sites for the intensity of use and adequate sites within designated development areas are difficult m achieve due to land costs and proximity of surrounding residential development (Opposition was experienced to Darden Towe Park, recreational improvements at Albemarle High School and establishment of recreational areas at Monticello High School). The immediate need for additional sports fields has been identified by the Department of Parks and Recreation. Staff recommends that the proposed conversion from discontinued landfill m recreational use represents: a) un opportanity for cost-effective use/reuse of public land b) with no site acquisition costs and c) which helps meet an identified need for field sports. Staff recommends that the proposed recreational use is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. 32.7.2 Safe and Convenient Access. Parking. Pedestrian Ways: 32.7.3 Streets and Roads: For the new entrance to the recreational area, VDOT will require a taper and tttm lane for right roms into the site. As to the existing entrance serving the landf'fll, the right turn lane is m place. VDT has recommended that: A left tuna lane should be provided to serve the site. With improvements scheduled to begin in the fall of 1998 for Route 637 west of this site m Route 635, traffic volumes are certain to increase with improved access to the western part of the County. A left turn lane will provide a much safer access to the site. 3 The County Department of Engineering has commented that: This item need not be addressed for site plan approval. While a left turn lane serving both entrances to the landfill would certainly improve safety, and we support the recommendation from VDT, most traffic entering the recreation area entrance is anticipated to come from 1-64, and a left mm lane does not appear to be warranted. Staff agrees that'new' traffic would be generated by the recreational area, but does not believe that improvement to Rte. 637 would appreciably increase traffic to the landfill. Given doubts about traffic, staff would recommend that left turn lanes not be required at this rune. The Board has reserved review of the landfill operation in about 2 ½ years and further evaluation of access to the landfill could be provided at that time. A left turn lane into the recreation area could be provided by the County at any time, if warranted, however a right mm lane into the recreational area should be provided with initial development. Roadways to the transfer facility and other areas accessed by the general public will be paved. A wheel washing facility has recently been installed between dirt road areas and the paved roadway. 32.7.4 Drainage: Stormwater Management: SoilErosion: Staff would emphasize that this site is subject to regulation by the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality. While the landfilling operations are not subject to site plan review, the Engineering Department provides review and regulation through the Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Ordinance on an on- going basis. The Engineering Department is reviewing the Stormwater Polhition Prevention Plan developed by RSWA consultants and required by DEQ. Engineering has previously provided comments to the consultant (Attachment J). 32.7.5 Water. Sewer and Other Utilities: Tkis property is within a jurisdictioual area of the Albemarle County Service Authority for public sewer (Attachment K). Public sewer has been considered as a method of transporting leachate, which is currently disposed of through pump- and-haul method. The consultant for RSWA has estimated the cost of extension of public sewer to the site to be significantly higher than on-site methods of disposal (Attachment L). Staff recommends that, based on zoning ordinance criteria, public sewer is not 'reasonably available' (Attachment M). The MSW transfer facility will be designed for leachate containment. Conditions of approval will require Engineering Department approval of leachate containment as well as transfer method to ensure that transfer operations will be enclosed. 32.7.6 Fire Protection: The gas management/venting system(s) will require permitting by DEQ, which includes fire safety measures. Staffhas already recommended that no expenditure occur for recreational development until the gas venting system has been approved by DEQ and evaluation of safety issues has been provided to the Board of Supervisors (RSWA anticipates 4 DEQ permitting in March, 1998). 32.7.8 Signs and Lighting: Signage must comply with zoning regulations. RSWA has agreed to posting of a 'reminder' sign that haul vehicles are to have covered loads. Lighting will be situated around buildings but will not be used under normal operations. A note reflecting zoning ordinance requirements for lighting has been added to the site plan. 32.7.9 Landscaping and Screening: Since parking areas are internally located, no landscaping measures will be required for the recreational facility. The RSWA has voluntarily submitted landscaping proposals for the discontinued cells. Due to DEQ restrictions related to cap maintenance, extensive landscaping cannot be provided on-site. The RSWA has offered $15,000 of landscaping stock to adjoining property owners for landscaping on their properties. RSWA does not believe that new improvements will be visible from immediately adjoining properties. Site section drawings will be presented at the Planning Commission meeting. Staff will require effective landscaping/buffering from Rte. 637 for landfill improvements. SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION In summary, while staff has been mindful of public concerns in development of recommended conditions of approval of the site plan, not all issues of concern can be addressed through site plan review. The Virginia Department of Environmental Quality and the County Department of Engineering have been and will continue to be involved review of the landfall for some matters not addressable by the site plan regulations. The issue of continuance of various activities of the landfill have been discussed by the RSWA Board, City Council and the Board of Supervisors. The Board of Supervisors reaffirmed its commitment to "Option 7A" in early November, 1997. The following addresses various items reqmring Planning Commission action: Comprehensive Plan: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission find the recreational use to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Curvilinear parking for recreational area: Curvilinear parking in the recreation area is responsive to topography and grading limitations related to cell cap preservation. Staff recommends that the Commission anthorize curvilinear parking in accord with section 4.12.6.5 (c) of the zoning ordinance. Recreation Area Site Plan: Staff recommends approval of the site plan as it pertains to recreational use subject to the following conditions: 1. The final site plan shall not be submitted for signature nor accepted for signature until the following conditions have been met: a) Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan; b) VDOT issuance ora commercial entrance permit to include a taper and right turn Lane; c) VDOT approval ora planting agreemem for any landscape materials within the public road right-of-way; d) Note on the plan that no outdoor lighting will be installed without Planning Commission approval. 2. Construction shall not be begun until approval has been obtained by the Board of Supervisors as required by section 5.1.14 of the zoning ordinance. Ivy Landfill End Use Plan: The CDD and other fill cells do not require site plan approval. These conditions of approval are applicable to the landfill entrance and circulation, encore center, improvements, compsting area, and MSW transfer station. Staff recommends approval of the site plan as it pertains to the RSWA landfill operation subject to the following conditions: I. The final site plan shall not be submitted for signature nor accepted for stgnature until the following conditions have been met: a) Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan; b) Engineering Department approval of the location, design and operation of the tire wash facility to prevent off-site tracking of mud from unpaved roadways; c) Engineering Department approval ofleachate containment measures for MSW transfer station; d) Engineering Department approval of method of MSW transfer to ensure that transfer activity is enclosed so as to reduce wind-blown debris and exposure to precipitation, thereby minimizing the volume of leachate; Planning staff approval of a "reminder" sign regarding state law applicable to load covering of vehicles. The sign shall be approved as to location and wording by the Planning staffand shall be considered as a sign as required by the Planning 6 Commission under section 32.7.8.1 of the zoning ordinance; f) Planning staff approval of landscaping/buffering measures of landfill improvements from Rte. 637; g) VDOT approval of a planting agreement for any landscape materials w/thin the public road right-of-way; h) Demonstration to the County Attorney of compliance w/th all applicable provisions of the Code of Virginia as related to cemeteries and places of burial of the dead. 2. The Board of Supervisors has reserved reconsideration of the transfer of CDD after 2 ½ years. The Board may require installation ora left mm lane to serve the site at that time or at earlier date upon determination by VDOT that warrants have been satisfied. ATTACHMENTS A- Location Map B- Parcel Map C- no attachment D- RSWA "Narrative for the Ivy Landfill" E- Zoning Administrator Official Determination of Use, March 24, 1997 RSWA Description of Use, March 17, 1997 F- CIP- Ivy Landfill Recreation Access Development G- Memorandum from Director of Parks and Recreation, November 18, 1997 H- Excerpts from Community Facilities Plan I- Section 5.1.14- Zoning Ordninance J- Letter from Engineering Department to RSWA, January 8, 1998 K- Letter from Planning to RSWA, December 13, 1995 M- Section 32.7.5.1- Zoning Ordinance N- Letters received from public \ o \ TOP SDP 97-110 Ivy L~dflll End U~ ALBEMARLE OOUNTY IATTACHMENT E IPagel'~ 72 SDP 97-110 Ivy Landtal End Uae / ¢ ~,, \ · 87 SAMUEL MILLER AND WHITE HALL DISTRICTS SEGTION 73 Narrative for the Ivy Landfill I ATTACHMENT£ IPage~ Thc Rivanna Solid Wasle Authority (RSWA) was formcd in 19go to providc solid v,"aste disposat and recycling services to its member jurisdictions, Its member jurisdictiuns are the City of Charlottesville and the County of Albemarle including the Town of Scottsville. Its original primary function was the operation of the Ivy Landfill which for many years had been operated under a joint agreement between the City of Charlottesville and the County of Albemarle. The Ivy Landfill islocated off Route 637 approximately 12 miles wesl of Charlottesville, This site encompasses just over 300 acres of which is equally divided between developed, disturbed, and virgin lands. The site has historically accepted municipal solid waste {MSW), construction demolition debris (CDD), and friable asbestos. The RSWA currently has one administration and three operational locations with 30 employees. Administrative functions are carried out in a facifity jointl~ operated bythe RSWA and the Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority (RWSA) located on Franklin Street just outside the City of Charlottesville. Operational locations are the Ivy Landfttl. the Paper Sort. and Mclntire Recycling Center. Ivy. Sanitary Landfill The ivy Sanita~ Landfill currently accepts approximately 250 tons of mtmicil~l solid waste (MSW) and 100 tons of construction demolition debris ~'CDD) per day. All waste materials entering the l vy Landfill are first weighed before entering the facility and then weighed again, upon leaving the facility with a cost affixed to it {based on the tip fee/. MS;W is generated from residential, commercial and institutional facilities within the service area. This material is currently being filled in Cell 3 (unlined) which is scheduled to be completed by July. 1998. Construction and demolition material is buried in a separate pomon of the facility. The material is scavenged for reusable materials ~cl~ as doors, windows, and recyclabte metals. During the last twelve months, the RSWA has recycled over 1.000 tons of metal from this area of the facility. In addition, the RSWA ooerates an Encore Center which is a facility where usable materials such as the doors and windows arc sold to the general public or given away to charities. Any materials not utilized in the Encore Center are shipped to a salvage yard in Richmond for sale as reusable materials. Yard waste and vegetative debris are segregated in a special location in this area of the Landfill. When a sufficient amount of this material is stockpiled, it is ground into mulch. Mulch is either given away to individuals who hand load the material, sold to individuals who have it loaded in their vehicles by the RSWA. or sold to individuals who have it delivered to their location by the RSWA. The pallets (which are not sold for reuse) and crates that are delivered to the site are ground into a bulking agent which is utilized by the RWSA in its sludge composting operations, Marketable logs are sold to local lumber mills. The fi'iable asbestos accepted at the landfill is placed in a roll-off container, and when full. transported to a permitted asbestos disposal facility. White goods are accepted and are recycled following the extraction of I ATTACHPIENT D I Page 2 CFC'sand HCFC's (gases) as required. A small pilot composting program is also underway at the facility. This program has been most successful by producing a soil enhancer and diverting tans of waste from burial. Wood chips generated by the RSWA arc used as a bulking agent for thc residue vcgctable materials that are composted. The Landfill recycling drop-off location is used primarily by waste haulers (plus a small number of citizens) to drop off blue bags and newspaper products. The blue 0ags are transported under a private contracl by the County of Albemarle and the newspaper is transported by the RSWA under contract with thu County of Albemarle. Once a month (9 months per yeur) the RSWA operates a household hazardous waste collection day. This servtce is provided to the citizens of City of Charlottesville and the County of Albemarle at no cost to them. It allows them to dispose of materials which serve to harm the environment if improperly disposed, The site has had approximately 88 acres filled with waste. Cull 1 and 2 are closed along with a former brush disposal area. Closure activities consisting of placemant ofa geosynthctic clay liner and two feet of soil with a vegetative cover have been recently completed on the slopes of Cell 3 (unlined~ and Cell 3 (lined) which comprises 21 acres, The site has a passive gas venting system in place. However. the passive vents are directed through activated carbon filters which absorb much of the volatile organic compounds and the odors associated with normal passive gas venting. Leachate, which is the contaminated liquid generated from a landfill, is collected in a leachate pond. This pond was completely relined during the '~ rater of 1996. Thc lenchate is transported by tank truck to the Moores Creek Sewage Treatment Plant tbr processing. FUTURE RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY ACTIVITIES The RSWA is in a period oftransitieu. During the next eight months the RSWA will be working diligently towards establishing itself as a new operating entity. The RSWA will be enhancing its recycling and reuse activities as well as continuing ~ts composting, transfer and CDD processing/disposal programs at the Landfill. The RSWA will also administer two municipal solid waste transfer and disposal contracts. Construction The start of construction of the waste-to-compost facility ~s projected for fall. 1997. This primarily involves the paving af the former asbestos/CDD area at!iacent to me administrative building at the Ivy Landfill. Included in this construction will be a pole-barn style building, scheduled for early 1998. which will be used for the mixing of the raw material with bulking agents. The asphalt area will include a compost loading unit as well as the cun~vost bags (6'H x 10'W x 200'L) and active aeration system. Curing will also take place there along with screening. I ATTACHMENT D~ IP. age 31 It is anticipated that the transfer station Will bi: built in April. 1998. This loading dock style transfer station will be operational by July, 1998. It will be equipped with a leachate eolleetion system as required by the DEQ and be aqiacent Io the waste-lo-compost operations. The grading for Cell 4 will commence during the fall of 1997. Grading includes the addition of fill material to Cell 4 as well as the building of a single lane access road and the installation ora leachate trunk line. Lining of the Cell will take place in the spring of 1998 with an openingfor operations by July, 1998. The gas management treatment facility is currently under study with a recommendation to be made at the July 28 RSWA Board meeting. In 1998. the RSWA will be installing gas collection wells on Cell 3 (lined'~ and a small portion of Cell 3 (unlined), The active extraction unit will be installed in 1998 to connect with Cells 1.2. and 3 (lined). During the fall of 1998. Cell 3 (unlinedl as well as the CDD area will also have wells installed and be connected into the active gas collection system. Ivy. Landfill End Use End use is an ongoing process being developed with the RSWA and its consultants with public input. The final Site Plan will be submitted to the County of Albemarle in October with an anticipated approval received in late fall of 1997. The RSWA is already beginning to construct eells in a manner that facilitates the ~ preliminary) final use for the site. All passive/recreational uses will be developed in coordination with the County. Actual constru~;tion, tirnelines and funding are County responsibilities. It is anticipated that the central portion of the closed Landfill will be used for field play, To the east of the proposed fields is undeveloped virgin lands that can be used for nature hiking trails. The park will be maintained by the RSWA for thc County of Albemarle under an agreement. It is anticipated that the facility fields will primarily be utilized for soccer and possibl? lacrosse. Nature trails will be rural and not overly developed. A central road with fencing on a berm will divide theongoing solid waste activities from the recreational activities. The central road will also be oaved to limit dust from ongoing activities. The Authority will. as a regular part of its closure activities, grade the playing fields as shown on the site plan. The Authority will also grade the entrance roadway from approximately Station 3+00 to its terminus in the northern most parking area. The Authority will also create the planting berms and install the planting for screening around the public access areas and will stabilize the finished surfaces with grass. Additionally, the Authority wilt install the active gas collection system under the athletic fields and all necessary and required drainage swales, ditches, p~pes and related elements as shown on the site plan. Phase I implementation will be by the Albemarle County Department of Parks and Recreation, during which they will complete the entrance roadway from Route 637 to its connection point, at approximately Station 3+00. Phase I development, and beyond, will be contingent upon available funding. One option j ATTACHt4ENT D i l Page 41 may be application to VDOT for recreation access funding for the completion of the new access roadway. The Department will also develop tot-lot areas and provide any goals and related appurtenances as may be desired by them. For the eastern portion of the site. the natural area. the Department will. from time to time. make various improvements to pathways ant other elements to more readily facilitate public access and use of that area. The Authority will maintain the areas through the regular mowing of grass and the correction of any settlement that occurs in the area of the athletic fields. Building Code Information (804) 296-5832 COUNTY OF ALBEMARI E Depar~ent of Building Code and Zoning Services 401 Mclnfim Road, Room 223 Charlot~'ille, br~inia 22902-4596 FAX (804) 972-4126 ~1 tu (804} 972-4012 I.~l iACHMENT E ~ning Information (804) 2~>5875 Mareh 24, 1997 Steve Chidsey Director ~f Solid Waste Rivanna Solid Waste Authority P.O. Box 979 Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-0979 Fa~x 804-293-8858 Re: Official Determination of Use - Transfer Activities at the Ivy Landfill Dear Mr. Chidsey, This is to confirm in writing that which we have discussed by telephone. It is my opinion that the activity described in your letter of March 17. 1997 as a "mini-transfer station" is permitted by-right at the Ivy Landfill. This is based on the finding that this is not a change in use but is a continuation of the existing use. The Ivy Landfill is a public use and is permitted by-right in the Rural Areas district by Section 10.2.1(9). This decision is consistent with that which was previously given. Transfer activity is accessory or customarily incidental to a landfill. It results in decreased landfilling with no measurable increase in track traffic. The "mini-transfer station" is not exempt from applicable requirements of the zoning ordinance. The Director of Planning & Community. Development will review your submittal to determine ifa site plan is required and what process is necessary. I recommend that we meet to discuss it. If you are aggrieved by this detemfinarion, you have a right to appeal it within thirty (30) days of the date notice of this determination is given, in accordance with Section 15.1496.1 of the Code of Virginia. If you do not file a timely appeal, this determination shall be final and unappealable. An appeal shall be taken only by filing with the Zoning Administrator and the Board of Zoning Appeals a notice of appeal which specifies the grounds for the appeal. The date notice of this determination was given is the date of this letter. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. AmeF~a G~ McCulley, AJ.12.P~ t~ Zoning Administrator cc: Ella Carey, Clerk for Board of Supervisors Jan Sprinkle, Wayne Cilimberg RIVANNA [ ~TTAcHI'IENT E J Page 2 SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY March 17, 1997 Ms. Jan Sprinkle Zoning Assistant Department of Building Code and Zoning Services County of Albemarle 401 Mclntire Road Room 227 Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Ms. Sprinkle: As you are aware, the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority's Board of Directors is considering a number of different options for solid waste management in the service area. I am writing you for clarification concerning a proposed activity at the Ivy Landfill. One of the options under consideration by the Rivarma Solid Waste Authoritfs Board of Directors is the placement of a mini-transfer station at the Ivy Landfill rotation. A transfer station accepts waste from citizens as well as collection vehicles. II operates under a "permit-by- rule" from the Department of Environmental Quality. Waste is placed in a trailer and then shipped to a penuitted Subtitle D landfill outside the Authority's service area (most likely in the grea~er Richmond area). Currently, the Authority ships om a number of materials from the Ivy Landfill. These include the following: · Household hazardous waste · Tires · White goods · Metals · Mulch · Wood chips · Salvaged reusable materials · Recyclables (including co-mingled containers and newspaper) These materials are shipped throughout the State of Virgini~ Some of the material is transported by the Authority and other is transported under contract, it is anticipated ttmt the re'mi-transfer station would be operated and transported by Rivanna Solid Waste Authority staff. Under the proposed scenario, the Landfill would continue with its current operations with the exception that the municipal solid waste (r~idential, commercial and institutional waste) would be shipped out to the aforementioned contracted landfill. I am looking for confirmation that the mini-transfer station would be considered an accessory operation to the ongoing activities at the Landfill. The ongoing activities (including the previously described shipping of materials) would include: · Recovery of selected construction demolition debris (CDD) materials and the landfilling of any residue · Acceptance and grinding of land clearing debris (including yard waste and vegetative waste) into mulch · Grinding of pallets into wood chips · Recovery of scrap metals and white goods · Collection of used tires · Collection of recyclable containers and newspaper (drop-off center) · Acceptance of residentially generated and generator hauled waste (convenience center) · Composting of wet-stream or generator separated organic waste · Opemuon of remediation and environmental control systems · Asbestos disposal · Collection of household hazardous waste (HHW) The Landfill will cominue to be permitted under at least two permits under the Department of Environmental Quality. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions. I appreciate your assistance in this matter. Sincerely, Steve Chidsey Director of Solid Waste SC/mac cc: Arthur Petrini sharedXlc'llcrXst~v¢\CONFIRMATlON OF TRANSFER STATION J ATTACHHENT F IProject Contact: P. Mullano', Parks & Rea New Request? X Mandated Project? CIP Staff(Engineering) Assistance Req. ? C'ontinuation ? `Documented Project/Need? _Pro~iect Dat_e_s.'_ ......J_ ~t].r 99 - Feb. O0 Revised? Other Cmty. Need/Service? X Project ,Description: This project budgets funds toprov~dc acces~ roads and parking for 5 muh~purposc fields itl Bt2 developed by thc Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority (RWSA'~ as pan of the closure and capping of sectmns o£the IW I.andfill Parks and Rccreamn; has wc, rkcd closely ,.: ~ttt RWSA m dcvck~pmg th~s pre, cut. which m based on their plans Ibr thc landlill Project Changes~Reasons for Revision: Project Justification: Thc Comity currently ~s m nccd ol addlltonal alhletlc lield space The Ixx' area ts one of thc areas where the field slm~agc ~ crucial ~cccr alia baseball ICtllllS ~denlificd Iht ~mmcdmlc nccd Ibr g addithmat fickls F}ns complex ol 5 liclds can sc~'e alt Ix5' mca tcanls 1~cc11¥ thc ticlds up at Mugav and Mcrm'cthcr I.cwts lbr hasc~al] 1[ also can Fundinl4 for thi~ new project £~ requested durinl., Fl' 99'01t to meet the intmediate need for addilional athh,ticJ~ehl ¥?tlt.t, itt the ('ount. l', ired to coincide with the closing of the I.ttttdfilL Relationship to P/an: 'flus promm ~s ctmslstun! wtth mc C'omprehcnsxv¢ Plan by prornt~tmg an adequate stm~dard ol hxmg and quality oftifc lbr all County residents through a combinatmn of mutually comphmemar7 public Ihcthnes and lmpact ~f Project Not C'ompleted: Ii'not Ihndcd xw xxlH Addmonallx. thru lhcthtx would be ddlicu[l to lucatc anvxxilctc cJsc m thc ('ountx Location/ Site Status: Ix",' I.andli and trash ctmtroL estimated at $13.930 FYoII/.