HomeMy WebLinkAboutSDP201700070 Review Comments Final Site Plan and Comps. 2018-07-23COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE
Department of Community Development
401 McIntire Road, Room 227
Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-4596
Phone (434) 296-5832 Fax (434) 972-4126
Project: HTC Hotel — Comfort Inn — Final Site Plan
Plan preparer: Peter Russell/Justin Shimp, Shimp Engineering, 201 E. Main St.
Suite M, Charlottesville, VA 22902 [iustin(a�shimp-en ine eering coml
Plan received date: 29 Nov 2017
(Rev. 1) 23 Apr 2018
(Re. 2) 26 Jun 2018
Date of comments: 19 Dec 2017
(Rev. 1) 16 May 2018
(Rev. 2) 23 Jul 2018
Reviewer: Bobby Jocz (Rev. 1, 2 /John Anderson)
Project Coordinator: Paty Saternye
SDP2017-00070
1. ,,..,. �,... �,,,,.., , (Rev. 1) Applicant acknowledges;
requirement for VSMP approval prior to FSP approval persists.
2. Drainage plan including stormwater calculations should be included in FSP. (Rev. 1) Not addressed.
Provide drainage plan, flow patterns, and storm sewer calculations; utilize VDOT table format. (Rev. 2)
Addressed. Asfollow-up, for proposed 8" HDPE roof drains (unless UBC or Albemarle County building
permit plan review dictate otherwise):
a. Recommend show 8" roof drains in profile to evaluate potential conflicts with walks or pavement.
b. Assign alphanumeric labels to roof drain pipes.
c. Provide cleanouts at roof drain line bends >45-deg.
d. Provide two (2) 45-deg bends instead of a 90-deg bend at south corner of hotel.
e. Show 8" roof line at Str. C 1, Inv. In Elev.
f. Show 8" roof line tie-in at Ex. Str. 4 (Elev.).
3. Bumper blocks should be provided for parking abutting 5' sidewalks. Bumper blocks are required for any
parking abutting sidewalks <6' in width. (Rev. 1) Not Addressed. Bumper blocks required for 30 typ. + 3
HC parking spaces fronting hotel and proposed 5' sidewalks; see ACDSM, p. 17 (link:
http://www.albemarle.org/oload/images/forms center/departments/community development/forms/design standards
manual/Albemarle County Desian Standards Manual 2015-04-25 draft.pdf ). (Rev. 2) Addressed.
4. In the northwestern parking lot, the CG-12 and detectable warning strip should be centered on handicap
access isle. (Rev. 1) Addressed.
5. Stop sign should be provided at intersection of two private travelways. Stop sign should stop cars traveling
northeast to southwest. (Rev. 1) Partially addressed. As follow-up: Provide stop signs or stop bars at SW
ends of parking aisles, at intersection with private travelway. Allow thru motion on private travelway with
stop required just beyond hotel entrance canopy, and at same location in 47 space parking lot to the NW.
(Rev. 2) Addressed.
6. [Sheet C5] Ensure all new and existing easements are labeled. Some easement labels are misaligned or
conflict with other labels making them illegible. Please correct. (Rev. 1) Addressed.
7. Identify/label gutter type to be used along new travelways. (Rev. 1) Addressed.
8. Curb with gutter should be utilized wherever stormwater is to be conveyed. (Rev. 1) Addressed.
Engineering Review Comments
Page 2 of 2
9. Engineering details for curbing (CG-6, CT-3, etc.) should be provided. (Rev. 1) Addressed.
10. Agreement must be made/provided related to access and construction of private travelways located outside
limits of parcel. (Rev. 1) Not Addressed. (Rev. 2) Comment pending. Applicant response: Approval on
improvmeents will be forwarded when available.
Comments on Exhibit Dated 12/18/17
1. Scaling is incorrect making it difficult to verify contours/slopes. (Rev. 1) Uncertain if addressed; please
provide copy of revised exhibit. (Rev. 2) Addressed.
2. Entrances must be a ma f 4% grade for the first 40 feet from the intersection. (Rev. 1) Uncertain; please
provide exhibit. (Rev. 2) Comment withdrawn.
New 5/16/18:
1. Title Sheet: Recommend revise signature block to read Albemarle County Engineer. (Rev. 2) Addressed.
Sheet C4
2. Provide VDOT detail for CG-12, 2-ramp configuration (ramps at termini, ped xing pavement markings).
(Rev. 2) Addressed.
3. Provide VDOT ref, to pedestrian crossing pavement marking specifications. Provide detail showing bar
width; paint type, etc. (Note: experience with accelerated wear of pavement markings on Meeting Street
lends justification to need for specification /detail.) (Rev. 2) Addressed.
4. Provide Auto -turn for dumpster. Use typ. local vendor truck wheelbase. Design cannot be approved unless
trucks can access and service dumpster without 3-point turn. Access must be direct, and cause no damage
to curb when truck is reversing. Current dumpster orientation appears problematic. (Rev. 2) Addressed.
Asefollow-up: Label open gate width dimension, dumpster enclosure detail (C10).
5. Identify New GV feature, northernmost parking space. Locate any gas appliance outside parking spaces,
for safety and ease of servicing. New GV is inaccessible if a vehicle occupies this parking space. (Rev. 2)
Addressed.
C5:
6. Reverse direction of flow arrow between storm sewer structures B 1 and ST7. (Rev. 2) Addressed.
7. New 10' X 6' water vault will not fit in 5' sidewalk; revise to show proper scale. (Rev. 2) Withdrawn;
review error.
8. Provide bedding detail for HDPE in trafficked condition; structural backfill should extend (at a minimum)
from the top of the pipe to 6-inches above the pipe (ref: htips://www.prinsco.com/wMm
content/uploads/2014/06/Minimum-and-Maximum-Burial-Depth-per-AASHTO-Tech-Note3.pdf ). (Rev. 2)
Addressed.
9. C7: Provide Detail 3 on C7 (dumpster pad concrete slab detail). Detail 3 is ref, on sheet 10. (Rev. 2)
Addressed.
10. C10: Revise Parking Area Pavement detail. Provide pavement design based on VDOT Pavement Design
Guide, rev. Feb 2014. Provide Dr, Dp, using ADT =200. Note: 3" of SM-9.5A and 8" VDOT 21A base
stone would satisfy design criteria and meet VDOT design guidelines. Other options are also available.
(Rev. 2) Addressed.
Please call if any questions: 434.296-5832 —x3069
Thank you
SDP201700070-HTC Hotel FSP rev072318 rev2.doc