$14.625 [~'chnicat Committee Recommendatimt: l'hc 'Iechmcal ('II' I I ! Tota! ProJect Cost Less l'~en Pr.jert TL 33(I.00t} 13.9311 14.625 15.355 16.1211 60.030 DRAFT Capital hnproventent Program ~Y 1998/99 - 2002/03 I Page I COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Parks and Recreation Departrnen! County Office Buitdir~j 401 Mclntire Road Chariottes~lte. Virginia 22902-4596 Telephone (804) 296-5844 TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Ron Keeler, Chief of Planning Pat Mullaney, Director of Parks and Recreation November 18, 1997 Ivy Landfill Project Our Department has been working closely with the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority on the plan to convert the closed sections of the landfill into multipurpose fields to help meet the expanding athletic field needs in the County. We have just completed the process of interviewing the representatives from the various area athletic organizations to determine current and future athletic field needs. The largest field user in the County is SOCA (Soccer Organization of Charlottesville and Albemarle). This one organization has approximately 3500 participants on 233 teams. SOCA has estimated a current need of 9 more fields in the County and a 5 year'need of a total of 16 new fields. The SOCA programs consist of various leagues based onage and skill level. The recreational league teams are organized based on elementary school districts, so practices are conveniently scheduled at nearby school & park fields. The more competive youth and adult league teams are arranged by skill level, so while practices still occur at County schools and parks, travel is anticipated by the participants. SOCA competes with other area athletic programs for field space at County schools and parks. Providing a complex of fields suitable for soccer use will have a spin-offaffect of freeing up existing fields that will benefit all area sport organizations. The five fields at the landfill will be convenient for Ivy based neighborhood teams currently practicing at Meriwethar Lewis and Murray elementary schools. Currently soccer teams have to share practice space at those schools with little I ATTACHtflENT G IPage 2 league baseball. The result is that. neither has sufficient time or space to conduct their programs in that area. The location near the 1-64 Ivy exit makes the location a good one for the skill based youth and adult programs which draw players from all over the County. This will flee up significant field space County wide for the other organizations. In addition the multipurpose design will allow other sports such as field hockey, lacrosse, youth football and t-ball to make use of the fields. This project is a unique oppommity to get additional public benefit from this property. The residents of the area seem m favor this as a more acceptable public use than the continuation of the landfill operation. With proper planning, engineering, and maintenance this property can be transformed froma facility that is seen as a necessary evil, to one that is a positive benefit to the residents of both the iam~ediate area and the entire County. I ATTACHMENT i I I ! I 1 I I I 1 I OVERALL FACILITY OBJECTIVES Them are a number of general oblectives wltich are common to all community faeilities. Th~ are listecl below with a brief explanation following some of the objectives. Other service objectives established within specific facility sections are to be utilized in conjunction with thee objectives when developing the plan. Objective: Commlnli[1/facilities should be equitably provided for all County resldenls based on cost-effectiveness. ]Levels of service will vary based on tile area of the County, Those in the outlying Rural Area should not anticipate an equal level and range of services as are provided in the Growth Areas. Objective: The location of new facilities should be within the County growth areas so as to supporl County land use policies. Outlying Growth Areas such as Communities and Villages will serve as service center locations for the Rural Areas, The location of community facilities can be an important factor in determining where development can and will be accommodated. Therefore the provision ofcommumty facilities must be carefullycoordinated with tile land use plan to ensure tile adequate provision of facilities and services to accommodate existing and anticipated development. The primacy li~cus of tile land usc plan is to cnacourage developmem in the Growth Areas the necessary facilities should be provided to support this pattern of growth. In certain cases, may not l~z appropriate, or tx~s.siblc, to provide facilities solely in tile Growth Areas due to the nature of the ser~'lCe. I lowever, the priority is to provide the highest level of service to the Growth Areas, Objective: Give priority to facilities which address emergency needs, health and safety contemn, and provide the greatest ratio of benefit to the population served. Objective: Priority shall be given lo tile maintenance and expansion of existing facilities to meet service needs. Maintenance of existing facilities is of primary importance. No benefit is gained if new facilities are provided while existing facilities deteriorate and become substan¢ 'lard. Also, in meeting new service needs consideration should be given whether the ex~sting facilities can provide an adequate level of service through modification of existing ~acilitics Objective: All sites should be able Io accommodate existing and future serviee needs. All buildings, stroclures and other facililie$ shall be designed to permit expansion as necessary. Objective: services/facilities shall be located witbin and Related or complementary one complex centralized whenever possible. There are distinct advantages for both the scm, icc providers anti tile public when related and supporting facilities are in a centralized location Operational economies are achieved, capital facility and develop- IATTACHMENT, Page ment cust a~ t~uced (buildings, parking and accesaory facilitie~ can I~ sharedL and cooperation and support between personnel can be provided in some cases. Objective: Schedule funding of commtlllity facilities fl~rough the Capital Improvement Progt=atn (Cl~), based on the adopted CornmuniW ~acilitias Plan. Objective: All conll~t~nlty facilities shall be in conformance with site development regufatio~s. Objective: Determine the value of maint~inlng existing but obsolete facilities and sites for the potential re-use for other services/faeilitias prior to their disposal. Consideration should be given to the re-use of public facilities/sites for other public uses. It is costly and often difficult to purchase property and site public facilities in new locations. Prior to disposing of public properties a review of the site/facilities potential for other public uses or reservation of the property, for future use should be considered. I I I I I I i I- s I ATTACHMENT !'~. 5.1.14 SANITARY LANDFILL The site plan review committee, as provided for in section 32.0, shall review each application for a landfill and shall furnish a report to the commission and board of supervisors; No special use permit for a landfill shall be issued unless the same has been approved by the county engineer, the State Water Control Board, the Virginia Departmen~ of Health and other appropriate agencies with respect to the suitability of the site for such use; Every special use permit ~or a landfill shall be deemed to incorporate as specific conditions all other pro- visions of law related to such use; Upon completion of operations, the land shall be left in a safe condition and in such a state that it can be used for development of a use permitted in the district in which such land is located. Further, sufficient drainage improvements shall be provided so as to prevent water pockets or erosion, and such improvements shall be so designed that both natural and stormwater leaves the entire property at the original natural drainage points, and the area draining to any one point is not increased; Excepr for improvemenss necessary for the operation of a landfill, no improvements shall be constructed in or upon any landfill for a period of twenty (20) years after the termination of the landfill operation without the prior approval of the board of supervisors. No such approval shall be granted unless the applicant demonstrates that: -64 - I ATTACHMENT ! Any residual post-construction settlement will noT affect the appearance or structural integrity of the proposed lmprovement; The nature and extent of corrosion-producing properties, the generation and escape of com- bustible gases and potential fire hazards cf the constituen~ material, considering its state of decomposition, has been provided for adequately and will not create an unsafe or hazardous con- dition in or around any of said proposed improve- ments; There shall be an annual inspection of each landfill by the county engineer who shall report his findings to the board of supervisors. In making such report, the county engzneer may request information ~rom any appropriate govern- mental agency he deems necessary. Every landfill shall be subject to such additional regulations as may be required by the board of supervisors including type of debris and materials to be deposited and soil compaction adequate to support ,,3eimatm use of the property. ~'I-rACHI~ENT i COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Department of Engineering & Public Works 401 McIntire Road. Room 21 t Charlottesville, Virginia 229024596 (804-) 296 - 5861 Fax (804) 972 - 4.035 8 January 1998 Mr. Bill Mechnick. ASLA Land Planning & Design Assoc.. Inc. Post Office Box 1606 Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Re: Ivy Landf'fll, End Use Plan. Final Site Plan Dear Mr. Mechnick: The final site-plan received on 4 November 1997 has been reviewed for fmal site plan requirements. Preliminary plan requirements have been met previously, as indicated in our memorandum to Ron Keeler of the Planning Depamnem on 14 November 1997. The Engineenng Department will grant tentauve approval of the final site plan when the following items have been satisfactorily addressed (in addition to Board of Supervisors approval). Engineering Department approval of an erosion control plan is required. An erosion control plan has not been received. Under section 19.1-6(e)(4) of the Runoff Control Ordinance. a runoff control permit is not required for any developments resulting in a total impervious coverage of less than five percent. Based on the current plans, we estimate the proposed improvements will result in approximately 2.5% total impervious coverage over the 300 acre parcel. Therefore, Engineering Department issuance of a runoff control permit is not required. However. we feel the stormwater management provisions and practices of the "Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan", prepared by Joyce Engineering and implemented by RWSA, adequately addresses the provtsions of the Runoff Control. The details of this "Plan" are discussed later in this letter. The previous "Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan", prepared by Joyce Engineering for stormwater management at the Landfill. did not account for the additional road and parking areas. It appears as though all the new ~mpervious areas will drain to one basin on the east side of the site, labeled as Sediment Basin 5. The grading necessary to construct the portions of the fields that drain to the west will have no significant effect on the prevaous stormwater plan. Therefore. revised computations for these field areas will not be required. Page 2 Mr. Mechnick Re: Ivy Landfill, End Use Plan 8 January 1998 It is important to note that the Ivy Landfill is subject to DEQ stormwater discharge requirements. one component of which is to develop a "Stormwarer Pollution Prevention Plan." Such a plan was developed in 1995 (General Permit VAR 360046 issued by DEQ). The Engineering Department reviewed the p}an in 1995 and made comments to Joyce Engineering. The comments addressed interim erosion control and stormwater management for open ceils and active borrow areas, as well as the design of permanent stormwater management facilities/BMPs for closed landfill cells and borrow areas (letter from David Flirschman and Jack Kelsey to James R. DiFrancesco of Joyce Engineering, dated 9/18/95). Interim stormwater management provisions included basins designed to remove sedimem, provide detention of the flows generated by the 2 year and 10 year storms (based on flows existing prior to landfill activity), and in some cases sediment forebays to increase sediment removal efficiencies. A number of the erosion/stormwater management facilities have been constructed and pollution prevention procedures have been implemented. David Hirschman - Water Resources Manager and I have scheduled an inspeeuon to observe the status and condition of these facilities and the closed areas. Based on this inspection the Engineering Department will make further recommendations as needed. Contact me at your earliest convenience if you have questions or require additional information. mcerety, JMK/ Copy: SDP-97-110 Ron Keeler, Chief of Planning Bill Mawyer. Director of Engmeenng & Public Works File: IVY ! ATTACHI~ENT ! December 13, 1995 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Depl. of Planning & Community Developmem riO1 Mclntire Road CharJolle~viJle Virgil]h* 2~102.4596 (804) 296.5823 An Pclrini Rivaana Solid Waste Authority P. O. Box 97{) Charl.allesvillc. VA 22002 RE: Sci'vice Area Jurisdictional Area Rcqllcsl - VD(YF AIbcnuirlc ('ounly Rest ^teas laid I{ivanaa Solid Wasle Aulhorily Iv)' I.andfill I)car Mr. Pclrini: Thc Albemarle C'ounly Board of Supervisors. al i~s inccfing on I)cccmbcr 6. 1995, look thc Ibllowiag actions regarding thc aJ~ovc-nolctJ request Io illllClld Ibc service area bOmldari0s of Ibc Albemarle Collllly Service Aolhorily lbr sewer service lo exisling sl[uctares only at 1-64 Easl rcsl area; Ibr water and sewer SCl'vice lo cx]sliag slrttcltH'cs ill J-6,l Wcsl I'CSI iii'ual alia Jla' scxvcr SCl'Vi~ lo lite Ivy I.aadJ]JJ: I)enicd i'etjttesl to crlettd Ihe sort,ice ttre~t boltltdttt'it's t~f the ..llbemarJe ('ottttlv Service/Ittthoritv Apln'oved requesl to ameml lhe seri,&'e t,'ea botmthtrtes q/'lhe Albemttde C'oltltll, ,S~l'l,ice ..1 ltlhtn'iO, Jbr limited .velvet' service to lite cxi.vti~ig rest ~u'ect slrttCltO'e& oriel' rtl the I'irginia lJtT~tt'lment ,~7>'ttn.~7~ortttlitm 1-64 1Si.vi re.vt ttrctt {'lily i~[tq~ 54) tmd ttl thc t/it~Otia l)ellttrlmenl t~f D'ttn.v~orltttion 1-64 If%st rest ttl'c~t ('l}tr Akq~ 73). bi athJilion, the servk:e limited sewer service lll'C exle~lt&d lo pl'oi,ii& limited sewer service lo lite h,v .¥totiit# .fi~r pttiy~o.~e.¥ (~f lcttchtllc Ilttltltt~ttlllt'll[. OII(V [?}l[' Ahq~ 73 Parcel 2N) Service lo these to'cas is required Io be provided by In'irate sen'er Ihtex within evi.vth~g Virgi.ia Deparlment by thc [hldingv thai il is ii~'cc'.vsttt'l fi,/' CVl.~'lill~ Ind~lit'[v-OWtlt'd ti.vex ttttd i,v }tdcessttt? ident~fied pablic health, sqlctv told Sincerely, J)c¥cJoJ)IIIClIJ cc: I)avid I lirsclmum Bill Ili'eiil I ATTA'CHPIENT L Memorandum From: Copy: Date'. Re: Arthur D. Petfird - Executive Director RSWA Ron DiFrancesco, P.E, - Project Manager JEI Steve Chidsey - Solid Waste Director RSWA January 8, 1998 Leachate Transport Line Versus Pump & Treat Costs In response to the Ivy Steering Committee, this is a brief summa_~ of the preliminary comparisonbetween two disposal options for landfill leachate and contaminated groundwater at the Ivy landfill facility. The two opuons we examined are a pump station with transmission force main to the Cmzer sewer system, and on-site treatment with direct discharge of treated effluent to surface waters, and/or on-site re-use (e.g., irrigation, dust control). The Ivy Steering Committee has requested a pump station and force main be installed to deal with the waste water generated by the facility. Based on the timing and mst effectiveness of implementing a disposal solution for the waste waters generated by the facility, it is our professional opinion on-site trealrnent with direct stream discharge and/or on-site re-use be implemented. We understand the RSWA is comrrfitted to dealing with groundwater problems as they arise as well as responsibly plarming for the disposal of landfill leachate. Our recommendation to implement an on-site treatment system (also known as a pump and lreat system) meets these goals, This recommendation may not be the final or only solution to meeting the requiremeras of the Assessment of Corrective Measures. It may be used in conjunction with other traditional or innovative treatmenl and disposal technologies to serve the needs of the RSWA. The summary comparison below presents both advantages and disadvantages of the two options, as well as preliminary financial considerations. PUMP STATION AND TRANSMISSION FORCE MAIN The selection of lifts option was based on the traditional use of pump stations and force mains as an acceptable means of treatment and disposal of landfill leachate, with treatment being provided at the end of a collection system usually by a publicly-owned treatment works (POTW). In this case, the POTW is the Moore's Creek Waste Water Treatment Facility. In addition, the use of a pump station and force main provides a low risk solution to achieve the desired result. This solution, however, requires a high capital outlay for design and constmcaion and a long implementation schedule (approximately 15 to 24 months) to begin Page 1 of 3 335.01 I ATTACHlqENT ~ IPage 2 the tra~pon of' liquids. It should be noted this option requires permanent installation of a pump station and force main which would be cost prohibited ~o remove if the need for the system was eliminated in the future. As per our memorandum dated October 29, 1997, to the RSWA, we evaluated seven different force main routes which could be used to uansport liquids to the Crozetsewer system. The routes varied in location, lengti% easement requirements, and total cost. It was determined tha~ depending on the route chosen, the project cost range would be approximately $700,000 to slightly over $I,000,000 for design and consmaetion. Annual options and maintenance and disposal fees were anticipated to be approximately $110, ~0~0 regardless of the mute chosen. Below is a summary of our opinion of probable costs. Pump Station and Trannmission Force Main Total Project Cost : $1,000,000 (Including Design and Construction) $700,000 to Annual Operational and Maintenance Cost: (Including Waste Water Disposal Fee) $110,1)00 ON-SITE TREATMENT WITH DIRECT STREAM DISCHARGE AND/OR ON- SITE RE-USE The selection of this option was based on the traditional use of pump-and-'geat systems as an acceptable means of treatment and disposal of contaminated groundwater. Disposal will be a controlled, permitted outfall to surface waters, or on-site re-use for irrigation or dust control, or a combination of these two discharge options. Due to the relatively low volumes of landfill leachaxe, and the relatively low contaminant concentrations in the leachate, this opuon can provide treatment and disposal for the combined waste water flow stream of landfill leachate and contaminated groundwater. This process will use the existing leachate storage lagoon as an equalization and set'ding basin that will significantly dilute the landfill leachate x~th the relatively high volume of contaminated groundwater. The combined waste water flow will then be pumped through a conventional 'a'eatment process using aeration to volatilize the organic compounds. The air effluent will pass through an activated carbon adsorption filter to remove the organic compounds as well as control odors. The treated liquid effluent will discharge to surface waters adjacent to the site at or below State Ambient Water Quality Standards. The process will be designed, permitted; operated and monitored in accordance with the Virginia Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (VPDES) permit requirements. The treated liquid effluent could also be used on-site for purposes such as irrigation and dust control_ Trmaspor Page 2 of 3 335.01 I ATTACHMEFIT ,L IPage 31 ~ option provides a low risk and low cost solution to achieve the des'n'~d result In addition, this option satisfies the commiunem of the KSWA to deal with groundwater problems as they arise through the short implementation schedule (approximately 6-8 months) to begin Ireaunent of the waste waters. The system also has the flexibility to be decommissioned and removed from the site if the nevi for the system was eFlm'mated in the furore. It is estimated that the project cost range would be approximately $100,000 to $125,000 for design and construction. Annual operations and maintenance costa are anticipated to be approximately $25,000. Below is a summary of our opinion of probable costs. On-Site Treatment with Direct Stream Discharge Total Project Cost : (Including Design and Construction) $100,000 to $125,000 Annual Operational and Maintenance Cost: $25,O00 After considering the associated total project cost~, implemanmtion schedules, and the commiunent of the KSWA m deal with contaminated groundwater as problems arise, we recommend implementing the pump-and-treat system with a permitted stream discharge at this time. This, however, does not preclude the me of other traditional or innovative technologies used in combination with the recommended option to reduce waste waters produced from the site. After completing the on-going site invest/ganon work and the Assessment of Corrective Measures, further recommendations may be made to best handle the facility's waste water flows. Tranzpor Pa~¢ 3 of 3 335.01 FAX 804 29,1 8858 RI'FiNN.,[ AUTHORITIES RIYANNA WATER & SEWER AUTHORITY P.O. Box 18 · Ch~rlottc.willc, ~g{nia 12902 · tT~4) F77.29'~0 RIVANNA SOlID WASTE AUTHORITY P.O. ~ox Fax #: (804) 293-8858 FAX T/OkNSMXS$ION COVER . Total iF, of pagc~: Original to follow: . ,'f,./ wi (,please circlc approprl-~tc 11/17/97 09:25 PAX 804 29~ 8&$$ RIVANNA A~T/~ORITIES [~002/010 I ATTACHMENT ,~L Steady State Analysis Pipe Elevation at High Point J-1 ..~ P pe Leng~ 1.15,200' 2. 9,000' 3. 17,000' 4. 15,700' 5. 14,700~ 6. 12,900' 7, t4,400' Existing Leachate Storage Basin 1. 860' 2. 720' 3. 780' 4. 860' 7. 710' t. 8,300' 2.19,500' 3. 6,400' 4. $,$00' 5. 6,000' 6. 17,800' 7. 18,600' Pipe Elevation at Interceptor 1. 620' 2. 520' 3. 565' 4. 620' 5. 565' 6. 520' 7. 520' Note: Pi~--lengths and elevations shown were used to calculate fri~:fion head losses for the seven alternate pipe system layouts. Praj~ Engineer-' Maynard L, Eire~ Project "rirte: IW Leachate Transport Stu;~y WaterC~ vl ~5 [041] Joy=e Engineering, Inc. ~q:~appo~,¥aesbad~,g,'=U~leac. wcd Page 1 of 1 10/21197~G6'.t3:28 PM © HBestad Methods, Inc. 37 Brookside Read Water, u/7, CT 06708 USA (203} 755-1666 885! 8858 1~,I YANNA ~ 0 8858 29~ 88~8 I ATTACHMENT M 32.7°5 32.7.5.2 32.7.5.3 WATER, SEWER AND OTHER UTILITIES Adequate provision shall be made by the developer for all utili- ties, both on-site and off-site. Where deemed appropriate by the co~niseaon in accordance with section 32.?.1, the developer shall provide easements through the develo~nent for extension of such u~ilities to other properties. (32.5.15, 1980; Amended Within the service areas of the Albemarle County Service Authori- ty, where public water and/or sewerage service as reasonably available, sUCh service shall be extended by the developer. Ail such facilities shall be constructed =o Albemarle County Service Authority specification and dedicated to the Albemarle County Service Authority. Except as otherwise provided by Albemarle County Service Authority policy, all costs shall be borne by the developer. For the purposes of this'section, service shall not be deemed to be "reasonably available" in a particular case in which: The director of planning and community development in con- sultation with the Albemarle County Service Authority finds =hat the capacity 0fthe public water and[or sewerage system is inadequate to serve the proposed development; or The director of planning and community development in con- sultation with the Albemarle County Service Authority finds that the cost of connecting the proposed development to the public water and/or sewerage system, exclusive of connection fees, exceeds the cost of ihstalling an on-site well and/or septic system. (Added 5-1-87) (Amended 1-3-96) Ail public facilities, utility and drainage easements outside the right-of-way of public streets are to be shown on the final site development plan provided tha~ new easements may be generally shown and accurately dedicated by separate plat. Utility instal- lation in public snreeus and rights-of-way shall be coordinated with street construction plans and profiles approved by the Virginia Department of Highways and Transportation resident engineer for Albemarle County and the county engineer. (32.5.16, 1980; Amended 5-1-87) No sate development plan shall be approved by the commission without verif~cau~on from the Albemarle County Service Authority and Albemarle County flre official that adequate capability exists to serve such development including requared fire flows together with all other approved developments =o ne served by such eyeuem. Where the development ~s to be served by a central water or sewer system other than the Albemarle County Service Authority, no approval shall be granted untlt the requirements of Title 15.1, Chapter 9, Article 7 of the Code have been satisfied. Where servace Ks proposed by individual well or septic system, no approval shall De granted until written approval from the Virginia Department of Bealt~ has been received by the agent. (Added 5-1-87) -219.8- (Supp. #82, 1-3-96) ATTACHHENT..t Mr. Wayne Cilimberg Director of the Albemarle Planning Department 401 McImire Road' Charlottesville. Virgiula 22902 Cymhia Deuprec 702 Tat~ershall Farm Lane Charlottesville, Virginia 22903 ApriI24. 1997 Dear Mr. Cilimberg, This letter is to request that the proposed site plan (dated March or April 1997~ submitted by the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority for the Ivy Landfill be brought before the planulng commission for review. I am also requesting that there be a public hearing and public comment period in response to this proposed site plan. The RSWA is submitting this site plan for staff review only because it is thought that the plan indicates no major change occuring at the Ivy Landfill site. However. there are some major issues which the Ivy Steering Committee. the neighbors and I are concerned about. It is my belief that the citizens of Albentarle County as a whole should also be concerned. Below are listed a few of the reasons this site proposal needs more than a staffreview. REDUCED BUFFERS - The horizontal expansion of the landfill footprint will neceaskate the removal of many trees which make up what is left of the existing buffer between the landfill and Interstate 64. The landfill and its amiwty will become visible fi-om 1-64. which is a major entrance corridor into Charlottesville 2. ENVIRONMENTAL ENDANGERMENT- These new cells, which supposedly will only take Constmction Demolition Debris. may contain toxic wastes.. The transfer station will do nothing to check itsproductionofodororleachate. Both these activitias will contiane the threat of contamination and endangerment to the quality of air and water in the Ivy region. 3 DESTRUCTION OF VIEWS - The location of the proposed transfer station_ on a high and windy knoll, will be the dominant the view for drivers as they come down Gilliam's Mountain Road towards the Peacock ITfll subdivision It will be a dominant structure viewed fi-om Malvem Farm and fi-om Tat~ershall Farm. It will also be visible from route 637. The building of new cells to an unknown height will further block the existing views fi-om Malvern Farm_ Tattershall Farm. Gilliams Mountain. and fi-om others neighbors on Route 682. 4 NEW AL-I'iVlTII~S PROPOSED - New activities are proposed: soccer fields and a walking park. Are these activities appropriatel5 located next to such industrial activities? 5 INCREASED SCALE AND INTENSITY OF OPERATION - The proposed low-tech transfer station_ if maximized to its full capacity could handle as much trash as the Zion Cross Roads transfer station. However. there will be no teachate collection, no odor control, no wind control, and no content control The enlarged footprint oftbe disposal cell will increase the need to attract more garbage. This will result not only in increased and continued threat of contamination and endangerment to the environmem_ but also in increased truck traffic, increased noise, increased wind blown debris_ and an increase de~adation of the views into the landfill Although waste burial and management has been ongoing at the Ivy site for thirty years, the scale of the operation has been gradually enlarging This site plan contributes further to that enlargement. In the beginning, the dump was a small operation, occuring in the middle of the site The neighbors, the view shed_ the water, the air did not seem to be affected. However. as the scale of operation has increased so has I ATTACHMENT N the impact upon the surrounding contex~ and neighborhood. The buffers have been mostly removed, the number of true. is coming to the site has increased, the earth moving equipment has become larger and noisier, the odor has increased in frequency and intensity, and the threat of contamination and endangerment has continued to grow. This landfill is not the same beast that was grandfathared into the zoning map, and as proposed this site has the potential to expand imo a huge industrial operation. Small activities turning into large activities do have a changing impact upon the region and require careful thought. The proposed site plan needs to clearly indicate the maximum height for the ceils (via feet above sea level). The "propOsed disposal cells" should be clearly labeled as construction demolition debris disposal only (via "CDD DISPOSAL CELLS"). I look forward to hearing from you concerning the review of the proposed site plan for the Ivy Landfill submitted by the RSWA Sincerely, Cynthia Deupree Cc: Mr. Jared Lowenstein. Chairman of the Albemarle Planning Commission Mr. Brace Dotsom representative to the Planning Commission Mrs Sally Thomas. representative to the Albemarle Board of Supervtsors Mm. Charlotte Humphries. Chairwoman of the Albemarle Board of Supervisors Mr. David Booth. The Ivy Steering Committee RECEIVED t997 Ms. Cynthia Deupree 702 Tattershall Farm Lane Charlottesville, Va. 22903 Re: Ivy Landfill Site Plan COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE Dept. of Plannin9 & ComrnuniW Development 401 Mclntire 'Road Charlottesville, Virginia 229024596 (804) 296-5823 ATTACHMENT N IPage 3i May 1, 1997 Dear Ms, Deupme: Thank you for your letter of April 24, 1997. Mr. Cili~berg has asked me to respond to you since I will be (one ofthe) planner(s) reviewing the site plan for the landfill changes. You have requested that the site plan be reviewed by the Planning Commission. Please be advised that the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority has made no application for site plan review. Once submitted, the plan will be referred to the Site Review Committee, which consists of various local, state and federal agencies (In addition to these agencies, comment will be sought from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality in this case). Adjoining property owners will be advised by letter of the submittal of the site plan together with the date of the Site Review Committee meeting. As a public project with greta public interest, the site plan for the landfill project will be scheduled for Planning Commission review. The site plan review process follows a fixed schedule of about 60 days, provided the applicant revises the plan and submits other information in a timely manner. The process involves two meetings t6 which the public is invited- the Site Review Committee meeting (on a Thursday, 10:00 AM) and the Planning Commission Meeting (on a Tuesday, 7:00 PM). Written comments of the Site Review Committee agencies are available to the public on the Tuesday prior to the Site Review Committee meeting. The Planning staff report to the Planning Commission is available to the public on the Wednesday prior to the Commission review date. Of course, the Planning file would be available for inspection at any time during the review process. Section 32.0 SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN of the Albemarle County Zoning Ordinance provides the framework for review of a site plan. As to the Site Review Committee meeting, let me offer some comment on its format. The Site Review Committee is composed of various local, state and federal agencies and conducts its business in a cooperative manner. The time available for the Committee meeting is somewhat I ATTACHHENT limited as several items are usually on the agenda and when an issue arises regarding an individual plan that may require protracted discussion and/or participation by only a few Committee agencies, a subsequent meeting may be scheduled. In closing, this letter has been intended to provide you with a general overview of the site plan review process. If you are an adjoining property owner, you wiIl be notified in writing of site plan submittal for the Ivy landfill. If you (and others who are interested in this matter) are not an adjoining property owner, you may obtain written notice by submitting written request for notification together with a self-addressed, stamped envelop to this department. Your notice will be sent on the same day as notices to adjoining pwperty owners. Should you have any questions or if I may be of additional service, please do no! hesitate to contact me in writing or by phone at (804) 296-5823, ext. 3250. Sincerely, Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning RSK/rsk Cc: Mr. David Booth, Ivy Steering Committee Members, Albemarle County Board of Supervisors Members, Albemarle County Planning Commission The Ivy Steering Committee P. O. Box6084 Charlottesville, Virginia 22906-6084 OCtober 30, 1997 IATTACHMENT N Ms,Sally H. Thomas Board of Supervisors County of Albemarle 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesvillel VA 22902 Re: Reasons CDD material should not be buried at Ivy Dear Sally: I am providing both a list and a narrative version of why Construction and DemolitionDebris should not be buried at the Ivy site as you requested. I certainly hope that both of these documents will be shared with and candidly considered by all of the Board members and City Council. The proper resolve of these issues is critically important to us all. ttee David Booth cc: Ronald $. Keeler, Bruce Dotson The Ivy Landfill 'A Bad Idea Properly Ridiculed will go away" Reasons CDr should not be buffed at Ivy October 30, 1997 ATTACHMENT N.' Population growth and volume of waste materials are directly related. As population growth spirals upwards so will the Ivy landfill. Landfill sprawl in a residential neighborhood is undesirable, lowers property values and the quality of life. Some of ourproper~y values were, in fact, reduced by the last county assessment. Private business has the economy of scale to handle waste disposal more efficiently. The competitive bidding process will always provide the true cost of waste disposal. Development proJects must absorb the real cost of waste disposal if there is ever to be any real material recovery effort. Cost to remediate the Ivy landfill site should be shared equally by all who have used it-Charlottesville and Albemarle County; The continuation of landfilling at Ivy, in order to pay for remediation, continues to place an inordinate burden on the Ivy neighborhood. After 30 years of landfilling, it should be clear that "Ivy Has Paid Its Dues." The contamination of the headwaters of the county's reservoir continues indefinitely, even with a water crisis in the offing! The county should not add to. potential water problems by adding to the load of waste at the reservoir's source. The 30-year risk monitoring period and associated risk of clean up cost will continue until you stop landfilling. Constructing a CDr cell will keep the clock running and continue the risk of remediation. Expansion and continuation of the site as a CDr operation will take the Ivy landfill over the 2.75 million tons of waste limit that requires gas collection. The RSWA will therefore be subject to the cost of all new regulations that are enacted. The volume of CDD (36,000 tons/yr.) is a relatively minor volume of material for the manpower and equipment that will be required to bury it. The economy of scale simply does not exist at the Ivy site for CDD [andfilling. The continued environmental dsks associated with CDD landfilling at Ivy may prove to be costly and result in a net loss. 8. Property values in the Ivy Valley may actually recover if all landfilling stops, adding to county tax revenues. Past Boards lacked the courage to make these tough decisions. You now have the opportunity to show true leadership and courage knowing that you did the right "sustainable" thing for not only Albemarle County but the world we all live in. The Ivy Steering Committee I ATTACHI4ENT N October 30, 1997 I Page 7] Dear Sally, Thank you for asking that we provide you with the top five reasons why the burial of construction and demolition matedal (CDD) should not continue in the Ivy Valley. The list of reasons grows longer the closer one get to the landfill issue, or the closer one lives ~to the landfill site. I will start with issues of greatest concern to those who live closest to the site. The residents of the Ivy Valley are very proud of where they live and what they have accomplished in their lives. Gertrude Weber, for example, has spent a lifetime creating what all of you seem to want so much for Albemarle County- the best possible place to live~, and a working farm with maonificent views of the Blue Ridoe Mountainsz. She restored her home and farm with hard work and integrity: Maureen and I also transformed a derelict,-Tattershall Farm into a wonderful place to live. Many other families as well have close ties to the environment of the Ivy Valley, and you have heard from many of them, including residents of Peacock Hill and those who live on routes 637 and 68Z. None of us wants the heavy industry of the Ivy landfill to continue or expand, as it is incompatible with the nature of our neighborhood~ Our sense of community and the commitment to that community has been shown to be one of the stronqest in the counW~. The construction of cells 4, 5 and 6, and the process of filling it with construction debris, would expand the Ivy landfill for another 48.2 years and increase the threat to the sustainability of our community. In addition, you might note that three (3) cemeteries are directly affected by the landfill: one cemetery immediately adjacent to the landfill at St. John's Church and two cemeteries inside' the landfill site. Expanding landfill operations by constructing cell 4 and the transfer station would addto the desecration of these sites. We are very concerned about the effects of population qrowth and Sprawl in the county on the rural nature of the Ivy Valley4. We have already seen the unacceptable possibilities that lie ahead for the Ivy Valley. The current Solid Waste Organizational Agreement directs the Authority to expand the site to regional proportions. This direction was solidified when the BOS and CC accepted Option 7A, (expansion of the Ivy landfill site for the burial of CDD as a fiscal solution). The Ivy Valley is now anticipating endless landfilling of regional proportions on a site that was never, and is not now, appropriate for a landfill. Pdvate developers are directly linked to the growth issues in the county as well as the volume of waste generated. Developers must be required to include the true cost of CDD waste disposal in the cost of their projects. The Beat Possible home for us all in the Ivy Valley. Views of the Blue Ridge are blocked or marred by the Ivy Landfill. The Ivy Valley Sense of Comm,mity is strong Grooving Population and Rural Sprawl means Regional landfilling in the Ivy Valley . The politics that require only the cheapest method of solid waste disposal needs to be eliminated. The municioal oDeration of landfills leaves little real assurance that adioinino neiohbors will be treated equitablys. A better role for a municipality than operating a risky business like landfilling is regulating private industry. The time to deal with the aqinq landfill that we've inherited is at hand6. The continuation of' CDD burial at the Ivy site is a sho~-sighted, short-term fiscal solution. It substitutes politicians' desire for shore-term cost saving for long-term cost saving that would ultimately be of greater benefit to our community and our children. Furthermore, continuing the burial of CDD to pay for remediation of the site imposes an unfair burden on the neighbors of the Ivy Valley rather than imposing a fair burden on all county residents. The remediation and recovery of the Ivy landfill is a burden that can only be equitably shared-and afforded by--all who live in Charlottesville and Albemarle County and all who have used the site7. I ATTACHMENT !~ The creation of a park and the termination of waste burial at the Ivy site would be a win-win decision. It would result in ah environmentally safe site rather than a sprawling waste land that requires endless pumping, purging, maintenance, and monitoring. It would be PoliticallY. environmentallY, and fiscally qood for everyone in Albemarle County8. Many'county officials have led citizens for years to believe that the park option was' to be expected at this site. The cost of CDD disposal should be determined by competitive biddino9. Bidding-out the management of our MSW and CDD should be considered a step in the right direction. The competitive bidding scopeof work should direct that portion of what needs to be buried to a correctly located and operated site. The next step should naturally be to direct the Authority to cull the maximum of recoverable material and to work to create the market for those materials. Properly done this could result in long term revenue that could aid in the remeciiation expense. After all, the RSWA has been paid to accept the waste and if they can recycle it cheaper than shipping it out then there is a profit. We should minimize the amount of natural resources Albemarle county ~s condemning to burial. The Ivy Steering Committee Municipal operation 'of landfill leaves little assurance of equitable treatment. The time to deal with the aging landfill that we've inherited is at hand The clean up and recovery of the Ivy landfill is a burden that can only be equitably shared-- and afforded by--all Creation of the park would be politically, environmentally, and fiscally good for everyone ~n Albemarle County cdd disposal cheaper by RFP. Attachments: List of Reasons CDD should not be buried at Ivy cc: Ronald S. Keeler, Bruce Dotson 810 Gilliams Mt. Road Charlottesville VA:.,~.22903 I ATTACHMENT N LPage 9 The proposed "Final Use Plan" for the Ivy Landfill is to be presented to the Planning Commission on December 9, 1997. This plan is seriously flawed and fraught with deficiencies that will have damaging effects on those living close to the Landfill and on our entire county for years to come if accepted as proposed. There are many areas that must be considered and settled before this plan could be considered as a"final ske plan". The CDD (construction demolition debris) areas should be capped at 700 feet. Adequate visual and noise buffers must be assured and planned. Recreational areas must show the extent of gas capture and control systems. The sewer tine scheduled for the 1-64 rest stop should be tied into the landfill site to de~ with leachate that will be produced for generations to come and to begin to build the infrastructure for the final uses of the landfill site. An automatic, industrial style wash rack should be installed to prevent off site tracking of mud and solid waste and airborne clouds of dust. Plans should be instituted to transport MSW (municipal solid waste) and CDD to a properly constructed and environmentally sound transfer station located either in a centrally chosen point in the county or to regionally located stations rather than transporting all waste through the county to the Ivy site. Provisions should be instituted for denying admission to the landfill of improperly covered vehicles that spew their garbage along our roadsides. All trash haulers should be licensed and only licensed haulers should be granted ?~eess tn the landfill. This has been a policy instituted in other localities and has proved ver~ successful in managing waste disposal. Transfer stations should be enclosed buildings and located so that they am not visible from roads and surrounding homes. Composting needs to be done in a closed building and not with the current "gag bag" methodology. Conagra needs to compost their own waste and not dump it at the Ivy Landfill. The Imj Landfill has been there for 30 years and was supposed to have closed years ago. The proposed "final site plan" is a piecemeal plan, is very shaky and dangcrons. The time has come to close the Ivy Landfil~once and ~for all. ~, Charlotte Y.' Humphris. Chair Albemarle County Supervisors Jack Jouett District 109 Falcon Dr. Charlottesville. VA 22902 November 28, 1997 I ATTACHFIENT I J~CJ~ IPage 1 IVED Planning Dept. Dear Ms. Humphris: We are replying to your letter of November 7 in which you explained the Board of Supervisors' decision to proceed with GBB Option 7A and construct new Cell 4 at the Ivy Landfill. We appreciate your response to our suggestions of October 23, but we believe you apparently misunderstood both our recommendations and the implications of proceeding with Option 7A. At this point we have no technical questions for Mr. PetrinL but we do have very serious questions about your letter. First, you replied that our suggestion to "let a contract to private industry for disposal of all CDD" is not within your ability to effect, as Albemarle Coun[y and the RSWA cannot control where private industry brings its CDD for disposal. We know that you cannot direct private industry where to dispose of trash, but that iS quite beside the point. The point is that Albemarle County and the RSWA can close the Ivy landfill to further disposal of CDD as well as MSW. No state or federal statute or court decision requires the Ivy Landfill to be kept open for further disposal of any kind, It is certainly within your ability to effect a contract with private industry to dispose of the county's CDD elsewhere in an existing, properly constructed CDD cell. Why not close the Ivy landfill to further waste burial now--get the RSWA out of the landfill business and change its mandate to waste recovery? We had hoped, based on Mr. Tucker's comments at a recent BOS meeting, that that was the direction in which you were movung. We urge you te reconsider. Second. although Option 7A may avoid current hard decisions and allow the present Supervisors and the RSWA to avoid using taxpayer money in the short run, we are convinced that in the long term it is a money-losing proposition. It reminds us of the alcoholic who says that he must have a drink now to enable him to stop drinking later. Construction of another waste cell inevitably complicates remediation of the site and requires further monitoring, requiring future tip fees to pay for further construction...This kind of reasoning means that the landfill will never close. We do understand but we are very unhappy about--government officials' decisions to put short-term tax hedges ahead of long-term tax savings and long-term community welfare. Why not take the long-term view and close the landfill now to further waste burial? I ATTACHHENT ! Page 1' We find your statement that "past history does not predict future performance" not credible for two reasons. Past behavior is always the best single indicator of what someone is likely to do in the future, barring something like a religious conversion-or an unambiguous demand from a higher authority, with consequences for noncompliance clearly spelled out. Moreover, we have seen no indication to date of improved performance in landfill operations. Mud is still being tracked onto the road in great quantities. Neighbors along the western boundary continue to be harassed by noise and odors. We in Peacock Hill hear the rock ripper and other heavy equipment noise involved in construction of Cell 4. Plans for closure and final uses remain uncertain. Mr. Chidsey's communication ~o neighbors indicates that future operations will still not meet the standards of private industry, as the BOS has given the RSWA ins~]fficient funds to operate at a higher level. In shor~, every indication we have is that business is very much as usual at the Ivy landfill--and that this will continue indefinitely. How are we to take seriously your suggestion that past does not predict future when nothing has changed significantly? We do realize that the MSW waste stream is ostensibly to be transferred to another landfill not buried at Ivy, be~nning ne~t summer. If that occurs .as the RSWA has led the community to believe--it will be a significant step in the right direction. However, it will not resolve the other problems with the Ivy landfill operations, which are substantial. We trust that you and others now involved in the sordid tale of Albemarle's solid waste mismanagement are Trying to do the best you can. However. we also believe that your decision te continue landfiBing is misguided and not in either our naighborhood's or the county's best long-term interests. We hope that you will be open to rethinking the fate if the Ivy landfill and that you will close it sooner rather than later tn further landfilling. Sincerely yours, ~. ,.,~ ~.~// James M. Kavffman & Patricia L. Pullen 607 Big Oak Road Charlottesville, VA 22903 979-9878 Copy: Albemarle Board of Supervisors Albemarle County Planning Commission RIVANNA P.O. BOX 979 SOLID WASTE I:a~TTACH MENT I UTHORITY------ December 9, 1997 Mr. Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning County Of Albemarle 401 McInfire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Subject: Response to Booths' Letter Dated October 16, 1997 Dear Mr. Keeler: The letter from Mr. & Mrs. Booth raises some points to which I can respond: Visual Buffer: It is the goal of Rivauna Solid Waste Authority (RSWA) to install a high quality visual buffer of trees along the boundary where needed. To that end, the RSWA has contracted for more than $35,000 worth of tree and shrub plantings to improve the visual buffer from St. Rt. 637 as well as from neighboring property along the western boundary. This large scale landscaping work has begun. White Pines, the principal tree for buffer enhancement, have been widely recognized as having excellent sound and sight buffering capability by virtue of the thick, horizontal growth of their branches at all elevations of the trunk. It is not possible to plant fully grown buffer trees so that the maximum benefit will occur as the trees mature. The Landfill site plan shows where these plantings are to OCCur. A parallel plan to improve the visual buffer isto offer trees and shrubs to our landfill neighbors that will be planted at our cost on their property. We proposed to implement that plan this fall but we have been notified by Cynthia Denpree that the neighbors do not want the plantings to occur until the fall of 1998. These plantings are not shown on the site plan but do address the issue of visual buffers. Noise Control: The RSWA will close its municipal solid waste (MSW) disposal unit next year. At that time a significant amount of waste will be diverted to the BFI transfer station near Zion Crossroad. In addition, the smaller scale operations of the new transfer station will be much further away fi-om the western boundary than the current MSW.disposal area. The effect of these changes will be less noise along the western boundary. After closure, the only operations on the western side will be the deposition of inert waste, which will receive minimal traffic with specified material loads. The new CDD cell will also receive significantly less truck and heavy equipment traffic than the current MSW cell. To my knowledge, RSWA has never been cited in violation of DEQ noise ordinances. I presume that Mx. and Mrs. Booth refer to a past noise problem, over uvo years ago, associated with the twin engine excavating pans working on the closure of Cell 1 and 2 Lined located along the western bounda~. -We do not anticipate using this type equipment again on site. The Authority will monitor for noise periodieallyand if any regulatory noise levels are exceeded, we will revise our procedures. Odor: Odors fi.om the site emanate primarily fi.om the active face of the MSW cell. Cell closure next year will seal odors generated fi.om the MSW. In addition, RSWA will be installing a landfill gas extraction system in the coming year to remove odor-causing gas generated within the fully closed cells and prevent their dispersal f~om the landfill. The CDD waste does not generate the gases associated with the organically rich MSW. The placement of 6" of soil over the daily CDD working face, as the Booth letter suggests, would serve no useful purpose and is not required by regulations. To the contrary, it would decrease the efficiency of the operation and expend dollars needed elsewhere. Air Pollution: In 1998, RSWA will begin installation a DEQ permitted vacuum extraction system designed to actively remove potentially harmful gases from the waste cells. The gases will be transported through sealed papes to a gas destruction system that will not cause a health hazard to the neighbors. Modem systems have a destruction efficiency of 98% or better and meet all regulatory requirements. Any problems attributable to dust, odor, and off-gassing from the Landfall will be minimized as waste cells become fully closed and the amount of waste diverted to Zion Crossroads increases. To further decrease dust-related concerns, on-site access roads will be paved and a tire washing facility will be installed in the coming months. The fuel cell technology suggested by the Booth letter was included in a consultant report which studied the various landfill gas management alternatives. Their conclusion was that the use of a fuel cell is an immature technology requinng extensive gas pretreatment. The net present value ora fuel cell system is estimated at a $2,400,000 expenditure over 30 years compared to approximately a $200,000 expenditure over 30 years for either leachate evaporation or power generation via a generator. A fuel cell site using landfill gas was visited by RSWA staff and our inspection confirms the consultant's report. Sha~ed/L~M/Andrew/Coumy/Petfini booth response memo I ATTACHPIENT I~ Surface Water and Groundwater Pollution: RSWA has taken proactive steps to control and more accurately define the nature and extent of contamination on the entire site and specifically on the xeestem property boundary. DEQ has approved the concept ofRSWA's pump-and-treat corrective action measures currently being implemented on the western boundary. A funding plan for these and other actions has been established. Also, DEQ, Mr. and Mrs. Booth, and RSWA have agreed on further investigation of groundwater contamination on the Booth property. Clean fill is not a waste and so stockpiling of clean fitl is unregulated. The placement of clean fill in its designated area does not disturb the flow from the spring to the property boundary. In regards to soil and erosion control, all surface water is directed to storm water sedimentation basins per coun .ty and state regulations. All basins are functioning properly and are inspected regularly by County and State inspectors. Solid waste discharges from the basins are not occurring. ADP/csw Attachment cc: RSWA Board of Directors Ms. Kay Slaughter, Mayor Ms. Charlotte Humphris. Chair Sincerely, Mr. Arthur Petrini Executive Director David & Maureen Booth 531 Tattershall Farm Lane Charlottesville, Virginia October 16, 1997 Mr. Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning County of Albemarle 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Virginia 2290Z-4596 Re: Ivy Landfill site plan 22903 I ATTACHI IENT IPage 1. RECEIVED NOV 1-9 t997 Pianning Dept. Dear Mr. Keeter. Maureen and I are adjacent landowners located on the western bounda~j of the Ivy landfill. The western boundary of the Ivy landfill facility has been greatly impacted by past and current landfill operations. Our concerns with the proposed site plan include: Visual Buffer Noise Buffers Odor Air Pollution and Off, Gassing Surface Water and Groundwater Pollution Storm Water and Erosion Control Visual Buffer: The elevations of the landfill's perfect geometric cells at 750 feet of elevation have stolen our views of the mountains and have visually degraded our home and property. The impact of the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority landfilling operation has expanded above the tree line and to the edge of their property and beyond. All of the trees that provided a year round visual buffer of the landfill facility have been cut within the last two years. Maureen and I now have a 180 degree view into the landfill site along the western property boundary. The Albemarle County Comprehensive Plan indicates that landfill operations should be visually buffered from private residences. The site plans should not be approved without definitive plans that show how our home and those of other neighbors are to be visually buffered from this horrific eye sore. Noise Control: The ivy landfill site is on a rock ddge that swales off to valleys and streams that surround the site to the North, East and West. This tilted site configuration acts as a megaphone that blast the neighbors across the valleys created by the streams to the North and West with noise beyond comprehension while the noise in the landfill appears quite minimal. The Department of Environmental Quality has indicated in their reports that the off site noise from the Ivy landfill is beyond that allowed. We ask that you understand that the acoustics of the site will require noise barriers to protect the neighbors from the physical stresses of noise that continue to affect our health. Noise barriers to the West and North must be required if any form of landfilling operation is to continue in these areas. ATTACHMENT Odor: Our files are so thick with odor complaints that I won't even attempt to discuss this subject except to suggest that a; forever binding; non-retractable; non-waiverable requirement be placed on this Authority that requires daily soil cover of at least 6' be used to control odor if any landfilling of any type, blSW or CDD is to continue. There should be no chance of this Authority ever being given an option to use anything other than 6' soil cover as a minimum for the duration of landfilling on this site. Air Pollution: Thedust, the odor and the methane and other hazardous substance off gassing from this site became a major concern to us as we learned more about the nature and magnitude of off gassing that occurs from landfills (40% of all Methane is produced from landfills). There should be no hesitation about requiring full scale gas capture and control at this facility. We do not want to be subjected to gas fladng or leachate boil off as has been suggested by the Authority. Clean off gassing control as provided by Fuel Cell technology would be the preferred method. Surface water and qroundwater problems: The Ivy landfill has moved beyond its site boundaries with off site.flows of solid waste and chemical discharges to the surface water on Tattershall Farm. The ivy landfill site has been, and is now, out of control with regard to solid waste and eroded soil discharges onto our pdvate property. All streams on Tattershall Farm have been eroded at least 2' in the last two years. The amount of sediment that is being washed down stream from this municipal site, that is operated by the very Authority that is charged with protecting our water supply, should have incited an immediate cease and desist order by all responsible elected officials. There should be a resounding NO to further landfilling on or near the streams in the.ivy landfill yet the Authority continues to show future plans to landfill on top of springs that have their headwaters in the landfill (area called clean fill / future meadow on the south-western boundary). Tattershall Farm is Iooldng at continued impact from the Ivy landfill and a future of Off site, groundwater monitoring Wells located in what was pasture land on our farm. The problems with the Ivy landfill are far more extensive than I can or intend to write about in this letter. My best advice would be to close this the Ivy landfill to further landfilling of any sort and begin the process of healing the site and the neighborhood that it is located in from the environmental and political insults that have been inflicted. David and Maureen Booth cc: Bruce Dotson · ~deE] 8u!uueld C]3AlgO3EI · .:..; . -..:......... AR£^'r .... :'; ..' .. :" '.' ::"i - PROPOSED Ei~'TRA~ VEHICLE AREA (212) · PROPOSED BUS PARKBIG AREA (4) -EXlSTIqG 3 BOARD FENCE '- BUFFER FEI~. ,v L WASTE TO COIVPO$'II~ CON~OST MIXI~ BJI..DI~I6 L__ TRANSFER STATION "-- - EXISTING ENCORE CENTER ....... EXISTING' MAI~I'I~IAN(~ & 8OALE HOUSE BULDI~IG EXISTIqG LAI~$CAPE LEGEND LLNI) PLUtI'i]NG I, D]iiSIGN ik~O(~T~, Ill(:. RIVANNA P.O. BOX 979 SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA 22902-0979 (804) 977-2976 January 8, 1998 Mr. Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning County of Albermarle Department of Planning & Community Development 401 Mclntire Road - Room 218 Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Re: Ivy Steering Committee Issues List Dear Mr. Keeler: This letter is a point-by-point response to the "List of Issues for the Ivy Landfill Site Plan," which was submitted to the Planning staff by the Ivy Steering Committee. The issues raised in that document are a combination of those that are directly relevant to what we understand to be your scope of review, and those that we do not believe are relevant to your review. For that reason, this letter provides responses m those issues that we understand to be relevant to your review, based on our discussions during the past few months. Other issues are addressed as an appendix to this letter. For ease of reference, each issue is reproduced verbatim f~om the Ivy Steering Conumittee's list, with lettering and underlining preserved. Issues Relevant to Scope of Site Plan Review A. MAXIMUM ELEVATIONS AND FINAL GRADES: 1. Temper and contour existing slopes to reduce erosion risk and require the creation of earthen berms for the planting of visual buffers on site. Response: Regarding slope impacts: Existing slopes have already been planted and stabilized, and both the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) and the County Erosion Control Officer have inspected them and found them satisfactory. Where required, the existing slopes do have, and in the future will have, contours that intercept sheet flow to reduce erosion. Within the Site Plan area, a series of earthen berms separating the Site Plan area from the CDD landfill and other on-gomg solid waste activities areas will be constructed and planted. Once vegetation is established, there will be mirfimized erosmn and runoff to surface waters In the PRINTED ON RE~CLED PAPER RSWA's submittal to the Planning Commission, several sheets show details of the berm grading and plantings, including L1, L3, LS, Lt, LB, L17, L18, L19, L20, L22, L26, L27, and L28. B. RECREATION AREAS: 1. Show the extent of Gas Capture and Control system for both the primary and secondary gas capture systems. Response: The submission of the Gas Management Plan to the Department of Environmental Quality indicates the linkage and the distribution of pipe throughout the site leading to a gas management unit. The Gas Management Plan is available for review at the RSWA Administration Office. The RSWA is continuing to evaluate the cost- effective utilization of landfill gases for the heating of on-site greenhouses and other activities. The gas management unit location is shown on sheet LDMSP (page 1 of 1). 2. Include both Soccer and Rugby organizations as final uses of this site. Response: The County Department of Parks and Recreation will determine users of the pass,ye/recreational she once it ~s completed. C. REMEDIATION REQUIREMENTS: 1. Gas Management: a. No stack elevation shown. b. No power generation tie in to the electrical grid shown. Response: a. The stack height is estimated to be 30 feet, on an existing base grade of 735 feet, for a total elevation of 765 feet when completed. b. No tie-in of the gas management system to the electrical grid is envisioned. D. SEWER LINE: The sewer line scheduled for the 1-64 rest stop should be tied into the landfill site to deal with leachate that will be produced for generation to come and to begin the infrastructure for the final uses of the site. Mr. Ronald S. Keeler (2) I/8/98 The use of the proposed sewer hne for the 1-64 rest stop is only applicable if the VDOT project proceeds in a timely manner and our portion of the sewer line is both cost effective and timely. Neither of those two points are favorable based on the latest information: 1) The VDOT rest stop project is not scheduled for funding until the year 1999, and it would take a further year m a year and one-half to.complete the project. 2) An analysis of our portion of the sewer line versus the alternative of un-site treatment and discharge shows that the sewer line option is seven times more expensive than the on-site system ($700,000 versus $100,000). As for the infrastructure requ/rements for the final uses of the site, no sewer line is required. E. MISCELLANEOUS ("MISC"): MISC 1: The site plan should becomes the legal document defining the limits of industrial activities along with end use dates and final grades proposed to create the park. Response: Once the Site Plan is reviewed and approved by the Planning Commission, it becomes a legal document. The "industrial activities" that are part of the Site Plan (the transfer station, the compost operation, gas managemem station) are clearly stated in the plan and are delineated. There are no end use dates for these activities. Final grades for the park are shown. MISC 2: The site plan is labeled "End Use Plan". It is NOT an end use plan since it does not show what ALL landfilling has ceased. This plan should be entitled "Interim Use Plan". These new cells will be a continuation of and an expansion of the landfilling area. Response: The end uses of the acuvities within the Site Plan jurisdiction are clearly shown as stated in the above response. The recreational fields are clearly outlined and referenced as soccer fields for illustrative purposes. Landfilling is not part of the Site Plan. However, where landfilling of CDD is shown (labeled as disposal area) in the plan, the final use as meadows is shown. MISC 5: Your approval-of this site plan will be your legacy to the County of Albemarle. Response: This statement is true. Continuing to provide for solid waste management services is a positive legacy. Mr. Ronald S. Keeler (3) 1/8/98 F. TRANSFER STATION ("TRANSFER"): TRANSFER 1: The transfer station is a continuation of an industrial activity taken place in a erowin~ residential neighborhood. Locate a transfer station in a centrally located area of the County. Response: A centrally located facility was one of the many alternatives reviewed in detail. The RSWA Board, as well as the City and County governing bodies, have approved GBB Option 7a, which includes the location of the MSW transfer station at the Ivy Landfill site. TRANSFER 2: The proposed location of the transfer station is immediately adjacent to the proposed recreational fields. It will be very hard to buffer the dust, odor, sounds and sights of industrial Transfer Operation and the Raw Food Waste Compost activities from the recreational activities. This is a plan to fail. Response: The concept of separating recreation and solid waste activities is well established throughout the country. Areas of our site for recreation and areas for solid waste management will be separated by earthen beams with plantings, trees, bushes, and fences. Sight: Due to the berm and plantings, there will be minimal visual contact with the transfer station. Odors: The mixing area for the compost facility is enclosed within a building, and MSW transfer will be conducted using a covered trailer, in addition, acfi~e landfill gas management is planned for the recreational areas. Dust: Paving of the transfer area and installation of the wheel wash will mimmize dust. Sound: Most of the preparatory work for the compost operation will be in the building. The transfer of mixed compost to the compost bags is a low noise operation occurring periodically throughout the day. Truck noise will not have a significant impact as use of the fields by recreational groups will be concentrated to weekends and on weekdays after 6:00 p.m. Overlapping use of the facilities by sports teams and for solid waste activities should be minimal. TRANSFER 3: Wind blown debris is currently a problem at the Blue bag area. Any transfer facility needs to be enclosed, preferably in a building that would provide real control. Private companies such as the BFI facility at Zion's Crossroads are located in an industrial areas are environmentally and neighborhood friendly by being enclosed in a building and offering noise, odor, leachate and wind blown debris control. Response: The blue bag area litter is being addressed by the county and city working together with haulers on a number of alternatives. The method of transferring waste from collection vehicles to transfer vehicles (the transfer itself is enclosed within the Mr. Ronald $. Keele~ (4) 1/8/98 body of the trailer) minimizes the potential for wind~blown debris. The fact that the RSWA will no longer be landfilling MSW will eliminate the wind-blown debris fi'om the work'mg face. A leachate collection system will be under all MSW transfer trailers. In addition, a building would have more visual impact than the current plans. Odor: MSW will be transferred out daily. Occasional day end loads will go out the next working day. The transfer facility grounds will be mainta'med daily. TRANSFER 4: Any transfer facility should be enclosed in a building and well buffered from the neighbors and other uses of the site. The RSWA will continually seek the cheapest of the cheap method to deal with solid waste i.e. in open trucks with no odor, or debris control. Response: Buffer: The transfer station was specifically sited to maximize the distance fi-om the neighbors and minimize the visual impact. As shown on the Site Plan, a significant amount of plantings will occur around the transfer station. Debris control: The method of transferring waste from collection vehicles to transfer vehicles (the transfer itself is enclosed within the body of the trailer) minimizes the potential for wind-blown debris. The transfer facility grounds system will be maintained daily. A leachate collection system will be under all MSW transfer trailers. Odor: MSW will be transferred out daily. Occasional day end loads will go out the next working day. We trust that this- infon-nation meets your needs at this time and stand ready to answer any other questions you may have. Sincerely, o Arthur D. Petrini Executive Director ADP/SC/jj Attachment Mr. Ronald S. Keeler (5) I/8/98 To: Amelia McCulley,Jack Kelsey,Ron Keeler From: Greg Kamptner Subject: SDP 97-110; Ivy Landfill Date: 2/9/98 Time: 1 l:28AM Andrew Carter of RSWA sent me a letter outlining what RSWA proposes to do to comply with condition 1.h of the SDP: "Demonstration to the County Attorney of compliance with all applicable provisions of the Code of Virginia as related to cemeteries and places of burial of the dead." The provision of the Code of Virginia the RSWA needs to satisfy is section 15.2-2258, which provides: "When any grave, object or structure marking a place of burial is located on the land ..., such grave, object or structure shall be identified on any plans or site plans required by this article." To satisfy condition 1.h and section 15.2-2258, the RSWA has done a title search back to 1895 (earliest found) and explored the area identified in a 1950 deed reserving a small area for a family burial plot, but not identifying its location. A 1983 topo map of the RSWA shows a location. They have found no evidence of a burial plot at that location. The RSWA next will have a consultant: (1) search the general subject area of the landfill property for evidence of a burial plot; (2) certify that the footprint of the landfill gas management unit, included inthe site plan, does not contain a burial plot; and (3) advertise through the Daily Progress for claim of ownership or any other information related to the cemetery. Besides directly contacting members of the family ID'd inthe 1950 deed and having the preparer of the 1983 topo map let the RSWA know what they relied on to ID the location of the plot, I think they will have done all (if not more than) they need to do. Any additional ideas? Thanks. Greg Kampmer Assistant County Attomey Office of the County Attorney County of Albemarle 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 te1:(804)972-4067 fax:(804)972-4068 email:gkamptne@albemarle.org RIVANNA P.O. BOX g79 SOLID CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA 22902°0979 WASTE AUTHORITY (804) 977~2976 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: SUBJECT: DATE: Arthur D. Petrini, Executive Director of Solid Waste Steve Chids ,e~rector of Solid Waste Recreational Activities/Solid Waste Management Facilities January 13. 1998 I have done a brief survey of facilities in the State of Virginia pertatning to recreational activities and solid xvaste management facilities. In addition, attached is a survey from Malcolm Pirnie on active recreational projects. · Montgomery County Solid Waste Authority has baseball and softball fields and a model airplane flying area on the same site as its active landfill and recycling center. Hanover County has soccer fields on property adjacent to its landfill, which shares the same access road with solid waste vehicles. Goochland County is in the process of building a park. including soccer and baseball fields, on its former landfill adjacent to its current transfer station. Chesterfield County has three play fields adjacent to the solid waste area, but not on the former landfill. It is on the same site as its large convenience center and other solid waste activiues. · U.S.A. Waste operates the Big Bethel Landfill in Hampton. It has a 15-acre driving range on unfilled area immediately adjacent to its landfill, with which it shares an entrance road. I hope this serves to provide you with examples of the coexisting solid waste and recreational activities. SC/ii CC: Kathi A Mestayer, Senior Project Scientist. Malcolm Pirnie Steve R. Nesbitt, Associate, Malcolm Pirnie Word/Shared/L&M/Steve/Petrini - Recreational Facilities PRINTED DN RECYCLED PAPER RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY EXAMPLE LANDFILL ACTIVE RECREATION PROJECTS Harrisonburg, VA Public Works Harrisonburg County Landfill Jim Baker 540-574-4723 Softball fields were constructed over a closed MSW landfill which at one time existed along side an active MSW landfilling operation. The landfill cap consists of approximately 2.0 feet of general fill: Primarily a clayey material exists over the wastes in the softball field. No special design was incorporated in the construction of the softball fields. The Contractor for the project graded 2 feet of earthen material over the softball fields. A passive gas venting system has been installed and LFG vents are located along the perimeter of the softball fields. Until 1993 active landfilling of MSW was occurring within 200 feet of the softball fields. View of landfilling operations was obstructed due to sharp transitions in elevation between landfilling operations and the softball fields. Occasionally a truckload or two of earthen material is brought in to repair depressions in the softball fields. Along some of the slopes erosion occurs to the point that trash is exposed. Visitors to the softball fields did not object to playing along side an operating landfill. City of Salem, VA Salem Solid Waste Disposal Harrisonburg County Landfill Jim ]Fender, Solid Waste Director 540-574-4723 Softball fields, restrooms and a pavilion existed within approximately 700 feet of MSW and flyash filling operations. The landfill was closed in 1995 and a passive venting system was installed. The recreation facilities were not constructed over waste. Neither facility intruded on the operation of the other. City of Hampton (VA) Parks Department The Hamptons Golf Course Contact: Calvin Pearson, (757)727-6347 Golf course placed on municipal landfill. Open for bUsiness in 1989. Only 12 of 27 holes are on closed landfill. Slight depressions caused by settling of the waste have been incorporated into the landscaping of the golf course. No maintenance or filling activities specific to the depressions have been required since settlement is not extensive, and does not adversely affect play on the golf course. All structures (i.e. clubhouse, roadways) were placed on virgin soil. No methane gas extraction system installed. No air monitoring required. Only problems are associated with landscaping. Cannot place lxees over landfill. Must be careful when digging because landfill cap consists of only 18 inches of soil. Leachate problem has not occurred. Using man-made pond adjacem to golf course (landfill) as primary water source. Testing has indicated no leachate entering pond. Montgomery County (VA) Parks and Recreation Baseball fields Contact: Tom Bain, (540)382-6975 Municipal landfill closed in 1979. Site nowused for active recreation (baseball, softball), Original ballfields became unplayable. Differential settlement of up to 6 feet in some areas. A considerable amount of off-site borrow was used to fill in depressions and regrade the cap of the landfill in 1995-1996 at a cost of approximately $8,000 - 10,000. Settling continues; expecting additional regrading every 5 years. Passive methane gas venting system is used around ball fields. Three large vertical passive veto pipes with dissipators on top were installed on landfill. Vent pipes receive landfill gas from horizontal perforated pipes ruranng throughout landfill. Gas is extracted from landfill before reaching surface. The system was installed in mid-May, and no mon/toring has been done. Hoping that more expensive method of burning methane gas will not be required. Due to the settlement issue and associated costs, the County recommends against active recreation on landfills. Bend Metro Park and Recreation District (Bend, Oregon) Skyline Sports Complex Contact: Norm Viesmer, (541)389-7275 A sports complex was placed on 31 acre municipal landfill site. It includes softball and soccer fields. The complex has been in operation for approximately 20 years. Due to settling problems, the City is currently renovating the site. The City has been filling in depressions caused by settlement of waste on an annual basis to maintain level playing fields. To minimize the impact of settling, current renovation activities include placing fill material obtained ~om off-site (a t 0 acre area requiring 3 feet of fill on average) and regmding at a cost of $213,000. The fields were recrowned m enhance runoff and inhibit infiltration. The City found that the rate of settling diminished when the site was kept dry (infiltration minimized). The City expects additional large- scale renovation activities in 10-15 years. Additional problems include the repair of irrigation pipes, etc. Workers have to operate in difficult conditions. They are not certain what waste types will be encountered during construction activities. Light poles, for example, were inserted through the waste before they reached bedrock t4 feet below the surface. No gas extraction technologies are currently being used. Due to the settlement issue and associated costs, the City recommends against active recreation. Seattle Parks and Recreation Interbay Golf Course Contact: Robin Kordik, (206)233-7938 The Interbay site was purchased by the City in 1939 and operated as a landfill until 1956. After 1962 the s~te was operated as a driving range and golf course until it was closed in 1992 to allow for the addition of clean earth fill at the site in accordance with the Department's Golf Course Master Plan. The new golf course is scheduled to be opened by labor day of this year. The site has an active landfill gas extraction system which passes gas through a carbon filter. Landfill gas is a major problem, probably because the site was a tidal wetlands before landfilling began. The site has been covered with additional fill material (220 000 CY) to help control gas migration upward through the landfill cap. Settlement has not been a problem, but is expected to be a concern when the golf course begins operation. City of Seattle Parks and Recreation Soccer Fields Contact: Robin Kordik, (206)233-7938 The city owns a former landfill that was closed pre;RCRA on which soccer fields have been constructed. The major problem at the site is settlement, which causes depressions in the surface of the playing fields. The ci~' has had go bring in extra fill yearly in order to keep the fields smooth. Leachate seeps are also a problem at the site. Harborside Golf Course, Chicago, IL Contact: Frank Kudrna (630-969-3060), Dick Nugent (847-438-5222) Harborside Golf Course was built on a landfill that stopped receiving waste 30-40 years ago. Since the landfill is so old, very little degradation of waste,~and therefore very little settlement of waste is now taking place. Therefore, settlement is not a maintenance problem. Landfill gas control is not required since the landfill has stopped producing methane gas. The landfill was recently "closed" by placing an 18-inch low-permeability cap over the entire landfill. Since nc trees are allowed to be planted on the closed area, some landfill features were constructed using de_watered sludge from the waste water treatment plant. City of Charlotte (NC) Parks Department Renaissance Park This closed landfill was converted into a park which includes soccer fields and a golf COurSe. This site is "famous" for an incident thru occurred about two years ago when a "soccer mom" attempted to re~rieve a ball from a hole that had formed around alight pole (assumed to be caused by settlemenB. She ignited a pocket lighter in order to find the ball, which resulted in an explosion due to methane that was in the bottom of the hole. The explosion blew her back several feet. but did not result in major injury. The golf course section of the park has experienced settlement due to the decomposition of waste. Problems caused by settlement include breaking irrigation pipes, depressions in golf cart paths and tilting greens. Some leachate seeps has been observed at the park. Trash "popping" up through the landfill cover has also been a problem. Palm Beach County, Fla. Parks and Recreation Dye Park Linda Hodgkins John Booth, Dir. Of Engineering 561-640-4000, ext 4404(LH), 4600(JB) Constructed on a landfill closed in 1989. Opened in the summer of 1997. The facility includes an unpaved mountain bike path, equestrian trails, picnic areas, a remote control model airplane field, soccer and softball fields, pavilions and a 33- acre lake system. Only a small portion of the site was constructed over waste. A closed CDD unit is being utilized for some mountain bike trails. An active gas system is being utilized in which external operations of the system are located in an arearestric~ed to the public. The recreation facility is open to 11:00 p.m. and has an extensive lighting system. Thought has been given to utilizing the gas to power the facility, but such a system is not cost feasible. The authority was obliged under contract with the original owner of the property to construct a recreation facility on the landfill property after the facility was closed. The landfill exists in an upper middle class area of Palm Beach. There are no problems with settlement, leachate seeps, or "pop-up" of the trash. There are no problems associated with the waste. According to John Booth, the facility is being used extensively by the local community and there is little if any public opposition to it. Cambridge, Mass. Parks and Recreations Danahy Recreation Facility Attention: John Kissida, Vice President, Camp Dresser & McKee 617-252-8000 Danahy Park is approximately 50 acres and represents 20 percent of the open space for the City of Boston. The facility was closed in the mid to late 1970s and construction of the recreation facility was completed in 1991. Prior to construction, portions of the landfill received surcharges for approximately m two years, to reduce settlement. All playing fields are on--top of MSW and CDD waste areas. The height of the Waste areas is 60 to 80 feet with an average of 15 feet of placed fill, varying from 4 to 30 feet over the waste. The fill material delivered to the site as CDD. Waste composition is composed mainly of incinerated waste and CDD. The age of the waste varies from 20 to 40 years. Settlement has been monitored at .5 to 1 inch. The site has been regraded due to the wear of the ball fields. The LFG is controlled by a passive system placed around the perimeter of the LF: The passive system is composed of a stone filled trench around the perimeter of the landfill and a monitoring network that exists between the landfill and the trench and between the trench and the property boundary. Landfill gas generation rates have been steady for the past several years. The loss of vegetation on the site is attributed more to the frequent use of the fields rather than the stress of the vegetation due to gas migration. The cap of the landfill is composed of: · 4 to 30-fe~t (15-foot averageI of clean filI. · 6 to 8 inches of sandy gravel. · 6-inch loam. According to John Kissida, the recreation facility is us6d extensively by the residents. Cambridge, Mass. Parks and Recreations Yarmouth Recreation Facility Attention: John Kissida, Vice President, Camp Dresser & McKee 617-252-8000 The facility currently operaces a residential waste drop off center, compost facility and CDD transfer site along with recreation facilities and a golf course. The golf course and many of the recreation facilities were constructed over municipal solid waste. Surcharges were used in specific areas for a period of one year, such as the tee boxes and the greens of the golf course where settlement was of a primary concern. For the most part solid wasce operations are kept separate from golf course and park guests with the exceptions of some locations on the golf course and along the mountain bike trails. An active landfill gas system has been installed with external operations located in an area restricted to the public. Meetings Held With And Information Provided To The Public RSWA holds a Board of Directors public and publicized meeting on the fourth Monday of every month where public comment may be given at/he beginning and end of the meeting. The RSWA's Citizens' Adx4sory Committee holds a public and publicized meeting on the second Tuesday of each month where input from the public is allowed. May 16, 1995 Public Heating before the Albemarle County Planning Commission on the preliminary site plan May 17, 1995 Albemarle Architectural Review Board May 22, 1995 RSWA Board Of. Directors agree to scale back height of proposed landfill expansion from 910 to 800 feet. July 19, 1995 RSWA officials and consultants hold first of three proposed meetings with the Ivy Landfill's neighbors and general community at large to inform them of findings concerning the area August 10, 1995 Second of third public meetings with public on the proposed expansmn of the Ivy Landfill. August 22, 1995 RSWA held its third public meeting held at the Miller School to discuss the Landfill's master plan, groundwater monitoring results, new waste reduction measures, and new programs being proposed and implemented that Mil impact the waste stream. August 29, 1995 RSWA Board of Directors held a regular public meeting where six alternatives to the expansion of the Ivy Landfill. The RSWA Board .withdrew the proposed site plan and voted to have a citizens task force formed to examine the issues surrounding the Ivy Landfill. The Task Force would be made up of three appointees from each jurisdiction (City, County, RSWA) and one facilitator. Thetask force met in public meetings for eleven months. November 28. 1995 RSWA held a public hearing on an experimental permit for waste to compost at the Piedmont Virginia Community College. December 1995 Rivanna Water and Sewer released a commissioned study on water quality in the Rivanna Reservoir by Draper Aden Associates of Glen Allen. The consultants found "no evidence that the Ivy Landfill has impacted the quality of water in the South Fork Pdvauna Reservoir..." July 22, 1996 RSWA's Board of Directors, at its monthly public meeting, hires engineering finn and a local architectural Design firm to design long range use plans for the Ivy Landfill. Meetings Held With And Information Provided To The Public August 1996 City Council, Board ofSu,pervisors, RSWA's Board of Directors. and the Citizens' Solid Waste Task Force'met in a public meeting to discuss the recommendations of that task force. August 22, 1996 DEQ held a public hearing on an expenmemal Waste to Compost at the Ivy Landfill. October 1, 1996 RSWA held its first of two public input meetings on potential phased alternatives for the Ivy Landfill. The University of Virginia's Institute for Environmental Negotiations 'facilitated this and the following meeting. In preparation for this meeting, the Institute met with individualgroups from a?0und the county in order to better understand perceptions involved in this mgtter. Staff and consultants met with other parties such as SOCCA, League of Women Voters, Ivy Steering Committee. October 13. 1996 RSWA held an open "house" at the Ivy Landfill to show citizens what programs RSWA is actually involved in. November 12. 1996 RSWA held its second public outreach meeting on phased alternative uses for the Ivy Landfill. Findings from the first meeting was presented; facilitated breakout sessions were conducted to discuss such options; and a general discussion to conclude the meeting. Note: Through the process, staff, consultants, and the Board members have met with interested individuals and groups as requested. November 25, 1996 Gershman, Brickner and Bratton. a consulting finn, presented five options for the Ivy Landfill's future to the RSWA Board of Directors and public. January 27; 1997 Results from the two public outreach meetings were presented to the public and the RSWA's Board of Directors. March 10, 1997 City Council, Board of Supervisors, RSWA's Board of Directors held a public meeting where RSWA staff and consultants present future options for the Ivy Landfill. The public had an opportunity to respond. April 3, 1997 RSWA holds a public viewing of its new phased utilization plan wkich came directly from the two public outreach meetings. LAND PLANNING ~ DESIGN ASSOCIATES, INC. Landscape Architecture Planning Sanuary 28, 1998 Mr. Ron Keeler Chief of Planning Department ofPlanning & Community Development 401 McIntire Road Charlotesvilie, Va. 22902-4596 RECEJVED J~fl .5 0 ~98 Pl~nn~n · :..~., .g De~t. RE: IVY LANDFILL, END USE PLAN, FINAL SITE PLAN. Dear Ron: As per our telephone discussion of the 27~., concerning actions of the County Planning Commission on the 20*, my understanding is as follows; END USE PLAN Items lf. and lg. Item f. 'Planning staff approval of landscaping/buffering measures of landfill improvements from Rte. 637;' Resp. This landscaping has been installed. We believe, and hope, that it is adequate to screen and buffer as suggested. My understanding is that you will personally go out, next week, and look at this and call me to let me know if the landscape is adequate or, if additional screenin~uffering is required. Item g. 'VDOT approval of a planting agreement for any landscape materials within the public road right-of-way;' Resp. We do show some spots of minor planting within the right-of-way and will contact VDOT to assure thal thi~ is acceptable or, make appropriate adjustments. P.O. Box 1606. Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Virginia Beach. Virginia FAX (804) 296-2108 (757) 497-4218 (804) 296-2109 Ib~li~v~ that this accurately r~flects'our conversation. Ifther~ are any omissions or misstate, please let n~ know at your earliest convenience. For Land pI.nnlng & Design Associates, Inc., I am, Very truly yours, 1L Start Tatum, ASLA, CLA Vice President cc: Steve Chidsey, RSWA RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY P.O. BOX 979 CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA 22902-0979 (804) g77-2976 February 3, 1998 Mr. Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning County of Albemarle Department of Planaing & Community Development 401 Mclntire Road - Room 218 Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Keeler: The issue of litter control from uncovered vehicles has be~n referred to the Citizens' Advisory Committee for evaluation. I am enclosing a copy of a memorandum regarding that area of concern. It details the State Code as well as what a number of other jurisdictions are doing concerning non-secured/uncovered vehicles entering a landfill. As specified under End Use Plan 1E, the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority is presenting the following language for approval for its sign concerning uncovered vehicles: Please cover all vehicles. Blowing litter is a violation of State Law. We propose that this sign be placed immediately before the scale house so all the vehicles can see it. Please let me know at your earliest convenience if this language ~s acceptable so that I may order the sign. In addition, I will keep you informed as to the Citizens' Advisory Committee's recommendation concerning covered vehicles. Please contact me if you have any additional questions concerning this matter. Sincerely, Steve Chidsey Director of Solid Waste sc/ii Enclosure PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER Word Shared/L&M/Steve/Keel~r -Sign RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY (804) 977-2976 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: SUBJECT: DATE: Arthur D. Petrini, Executive Director Steve Chidsey, Director of Solid Waste Liuer Control - Uncovered Vehicles January 22, 1998 On January 20, the Albemarle County Planning Commission raised several questions concerning litter control for materials being transported through the County to the Ivy Landfill. As you are aware, enforcement of the State Code (Motor Vehicle and £qmpment Safety) is under the jurisdiction of either the local or state police departments. It is also important to note that the largest portion of the vehicles delivering waste in an uncox, ered manner to the Ivy Landfill (pick- up trucks) is exempt from regulations under the Stale Code as shown under Section 46.2-1156 B. as enclosed. The staff has performed a sun'ey 'of five jurisdictions similar to the Rivanna Solid Waste Authorig, to determine their uncovered vehicle policies. The only jurisdiction operating with an enforcement policy is the Roanoke Valley Resource Authority. The Roanoke Valley Resource Authori9, has a S10.00 per load surcharge if a load is uncovered. This regulation applies to delivery of MSW and construction and demolition wastes. Waste delivered either in plastic bags or trash cans is exempt from any regulations under the Roanoke Valley policy and is considered covered. I am auaching a copy of the State Code and our survey results for your review concerning this manor, as well as some information from Roanoke Valley. Roanoke Valley indicated that the establishment of this rate fell under ~he Virginia Water and Sewer Act; therefore, it required a public hearing as to this rate increase. It might be appropnme that the Citizens Advisory Conwnittee be asked to examine this issue to :tevelop a recommendation to the Board. Feel free to contact me if you have any additional questions concerning this matter. sc/ii Enclosure Attachment 51 in in .'ay the 11, 7 et r or :r or - for rlO - Or and arJy .s, of ~s of -':ion ;6.2- ~hall such 350, iph. -1127 46.2-1152 .MOTOR VEHICLE .~'<D EQUIPMENT S.~'ETY § 46.2-1156 weight of the two vehicles rests upon an axle or axles of the to~ng vekicle, pro;tried the towed and to~<ng vehicles each are within the weight limits ,p, rescribed in §§ 46.2-1122 t,hrough 46.2-1127. This section shall not permit ',he violation of any ]a~'.u, ll> establis?ed load limit on any bridge. For the purpose of tl-2s section, emergency includes to~'ing disabled inoperative vehicles to places designated by owners. ~1958, c. 541, § 46.1-339.1; 1977, c. 472; ~9S9, c. 797.) § 46.2-1152. Certain tow trucks need not be weighed. -- Notwith- standing any other pro~sion cf la,w, no ~ruck designed and equipped for the ~ozrng of inoperative or disab!ea moor vehicles shall be required to be weighed at sta;e-opera~d pe~anent weighing s~adons when not actually en~a~ed 5n to;~dng another vehk]e. ¢59S4. c. 95, ~ 46.1-339.2; t9~9, c. ~27.) § 46.2-1153. Permissible lengths of combination vehicles being :owed in emergencies. -- In an emergency as ore,tided in § 46.2-1149, the ~cwrng of ~isabled ;'ehicle~ w.h/ch ~annot be s~pfrated for safety, physical, or r, echardcal reasons and w~Jch e~ceed len~h m ts es;abl shed in .~icle 16 ~} 46.2-11t2 et seq.) of this chap:er, shall be permissible for the purpose of ;;~nna any such re,cie ;o;he nearest facility which can make the necessa~' :epaifs but not more than 5~y miles from ;he point such vehkle w~ disabled. Code ~950. [~ 46-328, 45-32~: ~$50. p. 665: 1952. c. 842; 1956, cc, 476, 483; 2~5~ c. 541. i! 46.1-S30.46.~-S55: ~962. cc. 115. 575; 1964, c, 2S6; t966, cc. 59, S73; ~972, c. 446; 1974, cc. 5~0. 664: 1975. c. 104; 1978, c. 254; 1983, c. 515: ~9~. c. 426; 19S6, cc. 72.4!7: ~$~9, c, 727.) § 46.2-1154. Length of vehicles; exceptions in case of breakdo~-n. -- The orovisions of § 46.2-ii!8 -.?all not apoly :o vehk]es ~j'kich, because of a mec~a~c~ bred;down or an a.cifenl, are ~owed to the ne¢rest repair whkh can ~sh the recu!red sec,Joe. In any such case such connection may ~ona~s; solely of a .chain,' rope, or cab]e of no more than fiReen feet long. !Stormed ~ver shall be a~ ~he ~on~ro]s of;he towed vehicle to brake, steer and ~-~ - 543, $ 46.1-~7; lssg, c. 727.) 3-=,~ ct£ 20. Lozc'e cud Cargoes. § 46.2-1155. Fasteni.ng load of logs, barrels, etc. -- No vehicle wkich is designed or used for the pur~o_~o of hauling logs, poles, lumber, barrels, has'heads, or other materials c~' containers which by their nature may s~ or roll, shall be opera~d or moved ca any h~ghway unless its load is securely fastened by adequate ]o~ chains, metal cables, nylon webb ag, steel straps or other restraining des5ces so as :o :revent t~,e }oad from shiking or falling kern ~he vehkie. ~bacco hoasheads ~av, ho~e~ er, be secured by ~anfla or hemp ~o~e, at least five-eighths inch ~n ~ame,er, cf su~cient stren~h securely to fa~ten the hogshead against s;ffk~n~, falling, or re]Hug. Nothing in this section shall :e'.e~e the owner or operator from liability for failure ~ hse reasonable care :o prevent ;he icad kern shiking or falling. (Code ~Sd0, ~ 4~-308; 1~54, c. ~4; ~55, c. 541, ~ 4~.1-304; 1972, c. 64; 1989, c. 7270 § 46.2-1156. Construction, maintenance and loading must prevent escape of contents; load qovers; exemptions. -- A. No vehicle shall be operated or moved on any highway un]ess it ~s so constructed, maintained, and loaded as to prevent its contents ?rom dropping, sifting, leaking, or other*rise 591 § 46.2-1157 ?OLleE. CRIMES AND OFFENSES, ETC. § 46.2-1157 escaping. No pro,?ion of this s,e, ction, however, shall apply t0 any (9 .motor vehicle whkh is .u, sed e×clusive]~ for ag;dcultural purposes and which ~s not o~erated on any pab]ic hi~.hway for any purpose other ~han m~ng M'~hwav or alo-n~ a h~gh~om ~e p~ ~f ~he owner's land ~ ~o~er ~spec~ive of w~ether the ~racts ~djo~n; (fi) s~cul~ural resole, ~ac~r, or other vehicle exemp:ed ~om re~s~r~fion and llcens~ng requlre~en~s pursuit ~o ~cle 6 (~ 46.2.~2 e~ seq.) of Chs~ter 6 of this fi~]e; or (fid motor veMcle w~nspo~in~ pou]~r~ ~r ]~vestock. B. The lo, ds cf all ~rccks. lraflers ~nd sem~trmlers ca~%g ~avel, sand, coal or other nona~cu]tursl and nonf~rest~' products on intersta~, or seconda~' hiahwavs :.r roads mainlined by cities, counties or incorpor~d t~x~ms ~ha]l b~e thor ,'?~ secured to the vehic e n wblch they are transposed ~r ~ii) covered'. Public se~fice company resoles, pickup tmc~, emergency snow remc. vaI equipment while engaged in snow reform ~pera- ti~ns shaI1 be exclude~ f:om the prcv~sions o~ this subsection. (Code 1950, f 46.307; 1958. c. 54L ~f 46.1.303.46.1-401: ~975, c. 553;~979, c. ~o. ~9;c 1989. 526, 727; 1992, c. 149.) c. 21; 1986, c. 6~ ...... cc. 662. ~97: cc. The 1992 ~men~ent de~e~d 21. § 46.2-1157. Requirement oflnspection; we]l.drilllng machlnery~ an- tique motor vehicle excepted. -- The Superintendent may compel, by proclamation of ~he C~vernor or otherwise, ~e owner or operator of any moor vehicle, trailer, or semkrafier re~stered in % ~r~nia and operated on a ~hway ~fithin this Comm~nweakh to submit his vehicle to an inspection of i~ mechan~s~ and equipment by an ~c~al inspection station, desi~ated for that purpose. ~n accordance ?.'kb ~ 46.2-~58. No owner or operator shall ~1 ~ submit a motor vehicle, tra~ler, or semhrai]er operated on the highways in ~s Commonwealth to such ~nspection or ~afl or refuse to co,eot or have co=ec~d in accordance ~th the requirements oft~s title any mecha~cal defects found bs' such inspection to ex,st. The pro~sions of tb5s sect ~n requ ~ng safety inspections of motor resoles shall also apply to vekYcles used for fire fighting; inspections of fire-fight~g ve~c]es shall be conducted pursuant ~o repletions promulgated by the 8upefin~ndent of State Police, ~ng into consideration the speciM pu~ose of such vehicles and the~on~tions under whkh they' operate. Fi~e-fighting vehicles located on Tanager Island are exempted from the requirements oft~a section. Each day cluing wkJch such motor vehicle, trailer, or semitrailer is opera~d on any highway ~n th~s Commonwealth aker failure to comply ~th t~s law shall constitute a separate offense. However, no penalty shall be imposed on any owner or operator ~cr ope?ation of a motor vehicle, trailer, or semitrailer aker the expiration of a ;.efiod fixed for the inspection thereof, over the most direct route between the place where such vehicle is kept or garaged and an o~cial inspecffon staffon. ~or the purpose of having it inspected pursuant to a p~or ~ppointment ~Sth such station. 592 S Survey: ,Non- Secured/Cover Loads Entering Landfills Henri¢o · Does not tuna away vehicle if Icad is unsecured. · Scale anended infernos customers xxhlh unsecured loads about slate code and asks lha future loads be secured. · Signs are posted at the scale house regarding liner comrol and necessity of securing loads, · Flyers are also handed out on a case by case basis. · Staffmaintains~heroad. · No additional fee is charged for unsecured leads. Augusta Co. · Does not turn away vehicle if;ca:] is unsecured. · Landfill is located on a stare read :hat VDOT cleans. · Road is also maintained !'y an ad¢pt a highway ~oup. · Phson labor is also used :o maintain the road. · Staff also mainlams Ihe road. · No additional fee is charged for unsecured loads. New River Valley · Does not turn away vehk]e if lead is unsecured. · Grounds keepers regularly pick-up liner on road. · Also use people who need to work off comn'~unny servke hours to pkk up litter on road. · Police wi]l periodically ticket people on ~he road if their load is unsecured. Also send out press releases to inform the ~ublic about xhe police presence (similar to the locally amounced radar sites for speeding). · No additional fee is charged fc, r unsecured loads. Roanoke Does not mrn away vehicle if load is unsecured. Hand out fee schedule that staes :heir policy lo charge a $10.00 fee if load is not tied down or properly secured. Prince William Co. · Does no~ rum away vehkle if]cad is unsecured. · Handout titter notices · Have police at the ]andfitl to licker people who do not comply · No additional fee is charged fc, r unsecured loads. k'you ~4 I~= mot= ~o~z~o~ ~ut r¢~'~g or ho,~=hotd h~'do~ ~:= ~os~, pt~c ~k for K~'s ~s Fac ~oper Dhpos~ ~c ~o~cct ~d for ~ ct~ ~ok: V~:F. ~ ~u f=r ~ ~o~ V~'s ~. S_NOUDD.~LLS.N7 DISPOSAL RATES RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY P.O. BOX 979 '- CHARLO"i-FESVILLE, VIRGINIA 22902-0979 (804) 977-2976 January 23, 1998 Mr. Ronald S. Keeler Chief of Planning Coumy of Albemarle Dept. of Planning & Community Developmem 401 Mclntire Road- Room 218 Charlottesville, VA 22902-4596 Dear Mr. Keeler: I am writing to you in response m the action taken by the Albemarle Plarming Commission on January 20, 1998, pertaining to condition 1E of the Ivy Landfill End Use Plan. It is anticipated that the Authority's Board of Directors may take action ar its January 30 meefmg in regards to litter control on vehicles regulated and unregulated under the Code of Virginia. Following the Board meeting (and dependent upon any action taken), I will forward to you proposed wording for signage at the Ivy Landfill relative to vehicle covers. I appreciate your assistance in this matter. Sincerely, Steve Chidsey Director of Solid Waste SC/jj Dept. PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER Word/Shat ed~L&M/S teve/Keeler - Ivy LAND PLANNING & DESIGN ASSOCIATES, INC. Landscape Architecture Planning September 9, 1997 Mr. I~k Kelsey Albemarle Cotlnty Engineer County Office Building 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, Vir~nia 229024596 RE: Ivy Landfill End Use Plan Dear Mr Kelsey: Please find enclosed our submittal for the Ivy Landfill located on State Rotae 637 in Albemarle County, Virginia. You Will find the following enclosed: I. 14 sets ofGradlng & Landscape drawings, sealed. 2. 14 Final Site development plan checklists. 3. 1 Final submittal fee for $900.00 We would li~ to request variences for the following submittal requirements: 1. We are submitting the plans at 60' scale vs. the requested 20' scale. 2. A specific Site Plan at 20' scale for the transfer station area is not included. As this is a permit by rule situation and will be submitted to DEQ. (You will be copied on the DEQ submittal.) 3. Spot elevations end slope data are shown on the grading plan in lew of 5' contour intervals, per our discussion on August 7, 1997. P.O. Box 1606, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Virginia Beach, Virginia FAX (804) 296-2108 (757) 497-4218 (804) 296-2109 SOCCER FIELDS IN THE IVY LANDFILL: THE POSITION OF THE IVY STEERING COMMITTEE Many people in Albemarle County and Charlottesville believe that the Ivy Landfill is closing and that it is being converted into a recreational area with soccer fields. THIS IS UNTRUE. Current plans for the Landfill involve: · Building a transfer station to receive household garbage (including household hazardous waste); · Building a large-scale food-waste composting operation, which will not be enclosed in a building; * Expanding the Landfill by building a new cell for burial of Construction and Demolition Debris. It is important for the citizens of Albemarle and Charlottesville to realize that what is being proposed IS NOT Landfill closure and conversion to a park. What IS proposed is the insertion of a strip of soccer fields into an active landfilling op~rolion. If this proposal is acted on, the soccer fields will be bordere4 by the new burial cell; by dump- trucks carrying Construction and Demolition Debris to the cell; by an opan-air transfer station, in which garbage trucks empty their waste into a tractor trailer; and by piles of composting food and agricultural wastes held under conditions which arc not likely to adequately control odors and vermin. The soccer fields themselves will be built on top of an existing garbage cell wbich is still emitting gases and oozing toxic leachalc. The Ivy Steering Committee is in favor of converting the Landfill site 'into a park, and believes that this can be done without jeopardizing the safety of our clfildran. However, the best way to accomplish this'is to close the landfill to burial of any new garbage. Once the Landfill is remedialed it may be possible to.build playing fields, especially in the less-contaminated areas which now am proposed for new waste burial cells. However, we do not believe that playing fields can safely be inserted into a Landfill managed by the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority. Our experience with the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority over the past three years has been that, in almost every case they select the cheapest possible option. Their short-sighted, penny-wise and pound-foolish attitude has received an eager hearing with the Board of Supervisors, who refuse to face the necessity for increased taxes, whether for schools, parks or environmental protection. It is a son~ reflection on our Supervisors that in a County of 45~0,000 acres the m~ty place they can find for our children to play is in the midst of an active Landfill. This is an attitude which should not be acceptable when the safety of our children is at stake. We urge you to speak and write to the members of the Board of Supervisors in favor of increasing the recreation areas and eliminating the landfilling at Ivy. >For the Ivy Steering Committee: >David Booth, President >Patricia $1ohoda, Vice-I~resident >Ed Strange, Treasurer >Michael Weber, Legal Committee Jack Marshall's remarks at the January 20, 1998, meeting of the Albemarle County Planning Commission Item SDp 97-110 Ivy. Landfill End Use Final Site Plan t~m Jack Marshall, Chair of the Board of the Rivanna ,Solid Waste Authorfty, and I'll introduce this request with some background and general comments. Art Pet~ni, the Executive Director of the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority, will then answer your questions or direct them to the appropriate staff memoer or consultant. AS you know, the RSWA - working closely with the city and county - is in the process of making significant changes in the way our community handles solid waste. These strategic decisions have been driven by, among other things, changing market forces, new waste management technology, our recognition that the Ivy site. big as itis, nevertheless has a finite functional life as a landfill; and vocal concerns and some good sugcjest~ons from some of the neighbors of the Ivy Landfill. This planning of new approaches for local waste management actfvifies has occured in the context of expanding knowledge and awareness about environmental safety, and requirements imposed by federal, state, and local regulations. We have also had to factor in the need to build and maintain a bank account of millions of dollars to cover closure and post- closure expenses and the costs of remediafing problems. Additional millions will be socked away for our environmental contingency fund, to pay for possible unanticipated problems in the future. If the Rivanna Authority is not able to generate the money for these essential purposes, we would reluctantly have to turn for the funds to the local city and county gevemments and their taxpayers. With these issues in mind, last Spring we asked the Albemarle County Board of Supervisors and the Charlottesville City Counsellors to select among.a range of thoroughly researched options. Both bodies selected Qption 7(a), and the Supervisors reconfirmed their choice in November. In order to comply with that guidance, we intend to stop landfilling Municipal Solid Waste (household garbage) at the Ivy Landfill, instead directing it to huge commercial mega-landfills in Henfico and Sussex Counties. Another significant part of OI3tion 7(a) is the plan to continue accepting construction and demolition debris (CDD); it will be buried in state-of-the-art lined cells at the Ivy Landfill, after it is first carefully culled for materials that can be re-used or re-cycled. All other cells will be capped and closed. We also intend to re'double our efforts to reduce our community's waste stream with new technology for turning organic waste into compost. We are here tonight because implementing Option 7(a) will result in changes at the Ivy Landfill in the use of some of the land there, for which we need your approval. Specifically, the RSWA is prepared to spend additional funds as we close some of the calls so that they can be used for recreation, as the public has requested. Moreover, we'll install supplementary landfill gas collection mechanisms that should eliminate any concern about the safety 'of kids playing there. We'll build berms and fences to separate the recreation area from the waste management functions that continue on the site, and provide some of the costs of a. separate roadway to the recreation fields. Also in this site plan is a transfer station, the waste-to-compost fadlity, and the gas- management station. We are prepared to answer any questions you may have about them. A huge amount of thought and analysis has gone into the end use plan. In addition to our own experts~and consultants, wa have solicited ideas and opinions from the community dudng the past~three years [see list, distributed in advanca]. We have tried to incorporate the recommendations of.the Solid Waste Task Forca, of city and county e!ected leaders and staff, of trash haulers, of producars of construction debris and of organic waste, of citizens who live near the landfill as well as those in the City and in the far comes of the county. it's no surprise, I guess, that the plan before you tonight does not please everyone. Though I believe we have taken huge constructive steps toward protecting the long- range interests of all the residents of the county and city, you'll hear tonight arguments that we haven't gone far enough, or that we're moving .in the wrong direction. In fact, we think the plan before you transform an existing public resourca into an even mere valuable mixed use site, incorporating both solid waste management and community recreational use. I know that your deliberations on our request will be guided by the need to represent broact community interests rather than narrow special interests. And I trust that you will request data to substantiate claims, and examine the quality of evidence; the validity of an argument is not proved by the emotional intensity of the proponent. I hope that you will NOT allow the discussion of this site plan, representing our progressive f~ture solid waste activities at the Ivy site, to be COnfused with our ongoing and effective efforts to deal with the problems we inherited from ~ land-filling practives. And I hope youwill encourage speakers NOT to re-visit the overall strategic TOT~_ P. 03 plan - since twice recently our supervisors have approved Option 7 (a) -- but to address the degree to which our proposed end use plan meets the overall strategic objectives in a way that is safe and cost-effective for the whole community and doeas not decrease the overall quality of life. ~natly, we think the Planning Department's report is thorough and its recommendations and conditions make sense. I urge you not to postpose a decision tonight. The deferral of this item from your meeting agenda six weeks ago pushes us pretty dose to deadlines to avoid inconvenience and added cost to our customers, and financial penalties from our contractor. Whatever you decide, we'll have to more quickly to implement it. Now let me introduce Art Petrini, who will handle your questions; LWV League of Women Voters of Charlottesville and Albemarle County 1928 .Arlington Boulevard ROOm 105, Charlottesville VA 22903-1561 phone: 804-970-1707 htt p://aven ue. org/Iwv Iwv~avenue.org fax: 804-970-1708 January. 20. 1998 To: Albemarle Plaumng Commission From: League of Women Voters Re: SDP 97-110 Ivy Landfill End Use Final Site Plan The League of Women Voters supports the proposed improvements to the Ivy Landfill site that will: 1~ Enable the carryi. 'rig out of activities already approved by. the County, City and Rivanna Solid Waste Authority and 2) Allow for conversion of part of the site to public recreational use. The previous approval of Option 7A virtually assures its implementation as long as RSWA receives the required permits. Therefore. we hope that the discussion and decisions tonight will remain fccused on the pertinent issues, We feel that the mini-transfer station, the composting oporation, a gas capture and management system and upgraded recycling/reuse facilities have been thoroughly investigated and their value to the commumty documented. The conditions recommended by Planning staff for the approval of the End Use Plan assure that erosion control and pollution prevention will be properly addressed. They. also respond positively to some concerns of the Ivy. landfill neighbors. The proposed change in the usage of part of the landfill from waste disposal to recreation is laudable. It meets the goals of the Comprehensive Plau~ fm a ~,dl lu~u~,,~ ~.t fw ~:.~t, fields-let .m,,' y,,-*h. Again- the conditions recommended will provide for the safety and well-being of both users of the recreational areas and nearby neighbors. While we would encourage further analysis of the recreational activities and their cost to the community, we wholeheartedly support approval of this change in usage. '...a non-~arti~an orl]ctrtizatio*t ~i~tcate~'to tFte.promotfon of informeaFa~r active jJartic¢ation of citize*t¢ 1. Introduction Hello, my name is Bill Mueller. I am the Executive DireCtor for SOCA (the Soccer Organization of Charlottesville-Albemarle). I have been asked to speak on behalf of the best interest of the participants of this organization. Thank you for allowing me the oppommity to present our views. Specifically, I am here to urge you to approve the end use site plan which has been presented to you this evening· 2. SOCA- ~ SOCA is a private, non-profit, volunteer, conlmnnity service organization devoted to providing a full range of soccer opportunities to the Charlottesville- Albemarle commumty. It is our mission to provide effective, high q~ality, soccer programs which develop both player skills and citizenship through enjoyable participation. SOCA is open to all youth and adults in the Charlottesville Albemarle area. This past fall season we enrolled over 3,100 players in one.ormore of our '-'-~any~programs. We estimate that over 6,000 households in the community have either a current SOCA participant, or have had one in the recent past. I would like to ask the members of the audience who are affiliated with SOCA, and whose interest I represent tonight, to please rise. (TURN TO AUDIENCE). These are some of the many people which I represent. These folks have come here tonight to demonstrate their commitment to the proposal before you, and to further urge you to approve the proposed site plan. 3. SOCA's Role SOCA's role on the community !s to provide a positive athletic 'experience suitable for all interested participants, young or old, male or female, novice or elite player. We are a comm~mity service organization providing an opportunity for constructive behavior. As the single largest provider of youth and adult sporting oppormm'ties in the area, we serve a major portion of the local population. We estimate approximately one of every five families has a current or recent affiliation with SOCA. We are eager to continue to serve all these people, and serve them well. 4. Dilemma At present, we are faced with a dilemma. Virtually every public athletic playing facility in both the City and the County, are being used at or beyond their · . . . capacity. C~ur ability to prowde the --m-,,~,-~J to the cornmumty ~vhidr~ -~-to-se, n~, ~ impaired. The use of the existing playing fields by our organization and. other sporting groups has exceeded the capacity of the fields to support that use. The fields are simply over-used· There are too few fields for the use of a growing population with an increasing interest in organized sports. And soccer is the major culprit. For you, as public servants, these are a good problem to have. You have an energetic population, interested in devoting time to a healthy, positive endeavor. You have an active, commtmity-minded group eager to Organize these activities and provide opporttmities for the citizens. What is missing are the fields on which to play. Here is where you can help us to help the community. By approving the proposed site plan, you will be putting into action the resolution of the missing critical piece of the pnz~le. Your approval will provide some of the much needed facilities for the community. The need for fields within the Charlottesville-Albemarle area is well documented. As you are no doubt aware, the Albemarle County Parks and Recreation Department has been gathering information, and preparing a study,~/~ the use of all playing fields by all groups Two issues are clear; the ~fi~ ,st, that there are too few fields, and that what fields do exist are over-used and~n~aintamed. The second issue is that if SOCA's (soccer's) field shortage problems are resolved, then the resolution of similar problems for the other sporting groups becomes much easier. SeCA submitted a report to the County Parks and Recreation Depa~huent indicating that we are currently nine fields short of a reasonable number needed to effectively nm our programs. That deficit is expected to continue to grow over the next five years. The problems of over-use and overcrowding on the playing fields should not be addressed by restricting participation, rather, these problems m.m_~ust be resolved by adding facilities for f~q use by the community. 5. Opportunity Therefor, we see the conversion of a portion of the Ivy Landfill into playing fields a,s a wonderful oppormmty tg., ,tlxn a contentious issue into a true community asset. The fields indicated ~n the~ a~ will help us to fi~lfill our mission. We see multiple benefits not only for our group specifically, but also the commlmity as whole. Some of these benefits are: · The reduction of wear and tear on existing playing fields. · A reduction in conflicting requests for the use of playing fields. · A probable increase in participation, with more youth involved in constructive athletic activiti6s. · These fields would help to serve the needs of the Ivy comrmmity, where we have about 550 youth players. · The opportunity to hold festive, community building events in a location where there are fields available to serve a number of participants. 6. ( Site Pla~ *' ~-~%'~ ~ I have reviewed the proposed site plan and met with members of the RSWA staff I have found that the plan for the recreational facihties addres~our safety concerns. I believe that the recreational facilities and the operations ofthe RSWA can coexist. The separation of the recreational and operational automobile entrances is a beneficial feature. The separation of the operational facilities from the playing fields by use of grading, berms, fences and planting will enable us to use the fields without fear. of unsafe interaction with the operations. The times when the fields would be scheduled for .use will primarily not coincide with waste management operations. We trust that the RSWA will continue to monitor the condition of the site to see that it rem~in~ safe and suitable for recreational use over time: We further trust that proper actions will be taken to evaluate, remediate, and monitor any portions which pose a threat to public health and safety. 7. Conclusion Finally, we understand that the chance to put these playing fields in place has a limited window of oppommity. There is an urgency to getting the plan approved soon. Because of the specifics of the landfill operations, any si~ificant delay in implementation of t_he proposed plan may ,,near, th/$ oppommity is lost for all time. I hope you won't let that happen. I hope you will jom us in our efforts to put kids on the playing fields, by approving the proposed site plan tomght. Thank you for your t/me and attention and allowing us to participate in this process. Benjamin Walter January 17, 1998 Hello, my name is Benjamin Walter. Last year, my science class became involved with the landfall and has offered input at several key points in this process. I come before you tonight to tell you that what is being proposed,is what we and the commtmity as a whol~ed for. In a survey that my classmates and I did last year, we asked hundreds of Albemarle County citizens what they would like to see happen to the landfill. The vast majority of those surveyed said that they wanted a park with recreational facilities including soccer fields and playgrounds. The plan that has been drawn up reflects what the commnnity has requested. There are several fields that can be used for sports such as soccer and lacrosse. For parents with younger children, there are two playgrounds where those children can play while their siblings are in a sports match. In addition to those who wanted a recreational park, there were some who wanted the area to be restored to its original state. This has also been included in the site plan. In fact, the plan calls for the fields 'to be in the middle of the area with the natural habitat surrounding it thus acting as a buffer. This buffer greatly reduces any noise and light that could disturb the surrounding residents. Many citizens have been concerned with whether or not making the landfill into a park is safe. They fear that methane gas and other variables might make it dangerous to have people participating in activities at the proposed park. However, many experts have been brought In to inspect the landfill and determine whether it would be safe or not. These experts have determined that it is, in fact, safe. Not only that but in the proposal there is a gas management station that will monitor the gases and make sure that they are at acceptable levels. County citizens have also voiced concerns about whether the proposed park will be successful and worthwhile. Nevertheless, this type of park has been implemented in other areas and the success rate is very high. One such example is the ever-famous Mount Tmshmore. We expect that this park will be even better because of the high amount of input that has come from the community. In short, the plan that has been proposed is what the community wants and it will work. Thank you for your time. March 4, 1998 1. Finding recreational use to be consistent with Comprehensive Plan: I move that the Bd of Supervisors agrees with the Planning Commission that recreational use at the proposed site is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, being an opportunity for cost- effective use/reuse of public land, but, as staff recommended: "no County expenditures should occur until the Board has made a positive finding under section 5.1.14 of the Zoning Ordinance" [p.3 of staff report] [this is the requirement that involves gas-management provisions] and, as the planning commission recommended, the recreational use will be a part ora Board- approved master Plan that includes the extent and final contours of the grading, '~0ps and slopes of att the cells and proposed cells before settlement, stormwater management plan and mitigation measures for the entire property and addresses future uses for the entire property, Mitigation measures include location and description of the treatment of gas. surface water and ~ound water, springs: and streams, and monitoring mechanisms. The plan must show buffers and plans for management and preservation of the buffers and limits of disturbance within buffers. Also to be inelnded are plans for plantings and landforms to rednce visual impacts and enhance the long- term appearance for it to look as much as possible like indigenous pasture land. This detailed master plan must be aoproved by the Board of Supervisors, with citizen participation. The Bd. also recognizes that p~niltting of landfill-related activities such.as ~ound,water remediation and gas management rests in the hands ofDEO andwe cannot preempt that responsibility. The site is far better than the '~figh and windy knoll" which would have dominated the view for drivers as they come down Gilliam's Mt. Rd and for some homes in the Peacock i-rtl subdivision and Malvem Farm, which was originally proposed. 2. The site plan which includes the landfill entrance, "encore" center, composting area, MSW transfer station and gas management area should be approved so that burial of MSW at the Ivy landfill can stop on schedule this summer, but approval is subject to the following conditions, as recommended by the planning commission, with a few amendments: a. Engineering Dept approval of an erosion control plan b. Engineering Dept approval of the location, design and operation of the tire wash facility to prevent off-site tracking of mud from unpaved roadways; c. Engineering Dept approval of leachate containment measures for MSW transfer station ~a0 e, omposting operation if En[.qneering Dept finds that to be necessary, il, Engineering Dept. approval ofthe aefive aeration _system or other process used.to canrure or r,iluqO ajay offensive odors associated with composting operations at that site. E.Engineering Dept approval of method of MSW transfer to ensure that transfer activity is desi_maed and managed so as to reduce wind-blown debris and exposure to precipitation, thereby minimizing the volume of leachate and milli/nizing the danger,, nuisance: or unsightliness to ad_Joining prop_ erty or activities,* F Planning staff approval of strong measures to prevent uncovered vehicles from entering or using the landfill, including, but not timited to, approval of a sign regarding state and Albemarle County. Code applicable to loads' being covered or secured in vehicles. The sign shall be approved as to location and wording by the Planning Staff and shall be considered as a sign as required by the Planning Commission under Section 32.7.8.1' of the Zoning Ordinance. G. Planning staffapproval of landscapinggouffering measures of landfill improvements from Rt. 637, Dick Wood's Road. so as to shield from pasaing autos the sight of the transferring operations. H. VDOT approval of a planning agreement for any landscape materials within the public road fight-of-way; i. Demonstration to the County Attorney of compliance with all applicable provisions of the Code of Virginia as related to cemeteries and places of burial of the dead; j Engineering Department approval of a Stormwater Managemem Plan consistent with Section 32.7.4.2 of the Zoning Ordinance. K. Review and approval by the Facilities Management'subcommittee of the RSWA Citi?en~ Advisory_ Committee of compost-mixing building's and gas management silo's external appearance, color and design, 2. The Board of Supervisors has reserved reconsideration ofthe transfer ofCDD at~er 2 ½ years. The Board may require installation of a lef~ mm lane to serve the site at that time or at an earlier date.upon determination by VDOT Xhat warrants have been satisfied. *~ote this does not require a building for the transfer operations. Our "7A" decision effusively precludes that option as it does not provide the funding for other than this tmck-to-tp~ek ltran~l'er system. If this system is unsatisfactory_, we and City_ Council will have to return to that decision. I regard our reconsideration of CDD after 2 ½ years of operation, as an opportunity to do so._l 3. Board defer approval of the preliminary sate plan submitted for recreational use (with its curvilinear parking), at least until master plan has been approved by the Board. Delayed approval will also allow us all to see the transfer station and composting activities, etc., in operation and determine suitability of land next to these operations to be in active recreation. Will be easier to judge when we can see it for ourselves rather than imagine it. 4. Board not deal tonight with the zoning ordinance approval of recreational use on a landfill, dependent on the gas-handling system, until some time at~er the master plan has been approved. No County expenditures within our CIP should occur until the Board has made a positive finding under section 5.1.14 of the Zoning Ordinance. Our action doesn't provide the guarantee that neighbors crave: that operations will not expand out of control. As ½ of RSWA, it is our responsibility to keep it under control. I would like to explore making the detailed master plan a part of, and amendment to, the Comprehensive Plan, as a possible way of cementing the extent of the pIans. Anything can be changed, and perhaps staff can arrive at a better solution, but I would like us to find the best possible way of giving neighbors a suriW as to the extent of the operations on this site. I would like advice from the staff on methods for doing so, at a later meeting. Ella Carey From: Sent: To: Subject: MR EDWIN L STRANGE SR [SJRY14A@prodigy.com] Tuesday, March 03. 1998 5;04 PM apetdni@dvanna.org; writeinsal@aol.com: bowerman@cs[one, net: jepascarel@deq.state.va.us: ecarey%acva@co.albemade.va.us: chumphds% acva@co.albemade.va.us; fmarshall%acva@co.albemarle.va.us: cmartin% acva@co.albemade.va.us' wperkins%acva@co.albemade.va.us: wdr8j@virginia.edu; jhpiggott@deq.state.va.us; ecouric@dc.net; del_harris@house.state.va.us RE: NOISE BEYOND WHAT IS ALLOWED BY DEQ Dear Art. Thank you for inqu~nng as to the source of my statement that DEQ had indicated in their reports that the off site noise from the Ivy Landfill is beyond that allowed. You will find it on page 2 of the 8/8/95 DEQ compliance report. It is again referenced in a 10/23/95 follow up letter from DEQ addressed to Steve Chidsey. You might want to check with him. he should have a copy. In the interest of saving lime debating this before the BOS at 4:00 PM Wednesday and thereby taking up valuable time which would be better spent debating other issues such as whether we should be expanding this leaky old dump at all (it will be larger as a result of this plan), I will attempt to put this to rest. If I may be so bold as to anticipate your response. I suspect that you will be quick to point out that the incident was blamed on heavy equipment involved in a "temporary" project. To which my response will be that there is always a "temporary" project ongoing. As of late it, has been the demolit on of the hard rock in the proposed new cell area which Bob Tucker and I wonder if it isn't diamond (and not rock since the beginning of the "two week project" was in early October. Should the cell actually be completed and utilized,, the noise from the day to day operation will replace that noise as the sound will ~e projected at me by cell 3 lined (not cell 3 UNLINED where you are now filling) in the background. In closing: I do hope that you are aware of the risks involved in this expansion plan. (1) The RSWA will be constructing a waste cell within 10 feet of the water table in an area that DEQ has stated to me they would like to place a monitoring well. You may well lose valuable data regarding the rate and extent of the contamination as well as contribute new contamination to the groundwater. You may recall that Sally Thomas stated 11/5/97 at the BOS that she had !,.e. amed that eve ,w, thing that was considered construction debris was not so nice_ Why DEQ would approve this project is beyond me. Perhaps they won't and then we can ship it out along with the rest of the garbage and the RSWA will be assured of $4.00 for every ton received. (2) The negative impact of this project will surely lower the neighborhood auality of life as well as PRIVATE PROPERTY values as you will be landfilling on the edges of your properoj. I do hope that you have factored this into your bottom line projections, as this expense will eventually have to be paid. (31 You are going into business and will be competing against seasoned professionals for an uncertain (uncontrollable) waste stream and while your expenses are mostly fixed your income projections are just that, projections. Good Luck and thanks again for asking..... Ed Ed Strange P.O. Box 6084 Charlottesville VA. 22906-6084 (H) (804) 977-7929 (E) SJRY14A@PRODIGY.COM "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them." - Albert EinStein Original Recipient: ECAREY.DVSEMAIL @ ACVA Ella Carey From: Sent: To: Subject: MR EDWIN L STRANGE SR [SJRY14A@prodigy.com] Thursday, February 26, 1998 8:05 PM wdteinsai@aoLcom; bowerman@cstone.net: ecarey%acva@co.albemarle.va,us: chumphris% acva@co.albemarle.va.us: fmarshall%acva@co.albemarle.va.us: cmartin% acva@co.albemarle.va.us; wperkins%acva@co, albemarle.va.us SOME CONCERNS RE:IVY DUMP EXPANSION PLAN Regarding BOS review scheduled for March 4. 1998 of the proposed Site Development Plan (SDP-110) Ivy Landfill Some of the neighborhood concerns are: Visual Buffer Noise Buffers Odor Air Pollution and Off Gassing Surface Water and Groundwater Pollution Storm Water and Erosion Control Visual Buffer: The e)evations of the landfill's perfect geometric ceils at 750 feet of elevation have stolen our views of the mountains and have visually polluted our homes and ~roperty. The impact of the Rivanna Solid Waste Authority's (RSWA) landfilling operation has expanded above the tree line and to the edge of their property and beyond. Many of the trees that provided a year round visual buffer of the landfill have been cut within the last three years. The Albemarle County Comprehensive Plan indicates that landfill operations should be visually buffered from private residences. The site plans should not be approved without definitive plans that show how our homes and the 1-64 entrance corridor (per Comprehensive Plan} are to be visually buffered from this eye sore. Noise Control: The Ivy landfill site is on a rock ridge with streams that surround the site to the North, East and West. This tilted site configuration acts as a megaphone that blasts the neighbors across the valleys created by the streams to the North and West with noise beyond comprehension while the noise in the landfill appears quite minimal. The Department of Environmental Quality has indicated in their reports that the off site noise from the Ivy landfill is beyond that allowed. We ask that you understand that the acoustics of the site will require noise barriers to protect the neighbors from the physical stresses of noise that continue to affect our health. Noise barriers to the West and North must be required if any form of landfilling operation is to continue in these areas. Odor: Our files are so thick with odor complaints that I won't even attempt to discuss this subject except to suggest that a; forever binding; non-retractable; non~waiverable requirement be placed on this Authority that requires daily soil cover of at least 6" be used to control odor if any landfllling of any type, MSW or CDD is to continue. There should be no chance of this Authority ever being given an option to use any cover material ather than the DEQ required 6" soil cover at a minimum for the duration of any landfilling at this site. Air Polldtion: The dust. the odor and the methane and other hazardous substance off gassing from this site became a major concern to us as we learned more about the nature and magnitude of off gassing that occurs from landfills (40% of all Methane is produced from landfills). There should be no hesitation about requinng full scale gas capture and control at this facirity. The RSWA has a gas capture plan but has not submitted it. We do not want to be subjected to gas flaring or leachate (garbage juice) boil off as has been suggested by the Authority. Clean off gassing centrel as provided by Fuel Cell technology would be the preferred method. Surface water and groundwater pro?ems: The Ivy landfill has moved beyond its boundaries with off site flows of solid waste and chemical discharges to the ground and surface water. The Ivy landfill site has been, and is now. out of contrel with regard to solid waste and eroded soil discharges onto private property. The amount of sediment that is being washed down stream from this mumcipat site should have caused an immediate cease and desist order by the appropriate officials. There should be a resounding NO to further landfiIling on or near the streams in the Ivy landfill yet the Authority continues to show future plans to landfill on top of springs that have their headwaters in the landfill (area called clean fill / future meadow on the south-western boundary). In conclusion: The plan submitted by the RSWA is lacking in detail and thereby commitment. What the RSWA is really asking for is approval Approval to build what they want, when they Want, that is once they decide what it is they (really) want. The truth on many issues at this time is, they don't really know. Ask for details. You will be surprised at the answers Remember the sewer line approval? They now seem intent on finding excuses NOT to build it. Don't be fooled again nor let the RSWA back you into a corner claiming time constrainfa. The problems with the Ivy landfill are far more extensive than I can or intend to write about in this letter. My best advice would be to close the Ivy landfill to further ~ndfilling (burial) of any sort and begin the process of healing the site and the neighborhood that it is located in from the ~nvironmental insults that have been inflicted upon it. Ed Strange P.O. Box 6084 Charlottesville, VA. 22906-6084 (H) (804) 977-7929 (E) SJRY14A@PRODIGY.COM "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them." - Albert Einstein Original Recipient: ECAREY. DVSEMAIL @ ACVA Edwin L. Strange P.O. Box 6084 Charlottesville, VA. 22906 January 30, 1998 County of Albemarle I)elmrtmen! of Plannln~ & Commmfity Development 4111 Mclntlre Road Charioltesville, VA. 22902 "i'o whom il may concern, I request a review' of SDP 97-110 (ivy Landfill) by the Albemarle Courtly Board of Sul~ervisors. ~ncerety, Ed Strange OaPd UVR CRNCER CENTER TEL:804-982-0689 Feb 06,98 5:40 No.OO5 F.Ul TO: Pete Anderson Ronald Keeler William Nichtmann Jared Lowenstein Hflda Lee-Washington David Tico William Finley FROM: Michael Weber~ for the Ivy Steering Committee The attached document clarifies the position of the ISC on the issue of playing sports in the [~y Landfill We support thc conversion of the ENTIRE Ivy site to a park, and have no objection to the ultimate inclusion of recreational fields in that park. We think it is profoundly stupid to insert playing fields into an unremediated toxic waste dump that is being actively used for landfilfing. It is doubly dangerous to carry out that activity when thc dump is managed by an agency such as the RSWA which has en established record of corner-cutting and incompetence. p .nning Dept. ALBEMARLE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS PRESS RELEASE MARCH 4, 1998 The Board of Supervisors is disappointed that City Council has chosen not to accept the Settlement Agreement that we have negotiated with the City over the last nme months and that City Council, instead, has chosen to continue to litigate reversion in the courts at great expense to City taxpayers. The proposed Agreement would have provided the City with additional County funds.to pay, for services for City residents in jointly-funded_programs and would have created a framework for negotiating many other joint-service opportunities. In exchange, the City would ...... ha~e.agreed to remain ~City..for a'~ leasttwenty, years and. County residents wouldrhav~been , .............. protected from any town annexation and loss of additional mx revenues. We felt this Agreement was in the best interest of the entire community. As we have said many times over the last two and one-half years, ultimately the City must decide whether or not it desires to revert to town status. It is time for the City to decide. If the decision is not to revert, and the litigation is ended, the County stands ready to renew discussions to improve the delivery of government services to this community to provide for a more healthy and vital City and County. CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE Office of the Mayor P.O. Box 911 · Charlottesville, Virginia · 22902 Telephone (804) 970-3113 Ov SUPERVISORS March 3, 1998 Forrest Marshall, Chairman Albemarle County Board o£ Supervisors 401 Mclntire Road Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Fo~em: Council has reviewed the County's latest proposal which sought a response from the City on or before March 3, 1998. After almost nine months of trying to negotiate an agreement acceptable to both sides, it is with sincere regret that City Council now concludes that current efforts to reach an accord with the County are not working. Our mutual efforts at creating an equitable formula for shared services and agreeing on the length offinte of relinquishment of the City's right of reversion, unfortunately, were stymied. We, the City Council, felt we were being asked to make a long term, binding commitment on the reversion waiver while the County was to have the legal right to reject its obligations at the end of each budget year. If there is remaining common ground between the two local governments, we think it can be found in those aspects of the proposed Voluntary Sett!eme~t._~,_greement which were intended from the outset to be essentially nonbinding commitments to explbre joint cooperative efforts in social services, fire services, education, planning, housing, transportation, business development and preservation of open space and natural resources. Our door remaing open to the County if and when the Board of Supervisors wishes to explore any particular cooperative ideas outside of *3e context of Reversion or a Voluntary Settlement. ...... · Forrest Marshall March 3, 1998 RE: Reversion NegotiaHons Page two Finally, I want to express appreciation on the part of the Council for all of the time and energy expended by you and other members of the Board and by County staff as everyone has tried to reach a final agreement. Our inability to f'md mutual ground on a voluntary settlement in lieu of Reversion, does noth'rng to lessen the continuing need to work together in the future. The larger community expects as much. Existing and proposed City-County projects deserve such an effort. Let's move on to those areas which will prove fruitful. S~c~e¢, Kay Slaughter Mayor cc: City Council Gary O'Counell Clyde Gouldman PRESS RELEASE March 3, 1998 For approximately nine months, the City and County have been trying to reach an agreement that would prevent the need for reversion. After much deliberation, the Council believed that a negotiated agreement could help to combine certain functions and facilitate cooperation between the City and County in a purposeful way rather than through wholesale changes under the reversion statute. It is our view that a healthy and vibrant city is essential to the County, and we regret that we have been unable to complete a final, legally binding agreement at this time. Consequently, in response to the Board of Supervisors' request, we believe that under the present circumstances, efforts at f-~ther negotiation make little practical sense. The Council concluded that a voluntary agreement would be preferable to initiating reversion proceedings which would take many years and would not affect many important issues: revitalization of the core city; equitable and joint provision of many services, including fire; and support for affordable housing in the region. Despite the failure of any overall agreement, the City and County had agreed to consider a number of important ideas, namely: To negotiate a long term agreement for provision of service and coverage from the City's professional Fire Department. To engage professional assistance in pursuing an agreement to combine social services deparrmems; To request the School Boards to create a Joint Commission on School Excellence through Combined Efforts, which would explore educatiunal opportunities identified by the Board of Supervisors and City Council in December 1995~, To inslx'uct the Planning Commissions and staffs to develop and improve community wide planning; To work cooperatively on the City's Pen Park housing initiative within the County; To expand the County Housing Committee to include city representation and to develop support for joint housing goals, i.e. more middle income housing in the City and affordable rental housing in the County; To annually review opportunities for expanding Charlottesville Transit Service and County Park and Ride lots: To explore the mutual benefits of the City's efforts to attract business and middle-income housing and the County's efforts to provide orderly development and preservation of rural areas and natural resources, including the public water supply. Council is still interested in exploring these and other cooperative ideas outside of the context of Reversion. We also believe that the City and County should find a more equitable way of sharing the community's resources ~o address joint services. While we were able to reach preliminary agreement about a formula based on fiscal s~ress, use and population, we were unable to find a way to guarantee that the formula would continue in place during a proposed 20-year moratorium on reversion initiatives. Despite the failure of formal negotiations at this time, we remain open to working with the County to expand areas of cooperation that will mutually benefit the entire region. 1 Charlottesville and Albemarle agreed several years ago to consider provision of some cooperative or consolidated joint school services, including magnet schools, summer schools, summer school enrichment programs, alternative schools, networking of computers between the two systems, staff recruitment and development, and adult education. COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Board of Supervisors LeeP. Catlin, Cornmunity Resources Coordinator, County Executive's Dept.~(~" March 6, 1998 Invitation List for Neighborhood Connections '98 Conference As was suggested by Sally Thomas at the March 4 Board meeting, I am attaching a copy of the invitation list for the Neighborhood Connections '98 conference scheduled for March 21. The attached list is our entire FYI newsletter mailing list - I have checked off those neighborhood associations/leaders on this listwho received an invitation to the conference. In addition to those people checked off on the attached list, we have also invited PTO presidents, Blue Ridge Apartment Council members, the DISC committee and real estate developers and managers. We would be very happy to send registration information to anyone else you think might be interested. Also, you are cordially invited to attend any or all of the conference. If you would like any additional information, please let me know. Ms. Tina Adams Hunter's Creek 2230-B Commonwealth Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Adelphia Cable Communications ATrN: Mr. Dell Hanley 324 West Main Street Charlottesville VA 22902 AlbdCh'ville Regional Jail Authority ATrN: John R. Isom, Superintendent 1600 Avon Street Extended Charlottesville VA 22901 Albemarle HoUSing Improvement Pro. ATTN: Theresa Tapscott, Director 700 Harris Street. Suite #101 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. & Mrs. David AHen Route 633 5627 Cove Garden Road Covesville VA 22931 Ms. Anne Marie Amiel Turtle Creek 140 Turtle Creek Road, AFt. # l0 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. James M. Ammons 500 David Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Mrs. Ellen L Andersen 2620 IGmbrough Ciralc Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Lisa Anderson Huntwood 960 I-Iuntwood Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Samuel A. Anderson, ~I Office o£the Architect, University of Virg~a The Rotunda, South East Wing Charlottesville VA 22906 Mr. Mark Andrews Route 706 1768 Dudley Mountain Road Charlottesville VA 2290] Mr. Bruce Angus 2 Farmington Heights Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Jane Arbogast Village Square - Phase One I092 Towne Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 ~pArbor Lake Townhouse Association · O. Box 8084 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Brenda Arrington Route gl, Box 112 Keewiek VA 22947 Mr. Floyd Artrip Milbum Estates 1205 Lafayette Lane Charlottesville VA 22902 ~shcroft Neighborhood Association 1990 Sassafras Circle Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Harold Atkiuson Westminster-Canterbray 250 Pantops MountainRoad Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms. Chris Audino Wildwood 1109 Cottonwood Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. George W. Bailey Board of Zoning Appeals 1667 Bailey Retreat Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Elizabeth Baker 1375 Earlysville Forest Drive Earlysville VA 22936 The Honorable John E. Baker Chairman Albemarle County School Board 2220 Rid#away Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 /~Mr. Martin Ballantine Farmingten 1 Tenuis Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. William Barber P. O. Box 581 Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Dennis Barberio Rural Route #23, Box 78-A Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Nancy Barnett P. O. Box 492 Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Gary Bartolacci CON-AGRA Route # 1, Box 24-A Crozet VA 22932 Mr. David Bass Board of Zoning Appeals 1864 Anchorage Farm Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Thomas E. Bass 1715 Merfiefielda Lane Ruekersville VA 22968 ~gB00edford Hills Homeowners Associatio Madison Drive Earlysville VA 22936 ~/~Mr. Roderick Beitzel Myrtle S~reet 736 Myrtle S~xeet Crozet VA 22932 ~Ms. Maria Bell 520 Nottingham Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~Mr. Richard Q. Bell KEARSAGE 660 Kearsage Circle Charlottesville VA 22903 v~ellair Owners Association ATIlq: RalphL. Fell P. O. Box 2057 Charlottesville VA 22902 ~Benfivar Neighborhood Association ATTN-: Anne Zimmennann 1890 Bentivar Drive Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. Richard A. Bergen 815 Quail Ridge Circle Earlysville VA 22936 x/~r. Carnice Berti Route 648 332 Clark's Tract Keswiek VA 22947 Mr. Rudolph A. Beverly ARB Member 533 Jeste~ Lane Charlottesville VA 22902 i/~Ir. Bryan D. Bickers Fieldbrook 1814 Hearthglow Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 ~ls. Diane Bicknell M/Il Creek 150 Mill Creek Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. J. Sam Biedler 1278 Millpond Road Charlottesville VA 22902 ~irdwood Homeowners' Assn. P. O. Box 5548 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. Steven W. Blaine ¢/o McGuire, Woods, Battle & Boothe 4t8 E. Jefferson Street Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Thomas D. Blue 100 Chesmut Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Martin Blank 3385 Martha Khags Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Steve Bobick 122 Turtle CreekRoad, Apt. #12 Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable Thomas & Bliley, Jr. 7th District Representative U.S. House of Representatives 2409 Raybum - HOB WashLngton D.C. 20515 Mr. Richard Bohleke 2078 Lomeera Way Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable David P. Bowerman Member Albemarle Board of County Supervisors 401 Beradek Court Charlottesville VA 22901 ~/~[r. Cary Branch Hession Hills 1710 Old Forge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Gloria Bowers Route # 1, Box 146-F Barbonrsville VA 22923 Ms. Edith Brann 1141 Mill Park Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Jim Bowyer P. O. Box 278 Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Everett Wayne Breeden Mis. Frederica G. Breeden 1616 Oweusville Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Melvin A. Breeden Director Depafonent of Finance County of Albemarle Mr. Bernard Breeding Rays Ford Road Route #2, Box 14 Earlysville VA 22936 Mr. J. William Brent Albemarle County Service Authority 168 Spot, ap Road Charlottesville VA 22901 %/Brinnington Neighborhood Watch ATTN: John F. Marshall 3570 Brinning~on Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. W. Wade Bromwelt 256 Rookwood Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Carlton R. Brooks, Sr. 535 East Rio Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Amanda Brown WCBR- Apartment//16 250 Pantops Mountain Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Constance Brown Waverly 3375 Brookside Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Michael Brown P. O. Box 3764 Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Thomas E. Bruce, Jr. WCBR - Apartment #317 250 Pentops Mountain Road Charlottesville VA 22911-8684 Mr. Michael Brunelle 1327 Pin Oak Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Leroy A. Bruton 2576 Free Union Road Charlo~esville VA 22901 Ms. Imogene Bunn 250 Pantops Mountain Rd,, # 121 Charlottesville VA 22911-8681 v~r. Paul Burke Orchard Acres 1255 Peachtree Drive Cmzet VA 22932 Ms. Ethel Burns 3192 Roiling Road Scottavllle VA 24590-9765 Ms. Cindy BurtOn 1600 Running Deer Drive Keswiak VA 22947 Mr. E. Buschman 275 Audubon Drive Earlysville VA 22936 v/Mr. James Busi Glenake 3820 West Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Business Ear ATI2xI: Bethe ]U~pFer 3480 Langford Drive Charlottesville VA 22905 v/~Mr. Bruce Butler Newburg Iteights 1805 Fiddlestick Lane Charlouesville VA 22903 C-VILLE Weekly ATTN-: ltawes Spencer I00 W. South Street, #1 Charlottesville VA 22902-5039 Ms. Susan M. Cabell Vice-Pres,Human Resources Martha Jefferson Hosl~tal 459 L~cust Avenu~ Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Cleveland C. Campbell Route #2, Box 177 Charlottesville VA 22901 Dr. Robert W. Cantrell Provost University of Virgima P. O. Box 179 Charlottesville VA 22908 Ms. Para Carmagnola 1905 Craigs Store Road Affon VA 22920 Ms. Sadie Louise Cart 1625 Cool Spring Road Charlottesville VA 22901-1378 Ms. Sarah Cagle News Deparlment The Daily Progress 685 W. Rio Road Charlottesville VA 22901 .,,/~r. Dougas E. Candler Solaris 1 l~elios Path Barboursville VA 22923 Ms. Ella W. Carey Clerk Albemarle Board of County Supervisors Ms. Libby Carpenter 2669 Kendallwood Lane Charlottesville VA 22911 ~arrsbrook Neighborhood Association ATrN: John Wokott 210 Carrsbroak Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. James L. Camblos, m commonwealth Attorney County of Albemarle Ms. Cass Cannon Public Information Officer City of Charlottesville P.O. Box911 Chaflottosw/lle VA 22902 Mr. Brian K. Carlson Regional Vice-Prec. State Farm Insurance Company 1500 State Farm Blvd. CharloResvlllo VA 22909 Mr. Rory Carpenter Director Children & Youth Commission P.O. Boxgll Charlottesville VA 22902 ~arrsbrook Neighborhood Associatio ATrlq: Mike Bates 106 Powhatan Cimte Charlottesville VA 22901 · vd~s. Beth Carta Candlewyck 1870 Cobblestone Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 x~r. Duanne Carter Nob Hill 430 Stribling Avenue Extended Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Janice Carter 3 Windsor Road Charlottesville VA 22901-3225 Mr. John 1L Carter 5465 Markwued Road Earlysvillo VA 22936 Dr. Kevin C. Castner Superintendent of Schools County of Albemarle - Education Depu Ms. Deborah A. Caruso lll-B Middlesex Drive Charlottasville VA 22901 Ms. Janet Candle 6114 Belle Drive Crozet VA 22932 Dr. John T. Casteen, Ill President University of Virginia Madison Hall, P. O. Box 9011 Charlottesville VA 22906-9011 Cavalier Daily ATTN: Editor Neweomb Hall, University of Virginia CharloResville VA 22903 CFNV Cable Company ATIN: News Department 1147 River Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ch'villedAlbemarle Airport ATTN-: Bill Pahuta 201 Bowen Loop Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms. Roxanne Chandler 213 Turkey Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Carol Chandross Oak Forest Circle 68 Oak Forest Circle Charlottesville VA 22901 Charlottesville Business Journal ATi~: Stave Johnson, Editor P. O. Box 9030 Charlottesville VA 22906 Charlottesville/Albemarle Tribune ATrlq: Agnes Whita P. O. Box 3428 Charlottesville VA 22902 ~C~hris Green Lake Neighborhood Assn. ATTN: Kathy Bryant 4419 Chris Green Lake Road Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. V. Wayne Cilimberg EMrector Planning & Community Dev. Dept. Citizens for Albemarle, Inc. ATIN: Karen Dame 3375 Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ks. Maureen Clark Garden Court 1644 Garden Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr./Mrs. Roy Clark Route #2, Box 128 North Garden VA 22959 Mr. Arthur W. Clinger 1529 IGnross Lane Keswick VA 22947 Mr. Richard Cogan Board of Zening Appeals P. O. Box 417 Crozet VA 22932 X~Colston Neighborhood Association ATTN: Dr. Munsey Wheby 3660 ColstonDrive Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Mary H. Coleman 1288 Ashton Road Keswiak VA 22947 The Honorable Emily Couric 25th Staata Senate District P. O, Box 5462 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. Robert CoHins CEO GE Fanuc P. O. Box 8106 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Betty Cox 37 Spring Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Pat Craft Education Ch~Lrperson Blue Ridge Homebnilders Association 2330 Commonwealth Drive, Suite 100 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Joseph $. Cragwall 2600 Barracks Road, Apt. #385 Charlottesville VA 22901 t.~r. Danny Craig Green Mountain Acres P. O. Box 177 Keene VA 22946 MrdMrs. Wade Cromer 3482 Roiling Road Soattsville VA 24590 Ms. Treva Cromwell 558 Worthington Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 L~2rozct Community Association 1205 Red Pine Court Crozet VA 22932 v~rozet Neighborhood Association ATrN: Tom Loach 1255 Baybe~ Court Crozet VA 22932 Ms. Valerie L. Cunningham Magistrate Albemarle County Magis~rate~s Office 309 East Water Street Chaflottosville VA 22902-5239 Ms. Charlotte B. Dammann 2958 Barrsden Farm Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. William Crutchfield President Cmtohfield Corporation 1 Cmtehfield Park Charlottesville VA 2290 Dr. Gloria D'Alessandro 2935 Meriwether Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable George W. Dansey Scottsville Town Council P. O. Box 395 Senttsville VA 24590 The Honorable Russell Madison Cum Member Albemarle County School Boaxd Route 1, Box 553 North Garden VA 22959 Mr. Hovey S. Dabney Jefferson National Bank P. O. Box711 Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Kathy Dansie 1301 Cmekside Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Larry W. Davis County Attomey Albemarle County ~AgIr. George Deilaganna Bedford l-fills 955 Madison Drive Earlysville VA 22936 Mr. Patrick Dempsey 1932 Arlington Blvd., Suite #3 Charlottesville VA 22903 w~Ms. Susan Dempsey Watererest 3026 Watererest Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Jennnl. e Densmore Route #2, Box 493 Keswick VA 22947 Ms. Martha Derthick 57 Georgetown Green Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Sam Y. Desaz 1601 Rio Hill Drive, Apt. # 102 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Damon Devito 1701 -B Solomon Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Jane D. Dittmar President Chamber of Commerce P. O. Box 1564 Charlottesville VA 22902 '~unlora Property Owners e/o Capital Management & Develop. 1305 Wisconsin Avenue, N.W. Washington D. C. 20007 Dr. Don E. Detmer Senior Vice-President University of Virginia P. O. Box 9016 Charlottesville VA 22906-9016 Dr. Deborah M. DiCroce President Piedmont Virginia Community College Route #6, Box 1 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. A. Bruce Dotson 2282 Whippoorwill Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Joe Duquette P. O. Box 5821 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. Mike Devine Route #1, Box 644 North Garden VA 22959 MrdMrs. Ronald G. Dimberg 105 Viewmont Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. M. C. Duncan P. O. Box 787 Scottsville. VA 24590 Ms. Marianne Durrer Franklin 1776 Franklin Drive Charlottesville VA 22911 Earls3Mlle Area Residents' League P. O. Box 684 Eaflysvilte VA 22936 ~r. Jonathan Earl Lake Reynovia 1650 Stonecrop Court Charlottesville VA 22902 ~Earlysville Forest Homeowners Assn. P. O. Box61 Earlysville VA 22936 ~Earlysviile Neighborhood Association ATTN: Lisa Harmen 4530 Mill Run Lane Earlysvllle VA 22936 ~dnam Community Association 2 Boars Heed Place, #260 Charlottesville VA 22901 ~"Ednam Village Owners Assn. 1112 East H/gh Street Charlottesville VA 22901 ~. Frank Edwards Locust Hill 2825 Locust Hill Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Christina EIzey 939 Wolf Trap Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~Ir; Dennis Elkin Merion Greene 750 Marion Greene Charlottesville VA 22901 Emergency Communications Center ATTN: Thomas A. Hauson, Direetor P. O. Box 911 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Bryan O. Elliott Director of Aviation Ch'vi/de/Albemarle Ai~ort 201 Bowen Loop Charlottesville VA 22911 t~s. Jeanne Erickson Claymont 96 Claymont Drive Earlysville VA 22936 Ms. Mary H. Eustis 2107 Minor Road Charlottesville VA 22903-1740 Ms. Darcn Everette 1274 Swan Lake Drive, Apu 103 Charlottesville VA 22902 ~MS. Joan Faruque Minor l-lill Manor 1519 Westfield Court Charlottesvile VA 22901 Mr. Theodore M. Feinblatt 1455 Bremerton Lane Keswiek VA 22947 Ms. Elizabeth Ferguson 1035 Earlysville Forest Earlysville VA 22936 '~. Jo Ann Ferguson Langford Farms 165 Lan#ford Place Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Louise Fernandez 1488 Minor Ridge Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Alfred Fernbach 11 Orchard Road Charlottesville VA 22903 ~Fl'eldbrook Neighborhood Association ATTN: Dan Pettit 1658 Redington Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Francis Fife P. O. Box 557 Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Carol Finch Route #23, Box 408 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. William W. Finley Albemarle County Planning Commi~s£on Route #1, Box 251 Free Union VA 22940 ~Mr. Andrew Flood Bruncblands 1232 Gazebo Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Mary Forbes 116 Turtle Creek Road, #2 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Chariie R. Flora 300 Spring Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 ~Forest Lakes Community Assn. P. O. Box 8084 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Robert P. Flynn 208 Alpine Court Charlottesville VA 22902 ~oForest Lakes Neighborhood Assn. ATIN: John MacDonald 1910 Barron Court Charlottesville VA 22911 ~'~is. June Foster Minor H/Il Townhomes 1438 M/nor Ridge Court Charlottcsvillo VA 22901 ~Four Seasons Townhouse Assn. P. O. Box 6389 Charlottesville VA 22906 L~r. Joe Frankowski Whispering Woods 2090 Tavemor Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Sharon M. Frazier Clerk Albemarle County Circuit Cour[ P. O. Box 1651 Charlottesville VA 22902 ~r. Lockwood Frizzell Bellair t7 Canterbury Road Charlottesville VA 22903 '~s. Jennifer Frei Autumn Woods 3171 Autumn Woods Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~r. Mike Fulton Berkeley 124 Commonwealth Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~Mr. Robert Freund Mallard Lake 330 Mallard Lane Drive Earlysville VA 22936 ¢~r. Jeff Gaffney Cove Po/nt 2999 Cove Trace Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable Susan Clayton Gallion Member Albemarle County School Board 3558 Lofflands Drive Earlysville VA 22936-2452 Ms. Nancy Garner 1505 Minor Ridge Court Charlottesville VA 22901 L~r. Fred Gerke Proffit 2365 Proffit Road Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. Rim Gardner Farmer's Home Administration 695 Berkmar Court, Suite #3 Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Sara J. Genthner Town Admiuistrative Official Town of Soottsville P. O. Box 395 Scottsville VA 24590 Mr. Jim Gilbert Westmoreland 509 Berwick Court Charlottesville VA 22901 C-~r. & Mrs. Bob Garland Canterbury Hills 105 Woodhurst Court Charlottesville VA 22901 L~orgetown Green Homeowners P. O. Box 5642 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. James Gillespie I191 Raintrce Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Tom Giiliam 206 Rowledge Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Pynke Gohanner Lyles Deputy Director Monticello Area Comm. Action Ageacy t025 Park Street Charlottesville VA 22901 ~raemont Homeowners Association ATTN: Dan Jones, President 3955 Graemont Drive Earlysville VA 22936 L/Ms. Victoria L. Gilman Wakefield Road 2303 Wakefield Road Charlottesville VA 2290 t - 1843 The Honorable Virgil H. Goode, Jr. 5th DishSet Representative U. S. House of Representatives 104 South First Street Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Gary Grant Route #1, Box 216 Earlysville VA 22936 The Honorable James S. Giimore, m Oovemor of Virginia State Capitol, Third Floor P. O. Box I475 Richmond VA 23219 Ms. Lynne Govornhk 3557 Deer Ridge Farm Charlo~esville VA 22902 I~Mr. & Mrs. Erik Greenbaum Beaumont Farm 3152 Beaumont Farm Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Ruth Greene 344 Westfield Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Sandra L. Greenwood Boar's Head Inn & Sports Club P. O. l]ox 5307 Charlottesville VA 22905 Greg Baldwin Realty 115 South Pantops Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. lt. B. Grekila P. O. Box 792] Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Jane Greyson 2700 Gray Fox Trail Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Warren E. Grupe 350 Barracks I~ill Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. James E. Haden President Martha Jefferson Hospital 459 Locust Avenue Charlottesville VA_ 22902 Mr. Michael J. Halseth Executive Director UVA Medical Center Me~aeal Center Box 148 Charlottesville VA 22908 Mr. J. B. Harlow 1204 Bixham Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mrs. William E. Hale 3 612 Rolling Road Scottsville, VA 24590 Miss Jennie Hamilton-Thorne 358 Thnrston Lane Glory Farm Faber VA 24590 ~s. Nena Harrell Briarwood P. O. Box 5548 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. Tom Hall A~rne Design Technology Company 1000 Allview Drive Grozet VA 22932 Ms. Virginia Hamrick 710 W~ndfiR Drive Earlysville VA 22936 Ms. Jane Mayo Harris 2406 Angus Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Martha Harris 4615 Pelham Drive Earlysv~lle VA 22936 ,/Mr. Steve Hash v W~ndrift 745 Windri~ Drive Earlysville VA 22936 The Honorable Paul C. Harris 58th Dish-iet Representative Virginia House of Delegates P. O. Box 1276 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Terry W. Hawkins Sheriff County of Albemarle P. O. Box 203 Charlottesvflle VA 22902 MS. Cynthia Hash 2065 Whispering Woods Drive Charlottesville VA 22911 Mrs. Mary B. Hayes The Colonnades, Unit C-3 2600 Barracks Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. James M. Heilman Registrar Albemarle County Registrar's Office Mr. & Mrs. Pete Hellmann 6980 Green Creek Lane Schuyler VA 22969 Ms. Karen Helm Route//6, Box 291 -N Charlottesville VA 22902 The Honorable Stephen H. Helvin Judge General District Court x/~r. John Herr West Wood 2545 Cedar Ridge Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Cole Hendrix Asso. VP-Comm. Relations UVA Health Sciences Comer Box 571 Charlottesville VA 22908 Mr./Mrs. John Herrmann Route #5, Box 241 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. John Hermsmeier 1465 Stoney Creek Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Harry C. Hewett 1480 Stable Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Rob Hewitt Route # 1, Box 93 Alton VA 22920 [,,'Hickory Ridge Owners' Association ATTN: Howard Curtim Pres. 705 Martingale Lane Earlysville VA 22936 Ms. Alice M. Hill 5757 Park Road Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Glen W. Hill HCR-05, Box t09 Madison VA 22727 ~istorlc Scottsville Community Assn. P. O. Box 339 Sootlsville VA 24590 t~s. Katie Hobbs League of Women Voters 337 Carcsbrook Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~Mr. Ed Hobson White Hall 4744 Sugar Hollow Road Crozet VA 22932 ~s. Susan Hodges Meriwether Hills 2780 Leeds Lane Charlot~sville VA 22901 t~r, & Mrs, Tom Hoclscher Poplar Ridge 2083 Liulier Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mrs. P.. L. Hoffman 1070 Blackburn Bluff Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Danny Holley 651 Miller School Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Mrs. Charlotte Hogue 3722 Dick Wood Road Charlottesville VA 22903 ~Hoilymead Citizens Association P. O. Box 8147 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Elva Holland Director Government & Community Relations, UVA P. O. Box 9012 Charlottesville VA 22906 Hotiymead Citizens Association P. O. Box 8147 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Ann E. Holt P. O. Box 194 Free Union VA 22940 Ms. Mabel H. Holt 2600 Baxracks Road, Apt. 251 Charlottesville VA 22901-2192 Ms. Dotty Hopkins 3410 Coleman Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Hopper, Tracey & Campbell, Doug Eastham 2552 Eastham Road Charlottesville VA 22911 I/~VIs. Dotty Hopskins Westga~e 2615-B Hydraulic Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mrs. Jacquelyn Huckle 255 Rayford Farm Earlysville VA 22936 Mr. Allen Hughes 3132 Ridgefield Road Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. John Hulbert 2280 Garth Road Charlottesville VA 22901 The Hon. Charlotte Y. Humphris Albemarle Board of County Supemsors 109 Falcon Drive, Colthurst Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Connie Hund 14 N. Dogwood Lane Charlottesville VA 2290.1 Ms. Susan Hunt Route #9, Box 113-C Charlottesville VA 22902 t~untwood Homeowners Association 1038 Huntwoad Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Huntwood Homeowners Association 1038 Huntwood Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Jeff Hutchinson Virginia Power 1719 Hydraulic Road Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Katherine L. Imhoff Route #2, Box 439 Keswick VA 22947 wl~vy Neighborhood Association ATTN: $~ Showalter P. O. Box 84 Ivy VA 22945 Mr. Thomas A. Jackson C.P.C.U. State Farm Insurance Company P. O. Box 6656 Charlo~esville VA 22906 Mr. Greg Jakubowicz 1834 Charles Court Charlottesville VA 22901 ~arman's Gap Homeowners' Assn. ATTN: Kenneth Diepold 1225 Red Pine Court Crozet VA 22932 Jefferson Area Board for Aging ATrN: Gordon Walker, Director 674 Hillsdale Drive, Suite #9 Charlottesville VA 22901 ~s. Donna Jenkins Echo Ridge 2021 Echo Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Thomas H. Jenkins P. O. Box 122 Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Jay Jessup, Jr. Pepsi Cola Bottling Company P. O. Box 9035 Charlottesville VA 22906 Mr. Darryl Johnson Route #2, Box 88 Keswick VA 22947 Mr. Harold Johnson 4066 Watts Passage Charlottesville VA 229 t 1 Mr; Michael L. Johnson P. O. Box 3182 Charlottesville VA 22903-0182 Ms. Susan Johnson 399 Old Seottsville Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Waiter F. Johnson 1015 Club Drive Keswiek VA 22947 Ms. Michelle Kailmes 2534 Holldaam Drive Chaflotteswille VA 22901 '~earsarge Homeowners' Assn. ATTN: Richard Roberts 678 Kearsarge Circle Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Frank A. Kessler ARB Member P. O. Box 5207 Charlottesville VA 22905 Mr. David W. Jones 1430 Old Brook Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~s. Bess Kane Old Ridge Road 4267 Woods Edge Road Troy VA 22974 Mr. James Kcnnan Associate Vice-President UVA Health Sciences Center Box 583 Charlottesville VA 22908 VKey West Neighborhood Assn. ATIN: Peter Hanchak 400 Key West Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable Jeffrey D. Joseph Member Albemarle County School Board Route #1, Box 1454 Keswiek VA 22947 t~V~s. Lina Kavoulius Waterford 3059 Clear Springs Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Max C. Kennedy Chair Board of Zoning Appeals P. O. Box 5025 Cberlottesville VA 22905 t-~s. Alice Keys Townwood 309 Glade Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Diana Kiesler Route #1, Box 18I-A Free Union VA 22940 ~d~. Gus Kiewra Laurel Hills t440 Birchwood Drive Crozet VA 22932 ~ Julia Kindred-Ashby Jefferson V-fllage 3023 Colonial Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~ Rochelle Koepp Gateway Village 3252 Gateway Circle Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Evelyn Kovacs 2 Monterey Drive Charlottesville VA 22901-1315 The Honorable Stephen H. Kolcszar Vice-Chairman Albemarle County School Board 142 Scarbrough Place Charlottesville VA 22903 ~s. Elaine Kroner West Leigh 2211 Croyden Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. R. Edward Kooncc ChiefAeaountant & Pachasing Agent County of Albemarle - Purchasing Depc Mr. Robert J. Kroner Gilliam, Scott& Kroner, P.C. P. O. Box 2737 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Fred L. Kruger Director Information S~rvices Depr County of Albemarle Mr. Willis G. Labes 1000 Allendale Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. George C. Landrith, HI 1369 Gristmill Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. George Laris 107 Tally Ho Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Fran Lavin MicroAire Surgical Insmunems 1641 Edlich Drive Charlottesville VA 22932 Mr. Warren Laws 2976 Trace Cove Charlottesville VA 22911 4777 Dick Woods Road Charlottesville VA 22903 League of Women Voters ATTN: President 1928 Arliagton Blvd., Room 105 Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Gary Leavel P. O. Box 3780 CharloResvilte VA 22903 Ms, Corinne LeBovit 1309 Branchlands Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Beverly Leonard Fox Field Farm 1125 Tilman Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Joyce Lesich 2216 Wflliarnsburg Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Hunter Lewis Cambridge Associates II10N. Gleb~ Road, Ste. 1100 Arlhag~6n VA 22203 ~'~ewis Hill Property Owners Assn. P. O. Box 337 Ivy VA 22945 Ms. Karen Lilleleht 2984 Meehum Banks Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. C. Timothy Lindstrom AP~ Member e/o Piedmont Environmontel Counfffl t 111 Rose I~ll D~ve Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr, C. Jarcd Loewenstein Albemarle County Planning Commission 2436 Proffit Road Charlottesville VA 22911-5752 Mr. Thomas C. Loach 1255 Bayberry Street Cmzet VA 22932 t~ofllands, Inc. ATTN: Kenneth Youel P. O. BoxC Earlysville VA 22936 Mr./Mrs. Joey Lockhart 126 Woodlake Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 t--'lfls. Mattie Logan Hydaulie Road 2530 Hydraulic Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. John C. Lowry 3475 Red Hill School Road North Garden VA 22959 t,"'Mr. James G. Lunde, Jr. 880 Old Brook Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Judy Lynch 1540 London Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Greg MacDonald Michie Tavern 683 Thomas Joffcxson Parkway Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Ruth Ann Marchi Route #4, Box 137 Charlottesville VA 22911 [,~lr. Carl Marshall Arrowhead 2262 Locust Hollow Road Charlottesville VA 22903 g,,~r. John F. Mm'shaH Brinnington-Ridge 3570 Brinnington Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Michael J. Marshall Route #2, Box 20-A Crozet VA 22932 MrdMrs. Reggie Marshall 1376 Suffers Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Shelby J. Marshall Clerk Albemarle County Circuit Court County of Albemarle The Honorable Charles S. Martin Vice-Chairman Atbernarle Board of County Superwsors 200 Pineridge Lane Charlottesville VA 22911 Wl~s. Pat Mathews Walton 1948 Quinta Das Torres Farm Rd. Charlottesville VA 22903 The Hon. Forrest R, Marshall, Jr. Chairman Albemarle Board of County Supervisors 2356 Scottsville Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Jewel Mason Route #2, Box lI5-A Keswick VA 22947 Mr/William I. Mawyer, Jr. Director Engineering & Public Works Dept. . t/aVis. Ann Martin Hollymead 1585 Poe's Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 t. Aglr. Larry Massie Ridgefield 3155 Summorfield Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Ernst A. Mayer-Aschhoff 2044 Whisporiag Woods Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Robert McAdamg 1649 Cool Spring Road, Townwood Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. John McCauley 1330 Villa Verde Lane Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Amelia G. McCulley Director Building Code & Zoning Serdces County of Albemarle Er. Jack McDonald Edgewarer 3109 Edgewater Drive Charlottesville V/~ 22901 Ms. Jane McDonald 91 Biltmore Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. John McDonald 1910 Barron Court Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms. Virginia C. McDonald Homing Coordinator Office of Housing County of Albemarle ~s. Margaret McDougall Four Seasons 29 Woodlake Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 I,~'l~r. John McDowell Raintree 1086 Snowden Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Forrest McKay Piedmont Virgmia Community College Route 6, Box 1 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Bates McLain 2145 Timber Pointe Road Charlo~esville VA 22911 The Honorable Diantha IL McKeel Member Albemarle County School Board 103 Smithfield Court Charlottesville VA 22901-2252 Mr. Andy Meade 1400 River Oaks Ridge Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Leigh Ann McKelway Virginia Association of Counties I001E. Broad Street, Suite #LL20 Richraond VA 232194901 Mr. Gene A. Meeks Route #2, Box 215 Crozet VA 22932 Mr. Ronald Menti 450 David Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Cathie Metallo 885 Warley Read Earlysvilte VA 22936 Mr. Norwood H. Meyer 2600 Barracks Road, #214 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Timothy M. Michel ARB Member 503 Fauleoner Drive, Suite #5 Charlottesville VA 22901 L~r. Wayne Micheletti WhippoerwflI 2595 Cardinal Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~Iill Creek Neighborhood Association ATTIq: John Hermsmeier 1465 Stoney Creek Drive Charlottesville VA 22902-7242 Ms. Diane Miller 5 Ivy Laue Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. John F. Miller Clfief Police Depalrment County of Albemarle Mr. & Mrs. Kit Miller P. O. Box 133 Esmont VA 22937 Mr. Paul David Miller Spuny Marine, Inc. 1070 Seminole Trail Charlottesville VA 2290 ] Ms. Berlinda Mills Route # 1, Box 200 Esmont VA 22937 G,~Vmor Bill Manor Neighborhood ATI~: Mary Bryant 324 Westfield Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~,~ ~Minor Hill Manor Neighborhood ATIN: Mary Morris 352 Westfield Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Daisy Moga 830 Tanglewood Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Cecil V. Morgan P. O. Box 6 Earlysville VA 22936 Mr. Howard Morraro 360 Heron Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Rowena Morrell Blue Ridge Homebuilders Association 2330 Commonwealth Drive, Suite 100 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Ebon Morrow 3241 Plank Road North Garden VA 22959 Mr. Jeff Moseicki P. O. Box 6825 Charlottesville VA 22906 ~l~s. Elaine Moyers Sherwood Farms 102 Mountain View Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Patrick K. Mullaney Director Parks & Recreation Deparanem County of Albemarle Mrs. James B. Murray, Sr. 333 Panorama Road Earlys~511e VA 22936 Mr. Bill Mustain Comdial Corporation P. O. Box 7266 Charlottesville VA 22906 Mr. Jori Nafziger 6075 York Road Crozet VA 22932-9448 Mrs. Pat Napoleon 168 Campbell Road Keswick VA 22947 V-~r. Rick Natalie Forest Lakes 3220 Malbon Drive Charlottesville VA 22911 Mr. Mitchell Neuman 5066 Spring Cove Court Crozet VA 22932 ~l~Is. Carol Newell Loffiands Wood 3964 Loffiands Drive Earlysville VA 22936 Ms. Ann Nickels Director, Communications/Public Relations Martha Jefferson Hospital 459 Locust Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. William J. Nitchmann Albemarle County Planning Commln-sion P. O. Box 2378 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Robert Nootbaar 2260 Mechum Place Charlottesville VA 22901 [/l~orthflelds Neighborhood Association ATrN: Alice Feehley-Maus 2805 Huntington Road Charlottesville VA 2290 t ~Mr; James Nottingham Montvue 2701 Magnolia Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~ls. Jane O'Brien Harmony 2460 Shady Sl~ng Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Gary B. O'Conneil City Manager City of Charlottesville P, O. Box911 CharloResville VA 22902 X--'I~s. Susan Oliveri Peaoock Hill 212 Turkey Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr./~rs. Herman J. Ortmann 3350 Arbor Terrace Charlottesc~le VA 22901 Ms. Cathy Owen 1500 London Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Dennis Owens 1721 Old Forge Road Charlolt~Mlle YA 22901 L~t~. Mary Ann Pairet Midway 6103 Wild Pear Lane Crozet VA 22932 I.~l's. Vidula Paita Key West 404 Key West Drive Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms. Louise Parham Route gl,Box 24 Keswick VA 22947 r. Vic Parmaiee ~I~ensville 1895 Owensfield Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Linda Peacock Assistant City Manager City of Charlottesville P. O. Box 911 Charlottesville VA_ 22902 The Honorable Paul M. Peatross, Jr. Judge Cimuit Court Ms. Fran Perrotta The Colonnades 2600 Barracks Road Charlotmsville VA 22901 Mr; William M. Patterson Mrs. Jean 1~ Patterson 6082 Rockfish Gap Turnt~ke Crozet VA 22932 [A~e'acock Hill Community Assn. P. O. Box 11 Ivy VA 22945 Ms. Edith Peoples P. O. Box 114 Keswick VA 22947 t~s. Barbara Perry Lc Pare 1347 Le Parc Terrace Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Ann F. Patton Clerk Juvenile & Domestic Relations Court 411 East l:I/gh Street Charlottesville VA 22901 ~]~-acock Hill Neighborhood Assn. ATTN: Alisun Campbell 819 Gilliams Monn~ain Road Charlottesville VA 22903 The Honorable Waiter F. Perkins Supervisor Albemarle Board of County Supervisors 5568 St. George Avenue Crozet VA 22932 Mr. David Pettit P. O. Box 2057 Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Betty Phelan P. O. Box 216 Free Union VA 22940 LMm. Jeanne Pierre Spring Court 36 Spring Com~ Charlottesville VA 2290 ~ Helen Plaisanee Rcdfields 1056 I-Iayrake Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Margaret Posten 335 Fou~ Seasons Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Marilyn Posten 54 Lake Forest Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Karen L. Powell 175 Terrell Road East Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Mickey Price 1328 Pin Oak Court Charlottesville VA 22901 ~l~r. Sterling Proffitt Running Deer 3795 Whitetail Lane Keswiek VA 22947 Ms. Patricia Pullen 607 Big Oak Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Cari J. Pumphrey Division Chief FiredReseue Administration County of Albemarle Ms. Bethany C. Puopolo ARB Membes 3455 President's Read Soottsville VA 24590 Ms. Ruth Raines 1760 Hearthglow Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 AL~T~Nntree Neighborhood Association : Don Lyons 1629 Bnghtfield Road Charlottesville VA 22901 t-l~aintree Neighborhood Association ATIN: John McDowell 1086 Snowden Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Katharine A. Ralston Director Albemarle Co. Dept. of Social Services Ms. Bernice Ramsey 2321 Finch Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Real Estate Weekly ATTN: Tim Sams, Publisher 2305 Commonwealth Drive, gA Charlottesville VA 22901-I 637 Mr. Leslie A. Reaser Director, Building Semaeos County of Albemarle L~dfields Neighborhood Association ATI'N: Helan Plaisanea 1056 Hayrake Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms; Leslie Reed P. O. Box 144 Ivy VA 22945 Mr. W. W. Reisinger 5490 Laurel Ridge Road Ruekersville VA 22968 Mr. Toby Reiter 768 Reas Ford Road Earlysville VA 22936 Mr. W. L. Rennolds Board of Zoning Appeals 1025 Blackburn Bluff Charlottesville VA 22901 Richard J. Funk Builder, Inc. 666 Kearsarge Circle Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Pat Richmond 2395 Kingston Read Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Pete Ricotta 4290 Dickerson Road Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms. Maria Ridge 172-D Georgetown Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. William D. Rieley Albemarle County Planning Commission 2375 Taylofs Gap Road North Garden VA 22959 MrdMrs. Dennis Rinehart 318 Glade Lane Charlottesville VA 2290 ~ Mr. Claude Ripley Route #5, Box 2t8-B Charlottesville VA 22901 ~l~vanna Homeowners' Association ATTN: Hal Brownfield 600 Arrowhead Drive Earlysvilte VA 22936 g/'~ivanna Homeowners' Association ATTN: Bo Rea6, Sec./Treas. 585 Arrowhead Drive Earlysville VA 22936 g/l~vanna River Basin Neighborhood ATTN: I~ane Soderquist 530 Explorers Road Charlottesville VA 22901 L~'vanna River Basin Neighborhood ATI2q: Patt Keats 421 Key West Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Rivanna Water & Sewer Authority ATTN: Arthur D. Petriui, Direotor P. O. Box 18 Charlottesville VA 22902 The Honorable Charles S. Robb United States Senate Russell Senate Bldg., Suite 154 Washington D. C. 20510 ~g~r. George Roberts Stonehenge 5 Cheshire Cout~ Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Guy Roberts 5001 Advance Mills Road Earlysville VA 22936 t,,,~r. Richard Roberts Kearsage 678 Kearsage Circle Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Lois Rochester 103 Shawnee Court Charlottesville VA 2290t Ms. Felicia Warburg Rogan Oakencrof~ Vineyard & Winery Route #5. Box 429 Charlo~esville VA 22901 Ms. Ann Rooker 1800 Roslyn Ridge Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Dennis S. Rocker ~bcmarle County planning Commission 115 S. Pantops Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Waiter F. Rooney University Village 2401 Old Ivy Road, Apt. # 1304 Charlottesville VA 22903 ~r. Tim Rose Colthurst 126 Falcon Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 V~oosemont Neighborhood Association ATTN: Rick Morton 3245 Teerose Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 MrdMrs. Waiter Ross 527 Woodchuck Lane Charlottesville VA 22902-8756 Mr. Steve Runkle P. O. Box 5207 Charlottesville VA 22905 _~r. Dennis Russo Georgetown Greene 25 Georgetown Greene Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. J. E. Sa'd 305 Barracks Hill Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Myrle Sandridge 2062 Lonieera Way Charlottesville VA 22901 ~l~. Roy Ann Sandridge Squi~el Ridge 1871 Pine Cone Circle Charlottesv/lle VA 22901 Mr. Leonard W. Sandridge, Jr. Exes. Viee-Prcs./CFO University of Vkginia P. O. Box 9014, Madison Hall Charlottesville VA 22906-9014 Ms. Allyson Sappington Soil & Water Conservation 695 Berkmar Court. Suite #2 Charlottesville VA. 22901 Ms. Linda Scandore 437 Peacock Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. David Schmidt 352 West Rio Road Charlottesville VA 2290 t-1301 Ms. Becky Schmi~z 425 Rookwood Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 Mrs. Elizabeth Schmitz Samuel Miller District Represe Social Services Board 425 Rookwood Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Sharon Scholl 1805 Owensfield Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Teddi Schrock Ivy Farms II 1771 Lambs Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Jan Schwab 405 Key West Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mrs. Fred W. Scott, Sr. Route #2, Box 30 North Garden VA 22959 Ms. Rhonda Scovill P. O. Box 2804 Charlottesville VA 22902 k~r.& Mrs. Jack Seal Ivy Oaks 1575 Gray Fox Trail Charlottesville VA 22901 Dr. Janet L. Seaie Steff`Development Coordinator Albemarle County Resource Center Ms. Molly Sebastian 1290 Garth Honse Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 MrJMrs. Gunnar Sedleniek 1147 River Oaks Lane Charlottesville VA 22901-7446 Mr. Janel E1 Sennewald 507 Woodmont Drive Charlottesville VA 22901-3741 The Honorable Jannene L. Shannon Judge Juvenile & Domestic Relations Court Ms. Beth Shatin Route #23, Box 424 Charlottesville VA 22911 ~. David Shaw Village Homes of Mill Creek 1316 Creeksi& Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Mary Shea Carrsbrook 103 Cherokee Court Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Lorcn Shelton P. o. Box 1174 Charlottesville VA 22902-1174 Ms. Missy Shenkir 420 Rook'woad Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 Dr./Mrs. W. M. Sheppe 2078 Waluntside Place Charlottesville VA 22901 L~Is. Cathy Shiffiette Bennington-Inglewood 209 Bennington Road Charlottesville VA 22901 L/l~r. Ronald Shuey Emerald Forest 5810 Emerald Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Ida Simmons 9373 Old Green Mountain Road Esmont VA 22937 Mr. Chuck Simon Sheraton Irm - Charlottesville 2350 Seminole Trail Charlottesville VA 22901 ~/~r. Gary Sloan Ivy Farms 800 Ivy Farm Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Catherine Sims P. O. Box 288 Greenwood VA 22943 Mrs. Gene Ecton Smith 306 Westminster Road Charlotteswille VA 22901-2234 The Hon. Katherine E. Slaughter Mayor City of Charlottesville P. O. Box 911 Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Karen Smith 733 Tilman Road Charlottesville VA 22901 L~r. Matt Smith Blueridge 1194 Blue Ridge Avenue Crozet VA 22932 ' Mr. Michael G. Smith 3275 Watts Station Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Milton S. Smith 400 Willwood Drive Earlysville, VA 22936 ~s. Barbara Spears Mount Pleasant P. O. Box 3 Kcene VA 22946 L~r. & Mrs. Bill Spicuzza Bloomfield 575 Bloomfield Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Beth Spindler 1200 Fox Ridge Drive Earlysville VA 22936 SPRINT ATTN: Eddie Lynch 2211 Hydraulic Road Charlottesville VA 22902 ~s. Sherry Stelling Hoards Mountain 7268 Banjo Lane Affon VA 22920 L~r. John Stillweli Edmam Village 5 Ednam Village Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 ~r. Jim Stone Termll 300 Terrell West Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Ed Strange P. O. Box 6084 Charlottesville VA 22906-6084 L,t~. Tom StraSsburg Loohridge Lane 735 Loohridge Lane Earlysville VA 22936 ~ Ann Stratton Woodstook Drive 104 Woodstock Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Diana Stricker 6 Sunset Circle Charlottesville VA 22901 MVIs. Betty Leu Stroh Bmokmill 1158 Mill Park Drive Extended Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. M. C. Sturgis 164 Georgetown Road, Apt. #2 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr.fMrs. Karl Suldey 1653 Miller School Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Paul D. Summers, Jr. Knole Farm, RFD//2 Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Nancy Swaneutt 2594 Kendalwood Lane Charlottesville VA 2291 t Mr. Robert F. Swantz 510 Wellington Place Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Pat Talbott 219 Montvae Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Karen Tarentino Fashion Square Mall P. O. Box 8007 Charlottesville VA 22906 ~ershaH Farms Neighbor. Assn. ATllq: David Booth 531 Tattershall Farm Lane Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Ann Taylor Montieallo Box 316 Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Sherwin H. Terry, Jr. 185 Terrell Road E. Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Ben W. Thacker 699 Taylofs Gal: Read Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Ben Thacker-Gwaltney Community Developcr/Organi?er Monticello Area Comm. Action Agenoy 1025 Park Street Charlottesville VA 22901 The Charlottesville Observer ATTN: Gary G-rant P. O. Box617 Charlottesville VA 22902 The Charlottesville Observer ATTN: Charlotte Stichter 100 South Street P. O. Box 617 Charlottesville VA 22902 The Daily Progress ATTN: Sarah Cagle, News Dep[ 685 W. Rio Roadq P. O. Box 9030 Charlottesville VA 22906 The Richmond Times Dispatch AT12,1: Carlos Santos 520 East Main Street Charlottesville VA~ 22902 The Honorable Sally H. Thomas Superv/sor Albemarle Board of County Supermsors 889 Leigh Way Charlottesville VA 22901-7748 Mr. Michael IL Thompson Director Albemarle County Human Resources Dept. Ms. Prudence Thorener 3140 Plank Road North Garden VA 22959 Thos. Jeff. Soil & Water Conservation ATTN: Alyson Sapl/mgton 695 Berkmar Cour[ Suite #2 Charlottesville VA 22901-0224 Thos. Jefferson Planning District ATi~: Nancy K. O~Brian, Director P. O. Box 1505 Charlottesville VA 22902-1505 Mr. David A. Tice Albemarle County Planning Commission 601 Brighton Drive Earlysvllle VA 22936 Ms. Phyllis W. Tignor Clerk General District Court 501 E. Jefferson Street, Room 138 Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Tim F. & Tolson Emerald Ridge 6675 Highlander Way Cmzet VA 22932 The Honorable David& Toscano Member, City Council City of Charlottesville P.O. Boxgll Charlottesville VA 22902 Ms. Jaye Morgan Tower Route #2, Box I21-C Ruckersville VA 22968 Ms. Hannah Twaddell Thomas Jefferson Planning District P. O. Box 1505 Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Harry Van Beek Kleackner - Pentaplast P. O. Box 500 Gerdonsville VA 22942 Ms. Deborah Van Ersel Executive Vice-Pres. Charlottesville Area Asseaiatian of Realtors 2321 Commonwealth Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 The Honorable Mitchell Van Yahres 57th District Representative Virginia House of Delegates 223 West Main Street Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Warren Vandell 737-12 Mmmt2fmwood Read Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Kenneth Vaughan P. O. Box 6848 Charlottesville VA; 22906 Ms. Susan Vest 1786 Stoney Creek]Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 %m~s. Betty Via Whitewood Village 211 Whitewood Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Virginia Cooperative Extension Servic ATTN: David II. Vaden, Unit D~ector 168 Spotnap Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Ali Vohra 779 Mountainwood Road Country Green Charlottesville VA 22903 Ms. Kate VonBriesen P. O. Box 36 Batesville VA 22924 Mr. Allen F. Voshell P. O. Drawer II Free Union VA 22940 Mr. Don Wagner P. O. Box 5526 Charlottesville VA 22905 Ml~r. Richard Wagner Lonesome Moun~a~_ Road 2944 Lonesome Monnm'm Road Charlottesville VA 22911 Ms, Kathy Walker P. O, Box 6392 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Rosemary Walker P. O. Box 481 Grozet VA 22932 Ms. Allison P. Walton 36 Wh/toover Ckcle Charlottesville VA 22901-3700 The Honorable John W. Warner, Jr. United States Senate Russell Senate Bldg., Suite 225 Washiffgton D. C.'20510 The Honorable Charles M. Ward Member Albemarle County School Board 2486 Lake Albemarle Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Ms. Hilda IL Lee Washington Albemarle County Plam~g Commission 1610 Robin Lane Charlottesville VA 22911 ~r. John Waring Red Hill SehooI 3669 Red Hill School Road North Garden VA 22959 Mr. Bob Watson 36 Chowning Circle Waynesboro VA 22980 Mr. Paul A. Watson 96 Wildflower Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Reverend Peter T. Way P. O. Box 58 Keene VA 22946 WCHV & WWWV Radio Station ATTN: News Departarent 1140 Rose Hi/] Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 WCYK Radio:Statlon ATTN: News Deparauem 1150 Pepsi Place P.O. Box 7703 Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Katharine Welch 2924 Idlewoad Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Mrs. Jean Weeks Charlottesville Rehabilitation Center 1265 Seminole Trail Charlottesville VA 22906 Ms. Meg West 6592 Jarman Gap Road Crozet VA 22901 Mr. David Weisman 3687 Airport Acres Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~,~estmoreland Neighborhood Assn. ATI~: Mafia Bell 520 Nottingham Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Earl Whitaker 2332 Lonieera Way Charlottesville VA. 22901 Ms. C. IL White 346 Four Seasons Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 WHTJ Public Television ATTN': News Department 300 Preston Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Mr. Glenn Wilhelm 480 Willwood Drive Earlysville VA 22936 L~s.-Kathy Wilkerson Asheroff 165 Walnut Lane Charlottesville VA 22901 MS. Eunice Williams P. O. Box 65 Eartysvill¢ VA 22936 Ms. Fritsie Williams 77 Woodlake Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~illoughby Property Owners Assn. P. O. Box 7506 Charlottesville VA 22906 Mr. Larry Wills 2708 Gatewood Circle Charlottesville VA 22911 ~ilton Farm ATI~: Manager 1475 Wilton Farm Road Charlottesville VA 2290 Mrs. Horace Wood 104 Bollingbrook Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 ~'~oodbrook Neighborhood Assn. ATTN: Charlie Traehta 203 Westbroak Plaoa Charlotteswille VA 22901 Ms. Margaret Wright SPIL!NT P. O, Box 6788 Charlottesville VA 22906-6788 WINA Radio Station ATTN: Sarah McCounell 501 East Market Street P. O. Box 498 Charlottesville VA 22902 L~r. Sid Wood Woodbrook 2911 Broom Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Mr. Bruce M. Woodzell County Assessor Real Estate Office County of Albemarle WTJU Radio Station ATTN: News Depanmem B-6 Peabody It, all, UVA Charlottesville VA 22903 ~. Fram Witt Parkview 5670 Oak Driw Crozet VA 22932 Woodbrook Neighborhood Assn. ATrN: Sid Wood 2911 Brookmere Road Charlottesville VA 22901 t-~S. Ida Wootten Solomon Road 1714 Soloman Road Charlottesville VA 22901 ~ - TV Channel 29 ATTN: [-iamld Wright. Mgr. P. O. Box 769 Charlottesville VA_ 22902 WVIR - TV Channel 29 ATIN: Mark Logas, News Dept. 503 East Market Street P. O. Box 769 Charlottesville VA 22902 WVTF Public Radio ATrN: Rick Mattioni 4235 Elcetrie Road, SW Roanoke VA 24014 WVIR - TV Channel 29 ATTN: AmandaItall, News Dept. 503 East Market Street P, O. Box 769 Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. Toby Zakin 3605 Raleigh Mountain Tm~l Charlottesville VA 22903 WVPT Public Television ATIN: Peter Thompson 2560-D Ivy Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Mr. D. Jack~on Zimmermann Coordinator Fiscat Services